Skip to main content

tv   The Stream 2017 Ep 157  Al Jazeera  October 3, 2017 11:32am-12:01pm AST

11:32 am
stations the palestinian prime minister has led a unity cabinet meeting in gaza as part of reconciliation efforts between his policy and hamas thousands of gazans lined the streets on monday as rami hamdullah crossed into the girls a strip his visit is the most ambitious effort yet to end the animosity between the political factions oft repeated famous. refugees have arrived in bangladesh for me a mosque while the two countries have agreed on a repack plan the deal to send back some of the hoff a million ranger was made after a representative for me amal's leader. went to bangladesh for talks myanmar. has made proposals for taking back the role hinge of refugees both countries have agreed to form a joint working group in order to monitor and to repeat the process both of us have
11:33 am
agreed on it now bangladesh will figure out what the details will be of the composition of the joint working group so will myanmar iran has deployed its tanks along the border with iraq semi autonomous kurdish region after last week's accession referendum and those are the headlines for now coming up next hear it out is there is a stream. it's not just phones contributing to send profits if we look at the u.s. economy the moment it does seem to be in pretty good shape up until around two thousand and five greek debt levels were basically stable we bring you the stories the economic world we live in counting the cost at this time. i am all they could be today a muslim intellectual part of ramadan joined the stream of prominent scholar shares his views on islam place in the world and what he calls the silent revolution.
11:34 am
psychedelic philosopher and author tariq ramadan has had his share of controversy his supporters say he has been working for decades to bridge the gap between european muslims and secular society his critics accuse him of holding messages to give you and having a hidden agenda to islamicize europe which he denies he joins us now from new york professor of contemporary islamic studies at the university of oxford professor thought a comment on welcome back to the stream it's a pleasure to have you here today thank you for inviting me so i'll start the so part of the conversation with your latest book introduction to asylum holding it here and in it you write in the very first sentence hardly a day goes by without some mention of islam and yet many people if pressed will admit that they know very little about the religion of one quarter of the human
11:35 am
race why was it so necessary do you think for this book to come out now in fact you know my publisher called me and saying we were looking for an introduction to islam and they didn't find something which was suitable for what's on so they asked me to write something and it took me thirty years just to good to dissent to try to say something about islam which is once again not. responding to the criticism of the controversy is because ninety nine percent of the time when we come on media is to say what islam is not is not violence is not discrimination but to come with a simple introduction simple without being simplistic about islam and trying to understand the terminology understand the concepts understanding the world view that is muslims have understanding the principles the history and also the diversity within this is essential and i am trying in this book to deal with all the controversial issues but not in the way the media are covering them by
11:36 am
asking the first questions but within this introduction by saying ok this is the world view and we have to deal with some of the challenges in muslim majority countries as well as in the west for example so thirty years though of scholarship and research how do you then condense that into this book what did you leave out and what did you think what's most important to me and here i think what was really important is just to get a sense that when you deal with is a universe of reference when you do you know islam you have to understand the spirituality on the you have to understand the philosophy and you have to understand the principles and the history but you also have as muslims today to deal with the challenges of our time and to be to address some of the issues our fellow citizens in the west but not only in the west by to win muslim majority countries is exactly the same that we need to tackle some issues and for example when it comes to violence to say well the limits of accept the diversity within
11:37 am
islam and people who are killing innocent people are in fact behaving against the islamic principles so i think that i'm trying to tackle these as well as some social issues when it comes for example in the way we have to deal was you know equality between gender and women within the society i'm just trying to be honest with the child. just that we are facing and also this book is for two audiences talking to muslims by telling them look you have to know you history in your tradition then you have to deal with some of the controversial issues but i'm also talking to people of out of phase eighty's that gnostics jews christians people who have nothing to do with islam but there are leaving with muslims they should also get a sense of what is and what the muslims stand for so talking about how you are so right to non muslims and i want you to take a look at this tweet we got from anthony in new zealand he we asked people how they
11:38 am
went about islam if they're not muslim and he says he learned about islam from b.b.c. documentary and went to pedia and from the news of over a decade and he also mentions the movie the message which is from the one nine hundred seventy s. what do you hope someone like anthony in new zealand gets from this book what is the overall effect that you're hoping for that exactly the point you are making the point you we can't now deal with to realistic society or live within pluralistic society having very superficial knowledge so what we have as a responsibility what responsibility i have as a muslim scholar is also to provide a better understanding by talking to my fellow citizens the language again understand so translating concepts and notions from arabic to english trying to get a sense of what are the common values that we have and the differences that we may face in our daily life but also to get a sense of islam is not an alien religion it's not me it's a western religion and you have to get it you're going to deal with your fellow
11:39 am
citizens and in fact we have to build the future together so it's not only need to get a sense of who are the muslims but also what are we going to build together what e's our common rests what are our common responsibilities when it comes to the future and this is critical and i think that it's a call for more knowledge most. commitment to some of the principles and something which should be stopped with the victim mentality all of us we have to stop with the victim mentality and to come and say what are our responsibilities to do to make this world. better to change the world for the better so i want to just bring it to current events now talk about things that are in the news and we'll start with the travel ban the newest travel ban from the u.s. take a look at this tweet from norrin shot she is with amnesty international she says turning the muslim ban into a travel ban won't fool us this ban will still cause thousands of people to live
11:40 am
and travel in fear so i want to ask you this because you were personally deny muses to the united states between two thousand and four and two thousand and ten can you talk about what a fact this new policy of putting a sign up that's a fact of when saying to people from these countries we don't want you here in the u.s. right now what are factors that exclusion have yes and just let me says something about what is happening today in las vegas and to express our condolences and so to the family of the victims and puerto rico and you know i think that this is also a sense of belonging to our societies to express listens and to the families and the victims that's something which is important knowing also that sometimes and this is the starting point of our discussion we should not going to use between the government and our fellow citizens so the government. it happened you know with under the patriot act it happened to me for six years we had no reason except that they had to did you positions being very critical towards the the american
11:41 am
government and then we had now trump and he's a ministration expressing something which is it is. bad it's targeting some of the countries only me and you know venezuela and other just to make it not something which is targeting the muslims we all know that is targeting the muslims and some muslims on needs are not going to. any band from the gulf states because this is where the money is coming this is why we are sending our weapons so that's the point the point is who are you banning and why are you doing this expressing a sense that islam is alien to the religion that anyone who's coming from muslim majority countries is suspicious and it happened to me to the point that at the end it's the obama administration and hillary clinton who said publicly there is nothing preventing tariq ramadan from coming so this is just you know spreading fear and nurturing this fear and the future of our country if we good that way it's going to be very very dangerous because these people and the trans populism in fact
11:42 am
is based in spreading fear and saying i'm going to protect the country from. these muslims that are in fact threat to our future no the threat to our future is people like him and people on the. within the political spectrum who are nurturing fear nurturing mistrust among the citizens and not helping us to get this piece which is so important for us today between black and white people between the rich and the poor and understanding that the future of our country cannot be by banning people and telling the people you have to show us that you are true citizens to the country by by. by not speaking out by being silent that's not the future if i am an american citizen if i'm a european citizen i should be critically loyal to my country and what does it mean if my government is right i'm going to support but when my government is wrong i'm going to be critical muslims are not that's not the point the point of citizenship
11:43 am
is not your religion the point of citizenship is an ethics as if you can chip based on principle so i think that what is coming now is these policies that are banning the people and targeting the very dangerous professor of law and you mentioned leaders who attempt to show that it's an alien in their lands i want to show a little clip a leader who some say tried to do the opposite of that this is french president emanuel micron in august this is his first major foreign policy speech and this is what inside. as you hear the think you're eighty looking sit where you. feel a little quality always an islamist leopoldine apriority the not a pretty good one here we should probably not always miss them east asia. law pro are the set it got me on a surprise that she couldn't you. couldn't even in leaked your love for
11:44 am
fundamentalistic pretty well certainly. and the crown goes on to say and i'm paraphrasing here we mustn't be naive and we mustn't be over afraid of islam we mustn't confuse islamists and islam and we mustn't look at the millions of muslims that live in europe with suspicion and so some would say there's a bit of a complicating message there and others are saying he's trying to spark parts apart semantics what's your take on it and you know yeah i think there are some are summarising the point is exactly the conflicting messages that he's sending he's right on one thing that the muslims cannot keep on saying it has nothing to do and these people who are killing. and book or her are for example have nothing to do is not we can't say this these muslims and i'm not going to put them outside a standard that theory position by putting people outside this name is wrong and saying that yes they rely on verses of the war on but it's a distorted understanding it's a wrong understanding it's outside the accepted diversity of muslims and this is
11:45 am
what i'm explaining in the book we have to be very clear by taking clear stance and this is what i have been doing for thirty years much before even two thousand and one was what was happening in muslim majority countries we have to do the job now what he is saying is it is in fact he's policy in france and his policy of brood is not helping this message to be clear because he wants us to understand we have to condemn violent extremists but what about the french policy going to bombard the people the civilians in syria oh in iraq all you need and telling us this has nothing to do is what they are doing to us in france while the people are saying you kill we're going to kill you in france of course we have to condemn violence but we also have to condemn the french policy and the french politics supporting dictatorships outside supporting some of the you know previous leader was reporting when i didn't an easier they were supporting get that feed welcome khadafi in paris
11:46 am
and all of a sudden he's a terrorist he's the bad guy. and france is playing to the i has to write the whole thing that's going to be wrong and blas what ease now the discourse about this from us is making the french muslim second class citizen by do we suspect that the state of emergency stalled getting muslims in the way in an incident and way and i think that this is where we have to say you are right by telling us we have to be clear on why not extremist what about your foreign policy what about your domestic policy so on that question of domestic policy towards muslims and western countries we have this tweet here from nestle and listen to it she says western muslims aren't part of mainstream society and she says because my daughter suffered harassment in australian schools for being the only muslim student to bring it to europe i want you to take a listen to this video comment we got from she's a ph d.
11:47 am
research researcher in france. a recent survey conducted by the vienna based engine see for fundamental rights found that a large majority of european muslims feel deeply connected to the country's a living and trust building institutions in spite of widespread discrimination for example with respect to france it was shown that muslims born and raised there feel a deep connection to their country given that what would it take for you being muslims to one day be fully accepted as peaceful citizens by their fellow men and women oh really never be enough despite how hard they try to assimilate and prove their religions so professor ramadan she says would it ever be enough and why why do you think that there is this disconnect between how european muslims feel often feel in their countries and citizens and the way their fellow citizens see them that that's the point and i think that what you just showed this is
11:48 am
a critical message we need to be quite clear on this what is said by the political and the media coverage of the muslims of the european muslims and by the way exactly the same as the american muslim because what we have been experiencing in europe it's coming now to the to to to the united states of america and even to canada and we have to be clear here that this narrative that or integration is failing the muslims don't feel that they are part of the society they are alien to this as the this is simply not right this is not the experience of western muslims in north african countries as well as in european countries that's not the truth they belong to the society they are more and more visible so there is a disconnect years between what is happening at the grassroots level at the local level within the society and the narrative saying and suspecting the muslim because
11:49 am
we need to get it right this. paula see that this narrative coming from politicians is just shifting the political discussion because they are not able to deal with unemployment they are not able to deal with discrimination and seek about the ization they don't know how to deal with the social problems so their needs sizing them. they are saying it's you because you are muslims and in fact the muslims and the west and muslims and the european muslims are now having this feeling that they belong to the country so we are in the past integration phase where now the most important thing is for the muslims not to be on the defensive to be assertive not to speak about integration to speak about their contribution the added value that they have within the society and this is what facts and figures are showing it's far from the narrative coming from the politicians and the media and we need to understand it will take time but we are going to succeed on this i'm very optimistic about this it's going to work so i guess we're going i don't know what i
11:50 am
deem your optimism but i do want to bring up two points here and get your thoughts on them so this is from the u.n. human rights is via twitter france draft counter terrorism law may have discriminatory repercussions especially for muslims and they go on in a statement this is dated september twenty seventh to talk about that draft law that really the emergency powers that you mentioned a little bit earlier that might impinge on the rights of people in the country and particularly muslim so that's on one hand on the other hand you had this headline just recently came out this is the atlantic what went wrong with france's the radicalization program now we've heard of these quote unquote the radicalization programs in other countries not just france the u.k. has one as well what do you make of programs like this that are the purported aim is to make sure that young muslims do not join groups like i so what do you make of their success rates look this is something which is very important and we have to
11:51 am
talk about the secure. the policy is the state of emergency by the way we are talking about france but as you said it's exactly the same with preventing the u.k. it's the same way as the patriot act and what we have for example in france now it's exactly what we had before in the states which is we go from the state of emergency to patriot act to normalizing within the legal framework laws and the ways of dealing with security and monitoring the people which is normalizing the state where we are losing our freedom so this is exactly what is happening in france now we are there they are saying oh we are going to stop the state of emergency but if you look at their policy there normalizing through the legal system things that you can monitor or you can spy and you even asking muslims to do the job for the state within the community and prevent is exactly the same and what is happening in the states is exactly the same so in the name of this war. on terror or this way of dealing with radicalization we are losing our freedom and
11:52 am
what i'm saying to my fellow citizens in the states as well as in europe be careful because you might think that it's only targeting the muslims but at the end it's all of us we are all citizens losing our rights and our dignity in the way we are monitored by the state spreading fear and telling us you know what you are scared we are going to protect you from being threatened by money touring you and this is not only about islam this is one second which is also something which is very important is all this business about radicalization and we was involved with the british government by saying something let us talk about radicalization what do you mean by radicalization that they were first believers and practicing muslims and then they step by step they became radicalized that's not the truth facts and figures are showing that the great majority of the people who went to the us are
11:53 am
going to a very quick shift to the point. that needs for example they were saying oh it was an overnight radicalization very quick what's that what are we talking about let us be serious about the fact that many of these people have nothing to do with religion they are not practicing muslims and they are dealing with something which is different for astri ssion a sense of alienation and also sometimes instrumental eyes asian. brain watch on internet let us be serious about this and it's not going to work like this and i would add one point which is essential to all the governments to the u.s. government as well as all the european governments they should understand that the muslim citizens are part of the solution they are not the problem if we suspect and we spread around that all the muslim citizens are suspected citizens it's not going to work we need to get it right we are all against violent extremists but let us be part of the solution and not being perceived as easy and to the society source and
11:54 am
only source of the problem and then we also have to connect this to the foreign policies because it's not going to work we are not isolated and we are not isolated countries so professor ahmed i mean a lot of ground to cover and we are heading towards the end of the program i want to make sure our community has questions get answered so to change to the topic of religious doctrine take a listen to this question we got from the causes of religious educator in the united states. sometimes it seems that the fear of assimilation has impeded islamic scholars from developing their ethical thinking in advancing issues specifically with respect to slavery in the past and now contemporarily gender issues so scholars of art and thought about keeping tradition as a so way to kind of maintain the purity of the religion and in a sense protected from innovations things that are repeated alive in islamic jurisprudence and texts we read about islam but this brings up the myth of some
11:55 am
pure islam that existed in some past and that we're trying to retrieve isn't really accurate to think of islam is something pure and from the past or is islam a dynamic evolving and relevant religion and faith that has meaning in any time and in any space so professor ramadan do you see islam as a dynamic religion and if so yes and i think what she's saying is going treat me right and i think that yes we have immutable principles we have immutable rituals we're not going to change this we are fasting we are praying this is not going to change but the way we have to deal with the surrounding culture and the way we have to deal was the new status and the new challenges means that there is no face fullness without evolution and i keep on repeating islam does not reform but the muslim minds need and she was talking about gender she was talking about equality and she is even i would add to this tragedy we need to have you know arts artistic
11:56 am
or statics all this is so important and we have to move on so the scholars who think that we are going to protect by leading and stressing only on the rules and relying on the rules this is not going to work the contribution is to be an intellectual cultural social artistic contribution and this is where the scholars as well as by the way average muslims should be involved in the process so as part of that i pulled up this headline here and this is. an interview. several months ago target ramadan there is a silent revolution underway what do you mean by that and i think that is exactly what we are witnessing today because you know we are talking as if the muslims are not moving over the last thirty years look at the end of the muslim narrative in the west and by the way also in which the majority country and just coming back from african countries you have exactly the same you have men and women now trying to be faithful to their religion so you wouldn't you know accept for example as a muslim but. to make. a new form and the know for unlawful we have principles and
11:57 am
we have a frame but now what we witnessing on the ground look around you look in the united states of america the new generation of men and women now they are speaking out this speak the language of the country they get the culture and now they want to be face full to their religion at the same time to be fully american and fully europeans and it succeeded and it will succeed this is the future so i would say that this is why you are right i have to question my optimism but my optimism is based on facts and figures i have been working on the field for the last thirty five years and i can tell you what we were saying and thirty five years ago is not what we are seeing now and we have now leaders and new generations of people coming and we have to trust them and we have to hope that with their fellow citizens they will be able to contribute for a better future well professor thought of the milan we're going to take that
11:58 am
optimism with us as we show that all the time we have for right now the book is going to islam and i will give the last word to our community down so our communities and there's the ask about the fact that. we got a comment from you tube just a reminder live on you tube now such an important book to be released when there is so much confusion fusion and lack of understanding thank you to our community for joining us and thank you to professor thought a kind of on time. ever since i was a little boy in india my dream was to make bollywood films so five years ago i decided i was finally queen to do it one man's quest to realize a lifelong ambition the story i chose to lose my one village and it's
11:59 am
transformation going behind the lens that's going to sing brings his personal story to life. al jazeera correspondent my own private bollywood at this time. al-jazeera is there when a story breaks but also that to see what happens next which is on. fire for a model barricade of seventy three that we need to hear the movies now is all about change people have gone here the area the mission of the national army is the entire complex and i just your stories about telling it from the people's perspective what they think is happening in their country. news has never been more available it's a constant barrage of it with every day but the message is a simplistic you have the frame that good logical rational person crazy monster and misinformation is rife dismissal and denial of well documented accusations and
12:00 pm
evidence is part of genocide the listening post provides a critical counterpoint challenging mainstream media narrative at this time on al-jazeera. the nature of news as it breaks. the way. i would like to destroy during the hurricane with detailed coverage this is what remains of an eagle refinery raid by the nigerian army hundreds like these up against ford in the past few months from around the world there are also hundreds of thousands of arabs that have arrived here in recent years i saw they feel very let down by the baghdad government. las vegas much point police department is working on two fronts to process the crime scene and also investigate the motive of the shooter. sixty four.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on