tv Erin Burnett Out Front CNN January 22, 2013 11:00pm-12:00am PST
it is not like she pulled a milli vanilli. even though we all know it wasn't milli vanilli singing any milli vanilli songs, it doesn't get better than kicking back on a cold night with a little "girl you know it's true." ♪ girl you know it's true ♪ my love is for real ♪ girl you know it's true >> not to mention even if beyonce did lip sync and, girl, you know it's true, she's got to be the best lip syncer on the planet. she looked amazing, sounded amazing. it wasn't like she turned the inauguration into an ashlee simpson "snl" moment or anything. ♪ on a monday i am waiting ♪ on a tuesday i am fading ♪ >> oh, it's still painful after
all these years. still hurts. speaking of painful to people who are apoplectic about whether beyonce lip synced, talk to me after you got on the stage in front of the president of the united states and hundreds of thousands to sing the national anthem in 40-degree weather. until then, that particular bomb "outfront" next, weeks after newtown, another shooting at an american school as two gunmen open fire at a texas college. we go to houston for the latest. plus the family of an american hostage murdered in algeria spoke out today. beyonce's national anthem. what you may not have known about it. let's go "outfront." good evening. i'm erin burnett. "outfront" tonight, a shooting at a texas campus. shots rang out at the lone star community college in houston today in what officials now are
blaming on a fight between two people. it was pretty awful to watch. it was so much uncertainty today as we started to see just what those helicopter shots, people running, there were stretchers. no one was sure what was happening, where the shooters were. police and emergency responders swarmed the campus minutes after a 911 call. students were ducking under desks and running for cover. here's how one terrified witness described it. >> i heard about six shots and kids started rushing down the hallway and a few even came into our classroom. everything really happened so fast. i called my mom just because i needed her to know that i was okay. and that, you know, that i loved her just in case anything was going to happen. >> at least three individuals were injured, a maintenance worker among them who was caught in the crossfire and two
suspects are in custody. ed lavandera is in houston tonight with the latest. ed, what is your understanding at this point about how this happened? >> reporter: really, the best information or the most colorful information we have received or heard so far is from those witnesses that saw the altercation taking place. there was one witness who had told one of the initial reporters here on the scene that they had scene the altercation escalate and in the words of that one witness, they talked about how it seemed like it was something that could have been resolved but it kept escalating. one gun involved between these two people. the maintenance worker who was shot in the crossfire there was wounded in the leg and he is being treated in the hospital as well. the two people who were involved in the altercation are also hospitalized and wounded and being treated as well, but so far, no charges and no arrests have been made. >> what can you tell us, you say one gun between the two people. with so much focus now on gun laws, what kinds of guns are used, whether they're legal, what do you know at this point?
>> reporter: well, we have been asking around as to whether or not this was a hand gun that was legally owned, legally purchased, what the background is on that gun. obviously there are agents that will handle that part of the investigation. i haven't been able to confirm anything on that end just yet. however, hand guns in the state of texas, you are legally allowed to carry a hand gun if you have the proper license and that sort of thing. however, just because you have that license doesn't mean you can carry guns on to a school campus. campuses and churches, there's a laundry list of places where you can't carry guns and school campuses are one of those. so as the sheriff here said in what i think was a school campus official said it's impossible to check the thousands and thousands of students that come through here, but in theory, this is not a place where you should have had a gun. >> all right, thank you very much. ed continues to work that story. as ed just mentioned, the texas laws, they are actually considering a law in texas right now that would allow you to
carry a concealed hand gun on a college or university campus. i want to talk more about that because this is the fourth school shooting since the massacre in newtown and it comes amid a bitter debate over gun control in the united states. just yesterday in his inaugural address, the president appeared to link the debate to the founding principles and the constitution. >> we have always understood that when times change, so must we. that fidelity to our founding principles requires new responses to new challenges. that preserving our individual freedoms ultimately requires collective action. >> "outfront" tonight, hogan gidley, republican strategist. michael waldman, former speech writer for president clinton and john avlon. michael, let me start with you. obviously that was a reference, a rather oblique one, to the gun control debate, but a reference it appeared to be. the fourth school shooting, though, in more than a month. nearly half the american people disapprove of what the president is doing on gun control.
is it time now for less talk and more action from the president on gun control? >> well, you're right, that in that powerful speech yesterday, he used the words and the sentiments of the founders to argue for his agenda and one of the elements obliquely, though not explicitly, was gun control. now, he took the first step with those 19 executive actions, but the next step of course is in the hands of congress, where the nra has been one of the most powerful forces for years and years and years. the really interesting question is this. this horrible shooting today following on those other horrible shootings, of course we've had these before, but since newtown, perhaps things have tipped. now the media is paying attention. every time it's a new bit of information about why we need some sanity on guns and when that happens, even politicians who are afraid of the nra might become afraid of looking like
they're just on the wrong side of history and the facts. >> hogan, let me ask you about this, because, you know, the nra has said let's put armed guards in schools. i've been skeptical of that just because all of a sudden you think you're going to find this whole host of people in the united states that know how to handle all these situations and know how to handle guns and know how to shoot and you're just going to put them in schools tomorrow and it's going to work. but i'm curious because the lone star college system, of course, where the shooting was today at the community college, employs commissioned police officers, they will put the statement up but i will paraphrase it here, that are just like police officers as well as noncommissioned security guards and those police officers carry department approved hand guns. the security guards are unarmed. so they have both kinds. they have armed guards. armed guards did not stop this. >> okay. what's your point? >> my point is -- >> it could have been a lot worse? we don't know. it's tough to know -- >> saying we're just going to put armed guards in all the schools, how can that possibly be a serious solution?
>> well, how could it not be a serious solution? if this is the battlefield with which the criminals have decided to fight, for us not to arm somebody on those campuses would just be ridiculous. no one's talking about a post-apocalyptic razor wire scenario here but armed guards are at festivals and football games already. half the children at newtown, half of them probably wanted to be policemen or firemen so it wouldn't be traumatic to any child or any college student for sure. that's just the world we live in today. the sanity we're talking about here as the previous guest just mentioned, the definition of sanity is going to be a little bit different from him and myself, because quite frankly, we need to look at some common sense solutions and feel good legislation is not going to matter. we need something that actually gets something accomplished and actually protects our children, and does that mean universal background checks? probably so. does that mean armed guards at some of these schools? absolutely. there are a lot of things we didn't look at. the mental health factor of it we talked about for weeks now since newtown.
but it's no one thing is going to fix the entire problem here. criminals are criminals for a reason. they're just bad people and evil happens in this country. >> let me ask you a question. you raise a lot of good points and as you said, universal background checks, you said probably a good idea. obviously the vast majority of americans and republicans support them. but i just have to ask you this since you are obviously coming here from the conservative side of the spectrum. if you're going to get armed guards in all schools, would you have federal money pay for that? schools are getting so many cutbacks right now, where are they going to get the money? >> well, thankfully that's not my job to figure out. that's something congress and the states are going to have to come up with. but look, talk to states like -- look, i think armed guards are important but look at a state like florida. let's look at what the states do. they have a 10-20 life law. they raised the penalty for gun crimes. if you commit a crime with a gun it's ten years mandatory. if you actually show that weapon, it's 20 years. if you actually use the weapon to commit the crime, it's absolutely life. that's for a first time offender. those types of things at the state level that we can look to,
the federal government needs to look at and see, those are things that actually could prevent some of this gun violence. let's make the crimes harsher, let's federalize some of the penalties for using a gun to commit a crime. >> all right. i just -- i find it ironic that people who want spending cuts are proposing more spending. that's a separate issue. john, let me ask you about this that i referenced in texas. they are now saying there's a law being considered, a bill in texas, where if you're already allowed to carry concealed hand gun, you would now be allowed to carry that concealed hand gun on a college or university campus. is that bill going to change because of what happened today or is it just going to go full ahead? >> let's hope so. if there's some common sense and decency on the part of the legislators to respond to changing facts on the ground. look, this shooting is a case study for why more guns on college campuses are a terrible idea. i mean, it doesn't pass the common sense test. anyone who has been to college, it's hard to imagine a worst case scenario than a bunch of college students with more guns. every once in awhile this
ideological driven idiocy is not driven by reality. four school shootings since newtown? at what point will we get a reality check and realize the worst thing we can do is have more guns on college campuses? today is a reality check, yet another one. this is a case study for why that proposal is idiotic from the beginning. hopefully some of these politicians will wake up. >> thanks very much to all three of you. we appreciate you taking the time and giving us your thoughts. "outfront" next, phil mickelson forced to apologize for saying he plans to make drastic changes because of the new tax laws. plus, a major development in the petraeus sex scandal. and prince harry brags about killing taliban soldiers. has he actually put the british people in danger? destined to take them over. ♪ the sirius xm satellite radio in the 2013 ram 1500.
engineered to move heaven and earth. guts. glory. ram. the new ram 1500. motor trend's 2013 truck of the year. [ male announcer ] how do you turn an entrepreneur's dream... ♪ into a scooter that talks to the cloud? ♪ or turn 30-million artifacts... ♪ into a high-tech masterpiece? ♪ whatever your business challenge, dell has the technology and services to help you solve it. [ male announcer ] how could switchgrass in argentina, change engineering in dubai, aluminum production in south africa, and the aerospace industry in the u.s.? at t. rowe price, we understand the connections of a complex, global economy.
our second story "outfront," phil mickelson's mulligan. the professional golfer apologized today for saying he was going to make, his words, drastic changes in his life because of new tax laws. there is no question that phil mickelson's taxes are going up. he is one of the highest earners in professional golf. only tiger woods made more in 2012, according to "golf digest." phil mickelson's numbers, $5.3 million on the course which is really just chump change for this guy because he made $40 million in endorsements. now, the 42-year-old golf champion told the "new york times," i'm quoting, if you add up all the federal and you look at the disability and unemployment and social security and state, my tax rate is 62% to 63%. roland martin is a cnn contributor and so is reihan salam. who also writes for "the
national review." all right, i love this story, because this hits on so many things. reihan, let me start with you. a lot of americans are going to have a lot of trouble saying phil mickelson earning $45 million, i really, i do not feel sorry for you. but this isn't really just about the super-rich who are going to pay about two-thirds of their income in taxes, is it? >> yeah. it's also true when you look at california, they raised the rate on those top earners. they also raised the sales tax from about 7.25% to 7.5%. that doesn't sound like a huge increase but the thing is it's already the highest state sales tax in the country, and the reason they're raising taxes on top earners is the same as they're raising the sales tax. it's that california's government is really ridiculously inefficient. it's one of the worst state governments in the country. so if those tax dollars were buying a great efficient terrific public sector, that would be one thing. but instead, it's paying for mediocrity, yet they keep asking for more and more. >> that brings me to a point. when phil mickelson was asked
would you leave california or the united states because of taxes, he said i'm not sure. but you know what, when taxes get to a certain point, people start to make those decisions and it's easy to point and say you're not patriotic. maybe part of the problem is with the taxes. >> first of all, he's the gerard depardieux of golf obviously, because he decided to leave france and go to russia. i was going to talk about notorious b.i.g. song, "mo money, mo problems." the opening scene is diddy playing golf on the pga tour. look, this is california. governor ann richards when she was governor and i was covering politics there, she would go to california to recruit companies to move to texas because of what, taxes. you have governor rick perry who sent a tweet to phil mickelson saying, hey, phil, come on to texas. a lot of golfers live in texas and florida, why, because of taxes. today, tiger woods held a news conference, he's playing in the tournament out there in torrey
pines, and he addressed the issue, saying one of the reasons he left his native california to move to florida was because of taxes. hey, here's my suggestion to phil mickelson. if you really want to confront taxes, be the next arnold schwarzenegger and run for governor of california. >> there's another way to change it. >> what the heck, run for governor. >> mickelson apologized. everyone jumps on the guy and he said, look, i should have kept my comments private but then he also said this. i think this is really important. right now, i'm like many americans who are trying to understand the new tax laws. i've been learning a lot over the last few months and i have talked with people who are trying to help me make intelligent and informed decisions. i certainly don't have a definitive plan at this time but like everyone else, i want to make decisions that are best for my future and my family. look, just because -- whether you're rich or whether you're poor, when your taxes change dramatically, people can change how they spend money. what's wrong with that? why are people picking on him for that? >> i think it's pretty silly to pick on him for it. look, what happened in california is that that top rate
went from 10.3% to 13.3%. and then for a lot of hires across the country because of the new federal laws, you're also paying a 39.6% top rate. that means forget about other taxes like capital gains and all that stuff and the obama care taxes. you're looking at a rate that's a little bit over 50%. that means for every additional dollar, every new golf tournament, every new endorsement you get, you get less than half of every additional dollar. so that's going to have a big effect on your decision making. i'm not saying that rich people shouldn't pay a reasonable share of taxes. that's totally fair enough. but once you get to those very high rates, it starts affecting your economic activity and that has big consequences for everyone else. not only that, but when a state like california depends more on those high earners, the tax base gets really volatile. >> but here's the deal. 98% of the country is saying phil, shut up. they would love to make $40 million a year. they would love to win a golf tournament and make $1 million.
he was right when he said i should have kept my criticism to myself, because he looks like a whiner. here's the other piece. when he goes and plays in a golf tournament, know what he wants? he wants the people out there to buy tickets to see him play. >> fair point. >> he wants them to buy his golf clubs and the clothes he wears. >> you know what, i see your point. i think you're totally right. but then i think about it, i think how many people does he employ directly or indirectly. if he stops employing some of them because his taxes but is too afraid to talk out about it because people say he's whining, you have this bad effect and no one is aware -- >> there's only one person he needs to employ. his caddy. if his caddy ain't happening, he's not winning on the golf tournament. >> look, this is actually a very, very important issue because california is an asset for the whole country. california has one of the best climates. it's one of the most beautiful places. why is that state losing people to texas, to washington state, to nevada, to all these other -- >> texas is god's country. >> they have term limits. maybe we should think twice. >> i'm a native texan.
we welcome all californians to come to texas. >> you'll get more of them. >> please. >> thanks very much. roland's smart. knows where the taxes are low. that's where he lives. our third story "outfront," fears of retaliation. after prince harry boasted of killing taliban fighters in afghanistan. >> take a life to save a life. that's what we sort of revolve around, i suppose. you know, if there's people trying to do bad stuff to our guys then, you know, we'll take on the ge, i suppose. >> those comments were made as prince harry completes a four-month tour of duty. "outfront" tonight, max foster with more on what military life was like for prince harry in afghanistan. >> reporter: combat ready, captain wales of the british army making final checks to his helicopter before a mission. this is prince harry, third in line to the british throne, serving his country in camp
bastion, afghanistan. this is the flight line, where the aircraft operates from, including the apache attack helicopter. this is what captain wales has been flying. >> our job is to make sure guys are safe on the ground. if that means shooting someone who is shooting at them, then we'll do it. >> reporter: no one is saying how many insurgents harry might have killed during his 19 week deployment. but sitting in the front seat means it was harry who was in charge of the apache weapons system. >> got the panel up here so we know exactly what's going on. >> reporter: other bits of kit met more basic requirements. >> in our bag we have [ inaudible ]. if you're in the aircraft three and a half, four hours, if i can hold on, i will. once you've been out here two or three weeks, you master the art. >> reporter: away from his
helicopter, captain wales mixed freely on base, eating in the canteen like anyone else. >> he's not treated any differently. my interaction with him is exactly the same as with any of my other officers. >> reporter: on down time between missions, video games with the crew. >> there it is! >> it's mainly squadron. that's the way he likes to be treated when he's in work, essentially. >> reporter: back on the flight line, it was all about the job and the wider strategic aim, building the role of the afghan national army, the a.n.a., so it can eventually take over. >> great to see the a.n.a. taking more of a lead in things as well and, you know, the professionalism is definitely showing through. >> reporter: that's something his superiors in the army might say of the prince himself. max foster, cnn, afghanistan. "outfront" next, there were a lot of amazing performances at yesterday's inauguration.
[ bop ] [ bop ] [ bop ] you can do that all you want, i don't like v8 juice. [ male announcer ] how about v8 v-fusion. a full serving of vegetables, a full serving of fruit. but what you taste is the fruit. so even you... could've had a v8. overmany discounts to thine customers! [old english accent] safe driver, multi-car, paid in full -- a most fulsome bounty indeed, lord jamie. thou cometh and we thy saveth! what are you doing? we doth offer so many discounts, we have some to spare. oh, you have any of those homeowners discounts? here we go. thank you. he took my shield, my lady. these are troubling times in the kingdom. more discounts than we knoweth what to do with. now that's progressive.
welcome back to the second half of "outfront." we start with stories we care about where we focus on reporting from the front lines and we begin with the secretary of state hillary clinton tomorrow. she is testifying finally about the attack on the american consulate in benghazi. now, officials tell us she will address concerns about weak security at u.s. diplomatic posts and will answer, quote, every question asked of her. among those questioning her, republican representative chris smith of the foreign relations committee. he tells "outfront" he wants to know if clinton was aware of the request for security upgrades at the consulate. we will speak to the congressman tomorrow to see if he is satisfied with the secretary's answer. we have an "outfront" update on the artistic director of the bolshoi ballet who has been fighting to keep his sight because last week we told you about an assailant who had a mask on who threw acid as he approached his home. the russian state media reports he received third degree burns to his face and eyes and our phil black says he's scheduled for another surgery tomorrow. doctors will not know if he will have sight or be blind for
another ten days. iranian president mahmoud ahmadinejad is once again dismissing the impact of western sanctions on his country. today, the country's semi-official news agency quoted ahmadinejad as saying i don't give a damn if you don't want to buy iran's oil. we can gain ten times more money through our academic inventions than the money we gain through oil sales. anthony cortisman says the sanctions are having a powerful impact on the iranian economy but they have only succeeded in slowing the nuclear program, not halting it, meaning a decision on what to do about that for the united states and israel could come in the next few months. the defense department inspector general has cleared general john allen of allegations he wrote inappropriate e-mails to jill kelley. now, jill kelley had claimed that she was being threatened by paula broadwell. you may remember the woman who had an affair with the former cia director, david petraeus. we were sent an op-ed by kelley and her husband, scott, that will be published by the "washington post." in it, the kelleys describe how
they were victimized throughout the ordeal. they also urged congress to consider legislation to strengthen electronic privacy. it has been 537 days since the united states lost its top credit rating. what are we doing to get it back? a total of about 4.65 million homes were sold in 2012, homes that were previously owned. that number may not mean much but it does mean something important. it's the best year we've seen for those home sales since 2007. now, our fourth story "outfront." mourning the hostages lost. the family of one of the american victims of the algeria hostage crisis spoke out today. victor lovelady's brother and daughter told the world a bit more about the man they have lost. >> i just want to know how my brother died. it means a lot to me. if they told us they don't think he suffered. >> they did tell us that. >> and i want to know that, because that's closure for me. >> my whole life, he's always told me that good things happen
to good people and that i was a good person and good things were going to happen for me. and he's always told us that. that's what makes this so hard, because how good he was and that he didn't deserve that. >> we are also hearing more now from the hostages who did survive. nic robertson has their stunning stories. >> reporter: as it began at the remote algerian gas facility, no one had any idea that one of the most ambitious terror attacks of the last decade was under way. >> when i woke up early wednesday morning, i heard the alarm sound and gunfighting. >> reporter: neither they nor their families knew what was happening. >> we could hear gunfire outside, machine gunfire. sometimes rapidly, sometimes quiet for a little bit. we knew it was really, really bad situation.
>> i just went back to my accommodations, locked the door, turned off the lights and kept quiet. >> reporter: around 40 armed islamist militants loyal to this al qaeda-connected jihadist, mokhtar belmokhtar, stormed the site, taking hostages. >> he made us sleep with a strap around his neck, he had duct tape over his mouth and his hands tied. >> reporter: his brother steven survived. british engineer gary ballo did not. he called his wife and told her he had explosives strapped on his body. security sources say the terrorists may have been trying to take them out of the country to be used as bargaining chips to stop attacks on the militants. inside the plant, the jihadists' agenda to take only nonmuslims hostage was becoming clearer. >> they asked if we were algerian muslims. we said yes.
then they said don't worry, we are here to promote islam and to give the usa a lesson about islam. >> reporter: some foreign workers were helped to freedom by algerian workers. >> they said they were going to cut the fence and head into the desert, so they gave us hats and coats to make us look a bit more blending in. we moved into the desert very, very reasonably quickly and then we were picked up by military. >> reporter: by the time algerian forces finally took control of the sprawling plant late saturday, at least 37 foreign hostages were dead, including three americans and three britons. others are still missing. nic robertson, cnn, london. >> three americans dead in algeria. you just heard from nic. this is the response from president obama. one paper statement, one paragraph. he put it out the night the
hostage crisis ended, that was a saturday night. now he has had a lot going on this weekend, for sure. there was the inauguration. there was the speech. there were the balls. and there were a lot of people to see from beyonce to alicia keys. but take a look at the response from our closest ally. british prime minister david cameron postponed a major speech to deal with the crisis and he talked on television and to parliament three times. >> it appears to have been a large well-coordinated and heavily armed assault and it is probable it had been preplanned. the world needs to come together to deal with this threat in north africa. this attack underlines the threat that terrorist groups pose to the countries and the peoples of that region, and to our citizens, our companies and our interests, too. >> britain, like the united states, lost three citizens in the crisis. democratic senator chris kunz of delaware joins me tonight.
sir, thanks very much. obviously, two very different responses. the president yet hasn't said anything physically out of his mouth. prime minister cameron obviously coming out several times, talking passionately. three americans are dead and something that leon panetta and the administration called a terrorist attack immediately. do the american people deserve to hear directly from our president about this? >> erin, what i have been focused on in the days since i came back from a trip overseas is making sure that the highest level of our government is engaged, is committed to a full response to this attack by aqim, one that cost not just the lives of three americans, three britons but 37 foreign nationals. this is a remind that aqim, an affiliate of al qaeda in west africa, is a lethal threat, not just to our immediate interests but to our allies' interests. i think it is important that leaders in the united states such as i have done as the senate foreign relations subcommittee chair, make statements positively, make
statements that denounce this attack and that suggest our willingness to engage in strong support for actions in mali that were in part what caused this attack in the first place. >> you know, yesterday the president didn't touch on foreign policy very much in his inauguration speech, but he did a little bit. i just wanted to play you a part of what he said. here's the president. >> we, the people, still believe that enduring security and lasting peace do not require perpetual war. our brave men and women in uniform tempered by the flames of battle are unmatched in skill and courage. our citizens, seared by the memory of those we have lost, know too well the price that is paid for liberty. the knowledge of their sacrifice
will keep us forever vigilant against those who would do us harm. >> senator, obviously few would disagree with what he said there. it's pretty basic, eloquently said, as much of what he says is. but with three americans dead in a terror attack in 48 hours before he was speaking, would it have made sense to perhaps mention that? >> well, erin, i'm not going to parse with you exactly what the president said in his inaugural address. his second inaugural address. i will simply comment that i just returned on sunday from a visit to egypt, afghanistan, jordan, israel, with six other senators, a bipartisan delegation. we were supposed to go to mali a week ago yesterday but were diverted because of the deteriorating security situation there and across all these different places, we saw a common theme, which is that the united states needs to continue to be engaged in the world. we need to continue to invest in the military strength, the development efforts, the diplomacy efforts that will push back against jihadists and radical islam.
i think it's vital that the president and leaders in the congress continue to make visible to the american people the importance of our investing in a strong international presence. this shocking incident in algeria reminds us that america's interests can be attacked almost anywhere in the world. terrorists don't need to attack america to hurt our interests and to kill our citizens and we need a stronger presence around the world. >> and to your point, sir, let me just play something on this issue of al qaeda particularly. al qaeda-linked groups. i recently spoke to the still defense secretary leon panetta about this issue, about mali. i asked what the u.s. would do about al qaeda. here's what he said. >> we've got to go after al qaeda wherever the hell they're at and make sure they find no place to hide. let's not forget, the main goal of al qaeda is to attack the united states. and we're not going to allow that to happen again. if we're not going to allow it to happen, we've got to go after
them in yemen, in somalia and yes, in mali if necessary. >> senator, it seems panetta is raising his voice. it's not clear the administration is really hearing it or they are fully in agreement. you said northern mali has become the largest territory controlled by islamic extremists in the world. we have a defense secretary coming in and a new secretary of state in chuck hagel and john kerry who are known for favoring a light footprint. do you think that they are going to take the action that you believe is needed? >> well, i look forward to raising these questions with them when i get a chance to attend their confirmation hearings in the case of senator john kerry or to meet with him in person in the case of senator hagel. i met this morning with senator kerry to give him an update on this trip. a number of the senators who were on the trip with me met with him, and i am determined that we make certain that the united states invests in the kind of forward leaning relationship in africa that will
take the fight to al qaeda in africa and that will invest in stability in countries where, if we don't partner with them effectively, they may slip into the kind of state that mali's in now. just a few short years ago, mali was viewed as a stable, democratic ally of the united states, and it's come unwound fairly quickly. i chaired a hearing on december 5th to look at mali and to look at the situation there and try and raise its profile. i have gotten great cooperation from the state department and defense department but as you point out, this incident in algeria reminds us that it needs attention and investment at the highest levels of the american government. >> senator, thank you very much. we appreciate it. we will see if the president of the united states does indeed say anything about the three americans who died in algeria. "outfront" next -- elections in israel today. the voters send benjamin netanyahu a strong message. i'v paradise!
pack your bags, we'll leave tonight. uhh, it's next month, actually... eddie continues singing: to tickets to... paradiiiiiise! no four. remember? whoooa whooaa whooo! you know ronny, folks who save hundreds of dollars by switching to geico sure are happy. and how happy are they jimmy? happier than eddie money running a travel agency. get happy. get geico. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more. officemax can help you drive suand down.s down...
use your maxperks card and get a 10-ream case of officemax multiuse paper for just 4.99 after maxperks rewards. find thousands of big deals now... at officemax. ♪ (train horn) vo: wherever our trains go, the economy comes to life. norfolk southern. one line, infinite possibilities. see lioutdoors, or in.ight. transitions® lenses automatically filter just the right amount of light. so you see everything the way it's meant to be seen. maybe even a little better. visit your eyecare professional today to ask about our newest lenses,
we are back with tonight's outer circle, where we reach out to our sources around the world. tonight, we go to israel, where voters turned out in huge numbers today to decide whether a coalition led by benjamin netanyahu will continue to lead the country. a right wing coalition. the results were not as clear as expected. it's a crucial election for the united states and sarah seidner is in tel aviv. i asked her what happened. >> reporter: erin, here in israel, a clear but slightly wounded winner in the israeli elections.
benjamin netanyahu's coalition had expected to get more votes. they did in fact win the most number of seats but not as many seats as they had wanted. what ended up happening is that voters turned around and chose centrist or center left groups as well in big numbers. the big, big surprise was yesh ahid, a group that came out of nowhere almost because they just started their party last year but ended up getting the second largest number of votes. all the polls had predicted that netanyahu's party would swing farther to the right and it appears that he is opening up a possible large coalition and including perhaps the left if he can get them to join. so this may have an impact on how the international community sees israel, have an impact on some of the things this particular government goes after such as what they will do with the peace process or what they will do with settlements. certainly, there is going to be a lot of horse trading over the next few weeks. erin? >> thanks very much. now our fifth story out front. was she lip-synching?
it's actually hard to do. i can't imagine what it would be like. it's really hard to do, like you do more gesturing. it's hard. beyonce's rendition of the national anthem at yesterday's inauguration may not have been all it first appeared to be. ♪ oh, say can you see by the dawn's early light ♪ >> turns out beyonce may have used a prerecording of the anthem that she made sunday night with the u.s. marine band. now, there's been no comment from beyonce herself but why would she use a canned version? "outfront" tonight, lorraine allie music director of the "los angeles times" and the consultant for broadway shows, the book of mormon and one. you know everything about lip syncing and non-lip syncing. let me just start off with that question, though.
why would she use a prerecorded version when it seemed at least from what we've heard confirmed from the other artists, kelly clarkson, james taylor, who were there, both of them sang live? >> my feeling is that the only reason to lip sync would be the fear of the cold weather and certainly the pressure of the event surrounding her. but it seemed not lip syncing to me. >> it seemed totally real. >> it seemed very real to me. >> again, the u.s. marine band had indicated they didn't have time to do a live performance, that's why it was lip synced. beyonce has not commented, so we're not 100% sure. i have to say when i watched it, it was absolutely glorious, as i'm sure everyone would agree. i was amazed that she could sing like that with the cold and even with being beyonce, it's got to be kind of a nerve-racking moment.
>> actually, using something called a backing track while artists are performing on live televised events is kind of standard at this point. so it's possible that she was using a backing track, and by that i mean something that she prerecorded before the show and that she was singing along to live. so whether that constitutes lip syncing or not, i think when we talk about lip syncing we think about the humiliating milli vanilli moments, of them singing along to someone else's voice. but that very possibly could have been a backing track that she recorded beforehand. that's very common. they do that for super bowl. >> she's hearing herself but she's actually singing it, she wasn't just mouthing it. am i understanding you right? >> i mean, i'm not sure, i'm not sure what she was doing, but that's a big possibility because the way that i heard it as well, it sounded like it was live singing. it sounded imperfect, but it sounded good. and i would be surprised if it was a flat-out lip syncing.
>> i have to imagine that it's got to be really, really difficult to do that. just if she were to be lip syncing, when she hit that high note, your whole body arches up, you see the muscles in her neck, her eyes, how do you do that without actually belting it out? >> i find it theatrically nearly impossible to have completely been lip syncing to the "star-spangled banner" because of her phrasing and certainly because she pulled out one of the monitors in her ear sort of one-third of the way through the song. i feel like maybe the mix was not exactly correct in her ear, so she wasn't hearing her own natural instrument acoustically and frequency-wise exactly in balance. so maybe she needed to pull one monitor out so she could feel herself singing while she was listening to the band in her other ear, which says to me, if she was singing to herself singing, she was still singing live. >> let's say it turns out she
was lip syncing, which as you point out, is common, it happened at the super bowl before. she's scheduled to sing at the super bowl in two weeks. what does this do, does it hurt her reputation or credibility at all that it was quote, unquote, not real? it is her voice, but it may not have been real at that moment? >> i don't think so. if you look at other singers that have done this, i mean, whitney houston did it, jennifer hudson's done it, the e street band did it when springsteen played at the super bowl last time and they're one of the tightest bands around. i don't think it hurt her reputation. many in the industry know this is just what has to happen at a live televised event, and she already has such a stellar reputation as a singer, i would be surprised if this actually hurt her. >> it's a pretty amazing thing. i have to say watching it and rewatching it again at the moment everyone said maybe because her mouth is so close behind the mike, that's lip syncing. who knows?
if she can lip sync that well, she's even more amazing. >> exactly. >> thanks to both of you. everyone, let us know what you think about beyonce. next a recap of the best moment at least i thought from yesterday's inauguration and why, well, we're going to tell you why this moment was so important. a new look in this country. you kind of go like this and i'll tell you why. i had enough of feeling embarrassed about my skin. [ designer ] enough of just covering up my moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. i decided enough is enough. ♪ [ spa lady ] i started enbrel. it's clinically proven to provide clearer skin. [ rv guy ] enbrel may not work for everyone -- and may not clear you completely, but for many, it gets skin clearer fast, within 2 months, and keeps it clearer through 6 months. [ male announcer ] enbrel may lower your ability to fight infections. serious, sometimes fatal events, including infections, tuberculosis, lymphoma, other cancers, nervous system and blood disorders, and allergic reactions have occurred. before starting enbrel,
your doctor should test you for tuberculosis and discuss whether you've been to a region where certain fungal infections are common. you should not start enbrel if you have an infection like the flu. tell your doctor if you're prone to infections, have cuts or sores, have had hepatitis b, have been treated for heart failure, or if you have symptoms such as persistent fever, bruising, bleeding, or paleness. if you've had enough, ask your dermatologist about enbrel. trying to find a better job can likbe frustrating.gs, so at university of phoenix we're working with a growing list of almost two thousand corporate partners - companies like microsoft, american red cross and adobe - to create options for you. not only that, we're using what we learn from these partners to shape our curriculum, so that when you find the job you want you'll be a perfect fit. let's get to work.
so yesterday i attended president obama's inauguration in washington, d.c., with a million or so other people. it was an amazing moment in american democracy to experience the sights, the sounds of the parade, the balls, the crowds. and all of it live. well, sort of. and that brings me to tonight's number, which is 1.1 million. that's the number of inauguration themed tweets that were sent during yesterday's ceremony. that's an incredible jump from 82,000 tweets that were sent in 2009. not just twitter. this week cnn teamed up with instagram and on sunday and monday we received more than 10,000 photos from people at the inauguration. that's right. people were really busy on their phones during the ceremony. for better or worse, social media has changed the way we experience life. yesterday afternoon as the
president of the united states walked to the podium to give his speech, the audience was getting their phones ready to video it. and this moment is what was amazing to me when i was there. when the president and the first lady arrived at the ball, the crowd surged forward trying to get that perfect shot. like a wave of people lifting their right-hands about six inches forward of their bodies to film it. kind of like this new wave, i call it, where everyone is going like this and just looking like that instead of just actually looking like that. the camera on my beloved has been broken for a few months. i didn't have any video of alicia keys or stevie wonder. but i got to sing and dance, to my new favorite song by fun, which is impossible to do when you're holding a phone trying to film it. i looked at all these people and they're going like this instead of you know. great to share with friends and family, but if you're going to see the president of the united states dance just one time in your life at a ball with his wife at a moment in history, should you film it or should you
actually watch it? and as for all the tweeting, i realized when i'm busy thinking of a tweet and typing it and making sure it goes out, which is tough at an inauguration because it may take three or four tries because the wires get all mixed up, signals. i missed a whole lot of stuff since the first time i started to send the tweet. things have happened and i missed them. maybe being able to memorialize them is not all it's cracked up to me. the bragging rights of showing the video don't get you that far but the memories of things we see with our own two eyes and no screen in between are the greatest possession we'll ever have. "piers morgan tonight" is next.