Skip to main content

tv   Erin Burnett Out Front  CNN  July 23, 2018 4:00pm-5:00pm PDT

4:00 pm
anything about that. manafort is used in that narrative, but, again, until you've got the facts, all you've got is feelings. >> chris cuomo reporting for us. thank you. tune in tonight, "cuomo prime time," 9:00 p.m. eastern, right here on cnn. thanks very much for watching. "erin burnett outfront" starts right now. "outfront" next, breaking news, political payback. the president threatening to pull security clearances of former top intelligence officials. is this trump's witch hunt? plus, paul manafort in court, five witnesses granted immunity. will manafort be spared or spend the rest of his life in prison? or special "outfront" series, trump allowing big oil in. into america's wild, drilling in alaska. the debate that is pitting neighbor against neighbor. let's go "outfront." good evening. i'm erin burnett. "outfront" tonight, the breaking news. trump's real witch hunt. because the president's threatening to punish people who
4:01 pm
disagree with him. in this case, it's a very specific group of people. america's top former intelligence chiefs, the people who ran america's intelligence agencies. >> will the president consider senator paul's suggestion and call for the removal of former director brennan's security clearance? >> not only is the president looking to take away brennan's security clearance, he's also looking into the clearances of comey, clapper, hayden, rice and mccabe. the president is exploring the mechanisms to remove security clearance because they've politicized and in some cases monetized their public service and security clearances. >> let's be clear, it's an unprecedented thing if it happens. no president's ever done it and it's an extraordinary list of people. the former cia director john brennan, the former cia director and nas chief general michael hayden. former fbi director james comey. former director of national intelligence, james clapper. andrew mccabe and the former
4:02 pm
national security adviser, susan rice. i just want to be clear here almost all of these individuals have worked for both republican and democratic presidents for years in government. to get to the top of the organizations, the cia, the fbi, the -- the only exception is susan rice. what they actually all have in common is not their politics. what they have in common is that they have criticized this president. here is a small sample. >> i really do wonder whether the russians have something on him. i think his behavior was just unbelievable. >> i don't think he has a full appreciation of russian capabilities, russians' intentions and actions that they are undertaking in many parts of the world. >> what his motivations are, i think is a legitimate question, one that i trust that the special counsel is investigating. but the policies that this president has pursued globally have served vladimir putin's interest. >> yet the white house insists
4:03 pm
that the threat that they very explicitly labelled by name today is not personal or political. >> free speech he doesn't like and he wants to punish them for it. >> no, i think you are creating your own story there. the president doesn't like the fact that people are politicizing agencies and departments. >> isn't the president doing exactly what you just said the president doesn't want all these people doing, politicizing matters of national security by going after his political enemies? >> no, the president's not making baseless accusations of improper contact with a foreign government. >> now, when it comes to facts, the white house should be aware that comey and mccabe actually no longer have their security clearances, so when she said she's looking into that, we can check the box there. you don't actually need to do that. general hayden tells cnn he no longer goes back for classified briefings, but if the president is serious about pulling security clearances for people who disagree with him, he's going to have his hands full because according to a report from the director of national
4:04 pm
intelligence, this year more than 4 million people, 4 million people have access to some type of classified information in america. that is a lot of people who may have criticized the president. so this idea of punishing your enemies or those critical of you, well, here's the thing, it's straight from the playbook of those the president admires, including strong men like the turkish president erdogan. here is president trump at the nato summit. remember he let merkel and macron everybody, trudeau go ahead and he walked side by side with erdogan, on autocratic leader who has reportedly arrested 100,000 people in a purge of his political opponents, including members of the military and judges. that's the model we're talking about here. to strip the former intelligence chiefs of their security clearance is unprecedented. never mind that the president's team didn't actually check the facts of who even uses those security clearances. this move today should upset all americans. jeff zeleny is "outfront."
4:05 pm
jeff, the big question here is, you know, this comes out and they list all these names. is this for real? are they just trying to change the conversation? what's going on? >> reporter: it's certainly had that effect of changing the debate, changing the discussion. i am told by a senior administration official just a few minutes ago that the president is, quote, more than comfortable with how all of this is playing out. he likes this debate in the public sphere. he likes to be having this argument against old obama officials. this is not a new argument. he has been angry and seething at the obama administration officials, who he is watching a lot on cable television. let's be honest about this. so he likes this debate. the question is, is he ever going to go forward and actually do this and revoke those security clearances? that what's we don't have a clear understanding of. this security official said he may at some point but he's fine with it playing out the way it's playing out. we certainly did change the subject. we were talking about iran, the russia investigation, the putin meeting and now we're talking
4:06 pm
about this. so we'll see if this is actually something he does or if it is something he has threatened before, essentially firing jeff sessions. that has never happened before as well. >> right. >> reporter: it is unprecedented. it is something that has never happened before and the president seems to like this discussion. he thinks it fires up his base. it's the latest chapter in the deep state argument, erin. >> all right. thank you very much. of course what fires up your base may or may not be good for the country, whatever your base may be, right? "outfront," senator ron wyden is a member of the senate intelligence committee. senator, i appreciate your time. >> thank you. >> you heard sarah sanders said not just john brennan, let me list the rest of them, brennan, comey, clapper, hayden, rice and mccabe. security clearances could be stripped. it would be an unprecedented action if it happens. your reaction? >> erin, i have taken on the leadership of both political parties in the intelligence community. so i don't get a whole lot of invites out to langley or
4:07 pm
quantico. as i listen to this, it sounds to me like donald trump is talking about building an enemies list, and then the question would be if that's the case, are taxpayer resources going to be used to go after critics? >> i mean, that is -- that is the big question, right? you heard jeff zeleny report he's more than comfortable with this conversation. the big question for you, senator, is, if he goes through with this threat, is there anything you in congress can do about it? >> well, obviously we're going to have to have republicans get serious about pushing back. i mean, again and again they have made excuses. it seems to me after last week we ought to be talking about a bill that would sanction the russians. we certainly need to protect our democracy, we ought to pass my bill to make sure that every american gets a paper ballot. so the republicans are going to have to push back. >> former fbi special agent
4:08 pm
frank montoya talked to about this. it's an abuse of power even though he has the authority. would you agree? if he wants to do it, brennan, comey, whoever, you guys are toast. i'm taking it away. >> this is just plain wrong. i mean, the idea -- and that's why i characterize it building an enemies list in order to look at the possibility or strategize of ways to go after your critics. it's contrary to everything that our country is all about. that's why democrats and republicans are going to have to oppose it. >> but, senator, you said -- all right, let's, you know -- the republicans need to step up, all right. so sarah sanders today -- one of the top republicans, i'm sorry, in the senate, john cornyn, responded this way to the news. i wanted to quote what he said to cnn. some of these former officials have obviously donned the uniform of opposition team to president trump and i can understand his aggravation but i'll wait to see what he does.
4:09 pm
cornyn has disagreed with the president but he's come out today saying he understands the president's aggravation. it doesn't sound like republicans are jumping on board with your point of view. >> i just hope that -- and you saw this last week in the senate on judges, that republicans will come to their senses on some of these issues. they did when they said no to an extreme judge who also hid some very derogatory information about his background. they came to their senses. i hope they will here as well. and i think -- you asked what the motivation is, this is a twofer. obviously president trump dislikes a number of these officials personally. >> yeah. >> but this is also a major distraction. look at what he's been doing the last few days, he has been twisting himself into a pretzel to try to make sure that people wouldn't think he's in putin's pocket. so this is a twofer. he can go after his enemies and it's a major distraction. >> so the president called the
4:10 pm
russia investigation, which you mentioned, a hoax in a tweet this weekend, right? this is after he said, oh, wait, i didn't mean to act like i was friends with putin. i didn't mean it. now it's back to being a hoax. he tweeted in part, so president obama knew about russia before the election. why didn't he do something about it? why didn't he tell our campaign? because it's all a big hoax, that's why, and he thought crooked hillary was going to win. a basic fact check here, trump's campaign was informed of this, but the president's spokesperson said when he said hoax he wasn't actually talking about the russia investigation. so we're back to the let's try to backtrack. here is how she put it. >> the president is referencing the collusion component. once again, the president has faith in the intelligence that suggests and maintain that russia was involved in the elections. however, it's also important that that same information concludes that it had no impact on the election and that the president again would like to repeat that there was no collusion. >> again, just to make sure we
4:11 pm
put the facts out there, of course he constantly questions whether russia was involved in hacking the u.s. elections, but to her point, there was no collusion, you know, do you buy this explanation? >> when i heard the sanders explanation, i said, you've got to be kidding me. they literally change their position every few hours and the president's credibility, in my view, has just evaporated. as i have said several times in recent days, the fact is he didn't take on putin when it really counted and he's been trying to come up with one excuse after another for why he didn't. >> senator, do you think that if he goes ahead with this threat to strip these security clearances, an unprecedented action in the united states of america, that would be grounds for impeachment or does that not go far enough in your view? >> i will tell you that if he goes forward with what he's been talking about today, the idea of building an enemies list and then we'd have the prospect of
4:12 pm
whether taxpayer funds were being used to deal with critics, i would rule absolutely nothing out if he pursued that strategy. >> all right. senator, thank you for your time. appreciate it tonight. >> thanks for having me. next, breaking news. a dozen audiotapes made by michael cohen tonight in the hands of prosecutors. so what's on them? plus, president trump's all caps threat against iran. he says he's reacting to iran's threat. so does it add up? the alleged russian spy, maria butina, why did she meet with several american officials? [music playing] (vo) from the beginning, wells fargo has supported community organizations like united way, non-profits like the american red cross, and our nation's veterans. we knew helping our communities was important then.
4:13 pm
and we know it's even more important today. so we're stepping up to volunteer more and donate over a million dollars every day. so our communities can be even stronger. it's a new day at wells fargo. but it's a lot like our first day. rewards me basically so why am i hosting a dental convention after party in my vegas suite? because lets me do me. who wants to floss me?
4:14 pm you do you and get rewarded. ♪ keep it comin' love. if you keep on eating, we'll keep it comin'. all you can eat riblets and tenders at applebee's. now that's eatin' good in the neighborhood. with best in-class towing 2018 ford f-150. best in-class payload and best in-class torque the f-150 lineup has the capability to get big things to big places --bigtime. and things just got bigger. f-150 is now motor trend's 2018 truck of the year. this is the new 2018 ford f-150. it doesn't just raise the bar, pal. it is the bar. your hair is so soft! did you use head and shoulders two in one? i did mom. wanna try it? yes. it intensely moisturizes your hair and scalp and keeps you flake free. manolo? look at my soft hair. i should be in the shot now too.
4:15 pm
try head and shoulders two in one. you're trying to lower your very hwith a healthy diet... and exercise. and maybe even, unproven fish oil supplements. not all omega-3s are clinically proven or the same. discover prescription omega-3 vascepa. the one that's this pure... and fda approved. look. vascepa looks different... because it is different. it's pure epa. vascepa, along with diet, is clinically proven to lower very high triglycerides by 33% in adults, without raising bad cholesterol. that's pure power. proven to work. vascepa is not right for everyone. do not take vascepa if you are allergic to icosapent ethyl or any inactive ingredient in vascepa. tell your doctor if you are allergic to fish, have liver problems... or other medical conditions and about any medications you take, especially those that may affect blood clotting. 2.3% of patients reported joint pain. it's clear. there's only one vascepa. ask your doctor about pure epa prescription vascepa.
4:16 pm
♪ breaking news. more secret tapes. federal prosecutors tonight in possession of 12 different audio recordings that were seized during fbi raids on michael cohen, the president's former lawyer. this according to court filings. it comes just three days after we learn there is a tape of trump and cohen talking about a payment for a former "playboy" model who said she had an affair with trump. what do we know about these tapes? right now we know there are a dozen out there? >> that's right, erin. there are a dozen of audiotapes in the hands of prosecutors investigating michael cohen. we learned one of them is the tape we've been talking about last week, where cohen is discussing with donald trump the payment that american media made to karen mcdougal, the former "playboy" model who alleged an affair with trump. that payment and recording came before the election.
4:17 pm
what we've learned is that 11 other tapes include conversations cohen had with reporters and members of the media. now, all of this has come out because initially trump's lawyers had wanted these tapes to be kept secret and out of the hands but prosecutors by say theying they should be covered by attorney/client private. they with drew that request. the court appointed person in charge of reviewing these files that were seized in that raid for privilege said, okay, not they've withdrawn this request, i'll hand them over to the prosecutors. so, erin, that is the latest there, but we do know there are other tapes, including ones trump h cohen has recorded with trump. sources say those are rather mundane and have to do with such as, can you call me back. >> i want to go to the former u.s. assistant attorney for the southern district of new york where cohen is under investigation. and white house correspondent for politico, eliana johnson.
4:18 pm
great to have both you. we have 12 tapes now. what do you think? >> i think there are two questions, first of all, what's on the tapes? second of all, why did they withdraw their claim of privilege? not to go too inside the weeds on the legal side, but in general if you're under investigation and you can keep documents out of the hands of the government -- >> you do. >> -- you do. so did they let these go because they knew that they were going to be ordered disclosed anyway and they're avoiding a bad ruling by the judge? or because giuliani suggested, they're exculpatory and exclusionary. >> i want to talk about what giuliani said in a second. eliana, first, though, trump's strategy is go after michael cohen, the guy who said he would take a bullet for him, now trump is out for him. inconceivable a lawyer would tape a client. perhaps illegal. every client of a lawyer would agree with that. the white house press secretary sarah sanders today tried to downplay how worried trump is about all of this. here is how she put it.
4:19 pm
>> how did the president feel when he found out that his longtime lawyer and fixer had recorded him surreptitiously? >> while the president maintains he's done nothing wrong on this specific topic, i'd refer you to the president's outside counsel. >> eliana, how worried is president trump? >> you know, erin, i think we are getting only part of the answer from sarah sanders. if we've seen anything over the past week, it's really that there is a disconnect between the president and some of his top advisers. the fact that the president's tweeting about this and he's tweeting angrily i think is far more revealing as to his state of mind about this. the question to me is, is he simply resentful that michael cohen is now an enemy rather than a loyal friend or do these tweets reflect a worry that michael cohen really has something on him, not necessarily that will be legally damaging but that will be really damaging to him in the court of public opinion? >> right, which, of course, it's an interesting distinction you make, right? there is being legally afraid and then there is just being
4:20 pm
absolutely livid at somebody for selling you out. harry, as you pointed out, trump waived executive privilege on that tape between himself and michael cohen to -- to the "playboy" playmate. rudy giuliani says that's because trump said i'll do it in the form of a check so it can be properly documented. right? trump tried to do it the right way and had nothing to hide. hence, let's go ahead and put that out there. that's rudy giuliani's explanation. does it add up? >> i mean, in general, very broadly speaking, doing something by check rather than cash is proof that you don't want to hide something, but the question is, was the underlying payment legal? however it was made. if it was made -- >> it was before the election, obviously. >> that's right. if it was made essentially as a reimbursement to a.m.i. so that they would be made whole for having kind of played this intermediary role, paying off mcdougal to help protect the president, there is a question why that wasn't disclosed in the financial filings of the
4:21 pm
campaign. >> right. because it wasn't. they said, okay, we didn't end up paying them back. look, there is a lot we still don't know on what happened here, but eliana, it comes as we're learning new details about michael cohen himself. he's been running into michael avenatti in restaurants in new york for awhile now. i remember him telling me about one of those instances. apparently it happened again and they talked. this was just the other day. the source says avenatti pitched cohen on resolving their differences and working together against trump. basically joining forces. avenatti just came on cnn moments ago and talked about this. >> frankly, i think he's waiting for donald trump to appear in the middle of a dark forest and lead him out to salvation. i don't think it's ever going to happen. we have zero interest, wolf, in cooperating with michael cohen until and unless he comes to the conclusion that it is time for him to come 100% clean and do the right thing, disclose what he knows about the president and
4:22 pm
let the chips fall where they may. >> cohen and avenatti on the same side, eliana, do you buy it for a second or is this just great pr for both of them? >> i think it's more the latter than the former, erin. i would note that michael cohen, somebody who has surreptitiously taped his client and been pretty public about turning on him doesn't seem like somebody waiting in a dark forest for donald trump to rescue him. i think michael avenatti has been far more successful trolling donald trump in the media and running a sort of media campaign against him that gins of his base than he actually has been about forming alliances that have been legally damaging to trump. >> that's the thing here, would you ever buy these two joining up? >> no. the person who holds the keys for cooperation is the u.s. attorney's office, not michael avenatti. cohen if he wants to protect his family, as he said he does, needs to reach out to them. there is nothing right now avenatti can do for him. >> if cohen has something they want, they'll get it from cohen.
4:23 pm
thank you both very much. former fbi director jim comey asking americans why is putin missing from the the list of leaders trump has publicly attacked? plus, our special "outfront" series debuts tonight. >> welcome to one of the last truly wild places on earth. >> this is an amazing piece coming up. the passionate debate at the heart of the arctic national wildlife refuge and the president. ordinary eggs? not in this house. 'cause that's no ordinary family.
4:24 pm
that's your family. which is why you didn't grab just any cheese. you picked up new kraft expertly paired cheddar and swiss for eggs. beat that! kraft. family greatly. you finayou know it! chair? woah!
4:25 pm
(laughter) hahaha-aaaahhhh! gorilla glue. of course. gorilla glue expands into the materials to form an incredibly strong bond. for the toughest jobs on planet earth. you shouldn't be rushed into booking a hotel. with expedia's add-on advantage, booking a flight unlocks discounts on select hotels until the day you leave for your trip. add-on advantage. only when you book with expedia. give you the protein you need with less of the sugar you don't. i'll take that. [cheers] 30 grams of protein and 1 gram of sugar. new ensure max protein. in two great flavors.
4:26 pm
new ensure max protein. does your business internet provider promise a lot? let's see who delivers more. comcast business gives you gig-speed in more places. the others don't. we offer up to 6 hours of 4g wireless network backup. everyone else, no way. we let calls from any of your devices come from your business number. them, not so much. we let you keep an eye on your business from anywhere.
4:27 pm
the others? nope! get internet on our gig-speed network and add voice and tv for $34.90 more per month. call or go online today. . tonight, trump's all caps threat against iran heard around the world. that tweet reads, to iranian president rouhani, never, ever threaten the united states again. or you will suffer consequences the likes of which through throughout history have ever suffered before. we are no longer a country that will stand for your demented words of violence and death. be cautious. trying to read it the way someone would read something like that sent from the president of the united states to the president of another country. now the white house says, hey, president trump was just responding to a threat from iran. >> he was responding to comments made from them and he's going to continue to focus on the safety and security of american people.
4:28 pm
>> imagine when your kid comes to you and says, well, he did it, so i get to do it, too. if trump feels the need for an all caps threat against iran on twitter because he is responding to them, perhaps he should have responded many times since taking office. there have been a lot of threats from iran. where was the response when iranian politicians burned the flag in parliament chanting death to america? rouhani warning, quote, we will bring the u.s. to its knees in a battle of wills. how about when the supreme leader himself khomeini tweeted, this man's corpse will be worm food while the islamic republic of iran stands strong. president trump did not respond to any of those threats or many others levelled by iran since he took office. just now, just today, in all caps. "outfront" now, david gergen, former presidential adviser to four presidents and staff writer
4:29 pm
for "the new yorker." david, this is the big question, all of a sudden you get this big all caps, worm food didn't bother him. we can laugh, but, you know, funny or not funny. is this all about we don't want anyone paying attention to russia or anything else? let's just start talking about iran? >> well, it's clearly something that he does often and that is deflect attention he doesn't want you to be watching to something he does want you to watch. i think that's part of it. the democrats and others have gone after him for that. i would hesitate to say that's all of it, erin. there is a strong feeling with john bolton and others that iran is now more vulnerable than it has been. its economy is weak. there is a lot of restlessness in iran. its currency has dropped by half since the beginning of the year. this is -- this is an administration, the trump administration wants to get rid of the iranian government. failing that, they want to weaken the iranian government. it makes to easier to deal with the europeans and others to try
4:30 pm
to put the squeeze on them. i think it's a double bare motivation. >> susan, the president ending with be cautious. just a moment ago, the iranian foreign minister zarif, who, you know, many of us have met him in person, including you, right? he's got a dry sense of humor. he has responded on twitter in all caps. color us unimpressed, be cautious, in response to trump. how dangerous is it to play this game with the iranian regime, right? you're basically taunting each other with annihilation and water on twitter. >> well, you know, it's interesting, you're right. the iranian foreign minister is an astute user of twitter himself. when i interviewed him last year, he made the point to me, i'm like donald trump. he consults around quite widely before he sends out his tweets. i think this was a very calculated response on the part of iranians. they have interestingly tried not to take the bait up until now from president trump. when he withdraw from the iran nuclear deal, you did not see
4:31 pm
the iranians say, forget it, that's it, we're done as well and we're just going to start redeveloping our nuclear program. they chose, instead, to, you know, work with the europeans who have remained parties to the deal, along with russia and china. >> yeah. >> and to try to find a way around it. you know, will trump push them into a corner now is an interesting question, but i do think david is making an important point. there is a through line of the trump foreign policy that is really all around organizing and isolating iran and seeing iran as the focus of american efforts in the middle east in a much more concerted way. so i think that, sure, the president wants to distract from russia. let's not forget, it's been one week since helsinki and he still hasn't told us whether vladimir putin was telling the truth or not when he said that he made important verbal agreements with donald trump behind closed doors in that meeting. >> it's amazing that was only one week ago. you can say that almost of any week of this presidency.
4:32 pm
david, the thing is though, in that tweet when he said you will suffer consequences,s likes of which few throughout history have suffered before. it obviously is incredibly and one must assume intentionally reminiscent of this. >> north korea best not make any more threats to the united states. they will be met with fire and fury. like the world has never seen. >> kim jong-un came to the negotiating table. now big question what happens from there, david, but is this what the president is trying to do? >> well, i don't think that worked very well with the north koreans. they did come to the table but now they're skipping meetings and they're going into their dodging habits. as other presidents have found, they're extraordinarily difficult to work with. so i think that -- i think the president, frankly, on north korea has sort of overpromised and under-delivered so far. yet he tells us that things are
4:33 pm
-- he's satisfied with it. he can't be satisfied. as cnn has reported, the president was fuming over the weekend about the lack of progress with north korea. he tells -- tweets everything that is fine. but he is -- you have to remember that only a short while ago the administration was promising they would have a deal and have everything all set by the end of this year. they're nowhere close to getting a deal in north korea right now. >> susan, you know, the former fbi director jim comey just tweeted, thought experiment, make a list of all the public figures in this country and around the world the current president has criticized. ask you, why is putin missing from the list? no responsible american should ever stop asking why. it's tweets like this president trump says he wants to strip jim comey of his security clearance. does comey have a point, though? >> well, first of all, i guess comey has also pointed out he no longer has a security clearance, and i did think that even more than the iran tweet, the decision to have the white house
4:34 pm
press secretary announce essentially a white house enemies list from the podium today that included james comey and other national security -- >> right. >> -- former officials who have criticized trump really smacks of something very un-american, very anti-democratic, small "d," and something that even for trump, you know, is an ill thought through diversion. you know, they didn't even bother to check that the list of names included people who didn't have security clearances. >> comey and mccabe. >> we'll see. >> thank you both. next, breaking news. trump's team going back to mueller. they've got a new counteroffer about this interview. this interview is like waiting for goodell. so what's on the table and what's not? plus, trump's push to drill in alaska's wildlife refuge. >> we fought like hell to get anwar. he talked me into it. >> how is this playing, though, on the ground? bill weir is there with a special report. are you done yet?
4:35 pm
does it look like i'm done? shouldn't you be at work? [ mockingly ] "shouldn't you be at work?" todd. hold on. [ engine revs ] arcade game: fist pump! your real bike's all fixed. man, you guys are good! well, we are the number-one motorcycle insurer in the country. -wait. you have a real motorcycle? and real insurance, with 24-hour customer support. arcade game: wipeout! oh! well... i retire as champion. game hog! champion. pepsoriasis does that. it was tough getting out there on stage. i wanted to be clear. i wanted it to last. so i kept on fighting. i found something that worked. and keeps on working. now? they see me. see me. see if cosentyx could make a difference for you- cosentyx is proven to help people with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis... ...find clear skin that can last. don't use if you're allergic to cosentyx.
4:36 pm
before starting cosentyx, you should be checked for tuberculosis. an increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur. tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms. or if you have received a vaccine or plan to. if you have inflammatory bowel disease, tell your doctor if symptoms develop or worsen. serious allergic reactions may occur. never give up. see me. see me. clear skin can last. don't hold back... ...ask your dermatologist if cosentyx can help you find clear skin that lasts. ♪ ♪ our new, hot, fresh breakfast will get you the readiest. (buzzer sound) holiday inn express. be the readiest. why people everywhere are upgrading their water filter to zerowater. start with water that has a lot of dissolved solids. pour it through brita's two-stage filter. dissolved solids remain? what if we filter it over and over?
4:37 pm
(sighing) oh dear. thank goodness zerowater's five-stage filter gets to all zeroes the first time. so, maybe it's time to upgrade. get more out of your water. get zerowater. is part of a bigger picture. that bigger picture is statewide mutual aid. california years ago realized the need to work together. teamwork is important to protect the community, but we have to do it the right way. we have a working knowledge and we can reduce the impacts of a small disaster, but we need the help of experts. pg&e is an integral part of our emergency response team. they are the industry expert with utilities. whether it is a gas leak or a wire down, just having someone there that deals with this every day is pretty comforting.
4:38 pm
we each bring something to the table that is unique and that is a specialty. with all of us working together we can keep all these emergencies small. and the fact that we can bring it together and effectively work together is pretty special. they bring their knowledge, their tools and equipment and the proficiency to get the job done. and the whole time i have been in the fire service, pg&e's been there, too. whatever we need whenever we need it. i do count on pg&e to keep our firefighters safe. that's why we ask for their help. breaking news. president trump's legal team submitting a counteroffer tonight to the special counsel bob mueller over terms for a possible interview with the president. "the wall street journal" reporting tonight that trump's team is willing to face questions about collusion with russia. so that's obviously extremely significant, but they want to curtail questions about
4:39 pm
obstruction of justice, which, of course, would involve questions about the firing of the former fbi director james comey, also, of course, possibly michael flynn. trump's personal lawyer rudy giuliani also telling "the journal" an interview between trump and mueller is, quote, still on the table. "outfront" now, wired contributing editor garrett graff and author of "the threat matrix." good to have you with me. i appreciate your time, garrett. so what do you make of the fact that these negotiations are still going on? obviously rudy giuliani's the one who appears to be leaking it or certainly talking about it. >> yeah. >> this interview that never seems to happen is still on the table. >> yeah, and i think that that in some ways is just the most significant piece of news out of this. i mean, regardless of what the specific details of the deal or the offer or the counteroffer are at this point, the dee that t -- idea that the negotiations are still ongoing, they're not, you know, dead on the operating
4:40 pm
table yet is significant, because i think that that shows that mueller is still going to keep pressing on this and that the president hasn't totally closed the door on this. i mean, this is now, you know, i've lost track at this point, probably an eight, nine-month process. >> yeah. >> but it looked like this was pretty dead up until basically this new news breaking. >> right. i mean, you know, and it comes, garrett, as paul manafort made a rare court appearance in virginia today. he was wearing a green jumpsuit, rumpled collar. mueller's team has convinced a judge to grant immunity to five people, three women and two men. connections to real estate dealings of manafort. how significant must their information about him be, garrett? >> probably significant to manafort, not particularly significant to the context of their own professional jobs. as you said, these appear to be people largely tied to the
4:41 pm
financial dealings that manafort has, probably the facilitators of it, and something that we should sort of expect will take center stage as this trial comes down about sort of the ins and outs of paul manafort's financial machinations. >> the manafort team has gotten another week or so, ten days, right, to go through a lot of these documents. the trial now has been postponed. it's not starting this week. it's going to start a week and a half or so later. the president, though, garrett has tried to distance himself from manafort again and again. falsely claiming that manafort only worked for his campaign for a short period of time, which is mostly untrue and it was a significant time. can the president successfully distance himself from his former campaign chairman as this trial starts up? >> i think it's going to be pretty hard. these are going to be daily headlines about, you know, paul manafort really being charged with conspiracy against the united states. i mean, that's an incredibly
4:42 pm
serious charge, even if you're not talking about the one-time campaign chair of the incumbent president, the victor in the presidential race. >> all right. garrett, thank you. appreciate it. talk to you soon. >> talk to you soon. and next, the fight over trump's move to drill in one of the most controversial places in the entire united states of america. >> we are changing the world everywhere so fast, but why not leave a few places unspoiled? >> bill weir there on the ground in alaska. and the accused russian spy, why was she meeting with multiple american officials? te e plaque psoriasis, little things can be a big deal. that's why there's otezla. otezla is not an injection or a cream. it's a pill that treats psoriasis differently. with otezla, 75% clearer skin is achievable after just 4 months, ... with reduced redness, thickness, and scaliness of plaques. and the otezla prescribing information
4:43 pm
has no requirement for routine lab monitoring. don't use if you're allergic to otezla. otezla may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. tell your doctor if these occur. otezla is associated with an increased risk of depression. tell your doctor if you have a history of depression or suicidal thoughts, or if these feelings develop. some people taking otezla reported weight loss. your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. other side effects include upper respiratory tract infection and headache. tell your doctor about all the medicines you take and if you're pregnant or planning to be. ♪ otezla. show more of you.
4:44 pm
it's willingham, edge of the box, willingham shoots... goooooooaaaaaaaallllllll!
4:45 pm
that...was...magic. willingham tucks it in and puts the championship to bed. sweet dreams, nighty night. as long as soccer players celebrate with a slide, you can count on geico saving folks money. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance. the players on the... ♪ it's so hard to believe ♪ but it's all coming back me. ♪ baby, baby, baby. all you can eat is back, baby. applebee's.
4:46 pm
but it's tough to gete enough of their nutrients. new one a day with nature's medley is the only complete multivitamin with antioxidants from one total serving of fruits and veggies try new one a day with nature's medley. tonight, president trump drilling in alaska. the president taking the first steps that would allow drilling in alaska's arctic national wildlife refuge, an incredible step, trump signing legislation that would open up 1 1/2 million acres of land to the oil business for the first time since 1980. the big question, at what cost? bill weir is "outfront." the amazing images and footage
4:47 pm
in our first part of the series. >> reporter: way up in alaska, an airplane can feel like a time machine because the arctic national wildlife refuge, commonly known as anwr is the type of pure wilderness that america paved over a long time ago. >> there it is. we are in the heart of the arctic refuge. >> reporter: welcome to one of the last truly wild places on earth. brims with life from musk oxen to bears, both grizzly and polar. birds that will my great to the backyards of all 50 states. but as captured over the years, the most common creature is the caribou, and not just a few, put hundreds of thousands. the kind of herd unseen since the plains buffalo were wiped away. when he is here with his family,
4:48 pm
he can't help but wonder how long it will last. >> we need to keep some of these places untouched. we are changing the world everywhere so fast, but why not leave a few places unspoiled? >> for almost 60 years, that was the rationale that protected anwr from this. these are the oil fields that fill the famous pipeline and power countless lives. but since there are billions of barrels elsewhere, nature lovers have long argued there is no need to drill here, and for decades that argument held until -- >> one day a friend of mine in the oil business called and said, is it true that you have anwr in the bill? i said, i don't know, who cares? what is that? he said, well, you know, reagan tried. every single president tried. i said, you've got to be kidding. i love it now. after that, we fought like hell to get anwr. he talked me into it. >> december's tax cut bill also opened anwr to drilling thanks
4:49 pm
to alaskan senator lisa murkowski, who slipped in the provision, knowing it would only need 51 instead of 60 votes to pass. >> it is wrong for those from the outside looking into who have taken a nice trip into an area and say, this must be protected. >> but conservationists point out there is already a huge glut of american oil. >> oil companies are laying people off up here, right, because prices are so low? >> oil companies have been laying people off. you know, for the first time in the last five years, i was seeing more oil company workers leaving the state of alaska and going to places like north dakota than coming into the state. >> but much like trump's efforts to revive dying coal mines, the rush to drill here seems driven more by politics than economics. former speaker of the house tom delay once said if we can drill in anwr, it will break the back of the environmental lobby.
4:50 pm
>> they haven't drilled in anwr yet. we know the arctic regions are heating twice as fast as the rest of the world. it makes zero sense to come here to look for more oil that is going to exacerbate that problem. >> among those opposed, is this nation, the northern most tribe of native americans. >> how many people live here? >> about 150 >> i think of how many people live on my floor of the apartment building. >> reporter: their numbers may be tiny, but they're definitely not outsiders. >> archaeological evidence shows we've been here over 25,000 years. >> reporter: and the only reason they survived is caribou. back in the day, they would trap the animals in these hand-made corrals. these days they use guns and snowmobiles, but still need the animals to survive in one of the most expensive neighborhoods in america. groceries at the midnight sun can cost twice as much as the whole foods in manhattan. gasoline up here runs $10 a
4:51 pm
gallon. but still, given the choice between oil money and caribou, there is no debate. these folks will stick with the one animal that has kept them alive for thousands of years, and they cannot imagine drills and trucks and pipelines across what they call the sacred place where life begins. >> look what happened to the plains indians and the buffalo. that's not going to happen to my people. we're not going to allow that to happen again. >> reporter: to the tribe, they are a native american david against a goliath of oil companies, republican lawmakers, and a coastal tribe of native alaskans, eager to drill and cash in. >> now that the u.s. is saying we can finally do this, now we have the other side, the environmentalists saying we can't do this. what's wrong with this picture? >> reporter: as the government rushes towards development, community meetings lay bare the fight. tribe versus tribe, neighbor against neighbor. >> we have thousands of gallons
4:52 pm
discovered in places that have already seen destruction, but restraint is what we lack. when did we all become owners of the land? it has always owned us. >> reporter: bill weir, cnn, alaska. >> and that's just the first installment. tomorrow, part 2 of our special "outfront" series. bill is going to take you to an alaskan town where all anybody talks about is trump, the weather, and polar bears. >> skinny, hungry polar bears aren't the only warning sign up here that is the airport, and they're moving it away from the coast, due in part to sea level rise. that is tomorrow, only here "outfront." and next, new details about who is financing the alleged russian spy maria butina. and exercise. and maybe even, unproven fish oil supplements. not all omega-3s are clinically proven or the same.
4:53 pm
discover prescription omega-3 vascepa. the one that's this pure... and fda approved. look. vascepa looks different... because it is different. it's pure epa. vascepa, along with diet, is clinically proven to lower very high triglycerides by 33% in adults, without raising bad cholesterol. that's pure power. proven to work. vascepa is not right for everyone. do not take vascepa if you are allergic to icosapent ethyl or any inactive ingredient in vascepa. tell your doctor if you are allergic to fish, have liver problems... or other medical conditions and about any medications you take, especially those that may affect blood clotting. 2.3% of patients reported joint pain. it's clear. there's only one vascepa. ask your doctor about pure epa prescription vascepa. ♪ why people everywhere are upgrading their water filter to zerowater. start with water that has a lot of dissolved solids. pour it through brita's two-stage filter. dissolved solids remain?
4:54 pm
what if we filter it over and over? (sighing) oh dear. thank goodness zerowater's five-stage filter gets to all zeroes the first time. so, maybe it's time to upgrade. get more out of your water. get zerowater. a hotel can make or break a trip. and at expedia, we don't think you should be rushed into booking one. that's why we created expedia's add-on advantage. now after booking your flight, you unlock discounts on select hotels right until the day you leave. ♪ add-on advantage. discounted hotel rates when you add on to your trip. only when you book with expedia.
4:55 pm
4:56 pm
i'm a small business, but i have... big dreams... and big plans. so how do i make the efforts of 8 employees... feel like 50? how can i share new plans virtually? how can i download an e-file? virtual tours? zip-file? really big files? in seconds, not minutes... just like that. like everything... the answer is simple. i'll do what i've always done... dream more, dream faster, and above all... now, i'll dream gig. now more businesses, in more places, can afford to dream gig. comcast, building america's largest gig-speed network. tonight, new details about
4:57 pm
meetings between alleged russian spy maria butina and american government officials. that's right, officials, plural. she met with multiple of them. a person who arranged the meetings confirms in 2015, butina met with a high-ranking official at the federal reserve and an official at the treasury department, and we're learning even more about butina's financial backer. sara murray is "outfront." >> reporter: alleged russian spy maria butina naming constantine nikolai as her backer in senate testimony earlier this year. a source tells cnn butina launched a gun rights group in moscow. >> the most important and the basicer for any freedom is of course gun rights. >> reporter: and used it to build ties with one of our key avenues into u.s. politics, the national rifle association. she and associates even tried unsuccessfully to arrange back channel communications between candidate donald trump and russian president vladimir
4:58 pm
putin. nikolai's office said 2014 was their last contact. the funding was to support their efforts in russia to raise awareness around certain domestic issues according to a statement from his office. retired cia chief of russia operations steven hall says vladimir putin often taps local billionaires to back his influence operations. >> we still have crontrol. >> all of these people can say look, we're not members of the russian intelligence service. we're not members of the russian government. and to the western ear, that sounds right. but in truth that's not really what's going on. >> reporter: court filings describe him as a russian businessman with deep ties to the russian business administration. according to forbes, the 47-year-old is worth just over a
4:59 pm
billion dollars. he made most of his fortune investing in russian ports and railways. he is also on the board of houston-based energy company american ethane. butina's lawyer insists she is not a spy and she has pleaded not guilty to charges of con suspicion and acting as a foreign agent in the u.s. alongside her mentor, kremlin linked bank or the aleksandr torshin, butina attended 2015 meetings with stanley fischer, and nathan sheets, at that time the treasury undersecretary for international affairs under the obama administration. the center for national interest think tank arranged the meetings. we facilitated meetings for aleksandr torshin in his capacity as vice-chairman of russia's central bank, the director said. it was his decision that maria butina would accompany him as an interpreter. no so far no one else has been charged in maria butina's
5:00 pm
alleged scheme, including these russians who allegedly helped her out, but we could get more information on wednesday. that's when she is expected to be back in court. erin? >> thank you very much, sara, who again has been following this story since the beginning. thanks to all of you for joining us. we'll see you back here tomorrow night. "ac 360" with anderson begins right now. good evening. it's been seven days since president trump and vladimir putin sat down together behind closed doors of the summit in helsinki. seven days and the white house still will not give a detailed account of what went on between them, what was said, what was decided. and now the president seems to be eagerly trying to do his best to change the subject, tweeting dire threats in all caps at iran, trying to gas light the public yet again about the fbi surveillance warrants that four republican nominated judges approved targeting carter page, a former foreign policy adviser to the campaign, suspected of being a russian agent. the president also launched a new attack on a newspaper he hates. none of these, though, are new tricks of mr. trump's trade. but today there was a new attempted diversion and a new novel way of