Skip to main content

tv   Larry King Live  CNN  December 8, 2009 12:00am-1:00am EST

12:00 am
there were two kinds. >> i was out working, you know. >> there's still some left on the snack table. >> it's only ten hours old. thanks for watching. "larry king" starts now. >> larry: tonight, amanda knox's parents from italy. their exchange student daughter was called a drug-crazed killer. a she devil who played sex games before slitting her roommate's throat. did the jury convict that image of amanda? mom and dad say that the girl they raised could never have murdered anyone. and they'll tell us how they plan to get her out of prison and why they'll never give up clearing her name. and winning freedom next on "larry king live."
12:01 am
>> larry: they're the parents of amanda knox. she's the 22-year-old american exchange student convicted of murdering roommate meredith kercher in perugia, italy. the guilty verdict against amanda and her italian ex-boyfriend were returned on friday. we thank you both for visiting us tonight from italy, and even though this couple are divorced, they are totally united in the support of their daughter. you've had an opportunity to see her, how is she? >> you know, the first time we saw her, she was completely crushed. devastated, you know, in shock as we all are. a second visit today and she's, you know, she's got her -- she's ready to go, ready to fight on. >> larry: chuck, what was your reaction after seeing her today?
12:02 am
i'm sorry, kurt, what was your reaction? >> you know, she -- that's fine. you know, she was actually kind of put me in a good frame of mind because she was in a good place as i'm going to be leaving here in the next day or so. but it made me feel good to see she was ready to charge on and she wanted to get back to studying at school and stuff like that. so we're going to work on getting that prepared for her. >> larry: is the prison there enough? do you have open visitation, edda? >> no, you know, it's certainly limited. we get -- well, normally twice a week. but it's christmas over here. so there's lots of holidays. twice a week, an hour each time. but we do get to sit and hold her hand and touch her and hug her. so that's nice. >> larry: as we'll be discussing a lot of differences between the united states and the italian legal system. for one thing, amanda was allowed to speak out during closing arguments. she addressed the court in italian.
12:03 am
you'll hear a translation. here's an excerpt. >> translator: i have reflected in the past few days over what i wanted to say. it came to my mind and i wrote down a question that has left many people perplexed. and i wrote down a question that perhaps is still very perplexing to many people. and also many people have asked me this question and that is how do you manage to remain so calm? well, first of all, i am not calm. during these days i wrote on paper in front of me that i'm afraid. i am not calm, i wrote down that i was afraid to lose myself. i fear being defined as someone i am not. and by actions that i did not commit. i am afraid of having an assassin's mask forced on my skin. regarding the decision to keep
12:04 am
me in prison these past two years, i can confess i feel let down, sad, and frustrated. especially because these decisions to me seem to be saying well, let's see -- >> larry: curt, your said your reaction to that was shock over the verdict and then anger. you want to elaborate? >> well, what we were expecting and especially since this trial has been gone on so long, which is almost 11 months, during the last five or so days where we had closing arguments and there was really precise handling and review of the evidence and really a complete breakdown of what the prosecution was putting forth during these last few days
12:05 am
with the italian judicial system having beyond a reasonable doubt, i was expecting a complete innocent verdict far beyond reasonable doubt. and with them to come up with guilty i think was a huge mistake and it just angered me beyond all belief. >> and you, how did you react, edda? >> well, i was also in shock. we had been told, you know, by everyone how there -- because there was no physical evidence of her at the crime scene. because there was no motive, in fact, the prosecution had changed the motive four times during the trial. and at the end they finally had to say, well, we don't have a motive, but it doesn't matter. and there's no physical evidence, there's no eyewitnesses or murder weapon. everybody was -- everybody in the press, the people in perugia were all telling us, you know, it's going to be okay. she'll be let out. so we were shocked. >> larry: did you get to see her
12:06 am
right after the verdict, curt? >> no. >> no. we were not allowed to. usually they would allow us after each hearing to go back behind the wall and hold her for 30 seconds. and in this case, they just took her away. >> larry: i understand, edda, she's been moved to a different cell. is that right? >> that's true. she was in a cell, a five-person cell, and she's now been moved to a two-person cell with the only other american in the jail there as her roommate. >> larry: curt, how would you describe generally the conditions where she is? >> well, we only get to see the visitation room, and we don't get to actually see where she stays within her cell. but i can tell you it is very cold. it is concrete. there is nothing nice about it at all. it's a maximum security prison.
12:07 am
and it's -- it's not where you want to have your child for two years for something that she didn't do. and hopefully it will be shorter than a year before we can get to the appeals level. >> larry: edda, is that where she's scheduled to be if she were to do 26 years, she'd be in that place where you visit her? >> well, we have no idea. where you're kept is really dependent on the prison system. and it can change on a whim. i know that there are -- rafael when he was here at this jail, he was here at the jail one day and the next day he was gone. so it really depends on the prison system. >> larry: we'll take a break. when we come back, we'll ask about the appeals system. audience, what do you think about the verdict? go to click on blog, let us know, we'll be back with amanda knox's parents after this. welcome to the now network, population 49 million.
12:08 am
right now 1.2 million people are on sprint mobile broadband. 31 are streaming a sales conference from the road. 154 are tracking shipments on a train. 33 are iming on a ferry. and 1300 are secretly checking email on a vacation. that's happening now. america's most dependable 3g network. bringing you the first and only wireless 4g network. right now get a free 3g/4g device for your laptop. sprint. the now network. deaf, hard-of-hearing and people with speech disabilities access
12:09 am
12:10 am
>> larry: we're back with edda mellas and curt knox. the parents of amanda knox. here's another excerpt from her comments during the closing arguments of her murder trial. watch. >> translator: many people tell me that if they were in my shoes, they would have pulled their hair out by now. tearing their cell apart. and i say that i do not do these things. i don't let myself be beaten down. in these situations, i take a
12:11 am
deep breath. i try and i try to look for the positives. i try to find the positives in important moments. and i know that this moment is one of those moments. because in this moment, unlike the previous moments, a true decision must be taken on an action. i feel more in contact with you, more vulnerable in front of you. but i am trusting and confident of my knowledge. and for this i thank you. >> larry: curt, one of our legal
12:12 am
eagles says the appeal system in italy are fairer for the defendant than in the united states. you don't just have to rule on constitutional grounds, they consider the whole matter and if they deem someone didn't do it, even if the jury said they did and there was no malfeasance of justice, they could throw the case out. have you heard the same thing? >> yeah. that's absolutely true. we've also heard that there is a slightly different phase where they could actually open it up for further evaluation of evidence that can even provide new information to the hearing as a whole. so there is very different scenarios than what happens in the united states. >> larry: edda, does that encourage you? >> oh, absolutely. you know, there's many italians who have told us that, you know, worst case scenario, the first level rarely works correctly.
12:13 am
they'll get it right in appeals. she will get out of there, they will not, you know, put away this innocent young girl for a crime she didn't commit. >> larry: it could take up to a year before it's even heard, right, curt, is that going to be hard to deal with? >> well, absolutely. that would now make three years that amanda has spent in a maximum security prison for something that she had no part of. and, you know, it's frustrating all around. and what really bothers me is that it's such a big mistake that took place inside this particular court. and i actually hope they push it up, recognizing that it was such a failure in this case. >> larry: her attorney said she seemed depressed, edda. did you find her that way? >> yeah, you know. the last -- she was very strong at the beginning, but the last few months have been devastating for her. she couldn't stay strong forever.
12:14 am
and you could really tell that she was suffering. it was just horrible for her. today was better. she's ready to fight on. her lawyers told her to have courage. she knows she's getting support from all over the world, which is just amazing. and that helps. >> larry: curt, you said you're going home. what in the next day or so? are you going to be able to be in touch by phone? >> you know, we actually are able to have a ten-minute phone call each week. and that's one of the extremely nice things, at least be able to hear her voice. and edda will be staying during the rest of the month of december and i'll come back in january. so we'll just kind of keep having a person over here at all times like we have for the last two years. >> larry: so there'll always be someone there. what about letters? can you mail every day something? >> yeah. absolutely. and she does get a lot of mail.
12:15 am
and she loves the mail that she gets. i think she told me she got one letter that was addressed to her that all it said on the envelope was amanda knox, italy, and it got to her. yes, she gets lots of letters of support. >> larry: frankly, curt, are you surprised by all of the attention by people and the media? >> well, there's two different perspectives on that, larry. the first one is the impact it had on the actual case itself, which really started with a case closed by the prosecution, you know, literally just days after meredith's death without looking at physical evidence and the whole snowballing effect that that had of continuous mistakes being made. and the impact that i personally believe it had on the verdict in this scenario.
12:16 am
the other side of the coin is as edda said, the amount of support that has come out on her behalf and on our family's behalf has been extraordinary and we're very thankful for it. >> larry: and we'll be back right after this. discover gives you a cash back bonus on every single purchase. what you do with it is up to you. what will you get back with your cash back?
12:17 am
now more than ever, it pays to discover. >> larry: we're back. we've got the final excerpt from amanda's courtroom remarks during closing arguments. you'll hear the translator. here it is. >> translator: because you've
12:18 am
stood with me not only directly but indirectly through my lawyers, my defense, my family, and my friends are the reason. they are the ones who are saving my life every day, day after day that i manage to stand this. i also have to thank the prosecution because for sure they are sincerely trying to do their job. even though they don't understand. they don't understand. even though they haven't been able to understand because they are trying to bring justice to an act that has taken a person from this world. and therefore i thank them for this for what i am doing, for what they are doing. the important thing now is that
12:19 am
i thank you because now it is your turn and therefore i thank you. >> larry: edda, how has all of this changed your daughter? >> oh, you know -- none of us will be the same. and amanda most of all. she went to italy this care-free, trusting, naive, just wanting to see the world happy young woman. and she's really become -- she had to grow up. she's much more serious, she's much more cautious. yeah. it's been hard. >> larry: curt, naturally you weren't there. is there ever a moment when you have doubt about her innocence? >> absolutely not. absolutely not. never even crossed my mind. the way that she was raised, the way that she goes about her life, the way that she makes her friends, and truly the friends that she has are close friends, they are not kind of just superficial friends.
12:20 am
and nothing in her background would ever lead you to believe that she would be associated to something like this. >> larry: edda, in the aftermath of the murder, your family in germany suggested that amanda come and stay with them. she didn't. do you think that would've changed things? >> oh, you know -- i kick myself every day that i didn't make her leave the country. and so does my cousin in germany. because had she left and none of this would've happened. she wouldn't be where she's at. but you know, we can't go back and fix that. we just need to go forward. >> larry: you don't think they would have extradited? >> no, there was no -- there's no evidence against her. you know, none of that interrogation that they bullied her into that the supreme court found illegal, none of that would've happened. there's no physical evidence of her at the crime scene. they would have had no reason to, you know, extradite her or
12:21 am
even attempt to arrest her. and they even admit to the fact that they really have no physical evidence. it's just sort of bizarre circumstantial stuff that they have. >> larry: we'll take a break. come right back and ask the parents, why they think she was found guilty. don't go away. ♪ get down tonight that's about to change. so you'll pay for the tour, but i have to change my name? no, you're still kc, but from now on, they will be the sun life band. it's funky. sooner or later, you'll know our name. sun life financial. you can build walls that separate people from people, but it is impossible to build a wall that separates a man from his freedom. because freedom always finds a path...
12:22 am
to build peace. this film is dedicated to aung san suu kyi, still prisoner in burma.
12:23 am
>> larry: we're back with edda mellas and curt knox. you mentioned no evidence. didn't the prosecution assert that amanda's dna was on the handle of the kitchen knife used to kill meredith?
12:24 am
and meredith's dna was on the blade? isn't that true, edda? >> you know, well, no, they found a knife in rafael's house. koointsd of it's kind of yes and no. there was amanda's dna on the handle, and that's because she actually cooked meals there. the speck of dna that was about a human cell that they found on the blade is highly controversial. it's what they call low copy number dna. the fbi won't even use it in the united states because it is so unreliable that you can't -- you can't prove anything tw. and that's all they think they have. >> larry: curt, why was she found not guilty? found guilty rather. why did she lose this case? >> well, frankly what i believe happened in this particular courtroom was a huge character assassination that literally took place for two years.
12:25 am
and the extreme exposure that this case got, and the misreporting, leaks of false information, and all of that just snowballed. and during the closing arguments, the defense teams for both amanda and rafael did an extraordinary job of breaking down the physical evidence and literally having the prosecution change to a fourth motive of, you know, we don't need a motive. i believe this court didn't have the courage to say not guilty and just push it off to the appeals level, which is completely unacceptable to me. >> larry: edda, what do you know about that night? what do you know about the stories and drugs and sex games and the like? what do you really know? >> well, you know, we know -- we don't know what happened at amanda's house because she wasn't there.
12:26 am
what we do know for sure and what has been proven by evidence is that amanda and rafael were seen at his house. it shows computer activity at his house. they were there, they cooked dinner, they watched a movie. they hung out. all of that is proven through computer records. all the way up until at least, i think, 9:15. now, they believe that meredith was killed about 9:30. and somehow the prosecution claims that in 15 minutes amanda and rafael got totally wasted, ran off, found a guy they didn't know, and committed this murder in about 15 minutes. it's ludicrous. amanda was at his house, they stayed there all evening. that's what we know for sure. >> larry: do you buy any of the anti-americanism idea, curt? >> you know, i would like to believe that there isn't any of that. but after listening to what took
12:27 am
place in the court of law and, you know, the huge mistake that was made in the result of this, you know, i frankly don't know what to believe. and i -- i'll leave it there at this point. >> larry: we have a third person, the ivory coast immigrant named rudig gidday. he was convicted of meredith's murder earlier in the year in his trial. police say he implicated amanda, after he declined to testify, the prosecution tried to have transcripts of his interrogation introduced, the motion was denied. what do you make of his involvement in all of this? >> you know, it's interesting. because we do know what was admitted of his. we know that his dna is all over the room, in the victim's blood, on the victim's body, his footprints are in her blood all over the room. his dna is in her purse.
12:28 am
after the crime he all of a sudden had money that he didn't have earlier in the day. he went out partying and then he fled the country. and we know also and what was admitted in amanda's trial. the only thing that was admitted was that when he was on the run and the police were secretly wiretapping him and he was talking to a friend of his, the friend said you know they think amanda was there. and he goes, oh, i know who amanda is and she was absolutely not there. >> larry: curiouser and curiouser. back with more after this. significantly improve my lung function. so today, i've noticed a significant difference in my breathing and i'm doing more of what i want to do. so we're clear, it doesn't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. my doctor said symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. it should not be taken more than twice a day. symbicort may increase your risk
12:29 am
of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. my copd often meant i had to wait to do what i wanted to do. now i take symbicort and it significantly improves my lung function, starting within 5 minutes. symbicort has made a significant difference in my breathing... now more of my want to's are can do's. ask your doctor about symbicort today. i got my first prescription free. call or go online to learn more. (announcer) if you cannot afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help.
12:30 am
immune plus shot. this little shot is more like a big shot of-- (dog barking) ...for your immune system.
12:31 am
feel the-- (dog barking) feel the good >> larry: one curious aspect about your daughter. she falsely implicated a man named patrick lamumba. he was cleared. why would she do that? she was sentenced to pay 40,000 euros to patrick lamumba for defamation. do you know where he came in? >> well, there -- during the time frame in which meredith lost her life and when amanda was actually arrested, it was about a 90-hour time frame. during that 90 hours amanda was actually questioned and interrogated for over 41 hours. and it culminated in a 14-hour overnight very aggressive interrogation.
12:32 am
she told us it's -- she has never been more scared in her entire life. she was asked to visualize a number of things, they prompted her towards patrick lamumba and literally she described even in her testimony six to eight people circling her, shouting at her, questioning at her, hitting her in the back of the head. and at that stage of the game you're virtually willing to sign anything in order to get out of that situation. and that's a circumstance that if you take a look at it, across the world, you're going to find that a number of people do a number of things. and i believe that's exactly what happened in this case. and one thing to point out here is that both of the statements that she made during that interrogation were actually thrown out by the italian supreme court. so in this particular circumstance, yes, he was part of the trial and yes, he was
12:33 am
awarded something, but i believe in the appeal process we're going to be able to show that she was essentially coerced into it, and therefore, the civil settlement will go away. >> larry: the kercher family, the victim in this is suing for $36 million in civil damages from your daughter, her former boyfriend, and the man previously convicted. what do you say to them? edda, what do you say to that family? >> you know, i understand -- you know, we've always said that we can only imagine the pain that they're going through. they lost their child. there's nothing that compares to that. i don't know about the civil penalties. i know that amanda has nothing. and i think it's mostly a symbolic type of a thing. but again, i can't imagine the pain that they're going through for the loss of their child. >> larry: maria cantwell who represents your daughter's home state of washington says she's complained to the italian embassy about this case and plans to raise the issue with
12:34 am
secretary of state clinton. secretary clinton said she's willing to meet with the senator or anyone who has a concern, but the state department said today it's not received any indications that italian law was not followed in this case. so the state department seems to be backing away. what do you make of that, curt? >> well, first of all, i'd like to say thank you to maria cantwell. because she's really standing out, you know, front and forward on amanda's behalf. and we appreciate any support that will allow us to bring our daughter home because she is in a prison now that she does not belong in. and she's been there too long for something that she hasn't done. you know, i think as people -- and literally this happens over here in italy, as well. as people look closer and closer at this case, and in this individual court, they're seeing that wait a minute, this is the
12:35 am
wrong verdict for the evidence that was presented in the court of law. and i think it needs to be looked at more and more. and i truly appreciate the efforts she's putting forth in trying to bring that to a conclusion. >> no comment on what the state department said? >> you know, i don't -- i don't know specifically. i -- we're kind of running a little bit in the dark since we're so far away. >> larry: yeah. >> i think if they look into it further, they're going to find that they're going to want to pursue it a little bit more. >> and we already know. i mean even the italian supreme court has ruled that her rights were repeatedly violated. so you know, this is not all gone, you know, hunkey dory. even on itannian standards they have made huge mess takes, and her rights were repeatedly violated. >> larry: we have some twitter questions right after this. you ? yes, i can-- how about 2:00 ?
12:36 am
hmm... get over your cold faster. people think that honda is always the most fuel efficient choice. well, this chevy cobalt xfe has better highway mileage than a comparable honda civic. this chevy traverse has better mileage than honda pilot. the all-new chevy equinox has better mileage than honda cr-v. and chevy malibu has better mileage than accord. however, honda does make something that we just can't compete with. it's self propelled. chevy. compare us to anyone and may the best car win. consider this: these duracell batteries were given... to the mattel children's hospital, u.c.l.a. because when it comes to kids and healing... you're not just powering a toy. you're powering a smile. duracell. trusted everywhere. ♪ well, look who's here. it's ellen. hey, mayor white. how you doing? great. come on in.
12:37 am
would you like to see our new police department? yeah, all right. this way. and here it is. completely networked. so, anything happening, suz? she's all good. oh, my gosh. is that my car? [ whirring ] [ female announcer ] the new community. see it. live it. share it. on the human network. cisco. we decide to turn in early. we just know. announcer: finding the moment that's right for you both can take some time. that's why cialis gives men with erectile dysfunction options: 36-hour cialis or cialis for daily use. cialis for daily use is a clinically proven low-dose tablet you take every day, so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. tell your doctor about your medical condition and all medications and ask if you're healthy enough for sexual activity. don't take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. don't drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache.
12:38 am
to avoid long term injury seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than 4 hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision stop taking cialis and call your doctor right away. announcer: cialis for daily use or 36-hour cialis. ask your doctor if cialis is right for you, so when the moment is right, you can be ready. >> larry: the family of meredith kercher was present when the verdict against amanda knox was announced. meredith's brother had this to say. >> we're pleased with the decision, pleased that we got a decision. but it's not a time for celebration at the end of the day. it's not a moment of triumph. and as we've said before, at the end of the day we're all gathered here because our sister was brutally murdered and taken away from us. >> larry: we have some twitter questions for our guests.
12:39 am
one person asked, edda, has your child shown any signs of drug or sexual addiction? >> never. you know, amanda was an honor student all the way through high school and college. she was a normal girl, just like all college students who maybe try things that their parents really don't want them to. but she was a great kid who was getting great grades and working jobs and, no, she was not doing anything extreme. >> larry: curt, are you surprised at all the sex references with regard to your daughter? are you shocked at that? >> actually, yes. i mean amanda was what i might refer to as a late bloomer when it came to boys. but one of the things that she was very focused on was her schoolwork, and it's one that she never let go. and with that, you know, i think any time that you have young
12:40 am
individuals, they're going to experiment in sexual encounters with other males and so forth. but, you know, to try to portray her as being sexually dooef deviant or something like that is absolutely incorrect, and she is just a normal, college kid. and it's unfortunate someone would consider something like that. >> larry: why did she go to perugia? >> you know, amanda wanted to see the world. and she really is gifted in languages. and she wanted to see a really ancient culture. she wanted to come here and immerse herself in the language and the history and the people. and perugia is not what people consider a tourist town. she wanted to go some place more normal italy. and that is why she came here. >> larry: curt, what has the defense team come up with? what's their theory of the
12:41 am
crime? >> well, i think it's actually a fairly simple one when you look at it and look at the evidence that has taken place. number one, you've got rudy who has a prior history of breaking and entering through second story windows with a knife. >> and a rock. >> and definitely throwing rocks. but the other thing about that is -- i think in this circumstance he broke in intending to steal rent money because it was at the very beginning of the month. he got surprised by meredith coming home, and i think he took some steps to potentially have an encounter with her and it got out of hand and he basically killed her. and then essentially took off to germany. and it's literally that simple. >> larry: we'll be back with some remains moments with edda
12:42 am
mellas and curt knox. don't go away. ork better on pain tylenol 8-hour. so why am i still thinking about this? - how are you? - good, how are you? aleve. proven better on pain. your own seafood feast at red lobster. choose two or three from new creations... like wood-grilled shrimp with garlic creme and parmesan... to classics like succulent steamed crab legs. for a limited time, at red lobster.
12:43 am
>> larry: edda, what would you say to the family of the deceased? >> you know, again, we said it so many times. we can't even imagine their loss and the pain that they must feel. but we would also tell them that we know that absolutely amanda
12:44 am
had nothing to do with this. and meredith was her friend. and this is -- there's a couple new victims in this whole mess and that's amanda and rafaele. >> larry: curt, did the prosecution ever present a theory of a motive? >> you know, they actually went through four of them. the first one was a satanic rite. the second one was a sex-drug orgy. the third one was a hatred for meredith. and they could not prove any of those. so they just moved on to we don't have a motive during the closing argument phase. at least in the united states, you need to have a motive in order to convict somebody. and it just shows the entire weakness of the case and having the defense literally break down all of the physical evidence during closing arguments.
12:45 am
it was so crystal clear to me that she was innocent and should have been found that way, but there's been a huge mistake in this particular courtroom. and it needs to get fixed. and fixed soon. >> larry: edda, one of the twitterers want know, in what way will the consulate help them or maybe has helped them? >> you know, unfortunately they -- everybody is "keeping an eye on this case." we're in a foreign country, we have to abide by the laws in this country. you know, they're watching closely. we're not sure yet. i'm actually meeting -- i'm going to the embassy on friday to have another meeting. and so really we don't know how they can help or if they can help. >> larry: we're going to ask edda and curt to sit by. we have two segments left. two prominent american attorneys, john q. kelly who supports them completely has been on with us before, and defense attorney mark geragos. they will comment on this case and then we'll get to hear what
12:46 am
edda and curt think about what they say after this. ( coughs ) - no vacation? - ( laughing ) i can't afford it. you can if you name your own price. - i don't know how. - it's easy. priceline has insider deals-- empty hotel rooms, open plane seats. ( laughing ) you can save up to half off! that's a great deal! saving money is no laughing matter. ( laughs ) woman: (thinking) so, i stick this bounce bar inside my dryer and for about four months, it'll freshen my clothes automatically? wow, let's see you in action. hmm, i wish all my chores took care of themselves automatically. ( ♪ ) (dryer buzzing) ( sniffing ) enjoy automatic freshness for about four months with the new bounce dryer bar.
12:47 am
for about four months about all the discounts boswe're offering. i've got. i some catchphrases that'llideas make these savings even more memorable. gecko: all right... gecko: good driver discounts. now that's the stuff...? boss: how 'bout this? gecko: ...they're the bee's knees? boss: or this? gecko: sir, how 'bout just "fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance." boss: ha, yeah, good luck with that catching on! anncr: geico. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance.
12:48 am
oh. god, i'm lost. which way is me? i guess i have to do everything. [ gasps ] [ angelic voices vocalizing ] on sale at bookstores everywhere. we're joined by the prominent defense attorney here in los angeles, mark geragos, and in new york john q. kelly, a former prosecutor and civility gator, among his clients of he is states of nicole brown simpson. what's your read on this? >> i think amanda's parents have a real beef here. it's, i think, every parents's worst nightmare to send your child overseas, and then have them get ensnared in something like this.
12:49 am
by all accounts the evidence was anything but overwhelming and certainly not convincing. i don't know who said it, whether it was them or one of the other relatives, somebody had a great statement that i heard, which was they weren't trying amanda, they were trying some fictional character. it sounds like that's exactly what happened. >> edda, is that what you feel? >> oh, absolutely. it's amazing. everything that was said in court about amanda, we're looking at each other going who are they talking about. it didn't even follow the evidence of the people that knew her and testified about her. it was just weird fantasy, bizarre. >> larry: john, you've been involved with this and been on with us before about it. would this have been different if it was the united states? >> there's been injustice here, but this is just beyond the pale, larry. the manipulation of evidence, the unfavorable inferences drawn from those comment of
12:50 am
circumstances and conduct was just a gross injustice here. i mean, what the prosecution did was take normal negatives and create evidence out of them. if flrp no fingerprints in the room, it's because amanda cleaned them up. when her hard drive was destroyed by the police, she must have done it. when the murder weapon did not fit the wounds on the vick and the outline on the bed, the bloody outline, they should there must have been two knives involved then. they explained their lack of evidence by creating this elaborate cover-up and conspiracy that amanda was involved in. >> curt, r were you happy with the defense? >> i thought our defense team and for that matter raphael's defense team did a great job in breaking dow down and breaking up any physical evidence in the court of law. but i think as both of the attorneys that are on here with us have stated, there was something much bigger going into
12:51 am
this thing, and literally the character assassination that amanda experienced up front just continued to snowball. they made a person that they needed in order to fit their fantasy story that they put together. >> larry: mark, we've heard that the appeals system in italy is more favorable to the defendant in the united states. for example, they don't have to rule on whether the constitution was violated or not, they look at the whole case? >> it's almost a denovo procedure, meaning you get to start fresh. you get to start new. >> they look at the whole thing from start to finish. it's not limited to legal questions and evidentiary questions or anything like that. >> that seems in congress to where a trial is held. >> it basically gets two bites at the apple. the problem is as they've indicated is she sits there in a prison that something by all accounts she didn't do. as john says, the injustice here is something that is shared in
12:52 am
america. there are many cases in america where you ever this similar prot could you tellal technique of character assassination. it's the she doesn't act right evidence, or you get any rumor or anybody with an ax to ground and get up there and say anything they want. that inflames juries and gets jurors to focus on things that were not evidence and instead to get passionate or prejudice shall. >> why do you think the prosecution was so heavy-handed apparently out after her. >> first of all, there's a lot of pressure on them to sell this case quickly. it's a small college town, and it's very sedate there and all of a sudden they had this sa lose yus senseless killing of a beautiful young woman, a wonderful wong won. they needed suspects and arrested these two individuals based on groundless speculation
12:53 am
before they ever examined the forensic and physical evidence. they didn't want to back down from it. one other thing i want to point out that's never brought up is they talk about her inconsistent statements. in the last four and a half hours she was considered a subpoena there, and under ihe talian law they were required to video that last four and a half hours. that's where all the controversy comes in about kwha she was abuzed and was she hipt thet cal questions and they said, no, amanda is absolutely about -- >> larry: you don't have a tape. >> there's no tape there. so the hard drive on her computer showed her friendship with meredith and the videotape that was requires and i'm sure it was taken. both disappeared. >> we'll have more moments right after this.
12:54 am
because we believe in the strength of american businesses. ge capital understands what small businesses need to grow and create jobs. today, over 300,000 businesses rely on ge capital for the critical financing they need to help get our economy back on track. the american renewal is happening. right now.
12:55 am
12:56 am
>> larry: mark, what would the key aspect of your appeal, and would you be encouraging for edda and curt? >> yes. if the reports i read are correct, they've mortgaged and bankrupted themselves basically to fund the defense. but obviously, they're not giving up hope. they do whatever they have to do. it's their daughter. >> would this be a good appeal? >> i think so. i mean, it would be a great appeal if you were some place where you could trust the justice system. i don't know how much trust at this point they have in the italian justice system that basically as they've said and i par rotted and fictional character and invoked class war
12:57 am
father to do it and went to great lengths to take what are normal negative exonerating inferences and create bad evidence, if you will, out of them. >> larry: do you think they'll get a fair appeal? >> i certainly hope so. i think with the pressure brought on right now, i think they will. the goal is to get the case out of italy and get two new judges and six new lay jurors a little more open-minded and not infected by the media of the first month after this case broke. the parents have incredible resolve right now, and i know they're going to. >> edda, are you optimistic? >> you know, i have to be. i mean, if i wasn't, i wouldn't get out of bed in the morning. i have too keep fighting for amanda. there's no way that we'll stop fighting for amanda. >> larry: curt, what about you?
12:58 am
same thing. i mean, she is not going to be left in a foreign prison 6,000 miles away from us for something she didn't do. it's so chris cal clear to me that there is such a huge mistake in this courtroom that it has to be fixed and has to be fixed soon. >> i know both of you give many thanks to tell us thousands of people writing to you, right, from all over the world, edda? >> oh, huge. the support, larry, has been unbelievable, and thank you for allowing us to take a second here to truly thank the letters and the outpouring from starting in italy all through europe, all over the world. you know, lots of people in seattle, obviously, but everywhere. we want to thank them for their support. >> it's been extraordinary. i mean, just, you know, literally everywhere you can think of, there has been support for not only amanda but for us as a family. it's great to see. we truly appreciate it.
12:59 am
>> larry: mark, are you surprised at this support from everywhere? that this case is generatingene? >> no, it's interesting. if these same things went on in america, people have kind of a naive faith in the american justice system. i think that when you place it and say this happens in italy and people don't have that prism of faith in the american justice system and they then say, well, look, this put for the grace of god walk i or my kids, i think people are more rational about it and understand what a horrific situation this is. >> larry: john, are you surprised? >> no, not at auchlt it's an extraordinarily unjust situation from a he very good family. and it's every parent's worst nightmare, that their son or daughter could be overseas studying which so many strive for and get swept up by circumstances. their lives are destro


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on