tv CNN Presents CNN April 14, 2013 8:00pm-9:00pm EDT
diane called jackie -- this is the phone call where she sounded disheveled and disoriented. >> he basically stated she didn't sound like herself. at one point he called her danny, which is her husband's name. he knew something was wrong. the kids were crying in the background. he told his sister to stay put, he'd be right up there. >> when there is an incoherent phone call with her brother, her oldest niece is apparently on the phone to her parents saying there's something wrong with aunt diane. >> they're say aunt diane can't see, aunt diane can't -- something is wrong with aunt diane. they were pulled over at that point, and emma told her dad where they were. read me a sign, and she said tarrytown. >> warren races up from where he
is in long island to the tappen dsy bridge, to try and find diane. she leaves her phone on the jersey bar krer, the divider at the bridge. >> the phone was located on a pull-off. she found her cell phone sitting on a guide rail. her entire route up until the bridge is consistent with what she normally would have been done. then it's unclear where she went.
>> are you all right? >> no. confide frankly. >> well, thanks for doing this. >> um. >> was she your closest friend? >> i would say, yeah. she was. we were not very similar. i'm an easygoing person, let a lot of things pass. she had to be in charge of everything. there was nothing left to chance. everything has to be planned and precise. she loved you, she loved you. if she didn't like you, she could be difficult, you know. she didn't let anything go, you know. she, you know, somebody was rude or -- she would call them out right there. you know, she was okay as long
as she was in control of everything. >> reporter: did you guys every have conversation about any kind of pain she was having? >> um, you know -- i know she did have issues with, um, like eespecially that week, every time i would see her, she would be holding her jaw, moving her mouth around. knowing her and knowing what kind of person she was every day of her life and how she conducted herself, as crazy as it sounds, people grasping for, you know, reasons, it seems more plausible to anybody who knows her that something medical could have happened to her. >> did shy seem at all upset that week? >> not at all, and diane was never the type of person to hide her feelings. if she was upset with you, you knew she was upset. she would not smile and just pretend. if something was wrong, she would have said something was
wrong the. >> did she talk about her marriage with you? >> not really about her marriage. you know, i know to me she just appeared very content, you know, very happy with the way her life w was. you know, never heard her -- she wouldn't discuss her marriage, no. >> when was the last time you had spoken with her? >> about ten years. >> ten years? >> um-hmm. what happened with ten years that you didn't speak? >> you know, dhani just likes to do their own thing. we never got into a fight. there was never an argument, never a reason why we stopped talking. it just stopped. that was it. there was no rhyme or reason why it ended. >> i was the actually the only one invited to the wedding. i did not go by choice, because
>> yeah, this is '05, four years before. grinding teeth, sensitivity to cold, loose teeth, broken fillings, and tooth pain, difficult -- does that say abscess? maybe that was the same tooth that was bothering her afterwards. you know, it's so funny, she would never even tell people she was going to the dentist. it's not like people would know she was suffering -- >> no. she's like i'm fine, i'm fine, i'm fine. >> diane was a very private person. people who knew her said to me over and over again, that diane didn't talk about personal matters. she never articulated feelings about anybody. >> hi, this is liz gav is
calling again. >> her mom was like a nonissue. i don't think she really wanted to interact with her. she talked about a dad. she adored her dad. >> do we know why her mom left her? >> i did. >> you don't want to talk about her mom? >> no. i'm sorry. >> i don't even know 100% the background of the divorce. i just know everybody -- they were all very angry. >> the mother left with the next-door neighbor. >> i think it was like a family friend. >> issue never complained about it. she never talked about it. it was as if like -- almost like she wasn't even there. >> one time i talked to diane's mother, and she said i'm not the bad person. whatever that meant, i don't know, so i told that to diane when i came home.
she said -- >> diane's mother reached out time and again trying to reconciled, and diane has brothers, and diane's mother had a relationship with her sons, diane's brothers. so it was really uniquely diane who held some kind of unarticulated grudge against her mother. >> parents get divorced, but it's very rare that a 9-year-old daughter would not go with her mother in a divorce at that particular point in time. so diane herself needed to use some denial of being abandoned by her mother at the age of 9. of course it's very painful. i think issued that vulnerability about her.
my name is brad. i'm actually trying to help a friend right now. they're on their way home from a connecting trip with their aunt. they just called my friend, saying that the aunt is driving erratically, the best thing they can understand is they were in tarrytown, or those were the signs they saw. the aunt isn't picking up the cell phone right now. >> you know what kind of car they're in? >> yeah, in a minivan, red, with a ski rack. jackie is flipping out. she can't remember the license plate number. >> just based on what miss jackie had told me, that this was out of character for her sister-in-law not to answer the phone, and also the fact that one of the children had meanted that her aunt wasn't feeling well, i asked her if diane schuler had any history of medical problems. i think i even asked her, you know, if she had any history of drug abuse.
these are questions i would ask anybody, and she said no, so at that point i kind of treated it as an overdue motorist/possible medical emergency, but at that point we were just seeing if we could locate the van. >> there's a number of ways that she can get to the entrance to iconic. she could have gone up and suchly made a utern, so how she got to that exit ramp, we don't know. listen, i have a family here that thinks they have might have a medical emergency of their sister with five kids in the car. >> okay. >> do you know if there's any way we can track her cell phone to get a location if i give you a number? >> we can try it. >> the last name?
>> s-c-h-u-l-e-r. >> the phone bill is either schuler or -- >> he's talking on the folk. >> does the bill in schuler or. had ance? >> are you with me? raises it to a more meaningful place. makes us live what we do, love what we do and fills our work with rewarding possibility. aarp connects you to a community of experienced workers and has tools to help you find what you're good at. an ally for real possibilities. aarp. go to aarp.org/possibilities. all stations come over to mithis is for real this time. step seven point two one two. verify and lock. command is locked.
five seconds. three, two, one. standing by for capture. the most innovative software on the planet... dragon is captured. is connecting today's leading companies to places beyond it. siemens. answers. i'll just press this, and you'll save on both. [bell dings] ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, llllet's get ready to bundlllllle... [ holding final syllable ] oh, yeah, sorry! let's get ready to bundle and save. now, that's progressive. oh, i think i broke my spleen! welcnew york state, where cutting taxes for families and businesses is our business. we've reduced taxes and lowered costs to save businesses more than two billion dollars to grow jobs,
cut middle class income taxes to the lowest rate in sixty years, and we're creating tax free zones for business startups. the new new york is working creating tens of thousands of new businesses, and we're just getting started. to grow or start your business visit thenewny.com stay top of mind with customers? from deals that bring them in with an offer... to social media promotions that turn fans into customers... to events that engage and create buzz... to e-mails that keep loyal customers coming back, our easy-to-use tools will keep you in front of your customers. see what's right for you at constantcontact.com/try.
♪ i got a phone call from my brother-in-law, diane's brother. then i got my keys and my brother, and we went upstate. >> he asked me if i would take a ride with him, see if they could find diane. >> i was at work. when i heard jimmy call and say danny's coming over, he needs me s. we are going to find diane. at that point we just thought she wasn't feeling well.
you don't want to touch that. this is an area where we set up our alcohol levels for whatever sample we're testing, so it's blood, urine, brain. >> was diane schuler's blood alcohol 'tissed? >> yes. the frontal lobe of year brain starts to be affected around 5.01. she had over ten drinks in her at the time she died. her blood alcohol was 0.19%, and the vitt reius humor was 0.3, and gastric was 0.25. >> i'm a psychiatrist, trained in general sky triand additional
training in drugs and alcohol. once you start getting over 0.2, you start getting into alcohol toxicity. that's the level where people are needing to show up in the e.r., becoming unconscious, having blackouts, and even going into coma. >> with the marijuana on board, one and one don't equal two anymore. they potentate each other, so then she has the effect of the marijuana as well as the effect of the alcohol. >> alcohol may increase the absorption of the marijuana, so that people who drink first may experience stronger effects, so if she wasn't accustomed to drinking and smoking at the same time, the marijuana affected her so much more than she had anticipated. and marijuana being a ha lose no gen, your cognitive function can
deteriorate pretty rapidly. >> the thc, which is the active ingredient in marijuana, her level was 113 nanograms per mil, very high. we were able to tell based on research she could have smoked anywhere from 15 minutes to an hour before she had this accident. marijuana is our number one drug of choice after alcohol or with alcohol. in fact it's outpacing alcohol as being found in drunk drivers, throughout the nation, not just here. >> one thing they mention is about the pot, what do you make of that? >> not true at all. not true at all. on a rare occasion she would, but definitely not that weekend. >> was it something she used to relax? something she used to stress or fun? >> on occasion, to relax. that's all not true. everything in here is not true.
>> no, no, it was mostly to be able to get a good night's sleep. i think after everything was down, clothes are ironed, kids are in bed, books are read, maybe she would have some before she went to sleep. it wasn't like you would -- you would never look at her and think she smoked pot, but some people do. >> is why she took it? >> no, i just knew that she smoked. >> the question is, why did she need to use marijuana to help her relax? help her go to sleep? what was so painful for her? there was something in her life that was not controllable basically from the age 9. if you cannot control what happened at the time that it happened. r, they become hyper responsible, tightly wound. she was okay as long as she was in control. >> having an history of an early
loss or trauma definitely predisposes one toward both mood disorders and addictive disorders. so statistically, she's at risk. the witnesses i interviewed had encountered diane schuler's vehicle just prior to the accident. they were getting off pleasantville road exit, and they observed her coming at them the wrong way coming down the exit ramp of the taconic. >> it was literally as if we weren't even on the road. she's coming toward us, you know, i'm blinking my lights, beeping the horn, she's
flailing. we drove up on the grass. otherwise he would have been hit. she never put on a brake, she never even -- her eyes didn't even move. >> it's just i'm going where i want to go, i'm doing what i need to do, i'm where i want to be. >> and she went around the bend onto the highway itself. >> we know that diane schuler enters the taconic state parkway going south in the northbound lane approximately 1.7 miles north of the point of impact. she drives this 1.7 miles at a high rate of speed, and you have half a dozen callser to 911. >> state police, 911. >> state police, you've been northbound taconic, there's a minivan in the right lane going southbound. >> 911. >> hi, i'm on the taconic expressway, just passed exit 100-c there's a car going like
70 miles an hour in the wrong direction. >> it was surreal. thank god nobody was on the side. i was able to go over -- and i said at the time at 70 miles an hour. dead pinned straight. it wasn't doing this. it was dead pinned straight. right after it happened that's when i called 911. >> yeah, i've got a guy driving south on the northbound taconic parkway. i was in the left lane. he's going like a bat out of hell, should be on the parkway right now. it's a minivan. >> state please, where's your emergency? >> i'm on the taconic -- hang on. >> the van that's going southbound? yeah, they're going out for it. >> yeah, i just remember saying oh, my god, oh, my god, i was just trying to draw attention to get validation from rich that maybe something peculiar was there on the road. >> my heart was going about 200
beats a minute and then the car went past us. >> just like playing chicken. we saw something coming at us. we react, we mofds. she had no reaction at all. she didn't stop, didn't slow down, didn't move. i thought it was someone dead-set on killing themselves. we're all set to bundle your home and auto insurance together. i'll just press this, and you'll save on both. [bell dings] ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, llllet's get ready to bundlllllle... [ holding final syllable ] oh, yeah, sorry! let's get ready to bundle and save. now, that's progressive. oh, i think i broke my spleen! to prove to you that aleve is the better choice for him, he's agreed to give it up. that's today?
[ male announcer ] we'll be with him all day as he goes back to taking tylenol. i was okay, but after lunch my knee started to hurt again. and now i've got to take more pills. ♪ yup. another pill stop. can i get my aleve back yet? ♪ for my pain, i want my aleve. ♪ [ male announcer ] look for the easy-open red arthritis cap.
good afternoon. >> hi, doctor. >> i don't know if i can get up, because i'm all wired. >> very nice to meet you. >> nice to meet you. >> thank you for making the trip. we appreciate it. >> uh, okay. the autopsy report includes chemical analysis, toxicology, and interviewed some witness statements and police stateme s
statements. and i gained the impression that the autopsy was done properly and was done well. so is there anything that would, based on the autopsy, account for this crash? alcohol and marijuana actually would. >> we obviously don't know much about this, but she would not do this. there is something wrong with this picture, and i don't want her being a poster child for drunk moms, because you would never tell me she does is it. you tell me my sister who passed away? yes, she probably was drinking 100%, but this wasn't diane. this wasn't his wife. she would be the one to yell at us our kick or butts. >> what are we going to do?
>> i just feel, which is me being my strong opinion, is as soon as they saw alcohol, it was all stopped. okay, she was drunk, she was high, that's it, categorizes that, drunk mom driving five kids in the war. >> what about the abscessed tooth. >> the which? >> abscessed tooth. >> could that cause a stroke? >> could that cause a stroke? >> yeah. >> in theory, yes, but based on the autopsy, there is none that i saw on microscopy. a stroke is something like this, and does cant alcohol -- >> but could that reading be a mistake due to other manage conditions that people don't know she had? >> it could, but the question of the alcohol will always prevail. >> so say we exhumid the body and it's all -- there's x-rays from years ago. >> but the still will still prevail, how could it have
caused alcohol in the vitreous. >> maybe she had a stroke by mistake, thought it was water and drank it. >> we want to know physically happened, if she did have alcohol in her, did she top and be incoherent and do something melly that happened to her? we're even willing to say that, but there's no way if she was in the right state of mind she would go and take that bottle. you tell me she was having a stroke or hallucinating, this or that due to an abscess, we're going to have to live with that. >> if she does are an abscess, she could have had such pain and takes whatever is available to alleviate the pain. >> she would either have to be not thinking it's water. >> she's not thinking clearly because she had a tooth abscess. >> okay. that's what i'm thinking. >> okay. so if she had a tooth abscess, what you could do is say to
yourself she had severe pain, and she had to alleviate that pain now, not in an hour, now. >> so she drank 1.9. >> in 45 minutes? >> you know -- >> someone who drank once a month maybe? >> it really doesn't make sense, my trying to convince you. you have to have your satisfaction, your satisfaction is only if you're going -- is only going to be achieved if you send it to another laboratory to redo it. >> so that would be the next step? >> that's the only way i know what to tell you. >> and then also with exhuming, that's the way to go? >> yeah. >> it's very frustrating. people have promised us the world they would find out, get to the bottom, retest everything, and do that. it's been a year and three months. >> when you say people -- >> our investigator was supposed to get the samples and send them to another lab. >> and didn't do it?
>> we don't know. that's what we've been asking for. right? >> yeah. >> we do appreciate you looking at everything and doing this. >> thank you so much. >> you're welcome. i sincerely hope that you find peace with this. >> it's 5:00. i need like 100 cigarettes. ♪ >> so? why are you looking at me like that? you don't feel encouraged?
smoke. i need terese, please? come in. >> i had a conversation with the lab, and they indicated to me that tom ruskin had sent them the samples, and they had giving him results but couldn't give me information, because all of that belonged to tom ruskin and we would have to go. >> did we call? >> to tom? >> yes. >> that's when we placed all those phone calls. >> any samples? letters? anything? >> no, we never heard from him
about any of that. >> the biggest problem i have in this case is what happened with the investigator. that's something i have to live with. >> so danny couldn't call the lab, even though -- >> that's crazy, but it seems to be the case. >> i can't pick many your call right now, so please at the tone leave a message. i'll call you back as quickly as i can. >> hi, tom. it's jane schuler. long time no talk. i really, really, need to talk to you, and really need you to call me back. thanks, bye. >> there's just so much pushing i can do. i have to take care of my son and working, there's just so
much i can do, you know? it's getting old fast. >> what's getting old? >> everything. >> he has different views, and it's black and white with him, very black and white. he has completely different views about things. you know, he's -- i don't get it. he's off all day. you're off all day, you don't -- you don't even see bryan, you take him to school -- i'm working 14 hours, and then get over there. i don't understand what you're doing to me. why are you getting crazy? you're off all day. i told him, you're going to go back and work during the day and find out what a real working parent feels like, everyone is like why don't you put your foot down about it. ♪
he didn't realize how he comes off sometimes, like he'll be like bryan is like, clean it up, come on, let's go, and bryan is looking at a picture of mommy and erin, yeah, yeah, you're right, i miss them too, blah blah blah. you don't sound like, that's right, bry, i know you miss them. he has to know, this is the way life is now. it's like, okay, but he can cry. you can cry. we can all cry. what is that going to do? well, we'll be sad. the only positive thing is we've got bryan? therapy. bryan had a very bad meltdown last month, extremely bad, about mommy. he doesn't want to hear it, danny, but i spoke to a pediatrician, and the pediatrician told him you have
to get him enrolled. we have an appointment tomorrow at 10:30. ♪ i told him, he has to work on forgiving diane, because he does not forgive her at all for what happened. the way he doesn't forgive her is he never wanted kids and this is where i'm left now, and she was supposed to do all this. i want, okay, it's all right to be pissed at her, that's okay, but you have to work through it. he's like, what's there to work through? this is my life. this is it. some of the people in the cars got involved and actively tried to help.
some were on the phones with 911. some were just screaming. the scene was very chaotic. is our business. we've reduced taxes and lowered costs to save businesses more than two billion dollars to grow jobs, cut middle class income taxes to the lowest rate in sixty years, and we're creating tax free zones for business startups. the new new york is working creating tens of thousands of new businesses, and we're just getting started. to grow or start your business visit thenewny.com are you still sleeping? just wanted to check and make sure that we were on schedule. the first technology of its kind... mom and dad, i have great news. is now providing answers families need.
siemens. answers. diarrhea, gas, bloating? yes! one phillips' colon health probiotic cap each day helps defend against these digestive issues with three strains of good bacteria. live the regular life. phillips'. aaah! aaaaah! theres a guy on the window! do something, dad! aaaah! aaaah! what is happening? they're rate suckers. their bad driving makes car insurance more expensive for the rest of us. good thing there's snapshot from progressive. snap it in and get a discount based on your good driving. stop paying for rate suckers. try snapshot free at progressive.com. we don't let frequent heartburn come between us and what we love. so if you're one of them people who gets heartburn and then treats day after day... block the acid with prilosec otc
♪ there will never be a concrete answer with absolute certainty which can be given to what happened, but there's several plausible hypotheses. is it possible that that day in question she was in so much pain she went to analgesics, gel caps? when there was none available, could she anest they advertised her pain, by taking one drink, where she could relax and she lost control and lost perspective on how many she was drinking? that kind of slippery slope does
occur. people who have a deep pain sensitivity, who cannot stand feeling helpless and feel they need to be perfect. she has had reasons in her life for all three. >> did she consume an initial small amount in her right mind, not impaired? did she think because the kids were there, did she think she had to get in a lot quickly and misjudged? and in fact shot he blood alcohol concentration up much higher than she thought it would? and then something happened that she then consumed in a way that was very dangerous and very unlike her? you know, there was something beyond intoxication. did she have a infection going on? did she have a fever? that combined with the marijuana and alcohol could certainly
precipitate a delirium. a brain event that triggered where she was beyond poor judgment, she was not in her right mind, that we don't know what she was thinking, hearing, feeling. >> hi. tom, i do appreciate you calling me back. >> i always call you back. >> yeah, no, i'm just -- you know what, tom? i'm just so upset, because i don't know what happened. >> with what? >> all i know is when i spoke to terese, she said we needed you to get an approval to say that you can release some things. >> let's put it this way, all right? as i promised danny, we retested the beginning of last year, and i devoted my time, because there was no additional monies, but i
sent the results to them. >> to dominick? >> i never even heard back. i called danny and you. >> i was told not to pick up, because they didn't feel -- they didn't believe you were doing anything. >> whenever that was, i was trying to give you the results of the test. >> i don't know what to do anymore. >> well, we retested the samples, and it came back the same. the toxicology and the autopsy was correct. >> but can't you see how confused i am now? >> we'll never know if diane purposely did this. we'll never know. >> tom, you know, i'm spinning around in circles. >> i can understand. >> i have one person saying one thing, another person saying another thing, and then i do believe diane wasn't drinking.
all i want to prove, if there was alcohol, what happened to her? >> all i can tell you is all tests were consistent as if diane had drank and been high that day. >> it's overwhelming. >> so you tell me -- listen, i've already been straight with you. if you believe me or not, i can't help that. >> that's the thing, i've always believed you. >> i will tell you one thing further, the dna was hers. >> so what am i supposed to do now, tom? >> you tell me. i mean, i'm returning your call. >> i don't know. >> police, 911. >> my god.
>> what mile marker are youal? >> what mike marker are we ought? >> pleasant road. >> hold on, stop yelling. >> 911. >> listen -- >> are you out at the scene right now? >> yes. >> are there any injuries? >> no, we have fatalities. >> fatality at the scene. stay on the phone with me, let me give you ems. hold on. >> okay. sent an ambulance. we have a possible car fire. >> so a car fire and fatality? >> yes, numerous fatalities? >> numerous fatalities? >> 4.1 northbound taconic. >> diane schuler drives against traffic for 1.7 miles in the fast lane, never veers, seems to have a serene, almost oblivious
look on her face. and kills eight people. the worst accident in recent memory. >> diane schuler hits the vehicle, which then crashing into vehicle number three. the schuler vehicle goes off the road, down the hill, rotating, and eventually begins to burn. >> a lady was screaming? spanish, there were kids in the car. i went down the hill with this other fella. we were trying to get the door off. the door wouldn't open. we were looking for the driver, we couldn't find her. the car was fully engulfed in the front. ♪
>> we're the first ones there, and we just kind of circled the car, checking the doors. he checked the other side, i checked the driver's side, it was locked. i went around, ended up breaking the passenger side window to unlock the door. >> we finally got the door open. the guy i was with, he opened the door and her body fell on top of our legs. >> when she fell out, she like rolled into the two of us that were standing there. literally i had to step over her to reach in for the kids. we were just concentrating on getting the kids out of the burning car. they were piled on top of each
other. one adult handed me the girl, i laid her on the grass, put my head on her chest, i talked to her, prayed, please, make her wake up. please make her wake up. she wouldn't wake up. >> at 1:30 p.m. i got a phone call from the traffic management center. traffic was completely stopped. i had to drive on the shoulder of the road to get there. >> man. >> when i got there to the scene, i saw a minivan, which was burnt in the median down a hill. i also saw two suvs northbound on the taconic state parkway.
these vehicles had extensive damage to them. >> some of the people in the cars got involved and actively tried to help. some were on the phones with 911, and some were just screaming. the scene was very chaotic. >> i proceeded to look for any other signs of life from the others, the victims, and i immediately noticed a little y boy. he was hurt, hurt pretty badly. he was combative, he was crying, which is a good sign. that's why i immediately put him in the first ambulance. >> i didn't even know he was there. but he was underneath everybody. thank god he was underneath.
then i went to the top of the hill. i lost it. i started crying. i tried to go help the other fellows that were in the car crash. and they were dead. i felt all their pulses. they were dead. one fellow was hanging out of the car. >> there were some people that did attempt to take pictures of the victims, which we wouldn't allow. we put sheets up to preserve their dignity. it was the only thing we could have done at that point. there was no one more to help.
♪ jackie sent this card. it says hi, evan, i business seeing you, bryan, your mom and whole family. warren and i are broken, but you need to go and have a happy life. by doing this, you will so bryan that he can do the same. my life ended july 26th, 2009, for whatever reason, my purpose for living was taken. when you have children one day, you will understand you live and breathe for your kids. warren is having a hard time.
all the women in his life have left him, and he won't let me out of his sight. i pray the my pain will end soon and i can see my girls. give bryan and hug and kiss, and know you are a great person with a lot to give. love, jackie. >> whatever happened in this tragedy, there was no evident that diane schuler was a bad person. what evidence we have is that she was a very good mom, and a very good person generally, maybe too good. maybe a bit of a perfectionist. i don't see any evidence that what she did was intentional. given the fact she was generally someone with very high standards for herself, was someone very
socially connected, a good protector factors, so even if she found out some horrible news, i don't see it likely she would kill herself, especially not in the manner this tragedy occurred. it's hard to imagine, isn't it, that simple coincidences can be a major tipping point, and can result in a major catastrophe. it's not something we are built as human beings to be able to live with. >> don't worry, diane. i promised you i would take care of bryan. ♪
IN COLLECTIONSCNN Television Archive Television Archive News Search Service
Uploaded by TV Archive on