Skip to main content

tv   Quadriga - Right-wing Rise in Austria Threat for Europe  Deutsche Welle  October 20, 2017 6:30am-7:01am CEST

6:30 am
go africa people and projects that are changing our government for the better to make a difference in what. magazine. d w. y billion people in east africa threatened by starvation what are the causes of the situation. we focus on five specific problem areas. journalistic project tries to find the answers why africa goes green our topic this week. on mine. hello and welcome to quadriga he's young he's charismatic and he refers to his base as a movement rather than a party no it's not
6:31 am
a manual macaw i'm referring to but the even younger and distinctly more conservative sebastian courts in just five months he reinvented a party that has been in government for thirty years renaming it simply asked in courts list and borrowing anti immigration rhetoric from austria's hard right wing populists their leader. was also a big winner in last sunday's elections together the two parties took nearly two thirds of the vote. the election result is being called a tectonic shift abroad as well as in austria so is austria's swing to the right a threat to europe that's the question i'll be discussing with my guests it's a pleasure to welcome hammond she is a journalist for germany's topps daily newspaper and she says the swing to the right in austria is not an exception but the norm all of europe is shifting to the right. and with us as well as ron kaufman he is detail the use eastern europe
6:32 am
expert and he says if the end of positions itself is a right wing populist force in europe paris will respond with a stronger for europe than the populace surrounding viktor orbán in central eastern europe in hungary would be left behind. and finally great to have matthew carney chick on the show once again he has austrian roots and is politico's chief european correspondent and he says austria's course is not a threat to europe but a threat to the vision of closer integration pushed by french president my call and the e.u. commission so before we come to the implications for europe as a whole i'd like to talk a bit more about the causes of last week's election result and matthew carney chick let me start with you as an austrian mainstream parties have been governing together in a grand coalition in austria for what seems to many voters to be a near eternity so is this election result really about the issues or is it in
6:33 am
essence a protest by a lot of voters who say we are tired of politics political business as usual i think that's definitely part of it there's been a lot of frustration with the grand coalition in austria which as you say has been in power for quite a long time for ten years running but really before that for decades most of the post-war period and what that has led to is a lot of client a list of policies in austria with the two dominant party used the people's party in the so. democrats dividing up a lot of the spoils between them and that starts in public housing for example but really goes through every part of public life that includes the public television stations a lot of these positions have traditionally been divvied up between the new two main parties and so then you have this populist party come in the freedom party and say we want to really and these corrupt practices we want to create a level playing field so that has definitely been
6:34 am
a very potent issue for them traditionally but the other issue which might have been more powerful this time is the question of foreigners of refugees how to deal with that and in particular how to deal with islam and this is something that really gets a lot of austrians blood boiling is the question of what they call islamization or this fear that the society is becoming islamicized so i want to come back to that issue in just a moment but frank osman when we're talking about other factors that may have influenced the result to what degree would you put this down also to personal issues sebastian courts as a figure he kind of represents a new model of european politician along the lines in some ways in some ways of emmanuel mccaw what's behind this sudden new new model i think people in austria were looking for an alternative and founded in a very young man who was working on the political sphere for the last years as
6:35 am
a foreign minister as well and that quite a job that was accepted to people than he moved on with this. populist rhetoric using also the refugee crisis in europe in about four two years ago two thousand and fifteen and i have the feeling that many austrians oncet the loss of control with her vote voting a lot also not for only for the conservative people's party but also for the writing populace of freedom party. well he could have been sebastian courts as both other guests have mentioned took his party distinctly to the right with rhetoric that in some cases echoed what we've heard from the right wing populist the freedom party but still it's puzzling why are austrians suddenly susceptible to this message this is a country that is prosperous that has near full employment and which in twenty
6:36 am
fifteen stood firmly at the side of uncle americal as one of europe's most open and welcoming countries during that wave of migration so what's happened well i think basically austria has always had a very strong populist and right wing movement since back to the eighty's so in a way it's just more of the same it's not a radical change as you might think but also i think that in all of europe not only in austria you have two issues that are really burning and that people care about and it's all about security one issue is internal or security you saw it but borders that suddenly open that should be closed that should be controlled and the other issue that is almost or even more important is social security it is true that austria has full full employment more or less but many peoples nonetheless have this feeling they might lose out you have full employment but the. wages are not really rising you have a country with high growth but hardly anything is somehow. reaching
6:37 am
the employed or employees so i think and that's something the. freedom party. talked about and tried to somehow gain votes with them if they for example propose that there should be a thousand two hundred euros for every retiree who had been very can for forty years and that shows that there is an issue about social security also in austria that is not really addressed of was not addressed by the social democrats so they left the door wide open for the other parties that you can achieve what do we know about the austrians who voted for that right wing party for the freedom party to what degree are they truly threatened by immigration in any real sense are they losing out perhaps on housing on jobs because of the way the migration. well most of them or not and never will but as he says there is this sort of fear
6:38 am
of what could come and i think that's really you know at the base of this not just in austria but in the other countries there's this sense that there's so many people coming in they're going to take our welfare away from us our future is uncertain our children's future is uncertain one interesting take away from the austrian election talking to voters afterwards they did some surveys and they found that i think two thirds of austrians were pessimistic about the future they thought that their children would have a tougher time than they did so this is really want to sort of the classic reasons that people would vote for a party like like the freedom party i think to intervene i think the social democrats didn't really come up with a turnit of stimulus for the actual compay in austria is not a country that is per se against immigration austria is an immigration country was was always since i have spoke times and the ok you came on k.
6:39 am
a lot of austrians i come from hungary are coming from the balkans this is. this it's in the genes it's genetic for for the society which means for me that's not so easy to say ok they're just against islam they're just against foreigners no the leading politicians in austria did not find an answer for the questions of the people doing that complain my thing let's take a closer look by comparing the two young politicians i mentioned at the outset of the program namely emmanuel mccall and sebastian cortes the austrian result came as a surprise to many europeans who thought that the french election had stocked the right word drift in europe in its tracks in fact the anna and paris are taking very very different approaches when it comes to migration so let's take a look. they're both young ambitious and smart.
6:40 am
austria's designated chancellor sebastiaan courts and french president and mana why mccall both have promised to bring a breath of fresh air and have started their own political movements amash and there's a bust him court's next. but their approaches to right wing populism are very different. to past and courts owes his rise to the refugee crisis with his hardline against migrants and his isolationist policies he's co-opted the biggest campaign issue of the right wing populist and that strategy allowed his party to emerge victorious from the elections. a man of color on the other hand won the presidential election in france with a decidedly pro europe agenda and a profile that clearly defined him in opposition to the right wing populist of the form not enough. inclusion or exclusion what's the best way to keep rightwing populists in check. i think of him and let
6:41 am
me put that inclusion versus exquisite and question to you because it is in fact one that's also being debated there are adamantly here in germany should politicians take the rise of the right as a reflection of legitimate concerns about the destabilizing effects of migration and adjust their policies accordingly or should they in essence draw a red lines well if you look at my call he seemingly. red lines but in reality he also is very much against taking the fiji's for example he said that france would take a twenty thousand refugees in two years that is nothing so he claims to be different from independent and he is but nonetheless when it comes to immigration he is catering to the voters of the pen and i think that's the same is true of the as. social democrats north korea they've also very much against refugees already trying to somehow. to adapt to the voters that they're on the right side and we
6:42 am
shouldn't be too optimistic about mccloy i think because if he does not succeed to bring economic growth to france and i think it will not succeed and in the next election it will have an opinion this is this is just you know the this is just the last chance for europe you shouldn't be too. too caffrey about the success in france so the possibility that francis own right wing party the four nasional might in fact come roaring back across reforms are not accepted by the population matthew country it's unclear still what form the next government in austria will take but we could well see this right wing party the freedom party entering a governing coalition led by sebastian courts and his conservative party the people's party if that occurs will mr kurtz really be able to contain the freedom party by essentially adjusting
6:43 am
a bit to the right or might it wind up co-opting him rather than the reverse i think he will succeed because of the amazing support that he had in this election that he has within his own party right now because he really did re furbished this party around his own person and change the name even to the sebastian kurtz list and so forth so i think that he has an advantage there he also has the other advantage that generally his ratings in the population are extremely high much higher than his counterpart at the freedom party because you're talking so i think that he has that advantage on the other hand the freedom party he's been in the government with courts his party before from two thousand and till two thousand and seven in various iterations and during that time the. people's party really managed to put the freedom party in a box and it kind of led to that party's destruction and so mr struck it is very
6:44 am
concerned that this kind of thing could happen again so he's already said he's not going to basically always follow the lead of the people's party he's not going to dance to their tune he's going to stand up for his issues and we'll see so it could come to some very strong situations what are his issues mr himself claims to have changed his stripes and is now saying for example that his youthful contacts to neo nazis were simply. the madness of youth. do you think can we buy that has he really somehow moderated or is he in sheep like clothing yeah i think probably i would say the latter definitely and if you look at the rhetoric during the campaign his use of anti-semitic innuendo for example in campaign events in in debates there's no question that this party is part of the far right when you know
6:45 am
maybe even the ultra of far right a lot of the leaders of the party were members of these nationalist fraternities in austria that have a much more a kind of german nationalist tendency so i don't think there's any question about where this party stands but they have tried to broaden their appeal with things that you might normally associated associate with the social democratic party by suggesting you know more welfare payments for the elderly more help for workers more education support and that really is the core of their program and these are things that are not that controversial and at the same time bring a lot of people in michael flynn if we think back to the year two thousand just mentioned by matthew carney chick that was also a moment when the free party the right wing party entered into a coalition with the conservatives and in fact there was a cry about. oh across europe fourteen e.u. states impose sanctions on austria now there is barely
6:46 am
a peep and in fact we hear of the the social democrats in austria have not ruled out themselves entering a coalition with the freedom party what's going on i have feeling that the freedom party moved more to the center they tried to. get rid of people and positions extremists and far right of course there was a few arguments and t.v. discussions also were anti-semitism was lying under the surface but i think they're eager to to leave it there and not bring it up like before that's one point the other thing if i may i would like to come back to you how men who just this is our last chance in europe i disagree i think this is the biggest chance for what europe has now to to change the system to change the bloc towards more integration towards more europe with these societies and these countries that want to move forward ok
6:47 am
let's come back to that in just a moment i saw him shaking her head rather vigorously and i went it's not true that the freedom party moved to the center it's very right thing party and that hasn't changed i think the change came in europe because the sanctions against this first clinician between the people's party and the freedom party from two thousand to thirty two thousand and six when the sanctions were decided by the european commission proved to be. a disaster because nothing changed in austria instead everyone was the. law in favor of the freedom party than before because the austrians had if you ling that their country was attacked by europe so this time people just don't discuss about sanctions anymore because it was obvious that the freedom party was strengthened by this aggressive act and not subdued so this time people just hope that i. or things will be fine in austria in four years because one result could be that this coalition again. doesn't bring any
6:48 am
results for the voters it's just a lot of talk about enemies all about fifty g.'s but nothing happens so that the social democrats because it could become very strong as an opposition party and then rule in the next four to four years i think that's the hope in europe given the fact that concern about the future in general and about migration in particular are by no means isolated to austria let us now look at what the austrian election result could in fact mean for the rest of europe. sebastiaan courts and the austrian freedom party would like to limit the number of refugees admitted to zero that's a de facto revocation of the country's asylum. both pushing for permanent border checks around austria that's a clear break with europe's open borders policy. courts a sympathetic to members of the vicious right groups such as poland and hungary and their anti migration policies that could make
6:49 am
a fair distribution of refugees within the european union more difficult. austria could also blocky use sanctions against members of the vicious gradgrind. courts and the austrian freedom party see the autocratic flooding near putin mostly as a trade partner so they want to ease sanctions against russia found they want to allow more popular referendums possibly even on the euro and the e.u. itself does the election in austria represent a setback for europe. so let me get matthew carney and frank on the duel it out a bit now because your opening statements indicated rather contradictory views on what this means for the e.u. going forward so frank kaufman saw some potential for strengthening of core europe and you said you thought the austrian results could well halt the process of integration and halt mr macro push so perhaps matthew go first with that more
6:50 am
pessimistic view and then we'll but you know i mean but this is really the core question that's pessimistic depending on where you stand on the issue i think a lot of people even in germany would say we like the e.u. as it is we're not anti you we like the free market we like the euro we want to keep things as we are what we don't want is to shift more sovereignty to brussels now this would be the position also of the people's party in austria of sebastian course his party as well as the far right freedom party it's also the position of most of the central and eastern european. countries if not all of them who are really enjoying the freedom that they won after the berlin wall fell down in one nine hundred eighty nine and they are not as eager to shift their societies into this larger sort of european amalgamation and don't want a more federal europe they like what they're getting now and i think that the austrian election could strengthen that bloc because austria is
6:51 am
a net payer for example into the e.u. budget it is a western european country and i think with sebastian cordes who is becoming a very prominent figure in european politics as well because of his recent success and his youth and all the rest of it i think they could have somebody who is taking this message to brussels so you could see this bloc if you will acting as a kind of break to the kind of crawl visions that we've seen propagated recently but i also think it just one last point i don't even think that what mccraw wants i don't think that germany will be able to go along with that in the end i don't think that angle america will be able to go along with that in the end because i think it's very controversial within her own conservative bloc especially in bavaria where the sister party to merkel's party where many people also want to have this europe of the regions as they call it they don't want to shift everything to brussels from kauffman please address the arguments you've just heard but also
6:52 am
couldn't argue that austria if it positions itself closer to those central eastern european countries might even play a mediating role that would allow for a reintegration of these different blocs possible but then a lot of these central is new have been countries will have to change their policy towards europe and to join again the that the way and the policies of of good arguments and and the sheer in the says. necessitate in the bloc i have the feeling that it's a reaction to those elections in austria will be that the that we will have more europe in a couple of years time i think a bloc a core european group will integrate further as a reaction also to what happened in central eastern europe austria's most important neighbor hungary for example is suffering because it is politicians his elites mr robin the prime minister is
6:53 am
a prop it's arguing with less europe rather than with more europe we shift back to the financial crisis that time hungary was a candidate for the euro a lot of people invested and got credits in euro currency and after that they had a lot of problems to pay pay back their mortgages and that's one reason why he won a lot of he won a lot of votes and he won the latest elections means less europe is suffering brings people to suffer rather than more europe and i think this is one reason why a group of core european countries will create a kind of a stream where others either will follow oh really half of a situation where for a longer period of time we have to from space in the block so rekha haven't you got to be a tie breaker here that idea of a europe at different speeds has been debated very intensively for a couple of years now but can there really be different speeds on immigration the european court of justice for example has just rejected
6:54 am
a challenge from hungary and slovakia to e.u. refugee distribution quotas if austria also tries to balk at taking more refugees mightn't it wind up also getting a reprimand from the e.u. but i think that and i agree with les here here i think the if you key issue is decided in the sense that no country in whole of europe wants to take any more if you g.'s that is also true of germany and i think that. any european country. which doesn't want to. more integration towards europe that's even true of germany and that's also true let's say of the netherlands or belgium so what about mr mccall's proposal and did he want to yeah unfortunately i'd say he doesn't stand a chance what will happen is of course that you know the one thing is the programatic idea of europe that doesn't have a chance at the moment on the at the other hand you know that is the sheer necessity of working together for example if there was a recession in economic crisis of course suddenly everyone would start investing on
6:55 am
a european scale so the program that unlock all suggests would become reality but not because you think or believe in it and great europe but just because it's not necessary so not vision driven but pragmatic let me just ask all of you because we are getting close to the end of our time to come back to the title question that we posed at the beginning do you see the austrian election result and the possible formation of a coalition there as a threat to europe not because i think it's a threat to them i call vision not necessarily a threat to europe or say but a threat to this idea that europe needs to be much more closely integrated than it is i think it will empower my core mission in europe and we will move on to about sort of more integrated. danger because many conservative parties will copy this idea that puts it as you just
6:56 am
a couple of the program on the right i'm done in elections thank you very much to all of you for being with us and thanks to all of you for tuning in the same. the fact.
6:57 am
that. he. placed. the. traumas of the
6:58 am
holocaust. challenge the. portrait. piece of history. with what does a football loving country to which it's going. back to the top. made in germany. hijacking the news. where i go wrong the news is being hijacked journalism it still has become a scripted reality show it's not just good vs evil us versus them black and white. in countries like russia china turkey people are told it's that's not and if you're
6:59 am
a journalist there and you try to get beyond that you are facing scare tactics intimidation. and i wonder is that where we're headed as well. my responsibility as a journalist is to get beyond the smoke and mirrors it's not just about being fair and balanced or being neutral it's about being truly. funny was born gough and i were good enough. some people don't care about me. because they don't see my beauty. some people don't care about me because they think i have nothing to give. a two billion you can do. to then i am everything. their home. the a food. their life you. but day by day i disappear.
7:00 am
and so does everything i keep. two billion people care about me. me me. and now. i need. the los angeles police department has opened an investigation against harvey weinstein after a number of women accuse the film producer of sexual assault according to a police spokesperson one woman reported weinstein was involved in her alleged rape
7:01 am
in two thousand and thirteen.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on