Skip to main content

tv   Close up - Cigarette Butts - Poisoning the Environment  Deutsche Welle  October 3, 2018 11:15am-11:45am CEST

11:15 am
defending champions rail madrid were beaten in moscow manchester united were left with a scoreless draw hosting. and roma blasted czech side. you're watching d.w. news coming to you live from berlin we have more for you at the top of the hour sumi will be with you then and don't forget you can always get all the latest news and information around the clock on our web site that's at the w dot com thanks for watching. in. the colbys in germany to learn german. courage to the. point not learn with him online on the mobile and free to suffer from the w.'s in learning course because fake.
11:16 am
cigarettes cause sickness and death they don't just calm people they also laid waste to the environment many of the toxic dangers lurk in cigarette butts. it's old enough to make given the amount of nicotine they contain cigarettes are hazardous waste many people don't see the problem or even regard the bugs as trench . growing so back a ways we source intensive and requires large amounts of pesticides huge areas of rain forest like here in africa for example have been cleared to make way for plantations. just as they go nine it is a regional catastrophe and it doesn't just change the local climate but makes rain less frequent and beneficial insects don't come. intensive tobacco farming
11:17 am
and discarded cigarette butts cigarettes are an environmental problem. amy cream is on the hunt for both cigarettes stops for research purposes the american scientist works at both ends technical university she's looking for places where lots of cigarettes are discarded like the entrance to this railway station. she wants to find out how long it takes for the toxic substances to leach out of the stops. no other trash is so casually thrown away on the street a cigarette butts. on average she finds about three per square meter of course it's
11:18 am
a lot more in some places. this is the island's less at the entrance to the suburban railway i think you find a lot of stubs because people are rushing to get their train. and they don't have time to finish their cigarettes to get out there's still quite a lot of tobacco in the bus. in that hour the more tobacco there is the more nicotine too of course. the butts may be small but they still contain nicotine. even if city authorities clean this area regularly it would be impossible to remove them all. as the number of bots accumulates served as the poison they contain. the ones it isn't as you can see there are lots of bicycles locked up here and you can't get in here with a broom i can only really pick them up by hand and no one goes to the trouble kind
11:19 am
of life they stay here and the next out rains the nicotine will be washed out and then enter the sewage system through the storm drains loosed on get done in the office and up with the spices getting equal this time it takes are just a few minutes to collect an entire bag of butts will have a study. in the office and in front of this station alone there are probably thousands of butts and the numbers grow every day that we can be sure that a high concentration of nicotine is being released here every time it rains i guess . worldwide approximately five point six trillion cigarettes are concealed ideally four and a half trillion of them end up being discarded outdoors on the pavement or down storm drains. in the northern german city of hamburg the authorities are busy or hear around trying to keep the one hundred thirty storm drains free of stubs.
11:20 am
the trash that's extracted is later burned in an incinerator. but if those stubs and the toxins within them actually reach the cyrix system they become a problem. but are bad first of all they're trash and belong in the trash can it gift nicotine is a toxic no pollutes the rain water runoff and then can get into the sewage system as. waste water needs to be cleaned but the microorganisms in the sewage treatment plant aren't there to really minute nicotine in the food. they're also not able to completely eliminated. it's almost impossible to completely remove nicotine from waste water plant. here at the hamburg sewage works the microbes intended to tackle nicotine and not
11:21 am
one hundred percent effective. and the size of cigarette filters is a further problem most slip through the screening units that have to be removed using fina filters before being incinerated otherwise the stubs would end up in the elk river and of course butts tossed straight into rivers and lakes affect the water directly. cigarette stubs contain more than four thousand toxins some in the tobacco itself some in the filter other toxins are created during the burning process they include arsenic and dangerous heavy metals like lead and copper but it's nicotine that has the most immediate effect on flora and fauna. nicotine is a nicotine is a very potent one or zero toxin it was used in farming because it's very good at killing little creatures and it's plenty institute. with the aid of a special machine the research a wants to find out how much nicotine the bots
11:22 am
release into the environment. she's particularly interested in what happens to the toxin when it comes into contact with water when it rains for example. the toxins from the stubs that amy green has collected have already been washed out so she's producing her own butts three point seven centimeters long the average length of a discarded cigarette. according to e.u. regulations tobacco waste products containing more than half a mill a gram of nicotine should be categorized as dangerous. but scientists then exposes the bots that she's created an artificial rain showers the water runs over them leeching out the nicotine inside she analyzes this water findings on average
11:23 am
a cigarette but releases two milligrams of nicotine into the environment in some cases as much as six that's four to twelve times over the danger limit. must think if we have discovered that the nicotine dissolves very quickly it's water soluble some sixty percent of the nicotine leeches out just after two rain showers. it takes just half an hour for the majority of the nicotine to leach out and pollute the water. the consequences of this process of being studied in san diego smoking bans in california a much stricter than in germany and they also apply on the beach you can expect a fine for smoking here. thomas novotny is a public health expert and c.e.o. of the cigarette butt pollution project he's made it his mission to curb the damage
11:24 am
done by cigarette butts. the results of his research are alarming. he's revealed that nicotine in water harms the creatures living in it. he's experimenting with. on rainbow trout at the moment that swimming in clean water. professor novotny would release them into a wheelchair polluted with nicotine those ten bucks for every four liters of water . well they're preparing the leach eight which means these cigarette butts are sort of like a tea bag they. will will some of the chemicals that we think are toxic to living creatures and would be a way of getting some exposure in an aquatic environment for fish and other animals that might be affected by sugar but waste. the water is mixed with
11:25 am
a nicotine leech eight and allowed to stand overnight. the research is then poor this mixture into an aquarium. they introduce the young rainbow trout from the clean water aquarium into the nicotine. after just a few seconds the fish reacts at fust it's just a few but then more and more are affected by the nicotine. they look paralyzed. some. of those tunnel myside twitch. the creatures go into toxic shock.
11:26 am
we found that one cigarette butt or water kills half the fish that are exposed to that water in about four days and we call the lethal dose fifty in this experiment and you can see that there are now some cute facts of the fish that have just been placed into this. the chariots of ten votes for leader and the fish are experiencing some sort of neurological toxicity i mean it's not surprising aside from. heavy metals and on all and some other chemicals that nicotine is probably the key element that's produced in the syrup. solution that we've created here and clearly these fish are suffering from that exposure. after just a few minutes some of the fish recover from the shark but if they stayed in the water for longer the toxins would kill them. professor
11:27 am
novotny and his team prepare a chemical analysis of the bodies of the contaminated fish that did not survive the earlier experiments. the research is fine toxic substances from the cigarette butts stored in the fish's bodies. novotny and his colleagues fear the impact on humans. there is no on tobacco call oh it's and there are naturally present in the tobacco and tobacco smoke and then they are in the lead of the cigarette butts but in the more important some of these are highly accumulated in the fish so that means that if we eat the fish and the we are exposed to those chemicals. the neurotoxin nicotine moves through the food chain back to humankind. professor novotny believes that
11:28 am
cigarette filters play a big row. i think what we have to think about is not picking up cigarette butts not just going on collecting them because that's not going to do very much good we're my collect a million over a minute still wouldn't touch the burden there we'd need to look at ways of bringing latest product from an environmental standpoint and the number one objective but i have to ban the sale of pill to cigarettes. without filters smokers will be exposed to even more talk seems so it's a radical proposal. but it's one that at least spares other creatures and the environment. this is i would focus really cold like that we really have to invest you know scientifically we think we. just call it a cigarette butts in the environment and then we think that they're just gone you
11:29 am
know and they're not going to be harmful to the way but i know it's coming back to us. smoking isn't banned on this beach on germany's baltic states and even though it's officially frowned upon people still smoke cigarettes the most common form of refuse found on the. beach. coastal environmentalists environmental discovered that in a number of litter collecting initiatives. they've responded by installing several receptacles for the cigarette ends. to me like how long should have been twenty meters and fifteen meters in the meter but the environmentalist want to do more than that they want to change the behavior of the smokers. in just a few minutes they find fifty bucks in a small radius around one of the ashtrays they are.
11:30 am
it's not just the toxins in the cigarette ends that are the problem it's the material itself that the filter is made from. as it is in empty air base we can see some here where the cigarette filter is still covered with paper and the ones that are older than the borders are the papers no longer there it has already detached and probably brought it from that but it's the filter that's the problem is the sony most acetate isn't biodegradable we know from freshwater studies that a filter like this needs roughly ten to fifteen years to decompose in some water if we put this into the sea many can take up to four hundred years for something like this to decompose for that's. that's how long filters can inflict damage in the sea . the german cigarette association the tobacco industry lobby here has
11:31 am
a different view. than normal if you hadn't felt all the normal cigarette filters made from cellulose acetate are biodegradable i guess and never acquires a certain amount of time and that varies to. the way they decompose in the soil depends a bit. and the degree of exposure to like it depends how it decomposes in water that's a longer process and we're working together with the manufacturers in the chemicals industry to reduce these time spans that tighten this is for quite some. of the german company that has already produced a filter to made from paper that decomposes in just a few weeks. the firm has long manufactured filters for roll your own cigarettes finot than the conventional ones but identical apart from that. smokeless is passed through normal filters made from cellulose acetate feels less harsh according to
11:32 am
managing director christiane hands. but the disadvantage is that the fibers are dense get come down and as a result are less biodegradable than paper filter tips. here's the middle classes are made for here we see the classic method for producing our suited filters not just in our company but throughout the industry. and when you pull it it stretches like elastic. father they're going to fall do not itself like in war but. not much of them once not so on but now this material is from the paper filter mission. well of course that also passes through the machinery that far but you can already see the differences as far as biodegrade ability is concerned will work under. this machine produces filter tapes made from unbleached paper that event folded together it was a magically at the moment it's the only one of its kind in germany the unbleached
11:33 am
paper isn't very popular with some customers the draw isn't a smooth on the smokers hotshot some cigarette manufacturers started using the paper filters but then gave up again. but he's at once to stick with the new text despite the extra work involved. because of the ports this is the whole process it's more expensive i'm slower and the output is considerably smaller but theoretically at least every one of the industry can do it if they tried who understand what. the filters may decompose more quickly in the environment but the problem with the toxins inside remains. when bazza just flicked away no one feels responsible for them despite later collection efforts from local pressure groups and green organizations like here in the eastern german city of clive slide. they say that people aren't aware of
11:34 am
the scale of the problem. every year cigarettes generate an incredible volume of waste. much less move also how many cigarette butts out there wild wide then flights worldwide about four and a half trillion and if we place the boats into any time they would encircled the earth two times over that's how many buses there are and it's not just raising awareness with smokers i guy here it should really be classified as hazardous waste . so on your phone i phone is meeting with the mayor of ice but. even politicians and public officials aren't always aware of the danger that cigarette butts posed to the environment. as if he has to be to get it is for first important lesson for me was to learn just how toxic my stubs are and what a burglary or the environment might have to admit i didn't know that i hadn't
11:35 am
thought about it and something has to be done to ensure cigarette butts end up where they belong with. one discarded cigarette might seem harmless but they add up. annually discarded bots worldwide generate a mountain of trash estimated to weigh seven hundred and fifty thousand tons. and cigarettes also cause other types of environmental degradation. sagna borne collects information about tobacco plantations worldwide in a merging or developing economies such as in africa entire florists a cleared to make way for tobacco good. is also used in the drying process in tanzania and malawi five hundred to six hundred square kilometers of woodland are cleared annually for this purpose alone globally that amounts to two thousand square kilometers an area roughly the size of rio de janeiro or cairo egypt. and
11:36 am
deforestation is not the only problem to back across also remove nutrients from the soil then. went to back it was planted after two or three years the ground is so lived out that nothing will grow there for a long time afterwards. from there like me and if the soil is dry and promptly in areas like southern africa then it and roads and leaves the desert like conditions that have all. tobacco is a sensitive crop and requires a lot of care for most farmers artificial fertilizers and other chemicals are essential. that are wrong about tobacco cultivation requires a very intensive use of pesticides because it's a monoculture and in every type of monoculture there are certain types of pasts
11:37 am
that can wipe out all the crops that's why a lot of it has to sides are used many different ones including some that are banned here again and as is always the case with trash decides they don't leech into the soil and remain there or are washed into the ground water. five point six the german cigarette association says tobacco is not a major cause of deforestation. they cite studies that claim the toxicity of nicotine depends on its concentration and often pocket sized ashtrays to deal with cigarette butts that we have to make oversight of course people have become more environmentally aware and consumers pay a lot more attention to the way products are made they have. every right to you know and it's right that the industry should be put under more pressure to create these products more carefully and check entire supply chains more closely guns and . it's in our own interests to take a long term and sustainable approach so that these products are deemed acceptable
11:38 am
and that consumers are kept informed that's up for power and for me. so there is concern for the environment but only when it's customer driven. tobacco can be grown organically as it is here in southwestern germany like his grandfather and father before him marcos fisher is a farmer as well as growing tobacco conventionally he also cultivates it organically without the use of chemical fertilizers pesticides or insecticides that's a lot more work for the tobacco farmer but it's better for the environment as yet it comes at a price. a key level gannett tobacco is about to hear as more expensive than conventional tobacco.
11:39 am
in organic agriculture it's not like i can just take a sack of fertilizer and. it really is biological reuse dried co-parents dissolved in water locally. even tadpoles are happy here that wouldn't be the case in conventional tobacco. we treated an agent to kill the wire worms that would probably kill the cat calls if you would manage to survive but you wouldn't see such a swarm of a monkey wrench in all the farm land as you do among the organic one. we need a grass grow on the organic tobacco field and can't be treated with artificial pesticides a lot of environmentally aware smokers happily pay the price of organic tobacco but it has a difficult future in germany. in europe it's no longer allowed to describe itself
11:40 am
as natural or pure after the consumer advice agency brought a court action they say the advertising is potentially misleading as nic cigarettes also damage your health. yeah the problem is that consumers tend to understand these terms as having very positive connotations and could think the cigarettes were less harmful to their health and unfortunately that's not the case defied. the industry is now likely to turn its back on the organic farmers because they can no longer expect to attract added sales through advertising marcus fisher now plans to plant maize or wheat on his organic field no manufacturer is prepared to buy organic tobacco to make normal cigarettes it's too expensive. he blames the consumer protection advocates. what the day of the and there was you can see american spirit made lots of swag t.
11:41 am
shirts rain coats and such and then two years ago i got a call. they told us korea they destroyed all the t. shirts because they were no longer allowed to bear the words natural american spirit. only american spirit i think that sat on its inorganically produced product like letters cauliflower broccoli it's organically grown tobacco. why shouldn't it be called natural. med's pretty perplexing for of tobacco grower like me. and if the. cannick tobacco is better for the environment in terms of conservation but that is still the problem with the toxins in the filter. for decades smoke this is being used to focus the flicking away that cigarette butts modifying that behavior will be difficult and it's not just the environmentalists for a lot of men who think so. smokers like to get rid of their stubs as quickly and
11:42 am
easily as possible research has proved that. it's common in the us we found out that they estimated they would walk at least twenty meters but we could see from the data that they only walked ten meters is again. and an ashtray every ten meters is pretty unrealistic. even if it were possible thomas novotny in san diego believes that many smokers are resistant to change. while this is a you know effective way that it publicizes the issue i think by having it here very visible and tells people why they're doing this it's not just an ashtray this place out here in front of the smoke shop but as you can see that even though there's this facility and there's after syllabi right here. abut. processing the vote maple leaves that the buck should stop with the tobacco
11:43 am
industry he thinks manufacturers must pay more attention to environmental factors both in terms of tobacco cultivation and the toxic waste created by filters he hopes that stricter laws will force them to do so. what we need to do is try to change the product so that the behavior doesn't matter nearly as. well the important thing is that banfield for the cigarettes i mean i think that's a simple food. off. any money to do for the tobacco industry that people won't be smoking these products that are harder to smoke but i think what we're end up with is a farce a first. drug to do this but we should also i think people are going to be thinking twice about their smoking reduce the quantity that they're smoking anywhere and that will help. his vision is quite simple without filters there would be fewer smokers and he were problems for the environment.
11:44 am
the fast pace of life into digital shift as the lowdown on the web showing new developments and providing useful information to the wittiest finds and interviews with the makers and users of shift next on d. w. . her first day of school. in the jungle. first coming listen to the.
11:45 am
band doris grand moment arrives. join the ringgit tang on her journey back to freedom. in our interactive documentary. tour on trying to tame returns home on t.w. dot com tang's. shift hashtags. today a special edition focusing on digital berlin. with hyper lapsed views of the city gaming grannies on the internet and the paramount alter in three d. .


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on