Skip to main content

tv   To the point  Deutsche Welle  December 13, 2019 11:30pm-12:01am CET

11:30 pm
and you know what it's time all voices are blocked part. of the 77 percent be told the ball be easy to stop talking this is where. the 77 percent this weekend on d w. as un climate negotiations entered their decisive week in madrid young activists throng the city's streets demanding that world leaders get serious at their head time magazine's person of the year gratitude bag to school strides are the worldwide movement fridays for future focusing attention on the climate crisis as never before and helping spur initiatives like the new e.u. commission's trillion euro green deal many see the madrid negotiations as the last chance to set the world on track to avoid a worst case scenario with evidence of the crisis effects mounting many people are
11:31 pm
wondering whether the current climate anxiety comes too little too late and that is our topic. cut not gonna welcome to to the point we've got 3 top guests to explore where things stand stephan i'm stuart is a professor of ocean physics who heads earth systems analysis at the renowned potsdam institute for climate impact research he says the science is clear we're facing catastrophic risks and we need to act fast to avoid them it's time for decisive action not for anxiety. alan posner is an influential blogger and commentator for the german newspaper and he says we need courage not anxiety in order to save the climate democracy. capitalism and the dream of
11:32 pm
a good life for everyone abandoning one of these games when danger all of them. and it's a pleasure to welcome clara meyer she is spokesperson for friday's for future berlin and she says while a certain theater shows real concern it's important that this concern is now channeled into action especially from wired corporations and politicians who hold a great responsibility to pass legislation controlling this climate this crisis. so korea let me start out by asking you what does this term this phenomenon climate anxiety mean to you while i feel like. it shows that people are realizing what catastrophe what my catastrophe are actually n. i feel like a lot of people are now realizing what is happening in europe seeing what is
11:33 pm
happening in the global south and are simply afraid of what will come and what is already happening climate anxiety steffen is becoming now a recognized term for distress associated with global warming including on the part of people who are not yet directly affected or appear not to be directly affected by catastrophic risks like the one you mentioned in your opening statement do you think this climate anxiety is a positive force that will actually stimulate the kind of change that you called for. well i think 1st of all it's just a natural human reaction if you are faced with major threats for your future and the future of your children that cause a certain amount of anxiety the key thing is to not kind of leave that to you to suppress the problem and turn away from it but rather to confront it and
11:34 pm
avoid these risks alan your opening statement seemed to suggest that you think climate anxiety could wind up being counterproductive. yes yes i do i i mean. we have to fight climate change the 1st person to say that the 1st leader of a government to say that was maggie thatcher in 19891 day before the fall of the button wall in front of the united nations so this is been on the agenda for a long time all i'm saying is my caveat is that you can't you mustn't allow climate exile to dominate everything else i mean you must get into position where you say i'm so afraid of this change that we'll have to come down to democracy individual rights all i'm so afraid of of time of change and catastrophic dangers which the scientists predict that it's too bad you guys in africa and asia and latin america we can't. we simply can't afford you to come up to our level
11:35 pm
stuff like that i mean i do think that we need to take a balanced view climate change is a real problem just like i know fighting communism was a problem just like fighting the 2nd world war against the nazis was a problem and it has to be tackled but without giving up core values of our system that's what you know what he suggests i think anxiety is a tool that we can use i think anxiety is the 1st point that people reach for that is i'd have to spur action and that is the point where we're at right now so we actually have to turn our news id into concrete action this is the only way that we can solve this issue clara you're a movement friday's for future has tried to leverage climate anxiety and also anger as we have clearly seen from gretta turn back express that anger powerfully time and again it's also provoked quite a backlash fridays for future has come in for some very harsh attacks so 1st
11:36 pm
question how do you personally deal with that and secondly do you ever worry that friday's for future to some degree is polarizing the debate. in a way that could actually wind up turning some people off i think we're unifying the debate i think we we are the people that try to be the glue of society try to push the people further because yes we demand legislation from politics we demand change from the large corporations who are responsible for 70 percent of the world's carbon emissions but that change has to be supported by the people so that is what we're trying to do and. personal deal with heat well since mostly i get our rape threats and death threats i don't take them seriously because i am very willing and everyone i feel like in france future is willing to engage in a constructive debate but if people are just threatening you frankly that is not
11:37 pm
a debates and it shows that certain people. who are not willing to benefit our society as a whole are just that they criticize us with with well even sometimes criminal means i mean there's even a group in germany that. the very large facebook group that threatens to drive cars into our demonstrations and that is not a healthy debate at all. thank you for being so honest stefan my own climate distress increased rather significantly after i saw the damage done to a coastal area in the us that i have known since childhood and i asked myself when we see this heightened level now of. anxiety and awareness to what degree is it attributable to movements like fridays for future and to what degree is it attributable to the fact that people are now starting to see physical changes in
11:38 pm
their own lives but i think it is both and of course people are already affected millions of people are affected by the increase in extreme weather events extreme heat waves extreme drought flash floods the fire has and so it takes home close to home for more and more people just in the last 20 years half a 1000000 people have died from the direct effects of extreme weather events and these extreme weather events on the rise and for a long time the media have often not linked to extreme weather events to climate change because you can't tell for an individual extreme weather event what is due to climate change or not but you can clearly see the increase in extreme weather events due to global heating and the physical reasons behind that are also largely understood let's be honest here in europe most people have at most a limited experience of the crisis impact not so in many parts of the global south
11:39 pm
where sea level rise glacier melt and or drought are destroying people's homes and livelihoods our report takes us to the andes. the glaciers of. shrinking just one consequence of global heating that means less glacial water to last through extended periods of drought delivers and the soil are drying out for millennia people have lived on this. but now their survival is in doubt one plant species has always grown in the ground a protein rich grain but in recent years extreme weather has destroyed the harvest and heavy rains have inundated large parts of the territory. it's getting worse the extremes of more frequent it will because of the floods with built in levy around the village. you don't see without the water would destroy all the houses.
11:40 pm
if. for some years no young had been moving away now as climate change undercuts their subsistence many of their elders are thinking about following their fleeing the weather extremes but where to. where to indeed. would you say that europe and also perhaps north america are prepared for a major influx of climate change driven migration. we were obviously not prepared because we. almost collapsed in europe politically when we had to do with them syrian migration which was driven by civil war and brutality of a. you know of the regime in syria and so no we we're not prepared to be controversial hadn't we should do everything we can to prevent this
11:41 pm
migration for the simple reason that these people are needed especially the young people to to change things where they are i had a statistic that 31 percent of africans were preferred to move away from their continent and that these young ambitious like unlike in the like in your clip people who want a better life and we have to you know to simply say ok well. we response for the climate change in a great deal to have to take these refugees would say king the young the ambitious the people who want to change things away from where they needed to change things then i'm not you know. saying that we shouldn't take an refugees who come from for instance like syria but i am saying that we need to do much more. to enable them to combat climate change and adapt to climate change where they are and that includes by the way getting rid of or helping them get rid of the corrupt
11:42 pm
governments which don't do anything for them neither in the in the field of of vaccination against diseases nor in the field of of helping them deal with the drought nor the fear of democrat as asian you know who simply take away the wolf them. as it's a complex problem you're not going to help the africans deal with climate change unless you help them get democracies that there will can be imposed on their corrupt leaders let me just ask you one thing about democracy because your opening statement said that we need to preserve democracy and the promise of a good life at the same time that we're fighting. the climate the climate crisis so migration is inevitable indeed we need to work on causes but it's inevitable doesn't that possibly represent a threat to the very democracies here in europe and north america that you want to preserve we've seen what kind of strains migration is already imposing well to be
11:43 pm
quite frank it's not migration that. that destroys or endangers democracy it's right wing politicians who use migration as as a club to get back to democracy for their own areas and that happen but that will happen that's one reason why we have to control migration whether we like it or not because you know to be opening the borders isn't going to work politically but i think the more important reason is if you don't help people there i mean look at syria they're not going to do anything about time isn't that too busy dodging bombs and and when the bombs on philip on forming them or rebuilding their lives so we need a comprehensive support for democracy for development and for protection the climate for these countries rather than saying ok you guys. you know your country's ruined come here that's not going to work i think the debate is going in the wrong direction yes we are the main contributors to climate she is the global north just
11:44 pm
have to accept this position that they have in the world and change that because they cannot be that we the people of the global north produce the most you too and that people in the global south are suffering from it additionally suffering. as they have suffered through colonialism and exploitation from us for the last centuries so yes this is just another problem we're laying upon them but it is one that we can control that we have the financial ability to control so we have to tackle this issue now and fast and in fact this era as you know part of the. process has also been a fund to help people in the global south both adapt to climate change and mitigate the damages that they're facing is that fund in your opinion adequately financed and supported by the rich countries no because we're the main contributors of climate change and if we actually truly when except our position and change the
11:45 pm
thing about that we have to direct all of our capacities to solving the climate crisis because the climate crisis is a social crisis and as soon as we see that we can see that all issues that we have right now are directly linked to this crisis and that this is what we have to solve right now and on a global level and germany and europe as certain like financial and political leaders of this world have responsibility tackled this crisis crisis and to lead the fight now stephan if i can be you're welcome to respond to that but also if i can just take us back to the report one more time because your research is all about catastrophic effects and i wish you would just please tell us what you are seeing in terms of the magnitude of climate caused impact right now and what you think we will be looking at in the next 10 years so
11:46 pm
number of people likely to be displaced and other perhaps basic facts in a nutshell. well the number of people that are likely to be this place is very difficult to estimate obviously but since you mentioned syria i should mention that the mess protests and hundreds there broke out after the worst drought in the syrian history which according to sediment data from the eastern mediterranean was the worst in at least 900 years there which led to harvest failure as. cattle dying and one and a half 1000000 interior refugees in syria which also contributed to the strace and dissatisfaction with the government which didn't help the victims of the drought but where this will strike next and what extend is very difficult to say but drought is certainly one of the risks that i worry about most including a major food crisis a colleagues of mine have just published
11:47 pm
a study that shows that there is an increasing risk of synchronous drought in the main breadbaskets of the northern hemisphere and if that happens we are going to be in for a major food crisis then another thing that we worry a lot about is the tipping points in the system where self-employed fighting effects happen we already. see that out of the 15 tipping elements that have been identified in the climate system 9 active in this and that moving towards a critical tipping point for example for the complete loss of the greenland ice sheet which would take a very long time but it could be triggered it below 2 degrees or we see a slowdown of the gulf stream system in the north atlantic which has been long predicted and we're now seeing evidence that it has slowed down already by about 15 percent which means that the northern atlantic is the only region on the globe that
11:48 pm
has actually been significantly cooling in the last one he is while the whole rest of the planet has been warming. and there are major risks for our forests for example that we see the amazon forest is under threat that we now see big wildfires in australia where i have spent 6 months on a guest professorship so that's that's where it's very close to home for me when i see my friends and colleagues in australia sydney under a smoke of cloud a cloud of smoke and mess of fires wildfires burning there these are just i you know i could go on that me ask you about the timetable because the u.n. body of scientists the i.p.c.c. has issued some pretty dire warnings about the amount of time that we have to try to get on a track that would be at least to some degree sustainable what's your take how much time do you think we have in a word. very little if you see that to limit global warming to $1.00
11:49 pm
degrees we only have remaining emissions budget of $340.00 gigatons and we are emitting 40 gigatons each year that means at current emissions level after 8 years we would have run out of any more possibility to emit so 2 and a great. credit to very much to mention these numbers every time in his speeches which of course the i.p.c.c. has published them. already. more than a year ago and nobody takes them seriously apparently but that's not an opinion that's the best science we have so on the un cup process the paris treaty and the conference of parties to the treaty that try to put policies in place that is the main the of go by which the so-called world community is hoping to turn things around when you look at what's happened over the last 2 weeks how hopeful are you
11:50 pm
that this process can be successful and i say that with a focus on carbon markets which have been in fact the dominant topic of this past week. or do you. how hopeful. i hope we will be clever enough as a species to avoid our own extinction right. we have done in the past. look it's a thing that this cop at this conference is un conference had to move from chile to . madrid because of because the government entity was no longer stable why were there on this table because they put up the price of gas gasoline which is a which is something we're demanding right and that led to a to a people's rebellion now. these are the problems we have to deal with right i mean i think really we can agree on the fact that we should we really need to stay
11:51 pm
under 2 degrees global warming and that means definitely getting the c o 2 emissions down and that means that any kind of burning of fossil fuel is really a stupid idea and a bad idea and almost a criminal idea but when you actually try to do it if it's consumer call in france if it's the government in chile it is the government to run it it's the government in iraq. people are demonstrating and of course we're not doing that here but what i'm saying is we have to bring the people. along with us i mean obviously the government tehran is not going to do that because this is a dictatorship but we have to do it too if we don't want the kind of things that are happening in chile or happened last year in france that's what i'm saying well it has to be done in a socially just way otherwise we won't succeed with climate protection and bought some institute has of course made a report for the german government on how to do carbon pricing which included a carbon dividend that means that the money that the government takes in by
11:52 pm
a carbon price would be given back to the people on a per capita basis so that the low income earners at the end of the year they have more money in their account and it's the high income earners which will carry a proportionately a larger burden which actually still is a tiny fraction of the annual income. yes i agree examples you mentioned had no social balance whatsoever but is the important that we reach climate justice because that is our actual goal and what we see right now is if we don't act now if we don't act now we will not have a smooth. smooth passing to the next climate best option the longer we wait with the actions we take the more radical and the more drastic they have to be compared to our lifestyle right now so acting now is the less radical thing to do. a propos lifestyle germany just released it to sticks showing that
11:53 pm
there are more s.u.v.s on the roads in this country than ever before so we have a whole lot of germans joining climate activism protests at the same time are we seeing real concrete evidence of people changing their consumption habits i know you are opening statements said that it's corporations and policy makers and who need to move 1st but given the role of lobbies and given the coziness between many policy makers and for example the auto industry in germany do you really think that consumers can afford to wait for them to get wise i think it's very important not to mix the topics of consumption and production because what i always say is the grandma driving her to the supermarket because she can't walk anymore and the disabled person who use the plastic straw because otherwise he can drink those are not the main polluters the main polluters are the large corporations and that is why we need legislation to prohibit them from producing. c
11:54 pm
o 2 emissions or let's say s.u.v.s or generally products that harm our environment to a large extent. yes we need a change in the mindset of people and that is i think fight is futures for our responsibility to certain extent because we try to set the ground for legislation we try to. get the acceptance in society so that legislation is supported by the people. you called allan for the balance between what well essentially also for climate justice if you look at german energy policy and climate policy don't we see all kinds of contradictions that that illustrate exactly why this is so difficult on the one hand a very moderate rise in carbon pricing so that consumers would pay more for fuel on the other rebates to compute commuters how in the world is that going to change
11:55 pm
behavior. i don't know i mean german climate policy has been a zig zag policy to put it mildly i mean. it was probably a really bad idea to. try to get out of coal and nuclear at the same time. it was a really bad idea to force people to put 10 percent ethanol in there in there and that caused the tanks which led to the mains being. among a culture of maysan in the countryside there's a looks of things that we're really doing wrong it's a process of trial and error other countries one have to go through that so in a way i don't understand about the about giving commuters the money. that they don't assign it so since it makes sense to me but it seems you totally counterproductive this is only one of many counterproductive things that we're doing i hope other people will learn from mistakes i'm afraid i'll have to stop us
11:56 pm
right there thanks to all of you for being with us today and thanks to all of you for tuning in and seeing you in 3 weeks when we come back from holidays. and. look for.
11:57 pm
coming. in. karo the future of the east. coast sports is the latest edition valerie's a line up of electric cranks. on the hard tuner cars on their way home. we'll talk to some experts at the nasa motor show. drive it in minutes to.
11:58 pm
the suddenly nice friends i as came from jurors or dealing with any and i killed many civilians i mean. come it including my father says i was a student i wanted to build a life for myself. but suddenly life became alledge kind of sob. providing insights global news that matters d. w. made for mines. in the us of climate change. because mrs. watson stood. up to us today how for future. dot com for the mega city it's just so clear cut or.
11:59 pm
disrespect. the british love. the british. love. love. love. love. love. love. love love love love. love. love love love love. love. love and respect.
12:00 am
place . this is. the healing of begin says britain's boris johnson after his conservatives won a landslide victory in the country's general election a prime minister is bound to unite a divided country but many i'm not convinced those protesters take to the streets of london to voice their discontent also coming up to us in the wake is a pretty impeachment proceedings against president donald trump so many accusing him of the using his power and obstructing congress.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on