tv Tucker Carlson Tonight FOX News December 8, 2016 11:00pm-12:01am PST
about repealing and replacing obamacare, about education, about repatriation, about all of those issues. tomorrow night, 10:00 eastern. that's all of the time we have left this evening. we will see you back here tomorrow night. serving. >> all right. "special report" is next. this is a fox news alert. president-elect trump nominates another member of his cabinet today as one of his picks comes under heavy fire from the left. first, the death of an american hero. john glenn, the first american to orbit the earth died today after being hospitalized for more than a week at a columbus, ohio, cancer hospital. he was 95. president obama called glenn an icon who spent his life defending our freedom and breaking barriers. donald trump described him as a pioneer or hero who inspired generations of future explorers. my colleague john scott looks back at the remarkable life and legacy of john glenn.
>> reporter: john glenn will be remembered for his many roles in american history. he was a warrior in battle. our first astronaut to orbit the earth. one of our most successful political leaders. he added oldest person in space to his roster of achievements. >> i can't help but stand here with a sense of deja vu 40-year-old of deja vu.>> he n . >> reporter: he was born in ohio. after the japanese attacks pearl harbor, he signed up for the aviation cadet program and became a marine corps pilot. long before senator john glenn landed in our nation's capital, he served in world war ii, flying 59 successful missions. fire yeefars later, he was read to fly again, this time over north korea.
after serving in korea, glenn attended test pilot school at the naval air test center in maryland. here he gained early national recognition by setting the transcontinental speed record from los angeles to new york in three hours 23 minutes. by the late 1950s, the u.s. manned space program was just being conceived. john glenn was selected as one of the first seven astronauts for project mercury. three years later on february 20, 1962, he made history. becoming the first american to orbit the earth. >> turning around. that view is tremendous. >> reporter: after a few failed attempts at launching a political career, he ran again in 1974. this time he easily won a seat in the united states senate. he was re-elected in 1980 by the largest margin in the history of the state. political journalist jack germond followed his early political career. >> my first impression was when he ran on the primary was that
he had no feel for politics. he had a tremendous appeal to people. he was plain spoken. he was a national hero. >> reporter: senator glenn ran in the primaries of 1984 but bowed out to walter mondale. on january 16, 1998, nasa announced plans to return the 76-year-old legend to space, 36 years after he first orbited the earth. john glenn's second trip to space took off as planned. in october of 1998. >> liftoff with a crew of six astronaut heros and one american legend. >> reporter: when the mission was over, america's oldest space traveller was given another hero's welcome, his second ticker tape parade on broadway in new york city. >> one of the few legitimate american heros of our time. >> too often people say, i'm at this age supposed to be a couch potato. the thing to do is get out and
work to fulfill your dreams, your ambitions, at whatever age. >> reporter: following his retirement from politics and return from space, he and wife founded the john glenn institute for public service at ohio state university. they also served as trustees of their i'll alma mater. now to presidential politics. a headline in a washington newspaper today asks whether donald trump is already president? he is acting like it today. the president-elect met with families and first responders from last week's brutal terrorist attack at ohio state university. the event comes as trump continues his search for the best fit to be his top diplomat. on top of that, another celebration with the supporters tonight in iowa. peter doocy is in des moines. >> reporter: it was a few minutes ago that the president-elect left the campus
of ohio state university. he headed for john glenn international airport there in columbus on his way here to iowa. he did meet for about 40 minutes with victims of the recent stabbing spree on campus and the first responders who stepped in to save them. >> we just saw the victims and the families. we were really -- these were really brave people, amazing people. the police and first responders were incredible, the job done in particular by one young gentleman was incredible. >> reporter: the president-elect hosted a pair of potential secretary of state contenders in manhattan. he used to be a big critic of mr. trump. >> i think he does not seem to have a grasp of the issues that
are facing the nation. >> reporter: after emerging from trump tower's elevators, he sounded like an admirer. >> i found it to be a very interesting and a very informed conversation. >> reporter: the other invitation is intriguing. he was at boeing, singled out as spending too much on the next generation of air force i and ford which mr. trump repeatedly warned against building any more of its cars out of the country. >> you are not going to have any cars coming across the border unless you pay a tax. >> reporter: they are stressing ford was the only big american car company not to take bailout money. the trump cabinet continued filling up with the announcement mr. trump was puzner of labor secretary. the businessman regularly advocates against raising the minimum wage. that labor department pick followed a night of fighting
with organized labor, the head of a union represents carrier workers thinks the president-elect inflated the number of jobs saves there telling "the washington post" this week, trump and pence pulled a dog and pony show on the numbers. there are new questions today about whether or not mr. trump will completely sever with his ties by inauguration day. he may keep a stake. michael cohen responded this morning. >> everybody is concentrating on what he is going to do with the business. they will find out december 15th. >> reporter: here in des moines, it's very, very cold out. it's looking like it will be a warm welcome inside for the president-elect who will be joined tonight on the third stop of the thank you victory tour by the president-elect and the state's governor who the next
administration hopes to send to china as the next u.s. ambassador there. >> peter doocy, thanks for that. we are apparently nearing an end to the presidential vote recounts in a handful of states. wisconsin reports if t is more than 70% complete. hillary clinton gained 83 votes. a partial recount continues in nevada. pennsylvania's effort is the source of a hearing tomorrow. they ended that activity last night saying green party candidate jill stein is not eligible to ask for a recount. environmentalists would like a recount if they could get one on donald trump's decision to name a noted climate change skeptic to run the environmental protection agency. tonight, why so many are so afraid of scott pruitt. >> reporter: if today was any indication, the biggest fight facing a trump cabinet pick
could be over the choice for epa administrator, scott pruitt. who is ly allied with oil and gas. allies who maintain the science of global warming is settled despite conflicting evidence tore into pruitt. >> this is an environmental emergency. we have a person who is not just a climate denier but who is a professional climate denier. >> reporter: it came after trump met with dicaprio and gore. >> it was a sincere search for areas of common ground. >> reporter: pruitt's pick is seen by many as an antidote to epa's overreach and it cost it imposes on businesses. >> we want clean air. we want safety. we want clean water. crystal clean water. but we can't give hundreds of
billions of dollars away to groups that we don't even know where the money is going. it's crazy. >> reporter: nowhere is the epa's overreach more controversial than in the clean power plan. its implementation is on hold after a supreme court stay. >> that policy agenda is something that is resulting in the destruction of huge numbers of jobs, destruction of affordable energy. >> reporter: even present epa administrator admitted it's largely symbolic, after she was confronted by a congressional critic who noted it reduce temperatures very small. >> the value is not measured in that way. it's measured in showing strong domestic action which can trigger global action. >> reporter: pruitt was among dozens who sued the epa, the agency he will head if confirmed. democrats plan an assault. >> we should be prepared to talk about this not just as a matter
of bad climate policy but as a matter of corruption of government. >> reporter: one explanation for the outrage comes from this nobel prize winning physicist who has been demonized for noting how stable temperatures have been over 150 year sgls. >> global warming has become a new religion, because you can't discuss it. it's not proper. >> reporter: pruitt is not as vindictive toward his opponents. he said, we call upon them to press those beliefs through debate, not through governmental intimidation. >> thank you. let's talk more about trump's pick to run the epa. charles krauthammer joins us. i think it's fair to say the democrats' hair is on fire about the pick of scott pruitt. how worried should they be? >> they should be worried, because they have overreach now for eight years.
and that's about to be stopped in its tracks. all the coverage has been on the fact that he believes x, y or z about climate change, as if we have a religious test for office in the country, because as we just heard, climate change is a kind of religion. the fact is, we don't care if the guy believes that the moon is made of green cheese. his job is to administer. that means to carry out the law as passed by congress. the complaint of the right of conservatives about this administration, it's absolutely trampling the idea of administrators as interpreting the law. they make it up. that's why the epa has been stymied time and again in the courts led by pruitt and other attorney generals. when they try to overstep. they interpret the law in a way that gives them absolute dominion over almost everything. if it rains on your farm and
creates a pond, the feds -- the epa claims the right to regulate you. that's going to stop. >> for folks like you who i think it's fair to say doubted whether or not donald trump was a true conservative, when you look at people like scott pruitt at epa and labor and tom price with health and human services, this is shaping up on the domestic side as a very conservative cabinet. >> without question. each of these appointments appears targeted at a specific thing, like school choice for education, the epa is going to be on the essentially obama taking over the energy industry. he tried by legislation in 2009 and '10 when he had control of the congress with cap and trade. even the democrats rejected that. he did, as he has done in a dozen other areas, try to length la legislate the regulation. that's why conservatives are
encouraged by these appointments. >> we share several passions, baseball, politics and space exploration. you and i have talked about that a lot. i would love to hear your thoughts about the passing of john glenn. >> john glenn was the most celebrated american adventurer of the century. second only to charles lindbergh. he deserves it. he was insanely courageous. not just a fighter pilot in the second world war and the korean war. a test pilot in the '50s in the supersonic and space age where life expectancy was quite short for those pilots. but here he is the first man to go into orbit. imagine this. when you are ready to go -- it was postponed i think 11 times. your colleagues, co-workers strap you in, shut the door, they go down and they drive three miles, not one mile, not two, because of the fireball
that's about -- >> you are at the top of the firecracker all by yourself. >> all by yourself. your best pals, your colleagues are in a bunker three miles away. that tells you how insanely courageous they were. you do remember, in the early '60s, we were having launch explosions with unmanned flights. that's why it was such a chance. it seems safe now. it wasn't. >> i do remember it got scrubbed. that was the word they used scrubbed over and over again because of bad weather on the cape. finally it took off. john glenn, godspeed. thank you, charles. one of candidate trump's rallying cries was getting rid of trade deals. many republicans are resisting trump's ideas how to accomplish that. ed henry is here tonight to tell us why. >> reporter: donald trump has not been sworn into office and
top republicans are balking at his push for a massive tariff on companies that ship jobs overseas. with kevin mccarthy warning of a trade war. paul ryan tried to brush off mr. trump's tariff more diplomatically saying the focus should be on cutting corporate taxes. >> the best way to get at this circumstance through tax reform. >> reporter: the president-elect has warmed the hearts of republicans with promises of tax cuts. he is upending conservative orthodoxy dating back decades with a thank you tour that sometimes makes him sound like a democrat. >> the era of economic surrender is over. >> the bottom 90%, the working class families have not seen a raise in 20 or 30 years. >> reporter: mr. trump is pushing the 35% tariff on com p companies for outsourcing, it could shrink the economy and put four million workers out of jobs and lead to another 3.3 million jobs not being created.
all on top of the carrier deal that also ran counter to gop gospel on free market. >> we can't be giving special interest fafsvors. >> reporter: steven moore note olympinoteed he could push through major tax reform and regulatory relief. the president-elect has signalled 35% is just an opening gamut to deal with the fact that the u.s. had a trade deficit of $40 billion. >> more than a $30 billion trade deficit with china alone. all right? think we're doing a good job at negotiating? i don't think so. >> reporter: moore who worked on the trump campaign but is not involved in the transition notes there's no denying the president-elect's success so far. >> not only did donald trump win with this message, but look at what has happened to the stock market, look what has happened to consumer confidence, look what happened to his approval rating. this is a president who is on a
roll. >> reporter: moore did warn mr. trump has to be careful a bunch of companies may now be lining up on pennsylvania avenue here in washington and fifth avenue in new york looking for goodies. >> thank you. up next, will president obama pardon hillary clinton on his way out of the oval office? first here is what some of our fox affiliates around the country are covering tonight. atlanta, a death of a second south georgia police officer involved in a domestic dispute shooting yesterday. police in america's georgia say the 32 suspect killed himself today as authorities arrived at a home where he was hiding. reno, nevada, a high school student was threatening other students is in critical condition after being shot by a campus police officer. the chief of police says the officer took the action when the 14-year-old boy failed to follow his commands.
this is a live look at san francisco from fox 2. one of the big stories there tonight, a magnitude 6.5 earth quake rocked the west coast this morning. the u. it was centered about 100 miles west of ferndale, california. there are no reports of daniel or injuries. that's tonight's live look outside the dealt way from
kevin cork looks at that tonight from the white house. >> reporter: with over 1,000 commutations, he granted clemency to more people than the previous 11 presidents combined. how he handles several high profile applicants could well be his most enduring legacy. accused army deserter bowe bergdahl, chelsea manning and edward snowden looking for an 11th hour reprieve before mr. obama leaves hour. pressure is rising to pardon snowden who is charged with multiple felonies. the aclu joined by amnesty international and human rights watch and calling on the president to grant clemency. ask about that suggest last month, the president said, i condition pardon somebody who hasn't gone before a court and presented themselves. mr. snowden raised legitimate concerns. it did not follow the procedures
and practices of our intelligence community. house democrats has called on the president to pardon about 750,000 young undocumented immigrants who are shielded from deportation under a 2012 executive order. white house officials conceded that the president can't protect the dreamers as they are known from a change in policy under a trump administration. >> the president cannot use his clemency authority to legalize the immigration status of anybody. that is why we pursued the executive actions we did. >> reporter: what of the fate of hillary clinton? might the president give her a blanket pardon? much in the way president ford offered president nixon. >> it would imply there was guilt by secretary clinton. that's something she's unwilling to believe. it's something the president is unwilling to believe. it's likely not something that i
think any of the parties would be interested in. i don't think the president would do it as a result. >> reporter: interesting conversation. by the way, those immigrant dreamers gave the government a lot of personal information, including fingerprints and the home addresses of their relatives in order to apply for protection. there is concern tonight among democrats that the government under a trump administration could use that very same information to deport them. >> kevin cork reporting from the white house. thank you. congress is trying to get out of town as soon as possible. the one thing holding up lawmakers is a spending bill to keep the government running. republicans are trying to use that leverage to their advantage. mike emanuel is on capitol hill tonight to tell us how. good evening. >> reporter: good evening. that package passed the house 326 to 96. even though the house democratic leader voted again it. it would fund the government through next april 28. it contains $10.1 billion for
fighting isis and other overseas contingency operations. it has $4.1 billion for disaster relief, including money for hurricane matthew victims. $170 million for contaminated drinking water, 118 democrats in the house voted for the measure but not their leader. >> members will do what they do. the fact is is that it's a missed opportunity. it's really kind of sad, because there's so many things that we could do to meet the needs of of the american people working together in a bipartisan way. >> reporter: two democrats in the senate are upset benefits for retired coal miners are extended four months. they threaten to hold up the senate but don't appear to have the votes. >> our friends across the aisle need to face up to the reality that if they somehow prevent us from passing this continuing
resolution, it will be on their hands. i hope they will reconsider. they will not be able to achieve the goal they are seeking. >> reporter: with more than 100 house democrats voting for the measure, many republicans on capitol hill say manchin and brown lost their leverage. >> harry reid is about to end his tenure as the democratic leader in the senate. how is he saying good-bye? >> reporter: after 30 years here on capitol hill, including 12 as the senate democratic leader, it is almost over. late today, harry reid unveiled his official portrait with some democratic vips on hand, including vice-president joe biden and former democratic nominee hillary clinton in attendance. today reedoffered advice. >> i didn't make it in life because my prowess, because of my good looks. i didn't make it because i'm a genius. i made it because i worked hard.
>> reporter: mitch mcconnell note ed their many battles but they tried to keep them professional and not personal. >> mike emanuel on capitol hill. u.n. officials are scrambling to find enough land to shelter as many as 700,000 people fleeing mosul as iraqi forces continue to battle isis there. so far, about 82,000 have left. refugee camps are near capacity. iraq's parliament speaker says an air strike targeting an isis held town kill and wounded dozens of civilian. a u.s. military spokesman denies any involvement. isis is calling on its followers to target american military personnel ahead of of a visit there by defense secretary ash carter. it comes as u.s. and russian officials continue talks on implementing a cease-fire in aleppo as the humanitarian situation there gets worse every day. we have that story tonight from
the israeli border with syria. >> reporter: the sound of prayer and the sound of war. a constant chorus as thousands remain trapped in eastern aleppo. help may be coming. >> translator: i can inform you they suspended military operation in eastern aleppo because another one and the largest operation of withdrawal of civilian is being conducted. >> reporter: 8,000 receive yal n civilians he said. they agreed to meet saturday to discuss the withdrawal of opposition forces. se syria's government says it controls 75% of eastern aleppo. but they have been stopped in other parts of the country such as along the israeli border. you are looking at a village that has been destroyed in the fighting. we have been hearing sporadic gunfire in the distance.
i'm standing probably a couple hundred yards from the border. i'm in an unmanned bunker. i don't want to get too high because of the threat of sniper fire. due to the violence, israel's military has increased its presence along the border here. syria said israel attacked one of its military air bases in damascus early wednesday. israeli defense minister said that israel acts to prevent syrian weapons from falling into the hands of hezbollah. israel has no interest in getting involved in syria's civil war, a war that continues to tear the country apart. our series on the first 100 days of the trump presidency continues tonight with a look at national security. it was one of donald trump's major issues in the campaign. chief intelligence con
correspondent catherine herridge reports. >> i hope we have somebody that can say islamic terrorist. >> i hope they can focus on what's right, not what is politically correct or advantageous to themselves. >> reporter: these two live 60 miles outside seattle. the legacy of his army service includes two bullets in his back and leg. >> when i went down to the ground, he kept shooting me. he ended up putting another five rounds into me. >> i still can't shake the phone call. the phone call was the hardest. sorry. it replays in my head.
>> reporter: married six weeks before the attack, they sort through paperwork. >> we had x-rays done. on two instances, we were turned away because we were told the machine was broken. >> reporter: as part of restoring national security, trump promised major changes. >> how many veterans? the right to seek private medical care when they can't get proper service. >> my only fear is if they switch to a privatized system, some of the care at the va facilities could be degraded. i hope they focus on fixing the problems. >> reporter: the act pledges to eliminate defense budget cuts known as a sequester and to expand military investment. a pentagon report about maintenance teams taking extreme measures struck a cord. >> they are flying planes that they go to a plane museum or to
an airplane graveyard because they don't even make the parts anymore. >> reporter: the mannings say ending sequestration should be a priority. coupled with the va frustrations, it adds another layer of stress. >> i have had friends that had basically been given pink slips. they were close to retirement. it's a shock that they were booted out. >> reporter: the president-elect's national security strategy is broad. from the war fighter to the border agent, as well as the intelligence professional who tracks the cyber threat, the plan is ambitious and will challenge the established order. this november 17 transition video calls on senior military leaders -- >> to develop a comprehensive plan to protect america's vital inf infrastructure from cyberattacks and other forms of attacks. >> you see an uptick with cyberattacks. >> i do. it will be a dark year. we will see more destructive attacks, that dismantle data.
>> reporter: elevating the issue is the right thing, but there will be resistance. >> there's too much of a turf war between the government agencies that are responsible for dealing with cyberattacks. we need more cooperation and collaboration. >> reporter: immigration is a final component. calling for a new screening procedure and a stronger border. this week, the house committees republican's chairman prom igsed to draft legislation. >> we will put in place a historic multi-layered defense system so that drug cartels and terror i have ists don't slip t. >> reporter: the first 100 days seem like a drop in the bucket for the mannings who are waiting for his injuries to be deemed combat related. getting the purple heart last year was progress. now they hope mr. trump will live up to his tweets. >> i remembered that tweet of his support back in 2012. that's exactly why i voted for him. >> it's not a left or right thing. it should be an american thing. >> reporter: in washington
catherine herridge, fox news. tomorrow we will look at the promises that president-elect trump made to drain the swamp in washington and what he could do in his first 100 days. a federal judge denied a defense request for a mistrial in the case of the accused charleston church shooter dylann roof. facing charges of killing nine black church goers in the summer of 2015. the judge said today, a survive's testimony about roof belongs in the pit of hell was not a statement on what his sentence should be. record highs on wall street today. the dow jumped 65. the s&p rose 5. nasdaq was up 24. donald trump has environmentalists turning all kinds of shades of green with his choice to run the epa. we will talk with the panel about that when we come right back.
this president has promised us many times he will use the regulatory process to bypass congress. i'm grateful we have people holding the president accountable. >> the idea we will do a 180 on climate policy, it's disastrous. >> it won't be abolishing the epa. they will roll back hundreds if not thousands of regulations. >> oklahoma attorney general scott pruitt stating his opposition to president obama's environmental regulations. as you could see, democrats and republicans with sharply different reactions to trump naming pruitt to be his epa administrator. let's bring in our panel, steve haze, laura ingram and charles lane. start with the nomination of pruitt as epa administrator. he says the debate over climate change is far from settled. he is part of several lawsuits against epa regulations on
greenhouse gas emissions. your thoughts about this nomination? >> it's going to drive the left absolutely crazy, which it has started to do. i think they're going to fight this as hard as they fight anything the trump administration puts forward. it goes to the heart of their argument that the planet is warming, cut greenhouse gas emissions, we will save the planet, the oceans won't rise, we won't have destruction along the coastline. i understand that. but it's like the church of global warming has also in the eyes of many completely subsumed the idea that business still has to exist. there has to be a balance between protecting the environment and having business be able to operate. not unfettered but with some degree of freedom. does it surprise me that trump picked him? absolutely not. they're going to have to be ready for the hearings and with a responsible approach that we
want an environment that's protected. there are people out there -- he thinks the earth is getting hotter. he thinks the dire predictions of the climate change are way over the top. very respected. there's intolerance on the other side as well. >> steve, when trump met with al gore this week and then you got to remember when he met with the "new york times" and said he had an open mind about climate change and the paris climate accord, there were some conservatives who were wondering whether trump had gone soft on environmental regulations. with the appointment of scott pruitt to run the epa, was that a head fake? >> it might have been. those concerns were unfounded. this is the person you want if you wanted to challenge the epa. pruitt is a thoughtful movement conservative who has been doing this for quite a while. he ran on it when he ran for attorney general in oklahoma.
he executed the plan that he ran on. he was creative in using the law to push back on federal regulations that many people, not just business people but average citizens around the country think go too far, not just on the epa but on obamacare and other things. i think this is the kind of person you want in administration. it's funny to watch this liberal heads explode as this happens. nobody should be surprised that donald trump is going to nominate somebody who basically agrees with the kinds of things that he has argued. back when president obama won and he was filling out his cabinet, selecting his top staffers and advisers, the left said, we won. we get to make these choices. donald trump -- he won. he gets to make these choices. >> as part of the trump surge in the stock market, energy prices went up. i want to go with you, chuck, to this question of the reaction by
democrats who seem to be more upset about this than any other nomination that trump has made so far. usually, in a transition, there's one person that the opposition party looks to knock off, because they can't go after everybody. is this one? is this the battle in the confirmation hearinghearings. >> there's going to be competition for that honor. there's important money in the democratic camp from tom stire among others that is -- that flows in the democratic party based on environmental issues. those people will really be arguing to take a stand on scott pruitt. here is the catch. there are a number of democratic senators facing re-election in 2018 in red states or in coal burning states. often the same thing. i'm thinking about bob casey in pennsylvania. even someone like brown of ohio
who is liberal but a coal dependent state. those folks will face a dilemma in how to handle the future of the clean power plant to the extent it's an issue in this case. of course, the question will be, do we filibuster pruitt? you will need 40 solid democratic votes to do that. by the way, on the other side there's at least one republican i can think of who might have concerns. >> there's the possibility of republicans going to the democratic side and opposing him. this is with the nuclear option that harry reid put into affect, 50 votes is what you need. >> of course, i forgot to mention, joe manchin of the coal state of west virginia will probably like this appointment. it's not exactly a straightforward partisan issue. >> i want to ask you, laura, about another pick that the president made today. that was the fast food executive for hardy's. he is an outspoken critic of
obamacare. a critic of the minimum wage and administration overtime rules. what are your thoughts about his pick? >> i think he is going to annoy both sides. he is extremely smart, very accomplished. i think you can make a case for him. however, on the issue of immigration and foreign workers coming into the united states, there's a lot of folks out there, breitbart has a piece tonight, that puzder is not good on those issues. he kept wages low at his companies by having mostly immigrant workers. is he opposed to one of the bedrock ideas that, of course, president-elect trump ran on? that is a concern. i've been getting lots of e-mails over the last several hours about this pick. we will see how that shakes out. it could annoy both sides. >> he is a big exponent of
automation and the idea that you can save money by having machines, not employees. one of his arguments is, if you make the cost of labor too expensive, people are just going to go do machines in places where they can. >> we will see how that works out. >> we have to take a break. up next, donald trump against congressional republicans on the issue of trade. and can you explain to me why you recommend synthetic over cedar? "super food"? is that a real thing? it's a great school, but is it the right the one for her? is this really any better than the one you got last year? if we consolidate suppliers what's the savings there? so should we go with the 467 horsepower? or is a 423 enough? good question. you ask a lot of good questions... i think we should move you into our new fund. ok. sure. but are you asking enough about how your wealth is managed? wealth management, at charles schwab.
we're going to improve the environment for manufacturing jobs in this country. we're going to take away the advantages the companies have had for decades to take jobs out of the united states. >> we believe the pest way to solve that very important goal is comprehensive tax reform. >> a sharp difference of opinion between vice president elect mike pence and republican house speaker
paul ryan over the best way to stop american jobs from going overseas. and we're back now with the panel. so there is this disagreement, steve, between the trump team, which favors the idea of punitive 35% tariffs if a company moves out with its jobs and then troys to ship goods back into the u.s. and the republican leadership in congress which is talking about, no, just general tax reform, better business climate, cut back on regulations. not trade wars. where' this going to end up? >> good question. i think we're likely to see a huge effort by cop congressional republicans to push back on some of the things that donald trump said but it all depends on when he does this. if donald trump moves early on trade issues, he can make the argument that he ran on these issues. they were one of his signature issues without a doubt. and that he deserves sort of the benefit of the doubt as he makes his case. i think the question in a broader sense remains are
republicans here trying to sort of fill in the gaps that the free market sometimes loaves, whether you are talking about trade deals or whether you are talking about just the operation of the markets inside the country or are you talking about abandoning free markets? i think if it's the former you may actually find common ground between people who have been traditionally free traders like paul ryan and donald trump. if it's the latter and sharp turn away from free markets and the quote from mike pence last week where he said you know we have tried the free market in america has been alesser, that's going to be alarming to republicans who believe in free markets to businesses and people like me. >> let me ask you, laura, because it raises an interesting question. i think there are some people on capitol hill who think that trump really doesn't care about the details and they can set the agenda and they can pass the bills and trump will just sign it. and you're shaking your head that ain't the way it's going to work. >> i don't think that's the way it's going to work. i think on this issue he believes he has both support
on the right and on the left. i know we talked about this carrier thing coming up. you go back to the head of the indiana steel workers union, the national steel workers union as well. they are in favor of the tariff. they like the idea of tariffs. not throw on tariff for the sake of tariffs, when the market is inefficient and fro market fails because of a foreign country subsidy or cheating or dumping and all the things we know china does. that's when presidents throughout our history have engaged in selective use of tariffs. and i think that's the rub here. will this make sense? certain cases? will it be uniform, you know, slapping on a 35% tariff? you can do both things and traditionally both republicans and democrats have done. four letter word preposterous. it can be a market efficiency maker if deployed the right way. on the carrier thing i don't know if we are going to get into that. whether it's 800 jobs or 1,000 jobs that makes market
sense because it really doesn't cost 1.6 months all the costs for this gets paid back. >> let me get into that because it's not just ceos that mr. trump is confronting. he also got into quite a tussle today with the head of the local union in indiana that represents a lot of the carrier workers. and he accused the president-elect of exsag ger rating how many jobs, in fact, he saved. here first is that union boss. >> he didn't tell the truth. he inflated the numbers and i called him out on it. >> here is mr. trump's tweet reacting to that criticism from union leader chuck jones, quote: if united steel workers 1999 was any good, they would have kept those jobs in indiana, spend more time working, less time talking, reduce -- i assume he is talking about union dues, check, what do you make of that. >> in addition to the fact that we all have to forget this idea that there is ever
going to become a time where donald trump doesn't retaliate when somebody insults him. that's just what he does. is he going to do that. >> he already said when they punch i punch back harder. >> that's point number one. point number 2 is the actual -- to an extent you have substantive point about the union now is to blame for the fact that the jobs were going to go to mexico. before, it seemed like he was blaming the evil company. and in that sense, you know, the whole idea, whatever it is behind his plan to prevent jobs from leaving suddenly becomes all confused. it used to be that these were -- it was the fault of the corporations who didn't care about americans and didn't care about their workers. now all of the sudden he is mud ling the picture by saying sometimes the unions are to blame, too. so what that tells me is that he hasn't actually thought this whole business of selectively punishing companies through very carefully. what laura is talking about is one thing where there is like a legal finding where a
whole industry is being attacked by a foreign country violating international law with respect to trade, what he has been always talking about up to now like this or that company just gets up and moves to mexico, i'm going to stop that by punishing -- >> --laura, 30 seconds. >> i think the thing that's happening here is he is reacting to a problem in america with jobs going overseas. in this particular case, with carrier, whether it's 800 jobs or 1,000 jobs, i don't think in the end people care about that. what they care about is that this is partly of the plan. it's not the whole panacea to restore real jobs to america and make the atmosphere here more hospitable for business. that's what he is getting at. i get the thing about the tweeting. i think that's his overall goal,. >> i suspect we are not going to resolve this day but other tweets and ordinary possibilities. see how they handle snow in canada. they should be good at it, right?
>winter is coming. we can show you how they handle winter on the first snow day of the season. nobody was hurt so it's okay to laugh. here you go. bus is like a snowplow. the bus is still there. i guess it's a cab. oh my gosh. here comes another bus on the bus. and now here's a police car. thislikeed like a different corner. but this isn't good. and going backwards down the street and there -- get out of the car. >> you can hear that got a littlactuality here. bam, roller derby if you have ever been in that situation, there is no more helpless feeling. that's "special report" for tonight. i'm chris wallace in washington.
let's put up the plug because i have an exclusive interview on sunday with donald trump. we talk to him in trump tower on saturday. why will go on trump force one. couldn't be more excited. that's sunday well -- welcome to "red eye." i'm tom shillue. let's check in with andy levey at the "red eye" tease desk. >> comp up, donald trump's never ending tour of gratitude continues. and santa claus tells a 9-year-old kid to layoff the burger and fries. this from a man who needs magic to fit down a chimney. and tom breaks down the tom tweets of the year. if you don't want to wait you can go to twitter.com/andy levey. back to you, tom. >> thank you, andy. let's welcome our guests.