Skip to main content

tv   2020  ABC  November 9, 2018 10:01pm-11:00pm PST

10:01 pm
there's blood all over. >> okay, where is she at? >> oh. >> tonight, you will see the chaos for yourself, caught on a deputy's body cam. >> face plant right in the wall. this room is clear. >> tonight, on "20/20," it's the tale of the tape. >> there was blood on the wall. she fought to the end. >> a small-town hockey star discovering his own wife, dead. >> she's dead. i said, what? i couldn't make sense of it. >> the only witness -- their 7-year-old daughter, charlie. >> she told me a man was hurting
10:02 pm
mommy. >> this guy came and started hitting my mom with this pipe thingy. >> mommy was yelling, run, charlie, run. >> what did the robber look like? >> what she answers will set in motion an investigation no one could have imagined. >> he was going to set the house on fire with kelly and the children in the house? >> that's correct. a cold-blooded killer. >> it's a bizarre scenario, about what really happened. >> she fought to her last breath to save her life. >> this is "20/20." reporting tonight, deborah roberts. >> reporter: the finger lakes region of new york state, known for its breathtaking scenery, lush wineries and brilliant fall colors. >> it's just a nice, laid-back community. very easygoing, a nice place to raise kids. >> reporter: 18 years ago, a new
10:03 pm
the elmira jackals, a minor league hockey team. >> yeah, hannah! >> reporter: bringing a fury of energy and excitement to the area. >> when the jackals arrived, it really gave the community, the town, something to really rally around on those winter friday nights and saturday nights. suddenly you had 4,000 people kind of going downtown. a lot of them maybe grab a drink afterwards. >> jackals forward tom clayton knows how to get under his opponents' skin. >> reporter: one of the big stars, number 18, thomas clayton. >> he's looking to take his game to the next level. >> if you can get one of their top guys off the ice for two minutes, five minutes, you know, it gets that job done. >> tom was chippy, aggressive. his job was to go out there and instigate trouble. he would slash other players, he would just try to get them agitated to the point where they would draw a penalty. >> he was an instigator on the ice. >> and now we've got a fight behind the play. it looks like -- >> he would start fights. >> reporter: here he is scrapping it up with a rival player. >> clayton coming back at him. >> what do you want to do? you want to fight someone. just like when you're a little kid and you just get so mad you want to fight, you know?
10:04 pm
>> reporter: cocky, animated and intimidating -- >> clayton helps to keep things in perspective. >> reporter: -- the hockey sensation would soon meet his match in kelley stage. >> kelley was definitely outgoing, spontaneous. she cared about everybody. fashionable. crazy at times. loyal. sassy. definitely sassy. didn't put up with anything. >> reporter: a local girl, she spotted tom from the stands, says sister kim bourgeois. >> at a game is when she first saw thomas clayton. and she thought he was cute. she went out that night to a bar after that game with her best friend. >> he was sitting at the bar, and i asked him, "do you have a girlfriend?" and he said, "who are you asking for?" i said, "not me." he said, "the blonde? she's unbelievable." >> reporter: were they smitten with each other? >> yes. very. he was known as a bad boy. he would have a harem of girls following him. >> reporter: what was it about him that attracted such
10:05 pm
attention? >> tom was very good-looking. he was smooth. he'd try to make you feel like you were the most beautiful girl in the room. >> reporter: the relationship grows serious quickly, and they marry in 2006. the following year, tom's hockey career crashes when he injures his leg. >> he was looking to really try to put that behind and move on and start a family in the area. >> reporter: first with baby girl, charlie. >> hi! you gonna give a smile? >> reporter: and three years later, son cullen follows. were they happy? >> she was very happy. and as far as i knew, he was happy, too. she loved him. i know that my sister truly, truly loved him. >> reporter: and kelley, as a mom, was she having a great time as a young mom? >> she was a great mom. very involved in both of their lives. >> reporter: tom is a successful businessman, owning rental
10:06 pm
properties and heading up a local servpro franchise. >> they do cleanup in homes and businesses after fires and floods. he was a fairly high-ranking operations manager. >> reporter: were they doing well financially as a family? >> they were doing extremely well. they had purchased a home that kelley loved. she was so excited. life appeared to be wonderful for kelley, tom, charlie, and cullen. >> reporter: that is, until one autumn night, after a night of poker, tom clayton finds something sinister has happened in his home. >> 911. >> help me, help me. my wife, she's dead. >> how long has she been down? >> i don't know. i don't know.
10:07 pm
i just got home. >> sir, you need to calm down so i can help you. is she beyond cpr? >> yes. >> sir, why do you think she is beyond cpr? >> just trust me. >> i was on duty, on patrol here in the east corning area at the time when the call came in. >> reporter: what do you hear? >> the call came in as a woman down, a medical situation. >> reporter: steuben county sheriff's deputy dean swan gets the call that night. he drives me along the route to the family home in caton, new york. >> caton is quiet. it's very rural. it's extremely dark. lots of back roads, open fields. you really can't see much when you're driving there. >> reporter: what were you thinking? >> en route up there, something was wrong. i just had a gut feeling something was wrong. >> reporter: as he approaches the home, deputy swan switches on his new body camera. what you're about to see is realtime footage of the scene that night. >> let's turn our red lights off.
10:08 pm
we're close enough. when i pulled up to the scene, i saw a gentleman at the front door. i just started asking questions about what's going on. >> how are you doing? >> i'm okay. >> what's going on? >> tom just came -- i'm the neighbor. tom just came and got me out of bed. >> reporter: he was pretty frantic? >> yes. he was visibly shaken, very flustered, and he couldn't get much out. >> okay, what happened, though? >> his wife -- his wife is in there. >> okay. >> reporter: the deputy, a 20-year veteran, enters the house looking for tom. >> anybody else in the house, tom? just you? >> i got the kids out there at the neighbor's house. >> reporter: completely unprepared for what he is about to see. >> okay, where's she at? >> over there. >> whoa. whoa. okay. some sort of blunt force trauma had occurred. i want you to have a seat. you don't need to see that anymore, okay? there was blood splatter on the ceiling, on the walls. yeah, there's blood all over.
10:09 pm
she's been dragged. >> this was a hods -- homicide. that's when i started to interview tom clayton. tom, where were you when this all went down? >> playing poker with my buddies. i came home and my daughter said there was a robber in the house and she saw them. >> yeah, you got to chill out there, man. let me see your hands real quick, man. and you ain't hurt or anything? okay, good. okay. >> reporter: tom, visibly shaking, is checked for weapons and bloodstains, and directed to the back seat of the squad car. >> take it easy. you're not in trouble. just sit right there. i'm going to leave the door open. just sit right there. relax. we've got a crime scene. we have a possible homicide. nobody's going in right now. we've got to clear this house. >> reporter: deputy swan inspects the rest of the house. the intruder and possible killer could still be inside. >> i was afraid the robber could possibly be in the house. he said there was a robber in the house. just cover me.
10:10 pm
i'm gonna go upstairs. i gotta go up and clear it. that's when i searched the home to make sure in was nobody there. i've gotta clear over here. the kids' rooms are over here. there's blood in the kids' room. okay, kids' rooms, this one's clear. >> reporter: as they search the home, guns drawn -- >> there's blood all over up here. >> reporter: -- the trail of evidence begins to tell a twisted story of its own. >> i'm trying not to step on anything. okay, clear. let's get the hell off this. house is clear. >> reporter: when we come back, an all-out manhunt for a killer. >> they're looking at footprints and tire prints. >> we had a dog that had tracked something out to the pond. >> reporter: next. ter: next. - [narrator] if you want serious cleaning with a cord-free vacuum, you need a shark. because only shark's cord-free lineup has duo-clean technology so you can deep clean carpets and give hard floors a polished look. and with two swappable batteries at maximum suction, our shark ion f80 gives you more run time than the dyson v10 absolute. and now shark takes cord-free beyond stick vacuums by introducing a full upright model.
10:11 pm
shark ion cord-free vacuums available in stick and upright. (man) hey portal, call rory. by introducing a fulhappy birthday!. (woman) awww, you remembered! (man) of course i remembered, you're my sister. (woman) what'd you get me? (man) uhhh, i got you...this! (woman) it's half dead. (man) just like you! (woman) oooooh! wait until your birthday comes. [man laughing] this weekend at target get 25% off hom♪ décor and more. 25% off dining rooms. 25% off guest rooms. and 25% off extra rooms. weekend deals. only at target. (burke) seen it, covered it. we know a thing or two because we've seen a thing or two.
10:12 pm
♪ we are farmers. bum-pa-dum, bum-bum-bum-bum ♪ julie means more to me and i wanted to ask you before i ask her. may i have your permission, to marry her? you're marrying her and her whole world. shop neil lane diamond engagement rings... kay. is our baby. and like any baby, it's loud, stressful and draining. and we love it. i refuse to let migraine keep me from saying... "i am here." aimovig, a preventive treatment for migraine in adults, reduces the number of monthly migraine days. for some, that number can be cut in half or more. the most common side effects are pain, redness or swelling at the injection site and constipation. talk to your doctor about aimovig. and be there more. talk to your doctor about aimovig. in our home we make memories. in our home we are grateful. in this family we know what matters most is made at home.
10:13 pm
now, an all-new "20/20"
10:14 pm
continues. >> i got a female, mid-30s, early 40s. her face is completely beaten in. husband's story right now, kids are home with mom. husband is claiming he was out playing poker. came home. kids said, "daddy, there was a robbery." >> reporter: 35-year-old mom of two kelley clayton has been found bludgeoned to death in her own home in the secluded, picturesque community of caton, new york. it's a grisly scene. deputy dean swan is the first to arrive. . >> blood on the wall. looks like a face plant in the wall. blood everywhere, where the victim was, in the kitchen. i believe it was an extreme
10:15 pm
struggle. she fought to the end. we're going to need all investigators. homicide. >> reporter: awaiting backup, he's got a hunch. he's convinced this was no robbery. >> i just want to make sure there is no forced entry anywhere else. i didn't see any. it was a typical home, nothing was out of place, nothing rummaged through. in the office, a desk with paperwork on it. nothing on the floor, nothing like that. there was nothing. >> reporter: the deputy's gut instinct tells him this is a domestic incident gone bad. >> i'm wondering if he got domestic with her. she face planted. boom. then he puts her out in the kitchen. in her face, you can see how her face is beat in. >> is there a suspect? >> husband. >> i thought he was lying to us.
10:16 pm
i was not buying his story at all. >> reporter: he quickly begins questioning the clayton's neighbor, derek almy. >> okay, you don't know of any troubles between anybody here, him and her, or somebody else and them or anything? >> not really, no. >> no domestics you know of in the past? >> no. >> was he upset? >> oh, my gosh, indescribably. he said it's gruesome in there. >> did he have any blood on him when he came over? did he change his clothes ever? >> here? no. >> no, okay. >> reporter: almy doesn't know it yet, but deputy swan is taking a hard look at his neighbor, tom clayton. fidgety, anxious and muttering after the discovery of his wife's body. >> i'm gonna [ bleep ] pass out. >> well, sit down then. come over here and sit down. >> i keep sitting down and getting back up. my daughter saw it.
10:17 pm
my daughter saw my wife. >> okay. >> reporter: clayton has also called kelley's sister kim to break the news. >> my phone rang at 12:49. "kim. kim. kelly's dead." i said, "what?" "kelly's dead." and i just remember pacing back and forth. pacing, like, "what?" i just couldn't make sense of it. and i remember getting clothes on, and i remember it was raining and it was cold. >> reporter: soon, relatives and friends are all alerted to the tragedy. >> i get up to her street, on her road, and i don't see any -- it's pitch black. country road, pitch black. no lights. go over a hill, still black. go over another hill and it's lit up like christmas. just tons of lights. >> family coming. you're going to have to stop them. >> and i just remember hearing kim screaming. >> oh, god!
10:18 pm
>> i remember running to the ambulance expecting to find them working on my sister. and i am like, "is my sister in there? where is my sister? where is my sister?" >> where's my sister? >> reporter: was tom distraught when you saw him? how did he appear? >> all i remember is that his head was down in his hands. i couldn't hear him. i also couldn't get near him. >> reporter: that's because thomas clayton, the once minor league hockey player who was used to instigate fights on the ice, is now headed to a different kind of penalty box. a police interrogation room. >> something i'll never forget. i'm backing out of the driveway, trying to avoid all of the emergency vehicles. clayton just kind of out of the blue says, "well, you know where i was, because my truck has a gps on it." which obviously kind of threw a flag. i didn't ask you where you were
10:19 pm
yet. but he made sure he threw that out there. >> reporter: clayton pens a statement declaring, "i did not hurt or kill kelley" and requests an attorney. was he wondering who could do this? why somebody would do this? >> no, he wasn't. that was another thing that struck me as odd, is that he wasn't really concerned. he could mention not one suspect or possible suspect of who might want to harm his wife or his family. not one person that he could think of that would want to do harm to them. >> reporter: meanwhile, an all-out investigation is under way. >> you can see a very heavy police presence was there early in the day. >> reporter: police on the hunt for clues. tire tracks, footprints, anything that might lead to the killer. >> we knew that someone had went out the back of the house wardthpo. weve aog thad acd g to p looking for evidence. >> reporter: next, police get the ultimate lead -- an
10:20 pm
eyewitness. the claytons' 7-year-old daughter. she had seen her mother killed? >> she described kelley's last breaths. she was able to describe the weapon. >> can you tell me what he looked like? >> he was wearing jeans, a black long-sleeved shirt and a mask. >> reporter: but who will she say is the killer? stay with us. ♪ thanks, hun! (girl) mom! yes! okie dokie! what?! mrs. johnson? (train whistle blowing) (vo) every hero deserves a reward. (screaming) (vo) gifts for them... kohl's cash for you. thanks! (vo) kohl's. give joy, get joy. (train whistle blowing) depression for years. with bipolar i wasn't happy with myself and i missed so much. not being there for the ones i love was hard. it made me really sad.
10:21 pm
so i talked to my doctor. she prescribed latuda. latuda is the number one prescribed brand for bipolar depression a different type of depression latuda was proven effective for many people struggling with bipolar depression. latuda is not for everyone call your doctor about unusual mood changes behaviors, or suicidal thoughts anti-depressants can increase these in children,teens and young adults. elderly dementia patients on latuda have an increased risk of death or stroke call your doctor about about fever, stiff muscles, and confusion as these may be life-threatening or uncontrollable muscle movements as these may be permanent these are not all the serious side effects to learn more go to or talk to your doctor. being part of life's little moments i like what i'm seeing with latuda ask your doctor and sign up for copay savings at ♪ i'm a big kid now ♪ ♪ i'm a big kid now ♪ ♪ went from baby bottles to drinking from sippy cups ♪ ♪ went from wearing diapers to rocking these fresh pull-ups ♪ ♪ we're 50 million strong ♪
10:22 pm
♪ so put on your pull-ups and help us sing this song ♪ for you to reflect on homecomingyour servicepaceg ♪ and think about what comes next. i can't wait to hear your stories. and talk to you about where you see yourself in the years to come. does anyone have any questions i can answer? ♪ new listerine® ready! tabs™ aren't gum, mints, or marbles. seriously, what is this? if you guessed they're tabs that turn into liquid as you chew, so you can swish and clean your whole mouth instantly, then you were correct. and that was a really good guess. nice job. and back pain made it hard to sleep and get up on time. then i found aleve pm. the only one to combine a safe sleep aid, plus the 12 hour pain relieving strength of aleve.
10:23 pm
i'm back. aleve pm for a better am. ♪ jumping on a trampoline. ♪ flipping in the air. ♪ i never land just float there. ♪ ♪ ♪ i never feel so loved. ♪ la, la, la, la, la ♪ >> reporter: monday night in corning, new york, is poker
10:24 pm
night. greg and lucky miller host a high stakes game every week. complete with dinner, drinks, and dead presidents. >> this is where we play poker on monday evenings. every monday at 7:00. >> reporter: among the regular players, thomas clayton, also known as hockey puck. where did tom sit? >> tom sat here the last night that he played. and i would be the bank over here. >> was he good at poker? >> he was very good at poker. he was very lucky in the beginning at my house, for many, many months. finally, it kind of evened out after a while. >> reporter: still a good and aggressive player, but not on that night. >> he was not playing as many hands. he wasn't spunky that night. usually he jokes around. there was none of that. >> reporter: the game shuts down relatively early, about midnight. and the millers go to bed. at what point did you hear that there had been a tragedy at the clayton home?
10:25 pm
>> the next morning in the 6:00 range, there's someone knocking at the door. >> reporter: it's an officer with the sheriff's office. >> he says, "you were at a poker game last night?" i say, "yes." he says, "a guy that you know as hockey puck was here? tom clayton." i go, "yes, he was." then he says, "tom went home last night and found his wife murdered." it was like, "whew." >> reporter: what were you thinking? you hear that kelley was killed? >> i was numb. i think he talked to us and i didn't even know what they said. >> they started asking all kinds of questions about the poker game, and what time it ended, what time it starts, and what his mood was, what was he wearing. >> reporter: the millers corroborate their friend tom clayton's alibi, that he was at their home around the time of the murder. >> i said, "there's no way. there's no way could tom could do anything like this." i said, "there's no possible way." i said, "you're looking at the wrong guy." >> reporter: did you think the same thing as your husband? "no way?" >> absolutely. >> reporter: but then police hit paydirt when they find an
10:26 pm
eyewitness. tom and kelley clayton's 7-year-old daughter, charlie. >> she told me that "a man was hurting mommy." then she kept saying, "he did this and he did that. so finally i said, "how do you know it's a he?" and she said, "because his eyes look just like daddy's." and that was a chilling moment for me. >> reporter: a few hours later, sheriff jim allard brings charlie here. you are looking at different kind of interrogation room. still small, but soft seating. and on the table, toys. >> well, charlie, do you know why brought you here today? okay. we're gonna have to talk a little bit about last night, okay? >> reporter: in this video, obtained from authorities after it was played in court, charlie describes to investigators what she saw. >> you know what a truth and a lie is? what's a truth? >> it means it really happened and a lie is that it didn't happen. >> right. right, very good.
10:27 pm
so what happens if you tell a lie? >> you can get in trouble. >> establishing that the child knows right from wrong, knows the difference between a truth and a lie, knows that there's consequences to not telling the truth. >> reporter: then, in a matter-of-fact manner, unaware her mom has died, she offers details of the attack. >> in the middle of the night, this guy came and started hitting my mom with this pipe thingy. >> can you tell me more about that? >> there was blood everywhere. on my door, on the floor. not on the carpet though. >> what did you hear? >> like, my mom ran to the door screaming, "charlie, charlie, charlie, charlie." >> "run, charlie, run." those were the last words she heard from her mother. one of the most haunting things i've ever heard from a parent to a child. >> i saw the robber, like, hitting her until she was on the ground. she was sort of suffering. like, captured with a hockey
10:28 pm
stick. then i hugged her leg. >> reporter: charlie says after she saw the robber leave through the garage, she ran to her little brother's room to protect him. but most interesting to investigators is her physical description of the intruder. >> can you tell me what he looked like? >> like, he was wearing jeans, a black long-sleeved shirt and a mask. >> okay. what did the robber look like? >> he looked like my dad. >> and why do you say that? how did he look like your dad? >> the mask and his jeans. >> she said that he had on a mask like what daddy wears when he's hunting. >> how about the size of him? was he a big, big guy or was he a little guy? >> the size of my dad. >> i said, "well, is he fat like me, or is he thin?" and she said, "he's just like daddy." everything was just like daddy. every question i asked her
10:29 pm
related back to daddy. and then she looks at me. she goes, "but it couldn't have been daddy, because then who would take care of us?" >> did the robber say anything? >> he probably didn't say anything 'cause what if it was my daddy? we could recognize his voice. >> i observe no deceit in the statements she gave. i believe it was true in her mind when she told it. it was chilling. there was no emotions. i don't know if it was she was still in shock. it was just breaking my heart the entire time. >> reporter: the 7-year-old then turns the table on police, asking them a question. >> it's about my mom, but, like, where is she at? >> you know, we, you know, we need to find that out for you. >> that was not the time or place for her to learn that. she needed to be with family. >> reporter: it appears to police that charlie is pointing the finger at her own dad. but how could he be in two places at the same time? next, a new lead takes police in another direction.
10:30 pm
>> tom had to fire a couple guys from his work, from his job. >> reporter: a new man emerges. >> someone had an ax to grind with him. >> reporter: and a surveillance camera captures a glimpse of kelley clayton's killer. >> there was a lot more to this story. >> reporter: stay with us. whoa! (phone rings) daddy, mommy's on the phone! hi! how are you guys? at&t proudly offers wireless and tv discounts to military, veterans, first responders and their families. visit new olay foaming whip body wash. luxe lather, with a weightless feel, transforms skin from dull to dreamy. new olay foaming whip body wash. ♪seed to the oat, to the o, to the honey.♪
10:31 pm
♪sweet is all the good that we do.♪ ♪by scanning that box, good goes not stop.♪ ♪cause good goes around and around and around...♪ ♪good goes around and around. ♪hey! what sore muscles? what with advpounding head? .. advil is... relief that's fast. strength that lasts. you'll ask... what pain? with advil. ♪ ♪ ♪
10:32 pm
it deserves a moment... ...or two... ...or three. everyones favorite chicken pot pie. just one of the many crave-ably delicious meals from marie callender's. it's good mood food. ♪ childhood magic. we have a fragrance for that, new from glade®. sc johnson. and see disney's the nutcracker and the four realms. in theatres november 2. and see disney's the nutcracker and the four realms. it's "gaming with america's best internet provider" internet. just any internet. it's "all your teenagers streaming at once" internet. it's "i can get up to one-two-three-four-five
10:33 pm
mobile lines included" internet. it's internet from xfinity that makes your life... simple. easy. awesome. get a special offer on xfinity internet and tv for $35 each a month for 12 months when you bundle both, and ask how you can save on your wireless bill when you include xfinity mobile click, call or visit a store today. and i am a certified arborist for pg&e.ughes i oversee the patrolling of trees near power lines and roots near pipes and underground infrastructure. at pg&e wherever we work, we work hard to protect the environment. getting the job done safely, so we can keep the lights on for everybody. because i live here i have a deeper connection to the community. and i want to see the community grow and thrive. every year we work with cities and schools to plant trees in our communities. so the environment is there for my kids and future generations. together, we're building a better california.
10:34 pm
>> reporter: small town corning, new york, is in disbelief when just 24 hours after kelley clayton is found murdered, her husband is arrested, in part because of the statement given by the only eyewitness to the crime, his young daughter.
10:35 pm
>> more tonight on the murder in caton. tom clayton is in jail, suspe suspected of killing his wife. >> when tom was arrested, i was in shock, definitely, like everybody. >> reporter: had she ever indicated any aggression from him? >> never. >> people always think, we make an arrest, that's the end of the case. but the investigation continued. it was determined shortly after tom was arrested that there was a lot more to this story. >> reporter: kelley's family can't believe her husband could have done it. they point police to michael beard, clayton's longtime employee. >> if tom didn't have any work through servpro, he always had him up at the house doing stuff. cutting down wood or whatever. >> reporter: beard had recently been fired. could he be holding a grudge? >> there was an initial check at his residence just as a follow-up. he didn't know anything about
10:36 pm
anything and indicated that he had nothing to do with any part of this. >> reporter: investigators are stalled until they get a lucky break. remember lucky miller, who with her husband greg hosted that infamous poker game the night kelley was killed? she now recalls a strange request tom made that night. >> wait a minute, he asked to use my phone. and i look at the phone, i'm looking to see the past when he called and there's nothing. >> reporter: no evidence of a phone call? >> nothing. >> she's yelling at me and she's shaking like this. and i go, "then he deleted them." and she goes, "you can delete phone numbers?" >> who hides evidence? you only do it if you really have something to hide. >> reporter: the millers pull up their phone bill online. and, sure enough, at 10:53 p.m., a pair of calls to an unfamiliar number. >> lo and behold, that phone
10:37 pm
number comes back to michael beard. >> reporter: they question him again, this time bringing him here, the state police barracks, and put him in this hot seat. polygraph chair? >> polygraph chair. that's the same chair he was sitting in. >> reporter: how did he handle the polygraph? >> he denies all involvement in it. and he was deceitful. >> reporter: while michael beard, the hard-working handyman, is failing the polygraph test miserably, his live-in girlfriend holly barrett is speaking her truth. >> holly tells investigators that tom had offered michael $10,000 to basically burn his house down. >> my boss came into the interrogation with that information. said, "michael, we know about the $10,000." >> beard looks down and then he looks up, and he finally gives up the whole story as to what had happened, placing himself at the crime scene. he did it at the direction and request of thomas clayton. >> reporter: it is a surprising twist for investigators. beard making a full confession to murdering kelley clayton as another job for his boss.
10:38 pm
>> he didn't even get any money upfront. i mean, he was going to go do this on the promise from tom clayton that he'd be paid $10,000. >> reporter: in a transcript of his confession, beard reveals details of the plan, saying, "he wanted me to go to the house, kill kelly, then light the house on fire. he said the kids would be at her sister's house. there was also gas in the garage. he wanted the cars to burn also so that he could collect insurance money." when asked why, beard said, i needed the money. >> he said in his words that he got scared. >> reporter: stunningly, it appears to police that clayton had a secret plan he didn't reveal to beard. he was going to set the house on fire with kelley and the children in the house? >> that's correct. this is a cold-blooded
10:39 pm
attempt to remove your own wife and children from this earth. >> reporter: beard agrees to show police where he got rid of the murder weapon. >> he's driving 225 south, and throws it out the window. >> reporter: when day breaks, search times find this in a wooded area. what appears to be a yellow stick, but it's actually the handle of a sledgehammer. it seems like michael beard left a lot of bread crumbs around town. police are also able to locate keys to the clayton home tossed into this creek. and they recover michael beard's clothes from the night of the murder, dumped in this swampland. bloody clothes? >> yeah. they had blood on them. her blood. >> beard was then arrested for murder, and now the focus shifted from thomas clayton doing the crime himself.
10:40 pm
now it became a murder for hire. >> beard confesses to the murder, tells them where the murder weapon is, tells them where the bloody clothes are buried, but adds the critical detail, the reason he did it was because tom clayton offered him $10,000 to kill his wife. >> it was shocking to hear that there was another person involved in the murder of kelly clayton. we weren't expecting it at all. >> reporter: so your sister has been brutally murdered, and now your brother-in-law is being charged. how did you even begin to fathom this? >> you can't. so, this person who you stood up for to marry your sister, is, now you find out, a monster, a sociopath. the fact that he planned and calculated this entire plot to have my sister killed made it 100 times worse. >> reporter: next, thomas
10:41 pm
clayton and his handyman face off in court. then one makes a stunning move that threatens to derail the entire case. >> this case really became all circumstantial. >> and now they have a mess. >> reporter: stay with us. ♪ no one gonna hold you like i do ♪ dare to be devoted. jared. makeup now optional.
10:42 pm
new aveeno® maxglow™ infusion drops with kiwi to lock moisture. and soy to even skin tone. unleash dewy, glowing skin from within. new aveeno® maxglow™. iyou may be at increased riskf for pneumococcal pneumonia -a potentially serious bacterial lung disease that can disrupt your routine for weeks. in severe cases, pneumococcal pneumonia can put you in the hospital. it can hit quickly, without warning, making you miss out on what matters most. a single dose of the prevnar 13® vaccine can help protect you from pneumococcal pneumonia. prevnar 13® is approved for adults to help prevent infections from 13 strains of the bacteria
10:43 pm
that cause pneumococcal pneumonia. don't get prevnar 13® if you have had a severe allergic reaction to the vaccine or its ingredients. adults with weakened immune systems may have a lower response to the vaccine. the most common side effects were pain, redness and swelling at the injection site, limited arm movement, fatigue, headache, muscle pain, joint pain, less appetite, vomiting, fever, chills, and rash. prevention begins with prevnar 13®. ask your doctor or pharmacist about prevnar 13®. i'm always going to be a maker. and i think a company is the coolest thing you can build. i'm adam, and i make robots. you never know when inspiration is going to strike. so i take my surface pro everywhere. part of an entrepreneur's job is to get stuff done. i like to do, like, four things at once. the new surface pro can handle all of my programs. i can paint, i can mold, i can code. i have it on all the time, it's fantastic. we get to build toys for kids and change the world. it's a big deal.
10:44 pm
10:45 pm
>> reporter: there is a new color taking center stage in kelley clayton's home town. purple ribbons now dotting the community, a poignant reminder of the young woman's murder. >> the purple ribbon represents domestic violence awareness. so, the more and more we saw that around town, the more and
10:46 pm
more we thought that this was a case of domestic violence. >> they will see purple ribbons, and they'll say, "oh, purple for mama, purple for mama." everywhere we go, "look, that's for mama." >> reporter: but no ribbon more prominent than this one, on the arena marquee of thomas clayton's former hockey team. only one man in town seems upset at the outpouring of support -- thomas clayton, now out on bail. >> he calls me. he did not mention losing his wife and the situation with his children. what he had mentioned to me was that jail sucks, and how can we put that ribbon up on our building? at no point did he seem like a grieving husband. >> reporter: especially since he continues his now all too familiar trips to area casinos. >> that's where he spent the entire time he was out on bail, was going from casino to casino.
10:47 pm
>> reporter: and who does he run into -- his poker friends greg and lucky miller. >> he was, like, screaming, "lucky!" and i turned around and he was, like, arms out. i'm, like -- >> reporter: what did you do? >> i'm like, "hi." and he's, like, "hi, lucky. i'm so sorry. i'm so sorry." he goes, "i didn't do it." >> reporter: were you frightened at all? >> i was terrified. here, i thought i was getting away, out of town. >> reporter: more than a year after kelley clayton's murder, her accused killer, michael beard, is finally on trial. >> opening statements began in the murder trial of michael beard. >> reporter: in a shocking about-face, he takes the stand and makes a stunning declaration. >> michael beard recants his confession and offers up a bizarre scenario about what he says really happened. that, yes, he was at the scene, but he was there to burn down the house for insurance money,
10:48 pm
and that the killer, the real killer, was actually there, and he saw him. >> reporter: beard now makes an outlandish claim -- that kelley is already dead when he walks in the house. and just like 7-year-old charlie, he sees a man who looks like thomas clayton. >> he then hands you the weapon. you run out the door. you dispose of the weapon. like, you have got to be kidding me. >> even though michael beard had changed his story, the prosecution still had hard evidence against him. they found kelley's blood on his clothes. he led them to the murder weapon. and his dna was found inside the clayton home. >> reporter: after a ten-day trial, beard is found guilty of murder. >> we got it. >> with beard's confession, prosecutors are thinking, "we've got an airtight case here." then he recants, and now they've got a mess. >> reporter: remember, beard would have been the star witness.
10:49 pm
the only one directly linking clayton to the murder, says special prosecutor weeden wetmore. >> this case really became all circumstantial. we don't have a smoking gun. we have to build our case piece by piece. >> the man accused of killing his wife back in september appeared in court. >> the courtroom was packed every day. the biggest story in our area for a while. >> tom was cool, calm and collected every day when he walked into court. you would never realize that he was on trial for his wife's murder. >> reporter: that could be because clayton knows the case against him isn't a slam dunk. but prosecutors believe they have an ace up their sleeve. this man, sy ray of zetx corporation, a former police officer who mapped their cell phone movements. >> were able to show that beard and clayton were together at certain points when they shouldn't have been, unless one looks at the homicide, and then it becomes all clear. >> reporter: most telling, a pair of phone calls made on the
10:50 pm
day kelley was killed. the first from a used car lot. >> there was an incoming call to michael beard from m&m auto. m&m auto has never called michael beard before. >> reporter: it isn't the dealership calling. it's actually clayton. >> we can actually put his device in the parking lot of m&m auto when this call was made. >> reporter: and then, hours later, clayton makes a second call to beard from someone else's phone. yup, lucky miller's, at that poker game. >> that was the go call. and that immediately sets things into motion. >> beard shortly after that phone call drove out to clayton's home and committed the murder. >> we were able to use the records and show the two parties coming together, separating, conversations between the two of them, and lay out the conspiracy to commit the murder, leading up to it. >> there was no evidence into the content of those calls and
10:51 pm
sy ray's testimony was skewed in trying to make much more of those calls. >> it's a pattern that clearly shows michael beard and thomas clayton did this together. >> reporter: but what remains missing is motive. why would thomas clayton want his wife dead? what did you begin to learn about your brother-in-law th ♪ the new capital one savor card. earn 4% cash back on dining and 4% on entertainment.
10:52 pm
now when you go out, you cash in. what's in your wallet? now when you go out, you cash in. (mom) ooh, what is it? (boy)(man) whoa whoa whoa.what we got. (woman) hey portal, call lauren. (mom) ahh! (woman) wait, it's moving. (man) you mean if i go over here, camera follows me doesn't it? (woman) you can see up here, right? (man) run past it like quick. (woman) i see you. (boy) meow meow meow. (man) meow meow meow. (man) hey casey... it was nice to see you today. love loud... love le vian. from the world's only chocolate diamonds... to gemstones bursting with color. no one colors your world like le vian. and nobody sells more le vian than kay. how's your cough? i'm good. i took 12-hour mucinex and sent it far away. hey buddy, have you seen a nice woman with a cough?
10:53 pm
woahhh! mucinex dm releases fast and lasts 12-hours, not 4. send coughs far away all day. ♪ ♪♪ ♪♪ it only takes a second for an everyday item to become dangerous. tide pods child guard pack helps keep your laundry pacs safe and your child safer. to close, twist until it clicks. tide pods child guard packaging. theat the risk of ruininguld retheir thank you. is the same type of person who can help you quickly and easily get an appraisal on your car, because helping people is what carmax people are all about. ♪ darling, tell me all the ways, tell me all the ways ♪
10:54 pm
♪ all the ways get gifts in a snap with free two day shipping at target. witness testimony continues today in thomas clayton's murder trial. >> it was a long and in-depth trial. there was more than 75 witnesses, hundreds of pieces of evidence against thomas clayton. >> the question remained, why? even if there's all this evidence linking clayton to beard and potentially to the crime, what was the motive? >> this was a shock for everyone. >> testimony from one of the women who claims to have had an affair with thomas clayton. >> the women, the multiple affairs that he was having right under kelley's nose. my nose. i never heard of an affair, ever. >> up until that moment we thought that tom and kelley had this loving, almost perfect
10:55 pm
relationship. and here we find out he was cheating on his wife, even telling some of them that kelley was a -- >> he had mentioned to me that divorce was never going to be a possibility because she would take him to the cleaners, his words. >> the question was, did he do this crime? >> reporter: but prosecutors present no evidence of any cash payments made by clayton to beard in a murder-for-hire scheme. >> there's no direct proof that tom clayton engaged in a plot with beard to kill kelley. there was no record of any payment. there was no record of any agreement to pay. >> reporter: the trial spans over seven weeks, and now the former hockey player's fate is in the hands of the jury. >> in my mind, it could have gone either way. >> reporter: after only six hours of deliberation, a verdict. >> we broke into programming immediately. >> breaking news out of steuben
10:56 pm
county court. thomas clayton, guilty on both first degree and second degree murder charges. >> there was a tremendous amount of emotion in that courtroom. we obviously were ecstatic with the outcome, because we felt we had accomplished justice. >> i truly believe that this is one of those rare moments. and i emphasize rare, where the jury got it wrong. >> we did it! we did it. >> reporter: family members immediately broke out in tears and in cheers, and left the courtroom extremely happy, but still emotional. >> i told my sister from the night she was murdered that we would not stop fighting for her, we would not stop fighting for justice for her. >> it's been a long haul and i'm sorry for his family. i'm sorry for all of us. no one won in this. no one did. >> this case was a puzzle, and they put together the pieces in a way that was convincing beyond a reasonable doubt. >> reporter: at his sentencing, thomas clayton is given life without parole.
10:57 pm
>> he was very angry. he gave a very long, profanity-laced statement saying that michael beard was the perpetrator and that he was innocent. >> first and foremost, i'm extremely proud and honored to call thomas my son. >> reporter: did the children want to say anything to their father? >> charlie actually wrote a letter on her own. that she loved her mom. she loved her dad. but that her dad was a coward because he made michael beard kill mommy. >> reporter: was michael beard a victim of thomas clayton? >> i believe that thomas clayton was a white privileged man. he used michael beard. michael beard would do just about anything for money for his family. >> reporter: along with kelley's
10:58 pm
family, so many lives in this small community, now forever changed. do you still play poker here? >> no, we haven't played poker here since that evening. we don't play here anymore. >> reporter: so not the same anymore, huh? >> correct. >> reporter: so this table is basically closed? >> done. >> as tragic as this was, to hear such a loved member of the community was murdered, at the end of the day, there was two kids without their mother and their father, taken away from them. >> kelley spent a lot of time here. and kelley would also bring her children here. >> reporter: kim and her mom take me to this treasured bench placed in a local park in kelley's memory. >> i feel comfort when i come here. >> cullen calls it "my mommy's bench." >> yeah. "my mom's bench." >> reporter: as you raise them, what do you want them to know most about their mother? >> her unconditional, unmeasurable love that she had for them.
10:59 pm
i want them to know that she fought to her last breath to save their life. >> so powerful, that mother's sacrifice. thomas clayton has just filed an appeal, and michael beard tells us he's going to do so as well. >> that's our program for tonight on "20/20." thanks to deborah and thanks for watching. i'm david muir. >> and i'm amy robach. for all of us at abc news and "20/20," good night.
11:00 pm
is pg&e responsible for sparking the deadly camp fire? sparking the deadly camp fire? >> the new it is hard to find your footing, sparking the deadly camp fire? >> the new so you need people that you're close to... to help guide you. i think about how important it was for me to have the role models i've had. oh, look at that! i wasn't able to get there alone. he essentially plucked me out of obscurity. he's the one who said, "hey man, this is your life, this is what you need to do." nobody can do it alone. the more help you can get along the way, the faster you can achieve your goals. i'm in it to fly. help people achieve their dreams. speak for those who can not. whatever you're in it for... ...we're in it together. ♪ ♪


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on