tv All In With Chris Hayes MSNBC September 20, 2013 5:00pm-6:01pm PDT
this country takes a hit the week after next. every time the government fails, the haters of government can't wait to globe right with satisfaction and that's "hardball" for now. thanks for being with us. all in with chris hayes starts right now. good evening from washington. i'm ezra cline in for the uncanny chris hayes. tonight, the absolute train wreck that has become the 113th congress on track to be the worst performing, maybe the worst behaving, definitely the least productive in history. also tonight, there is one huge problem with the republican plan to stop obama care. it won't actually stop obama care. and i'll tell you why the plan might make it a little bit stronger. plus, putting faces on some of the people who will feel the pain of republican cuts to food stamps. those stories are ahead, but we begin where we have to begin with the big news out of the
house of representatives where republicans just passed a bill to fund the government. it also defunds obama care. that means it's a bill to shut down the federal government. >> and so, our message to the united states senate is real simple. the american people don't want the government shutdown and they don't want obama care. the house has listened to the american people. now, it's time for the senate to listen as well. >> senate democrats to do the same thing. and i want to know where senator prior stands on protecting the middle class. the consequences of this horrific bill. how about kay hagen in north carolina? does she understand the consequences that obama care is having in her state? what about mary lan dree of
louisiana? >> republican congress want to stop the country to deny the people the chance to see a doctor. how many times are we going to do this? >> it is a wolf in wolf's clothing. the underlying bill to shut down government is reason enough to object to it. and you know what that's about? that's simply about putting their friends, the insurance companies, back in charge of medical decisions for your families. either you don't know what you are doing or this is one of the most intentional acts of brutality that you have cooked up with stiff competition for that honor. >> 230 and nays are 189. the joint resolution has passed. is laid on the table. >> speaker john boehner does not want to shut down the
government. he has spent the last couple of months trying, begging his members, to figure out a way around passing a bill to defund obama care and shut down the federal government. he would have been open to one that didn't mention obama care at all. they tried to put one on the floor that just held another vote on defunding obama care. he did not want this. he does not want republicans to shut the government down and make everybody hate them. but as often happens these days, house republicans did not listen to john boehner and so john boehner, rather than fight his members, spent this morning passing a funding bill that defunded obama care and a straight face speaker boehner said this. >> we have a victory today for the american people. also a victory for common sense. >> yeah. >> senator baucus said it right when he said this law is a train wreck and it is a train wreck.
>> yeah, great victory that i think is a huge strategic error, that kind of victory. let's talk about train wrecks for a minute. obama care begins open enrollment on october 1st, so soon. it begins delivering health insurance on january 1st. whether it's a train wreck remains to be seen. it hasn't even started yet. but here's what we can say. under the leadership of john boehner, the 113th congress and the house of representatives in particular is a complete and total train wreck. begin with the simplest question, what have they done on behalf of the american people? the senate passed immigration with a broad bill. the house's effort has completely fallen apart. the senate passed a farm bill. the house failed at that. has been breaking their farm bill into little pieces and trying to pass it one at a time. the senate passed a budget for the two chambers could bring
their budget together, come to a budget compromise for the country. the house passed a budget and refused to go to that conference with the is that the because it was scared of what might happen. gun control was a total flop. the appropriations process has completely broken down. we almost went over the fiscal cliff when john boehner's plan b failed. sequestration which boehner once calleded devastating is now the law of the land and will be. the r federal reserve, ben bernanke, cannot pursue the policies it thinks make sense because it is scared. ben bernanke just said this the other day. that congress will drive the economy into a ditch, so the fed needs to support the economy. the data tells the same story. so far, the 113th congress has passed 36 public laws. for comparison, the 112th congress passed 283. at this rate, the 113th congress
is on track to be by far the least productive congress on record. by far. boehner however, to be fair to him, says he rejects those metrics. he said we should not be judged on how many new laws we create. we ought to be judged on how many laws we repeal. through conservative comment. so how many laws has john boehner appealed? none. he tried to repeal obama care a number of time, he hasn't managed to appeal any other major laws, not gone after medicare or social security or anything, but perhaps the american people just enjoy this kind of gridlock. perhaps they hate congressional productivity. they love the status quo. they think things are going so great in this country right now, nothing congress could possibly do to make it better. perhaps they want nothing done and nothing undone. if that is the case, then they have a funny way of rewarding success. americans have never had less confidence in congress than they do right now. heck of a job, guys.
in fact, as unpopular as obama care is, congress is even more unpopular and it is getting worse. there was today's debacle, where boehner buckled to conservatives in his conference, but more disturbing, part of his strategy to avoid a government shutdown is to convince his members they should hold their fire for a quote whale of a fight over raising the debt ceiling. that moves the conflict to a more dangerous theatre. one that could result in a complete global financial crisis. for all the press it gets, his threat of a shutdown is far less responsible than the threat of a default. this isn't all boehner's fault. he's getting outflanked by media savvy hard line conservatives. some of it is boehner's fault. many of his members don't trust him. refuses to level to republicans ant what's possible for them to achieve. he refused to go around them by cutting deals with the democrats
on issues where there could with agreement. like immigration, the government funding bill. he's promoting a debt ceiling fight that could have zis rouse consequences and speaker boehner is ultimately the guy in charge of the worst performing congresses' in history. if he is looking for a train wreck to fix, he might be getting closer to home. joining me now, democrat from kii kentucky and member of the house budget committee and jim cooper, democrat from tennessee. there will be, do you think there will be a shutdown? >> i've been saying for weeks i thought there would be a shutdown. by the way, i was ready to walk out when you started talking about congress' popularity. oh, my gosh, why do you even want us on? i've been saying for weeks, i think there will be. unless speaker boehner realizes and commits himself to being the speaker of the house for the entire country, not just for the
republican party, we're not trying to pass everything on only republican votes, we're never going to get to a place where the house will pass something that the senate will accept and the president will sign. that's just the absolute facts of the situation and really doesn't matter what the issue is. he has to have democratic support in the house. he has to be willing to pass legislature with a smaller number of republicans than 218 and then do something that not only works, but can pass both houses and signed by the president and so far, he hasn't been willing to do that. except in a couple of instances, he has. he needs to go back and visit the sandy relief bill and some other things that have been done where he allowed things to go to the floor with less than a majority of his own confidence. >> i'm curious if you agree on one, if there will be a government shutdown. a cell burning thought, but two, if there is, or if there's not, the thing that scares me is the
idea we would not pay our bills because that would be a financial crisis and speaker boehner has said he will demand significant concessions to try to raise the debt ceiling. one, do you think there will be a shutdown and two, a breach? >> we're getting closer than we probably have in history, at least since gingrich shut down the government in the '90s. this is a real tragedy for america. this isn't regular political bickering. this is genuinely dangerous for america. it risks long-term damage to our country. damage that we could not undo. it's like boehner's playing with dynamite right now with government shutdown, but he's thinking of playing with nitroglycerin, thinking of defaulting on america's debt. he's got to be stopped. >> congressman yarmouth, one of the things i think is interesting about this is that boehner didn't want it. he did not want this bill to go forward.
not the approach he wanted to take. the 200 democrats in the house didn't want it. not many who want this approach. you said it earlier that speaker boehner needs to work with democrats to get things passed, but the thing that seems surprising is he doesn't seem to have the namty from both members. you have to trust me doing this kind of approach. shutting down the government is just not a good idea. >> politics of america, certainly on the republican side, has become very entrepreneurial. this is individual members out for themselves dealing with their own districts. people have said this is about 40 idea logs wag iging the, bei the tail wagging the dog. it's really not. it's 40 idea logs and about 140 other republicans who are afraid of being replaced by those. that's the dynamic speaker boehner's working with. again, there are 50, 60, maybe at most republicans who are very
thoughtful, reasonable people who are willing to compromise, willing to understand that government is about the possible and not idealism all the time. that's what speaker boehner has to do. he's not been willing to crack the whip. if you want funding, if you want me to come to your district, you've got to play ball and you've got to do something that works for the country. nancy pelosi would never ever have allowed this kind of ranger in her own congress. >> i often wonder what nancy pelosi is thinking. i often wonder. but congressman cooper, one thing i wanted the ask you, one thing that is being missed here in this whole discussion about obama care is that this continuing resolution represents entrenchment of sequestration and keeps it as those levels. can you say a word about what
this represents on funding, putting obama care aside. >> sequestration is like a stupidist diet in the world and why we're still on it, it doesn't make sense. it's crippling our military, other important parts of government. these cuts are irrational. we at least need flexibility and we need to remove the cuts in a sensible way and have more sensible budgeting, but as john and you have pointed out, now that the senate has passed the budget, the house refuses to talk to the senate about having a real budget for america. it's not enough to have a budget for the senate and house, we have to have a budget for america. "wall street journal" has said they're acting like kama pilots. it's even putting fear in the heart of ben bernanke. we've got to have better management for america.
because this is reaching the crisis point. >> congressman john yarmouth and cooper, thank you very much for being here tonight. >> thank you. and with me, debbie stabenow. you heard that and sitting from your lofty perch from the u.s. senate, how does it look to you? what's going to happen when this resolution comes into your chamber? >> i share the concern of my house colleagues. particularly this week rather than it getting better, it's really gotten worse. it really is about a group of folks who are anarchists who just want to shut our government down. we look at global economy where everybody else is is trying to be like america. have a middle class like us. outcome pete us on education, invasion, and instead of moving forward with everybody working together to continue to improve on the economy and grow the middle class, they're taking us
backwards. way back. it's like they're running towards a third world country while everybody is trying to be like us. it's a waste of time and money. i don't blame people for being sick and tired of it. in the senate, i have to say, we have seen something different happening. as you have mentioned. immigration. a farm bill. you know, if they want to cut spending, pass a farm bill. $24 billion in deficit reduction added by the way, to about 237b9 $5 trillion and deficit reduction. we have already put in place over the next ten years, so when they talk about they should do something about the deficit, we're already doing something about the deficit and if they would work with us and stop this crazy sequester and focus on outinnovating and outeducating in a global economy, we could do even more. >> also repeal obama care, that increases the deficit.
but senator ted cruz, one of the thipgs happening here, a lot of pressure, too, coming from your chamber, forcing the senator, mike lee, senator rand paul, they're going to try to do what rand paul did on the drone. go to the floor of the -- are senate democrats prepared for that? >> filibustering is not a new thing. and if they decide to do that, then it will be up to us to close debate and we will need 60 votes. we have colleagues that have spoken out. responsible republicans in the senate who have said this is crazy and we're going to count on them to join us because think about for a minute, this whole issue on repealing health care
reform. they want to stop over 30 million people from getting health care. women who are pregnant from having access to maternity care. starting in january for the first time ever, you're going to be able to know that essential health care benefits includes prenatal care and maternity care. this is not some radical thing. they're talking about taking away the opportunity for small businesses to be able to have lower costs through competition and people to have access to health care and that's a fight worth having. >> thank you so much for being here tonight. >> my pleasure. >> what's the real reason republicans want obama care to fail? i will tell you coming up. pref. but when it comes to investing, i just think it's better to work with someone. someone you feel you can really partner with. unfortunately, i've found that some brokerage firms don't always encourage that kind of relationship. that's why i stopped working at the old brokerage,
and started working for charles schwab. avo: what kind of financial consultant are you looking for? talk to us today. [ crashing ] [ male announcer ] when your favorite food starts a fight, fight back fast with tums. heartburn relief that neutralizes acid on contact and goes to work in seconds. ♪ tum, tum tum tum tums!
but tracking all the action and hearing everything from our marketing partners, the media and millions of fans on social media can be a challenge. that's why we partnered with hp to build the new nascar fan and media engagement center. hp's technology helps us turn millions of tweets, posts and stories into real-time business insights that help nascar win with our fans. [ engine revs, tires squeal ] [ male announcer ] since we began, mercedes-benz has pioneered many breakthroughs. ♪ breakthroughs in design... breakthroughs in safety... in engineering... and technology. and now our latest creation breaks one more barrier. introducing the cla. starting at $29,900. ♪
there's a kind of a cold logic, a real reason behind the willingness some conservatives have to risk everything to stop obama care. but the logic isn't based on what you usually hear. it's not the notion that obama care will fail. after all, if the logic's going to be a total debacle, republicans would let it take effect. ride it out, come back, use their massive majorities to repeal it, but they don't want to do that. because the gop's fear is not that the law will fail. it's that the law will succeed. that once obama care starts
delivering health insurance to millions of americans, it will become impossible to repeal. that's what's happened in every other country. it's what happened with medicare and medicaid and social security. it's why the right needs to sop it before it begins, but the irony of this strategy is that shutting down or defunding the federal government doesn't stop obama care. it might even help it. the nonpartisan research service put it bluntly saying quote, it appears that substantial limitation might continue during a lax in annual appropriations. there are a few reasons for this. first thing, if there is a shutdown, disruption in funding, it only hits one part money. it hits so-called discretionary money. that's the part of the budget decided on by congress. but obama care's main function, they're in the more permanent part. so, for example, the money for
tax credits, that money's uneffective. it arrives on schedule. the state and federal exchange, they still operate. the mandate would still be in place. of the lost funding that's affected, it could be fielded by the obama administration moving money from these mandatory pots into these other pieces and the white house could argue that a lot of the crucial positions fall into the bucket of essential personnel who are protected during the shutdown. so, it wouldn't be ideal. implementation would move forward and it could get worse for republicans from there. obama care is first year, the it's just going to be full of glitches and hiccups and mistakes. things are going to go wrong. big things. that's just true for every big and complicated law. when john boehner was first made minority leader in 2006, he was asked about the implementation of medicare part d, which he and his colleagues just passed.
he said, quote, the implementation of the medicare plan has been horrendous. now, the expectation for obama care, republicans are going to be able to take advantage of the problems. they'll use them to argue the bill is terrible, ha americans need to elect them in midterms and maybe they'll win a few more seats because of it, but if it's happening during an extended government shutdown, republicans might well get blamed for the glitches as in the media. would it have gone more smoothly if the gop hadn't turned out the lights on the government that was supposed to be putting it in place. if the republicans get blamed for an annoying government shutdown, that might bump the gains in t midterms and more midterms in congress, means more protection for obama care going forward.
it might mean republicans get blamed for some of the problems of implementation and it might mean the they did okay in the rollout. won't yield against obama care. might ultimately prove to be among the laws of best friends. since the day you met. but your erectile dysfunction - it could be a question of blood flow. cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be ready anytime the moment's right. you can be more confident in your ability to be ready. and the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph like needing to go frequently or urgently. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medications, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sexual activity. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than 4 hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision,
or if you have any allergic reactions such as rash, hives, swelling of the lips, tongue or throat, or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a 30-tablet free trial. how can i be a more fun mom? hmmm. can you dance? ♪ bum ba bum ba bum ♪ bum ba bum ba bum no. no? can you make campbell's chicken noodle soup? yes! [ wisest kid ] every can has 32 feet of slurpable noodles. now that's fun. mom, you're awesome. oh yeah! ♪ bum ba bum ba bum [ gong ] [ wisest kid ] m'm! m'm! good!
ted cruz, those stories are ahead, but first, i want to show you the awesomest things on the internet today. this is be girl tara. she is 6 years old, from the u.k. and way cooler than you or at least way cooler than me. now, i could tell you she has millions of views on youtube, but she's part of a dance team with her 9-year-old sister or that she schooled her competition or toured as a professional dance crew. i could tell you all that, but wouldn't you rather just watch her bust out those moves? the second, toys will be old outdated toys. 1980s brought us classic action figures like he man and transformers, but the me decade also laid his fair share of duds. a list of 15 toy lines from the
'80s that are never going to compete. like the rock lords. a spin off from the already lame go bots line or the food botts. like sergeant scoop and private pizza. also, the barnyard commandos and these. >> police academy. >> numb skull's robbing the bank. >> each sold separately. >> total shocker kids weren't clambering for a steve gutten berg action figure. then a moon dreamer. the third awesomest thing on the internet today, the television crossover everyone demanded. if you've been watching "sesame street," it could use a little more ""game of thronegame "game"
♪ whatever simon says ♪ they just say simon says and that's the cue ♪ also showed up on a recent episode. "sesame street" has always been pretty hip. but the current guest roster is really growing. john cho is playing around with the muppets this week as was charlize theron. they may not be as cool as be girl tara, but still pretty cool. you can find all the links for tonight's click 3 on our website and we will be right back. [ male announcer ] when it comes to doing what you love,
more is better. that's why we designed the all-new nissan versa note, with more technology, to get you into, and out of, tight spots. and more space so that you always have your favorite stuff. and just for good measure, an incredibly efficient 40 mpg highway. so that when you're doing more, you're spending less. the all-new nissan versa note. your door to more. ♪ "i" formation! "i" formation!
we have got to get the three-technique block! i'm not angry. i'm not yellin'. nobody's tackling anybody! we got absolutely... i don't think this was such a good idea. i'm on it. if we can't secure the quarterback center exchange... you're doing a great job, coach. well they're coming along better than i anticipated. very pleased. who told you to take a break? [ male announcer ] want to win your own football fantasy? just tell us. then use your visa card for a chance to win it. diarrhea, gas, bloating? yes! one phillips' colon health probiotic cap each day helps defend against these digestive issues... with three strains of good bacteria. [ phillips' lady ] live the regular life. phillips'.
requirement, in a very high unemployment year, why should that person not get 100 bucks a month from the government? >> what this does is maybe the dead person should get the 100 bucks a month. the lottery winner. >> you need to throw off 4 million people. >> the dead people are the people you're getting rid of. >> dead people are not actually catching those checks. >> i can't believe these things, man. that was chris speaking last night about the house's food stamp vote. if you're going to believe the rhetoric out there from some conservatives, food stamps are for the entitled, possibly dead moochers trying to rip off the government. plus, got a 40 billioncut yesterday. the reality is quite different. food stamps play just a huge role in helping actual living
americans out of poverty. it keeps about 4 million people above the poverty line. prevents millions more from sinking deeper into poverty. 15% of the population are getting help from food stamps each month. children and teenagers make up almost half of that number. children and teenagers. about 10% are are seniors. and the average benefit is only about $133 a month. to quality, you could only have earnings 30% higher than the federal poverty level. $30,000 for a family of four. but those are by the way not lottery winners, but none of those stopped house republicans from slashing $40 billion from the food stamp program over the next decade. it doesn't hurt shady lottery winners or the dead, but kids and the elderly, disabled, low wage workers and members of our
military. a post on a blog made rounds today. my name is jason. i'm a 35-year-old white combat veteran. i'm on food stamps. he's worked his entire life and is now on food stamps. it is what is keeping him from going hungry. he isn't alone. military families alone redeem about $100 million in food aid. millions of people in poverty fall into three categories. you can call them the lucky category, since conservatives seem to think people on welfare hit some sort of jackpot. those living paycheck to paycheck, they're just a little bit lucky. those living unemployment check to unemployment check, but those living second of the month to second of the month, food stamp group, they have hit the jackpot. the second of the month being the time when funds get deposited on to the ebt card, at least in new york. for those who have never been
fortunate enough to hit the power ball. joining me now is kayla williams, author of leadoff my rifle more than you. young and female in the u.s. ar army. >> i was on them out of and on when i was a kid. my mom was like so many others, among whom take advantage of the benefit, single mom and well fell on financial hard times and it kept me from going to bed hungry. >> did you find the allotment was lavish. it created a real huge food budget? >> no. it didn't. supplemented by some lovely government cheese. sometimes, we had jalapeno flavored cheese, so that was exciting. but not a lavish benefit and something that was something to be ashamed of and that stigma i think is another thing that's really difficult. it seems as if the republicans want that shame and stigma, but is that something we want to do to children, to make them ashamed of their parents?
doesn't seem like good family values to me. >> in the bush administration was real supportive of the program. part of moving it towards on ebt cards. instead of getting this recognizable sort of voucher, you have what h looks like a credit card. very helpful. there's now a pushback. just gone way, way, way too far. what do you think about some of that transition away from that stigma? hue do you think that affects folks? >> i think that is a good thing. you have for example, military personnel and guarded reserve personnel having a harder time keeping their jobs between deployments, discrimination and these are people we want to hold up as heroes in our society. do we want to make them feel ashamed for needing an extra helping hand? no, we don't. if they're having trouble, we don't need to make them feel ashamed of needing a little extra helping hand. these are people who served
honor bly and with pride. any kid doesn't need to have that stigma of feeling like there's something wrong with them. to bring that back today is a move in the wrong direction. >> has there been a sharp rise in use of food stamps in the military after 9/11? >> not necessarily among active duty. they've gotten pretty significant pay increases over that time. but use of snap benefits in commissaries have gone up and people who can use commissaries, also retirees and again, guard and vefr personnel. >> when you actually get into these debates, you have a $40 billion cut in house of representatives yesterday. one you don't hear from are veterans lobbies. but don't seem to engage that. any thoughts as to why? >> i don't. but i'm trying to change that. why i'm here speaking with you
right now. >> where do you think this goes from now? the senate probably is going to pick it up. do you think that the changing is impressions of who's on food stamps as your colleague did today, as you are doing, do you think that is part of this political battle? >> i hope that it will be. i hope that more people like me, who have been on food assistance at some point in their lives will come forward and say you're talking about people like me. you're saying that kids like i was should go to bed hungry. is that the kind of country we are? if you don't believe that's the kind of country we should be, you need to call your elected representatives and let them know that this is not the type of place where we left children go to the hungry. >> coming up, i will tell you why a very small part of me, sometimes, a very big part of me, feels sorry for john boehner. (vo) you are a business pro.
(vo) meee-ow, business pro. meee-ow. go national. go like a pro. always go the extra mile. to treat my low testosterone, i did my research. my doctor and i went with axiron, the only underarm low t treatment. axiron can restore t levels to normal in about 2 weeks in most men. axiron is not for use in women or anyone younger than 18 or men with prostate or breast cancer. women, especially those who are or who may become pregnant and children should avoid contact where axiron is applied as unexpected signs of puberty in children or changes in body hair or increased acne in women may occur. report these symptoms to your doctor. tell your doctor about all medical conditions and medications. serious side effects could include increased risk of prostate cancer; worsening prostate symptoms;
decreased sperm count; ankle, feet or body swelling; enlarged or painful breasts; problems breathing while sleeping; and blood clots in the legs. common side effects include skin redness or irritation where applied, increased red blood cell count, headache, diarrhea, vomiting, and increase in psa. ask your doctor about the only underarm low t treatment, axiron. like carpools... polly wants to know if we can pick her up. yeah, we can make room. yeah. [ male announcer ] ...office space. yes, we're loving this communal seating. it's great. [ male announcer ] the best thing to share? a data plan. at&t mobile share for business. one bucket of data for everyone on the plan, unlimited talk and text on smart phones. now, everyone's in the spirit of sharing. hey, can i borrow your boat this weekend? no. [ male announcer ] share more. save more. at&t mobile share for business. ♪ in communities like chicagoness. we're coming together with the city and military veterans for the coca-cola foundations
troops for fitness an innovative program that's inspiring hundreds of people with fun ways to move a little more stay active and to see how good a little balance can feel part of our goal is to inspire more than 3 million people to rediscover the joy of being active this summer. see the difference all of us can make... together! there's been a lot of talk about the irresponsibility of ted cruz in pushing to shut down the government if the obama administration doesn't do the defund. talk on this network, even some of it by me. that is an irresponsible thing to do and maybe kind of counterproductive and maybe going to be a huge disaster, but during that, john boehner is the
adult in the room. failing maybe, but at least trying. but part of the way boehner is trying to get out of this shutdown is by telling his members, you don't want to waste your time shutting down the government. what you want to do is hold your fire until the obama administration, less they delay obama care for a year, you won't raise the debt ceiling. that is john boehner's plan. no government shutdown right now, but a huge debt ceiling fight very soon. president obama called john boehner tonight saying i'm still not going to negotiate with you. that is more irresponsible than what ted cruz has cooked up. you shut down the federal government, it's bad for the economy, bad for people who rely on government services, but you'll be fine once you reopen. you reach the debt ceiling and you cause a global financial panic and it won't be fine when you start paying your bills again. that doesn't just go away. boehner's got a hard job. his members don't listen to him.
he just picked up a primary challenger the other day, but he makes his job harder and more dangero dangerous. the question is why. why and how does he get out of it? joining me now, publisher of the new federalist, a web magazine and senior fellow at the heartland institute. david weigel, he was at the vote today and heather, chief economist at the center for american progress of progressive think tank. so, there are two kind of beats here. boehner's, somebody's got a shutdown and he is amping up the debt ceiling talk. so when you speak defaults in the conservative movement or to house republicans, what do they see as the likely solution here? the good vision of the future? >> the good vision of the future? i think you've played this out in a way to say that all of this talk along that he was this
crazy guy, and boehner was this voice of seriousness, neither is really the case. both are points of inflection. both are points of leverage that the republican party is is seeking to find in order to force president obama to come to the negotiating table. he has been enormously reluctant to do. particularly -- >> wasn't it boehner who said at the beginning of this congress, no more negotiations wean him and president obama? >> exactly. yes, i think it did, but what you're seeing now is enormous pressure being brought within his own caucus for boehner to take on something that is viewed as an extremely important and serious piece of legislation that's going to be around for a while if we don't stop it. this creates a scenario where you have to engage in a more serious level of brink man ship. from the republicans perspective on capitol hill, that's only thing that will make the president listen. >> there's no scenario in h the president undoes his legislation.
that's the thing that's weird. it is a complete up ending of the roles of politics. you lose the elections, you need to regain power and you're not the folks in charge. can't just blow up the capitol. >> there's really not a strategy you're missing. >> i'm sorry to hear that. >> after this vote today, i asked members what do you think the senate should do? filibuster a motion to proceed? block the amendment? the answer i kept hearing, i'm not an expert on senate procedure. they do believe the country will become a socialist distaupe area. they just don't have a plan for how this will undo obama care.
>> i give them that credit. but heather, you actually watch the economy and where as we might besocialist, will we go throu through. >> we're beginning to see the beginning of the crazy season. discussing how far over the brink should we take the u.s. economy. last time we had this conversation about not raising the debt ceiling, we saw the american debt downgraded for the first time. we are still in a situation where although we are three years into an economic recovery, it has not been a recovery for american families in so many ways. we see incomes that are
stagnant. nine million people who should be at work today, but aren't. it's a bit of a smoke and mirrors. let's talk about obama care as though it were the most critical issue, when in fact, it is because congress has not acted. we've got this poor economy. >> ben, i'll let you in on this when we come back. s squeal ] [ male announcer ] since we began, mercedes-benz has pioneered many breakthroughs. ♪ breakthroughs in design... breakthroughs in safety... in engineering... and technology. and now our latest creation breaks one more barrier. introducing the cla. starting at $29,900. ♪ and struggle to sleep comfortably together, now there's a solution. sleep number dual temp, the revolutionary temperature-balancing layer with active air technology that works on any mattress brand,
including yours. whether you sleep hot or cool, sleep number dual temp allows each of you to select your ideal temperature. and it's only at one of our 425 sleep number stores nationwide. sleep number. comfort individualized. if you were wondering where chris hayes is, do not worry. he will be on television tonight. he's going to be on real time with bill maher. we'll be right back. we have got to get the three-technique block! i'm not angry. i'm not yellin'. nobody's tackling anybody! we got absolutely... i don't think this was such a good idea. i'm on it. if we can't secure the quarterback center exchange... you're doing a great job, coach. well they're coming along better than i anticipated. very pleased. who told you to take a break? [ male announcer ] want to win your own football fantasy?
just tell us. then use your visa card for a chance to win it. jron: i'm sorry, who are you?nt we all like? jc: i'm your coworker! c'mon guys, i'm driving. hey, you guys comfortable? it's best-in-class rear legroom. no way we'd fit this comfortably in your car, dan. ron: it's ron. jc: ron... and the passat has no-charge scheduled carefree maintenance... wish stevens had "carefree maintenance." right? that guy is so uptight. stevens: i'm "stevens." jc: ron stevens... right... vo: right now get the 2013 passat for 0% apr for 60 months with optional down payment match of up to $500.
significant effects on the economy. i think people largely agree if you look at the polling. but i would also make another point about the nature of debt ceiling fights versus shutdown fights. there were about ten shutdowns over the course of the carter and reagan administrations. they lasted about a week to ten days. there was one significant debt ceiling fight. actually came after water gate when ted kennedy and water mondale had a debate in the wake of watergate. i would compare that very much to what we're seeing now. one party that views this as a threat, an issue that has to be handled right now and another party who says we've got to move on. >> here's the way it's not comparable. ted kennedy and mondale were in a similar position. you're also talking about a mixed political party, period.
that seems to me to be what's different here. what i find striking is not the desire to repeal obama care. i'm not surprised by republicans fighting on the debt ceiling. there was an argument there that if only the presidency would have been up, they would have won it, but they did not win the last election. they did not have the mandate for this kind of hostage taking this time. >> no, they just convinced themselves that because obama care is unpopular, they're going to win. the public will blame barack obama and not them for what happens. not just ted cruz, but activists saying it has been pretty well internalized, that has been repeated when john boehner talks about the default, the possibility of default, he blames it on barack obama. again, i wish i had a great insight as to how they're going to convince the american people that is the case. they've just convinced enough of themselves and the base that they believe this and no, they don't really have a plan for
selling that beyond the people they already sold it to. this is the problem, they don't have to answer to any voters, especially in the house, beyond conservative voters who believe this. >> i would suggest their version of a win is different. it's like what we saw with rand paul in florida with the drones. his win was changing the conversation. >> ted cruz this week said when asked if he would filibuster, said i'll do anything it takes to filibuster the continuing resolution. he wouldn't say yes, so it might be they convince themselves of this, then there's a point. >> but boehner has stood up on the debt limit and said i will make sure we get a one-year delay on the obama care and today, the president called and said, just a reminder, i am just not going to negotiate with you. if what ben is saying the true, that's fine. if they just want to filibuster on the floor, get some media attention and we keep the
government open and pay our bills, that's one thing. if they don't, that's a whole other, heather. >> it seems to me they're afraid obama care's going to go into effect. once it does and once people can buy insurance on exchanges and get their preexisting conditions covered, this is a good thing, right? but whether or not republicans are so afraid of this being a good thing that people start like it, how far they're willing to push the u.s. economy is, that's the question on the table. but this is not, this is not good and in fact, we heard on wednesday that chairman bernanke said that it was federal fiscal policy that is a continuing restraint on economic growth and a source of risk for the economy. so, i mean, we know that what's going on right now is actually, it's affecting macro economic policymaking and it's not good for jobs and income. >> i think that's a key point.
there's this idea out there that the thing republicans are afraid of is that it will fail. but it often seems they're afraid it would succeed. if it was failing, they could just win in 2014 and repeal it. >> i think in 2017 where you have x number of people on this new entitlement, whether it succeeds or not. now, if the administration has slowly scaled back its estimates, but whether you're dealing with 10 or 20 million, a sizable medicaid population or sizable population on the exchange, there's going to be people locked into that money and that means it's more difficult to roll back. i think that's why ted cruz has been so definitive saying this is the moment, the lip, we have to stop them here. i think he believes it and i think boehner to a degree does as well. >> thank you very much all for being here on a friday night. that is "all in" for this evening. chris will be back on monday.
hubris selling the iraq war starts right now. good evening. they put on blue helmets, body armor, got into white armored suvs, they braved sniper fire that hit its target that disabled their lead vehicle, but they got in there and did the science that needed to be done. this 38-page report, those inspectors turned in on monday of this week, this shows what they scientifically documented and it is terrible. it's the effect of large scale apparently military grade chemical weapons in the civil population in syria. u.n. inspectors report this week does not make anything about that better. but it proves it. documented, verifiable confirmed evidence collected by internationally sanction