Skip to main content

tv   The Last Word With Lawrence O Donnell  MSNBC  June 28, 2017 10:00pm-11:01pm PDT

10:00 pm
where does the time go? [ laughter ] >> now it's time for "the last word" with lawrence o'donnell. good evening, lawrence. >> rachel, you can't do a cliff-hanger like that. come on. how long would it take for you to say this amazing thing right now? >> it involves a prop and control room is not going to give it to me. they're laughing at me in my earpiece. >> these control rooms conspiring against the art of this with these crazy limits like the one-our thing on the show and commercials and all that stuff. >> me losing the capacity at age 44 to read a digital clock. yeah, it's awkward.
10:01 pm
>> so we've got a real cliff-hanger for tomorrow night. >> yes. >> at 9:00 p.m. >> it involves a prop, and it's funny, and it's about the epa. >> my guess is it will still be scheduled for the end of the show. >> probably. >> so i'm going to see it, and i'm going to have to react to that. i cannot wait, rachel. >> thank you. >> by the way, tomorrow night, no matter what they say in that control room, take as much time as you want. >> i will. thank you, my friend. >> thank you. well, new polls out tonight show overwhelming opposition to the republican health care bill, and now we know why the mcconnell bill is the first health care bill in senate history to bypass the senate finance committee. because that's where it would have died. >> we are looking at a health care that would be a fantastic tribute to our country. >> republican senators are not afraid of defying him. they feel like his threats are empty, that he doesn't have the political standing out in the
10:02 pm
country and in their home states to really be a threat. >> we're working very hard. we've given ourselves a little bit more time to make it perfect. >> i get the sense that, you know, this issue is maybe not the president's wheelhouse. >> there seems to be pressure coming from those moderates on leadership to work with democrats. >> i have said all along that i thought we had -- should talk to the democrats from the beginning. >> president trump, my republican friends, the choice is yours. >> nobody inside the administration or out can point to a plan or a coherent set of steps that the trump administration is taking to protect the election system. >> if he continues to refuse to act, it's a dereliction of the basic duty to defend the country. >> given that he won't even, i think, level with the american people about the russian interference in the election, it's hard to imagine him confronting vladimir putin.
10:03 pm
the day after the resistance crushed mitch mcconnell's attempt to repeal and replace obamacare, the day after mitch mcconnell's worst defeat as the republican majority leader, mitch mcconnell began his day on the senate floor saying exactly what a defeated leader in the senate is supposed to say. >> we'll continue working so we can bring legislation to the floor for debate and ultimately a vote. >> he didn't even attempt to sound optimistic about ever actually being able to bring a health care bill to the floor for vote. he didn't try to sound optimistic about trying to win that vote if he ever gets a vote on the senate floor. but at least he didn't step up to the microphone and just quit the way paul ryan did when paul ryan was forced to pull his first health care bill off of the house floor. mitch mcconnell is not in the same place that paul ryan was when ryan suffered his first-round defeat on a health
10:04 pm
care bill. this does not mean that it's all over in the senate, but it does not mean that mitch mcconnell can do what paul ryan was eventually able to do, which was find a so-called compromise that allowed conservatives in the house of representatives to ignore their so-called principles and vote for the repeal and replacement of obamacare. for mitch mcconnell doing that, reviefrning this bill the way paul ryan did in the house of representatives, is literally ten times more difficult. ten times more difficult for mitch mcconnell than it was for paul ryan. paul ryan could afford to lose 20 republican votes in the house of representatives. mitch mcconnell can afford to lose two. so far, publicly mitch mcconnell has lost nine votes. nine republicans were ready to vote against mitch mcconnell's bill if he brought it to a vote this week.
10:05 pm
the latest whip count after the seemingly pointless meeting with republican senators and president trump at the white house shows that there are now eight republicans ready to vote no. ron johnson was moved from the no column to the undecided column today because he said he was simply unable to vote on the bill this week. and so by delaying the vote, it now becomes theoretically possible to get ron johnson's vote. but mitch mcconnell's biggest problem isn't actually the number of senators who are against the bill publicly. it's the number of senators who have said publicly that they are for the bill. there are only five of them. mitch mcconnell, mike enzi, lamar alexander, and jim enhop. that is it. no one else is willing to say they support mitch mcconnell's bill. that leaves 39 republican senators undecided. i have never seen less support for a majority leader's top-priority bill, which is a top priority of his party and his president.
10:06 pm
the five, five public supporters are the loneliest public supporters of a major party agenda item that the senate has ever seen. this legislation was supposed to be handled by the senate finance committee. that's the committee with jurisdiction over this. but mitch mcconnell, in an unprecedented insult to the committee and a personal insult to chairman orrin hatch, removed the bill from the finance committee and created, out of thin air, a group, a group of 13 republican men to replace the finance committee. they were extraordinarily lucky to be brought into the room for the most important legislation on the agenda. and in turn for this astounding, unprecedented honor, this elevation to this unique group of 13, this honor that mitch mcconnell gave them, most of them gave mitch mcconnell absolutely nothing.
10:07 pm
only three of the men on the group of 13 are supporting the bill that they came up with, with mitch mcconnell. nine of them. nine of them are undecided, and one of them is opposed. one of the 13 hand-picked senators who was supposed to do this with mitch mcconnell is opposed to what they did. but that's better. that is actually better than what would have happened to mitch mcconnell's bill in the senate finance committee. mitch mcconnell knew that if he sent the bill to the senate finance committee, that it would have died in the senate finance committee. here are the members of the senate finance committee. if the bill had gone to the finance committee, we would have heard the input of three women on the democratic side, which was something mitch mcconnell was not eager to here. but that wasn't going to be mitch mcconnell's biggest problem. there are 14 republicans on that committee in the majority. there are 12 democrats. mitch mcconnell always knew that
10:08 pm
this bill was going to be a very serious problem for republican dean heller, one of the junior republican members on the senate finance committee. mitch mcconnell knew that he might have to allow dean heller to vote against the bill for dean heller's own survival in nevada in his re-election battle next year. he could allow him to vote against the bill on the senate floor. that he could allow. but mitch mcconnell could not live with dean heller voting against the bill in the senate finance committee. mitch mcconnell could have been -- i mean dean heller could have been one of the two republicans that could be allowed to vote against the bill on the senate floor. but if dean heller voted against the bill in the senate finance committee, he would kill the bill dead in that committee because the vote in the finance committee would have been 13-13. tie vote. a tie vote kills a bill in the senate finance committee.
10:09 pm
mitch mcconnell knew, knew that vote would be a tie in the senate finance committee. so mitch mcconnell's health care bill is, in theory at least, still alive. and it's not alive because he kept it away from the democrats on the senate finance committee who would have been so critical of it, including senators stab know, kent well and mccaskill, who would have brought a womanly perspective to this legislation that was not included in mitch mcconnell's group of 13. mitch mcconnell's bill is theoretically and only theoretically alive because he kept it away from dean heller in the senate finance committee. this is the first health care bill in senate history that was not handled by the senate finance committee. mitch mcconnell bypassed the committee because he couldn't afford to lose one vote. one vote. now he's trying to get some kind of version of that same bill
10:10 pm
somehow revived on the senate floor where he cannot afford to lose three votes. mitch mcconnell is the best tack tissuen working in the congress today. he's better at legislative strategy than paul ryan ever was. much more experienced. but he's not a miracle worker, and that's why the resistance won yesterday, and that's why the resistance wins every day that goes by when mitch mcconnell doesn't add a single "yes" vote to a bill the republican senate is afraid to vote for. joining us now, john hol iman, national affairs analyst for nbc news and msnbc, and joy reid, host of a.m. joy on msnbc. so, joy, this peculiar process of what's he doing, how come he isn't using the committee, why is he using this group of 13 -- he knew.
10:11 pm
>> yeah. >> he knew if this goes to the committee, it dies there. >> yeah. i mean because the thing is if you think about what mitch mcconnell is trying to do, obamacare is sort of like a four-part puzzle, right, that they're trying to unravel. you've got obviously the non-group market, people who buy their own insurance, which republicans would very much like to release them from the mandate to buy insurance, not have that 10 million or so people buying insurance. you get the much bigger piece, which is medicaid, which the people in the senate finance committee, particularly dean heller, they can do the math in their state and see something like 20% to 25% of people in their state are getting medicaid and only like 5% to 10% of the people are in the non-group market. it's a bigger piece. then there's the even bigger piece which is of course all the rules and regulations that even folks like us that get insurance through our employer love, the free mammograms, the free testing, the stuff that you can access through the regulations. and then the fourth piece is the taxes, which they'd like to get rid of altogether, the taxes on rich people. which piece of that do you take out of that puzzle and pull out without destroying yourself?
10:12 pm
if the non-group market, if their theory is true that all 10 million of those people just don't want insurance, which is crazy because i doubt they don't want insurance, that would only be 10 million versus 72 million people on medicaid. if you're dean heller, you can do the math. and if you're most other than those 13 guys or five of them, they can just do the math. it's very hard to undo obamacare. >> let's put up on the screen again the names of the undecided republicans if we can do that. 39 of them, john. it's a stunning group because it includes members of the leadership. it includes john thune. it includes john cornyn. it includes the republicans from mississippi. why? because they're afraid of being beaten by a democrat if they vote for this thing? it includes the republicans from alabama. it includes most of the chairmen. it includes all of the high levels, chuck grassley, the senior players. >> there's a simpler explanation that goes to another aspect of the peculiarity of this and the situation in which mcconnell finds himself in trying to figure out a set of tactics that will get it passes. most of those people are undecided because they don't
10:13 pm
know what's in the bill. they haven't seen the bill. they haven't read the bill. all of them know this is a politically dangerous, potentially toxic situation, even if you're in mississippi. so most of them would like to be -- they plan to be for the bill, but they want to at least have read the bill to understand how much trouble they're going to be in. and some of them were hoping what has happened would happen, which is to say without having to take a position on the bill, mitch mcconnell would have to pull the bill, and they would never have to see the bill again or take a position on the bill for those reasons. and i think that's kind of where we're likely headed right now. to joy's point, i think the reality is part of the reason why this is so complicate san diego because rand paul is right. this is not an obamacare repeal. this is this machine he's trying to concoct to solve the fundamental problem, which is there isn't a bill that the moderate republican conservatives in the senate will agree on that the conservative, conservative far-right senators will agree on.
10:14 pm
there's not one there. it doesn't work. so you can't just repeal and replace it because there's no singular new system that they would agree on. then you get into rube goldberg world, and that's not going to work either, which is why i agree with you. not dead, but man, i had a hamster that i put in the clothes dryer when i was 8 years old. that hamster might be alive today, but it's probably theoretically dead. >> i want to issue an invitation, if you make up your mind, please come on this program and i'll let you announce your yes vote and why you're doing it. i won't even cross examine you. you can call this a dare if you want. i dare you to say you're willing to vote yes. joy, i dare any of the 39 to move from hiding to yes. >> and your producers have had the same issue mine have. it's very hard to find an elected republican who will come on and defend the bill. when they do, if they're willing to be honest, we had congressman reid who at a certain point admitted, i don't think taxpayers should pay for medicaid.
10:15 pm
if you're going to be honest, you're going to have to give a reason that's going to be super unpopular and make yourself look cruel. even if they're a yes, they don't want to be a public yes. one other thing, mitch mcconnell is sort of hurtling down a train track where at the other end of it are democrats who he's going to have to eventually deal with. what the republicans have also done is threatened not to fund the subsidies for the people who buy through the non-group market. those 10 million they say -- at a certain point, that market might actually collapse. then you're going to have instead of obamacare repeal and replace, obamacare rescue. a bailout of insurance companies is coming, or a compromise with democrats to fix the affordable care act, which is the logical thing to do, but mitch mcconnell doesn't want to do it. >> here's another thing we're learning and it goes to your point about mitch mcconnell's tactical mastery. there's no doubt the man knows how to work that chamber, but he has spent the last eight years using that chamber and his
10:16 pm
mastery to stop things from happening, from keeping president obama's priorities from becoming law. he's now being asked to legislate, which is a different thing. he's out of practice. and not just to legislate, but to legislate on the hardest possible legislative priority you could imagine at this moment. so i think it's not that his mastery is overstated. it's just that the kind of mastery he's developed is not well suited to doing the actual job of legislating. >> my point is he's not a mer miracle worker. i just want to leave this footnote. when that bill died in the house the first time, it was declared dead. it turned out it wasn't. i do believe the degree of difficulty here is ten times more. but we'll know it's over sometime later in july to be absolutely certain. but we will leave it there for tonight. thank you both for joining us. coming up, president trump's lawyers have discovered that attacking people like maybe the
10:17 pm
prosecutor who is investigating president trump is not, not their best idea. they're backing off from that. and later, union members were warned that president trump was not telling the trukt when he said he was saving all those jobs at the carrier manufacturing plant. those jobs have been lost in exactly the numbers that the union head predicted they would be lost. that union chief will join us later. so, your new prescription does have a few side effects. oh, like what? ♪ you're gonna have dizziness, ♪ nausea, and sweaty eyelids. ♪ and in certain cases chronic flatulence. ♪ no. ♪ sooooo gassy girl. ♪ so gassy. if you're boyz ii men, you make anything sound good. it's what you do. if you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. it's what you do.
10:18 pm
next! ♪ next! edible arrangements for summer. order in store or online. i know you worry i can't keep up with our weekly tee times. dear son, but i've been taking osteo bi-flex ease. it's 80% smaller but just as effective. which means you're in big trouble, son. improved joint comfort in seven days.
10:19 pm
osteo bi-flex ease. made to move. for years, centurylink has been promising fast internet to small businesses. but for many businesses, it's out of reach. why promise something you can't deliver? comcast business is different. ♪ ♪ we deliver super-fast internet with speeds of 250 megabits per second across our entire network, to more companies, in more locations, than centurylink. we do business where you do business. ♪ ♪
10:20 pm
a senate intelligence committee has announced that they will soon get the memos of former fbi director james comey's conversations with president trump. committee chairman richard burr told politico, quote, i've got a commitment. he was asked who gave him that commitment. the senator responded, i'm not going to tell you. he said, he is fairly certain of the timeline for getting the memos and suggested it would be soon. it does us no good later. bloomberg reported that president trump's lawyers are now backing off their threat to attack james comey's conduct, saying trump's lawyers will postpone filing a complaint against former fbi director james comey with the justice department according to a person familiar with the decision. a bid to stop antagonizing the special counsel who is investigating ties between the president's campaign and russian officials. the report adds, the president's lawyers still intend to file a complaint at some point. today, former nato ambassador testified before the senate intelligence committee.
10:21 pm
>> i don't believe any previous american president would argue that your own hearings in the senate are a waste of time or, in the words of president trump, a witch hunt. they're not. you're doing your duty that the people elected you to do. it is his duty -- president trump's -- to be skeptical of russia. it's his duty to investigate and to defend our country against a cyber offensive because russia is our most dangerous adversary in the world today. if he continues to refuse to act, it's a dereliction of the basic duty to defend the country. >> joining us now, senior white house correspondent for bloomberg, who broke today's story about trump's lawyers, and mieke eoyang, the vice president for the national security program at third way.
10:22 pm
margaret, so this is obviously a change in style for trump lawyers and the new lawyer, mr. dowd, is the one with the kind of experience that one would expect this from. >> so, lawrence, this has been going on, as you know now, for about almost three weeks, these deliberations about what to do after james comey testified that he had these memos, that he had in fact leaked those memos -- i'm using the word in quotes -- to someone who would get it to the press, and that his whole intention was in part to try to force the triggering of a special counsel. we know that president trump was incredibly frustrated after that, and that's where this threat to file these reports, these complaints to the justice department's inspector general and the senate judiciary committee came from in the first place. but you're right. even just as recently as last week, we expected that these filings would be coming.
10:23 pm
this decision signals a strategic shift to say the least by the trump legal team. >> and, margaret, it also seems to indicate client trump following at least some lawyers' advice. >> yeah, i think that's a really important distinction, and we've seen some parallels of it in the way the president has conducted himself in his public comments and on twitter in recent days. he seems to have, at least for now, put on hold the idea of attacking bob mueller's character or reliability. we still know he's no fan of james comey, but he's not going after mueller right now, and that is also part of this approach to show a little respect to bob mueller, give him the space he needs to do his job. it's those optics, those signals, that the legal team appears to be trying to send now. > what will the comey memos, the actual possession of the comey memos by the intelligence committee add to their investigation since james comey seems to have testified about those conversations with the president in full already? >> so i think these memos are really important for them to
10:24 pm
have because it establishes a written record that comey was making at the time that they can use to then interrogate other witnesses, compare their memories of what happened to what comey had written down at the time, which is probably the freshest recollection of any of these incidents. so it's really helpful for them to fact-check as they go forward. >> what do you expect after they get the memos, when you're building an investigation like this? there are these basic building blocks you want. where do you see them moving them after they get the memos because they've now read those memos? >> so after you've read the memos, you're going to want to go back and interview the people mentioned in the memos. this is on the obstruction piece of it. comey's memos are also on the question of what was russia doing and who responded. what did they say? they're going to want to go back and ask those people on how russia conducted its election interference as well.
10:25 pm
>> and, margaret, back to the president's defense. is there a feeling now within the white house, do we know, that the lawyers -- and it seems like it's dowd who is the new addition here, who is not the flamboyant not, not the one going out there doing press conferences and going as a guest on television shows, who may have gotten control of this. do they feel in the white house that dowd actually has control of the president now in this investigation? >> well, there has been a real firewalling or really attempt to firewall both the white house, you know, don mcgahn and the president's advisers from the legal size and at the same time this addition of jay sekulow and dowd. but i think nobody in that legal team or outside of it is predicting that trump himself will be able or will be willing to commit to permanently holding his fire. this is, let's say, a strategy for now that is designed to create a little bit of space and cooling off period for now. but there's an entire summer worth of investigations and twists and turns in testimony and document gathering, negotiations with the treasury department over financial documents to take place. so between this and that, there's a whole lot of room for the tactics and the instincts to change.
10:26 pm
>> mieke, your old committee, the house intelligence committee, now saying july 24th they will be hearing from roger stone, longtime trump adviser, and they're going to be doing that not publicly. they're going to close the door for that hearing. roger stone says he wants the hearing to be public. why isn't it public? >> i think with a witness like roger stone and the sensitivity that you have involved, the committee is going to want to interview him first in closed session to establish a record. this is a guy who loves to grandstand, who wants to score political points. they don't want to do that. this is a fact-based investigation, and they're going to want to tie him down on specific facts on his relationship with guccifer or these russian hackers, with wikileaks. what kind of contact did he have?
10:27 pm
when did he know what he knew? and establish that record in closed session. >> thank you both for joining us tonight. appreciate it. >> thank you. coming up, who's afraid of the big bad wolf? well, in washington apparently, no one is. it's ok that everybody ignores me when i drive. it's fine. because i get a safe driving bonus check every six months i'm accident free. because i don't use my cellphone when i'm driving. even though my family does, and leaves me all alone. here's something else... i don't share it with mom. i don't. right, mom? i have a brand new putter you don't even know about! it's awesome. safe driving bonus checks, only from allstate. sometimes i leave the seat up on purpose. switching to allstate is worth it.
10:28 pm
manait's a series of is nsmart choices. and when you replace one meal or snack a day with glucerna made with carbsteady to help minimize blood sugar spikes you can really feel it. glucerna. everyday progress. whuuuuuat?rtgage offer from the bank today. you never just get one offer. go to lendingtree.com and shop multiple loan offers for free!
10:29 pm
free? yeah. could save thousands. you should probably buy me dinner. pappa's eatin' steak tonight. no. at lendingtree, shop and compare loan offers from top lenders and in just 5 minutes, you could save thousands. lendingtree, when banks compete, you win. i love date night. somebody's ruining it. yeah. well you could leave if you wanted to?
10:30 pm
president trump hasn't been able to convince senate republicans to support the republican health care bill for two reasons. one, it is a very bad bill.
10:31 pm
two, because according to "the washington post," quote, in private conversations on capitol hill, trump is often not taken seriously. john weaver, former chief strategist for john kasich tells "the washington post," when you have a 35% approval rating and you're under fbi investigation, you don't have a hammer. pulling support for what is now the mitch mcconnell health care bill ranges -- and this is recent polling taken this week, ranges from a high of 27% from a fox news poll to a low of 12% in a suffolk university poll. joining us now, liz mayer and john hol iman. liz, it doesn't seem as though the president has a hammer. i don't know what else he has, and i just don't see why any republican senator would take him seriously in any conversation. am i missing something? >> i don't think you're entirely missing things, no. my perception of this is, you
10:32 pm
know, first of all, i think john weaver has a few points that are very well taken here. i don't think he really does have a hammer. but in addition to that, trump is, to be quite blunt about it, he is not regarded as somebody who is in any way shape, care, or form, a health care policy wonk or a policy wonk at all. about all he seems to know about health care is like many big employers, i think he would rather not have to personally deal with the hassle of getting insurance, and for that reasons he seems to have defaulted to single payer health care or socialized medicine. and i think that's probably about as much as he really knows about health care policy. you know, i also think candidly he doesn't have the hammer, but also he hasn't really been that engaged in health care policy in the formulation of this obamacare repeal package. so it's kind of hard to even measure whether he's proving to be a total success, a total failure, or just a gigantic nothing burger. he just kind of isn't really there to the degree that i think a lot of people would typically
10:33 pm
expect a president to be. >> john, i for one think presidential leadership in legislative affairs is the easiest thing in the world to exaggerate. >> overrated. >> meaning that, you know, you can be a master of the policy. and if this isn't good for me as a house member, i'm not going to vote for it. if it isn't going for me as a senator, i'm not going to vote for it. you don't find bravery in the casting of these votes and they are not cast for individuals. once in a great while, there's a handful of votes that can be persuaded on a personal basis. i think president trump had that. bill can't -- i'm sorry. president obama had that. but not in big numbers. >> no. >> and this president -- >> it's on the margins. i'm not a mathematician, but the math is not hard to do here. you've got a president in the mid-to high 30s. you know. what am i doing? if i'm doing the arithmetic on capitol hill, that's not a thing for which -- you're looking at those numbers and saying this is
10:34 pm
not -- i don't see how this adds up. the other thing that's the reality is the one place they really interseeded in this whole fiasco so far was the dean healer thing. as soon as heller comes out and says i'm not for the bill, it's unhelpful. but he didn't say i can't be brought around. they said we're going to run ads against you. they drop an ad on him and start talking about how they're going to primary. and mcconnell rightly calls up reince priebus and says, this is the dumbest thing you've ever done. so to the extent they had any kind of leverage, that kind of behavior is the kind of behavior that is like anti-leverage. it's not just not having a hammer. whatever the metaphorical opposite of a hammer is, that's the thing that makes people say, that's not going to get it done. >> that is because of course mitch mcconnell believes that if we are going to have a republican senator elected in nevada next year, that person's going to be named dean heller. he's the guy who can win the
10:35 pm
state for us. you know, don't fool around with him. >> no. i think that's correct, and i think that, you know e beyond what john discussed, it's worth noting that that outside trump group was actually planning on running ads not targeting republican senators per se but running ads supposedly targeting like democratic senators in a bunch of the states of republican senator who's are wavering on the bill. so it's not just that i think trump has lilly pissed off dean heller, that's pissed of the senatorial. i think with regard to the heller ad, there was so much publicity. within the nevada local media market, there was so much coverage of that that the damage was really done whether or not they decided to actually go ahead and drop their seven figures running the ad attacking him. so the whole thing is really an example of them having severely
10:36 pm
misplayed their hand. i notice one strategist was quoted in one of the axios morning newsletters saying they think attacking dean heller and threatening to drop seven figures against dean heller was probably the stupidest mistake the trump team had made second to firing james comey. i think that speaks volumes. >> quick last word. >> the other thing of course is the notion that trump holds a victory celebration for the passage of the house bill and then later calls it mean. obviously it's inconsistent but the point is if you're a senator -- >> that's anti-leadership. >> if you're going to exercise leverage, people have no know you're going to be consistent and reliable. once you think the guy could do anything at any point, he comes to you and begs you to vote for something and then he's going to screw you later, it doesn't work. >> liz, john, thank you both for joining us. appreciate it.
10:37 pm
>> thank you. coming up, president trump threatened the owner of the "washington post" because he is so jealous of the owner of the "washington post." ♪ at lincoln financial, we get there are some responsibilities of love you gotta do on your own. and some you shouldn't have to shoulder alone.
10:38 pm
like ensuring your family is protected, today and tomorrow, no matter what the future brings. ask a financial advisor how life insurance from lincoln can help start protecting your family's financial future now. having mplaque psoriasise is not always easy. it's a long-distance run. and you have the determination to keep going. humira has a proven track record of being prescribed for nearly 10 years. humira works inside the body to target and help block a specific source of inflammation that contributes to symptoms. in clinical trials, most adults taking humira were clear or almost clear and many saw 75% and even 90% clearance in just four months. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal, infections and cancers, including lymphoma have happened as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common,
10:39 pm
and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms, or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. join over 250,000 people who have chosen humira. ask about the #1 prescribed biologic by dermatologists. humira & go.
10:40 pm
introducing the easiest way to get gillette blades noo text "blades" to gillette on demand text to reorder blades with gillette on demand... ...and get $3 off your first order jeff bezos is the kind of rich guy that donald trump has always dreamed of being. first of all, jeff bezos is a real billionaire, okay? start there.
10:41 pm
worth an estimated $85.3 billion, and he made it all himself. he's a self-made man. jeff bezos started getting rich all on his own long after donald trump's big head start of being born rich. and jeff bezos' massive wealth was built on his success with amazon. this has allowed him to branch out into things like movie producing, hollywood. this year, jeff bezos's movie manchester by the sea won oscars and everyone in hollywood is bowing and scraping to jeff bezos everywhere he goes in the hope he will finance their next film or tv series, and donald trump has never been wealthy enough to finance a single movie, to hire a single actor, to finance a single tv series. no movie star has ever had to say, thank you to donald trump for anything. jeff bezos has also branched out into ownership of the
10:42 pm
"washington post," which earned him this tweet from the president of the united states today. the amazon "washington post," sometimes referred to as the guardian of amazon not paying internet taxes, which they should, is fake news. joy reid is back, and so donald trump has found a tax that he likes. he wants -- there are days he wakes up and he doesn't remember he's a republican. so he tweets, i want to do this tax. of course he doesn't know because it's the internet. he's never been on the internet that, of course, amazon does pay sales tax. on all the purchases on amazon, you pay the state sales tax where you buy it. >> he doesn't know things. he knows feelings and vibes. the thing you left out is that jeff bezos is also respected. that is something that donald trump has craved his entire life. it's this neediness that makes him chase after "the new york times." i think he cannot tolerate that
10:43 pm
somebody like jeff bezos is more successful in things donald trump would like to be successful at, including media, so now he's decided to go off the reservation. so here's the question, though. how long will it be before rank and file republicans who like donald trump also are for internet sales taxes. >> okay. i'm going to bet that that's a bridge too far for them, that he will get zero support for sales taxes. >> i don't know. i mean trump voters, trump supporters have decided russia is okay. they've decided russian hacking is okay. >> right. >> i mean the rubicon has been crossed on what republicans are willing to tolerate. the polling shows that even though they think donald trump might have colluded with the russians, they don't think there's a problem with that. >> they've always hated taxes more than russia. they've always hated taxes the most. >> that is true. >> so tonight the president has a fund-raiser for his re-election earlier than any president in history has ever
10:44 pm
done this. of course what it really is, first of all, is a big income event for his hotel in washington because he gets these people to contribute money. >> yep. >> which is then paid to his hotel to have this event. he then personally takes the profit out of that. >> right. >> which might have something to do with why he's scheduling fund raisers so soon. >> ha is the other thing, that donald trump has blown through the norms on emoluments. he's enriching himself being president. and charging these fund-raisers to his hotel is one of the ways he's doing it. it should be illegal, but i guess no one is going to enforce it. >> they're certainly studying it, and the competition in washington is saying -- suing him, saying it's unfair advantage there, and those suits have legs. we'll see what happens. joy reid, thank you very much for joining us. coming up, remember when president trump promised to keep jobs, save those jobs at the carrier plant in indiana? he was lying, and now we have the proof. a few weeks after he won the electoral college, donald trump through to indiana to announce that he had just saved over
10:45 pm
♪ at johnson's we care about safety as much as you do. that's why we meet or exceed 15 global regulations for baby products. and where standards differ, we always go with the toughest. johnson's. if you have moderate to severe ulcerative colitis or crohn's, and your symptoms have left you with the same view, it may be time for a different perspective.
10:46 pm
if other treatments haven't worked well enough, ask your doctor about entyvio, the only biologic developed and approved just for uc and crohn's. entyvio works by focusing right in the gi-tract to help control damaging inflammation and is clinically proven to begin helping many patients achieve both symptom relief as well as remission. infusion and serious allergic reactions can happen during or after treatment. entyvio may increase risk of infection, which can be serious. while not reported with entyvio, pml, a rare, serious brain infection caused by a virus may be possible. tell your doctor if you have an infection, experience frequent infections, or have flu-like symptoms, or sores. liver problems can occur with entyvio. if your uc or crohn's medication isn't working for you, ask your gastroenterologist about entyvio. entyvio. relief and remission within reach.
10:47 pm
10:48 pm
i need the phone that's where i happen to be... to be the one that rings. i need not to be missed phone calls... to not be missed. i need seamless handoff... canyon software. from reception, to landline, to mobile. i need one number... not two. i'm always moving forward... because i can't afford to get stuck in the past. comcast business. built for business. a few weeks after he won the electoral college, donald trump through to indiana to announce that he had just saved over 1,000 jobs at the carrier air-conditioning plant. here he is then, basking in his view of his own heroism. >> we just visited 1,000 people in the factory that are going wild, in the plant. but i will tell you that united technologies and carrier stepped
10:49 pm
it up, and now they're keeping actually the number is over 1,100 people, which is so great, which is so good. >> in that same month, the american economy under president obama added 156,000 jobs. the month before that, the economy added 178,000 jobs. 1,100 jobs is so tiny a number that it is within the margin of error of the bureau of labor statistics count of jobs created or lost in america in any given month. so the president could not have picked a tinier number of jobs to celebrate, and that doesn't mean that each one of those jobs isn't the world to each person who has one of those jobs. it is everything to any person who has one of those jobs. a thousand jobs would be something local mayor to celebrate. a thousand jobs would even be something for some governors to celebrate.
10:50 pm
but the president of a country with 146 million jobs? you could tell that day that donald trump was not satisfied with announcing his rescue of only 1,100 jobs. >> over 1100 jobs. by the way, that number is going to go up very substantially as they expand this area, this plant. so the 1100 is going to be a minimum number. >> so the number was going to go up because they were going to do more hiring. the head of the union representing carrier, chuck jones, told "the washington post" that donald had, quote, lied his "a" off. donald trump has been called a liar by a lot of people but chuck jones was supposed to be one of those people saying thank you donald trump for saving those union jobs. of course donald trump attacked chuck jones after chuck jones called him a liar.
10:51 pm
donald trump tweeted, chuck jones, who is president of the united steel workers 1999, has done a terrible job of representing workers. no wonder companies flee country. chuck jones responded to donald trump on this program. >> i'm not backing up on my position one iota. he's wrong. i'm right. and we'll move on. and if he wants to keep on tweeting, i'll keep on responding. what he said was saving 1100 jobs, that was a falsehood. in all reality, like i said, 730 are staying, and here in indianapolis, 550 are losing their livelihood. >> chuck jones was outraged that donald trump was lying to the 550 people who chuck jones knew were going to be laid off. he hated having to tell those union members that president-elect trump was lying to them. he wished that donald trump was
10:52 pm
telling them the truth, that they weren't losing the jobs. chuck jones told them the truth because he knew they had futures to plan, christmas presents to buy, budgeting to do with the knowledge that they were going to be laid off. they needed to know that. this week we can now officially close the file on the case of who was telling the truth, donald trump or chuck jones. cnbc reported that the carrier factory's union has received the official notice as required by federal law that the first round of cuts, 338 jobs, will take place on july 20th with an additional 290 employees terminated on december 22nd, three days before christmas. the number of manufacturing jobs that will remain at the carrier plant is exactly 730, precisely the number that chuck jones made public when donald trump lied about saving a minimum, minimum, of 1,100 jobs. chuck jones didn't want to be right about this. but he was. and donald trump was, as usual,
10:53 pm
lying. chuck jones will get tonight's last word, next. when this bell. ...it starts a chain reaction... ...that's heard throughout the connected business world. at&t network security helps protect business, from the largest financial markets to the smallest transactions, by sensing cyber-attacks in near real time and automatically deploying countermeasures. keeping the world of business connected and protected. that's the power of and.
10:54 pm
10:55 pm
i'm ryan and i quit smoking with chantix. i tried to quit cold turkey. i tried to quit with the patch; that didn't work. along with support, chantix (varenicline) is proven to help people quit smoking. for me, chantix worked. it reduced my urge to smoke. compared to the nicotine patch, chantix helped significantly more people quit smoking. when you try to quit smoking, with or without chantix, you may have nicotine withdrawal symptoms. some people had changes in behavior or thinking, aggression, hostility, agitation, depressed mood or suicidal thoughts or actions with chantix. serious side effects may include seizures, new or worse heart or blood vessel problems, sleepwalking or allergic and skin reactions which can be life-threatening. stop chantix and get help right away if you have any of these. tell your healthcare provider if you've had depression or other mental health problems. decrease alcohol use while taking chantix. use caution when driving or operating machinery. the most common side effect is nausea.
10:56 pm
i'm so proud to be a non-smoker. ask your doctor if chantix is right for you. many insurance plans cover chantix for a low or $0 copay. over 1100 jobs. and by the way, that number is going to go up very substantially as they expand this area, this plant. so the 1100 is going to be a minimum number. >> joining us now, chuck jones, the former president of the united steel workers local 1999 which represents the carrier workers.
10:57 pm
chuck retired last month after 26 years as president and 48 years as a member. he joins us from his union hall in indianapolis. chuck, these seven months since the president was there, the official word has come to the people being laid off. do all the individual workers who know they're going to be laid off now know that and are they now able to plan for that? >> yeah. finally the dates were announced, and the people that are going to be affected are very aware of who they are. and they can plan their life going forward. >> is there a different feeling out there now about then-president-elect trump's visit to the carrier plant? >> well, i think at the time without a doubt the way he laid things out, people thought that he was going to have a job, only to find out, as you reported the next day, when we told him that wasn't the case, i think, you know, without a doubt now, people understand what the
10:58 pm
situation was, that he came in and did a little creative math with the numbers. and, you know, i made some comments to "the washington post," and i stand behind them. he did lie. >> i want to listen to something else that donald trump said at carrier that day. let's listen to this. >> companies are not going to leave the united states any more without consequences. not going to happen. it's not going to happen. i'll tell you right now. >> chuck, that was the tough guy talking. there are going to be consequences, consequences, carrier is not going to be able to do anything with these jobs. any consequences that carrier is suffering? >> no. the state of indiana rewarded them $7 million. so i don't know how in the world the state would give a
10:59 pm
corporation money for taking jobs out of this country. but there's no consequences i'm aware of. >> so chuck, it was your job to tell those people after the president told them one thing, you had to tell them something else. what you had to tell them was the worst news they could possibly hear. how did that conversation go, when you had to tell the workers that? >> people were surprised. you know, for the most part, there wasn't any reason to not believe us. but when you've got the president-elect telling them one thing and then all of a sudden the next day we're telling them another, they were definitely, you know, in a dilemma where they finally went to the company and the company verified what i had said and what the union officials said were the right numbers. >> chuck jones, thank you very much for joining us tonight, i really appreciate it.
11:00 pm
>> thank you very much for having me. >> chuck jones gets tonight's last word. "the 11th hour" starts now. tonight, he's running. the president is out raising millions of dollars for his re-election. but just five months in, the gop is already playing the blame game. plus the russia investigation. lawmakers are getting comey's memos and reports today that the president's legal team will hold their fire on the ousted fbi director, for now. also tonight, access denied from the white house briefing room to the president's fundraiser. the president secretary's podium is being weaponized by a white house eager to escalate its war with the press. "the 11th hour" starts now. good evening once again from our nbc news headquarters in new york. i'm nicolle wallace. brian has the night off. it's day 160 of the trump