Skip to main content

tv   The 11th Hour With Brian Williams  MSNBC  July 17, 2018 8:00pm-9:00pm PDT

8:00 pm
11th hour" with brian williams, which starts right now. tonight, the president stumbles while attempting a walk-back after a global drubbing for siding with putin at their summit. he now says he got a word wrong in his statement. he reads a statement saying he agrees with the u.s. intel finding that russia hacked our election, but then he adds that it could also be other people. tonight, the president is back to calling the meeting a great success while his white house struggles to contain the mess created in helsinki. and we heard from the mueller investigation today, asking for immunity for five people so they can testify against manafort at his trial next week while a russian woman with ties to the nra is due in court in d.c. tomorrow. all of it as "the 11th hour" gets under way on a tuesday night. well, good evening once again from our nbc news headquarters in new york. day 544 of the trump
8:01 pm
administration and following what became a global blowback after taking putin's side on election meddling, the president attempted a fix today that was then quickly broken. on social media, as late as this evening he continued to insist, quote, the meeting between president putin and myself was a great success, except in the fake news media. now, before we get to the mistaken word the president said he got wrong yesterday, here now a reminder of what he said in helsinki while standing next to putin yesterday. >> my people came to me, dan coats came to me and some others, they said they think it's russia. i have president putin, he just said it's not russia. i will say this, i don't see any reason why it would be. >> those words set off alarm bells around the world. they brought about charges of treason by seasoned intel vets
8:02 pm
in this country and resulted in a hastily arranged meeting of the trump administration national security types this morning. nbc news is reporting tonight it was vice president mike pence and secretary of state pompeo who urged the president to publicly clarify his comments. one of the anchors on "fox & friends," assuming their most ardent viewer was watching this morning, actually urged the president on camera to make a correction. ashley parker of "the washington post" has been reporting on all of it, will join us in just a moment. she and her colleagues write this tonight, quote, trump was particularly rattled by a critical tweet monday from newt gingrich. one of the people said gingrich, long a stalwart ally, urged the president on social media to clarify his helsinki statements, saying they were the most serious mistake of his presidency and must be corrected immediately. so the white house called the media in to a pre-existing meeting the president was having with members of congress about taxes and reading off a printed
8:03 pm
statement, the president said he got a word wrong yesterday. >> i said the word would instead of wouldn't. the sentence should have been, and i thought it would be maybe a little bit unclear on the transcript or unclear on the actual video, the sentence should have been, i don't see any reason why it wouldn't be russia. sort of a double negative. so you can put that in. i think that probably clarifies things pretty good by itself. >> again, here's what he's talking about, his original comments alongside putin yesterday in helsinki. >> my people came to me, dan coats came to me and some others, they said they think it's russia. i have president putin, he just said it's not russia. i will say this, i don't see any reason why it would be. >> yesterday, the president also seemed willing to accept putin's denial that the kremlin had nothing to do with our election
8:04 pm
meddling. >> translator: the russian state has never interfered and is not going to interfere into internal american affairs, including the election process. >> president putin was extremely strong and powerful in his denial today. >> today, the president made a point of expressing his support for the home team, the 17 intelligence agencies here in the u.s., but then he couldn't help himself and he added to his written remarks and left himself some room. >> i have felt very strongly that while russia's actions had no impact at all on the outcome of the election, let me be totally clear in saying that -- and i've said this many times. i accept our intelligence community's conclusion that russia's meddling in the 2016 election took place. could be other people also. there's a lot of people out there.
8:05 pm
>> then this, in the age of digital photography, cameras caught a glimpse of the statement the president was reading from. it shows he crossed out a line about bringing all those who hacked our election to justice and he added, there was no collusion in his own handwriting. the president did not offer an explanation why he waited until today to correct the record. instead of closihoosing to do s either of the two fox news interviews he taped immediately after the press conference leaving helsinki. tonight the white house has continued its pr offensive. the administration sent out a press release with a detailed description of how for the first time it is, quote, protecting our elections and standing up to russia's malign activities, but the damage from helsinki may indeed be done. tonight a piece in "the washington post" by longtime conservative columnist george will carries this striking headline, "this sad,
8:06 pm
embarrassing wreck of a man." let's bring in our leadoff panel for a tuesday night. ashley parker, pulitzer prize winning reporter for "the washington post." charlie sykes, conservative author and longtime radio host who is contributing editor and podcast host over at the "weekly standard." and frank montoya, who during his time in the bureau played a role in establishing the national cyber investigative joint task force, which gives him a specially germane line into tonight's line of question. ashley, i'd like to begin with you. anatomy of a correction. give us the cliff notes of how this happened, starting on the flight home, the initial arrival back in the united states, morning television today and then seeing what we saw on television. >> so it did really start on the flight home where the president, as he always does, watched cable news, and he had actually been quite pleased with how he felt the summit went, but as he watched the blanket coverage
8:07 pm
that was almost universally negative and there were really no people out there defending him, and negative from not just the usual critics, the mainstream media and democrats, but from republicans. you know, including as we wrote there was a tweet that newt gingrich sent that i believe was then aired on fox news, which the president watches, that really rattled him because newt gingrich is someone who has really been with him through thick and thin. his mood starts to darken and change on the flight home. on the flight home, there was the tiniest bit of a walk-back. there was a tweet he sent saying he does believe his intelligence community but we really need to look to the future. that gave you the first inkling of what was to come. he lands. he gets a late start this morning, which means he's in the residence watching more tv, getting more frustrated. there was really a push by a number of people both inside and outside the white house to get him to make some correction and walk it back. the white house has told us these were the president's words, but this was also a
8:08 pm
collaborative effort. the first draft was written by his top policy adviser and speech writer stephen miller. the president weighed in. as you saw, he was even weighing in in those photos up until the last minute, scribbling in that trademark sharpie scrawl of his, you know, no collusion and little tweaks to the manuscript. as you said he read somewhat haltingly and begrudgingly finally around 2:00 p.m. today. >> our guest later on in the broadcast, eugene robinson, was the first to go on television and brand what he witnessed a hostage tape, in his view. frank, which trump do you believe as a career intel expert, the trump standing next to putin in helsinki or the trump correcting the record today and saying he got a word wrong in helsinki? >> well, i'll tell you the one that concerns me the most is the one in helsinki yesterday. there is no question that what he did yesterday was confirm the
8:09 pm
suspicions that a lot of intelligence and especially counterintelligence professionals in the government have that, you know, there is something there, that there is the possibility of compromise, that though people don't want to talk about it, call it some kind of a fringe theory or even conspiracy theory that he may be acting as an agent of a foreign power, that didn't put to rest any of that concern. in fact, i think there is going to be more talk about that that is not so covert, so to speak, just because of the way -- because of what he did and the way he did it, standing right next to vladimir putin. >> frank, you mentioned this. we don't talk about it because it sounds flat-out crazy and because even those inclined to think that way, it's such a deeply scary notion for patriots in this country. >> well, i mean, first of all, there is an investigation because those suspicions exist, that there was a conspiracy amongst americans, members of
8:10 pm
the trump organization or the campaign or the administration to assist the russians in attacking our democracy. so that's a given. but the fact is he is the president of the united states. it is the office of the presidency. it's supposed to be the leader of the free world. the idea that he may be an agent or acting as an agent of a foreign power is terrifying. i mean, look at what he knows and the power that he possesses, but at the same time there is just a litany of behaviors that have -- that led up to yesterday. what they really did, i think, is confirm, not just to those who are working the case but to the world, that there is a reason to be suspicious. that there is a reason to be concerned. >> charlie sykes, folks on the left are fond of calling fox news state-run tv, and i want to read you a portion of the "new york times" story tonight. by tuesday morning, it was clear mr. trump could not rely on support from even his most diehard allies. on "fox & friends," his favorite
8:11 pm
morning tv program, the host, brian killmeade spoke directly into the camera. from november, when everybody had you losing, you shocked the world. it wouldn't because of russia but russia's goal was to upend the electoral process. they hate democracy. he went on to say, this has to be corrected. the president later corrected it. so, charlie, were minds changed today, when even members of the president's base saw that statement he read in the cabinet room? >> only the minds that wanted to be changed, because as a walk-back this was ludicrous. i mean, as an excuse, this made the dog ate my homework seem like a brilliant alibi to say, oh, i just dropped this contracks. because obviously what you saw in helsinki was that was the real donald trump. that was not a gaffe. that was what donald trump
8:12 pm
thinks. that is his attitude towards vladimir putin. that is his relationship with vladimir putin. in fact, you know, whether you want to use, you know, the word treason, which i think goes a little too far, it was a betrayal of his own country, it was a betrayal of the presidency, and what you actually saw was collusion in action, which, of course, was ironic. and i think that what a lot of the folks even at fox were seeing is, look, this is a man who was supposed to be strong, never apologize. instead you saw this own seek wuss craven sycophancy in the presence of one of the most thuggish dictators in the world. it was a terrible moment for donald trump, but what a pathetic attempt at a walk-back. >> ashley, where are we on the trump cycle? here's what i mean, those who like you watch him so closely have seen the rare times he's been forced to do a walk-back, a corrective statement. often it's somewhere around 24
8:13 pm
hours before he finds himself back to his natural place, his original position, as if the walk-back never happened. did tonight's tweet give us any clues? >> well, i think there is sort of a release -- steam release valve theory for this president. for that cycle we're in about the middle. i'll explain what i mean. the president gave, again, a begrudging walk-back. you could tell from his body language, his arms were folded, which is sort of his default posture of peak. he was reading from the paper. so what will happen is probably the walk-back, as charlie said, is not going to change anything. all of the people who have criticized him are unlikely to be swayed by this sort of double negative argument. when the coverage tomorrow morning is still similarly unflatering, maybe fox news will come around, but i would be surprised if anyone else really does an about-face.
8:14 pm
the president will go -- grow increasingly frustrated. he will be angry that he feels he was forced into something by his aides that he really didn't agree with and was against his gut, and that's when he will need to release this steam and we could see some anger, some lashing out, some return to his true opinions on twitter or in private or in public statements. some time i would say within the next 24 to 48 hours. >> all right. well, having that timeframe is useful. frank, let me give you a hypothetical. let's say that yesterday our deputy assistant secretary of state for all things russian was in helsinki for a meeting with his or her counterpart in russia and they came out in a press event after that and seemed to take the russians' side in a great perhaps existential importance back home. how would that government official be treated and viewed by the government if this were,
8:15 pm
in other words, anyone else in our government, what mechanisms would be triggered? >> you know, i think that if you look at it from the context that there were already this litany of behaviors that existed, very good possibility there would already be an investigation under way that could include everything from the use of national security letters to interviews to fisa activity. the point being to try to build a case against this individual. if they were to make some kind of a disclosure like that, again, it would just heighten our awareness that we were on the right track, that we were looking at somebody who could be betraying this country. it was that stunning yesterday, in terms of the disclosures that were made, in terms of the betrayal, like charlie was talking about, to this country in terms of the oath that we all swear to protect and defend the constitution and this country. so, yeah, it would be another straw on the camel's back, so to
8:16 pm
speak, another piece to the puzzle, as we were making our way through this investigation. it would not bode well for that subject. >> so, charlie, that's bracing to hear if it had been anyone else in government, it may have triggered a fisa-style surveillance of your life. the george will headline that we mentioned at the top of the broadcast was bracing. in your view, charlie, what should your fellow conservatives be doing and saying? who do we see about all of this? >> well, part of the problem, of course, is that this is so unprecedented. you can't really put this in historic context. i wrote a piece yesterday where i said, you know, donald trump is often compared to neville chamberlain, but that's unfair to chamberlain, because chamberlain even though he was deeply wrong-headed was, in fact, patriotic and a serious man. we've never had a president behave this way. there are things that republicans can do. you know, perhaps the maximum would be a resolution of censure
8:17 pm
or a resolution of congress, reasserting our support for what intelligence agencies have done, but i do think this is one of those moments where i think, you know, you pulled aside, you know, the curtain and all the rationalizations and all of the enabling of donald trump, this -- this is who he is. despite the fact that he wraps himself in the cloak of patriotism, it's always donald trump first. i think ashley is exactly right. we've seen this play before. unfortunately we've seen several things. you know, yes, you know, donald trump is still going to blow at some point because this is what he really believes, and, of course, we're going to see what the republicans do. because after charlottesville, you had lots of handwringing, lots of expressions of concern, but ultimately they fell back into line. i think it's going to be an interesting tell whether or not republicans do this, even though we're at this moment where the president of the united states is not reliable in standing up for the united states of america. you know, the man who runs on
8:18 pm
america first stands in front of vladimir putin and he sides with vladimir putin over the united states of america. if this is not one of those turning points i don't know what would be. but, brian, as you know, we've had this conversation dozens of times and we've seen this scenario play out over and over and over again. there is no reason really to expect it's going to be different this time. >> it may take a congress other than the one we know to be existing in washington. three people who know a lot about this story. three people who care deeply about this story. our thanks to ashley parker, to charlie sykes and frank montoya. appreciate it very much, gang. coming up here, we'll talk to former cia director leon panetta about what he thinks there is between putin and trump and what he made of today's attempted walk-back. then later, an update tonight on the attempt in the house of representatives, the aer for mentioned congress to impeach deputy attorney general rod rosenstein. "the 11th hour" just getting started on a tuesday evening. discover our largest variety of crab and crab dishes all year!
8:19 pm
like new crabfest combo. your one chance to have new jumbo snow crab with tender dungeness crab. or try crab lover's dream. sweet, juicy king crab and jumbo snow crab cozied up with crab linguini alfredo. even our shrimp is crab-topped! so hurry in and get your butter-dunkin' game on! 'cause crabfest will be gone in a snap. and now bring home the seafood you crave with red lobster to go. call or order online today. you made moonshine in a backwoods still. smuggled booze and dodged the law. even when they brought you in, they could never hold you down. when i built my family tree and found you, i found my sense of adventure. i set off on a new life, a million miles away. i'm heidi choiniere, and this is my ancestry story. now with over 10 billion historical records, discover your story. get started for free at discover your story.
8:20 pm
you like to be in control. especially when it comes to important stuff. like, say... your car. well, good news. the esurance app lets you keep an eye on your repairs when your car is in the shop. it's kinda like being there, without being there. which is probably better for everyone. that's insurance for the modern world. esurance. an allstate company. click or call. if you way too often...e moves then you might have a common condition called dry mouth... which can be brought on by many things, like medication and medical conditions. biotène provides immediate, long lasting relief from dry mouth symptoms. it is clinically proven to soothe and moisturize a dry mouth. plus, it freshens breath. biotène. immediate and long lasting dry mouth symptom relief.
8:21 pm
streaming must see tv has never been easier. paying for things is a breeze. and getting into new places is even simpler. with xfinity mobile, saving money is effortless too. it's the only network that combines america's largest, most reliable 4g lte with the most wi-fi hotspots. and it can be included with your internet. which could save you hundreds of dollars a year. plus, get $150 dollars when you bring in your own phone. its a new kind of network designed to save you money. click, call or visit a store today.
8:22 pm
as the white house continues to deal with the fallout over president trump's news conference with vladimir putin, former members of the intelligence community are continuing to weigh in on this news over the past 48 hours. well, earlier tonight i had a chance to speak with leon panetta, whose resume may be unmatched in the modern political era, starting with his 16 years in congress representing his california district. he was later omb director and chief of staff in the clinton white house. he then served as both cia director and secretary of defense under president obama. he's a man who maintains close ties to senior defense officials in this country and with officials in the intelligence community. >> mr. secretary, thank you very much for being with us tonight, and i'd like to begin by asking you if you take the president at his word that he misspoke in one
8:23 pm
of the multiple times that he sided with the russians? >> my problem is i'm not sure what this president's word is. i think it was a poor effort at trying to walk back from what he did in helsinki. it was pretty clear when he spoke in helsinki he was saying what he thought, he was saying what he wanted to say and as a result of the political explosion in this country and reaction to that he tried obviously to try to walk it back, but i thought he did a poor job at it. he was reading it -- when you start to parse words like would or wouldn't, you know, it just doesn't really sound like he is honestly trying to say he made a mistake. i think he fought it every bit of the way and it showed. i think the damage has been
8:24 pm
done, and very frankly, he hasn't repaired the damage with what he did today. >> are you worried about the two hours that we may never know about, knowing full well that it's quite likely the russians know what was said with just translators in the room and just the two men? >> i'd be very disappointed if we don't know what went on in that room, but that could very well be the case. there is no question in my mind that the russians know what went on in that room. that's the way they operate. but just the fact that the president of the united states and the leader of russia, our primary adversary, had a closed meeting one-on-one without any aides there to explain to the american people what happened in that room, i think really sets a terrible precedent for the presidency of the united states.
8:25 pm
i think it was a mistake and i think the president's going to pay for it. >> does it make things worse for you knowing, a, this president knows more about the degree of meddling than the rest of us because he's had briefings that civilians have not, and, b, he was given a heads up that these 12 most recent indictments were coming before he left on this trip from his own government? >> brian, this is -- this is about the truth. presidents who underestimate the american people and think that they can tell them whatever they want to tell them and that the american people will accept any lie that they tell them really does underestimate the american people and weaken himself. i don't think there is any question this president received important briefings time and time again that laid out the case how the russians
8:26 pm
specifically took steps to interfere with our election process. the intelligence community has clearly presented that case. 17 intelligence agencies agree that the russians were involved. in addition to that, you now have 12 indictments of russian military officers who were involved in that effort to undermine our election process. there is no question in my mind that the president of the united states knew the truth, and the truth is that the russians were behind this. >> it's hard to watch the helsinki event and not think that something isn't up, and not think that they don't have something on him, to use a phrase. what do you think at long last it might be? >> well, there is no question that there is something here that intimidates the president of the united states.
8:27 pm
i mean, this was a moment in time when you have a major summit like this where the president of the united states, who is sworn to preserve, protect and defend our constitution, has to defend the interests of the united states of america. rather than standing up from strength and really telling the russians that it is unacceptable what they did in the crimea, what they're doing in the ukraine, what they're doing in syria and what they're doing against us in our election process, that that is unacceptable. yes, there are areas we can work with them on but they have to correct their behavior in these other areas. rather than saying that, this president basically coddled mr. putin and it was clear that he was intimidated by that situation. whether the russians have something on this president or not, no one really knows, but
8:28 pm
the way he behaves, there is a clear signal that the russians have something on him. >> you called yesterday, barring such things as assassinations and the like, perhaps the worst day of the modern era of the presidency. former cia director brennan said his behavior was treasonous. do you use that word? >> well, i think -- i think treasonous is a word, you know, that requires in the law an awful lot to be able to make that case. i think this was more of a case of incompetence. that the president rather than preparing for that kind of high-level summit, rather than understanding the history behind that kind of summit, rather than reading into the issues, rather than following the advice, i'm sure, of those around him, his secretary of state, his chief of staff and others, that he had to be strong in that meeting with
8:29 pm
putin and make clear his objections to what the russians were doing. that is what tells us that a president is prepared in order to engage in that kind of summitry. that didn't happen here because this president refuses to learn and to listen and to do what is necessary. he'd rather operate by his gut instincts. that's fine if you're a new york developer. it works if you're a new york developer. it does not work if you're president of the united states. >> former cia director, former secretary of defense, leon panetta with us tonight from california. mr. secretary, thank you so much for being with us. >> thank you, brian. coming up, as we continue the political fallout before and after donald trump's attempt at damage control. how the putin controversy is playing out far from the nation's capital. that is more when we come right back. severe plaque psoriasis
8:30 pm
is not always easy. it's a long-distance run and you have the determination to keep going. humira has a proven track record of being prescribed for over ten years. it's the #1 prescribed biologic by dermatologists. more than 250,000 patients have chosen humira to fight their psoriasis. and they're not backing down. for most patients clearer skin is the proof. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma have happened, as have blood, liver and nervous system problems. serious allergic reactions and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. join over 250,000 people who have chosen humira. ask your dermatologist about humira & go.
8:31 pm
the kayak explore tool shows you the places you can fly on your budget. so you can be confident you're getting the most bang for your buck. alo-ha. kayak. search one and done. douglas! we're running dangerously low on beans. people love your beans, doug. they love 'em. doooooooooug! you want to go sell some tacos? progressive knows small business makes big demands. doug, where do we get a replacement chili pepper bulb? so we'll design the insurance solution that fits your business. it's a very niche bulb. it's a specialty bulb. but prevagen helps your brain with an ingredient originally discovered... in jellyfish. in clinical trials, prevagen has been shown to improve short-term memory. prevagen. healthier brain. better life.
8:32 pm
i'm 85 years old in a job where. i have to wear a giant hot dog suit. what? where's that coming from? i don't know. i started my 401k early, i diversified... i'm not a big spender. sounds like you're doing a lot. but i still feel like i'm not gonna have enough for retirement. like there's something else i should be doing. with the right conversation, you might find you're doing okay. so, no hot dog suit? not unless you want to. no. schedule a complimentary goal planning session today with td ameritrade®.
8:33 pm
in plain english, it's been a heck of a week and it's tuesday, let's not forget, so on nights like this we like to bring in old friends of the smart variety. not old in age, of course, people we've known a long time. here they are. eugene robinson. pulitzer prize winning columnist for "the washington post." jim warren, veteran print journalist, political commenter. these days executive editor of
8:34 pm
the news start-up called news guard that will rate the veracity of all of us in the business, news and information sites. welcome to you. gene robinson, you get credit for calling what we witnessed from the cabinet room a hostage video. the printed remarks, kind of the addendum by sharpie. do you think any minds were changed today? >> i think some reactions were changed. i think there are republican officials in congress, mostly members of congress, who were critical perhaps before the president's remarks who will now accept them. like marco rubio, for example. i don't know that his mind was actually changed about what president trump said, but his -- his rhetoric has certainly changed. and i think for some trump supporters it will be enough. but i to think this was a big deal. i think this is a big deal.
8:35 pm
it's -- that moment with the president of the united states and the president of russia, the president of the u.s. sides with vladimir putin over his own intelligence officials and it raises the question in a very real and present way of the enormous power this man has and his questionable loyalties, frankly. i mean, it's just -- i think that gets to people in a kind of different way. >> speaking of enormous power of the office, nicolle wallace, former white house communications director, said today on her broadcast, say nothing of 27 hours. you can get a transcript of your own remarks if you're president in about 60 seconds. why the 27-hour wait and why the need, jim warren, to write there was no collusion on your own remarks, since it's something you have worked into every set of remarks you've given? >> because presumably he was
8:36 pm
resisting that for all this time. he didn't want to say what he said. leon panetta hit it. i also think one should note something charlie sykes said just a few minutes ago, which i think reflects, perhaps expectedly, a sort of cynical orthodoxy. we've seen this before. we've been here again. we've had a whole day of cable news about this and that. we've said a million times this is beyond the pale but nothing has changed. for sure i think in the short term, and judges by some calls i made tonight to trump supporters in chicago said they were unchanged. certainly by looking as i did all day for my new job at websites this got less play than one would think. in janesville, wisconsin, the big story, 20% hike in water bill. go town to san antonio, a murderer released. chicago, a house fire. here in new york city, the downpour today. >> water spouts spotted off brooklyn. >> at the same time, for all the
8:37 pm
reasons my good friend mentioned, sykes mentioned earlier why this may be interesting because it may ultimately provide the framework for a legitimate primary run by the republicans -- by a republican against donald trump. all the same values that somebody like charlie sykes sees violated, i think it could prop up a run against the president in a primary. as we know, every time there has been a serious run against an incumbent in '68 in mccarthy, the incumbent has ultimately gone down. >> gene, i want to talk about the world order and show you tucker carlson and donald trump taped yesterday in helsinki. here we go. >> so membership in nato obligates the members to defend any other member that is attacked. let's say montenegro joined last year, is attacked. why should my son go to montenegro? >> i understand what you're saying. i've asked the question. mont nag wroe is a very tiny
8:38 pm
country with -- they're very aggressive people. they may get aggressive. congratulations, you're in world war iii. >> gene, how is the world order looking right now? >> not the way it looked a few weeks or months or years ago. >> turns out it wasn't a compliment that montenegroens are strong people. >> that was the president of the united states questioning the very reason for nato, article v, which, by the way, has only been invoked once, by guess who, by the united states after 9/11, not by montenegro, right? to it shouldn't be a surprise. he doesn't believe in the post-world war ii world order as established by, you know, and maintained by presidents for 70 years. he doesn't believe in it. he believes the world started
8:39 pm
when donald trump was inaugurated and took the oath of office and the rest of that is all trash. >> you know 30 seconds when you hear it. where are we on the timeline of trump? are we in the middle of the middle? are we in the beginning of the end? where are we? >> i think we are in the formative stage of a possible interesting republican primary run against donald trump, and i think it would serve folks to go out tomorrow if you can get out to waterloo or dubuque, in a place like iowa, fifth year in a row where farm income has gone down, soy beans are tanking, where people actually know big exports of pork go to china, mexico and canada, the same place he slapped tariffs and they're going to be pretty angry in the midterms and they're going to vent. those are a lots of people who up to this point have said, we kind of like his moxy. >> a guy who just did that is jimfall owes, who we're going to have on this broadcast. also wrote a critical piece this
8:40 pm
week on republicans. >> i would say one quick thing. where we are is four months before november, before a very important election. if you're looking for a point where you can say maybe it's the end of the beginning, that could be november. >> thanks to our friends, eugene robinson, jim warren. coming up, the special counsel's latest move ahead of the manafort trial in a week. we're back with that after this. ! but i am a simple farmer. my life is here... [telephone ring] ahoy-hoy. alexander graham bell here... no, no, my number is one, you must want two! two, i say!! like my father before... [telephone ring] like my father before... ahoy-hoy! as long as people talk too loudly on the phone, you can count on geico saving folks money. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance.
8:41 pm
8:42 pm
who would have guessed? an energy company helping cars emit less. making cars lighter,
8:43 pm
it's a good place to start, advanced oils for those hard-working parts. fuels that go further so drivers pump less. improving efficiency is what we do best. energy lives here. . we are back. and the headlines have been about helsinki largely, but it's easy to forget the special counsel investigation rolls on. the trial of former trump campaign chairman paul manafort expected to start just eight days from now. remember, this is the first trial of the mueller investigation, and today we learned mueller has requested immunity for five potential witnesses who may be called on to testify in this trial. the request did not name them. in fact, it asks that there identities be kept secret to prevent undue harassment or
8:44 pm
reputational harm in case they aren't needed to testify. with us to talk about this tonight, a man who is qualified to do so, guy lewis. former u.s. attorney who also worked with robert mueller, james comey and rod rosenstein, among others, during his time at doj. all right, guy, dual question to start you off. why five requests for immunity and what's the one paragraph viewers guide we're going to need in eight days when they gavel this thing to a start? >> very interesting, brian, how they've sort of teed this issue up. i mean, let's think about it. the special counsel has filed a motion to compel, in essence a motion to force five anonymous people to testify. each one of these people have claimed that if they testify honestly and truthfully that it may subject them to criminal prosecution so they're
8:45 pm
exercising their fifth amendment. so really when i've done this in the past in cases that i prosecuted, this is like playing with fire when you're a prosecutor. the witness comes in, they don't want to be there, they may have criminal liability themselves, and i've had experiences where it's blown up in my face and the witness says, look, you know what, the only reason i'm saying this is because you and the fbi agents are forcing me to do it. >> well, guy, that doesn't sound like the very methodical, orderly special counsel that we've been told about. >> well, listen, he is certainly crossing his ts and dotting his is. he's having his witnesses present. but in many respects, a trial is a lot like a "nightly news" cast. a lot of times things happen that you don't plan on and can't anticipate, but certainly these witnesses, who really i would want to know about, and if i'm
8:46 pm
the defense i would be pounding the table because they have a right to investigate and cross examine the evidence as well. >> guy, i heard a gentleman who like you is a former u.s. attorney say on live tv today, this is what collusion looks like, and he was talking about this russian woman, this maria butina, who has ties to the nra. she's appears in court tomorrow. what can you tell us about this case? where does it fit and how important is it in the scheme of things? >> brian, very, very interesting. so, again, back in the old days when i was a prosecutor, we tried some -- indicted and tried some cuban nationals down here in south florida. it almost looks exactly the same. they were individuals, in this case russian nationals, a russian national student, young lady who has been tasked with reporting information, with
8:47 pm
infi infiltrating certain parts of our institutions, maybe our government. she's reporting -- clearly she's reporting to this fellow, aleksandr torshin, who has ties to moscow and is an important russian banker -- banking official. i would venture to get nat she is being managed by this guy, who it looks like to me is her handler, and maybe there are several others who are out there doing exactly the same thing. >> everyone says it's like an episode of the series "the americans." guy lewis, we will have you back. thank you so much for helping us to explain what's going on these days. coming up, because the plot lines we follow here each night so often sound like fiction, best-selling author dan silva will be here in a moment to talk kremlin secrets and the kgb when when we come back. (vo) what if this didn't have to happen?
8:48 pm
i didn't see it. (vo) what if we could go back? what if our car... could stop itself? in iihs front-end crash prevention testing, nobody beats the subaru impreza. not toyota. not honda. not ford. the subaru impreza. more than a car, it's a subaru. here's a trip tip: when you search hotels on tripadvisor... enter your destination and the dates of your stay. tripadvisor searches over 200 booking sites... to find the best deal on the right hotel for you. tripadvisor. well, esurance makes it simple and affordable. in fact, drivers who switched from geico to esurance saved an average of $412. that's auto and home insurance for the modern world. esurance. an allstate company. click or call. paying too much for insurance that isn't the right fit? well, esurance makes finding the right coverage easy. in fact, drivers who switched from geico to esurance
8:49 pm
saved an average of $412. that's auto and home insurance for the modern world. esurance. an allstate company. click or call. esurance. an allstate company. i'm a fighter. always have been. when i found out i had age-related macular degeneration, amd, i wanted to fight back. my doctor and i came up with a plan. it includes preservision. only preservision areds 2 has the exact nutrient formula recommended by the national eye institute to help reduce the risk of progression of moderate to advanced amd. that's why i fight. because it's my vision. preservision. also, in a great-tasting chewable.
8:50 pm
8:51 pm
u.s. intelligence agencies have unanimously found what is now regarded assetaled fact. russia indeed reached deep within our electoral process, an electronic attack that remains under way as we speak at this moment. it's just the most recent effort of theirs in a campaign to infiltrate american politics dating back by the way to the days of the cold war. that is the subject of a new novel, "the other woman," by best selling author daniel silva. he joins us here in our new york studios. welcome. it's great to see you again. >> nice to be here. >> i reckon you and i are pretty close in age and so we have watched the arc of all things, first soviet union, hen russia. you've had the great good taste to start writing about it for the last decade or so. can you believe as a person our age how much the conversation is about russia and russians here
8:52 pm
in the united states mb of america? >> i can believe it actually. sti wrote my first book dealing with russia in 2008. it was a book called "moscow rules." i spent a big portion of the summer of 2007. moscow and st. piecersburg researching. > what did you know the rest of us didn't know. >> i spent a lot of time with russian dissonants, russian journalists living in fear of vladimir putin. i came to the conclusion in 2007 that vladimir putin and the new russia were a ma leb lent force, we would have big problems with them. when i wrote the first book, it was a very successful novel. i got a lot of blow back on it. people thought you're being too hard on putin. i didn't get it wrong. i got it right. i'll say one other thing about four years ago i wrote a book that dealt with russian meddling in british politics. i didn't make it up completely out of whole cloth. i wrote about it because they
8:53 pm
were doing it in western europe. i guess i'm only surprised it took them so long to do it here in the aunts. >> as people make their way to a brick and mortar bookstore or electronic book seller, what we should know about their tactics and methods that may inform how we will take in the news of the day we'll get in purchasing this book. >> well, i wrote in this book a very old fashioned mole hunt. my hero, gabriel, the legendary head of israeli intelligence is looking for a russian mole that has been inserted into western intelligence. and i wrote that old-fashioned style cold war thrill they are year because i think that there are a lot of similarities between what is going on now in the way putin is conducting himself with the way that the old soviet union conducted
8:54 pm
itself. when i say the old soviet union, i mean going back to the days of the 20s and 30s when a very youthful paranoid but aggressive soviet union under lennon and stalin reached out beyond russia's borders and tampered with the west. they did it through black propaganda, through murder and mayhem. they did it through disinformation campaigns. when vladimir putin meddles in our election, when he meds in brexit, when he kills someone in the united kingdom because of he's opposed to the regime, he's reaching back into a very old toolbox that these guys have been using for almost a century now. and you know what, i'm afraid they're very good at it. >> that's why they're thrillers. we'll live on a cliff daniel silva whose name could make a recipe vault into the top ten. you don't need my luck but best
8:55 pm
of lucking. > thank you very much for coming on. when we come back, warning of the politics of fear. a certain former president critiques the current oval office occupant while never mentioning his name. we're back with that after this. what about him? let's do it. ♪ come on. this summer, add a new member to the family. at the mercedes-benz summer event. lease the glc300 for $429 a month at your local mercedes-benz dealer. mercedes-benz. the best or nothing. but climbing 58,070 steps a year can be hard on her feet, knees, and lower back. that's why she wears dr. scholl's orthotics. they're clinically proven to relieve pain and give you the comfort to move more. dr. scholl's, born to move.
8:56 pm
almost 250 years ago, two lanterns were hung here to warn of the incoming attack on america. today we have to acknowledge what our president won't: our democracy is under attack again. donald trump praises vladimir putin and meets with him on foreign soil, while rejecting our own law enforcement officials who say putin launched a hostile attack on our last election and is planning to do it again this year. why would an american president want to meet with a dictator
8:57 pm
who's trying to undermine our democracy? is trump again getting played by putin, or is he conspiring with a man who helped put him in office? if paul revere and other patriots had waited to act until it was safe or politically correct, we would never have the country we have today. it's time for congress, republicans and democrats, to put their political interests aside and act on behalf of our country. [ horn honking ] [ engine revving ] what's that, girl? [ engine revving ] flo needs help?! [ engine revving ] take me to her! ♪ coming, flo! why aren't we taking roads?! flo. [ horn honking ] -oh. you made it. do you have change for a dollar? -this was the emergency? [ engine revving ] yes, i was busy! -24-hour roadside assistance. from america's number-one motorcycle insurer. -you know, i think you're my best friend. you don't have to say i'm your best friend. that's okay. you don't have to say i'm your best friend. a hilton getaway means
8:58 pm
you get more because... you get another day in paradise. get a sunset on a sunday. get more stories to share. get more from your summer getaway with exclusive hilton offers. book yours, only at last thing before we go here tonight, one day after president trump sided with the leader of an adversarial nation over american intelligence services his predecessor in office was speaking out in defense of democracy. at an event marking the 100th birthday nelson mandela in south africa, former president barack obama warned about the rise of bigotry and nation nationalism. never mentioning trump by name, the former president outlined his concerns over what's happening in our times. >> strong man politics are ascendent suddenly.
8:59 pm
whereby elections and some pretense of democracy are maintained, the form of it, but those in power seek to undermine every institution or norm that gives democracy meaning. unfortunately, too much of politics today seems to reject the very concept of objective truth. people just make stuff up. they just make stuff up. we see the utter loss of shame among political leaders where they're caught in a lie and they just double down and they lie some more. and just as people spoke about the triumph of democracy in the '90s, now you're hearing people talk about the end of democracy. and the triumph of tribalism and the strong man. we have to resist that cynicism.
9:00 pm
because wa we've been through darker times. we've been in lower valleys. >> barack obama in south africa. that is our broadcast on a tuesday night. thank you so very much for being here with us. good night from nbc news headquarters here in new york. >> last night at this time, we were reporting on a new criminal complaint just filed in federal court in washington, d.c. against russian citizen who has now been arrested in this country accused of acting secretly in this country as an agent of the russian government. so last night when we got on the air, we were unable to tell you it was a criminal complaint filed against this is woman, mariia butina. as of right now, it is not just a criminal complaint anymore. now it is an indictment. a grand jury convened by the u.s. attorney so not the special counsel's office,


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on