Skip to main content

tv   Hardball With Chris Matthews  MSNBC  May 13, 2019 4:00pm-5:00pm PDT

4:00 pm
that does it for me. ari will be back tomorrow. i'll see you back here tomorrow morning on "first look" at 5:00 a.m. eastern. "hardball" with chris matthews starts right now. trump justice? let's play "hardball." good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. tonight, donald trump is attacking his own people. not content to fire away at democrats or the media or anyone else for that matter, the president's at war now with the very people he appointed to their top positions. his targets anyone who shows loyalty to the rule of law, to historic government institutions like the fbi, anyone or thing but donald j. trump. over the weekend trump turned
4:01 pm
his rage against two administration officials, former white house counsel don mcgahn and his fbi director christopher wray. trump is trashing mcgahn after the news broke friday that mcgahn had refused trump's demand to clear him of obstruction of justice for trying to fire special counsel mueller. on saturday trump tweeted "i was not going to fire bob mueller and did not fire bob mueller. actually, lawyer don mcgahn had a much better chance of being fired than mueller. never a big fan." separately, trump's attack on fbi director wray comes after wray refused to say in his testimony last week that the fbi had spied on trump's campaign. trump wanted him to use that word "spy." in a series of tweets yesterday, trump quoted a right-wing activist saying, ""the fbi has no leadership. the director is protecting the same gang that tried to overthrow the president through an illegal coup." mcgahn and wray join a growing list of officials whom the
4:02 pm
president has publicly attacked after hiring them for top jobs. the list from "the washington post" includes the former secretary of states and defense. his former chief of staff. the chairman of the federal reserve. the pattern of behavior shows that trump doesn't want civil seshts in his government. he wants office holders to be his servants. meanwhile, the president's administration continues to erode the separation of powers by stonewalling congress at every turn. "the washington post" again counted 20 house inquiries that the president and his allies have blocked by ignoring requests or refusing subpoenas all together. i'm joined now by u.s. congresswoman jackie speier, democrat of california and a member of the house intelligence and oversight committee. hei heidi przybyla. congresswoman, i just want to say, what do you make of this guy's penalty? he hires people to be his top lawyer in the white house, the head of the fbi, these are incredibly important positions. now he trashes them.
4:03 pm
>> well, it's very typical of the president. he is paranoid. he is, you know, a narcissist, anti-social behavior. he loves to attack people. he gets his thrills out of attacking people. don mcgahn, the white house counsel, is probably responsible for keeping donald trump out of jail by preventing him from firing bob mueller. i mean, he was going to actually resign, if we recall correctly, and he didn't because donald trump finally said, okay, i won't do it. >> well, you know, in a way what he points out the character of other people and his own lack. what do you think about the fact that mcgahn has stood up to him and he won't clear him on obstruction of justice? he refuses under testimony. >> well -- >> he won't say the president is clean. then wray refuses the word "spy." it reminds me what george bush sr once said, i'm not going to allow the nra to describe fbi
4:04 pm
officials as jackbooted thugs. he believed in the government. trump doesn't. >> so what we have is a president who wants a group of sycophants around him. if you stand up to him at all, you're either fired or leave on your own accord. as you pointed out, there is a very long list. this president can't keep staff, he can't field a cabinet and he can't work with congress. this is not someone who should be the president of the united states. and lindsey graham is a classic example. >> what do you make of him? what's he up to? >> well, on the campaign trail, you remember, he said things like he's a cookkook, i think h frae crazy, he has done a total flip and become one of those sycophants because he's afraid if he isn't, he will lose his senatorial seat. >> i think like you do, congresswoman, politically, occasionally. just kidding. you know what his republican
4:05 pm
support is in south carolina? lindsey graham's state is for trump, it's 82%, more than 4 out of 5. that's a safe place to be a sycophant. anyway, here's what the president said today when asked about his unprecedentied stonewalling of the u.s. congress. >> if you're so transparent why continue to block these house democrats looking for information? >> because they're asking for things that they're not entitled to. i could ask them, i assume, if they ask me, i could ask them for the same kind of thing. they wouldn't want to do it. >> an arthere he is sitting nex that autocrat from hungary, orban. he wants to be like orban. senator lindsey graham chose to side with the president's family over the institution he serves in, which is the united states senate. graham said donald trump jr. should not comply with the subpoena from his colleagues in the senate intelligence committee. here he is. >> if i was donald trump's lawyer, i would tell him you
4:06 pm
don't need to go back into this environment anymore. you've been there for hours and hours and hours and nothing being alleged here changes the outcome of the mueller investigation. i would call it a day. >> elliot, what do you make of the fact that the president's telling, well, actually the senator from south carolina, the friend of the president, golfing buddy, is saying ignore subpoenas from the senate. >> boy, the fear of a primary challenge is one hell of a drug. i tell you that because he sort of mixed up -- what would 1999, impeachment lindsey graham or 2006 lindsey graham, cutting immigration deals with democrats, think about what we just watched right there? it's feeding into the president's notion that congress isn't a co-equal branch of government that is entitled to do its own investigating of criminal and other matters. >> these guys aren't profiles in courage, are they? >> no, the thing is it is not just lindsey graham, and i think this is a moment that was under appreciated. it's not just mitch mcconnell, chris. did you watch the senate judiciary committee interview
4:07 pm
bill barr? there were hardly any questions about what was very, very troubling report, a two-year report on just the extent to which the russians attacked this country and the questions were all about investigating the investigators. it was very partisan, and i think a sign that the president continues to do this because he gets away with it. you showed that long list of people who have been given the boot. it continues to happen because unless you are a republican who is retiring, and we saw this in the last congress and we're seeing it in this congress. we saw it in the last congress with corker being the lone voice and now with burr on the senate judiciary committee. intelligence committee being the one person who is going to be to stand up for it here and he's getting beat up for it. so it is not just one or two republicans, it is a party systemic issue. >> graham's whole thing also called attention to the fact that don jr. did not speak to mueller the first time around. so everybody is getting
4:08 pm
conscripted into protecting the trump family and lindsey graham is carrying the president's water. it seems like he would do quite well as a member of the administration because she's schilling for the president -- >> congresswoman, what do you think about this cult of personality? because it does seem that the republican party, i grew up in a moderate republican family. my brothers, a couple of them still are, but they actually believe in fiscal responsibility, they actually believe in alliances around the world, they actually believe in rule by law. trump doesn't believe in anything except trump. it really is a difference and yet this party is going along with him like little ducklings, trumpeting behind the master. >> what's really remarkable here is senator burr has actually voted with the president over 80% of the time. so his calling on donald trump jr. to come before him with a subpoena is because they've negotiated for months and donald trump jr. has not been cooperative. he used the world "cult."
4:09 pm
i know a fair amount about cults, having been in jonestown back in 1978, and it's a little eerie to see the kind of sycophants that the senate has become on behalf of the president. and it's all about somehow being able to stay in the senate. if the -- if the voter started to turn, you would see those senators turn just as fast. >> well, that term which we use for years, maybe dark humor, drinking the kool-aid. when you bump into your republican colleagues, and you do, as far as the traffic over there in the house. you bump into them. do they look like they'rezonked? do they admit to you, hey, i got to get re-elected. >> of course they do. >> they do? >> of course. there are a number who roll their eyes about the president but they're worried about
4:10 pm
someone from the right running against them in the republican primary. >> wow. here is somebody who drank deeply of the whatever the kool-aid. here is rudy giuliani. he says he's cancelled his trip to ukraine to ask the government of that country to investigate trump's political opponent joe biden. giuliani's attempts to enlist a foreign country, of course, to interfere in another presidential election provoked widespread outrage after it was reported by "the times" last week, that he's going over there to get dirt on this president, the current president's possible opponent, joe biden. anyway, late friday night giuliani announced he's backing off the idea of going to ukraine not because it's wrong or even illegal, but he now says the government of ukraine is trump's enemy. let's watch this. >> i'm not going to go to the ukraine. >> you're not going to go? >> i'm not going to go because i think i'm walking into a group of people that are enemies of the president, in some cases enemies of the united states. >> well, now trump is saying he could urge the attorney general to investigate biden. he said his possible 2020
4:11 pm
opponent. as trump told politico late friday, certainly would be an appropriate thing to speak to him about, but i have not done that as yet. heidi, you know everything so i'm going to ask you this. what happened to rudy giuliani's crazy trip to kiev? could it be that he was punked. i'm reading that the group inviting him did not have a good intention for him. >> first of all, was he invited? a lot of the reporting was that he was going to go there and try to get a meeting. some of the reporting is that they didn't want to meet with him. >> zalesky, the new president. >> in some sense he got punk'd. the brazenness and the openness. okay, i'm going to get on a united flight to kiev and talk to a foreign government about how he can try to bring down trump's political adversary. all above board. >> i'm sorry. go ahead. >> on top of that, there is no world in which it's ever okay for the president of the united states to direct or dictate -- to dictate prosecutions. look, i watched a show with a
4:12 pm
woman riding a dragon blowing up a city last night and it's not okay there either. there is never a circumstance. this is why we left the british republic -- the british empire, the thought of rulers getting too much power and using that power to go after the political adversaries. >> public pressure still matters a bit. why do you think rudy giuliani didn't pull off his trip to kiev, congresswoman? do you think it was the embarrassment, everybody thought you look like an idiot going over there looking for more dirt when the whole colossal scandal over the last few years and about getting dirt from an eastern party? >> so, a couple of things. first of all, he is not a member of the executive branch. so was he going to fly over there on a campaign credit card from donald trump? i think clearly he was probably violating the logan act. the president's been throwing the logan act around, but he is not a member of the administration, and is going to a foreign country to negotiate with that foreign country. once again, i think the
4:13 pm
president is operating off the seat of his pants and probably what happened is there was a lot of blowback. >> yeah. >> because they got off of it very fast. >> and i don't think rudy giuliani -- speaking of pants, i don't think he was spending any personal funds on this trip to go to ukraine. my guess. >> this is, you know, we laugh about it, but this is what "lock her up" was all about during the campaign and wed media were berated for taking it seriously. and now you have rudy giuliani going to kiev and you have the president saying that it's well within his rights to talk with barr about investigating his political adversaries. >> there is a long bipartisan tradition and history in the justice department of the president, even as the head of the executive branch, not meddling in the affairs of the justice department. i was making the -- >> so it's wrong to suggest the prosecution? >> it is absolutely wrong to suggest a prosecution. it's absolutely wrong, frankly, to talk about the substance of prosecutions with anyone in the justice department. even as the head of the executive branch, there is a
4:14 pm
pretty strict and clear wall between the executive branch. >> i remember the big steel crisis and bobby and jack kennedy going after the steel executives. 5:00 in the morning, the fbi was investigating these guys. >> well -- >> using their expense accounts for their girlfriends. it was pretty rough in those days. >> in the justice department i worked in for six years at a very senior level, i remember quite specifically if the white house ever tried sniffing around anything we were doing, it was a problem. >> a policy created after watergate to prevent this type of undue influence -- >> after bobby and jack kennedy. >> times have changed for the better, young man. meanwhile, treasury secretary steve mnuchin has until this friday to comply with a house subpoena for the president's tax returns, which he has so far, of course, refused to turn over to the congress. the president now says he wants them to be an election issue, his tax returns, tweeting "i won the 2016 election partially based on no tax returns while i'm under audit, which i still am, and the voters didn't care.
4:15 pm
now the radical left democrats now want to regate this matter and make it a part of the 2020 election." today congressman bill pascrell of new jersey threatened to fine or jail secretary mnuchin if he doesn't comply. >> mr. mnuchin should remember as our treasury secretary that 71 -- 7214 in the code is even clearer as to what happens if you do not hand over the tax returns. there are fines. there is jail. there is -- et cetera, et cetera. this is serious business. >> okay, congresswoman, this is "hardball," and i will bring out my sarcastic wit. can you imagine the sergeant at arms for the u.s. house of representatives going to the treasury department demanding entrance into the treasury building right next to the white house, demanding to be able to arrest the secretary of the treasury because he's not complying with this subpoena and dragging him up to some cell on
4:16 pm
capitol hill and putting him in there until such time as it's decided how to proceed? now, i don't think that's going to happen or will it be a fine exacted against the secretary of the treasury. all these remedies in the pocket of the constitution, somewhere in the statute book, how are you going to make them work? >> well, chris, they're there for a reason. now, they haven't been used since the 1930s, but we do have that authority, and i don't think you should dismiss so cavalierly the -- >> but how do you do it, though? >> well, no, i think you -- i think we can call him to the house floor where he can be tried, he can be find. i don't know that we will put him in -- behind bars, but there are places in the capitol where someone could be held. i mean, this is so clear in the constitution -- >> this is so venezuela. this is so venezuela, congresswoman. you really think that the congress -- go ahead. you go ahead. >> well, it's so clear in the constitution or in the statute that you shall turn over the tax
4:17 pm
returns. >> i know. >> so the fact that that hasn't happened, that there are lackeys in these positions that are not complying with it, means that they are violating the law, and congress does have independent authority. we are an equal branch of government with the executive branch, and the president doesn't get that. he somehow thinks that he is superior. he is not. the only thing that is superior is the constitution of the united states. >> i agree completely in this sentiment and the spirit of what you say, i just wonder, how does it become operational? you believe there is a real possibility plausibly that the u.s. congress will send the sergeant-at-arms of the house to go arrest the secretary of state of the treasury? that's plausible? >> i think it could happen. i think it could happen. >> well, that's news. >> but even if it doesn't, we still haven't gone to the courts yet. there is still another branch of government that, you know, that can address this. >> judge kavanaugh is waiting for the case. >> if they don't comply with the court order then we're at a crisis.
4:18 pm
>> i think we got to vote next year, the american people have to vote on this kind of government and react to it strongly or it's going to get worse. a second term of trump will be much more of this scuff lawrie. thank you. sorry to put you on the skill, but i really do have a problem with the operational powers of congress. i think it's an -- who is getting hit hardest by the trade wars? we're getting serious where the tire hits the road. trump says it's china, but the american consumer also getting hit with 25% markups and all we buy. all that cotton is this the necessary price to stop china's economic aggression, however? plus, trump's long fight to change washington's 4th of july celebration to make it -- i can't believe he's grabbing the 4th of july and turning this year's event, the 4th, into the mother of all maga rallies. much more ahead. stick with us. us.
4:19 pm
woman: (on phone) discover. hi. do you have a travel card? yep. our miles card. earn unlimited 1.5 miles and we'll match it at the end of your first year. nice! i'm thinking about a scuba diving trip. woman: ooh! (gasp) or not. you okay? yeah, no, i'm good. earn miles. we'll match 'em at the end of your first year. our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy! whoo-hoo! great-tasting ensure. with nine grams of protein
4:20 pm
and twenty-six vitamins and minerals. ensure, for strength and energy. safe drivers shouldnt have to pay as much for insurance... as not safe drivers! that's why esurance has drivesense.® the safer you drive, the more you save. although i'm not really driving right now that would be unsafe. when insurance is affordable, it's surprisingly painless. age-related macular i've degeneration, with which could lead to vision loss. so today i made a plan with my doctor, which includes preservision. because it's my vision, my morning walk, my sunday drive, my grandson's beautiful face. only preservision areds 2 contains the exact nutrient formula recommended by the national eye institute to help reduce the risk of moderate to advanced amd progression. because it's my sunset, it's how i see my life. it's my vision.
4:21 pm
here'sshow me making it. like. oh! i got one. the best of amy poehler. amy, maybe we could use the voice remote to search for something that you're not in. show me parks and rec. from netflix to prime video to live tv, xfinity lets you find your favorites with the emmy award-winning x1 voice remote. show me the best of amy poehler, again. this time around... now that's simple, easy, awesome. experience the entertainment you love on x1. access netflix, prime video, youtube and more, all with the sound of your voice. click, call or visit a store today.
4:22 pm
the bottom line is we are taking in tremendous amounts of money. it already started as of last friday, but it really started seven months before that. it's in the form of tariffs or taxes. and it had a tremendous impact. so we're in a very good position and i think it's only going to get better. >> welcome back to "hardball." that was president trump, of course, in the oval office today saying he isn't backing down on his escalating trade war with china. after trump raised tariffs on $200 billion worth of chinese goods last week, china fired back with $60 billion worth of tariffs on american goods. for president trump who can boast about a much-improved u.s. economy, this promised battle was the potential -- has the potential to cause some economic pain everywhere. in the last five trading days, for example, the dow jones average has dropped almost 1,000 points, costing stakeholders the reality of about a 4% loss of their wealth. that's a lot. the president has tweeted and retweeted more than two dozen
4:23 pm
times about the economy and the ongoing trade war. while the president continues to incorrectly say it is china who is paying for tariffs, his own economic adviser, lawrence kudlow, is saying it's americans who are going to suffer. >> in fact, both sides will pay, both sides will pay in these things, and, of course, it depends -- >> if it's a tariff on goods coming into the country, the chinese aren't paying. >> no, but the chinese will suffer gdp losses and so forth. >> they may suffer consequences, but it's u.s. businesses and u.s. consumers who pay, correct? >> yes, to some extent. i don't disagree with that. >> i don't disagree with that because it's true. no more, i'm joined by republican strategist and democratic strategist. in all fairness, i think donald trump, although he's in many ways a wealthy guy and a republican now. >> you think he is now? >> he's also running against trade. that is a position a lot of people i grew up with in pennsylvania were against. they thought it was negative.
4:24 pm
they didn't like all the free trade talk. it killed industry in states like pennsylvania. some people like sherrod brown of ohio and casey and a lot of democrats very much against what's been called free trade. trump comes along and says i'm going to do something about it. everybody knows, joel, it's going to hurt. if you get into a trade war with a country that makes stuff really well. i mean, the cotton undershirts, dress shirts, everything we buy is cotton, is 100% cotton and everybody likes it. and it comes from china. it doesn't kill us. so it's very hard to fight with them. we want their stuff. >> yeah, look, i think the president -- look, even as a democrat has made a smart play on trade, but he's like a bull in a china shop. what he's not taking into account is the collateral damage he's causing to the economy. you mentioned the 4% impacted by the stock market. what about all the people impacted by goods going up in costs? and also not to be honest about it it's the same thing saying mexico's going to pay for the
4:25 pm
wall. >> you're a democratic strategist. what would a good democrat do on trade? we've been stuck with this issue for years with china. >> there are places to agree with the president on china. i think senator sherrod brown has been smart to find those places. i would not line up donald trump in terms of tone and being the economic statesman we're expecting in the oval office. >> well said. >> here's what people don't understand. this is donald trump. i would argue that china might be the biggest reason that he ran. what he's doing is saying, look, there is one thing worse than getting a no deal and that's getting a really bad deal. most politicians will go, they'll have these meetings, and if they walk away with no deal they say we failed. that's not how trump looks at it. second of all, trump believes in the case of china right now we're negotiating from strength. their economy is nowhere near as strong as our economy and he's willing to go there -- >> real simply, what do we sell in china? i know we buy cotton goods, khaki pants and everything. what do we sell them? >> we sell them soy beans and
4:26 pm
right now they're down 90% because of their whole tariffs deal. what's interesting, though, is the farmers and people in the rust belt are still staying with this president, understanding we need to have a long-term deal not short term. >> it's a base strategy. there is not a strategy that is built after going after moderates or independents. he doesn't care about that. he's created this culture war where he's got 35% to 40% of the people that are always going to be with him. >> what are these people trading? giving up economic pain, accepting it. higher prices. >> they want to be a part of the trump gang or the trump club. >> i'm talking about voters. i'm talking about regular voters. >> that's what i'm talking about, too. these people want to be associated with donald trump. >> while president trump's confrontational approach to china should come as no surprise as he campaigned heavily on the issue, as you said, joel, in 2016. let's watch. >> we're going to stand up to china on trade. >> china, which has been ripping us off.
4:27 pm
the greatest abuser in the history of this country. >> we can't continue to allow china to rape our country, and that's what they're doing. it's the greatest theft in the history of the world. >> then they say we're going to lose the trade war. we're already lose the trade war, folks. >> we're losing $500 billion in trade with china. who the hell cares if there is a trade war? >> we're in a competition with the world, and i want america to win. >> when it comes to the president's supporters on issues like this, "wall street journal" columnist peggy newnan writes, i have never talked to a trump support who are thought that trump had a high personal character, on the other high they believe he has a high political character, in that he pursues the issues he campaigned on. hey hired him as a hail mary pass. because we agree with him on the issues, john. >> she's right. here's what i don't understand. the left keeps saying, well, he's just playing to the base and they're responding. well, his base are democrats in
4:28 pm
places like pittsburgh, detroit, youngstown, ohio. i don't understand why the left is constantly criticizing the base they wish they had. on this particular issue they think we've been getting sand kicked in our face all over the world for decades and -- >> and now they're being lied to by a president saying they are not going to shoulder the burden of his food fight with china. >> they see somebody standing up and representing them and giving them a mega phone for the first time in a long time and they like it, quite frankly. >> my problem with the chinese, they're good at it. they have long-term plans. they had two bad centuries after the 19th and 20th, they're going to win this century. they get all that cash from us and buy all the land in africa. >> can i say something about the economy. >> that's what they do. i want to say that point. china wins. they beat us on trade and go around buying up resources all around the world. forever. >> there is a part of that that trump plays into, which is we're not going to get kicked around again, which is smart political
4:29 pm
theater. i want to make the point that i think there is this thought that donald trump has -- you know, how can he lose with this economy? i think you should turn it around the other way and say how he is not winning by more? >> because of his character. because of his character. >> with one of the greatest economies we've ever seen. >> what peggy newnan wrote, his personal character. >> i appreciate you saying he's created one of the greatest economies of all time. >> thanks, obama. >> i was taught in school, in grad school. working for a phd, actually, at one point, you couldn't get 3.6% unemployment. something's going on. pennsylvania by the latest numbers, incredible numbers in pennsylvania on the economy. thank you. a quick reminder, don't miss "hardball's" special live event "the deciders." we're heading to pennsylvania to figure out what issues are important to people there and why they vote the way they do, that's thursday night at 7:00 p.m. eastern on msnbc. >> coming up next, the trump administration is cracking down on u.s. citizens who -- any good
4:30 pm
samaritan who helps the migrants they bump in to. what are you supposed to do? the good samaritan could be facing criminal charges after pulling off the highway to help three young migrants in distress. ts in distress alright, i brought in ensure max protein... give you the protein you need with less of the sugar you don't (grunti)g i'll take that. (cheering) 30 grams of protein and 1 gram of sugar ensure. for strength and energy. it's either the assurance of a 165-pointor it isn't.on proces. it's either testing an array of advanced safety systems. or it isn't. it's either the peace of mind of a standard 5-year unlimited mileage warranty. or it isn't. for those who never settle,
4:31 pm
it's either mercedes-benz certified pre-owned. or it isn't. the mercedes-benz certified pre-owned sales event. now through may 31st. only at your authorized mercedes-benz dealer. and i heard that my cousin's so, wife's sister's husband was a lawyer, so i called him. but he never called me back! if your cousin's wife's sister's husband isn't a lawyer, call legalzoom and we'll connect you with an attorney. legalzoom. where life meets legal. your control. like bedhead. hmmmm. ♪ rub-a-dub ducky... and then...there's national car rental. at national, i'm in total control. i can just skip the counter and choose any car in the aisle i like. so i can rent fast without getting a hair out of place. heeeeey. hey! ah, control. (vo) go national. go like a pro. so, i started with the stats regarding my
4:32 pm
moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. like how humira has been prescribed to over 300,000 patients. and how many patients saw clear or almost clear skin in just 4 months - the kind of clearance that can last. humira targets and blocks a specific source of inflammation that contributes to symptoms. numbers are great. and seeing clearer skin is pretty awesome, too. that's what i call a body of proof. humira can lower your ability to fight infections. serious and sometimes fatal infections, including tuberculosis, and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. want more proof? ask your dermatologist about humira. this is my body of proof.
4:33 pm
welcome back to "hardball." president trump's call for a wall on the southern border with mexico has been at the center of his plan, of course, to crack down on illegal immigration.
4:34 pm
well, meanwhile "the new york times" reports, "as the trump administration moving on multiple fronts to shut down illegal border crossings, it has also stepped up punitive measures targeting private american citizens who provide compassionate help to migrants, good samaritan aid often intended to save somebody's live." in january four humanitarian aid volunteers with an arizona nonprofit were convicted of misdemeanor charges for leaving water and food for migrants coming by. an additional volunteer with the group faces felonies, harboring and concealment charges. "the new york times" highlights the case of texas attorney teresa todd. the report notes that ms. todd told three young people to get out of the cold and into her car. when a sheriff's deputy drove up, followed soon by the border patrol. she says they asked me to step behind my car and the supervisor came and started mirandizing me. and then he says that i could be
4:35 pm
found guilty of transporting illegal aliens. wow. joining me right now is teresa todd, county attorney in texas. thank you for coming on. >> thank you for having me on. >> i think the best thing you can do without many questions from me is tell us your good samaritan experience and how it went the way it did. >> yes. i was driving home from work one night. i had had a late meeting at the city of martha and i had a working dinner after that. it was almost 1:0:00, and i was driving the 20 miles between martha and ft. davis where i live in jeff davis county, and a young man just ran out into the road and flagged me down. he was about the same size as -- he looked about the same age as my younger son. so my heart just went out to him and i thought, oh, my lord, i've got to stop and help this young man. what if this were my son?
4:36 pm
i would want somebody to stop and help him. so i turned around, drove all the way back around and stopped to talk to him, and he was with his brother and his sister. they had all been traveling for days. they didn't have food or water. and his sister was very, very ill. i could tell that she needed immediate medical attention. it was chilly that night. so i asked them to get in my car so they would be in out of the elements. i turned on the heater and i called -- tried to call a friend who works for a refugee services organization, and then i called my friend who is sector council for the u.s. border patrol. and while i'm making these calls, i see someone pull up very slowly behind me. i don't know who it is and it was very scary because i didn't know if it was somebody who might want to cause harm to the
4:37 pm
kids or to me. so it ended up -- it was a county sheriff's deputy. he came and i explained the situation. i explained that the sister who now i know her name is esmeralda. that she needed medical assistance immediately. the border patrol came and i assumed that i, of course, would be asked to come down to the station and give a statement. i'm a prosecutor in texas. we take statements from witnesses. but when they asked me to step behind my car and started mirandizing me for harboring or transporting illegal aliens, it was very surreal and it was crazy and i immediately said, i didn't do that, i didn't do anything, i'm just trying to help these kids. but they took the kids in -- >> well, here's the question -- we've got to figure out the
4:38 pm
lesson because everything has to give us a lesson. what were you supposed to do as a human being, an american or whatever, you're driving along in the dark, you see people in desperate trouble. are they arguing you should have just left them alone out there to die maybe, in the one case of the one person who is really in trouble physically? is that what they said to you, just let them alone, just leave them out there alone? >> no, what they did say after they released me was that it wasn't safe for me traveling alone to have stopped to help anyone on the side of the road. >> hmm. what do you think should be done? is there an experience there that is useful to -- there is always this battle between humanity and our sovereignty. how do we protect our sovereignty and respect the humanity of people who are in desperate need of a better life? how do we put the two together? that, to me, is the conundrum. >> it's a great question, chris, and i've thought a lot about it. in texas law we have several defenses to prosecution for situations where one person is
4:39 pm
trying to help another. we have a defense of necessity. we have a defense of defense of third persons and we have another defense that has to do with people's physical welfare. so i believe that -- i'm not aware of there being any of these types of defenses under a federal immigration law, but i think there needs to be. i think that's how we preserve our humanity. >> okay. well said. so great to have you on. so glad we read about your story in "the new york times." good luck with the legal proceedings. i got to believe you're going to make it, but you're a good person. i'll tell you that. i know that. if i was out there in the desert, i'd want you to stop. up next, by way -- thank you. donald trump thinks americans, independents day, our celebrations here in washington need to be more about donald trump. how this president's inserts -- you won't believe this. this is cartoonish. how he's inserting himself into america's birthday celebration. it used to be the beach boys, now it's him. stay with us. celebrating mother's day.
4:40 pm
we're celebrating colleen's day. julia's day. marie's day. and all the one-of-a-kind women we call "mom." ancestrydna tells a story as unique as she is... ...with an engaging new experience that can help her uncover rich family details. give her ancestrydna for ...denise's day... . and at just $59, grab one for jeff's day, too. order a kit at ♪ leave no man behind. or child. or other child. or their new friend. or your giant nephews and their giant dad.
4:41 pm
or a horse. or a horse's brother, for that matter. the room for eight, 9,000 lb towing ford expedition.
4:42 pm
4:43 pm
welcome back to "hardball." ever since president trump got to see the splendid pageantry of bastille day celebrated in france, there it is, he's been trying to have one at home for himself. as soon as he got home from paris, he got to work. >> i was one of your guests at bastille day. it was one of the greatest parades i've ever seen. one of my early calls were i think we're going to have to start looking at that ourselves. we're actually thinking about 4th of july, pennsylvania avenue, having a really great parade to show our military strength. >> sometimes he talks like he's 8 years old. well, that idea quickly morphed into a plan to host a military parade on veterans day which eventually flamed out because it was too expensive. in february during a cabinet meeting president trump announced he was considering
4:44 pm
hosting a 4th of july event at the lincoln memorial. >> we're thinking about doing something which would become perhaps a tradition, a salute to america on july 4th or july 4th weekend. somewhere around that area. i think it would be a very exciting day, and the fireworks is there anyway, so we just saved on fireworks. we get free fireworks because it's already being done. >> that's why they have cabinet meetings. that tradition for 4th of july celebrations clearly already exists. in fact, washington, d.c. has a long history of paying tribute to our military during this national holiday. stay tuned to find out how president trump plans to rebrand trumpy, the 4th of july. you're watching "hardball." that's why there's otezla. otezla is not a cream. it's a pill that treats plaque psoriasis differently. with otezla, 75% clearer skin is achievable. don't use if you're allergic to otezla. it may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. otezla is associated with an increased risk of depression.
4:45 pm
tell your doctor if you have a history of depression or suicidal thoughts or if these feelings develop. some people taking otezla reported weight loss. your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. tell your doctor about your medicines and if you're pregnant or planning to be. ready to treat differently with a pill? otezla. show more of you. safe drivers shouldnt have to pay as much for insurance... as not safe drivers! that's why esurance has drivesense.® the safer you drive, the more you save. although i'm not really driving right now that would be unsafe. when insurance is affordable, it's surprisingly painless. it's how we care for our patients- like job. his team at ctca treated his cancer and side effects. so job can stay strong for his family. cancer treatment centers of america. appointments available now. play it cool and escape heartburn fast
4:46 pm
♪ tum tum tum tums so should the way you bank. virtual wallet from pnc bank. just one way pnc is modernizing banking to help make things easier. pnc bank. make today the day. pnc bank. i needthat's whenvice foi remembered that my ex-ex- ex-boyfriend actually went to law school, so i called him. he didn't call me back! if your ex-ex- ex-boyfriend isn't a lawyer, call legalzoom and we'll connect you with an attorney. legalzoom. where life meets legal. metastatic breast cancer is relentless, but i was relentless first. relentless about learning the first song we ever danced to.
4:47 pm
about teaching him to put others first. about helping her raise her first child. and when i was first diagnosed, my choice was everyday verzenio. it's the only one of its kind that can be taken every day. it gives us more time without cancer progressing. verzenio is the only cdk4 & 6 inhibitor approved with hormonal therapy that can be taken every day for postmenopausal women with hr+, her2- mbc. diarrhea is common, may be severe, or cause dehydration or infection. before taking verzenio, tell your doctor if you have fever, chills, or other signs of infection. verzenio may cause low white blood cell counts, which may cause serious infection that can lead to death. serious liver problems can occur. symptoms include tiredness, appetite loss, stomach pain, and bleeding or bruising. blood clots that can lead to death have occurred. tell your doctor if you have pain or swelling in your arms or legs, shortness of breath, chest pain, rapid breathing or heart rate, or if you are pregnant, nursing, or plan to be pregnant. common side effects include nausea, infections, low blood cells and platelets, decreased appetite, headache, abdominal pain, tiredness, vomiting, and hair thinning or loss. my relentless reason: it's them.
4:48 pm
my choice with my doctor: it's verzenio. ask your doctor if everyday verzenio is right for your first treatment. back to "hardball." if you're planning to visit the national mall for the 4th of july celebration, take note that things are changing. according to "the washington post," president trump has taken charge of the 4th of july. the celebration receiving regular briefings on the effort in the oval office and has got involved in the minutia of the planning. showing interest in the event he often doesn't exhibit for other administration priorities. administration officials tell "the washington post" that the fireworks display is moving from the mall to a location closer to potomac river and plans are being made for the president himself to deliver an address from the steps of the lincoln memorial. for more than 50 years, of course, the national park services has been in charge of the event, which includes a free
4:49 pm
concert on the lawn of the capitol. for more i'm joined by dana m milbank and michael beschloss. let's start with the history. the beach boys, the reagans were so smart. they never tried to politicize it. >> absolutely. >> blazing hot in washington. it's the hottest month, according to the farmer's almanac. hotter than march. much hotter than august. it just blazes and sweats. the one thing is free entertainment on the mall and now he wants to turn it into a trump event. >> and without the president sticking his face in the middle of it, you know, that's a tradition, it goes all the way back to george washington who from the very beginning he could have been a king, he could have been called your majesty. he didn't want that. what did he do on the 4th of july? he couldn't have given a speech somewhere. he mostly spent it at mount
4:50 pm
vernon. calvin coolidge was trout tissuing. they tend to watch from the balcony. >> -- >> the federal reserve does the same thing. but it's not about the president. it's about tcountry. it's about our founders, our history. we'll see what donald trump does with this. if this turns out to be a donald trump festival, this sounds more like a authoritarian government than ours. >> a little bit of el duche, no? >> this is the worst parade envy i've heard. first etrihe tried to take over veterans day. >> you have to turn these things to the period. >> when trump took -- >> parade envy. where did you get that line from? >> to mount vernon and he said -- he was baffled that george washington had not named mount vernon after himself. >> right. >> he said if you don't name stuff after yourself, nobody's ever going to remember you. of course, that's exactly what
4:51 pm
happened to poor george washington. >> but he got a capital named after him. >> yes, that's the point. this is what trump has always done, first with his buildings and now he's trying to inject himself into christmas. >> right. >> tonight is the iftar dinner at the white house. no doubt it's the donald trump ramadan celebration or something like that. >> i feel like we're watching will burr wilbur -- >> ross. >> and as the president has a serious meeting. why don't we have a big celebration with me giving a big speech. >> did you expect them to disagree? >> it's so frightening. >> foirks on the national mall. >> but the part of the president that is 8 years old, is so true. and actually i think some people vote for him would agree with it. some parts of him are like that kid in "big," the grown-up who is actually still a kid. he likes big parades. he wants to have, you know, like nixon wanting the big uniforms. what you want if you're 8 years old. i want a parade. i'm president. >> i hope that's all it is,
4:52 pm
chris. >> help me out here. >> i hope we can come back and say that's all it was. i'm not so sure. the host of victor orban, the dictator of hungary, who said he was a great guy and approves of what he's done in his country of hungary. there are a lot of signs that suggest that we're not exactly dealing with the free floating anxiety and -- >> why -- >> donald trump would love to be a dictator. >> i do think it's scary for history. he likes kim jong-un for no reason. >> right. >> he likes vladimir putin for no reason. he likes netanyahu, slightly different classification. he likes tough guys. >> yeah. >> well -- >> yet he won't talk to the ayatollah. he won't talk to people he should be doing business with. >> you never know whether it's following a totalitarian streak or being done clumsily. >> right. >> it seems often to be a mixture of the two things. >> right. >> but we know what's going to happen. some people are going to boycott the thing. there will probably be a protest there. the 4th of july is now even
4:53 pm
politicized. is it now going to be the trump liberty bell at the trump independence hall? >> i was talking to my producers today and we were trying to figure out what this is about. it's taking a holiday. of course it's about our independence, the 4th of july, but people don't think about that. what they think about on the 4th of july, this is a holiday. the whole country can have fun together. it's a holiday and he's turning it into a political day. >> and the most recent time somebody tried to do that was richard nixon july 4th, 19 70, couple of months after he very controversial announced he was invading cambodia. four students killed at kent state. later on students in mississippi killed at jackson state, so nixon wanted to bring the attention back to himself favorably so they had what was called "honor america day." big ceremony at the lincoln memorial. kate smith, bob hope -- >> she's had a hard week or two, kate smith. not what she used to be. >> right.
4:54 pm
has been accused lately -- >> giving racist speeches for songs back in the '30s. >> in any case, the idea was a little good publicity for nixon. even nixon had the good taste and restraint to know that it would not finally help him for him to be there, so he went to san clementi and let honor america day transpire and there were weed smoking protesters and they waded into the reflecting pool. it was never trump. >> if i want to give my speech about people coming to washington, i love this city. >> of course. >> i've been here most of my life. it's free if you can afford a hotel room within 20 or 30 miles. everything is free. all the museums are free. all the monuments are free. i tell people come to washington, you already paid for it. that is so true. dana milbank, thank you. michael beschloss, come to washington. you already paid for it. up next, the blue state of pennsylvania wasn't supposed to go for trump in 2016 but it did. i want to find out this week. you're watching "hardball." -♪ just like any other family
4:55 pm
♪ the house, kids, they're living the dream ♪ ♪ and here comes the wacky new maid ♪ -maid? uh, i'm not the... -♪ is she an alien, is she a spy? ♪ ♪ she's always here, someone tell us why ♪ -♪ why, oh, why -♪ she's not the maid we wanted ♪ -because i'm not the maid!
4:56 pm
-♪ but she's the maid we got -again, i'm not the maid. i protect your home and auto. -hey, campbells. who's your new maid? when you rent from national... it's kind of like playing your own version of best ball. because here, you can choose any car in the aisle, even if it's a better car class than the one you reserved. so no matter what, you're guaranteed to have a perfect drive. [laughter]
4:57 pm
(vo) go national. go like a pro. see what i did there?
4:58 pm
i grew up with my four brothers in pennsylvania on the philadelphia border with bucks county. when we moved there, we had barbed wire out back to keep the cows off the property. i remember the view of five different farm houses in different directions, so i wasn't completely a city kid. i group up with the usual pennsylvanian sense that we were getting passed over, ignored, really, as we watched all the shows on television talk about
4:59 pm
new york and how great it is, chicago, and los angeles, of course. this thursday night we're taking this show to pennsylvania to learn something about this great country. how did donald trump win the presidency? and how can he win it again? pennsylvania was the blue wall that was going to guarantee the presidency to democratic nominee hillary clinton in 2016. guarantee because the democratic party's presidential candidate has been a key part of the democratic electoral victory for candidates practically from the days of franklin roosevelt to barack obama. in fact, the last time the democrats won the election without carrying pennsylvania was in 1948 when truman beat new york governor thomas dewey. that's 3/4 of a century of the pennsylvania blue wall, so what happened three years ago? why did the blue state of pennsylvania go to donald trump? wasn't supposed to so why did it? this thursday we're going to lazerne county, there it is on the map, that shifted dramatically. we want to hear from real people, why, what mattered to
5:00 pm
them, what was at stake to them, what was their attitude to trump, to hillary clinton, to the political establishment of both parties and are they ready to do it all over again in 2020 or not? that's "hardball" for now. "all in" with chris hayes starts right now. tonight on "all in" -- >> when you're losing $500 billion a year, you can't lose in terms of a negotiation. it's really easy to win. >> donald trump drags america into a full-blown trade war. >> i think it's working out very well. >> tonight the chinese retaliate amid growing fears that the man who bankrupted his casinos is about to squander the economy he inherited. >> i've just raised the stakes. then -- >> he is going to testify -- >> congressman adam schiff on why he says mueller will appear before the house and what we're learning about don jr.'s subpoena. plus are democrats throwing away their chance to demote mitch mcconnell? and


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on