Skip to main content

tv   The Last Word With Lawrence O Donnell  MSNBC  February 18, 2020 10:00pm-11:00pm PST

10:00 pm
will be here after the debate to help make sense of all of it. so it's going to be a good, big night at a very exciting time in the democratic primary. set your dvrs. get your popcorn. i'll see you tomorrow at 8:00. that does it for us tonight. it's with lawrence o'donnell. good evening, lawrence. >> gee, rachel, i have my reading glasses on because at 9:23 p.m. when i know you were working, "the washington post" delivered a story saying, william barr is telling people he's considering quitting, but i know because you and i communicate during your commercial breaks that you're aware of this story. >> i just got it. >> but i just want to read you this opening. it says attorney general william barr has told people close to president trump inside and outside the white house he is considering quitting over trump's tweets about justice department investigations. three administration officials said foreshadowing a possible confrontation. the third sentence, he has his limits, said one person, familiar with barr's thinking. >> wait, a person familiar with his thinking?
10:01 pm
>> he has his limits. >> speaking from a person familiar with attorney general barr's thinking, speaking from inside the attorney general's mouth suggests -- >> possibly, possibly. so there are so many possibilities with this, including that it's real. there's also the possibility that william barr just kind of wants this out there as a way of kind of declaring, this is as much independence as he will declare, get a headline saying he's thinking about quitting. >> listen, the problem with what's going on here with the rule of law being shredded and made a mockery of is not that donald trump is tweeting witch-hunt, witch-hunt. that person should go to jail, this person -- the president has been doing that since before he started running for president. he did it all through his campaign. he's been doing it the entire time he's president. the problem is not the president tweeting. at least that's not the new problem. the new problem is attorney general william barr doing what the president is tweeting at him to do. the problem is attorney general
10:02 pm
barr intervening in cases at the president's insistence and to benefit the president. both in cases that we know about and cases we still don't know about where he's installed this team to override normal property prosecutorial discretion. if he has a beef here, he has a beef with william barr. >> before you go, i want to give you this one sentence, this one really exquisite sentence in the reporting. this is "the washington post" saying, trump, white house officials said, is not entirely receptive to calls to change his behavior. see, that's why i wanted to read that. i wanted america to get your reaction to this. i didn't want you alone in a room reacting to this. i wanted america to see your reaction to that. >> breaking news. sea is deep. sky is up. >> thank you, rachel. >> thanks, lawrence. >> congressman davidson salini will join us tonight. we'll get his reaction to the
10:03 pm
report of the possibility of attorney william barr resigning. if he does not resign, he will be asking attorney william barr questions the next time the attorney general testifies to the house judiciary committee which is scheduled for next month. we'll get the congressman's reaction to today's pardon party by the president of the united states. and most of what you hear the candidates say in tomorrow night's debate, almost all of it will be completely impossible for them to deliver, even if one of them wins the presidency, as long as mitch mcconnell is still the majority leader of the united states senate. he can block every single thing they want to do, just about everything that the candidates will propose tomorrow night will be completely irrelevant, even in a democratic presidency, if mitch mcconnell still controls the senate. no health care plan of any kind will pass. no tax increases on billionaires will pass. probably no supreme court justice would be confirmed for
10:04 pm
the entire four years of a democratic presidency if mitch mcconnell is still there. and so at the end of this hour, we will concentrate on the second most important political fight of the year and that is the fight to control the united states senate. we will be joined by two obama administration veterans, dan pfeiffer and jen palmieri at the end of this hour to look at the democratic seats democrats are looking to take away from republicans including susan collins in maine, where donald trump is now very unpopular, as is senator collins. we begin tonight with the president's pardon party today. who's next? roger stone? that's what roger stone is hoping tonight after donald trump's big flurry of pardons and clemencies issued today. roger stone is going to be sentenced on thursday. today the judge in the case said she will not execute the sentence until she formally rules on another request from
10:05 pm
roger stone's attorneys for a new trial. so he won't be going to prison on thursday. but is it coincidence that two days before roger stone gets sentenced, donald trump throws a pardon party? donald trump commuted the sentence of former illinois governor rod blagojevich today. blagojevich served eight years of a 14-year sentence for trying to sell an appointment to barack obama's illinois senate seat when barack obama became president of the united states. they had rod blagojevich on wiretaps. they had tape on blagojevich on the phone trying to sell the senate seat. he couldn't have been more guilty, but donald trump, who was impeached for a phone call, doesn't believe politicians should ever get in trouble for anything they ever say on a telephone. >> he's been in jail for seven years over a phone call where
10:06 pm
nothing happens, but over a phone where nothing happened. over a phone call where -- which he shouldn't have said what he said, but it was braggadocio, you would say. i would think that there have been many politicians, i'm not one of them, but have said many worse things over telephones. >> did donald trump commute blagojevich's sentence so he could take actions for a democrat who he thought got too tough a sentence? is that what he's going to say when he pardons or commutes the sentence of roger stone? i've done it for a democrat, i'm just being fair. i don't like sentences that are too tough. in trump world there's no such thing as coincidence. this happened this week for a reason. donald trump gave out some pardons to some very rich guys today who don't need pardons, who won't become one penny richer because they now have pardons. how much did they have to pay for those pardons, if anything?
10:07 pm
we'll never know because there are so many ways to give giant amounts of money to donald trump that we can never know about. the donors to trump's super pacs are anonymous. there is no legal requirement to reveal who gives and how much they give, they can give unlimited amounts of money to the super pacs, $100 million, whatever they want. there are many ways for the rich people who got pardons today to pour money into donald trump's businesses that we will never know about. but we do know how donald trump does business. >> ambassador taylor also described a comment that you made where you were trying to explain what president trump's view of this was. and you said that president trump is a businessman. when a businessman is about to sign a check to someone who owes him something, the businessman
10:08 pm
asks the person to pay up before signing the check. do you recall saying that to ambassador taylor? >> i don't recall it specifically, but i may have. >> one of the men who got a pardon today is not a rich guy, but he has friends who are and rudy giuliani was actually pleading his case directly to the president. so the fix was in. the fix was in for bernie carrick. he was the worst police commissioner in new york city history, the first commissioner to go to prison and he will remain a convicted criminal for life because he was not just convicted of the federal crimes that donald trump pardoned him for today, he was also convicted by new york state under new york state law. when rudy giuliani was mayor of new york, he promoted bernie carrick, who was a high school dropout all the way from being the mayor's chauffeur to being the police commissioner. bernie carrick was convicted of tax evasion because, among other things, he hid income from a book he wrote about what a hero he was in the aftermath of 9/11.
10:09 pm
bernie carrick also lied about a mob-connected company that did hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of free work on an apartment that bernie carrick actually banned from doing business with the city of new york. that's how bad that company was carrick, we discovered a lot. he used another apartment that a public spirited landlord donated to the city of new york for use near ground zero. for the use of the exhausted firefighters, police officers, and other city workers who were doing that horrible work in the rubble of the world trade center. carrick had other plans for the bed in that apartment. he used it for affairs with at least two women. one was a corrections officer with whom he had an affair when
10:10 pm
he was in the department. the other was the editor and publisher of his book, the book whose royalties he hid and lied to the u.s. about. no exhausted firefighters got to use that bed. no exhausted police officers. you can see in all of the worst evidence revealed about berne kerik, what emerges is a picture of what it would have been like if donald trump were the new york police commissioner. berne kerik is in every way a donald trump kind of guy. today the white house statement about berne kerik said he embodied the strength, courage, compassion, and spirit of the people of new york and this great nation. the federal judge who sentenced berne kerik to four years in prison says, i think the damage caused by mr. kerik is in some ways immeasurable. the same can be said of donald trump on this day of his presidency and on every day of his presidency. leading off our discussion tonight are joyce vance, former
10:11 pm
u.s. attorney for the northern district of alabama, she's a professor at the university of alabama school of law. barbara mcquaid is with us. former u.s. attorney for the eastern district of michigan. all three are msnbc legal analysts. joyce, let me start with you and let's start with the pardons and the commutations and your reaction to that package delivered today. >> if this was the first time we'd ever seen president trump deliver a pardon package, as you called it, i think more aptly, a pardon party, then maybe we would think that he was trying to fulfill some kind of a commitment to criminal justice reform and doing justice. but we know better than that at this point in the trump presidency. we know that this is a president who uses pardons to signal to people who have been his friends and have been his associates that if they will not turn and testify against him, that he
10:12 pm
will take care of them down the road. and with this package of pardons for people who have engaged in public corruption, lying to law enforcement, extortion, other crimes that are akin to some of the allegations that have swirled around the president and his associates, there's no way to take this other than as a message to people that he will take care of them as long as they don't stray from the fold. >> barbara mcquaid, the trump rule of corruption seems to be if i do it in public, if i actually say i'm doing it, if i tell you as openly as i can what i'm doing and why i'm doing it, it cannot be corrupt. and this, of course, is why there is a process for pardons so that presidents won't be pardoning their friends or friends of their friends. but donald trump puts in writing in the white house document today that bob kraft, the owner of the patriots, wanted this guy to get a pardon and bob kraft's name appears multiple times as one of the rich guys who wanted one of the rich guys to get a pardon today.
10:13 pm
that just seems to be the trump method of, i'm going to do it in the ugliest way possible, but i am going to do it publicly. >> president trump is exercising his power to the fullest extent. he has absolute right to pardon people who are convicted of federal crimes and he's using it. he seems to enjoy this power and he is using it in a very aggressive fashion. it's really contrary to the way prior presidents have used this power, though. when i worked in the obama administration as u.s. attorney, from time to time we would have applications come to us to review, and they went through the office of the pardon attorney and a really important part of that application was whether the person had shown remorse, admitted what they had done, and asked for forgiveness because they wanted to get back into society and become a productive member of the community. instead, we've got people like rod blagojevich who still deny they did anything wrong. it's a very different use of the pardon power and it seems to be one that favors the rich and the
10:14 pm
powerful and the well connected over those who are truly expressing remorse. >> benjamin, 100 years ago there was no formalized process set up about exactly how the president would arrive at pardons. but over the course of the 20th century it became a highly evolved process specifically to make people believe it was an honest process and it wasn't being corrupted by friends of the president. how is that process supposed to work? >> well, so, the process is voluntary on the part of the president in the sense that, you know, you have this process set up. but the power belongs to the president personally. and if he chooses to issue a pardon because, say, he likes rod blagojevich's hair, he could do that. it's this elaborate process that kind of exists only if you want it to exist. but the way it traditionally has evolved to exist is that you apply through the justice
10:15 pm
department's office of pardon attorney. the pardon attorney's office makes recommendations to the attorney general, who then refers recommendations to the white house, which then reviews them itself. and so the process can be quite elaborate, and this has allowed certain presidents, most notably in recent years, president obama, to use the pardon power to create certain -- to effectuate certain public policy objectives. so president obama was concerned about overly lengthy drug sentences for non-violent drug offenders and used the clemency process by way of shortening a lot of people's sentences. donald trump's, you know, if you take his pardons all together, i agree very much with joyce that one of the purposes is clearly to signal to people that loyalty to him will be rewarded. another purpose, frankly, is
10:16 pm
just to own the libs and some of the pardons he's issued, particularly to people like particularly to people like d'souza, or arpaio, are efforts to take a pie and smash it in the face of his political enemies. so i think there's a few things going on here. and then the final element that's just worth mentioning is one of the reasons he loves this power so much is that, you know, you get the sense that he kind of imagined the presidency as this, you know, like -- almost like kingly thing where you get to wave your hands and things happen. most of politics doesn't work that way. legislation is hard, running the government is hard, but the pardon power actually does work that way, you know. he just gets to do it. and he clearly loves that. and so i think those are kind of the three things that are behind it.
10:17 pm
he loves how free he is with the power. he loves using the power to upset his enemies. and, yes, joyce's point is absolutely right, that he signals with it to people who are still within the criminal justice system and may, may or may not be tempted to cooperate at some point, stick with me and i'll make sure things work out okay for you. >> joyce, the president was asked today, of course, is he thinking about pardoning roger stone. and he lied and said he hasn't even thought about it. here he is doing this two days before roger stone's sentencing. clearly i, for one, am not a believer in coincidences in trump world. >> i think that that's absolutely right. and it defies belief that he's being truthful here. as hard as it still is to say those kind of words about an american president, but we know that this is on his mind when he does this.
10:18 pm
and i suspect that there's a group of pardons that he's contemplating, perhaps starting with general flynn, maybe including paul manafort, and certainly extending to roger stone. i think the more interesting question, lawrence, is what the timing will look like. it would be brazen for this president to pardon his closest allies before the election. one would suspect that a president with wisdom in this situation, if you could call it that, would wait until after the outcome of that election was known. but one wonders if trump, who has been impetuous with pardons, who does not respect the pardon process that barr detailed and that ben talked about, if he might not just go ahead and do it off the cuff on twitter one morning. >> barbara, that's what i'm thinking about because there's no reason to do these pardons this week, none of these pardons makes sense now unless it is somehow related to roger stone. and the question of the roger stone pardon could be exactly
10:19 pm
how much time is roger stone willing to do? if roger stone is not willing to do a single night in prison, never mind all the way to november, then donald trump may be facing a pardon demand, in effect, from roger stone right now. >> i think president trump is doing what predators do, and that is grooming his victims. he is sensitizing the public to this idea that corruption is not a big deal. pardoning people like rod blagojevich, people engaging in corrupt activity, kerik, that says these aren't serious crimes. nobody got hurt. these weren't violent. roger stone's name is the next that comes up for a pardon. he gets grouped into the whole category of people who, eh, haven't done anything all that bad. >> ben, before we go to a break,
10:20 pm
a word about the "washington post" report tonight indicating that william barr is thinking about resigning. the article says that william barr specifically has warned the president that this is a problem for him. what's your take on that? >> i think it clearly is a problem for him, and it has dramatically eroded his already impaired credibility within the department that, you know, he -- the president tweeted a demand and he then seemed to comply with the tweet, though he claims to have made an independent decision to revise the stone sentencing recommendation even before the president issued the tweet. it clearly bothers him and he feels that he is, you know, made to look ineffective and non-independent as a result of the president's behavior. the problem, of course, as
10:21 pm
rachel said in your transition, you know, he's got his own problem here, which is that he is actively intervening in cases to the benefit of the president's interests, and that is not a problem that would be fixed by the president stopping tweeting. that's actually a problem with his behavior. and so i think he's probably sincerely upset about the president's tweets, but i actually think that is not wholly responsive to the problem that he faces. >> benjamin, joyce vance, barbara mcquaid, thank you for starting us off tonight. really appreciate it. and when we come back, congressman david sicilini will join us to discuss the growing list of questions that he has for attorney general william barr under oath if william barr is still attorney general when his scheduled appearance before the house judiciary committee comes next month. uhh, excuse me, is there a problem here? you're in a no parking zone. oh, i... i didn't know.
10:22 pm
you didn't see the sign? that... that wasn't there when i was here earlier. (whimper) really? you know, in italy, they let you park anywhere. have a good day, sir. with geico, the savings keep on going. just like this sequel. 15 minutes could save you 15% or more on car insurance. (glass shattering) (frustrated yell) (car horn blast) (yelp) when youyou spend lessfair, and get way more. so you can bring your vision to life and save in more ways than one. for small prices, you can build big dreams, spend less, get way more. shop everything home at
10:23 pm
[wood rolling] alexios, add toilet paper to the shopping list. [chiseling on stone] oh, and camel milk. and a chicken. and moisturizer. alexa: thanks, guys. i'll take it from here. ♪ applebee's new irresist-a-bowls now starting at $7.99. now that's eatin' good in the neighborhood. but when allergies attack,f any the excitement fades. allegra helps you say yes with the fastest non-drowsy allergy relief and turning a half hearted yes, into an all in yes. allegra. live your life, not your allergies. hi with the world'se first invisible trailer.
10:24 pm
invisible trailer? and it's not the trailer right next to us? this guy? you don't believe me? hop in. good lookin' pickup, i will say that. oh wow. silverado offers an optional technology package with up to 15 different views - including one enhanced view that makes your trailer appear invisible. wow. - that's pretty sweet. - that's cool. oooohh! that's awesome. where'd the trailer go? i love it. it's magic. wheneveryone is different.a, which is why xfinity mobile created a different kind of wireless network. one that saves you money by letting you design your own data - giving you more choice and control compared to other top wireless carriers. now you can choose unlimited, shared data, or mix lines of each and switch any line, anytime. no one else lets you do that. design your own data with xfinity mobile. it's wireless reimagined. simple. easy. awesome.
10:25 pm
10:26 pm
the breaking news of this hour is that "the washington post" is now reporting tonight that attorney general william rrpresident continues to tweet about justice department cases. today the president continued to do exactly that. the president tweeted today about the roger stone case, which attorney general william barr has said makes it impossible for him to do his job. >> he said that your comments on twitter are making it impossible to do his job. are you making his job impossible? >> yeah, i do make his job harder, i do agree with that. i think that's true. the attorney general is a man with incredible integrity. just so you understand, i chose not to be involved. i'm allowed to be totally involved. i'm actually -- i guess the chief law enforcement officer of the country, but i've chosen not to be involved. >> joining us now is congressman david cicilline, democrat from rhode island. he's a member of the judiciary and foreign affairs committees of the house, and the
10:27 pm
communications committee. your reaction, first of all, to the president saying he's the chief law enforcement officer of the country. >> yeah, well, good to be with you, lawrence. the president is wrong. he is not the chief enforcement officer of the country. that is the role of the attorney general, who is expected to lead the justice department in a fair and impartial way. he doesn't work for the president. he's not the president's lawyer. although the attorney general has behaved that way. the president said, i want my own roy cohn and he got him with the attorney general of the united states. and while he's disturbed by the tweets, he ought to be more disturbed by the ongoing effort of the president to politicize the justice department and to interfere with the administration of justice in this country. >> i want to get your reaction to the pardons today that we saw come out from the president, seven pardons, four sentence commutations. >> look, lawrence, i think the president is setting the stage for an additional set of pardons for his close associates that
10:28 pm
have been convicted in connection with the mueller investigation. roger stone, michael flynn, paul manafort. i think what he's doing today -- this is on the eve of the roger stone sentencing. there was no particular urgency to any of these actions, but i think he's trying to say, first of all, these are not big deals. these involve public corruption. these involve people who abused their position of trust, but they shouldn't get long sentences and i think it's a pretext so that when he moves forward with a pardon for those other individuals that are part of his inner circle, it will be sort of a lot of noise. he's doing a lot of pardons. he did a bunch of them last week. and i think it's really setting the table for, for his inner circle folks and his close associates. and he wants to make it very clear, stay loyal to me and i will take care of you. that's the message. that's the message of the people he picked to give pardons to today. it's the message he's transmitted all throughout the mueller investigation.
10:29 pm
it's the message he's tweeted about to roger stone. the people who stay loyal to him and don't share information which is damaging to the president will be taken care of. >> so the essence of this breaking news in "the washington post" tonight is that william barr has made it clear to the white house and the president that he might resign if the president continues tweeting about justice department cases and activities. and "the washington post" reports that the president has made it clear to white house personnel that he is going to continue tweeting about whatever he wants, including justice department cases. >> well, look, i think it's hard to imagine the president is going to remove the attorney general who has executed on everything the president wants. so this notion of the attorney general might quit because he doesn't like the tweets, how about an attorney general who says, you know what, i may resign from this position if you continue to interfere with the fair administration of justice. if you continue to try to influence sentences of individual defendants and
10:30 pm
corrupt the department. that would be an attorney general that we could all be proud of, that's defending the integrity of the department of justice. so it's hard to believe when you look at the record of this attorney general, who has basically behaved as president trump's roy cohn, who has defended the president's interests and undermined the rule of law, who mischaracterized the findings in the mueller report, traveled over to europe to try to meet with intelligence officials to dig up dirt on some of the political opponents of the president, and is following the president's recommendation of lowering a sentencing recommendation for one of his close associates. so it's hard to imagine that he's suddenly bothered by the president's tweets, but i called on the attorney general to resign many months ago. he ought to do it. and we ought to have an attorney general who has the confidence of the american people to fairly administer justice in this country. >> congressman david cicilline, thank you for being with us. >> thank you for having me.
10:31 pm
when we come back, the democratic presidential debate tomorrow on msnbc has a new player, which means the debate has a new target for the five debaters who have been on the stage. you have another thing coming tomorrow night. mike bloomberg could not be more different from bill de blasio including the fact mike bloomberg was a republican when he was mayor of new york. how will the dynamics of the debate change with a new player on the debate stage tomorrow night? that's next. as a caricature artist, i appreciate what makes each person unique. that's why i like liberty mutual. they get that no two people are alike and customize your car insurance so you only pay for what you need. almost done. what do you think? i don't see it. only pay for what you need.
10:32 pm
♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ managing lipids like very high tryou diet. exercise. tough. but if you're also taking fish oil supplements... you should know... they are not fda approved... they may have saturated fat and may even raise bad cholesterol. to treat very high triglycerides, discover the science of prescription vascepa. proven in multiple clinical trials, vascepa, along with diet is the only prescription epa treatment, approved by the fda to lower very high triglycerides by 33%, without raising bad cholesterol. look. it's clear, there's only one prescription epa vascepa. vascepa is not right for everyone. do not take vascepa if you are allergic to icosapent ethyl or any inactive ingredient in vascepa. tell your doctor if you are allergic to fish or shellfish, have liver problems or other medical conditions and about any medications you take, especially those that may affect blood clotting. 2.3% of patients reported joint pain. prescription power. proven to work. now with a new indication.
10:33 pm
ask your doctor about vascepa. skip to the good part with alka-seltzer plus. now with 25% more concentrated power. nothing works faster for powerful cold relief. oh, what a relief it is! so fast! if you have moderate to severe psoriasis, little things can become your big moment. that's why there's otezla. otezla is not a cream. it's a pill that treats plaque psoriasis differently.
10:34 pm
with otezla, 75% clearer skin is achievable. don't use if you're allergic to otezla. it may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. otezla is associated... ...with an increased risk of depression. tell your doctor if you have a history of depression... ...or suicidal thoughts or if these feelings develop. some people taking otezla reported weight loss. your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. tell your doctor about your medicines, and if you're pregnant or planning to be. otezla. show more of you.
10:35 pm
william barr's people at the justice department have been watching tv tonight and certainly reading that "washington post" report saying he is considering resigning if president trump keeps tweeting about justice department cases. the justice department has just tweeted -- we might be able to get this on the screen -- the attorney general has no plans to resign, okay.
10:36 pm
so it's official, no plans to resign. depends on what the next tweet is, maybe. a new nbc news/"wall street journal" poll of democratic presidential candidates show bernie sanders now clearly in the lead at 27%, and then an extraordinary four-way tie for second place with joe biden at 15%, mike bloomberg and elizabeth warren at 14%, pete buttiegieg at 13%. amy klobuchar is at the bottom of this poll at 7%. tom steyer is down at 2%. tulsi gabbard is at 1%. this morning an npr marist poll released at dawn showed more separation among the candidates with bernie sanders still at the top at 31%, mike bloomberg in second place at 19%, joe biden at 15%, elizabeth warren at 12%, amy klobuchar at 9%, and pete buttiegieg at 8%. mike bloomberg's second place showing in the polls qualifies him for tomorrow night's debate in las vegas right here on
10:37 pm
msnbc, and he has said he will join that debate. joining us now is jennifer palmieri, former white house communications director for president obama and former communications director for hillary clinton's presidential campaign. jamal smith is with us, senior writer for "rolling stone." jennifer, you've been there, you've been in campaigns at this moment when the new poll comes out and shakes things up a bit. but you've never been there when the new poll includes a billionaire with unlimited funding, who makes his first entry on the debate stage just a couple nights before the nevada caucuses. what is going to happen tomorrow night in this scenario we've never seen before? >> it's crazy. it's like the democratic presidential primary actually starts tomorrow night, right? the campaign has been going on for 13 months, right? warren got in in january of '19, but it's like it starts tomorrow because you have some -- it's remarkable. the campaign has been going on
10:38 pm
for a year, and the guy who is number two in the polls has never been on the debate stage. i think tomorrow night is the ninth debate. it might be the eighth or tenth. at any rate, there's been a lot of debates and michael bloomberg hasn't been on the stage. it would behoove the democrats to have him on the stage before tomorrow night. he's gotten a big head of steam. biden not doing well in iowa and new hampshire meant voters started to leave him. they were not waiting until south carolina where biden considers his firewall to make a decision they want to find somebody else who is going to pick up the mantle, i am the guy who can beat trump. bloomberg knows how to throw a punch. he's been doing it on twitter. his campaign manager tweeted today they have epic amounts of opposition research on sanders, so you can't lob something out there like that and not follow it through on the debate stage. all the candidates have been attacking bloomberg for trying to buy the debate, so i think
10:39 pm
it's hard to predict how the debate is going to go, but i think this is going to be raucous. yeah, something we haven't seen before. >> the collapse of joe biden in the polls is one story we're looking at. but there is one way in which he has not collapsed. and that is in the head-to-head polling of democratic candidate versus donald trump. and we're going to look at the pbs newshour version of this because for some inexplicable reason, the nbc poll did not include elizabeth warren in the one-on-one matchup. so we will ignore that. we'll look at the pbs version. joe biden is at the top of this. he has the biggest margin over donald trump, 50-44. bloomberg, 48-44. bernie sanders, 48-45. pete buttiegieg, 47-45. amy klobuchar, same thing, 47-45. elizabeth warren, 47-46. way still up there at the top on that one on one match up with donald trump is joe biden and the voters say that's the most important thing. >> well, i think you look at
10:40 pm
that poll, lawrence, and you see that people seem to believe that white men, specifically older white men, will beat donald trump, at least that's what they believe. i think that poll and a lot of other feelings that we're seeing going through this election are reflecting is people are scared. people are frightened specifically in this moment. you see a president who has been emboldened by his escape from impeachment. you see him behaving more rabidly than usual. and i think people are a little bit more frightened that he may survive into a second term, and so they are going to, i guess, their default in what they assume is a political sure thing and unfortunately in this country that tends to mean old white men. and they say that's a sure thing. unfortunately that tends to not actually have the best track record. so i think people need to look at that poll and realize that actually they can vote for whomever they like and they
10:41 pm
should probably have a good chance of beating donald trump in november. >> jamil, the polling now is so tight and now this new tension with mike bloomberg and the attacks we're seeing on mike bloomberg re-raise the question that have been answered already on this debate stage, but i think has to be asked again of each candidate, and that is, will you support the democratic nominee no matter who it is? that's a new question with bloomberg there. >> yes. and i think it's frankly a question that should be asked of all the candidates' supporters no matter who they are. i think certainly with bloomberg, i think people are turning to somebody that they don't fully understand and they don't really fully know what he's buying with all of his millions, is not necessarily support so much as name recognition. i think that's a point that we really need to hone in on. he is buying simply his name association with whomever he's putting in his commercials.
10:42 pm
i think people are mistaking the fact that, you know, he's putting obama in his commercials and people thinking that obama is endorsing him. obama has not endorsed him. people are thinking that he is some kind of staunch progressive, when in fact we're finding out more and more each day he's had these really terrible conservative opinions, specifically about some of the most marginalized communities that tend to vote democratic. so i think people need to really do their homework on who mike bloomberg actually is. they're going to find out a lot more when they watch the debate tomorrow night. >> jamil smith, jennifer palmieri, thank you for that round. when we come back, dan fifer, he's been where the candidates are. these worried about it and what could be a do or die presidential debate. when dan fifer was there, his candidate was barack obama. dan fifer joins us next. i'm your 70lb st. bernard puppy,
10:43 pm
and my lack of impulse control, is about to become your problem. ahh no, come on. i saw you eating poop earlier. my focus is on the road, and that's saving me cash with drivewise. i am totally blind. and non-24 can make me show up too early... or too late. or make me feel like i'm not really "there." talk to your doctor, and call 844-234-2424. we all use our cellphones very differently. (vo) why the french family chose verizon. someone's streaming sports. someone's video chatting friends. my parents are getting older so knowing that i can get in touch with them at any time is really comfortingt (grandma) wow! what channel? (vo) the network more people rely on, gives you more. like plans your family can mix and match starting at just $35. a year of disney+ included. and now, get a verizon stream tv on us for access to all your favorite shows and movies in 4k. that's verizon.
10:44 pm
bleeding disorderste medlike hemophilia.s so victor can keep doing what's in his blood. at bayer, this is why we science. try eucerin advanced repair and switch. it doubles your skin's moisture and repairs dry skin over time. so tomorrow can be a different story. eucerin - recommended and used by dermatologists. eucerin - if your adventure...
10:45 pm
keeps turning into unexpected bathroom trips. you may have overactive bladder, or oab. not again! we're seeing a doctor when we get home. myrbetriq treats oab symptoms of urgency, frequency, and leakage. it's the first and only oab treatment in its class. myrbetriq may increase blood pressure. tell your doctor right away if you have trouble emptying your bladder or have a weak urine stream. myrbetriq may cause serious allergic reactions, like swelling of the face, lips, throat or tongue, or trouble breathing. if experienced, stop taking and tell your doctor right away. myrbetriq may interact with other medicines. tell your doctor if you have liver or kidney problems. common side effects include increased blood pressure, common cold or flu symptoms, sinus irritation, dry mouth, urinary tract infection, bladder inflammation, back or joint pain, constipation, dizziness, and headache. looking for a destination that isn't always the bathroom? ask your doctor if myrbetriq is right for you. and visit
10:46 pm
how do you un-trump america? that's what the candidates on the debate stage tomorrow night will be trying to tell you they're going to do. our next guest has literally written the book on un-trumping america. he's been there. dan pfeiffer has been where the presidential campaigns are tonight. quite literally in 2008, it could make or break his candidate's presidential campaign. dan pfeiffer's candidate was
10:47 pm
barack obama, who did very well in that debate, and the rest is history. joining us now is dan pfeiffer. he's a former senior adviser to president obama and author of the new book, "un-trumping america." he is also the co-host of the biggest podcast in the universe, pod save america. dan, thank you very much for taking time out of your podcasting. >> thank you for having me. >> so the polling movement now with bloomberg is kind of sudden. i just want to take a look at the nbc news/"wall street journal" poll which shows where people were in january and what they've moved up to now. bernie sanders was 27 in january. he's 27 now. real stability. biden, down 11 points from january. bloomberg, up 5. warren, basically the same. pete buttiegieg, up 6 since january. amy klobuchar, only up 2 from what we thought was this big bump out of the last debate. but that's the national poll. she really surged in new hampshire. so in this debate you're aiming
10:48 pm
for a score in nevada, but this debate is also playing in other states like california where they're already voting. >> right. we are two weeks away from -- as you point out, people are voting in california. super tuesday will be the biggest chunk of delegates. that's ultimately what this is about, delegates. these candidates need to do two things at the same time. a message for caucus voters on saturday and speak to south carolina and people around the nation who may be tuning in for the very first time tomorrow night. it's a complicated task because they're playing three dimensional chess. they're worried about bloomberg looming, but if bernie sanders continues unimpeded, he's going to -- he may well be the nominee by the day after super tuesday if there isn't some change in dynamics. >> in debate prep, you can prep, but there is a certain amount of luck involved, especially when there's six people up there. if it's one on one, you actually have more control. >> right. >> you can make more of a plan of, i'm going to say this. but when there's six people up there, you might not ever get a chance to say something about that issue that you have something great that you're ready with. >> right. and sometimes the tone of the
10:49 pm
debate is set by the moderator early, right. sometimes if you start -- you may come in there with, you have a killer line you're going to launch on bloomberg. the first question is iran or syria. it's hard to get that zinger in there. then the debate has moved on before you can ever get there. these candidates have to be well prepared. opportunistic, look for opportunities to execute their strategy the moment there is a glimmer of opportunity to do so because we only have two of these left before super tuesday. this could be one of the last times these guys are ever going to have. >> is it more important for an candidate to say in a positive way, here's why you should be voting for me? is that more important to say than here's why you should not be voting for the other one? >> i think you have to do both. i think what's so interesting about the dynamics here is, we've been talking about policy nonstop. incredibly detailed substantive debates, ten, nine, ten debates. the issue everyone cares about is who can win. that's the movement in the poll you were talking about.
10:50 pm
we have some concerns about some other people. we're going to bloomberg who is an unknown quantity because he seems like he may be able to win which is an open question. i think these candidates have to get on stage and say explicitly why i can take on trump and why the people ahead of me polls are not. that's what people want to hear. we're going to take a quick break. i want to get to the answer that barack obama proved to the question, can he win? we also have to discuss the united states senate, as i said at the beginning of this hour. if one of the candidates wins the presidency, but the democrats do not win the senate, just about everything you hear tomorrow night will not happen as long as mitch mcconnell is there to stop it. we'll be right back after this. oh, hi, samantha.
10:51 pm
you look more like a heather. do you ever get that? it's nice to finally meet you in person. you're pete nocchio? oh, the pic? that was actually a professional headshot. i'm sure that's it, yeah. i, uh, i think i've lost a few pounds recently too. i'm actually doing a juice cleanse. wait! you don't... (glass breaking) (gasp) ah! oh...! with geico, the savings keep on going. just like this sequel. 15 minutes could save you 15% or more on car insurance. stand up to moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis. and take. it. on with rinvoq. rinvoq a once-daily pill can dramatically improve symptoms...
10:52 pm
rinvoq helps tame pain, stiffness, swelling. and for some... rinvoq can even significantly reduce ra fatigue. that's rinvoq relief. with ra, your overactive immune system attacks your joints. rinvoq regulates it to help stop the attack. rinvoq can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious infections and blood clots, sometimes fatal, have occurred as have certain cancers, including lymphoma, and tears in the stomach or intestines, and changes in lab results. your doctor should monitor your bloodwork. tell your doctor about any infections and if you are or may become pregnant while taking rinvoq. ready to take on ra? talk to your rheumatologist about rinvoq relief. rinvoq. make it your mission. ♪ do you recall, not long ago ♪ we would walk on the sidewalk ♪ ♪ all around the wind blows ♪ we would only hold on to let go ♪
10:53 pm
♪ blow a kiss into the sun ♪ we need someone to lean on ♪ blow a kiss into the sun ♪ all we needed somebody to lean on ♪ the new xc90 plug-in hybrid electric. xc90. recharged. ncan it one up spaghetti night? cleaning power of liquid. it sure can. really? can it one up breakfast in bed? yeah, for sure. thanks, boys. what about that? uhh, yep! it can? yeah, even that! i would very much like to see that. me too. introducing new tide power pods. one up the toughest stains with 50% more cleaning power than liquid detergent. any further questions? uh uh! nope! one up the power of liquid with new tide power pods.
10:54 pm
[ fast-paced drumming ] and now the reality note that will probably be ignored in tomorrow night's debate -- the
10:55 pm
united states senate. republican senator susan collins for the first time in her career is in trouble in her re-election campaign in maine. >> so why do you have that feeling that he has changed, that he learned a lesson? >> well, i may not be correct on that. >> in light of the president's actions, do you think there's any lessons that he learned from being impeached? >> i don't know which actions you're referring to. >> you said that the president learned his lesson. do you think he learned any lessons? >> that ad is paid for by the democratic superpac that's trying to win control of the united states senate for the democrats. susan collins is now polling in a tie with one of her democratic challengers, sarah gideon, the speaker of the house in maine. susan collins is polling at 42%. democrat sarah gideon is polling at 43%. the rule of polling for incumbents generally is that anything below 50% means the incumbent is going to have a very difficult struggle getting re-elected. that could mean the democrats might win back the senate.
10:56 pm
we're back with jennifer palmieri and dan pfeiffer, author of "un-trumping america." and, jennifer, almost everything they talk about tomorrow night won't matter if mitch mcconnell is still in control of the senate. >> yeah, and chuck schumer's really glad that you're making that point because that man is a relentless -- let me tell you, he is a relentless recruiting machine to try to get good candidates to run for senate. and they really do have an opportunity to win back the senate if, you know -- maine's a good example where there's other states where you have vulnerable incumbents, people you didn't expect necessarily to be vulnerable, like joni ernst in iowa as well. and you're right. without changing the makeup of the senate, you're just going to run -- continue to run into brick walls. >> and, dan, if the democrats can get the wave going, you've got arizona pickup possible. colorado seems like a very likely pickup. so, four, which is what they need, is well within the realm of possibility. >> that's right.
10:57 pm
we have a very good chance to get the senate, and we have to do it now because this is the most favorable map we're going to have for a while. and what's really important is that we are a united party that is strong at the top of the ticket because when democrats -- or the close races usually tip in the direction of the winner of the presidential. in 2012, indiana, missouri, north dakota all tipped towards obama. 2008, similar situation in minnesota and elsewhere. so we have to be united. if we do, we have an opportunity to actually get something done. as you point out, if we do not and mitch mcconnell still controls the agenda, then there will be no legislation. if we -- if a supreme court justice decided to retire on the way home from the inauguration, mitch mcconnell would hold that seat open for four years. >> he would, absolutely. i have no doubt about it anymore. jennifer, i want to go to you and dan on this question on the eve of the debate. a candidate who needs to convince voters that he or she can win, can beat the republican opponent, what is that like? you've been in presidential campaigns.
10:58 pm
what is that like when the candidate has that obligation? the candidate is not presumed to be the one who can beat the republican opponent. >> well, you know, the people in this race that it hits the hardest are the women. and it's bizarre because there has been somebody who went up against trump in a general election. it was a woman, and she got 3 million more votes, and women had historic wins in 2018. i argue if there is anything that we know about what happens when trump is on the ballot, is that women win. so i think, you know, you see warren makes a case really forcefully about electability now, and i know she does it because she feels like she has to. she's got to make that -- she can't let that question go unanswered. it may be that she's been helping amy klobuchar doing that, right? she made that case really forcefully in the last two debates, and you saw klobuchar did -- bested her in new hampshire. but it's the women in particular that have to prove to people that women can win. >> dan, how did barack obama and the obama campaign do it in 2008
10:59 pm
because he faced that question. can he possibly win the general election? >> well, he had to stand on that stage and be seen as someone who looked like they can be in the oval office. and i would c as that was, as the first african-american candidate, i think it's much harder now for the candidates of color and the women candidates because elect -- >> why would it be harder now? >> because there is a paranoia of fear in the democratic electorate, and there's been this narrative that the only way we win the election is convincing a group of working class white men in wisconsin that they should vote for a democrat. and we presume sexism. i think the best way any of these candidates can do it is to not seem like the replica of trump but to be the replacement, who looks like the opposite, who can represent change against him. and i think warren, klobuchar, buttigieg, sanders have the opportunity to do that. >> dan pfeiffer gets the last word. his book is "un-trumping america." thank you both very much for joining us on the eve of this next presidential debate. really appreciate it.
11:00 pm
that is tonight's last word. "the 11th hour" with brian williams starts now. president trump has today declared he is the nation's chief law enforcement officer. that title normally goes to the attorney general, but as we've noted, these are not normal times. in fact, if you believe the story just out tonight, that same attorney general is mulling over quitting if the president keeps tweeting. plus as another trump friend and ally faces some serious federal prison in a celebrated case, the president flexes one of the more awesome powers of his office by stepping into pardon criminals involved in some notorious corruption cases. we'll also look at what is motivating the youthful surge in support of bernie sanders. and we have a preview of tomorrow night. it won't look like any of the other democratic debates because of the new man onstage as "the 11th hour" gets under way on this tuesday night.