tv The Last Word With Lawrence O Donnell MSNBC December 16, 2021 7:00pm-8:00pm PST
xfinity brought us together, after all! power your whole home this holiday with wifi speeds faster than a gig. click, call, or visit a store today. sing 2 you know what tonight is? friday eve. because tomorrow's friday. helpful reminder. i'll see you again tomorrow. now it's time for "the last word with lawrence o'donnell." good evening, lawrence. >> do you really think it's helpful? isn't it kind of confusing the eve thing? you throw people off to thinking and then they have to throw it off and then they go oh, she means thursday. she means just thursday. >> nobody gets confused and think christmas eve is christmas evening. we know that the eve of something is the eve. and frankly, fridays are important enough to me that i
need to start celebrating in advance. >> but that's the thing. we're in the eve season. there is some big eaves coming up. >> that's true. >> we hear eve, it might throw me off even more now when i hear you say it in december. but -- >> i need eaves all year long because fridays are very important to me, lawrence. and i have so little that gives me joy. you must leave me this. >> i get it. you know who is going to give you joy? secretary pete buttigieg, who is joining us tonight in this hour. and our law professional laurence tribe. he co-wrote a piece in august saying the justice department should conduct a criminal investigation of what donald trump did to try to violate election law on january 6 and before. and i want to check in with professor tribe tonight to see if this week may be the evidence
base for and justification for a criminal investigation of donald trump has increased at all. >> certainly the january 6 investigators started talking in specific statutory language about what it is they're trying to figure out if trump did it. i mean, the language from liz cheney on this has been really provocative. it's deliberate and they're making a case for that kind of evidence which is going to put the justice department on the spot. but the january 6 investigation seems to be building a real case. >> yeah. we will see what professor tribe thinks of what's developed this week. and rachel, please enjoy the next couple hours of your -- >> friday eve. >> friday eve. friday eve. yeah, that's how you say it. >> i shall. i will celebrate with my family. thank you. >> thank you, rachel. well, they are still silent. they are still hiding. they're still living in fear of
the day when the house select committee to investigate the january 6 attack on the capitol will reveal their names. they are the republican members of congress who wrote texts and emails to the trump white house chief of staff mark meadows showing that they were active participants in a criminal conspiracy to violate election law on january 6 and overturn the resuls of the electoral college vote that was won by joe biden, and they all know who they are, every one of them. the authors of those texts, they know who they are. but none of them are voluntarily jumping up to tell us hey, i wrote that one. that was me. none of them are proud of those texts. today "the new york times" revealed a list of republican members of the house who are identified as, quote, right wing members of congress who became key foot soldiers in mr. trump's effort to overturn the election.
they are jim jordan, andy biggs, paul gosar, louie gome mart, mo brooks and scott perry. all of them remained silent today. here is a text from someone in congress the day after the attack on the capitol. yesterday was a terrible day. we tried everything we could in our objection to the six states. i'm sorry nothing worked. that's the bank robber saying the day after i'm sorry that we couldn't get out of the bank with all the money. the member of congress who wrote that text is afraid tonight, days after it's been revealed, afraid to come forward and say yes, i wrote that text. i'm proud of writing that text. that text is saying i'm sorry the crime we committed yesterday, the crime of conspiracy to violate election law did not succeed in our criminal objective.
yesterday congressman jim jordan was forced. let me repeat that, was forced to admit that he wrote a text that outlined a criminal conspiracy to commit election fraud and change the votes of the electoral college. jim jordan admitted that only after it had leaked to some reporters that jim jordan had wrote that text. that jim jordan forwarded this text to mark meadows from a republican lawyer describing a criminal plot to steal the election. on january 6, 2021, vice president mike pence as president of the senate should call out all electoral votes that he believes are unconstitutional as no electoral votes at all. the rambling text then goes on to quote alexander hamilton. before there was an established government of the united states, quoting alexander hamilton on a point that had nothing to do
with counting votes or the electoral college, jim jordan did not admit that that was his text until two days after that text was revealed. two days. jim jordan stayed silent for two days. he had absolutely no intention of admitting that was his text until it leaked to the news media. jim jordan's plan was to remain silent like every republican member of congress who sent one of those texts, texts that have been exposed. even the republican member of congress who sent this text is afraid to admit it. "the president needs to stop this asap." sent that on january 6 when the capitol was being attacked. why not admit yes, i sent that text? why not be proud of that? they are all silent, every one of them. the proof of their fear is their
silence. there is no louder member of the house of representatives than jim jordan. he was silent today, silent. silence is what jim jordan chooses when he is in very, very big trouble. jim jordan continues to remain silent about under oath accusations made by members of the ohio state wrestling team saying when jim jordan was an assistant coach of that team, he knew about sex crimes committed by the team doctor against members of the team. and jim jordan said and did nothing about that. members of that team testified under oath that when jim jordan found out that kids on the team he was coaching were being sexually abused by the team, dr. jim jordan chose silence. every day that jim jordan chooses silence is a day that jim jordan knows he's in deep trouble. today the house select committee
to investigate the january 6 attack on the capitol issued a subpoena to a man who "the new york times" describes tonight as, quote, the founder, forklift driver and floor sweeper at one shot distillery and brewery in dripping springs, texas. the man's name is phil waldron. he was one of the nonlawyers with no expertise whatsoever in rudolph giuliani's clown car, complaining about the elections in the swing states. mr. waldron is being investigated for circulating a 38-page power point presentation which bennie thompson calls an alarming blueprint for overturning a nation wide election. phil waldron spent 30 years in the army retiring with the rank of colonel, which is not a difficult rank to achieve when you spend 30 years in the army. you will hear him being referred to as a colonel, as if it's
worthy somehow of your respect, which it is not. he is someone who works in some kind of brewery and distillery. in august our next guest cowrote an article with barbara mcquade and joyce vance laying out a road map for the justice department to follow in investigating donald trump. harvard law professor laurence tribe cowrote the article, saying "if we are to maintain our democracy and respect for the rule of law, efforts to overturn a fair election simply cannot be tolerated and trump's conduct must be investigated. one possible charge is conspiracy. it is a federal crime for individuals to agree to defraud the united states by interfering with governmental functions." in the financial times today, edward luce writes history tells us that democracies that fail to protect themselves with the full force of the law are flirting with extinction. the article quotes washington's
governor jay inslee saying "the american psyche has not recognized we were one vice president away from a coup." leading off our discussion tonight is laurence tribe, university professor of constitutional law emeritus at harvard law school. he has won 35 cases in the united states supreme court. professor tribe, thank you very much for joining us tonight. i've been wondering this what the revelations of the week add to your assessment made back in august that the justice department should be running a criminal investigation of what donald trump was doing. >> this week, the house select committee released a cascade of information that confirms what i believed and other people i think joined me in believing back in august, and that is the department of justice really needs to look into the crimes
that were committed. liz cheney was very precise, clearly channeling a decision of a trump appointee, judge dab any friedrick from last week. she essentially quoted from 18 u.s. code section 1512 which makes it a federal crime for anyone corruptly to obstruct or impede, whether by action or inaction an official proceeding, and she held, dabney friedrick held in a prosecution brought by the justice department against some foot soldiers that an official proceeding includes what congress has to do when it counts the electoral votes on january 6. that's one of many federal crimes that are involved. another is the federal crime of aiding and giving comfort to an
insurrection, which is clearly what happened on january 6th. and what we have is an avalanche of information about texts and emails and other communications directly to the white house, directly to mark meadow, who was at donald trump's side. so the question of whether it was trump alone or trump and meadows or both of them with the six members of congress who were in constant contact with the white house all of them seemed to be involved in a conspiracy to commit a very serious crime punishable by 20 years in federal prison, and to the extent that they were aiding and giving comfort to an insurrection, that too is punishable by ten more years. and importantly, by permanent disqualification from holding federal office.
and it is certainly true, as edward luce said, that a democracy that allows this kind of crime to go uninvestigated and unpunished and merely exposed by the legislative branch is a democracy that is committing suicide. we cannot afford to do that. >> so we have a recent president of france who was convicted of criminal offense involving campaign finance, miner to what we're talking about here. and he was sentenced to a year of home confinement. and so in the western world, we do have examples of this, but it seems to me that washington generally and possibly the justice department even more so regards the possible criminal prosecution of a previous president as something that occurs not on this continent. this is not something for us. this is something for another kind of government in other
kinds of countries. what's your reaction to that kind of thinking about this? >> well, i imagine that that kind of thinking might have been in attorney general merrick garland's mind at an earlier stage before it became increasingly clear that he is almost certainly going to confront a referral for criminal investigation and prosecution of some very high officials. i think he is wise enough to recognize that dangerous as it is to make a common practice of going after the preceding administration, it is even more dangerous to allow any incumbent who has been voted out of office to plot and plan from the very date of the election and indeed by planting doubt about the election in advance the possibility of holding on to office indefinitely, regardless of what the people want. it's not indicative of a banana
republic to preserve the peaceful succession of power to someone chosen by the people and the electoral college. that's the hallmark of a democracy that cares enough about its future to preserve itself. remember franklin's famous comment. what do we have? a republic, if you can keep it. to keep it, we really have to up our game at the justice department. and i'm hopeful. i can't quite say i'm confident because there is no indication yet that a serious grand jury investigation is under way of the people at the top of the attempted coup and the insurrection. but i am hopeful that merrick garland will wait no longer, and that we are about to see serious criminal investigation, not only of the foot soldiers, but of the general, and of the top general of them all.
>> so donald trump remaining absolutely silent in the face of these revelations this week, the detailed descriptions of the criminal plot to violate election laws, steal the presidential election. the republican participants in the house of representatives remaining absolutely silent about their participation in the plot. so let me offer a possible defense from the silent side. a member, whether it be a house member or donald trump, says look, i didn't think any of this was illegal. i thought it was within mike pence's power to do this, and i firmly believed that the election results were fraudulent. i don't have any proof of that. i just believed it because all my friends voted for donald trump. >> you mean the insanity defense? is that what you're describing? >> i didn't know that was the insanity defense. i thought it was the ignorance defense, yes. >> well, you know, ignorance of facts i suppose is one kind of excuse. i didn't know that donald trump
had lost the election. but that's just not plausible. ignorance of the law doesn't count. and you have to be monumentally ignorant of the constitution and the laws of the united states to think that the vice president has unilateral power to basically disregard the certified electoral votes and allow a completely phony set of electors to come in their stead. people who say they believe that are asking you to accept a fantasy. and i just don't think that's a plausible claim. i don't think the attorney general of the united states is likely to be inhibited by the possibility that some juror might accept that claim. even if so, that's not a reason not to investigate thoroughly and fully. the idea of waiting, just waiting until the january 6 committee is done is a big mistake. memories fade. people shade their testimony to
meet what they've already heard. it's important that a parallel investigation by the fbi be under way right now. the justice department, with all of its power not simply wait for congress, but move all speed ahead to investigate fully the criminal responsibility of those who tried to overturn a fair and free election in the united states. its first time that it's gone this far. we cannot let it happen again. and the only way to avoid that is to invoke these laws that among other things disqualify people from ever holding office if they take an oath to uphold the constitution and then plot to subvert it. >> harvard law professor laurence tribe, always an honor to have you with us. thanks for joining us tonight. >> good to be with you. >> thank you. coming up, congresswoman mikie sherrill said she saw
members of congress giving tours the day before the attack on the capitol, giving tours of the capitol. congressman sherrill joins us next. us next there's a lot to deal with. not just unpredictable relapses. all these other things too. it can all add up. kesimpta is a once-monthly at-home injection... that may help you put these rms challenges in their place. kesimpta was proven superior at reducing the rate of relapses, active lesions, and slowing disability progression vs aubagio. don't take kesimpta if you have hepatitis b, and tell your doctor if you have had it, as it could come back. kesimpta can cause serious side effects, including infections. while no cases of pml were reported in rms clinical trials, it could happen. tell your doctor if you had or plan to have vaccines, or if you are or plan to become pregnant. kesimpta may cause a decrease in some types of antibodies. the most common side effects are upper respiratory tract infection, headache, and injection reactions.
every day in business brings something new. ready for an at-home treatment with dramatic results? so get the flexibility of the new mobile service designed for your small business. introducing comcast business mobile. you get the most reliable network with nationwide 5g included. and you can get unlimited data for just $30 per line per month when you get four lines or mix and match data options. available now for comcast business internet customers
our next guest, congresswoman mikie sherrill has been sounding the alarm on what her republican colleagues were up to before january 6. congresswoman sherrill, a former navy helicopter pilot, described seeing members of congress who had groups coming through the capitol that she saw on january 5th for what she thought was reconnaissance for the next day. joining us now is democratic congresswoman mikie sherrill of new jersey. she is a member of the armed services committee. she is a former federal prosecutor and a former helicopter pilot in the united states navy. congresswoman sherrill, we have come a long way from that experience you were having on january 5th watching these people move through the capitol
and wondering about it. 24 hours later, getting very suspicious about it. we now have all of this information gathered and revealed so far by the january 6 committee, which i sense is the tip of the iceberg of what they know. what is your sense of where we are and your understanding now of what you went through a year ago? >> well, lawrence, you're exactly right. adds you mentioned, i'm a former navy helicopter pilot and i've served all over the world. so we're trained to alert, to report things that are unusual or don't seem right. and certainly when the capitol was closed to visitors, to have those tours going through the capitol and then to see what happened on january 6, i reported that, and i think as we've seen through testimony and thousands of papers that have
been turned over in texts, we've seen reported that quite frankly, the coordinated effort that went into planning january 6 went far deeper than i think any of us had anticipated. there was a detailed plan, a coordinated effort that led to those attacks, the effort to overturn our democratic elections. and luckily, just because of really our deep belief in congress, we were able to go back and ensure the will of the people were heard, that we were able to certify the elections, but at such a heavy, heavy cost. >> i want to repeat the list that "the new york times" is publishing tonight about the members of congress who were heavily involved in a plot with mark meadows to overturn the election. these are the republican members of congress. jim jordan, andy biggs, paul gosar, louie gohmert, mo brooks, scott perry.
they were actively involved. "the new york times" describes it this way. this circle moved well beyond words and into action. they bombarded the justice department with dubious claims of voting irregularities. they pressured members of state legislatures to conduct audits that would cast doubt on the election process. they plotted to disrupt the certification on january 6 of joseph r. biden's victory. and as we just heard from professor tribe, that plot was a criminal plot. >> well, i think we saw over time that the former president was very impressed with strong men like duterte and putin and xi jinping and kim jong-un. these were the people that he looked to and lauded, really, and spoke in very complimentary terms about while turning his back on our traditional allies that supported democracy with
us. so should come as no surprise really he was emulating them. and we saw even his own legal team put together a 36-slide power point on how to keep him in power and what people could do and were presenting that evidently to members of congress. so to see that this was a coordinated effort to overturn the will of the american people really now comes as no surprise. >> what has been your reaction this week to cover all these texts going from republican members of congress to mark meadows during the attack on the capitol saying donald trump has to stop this. they all believed that donald trump had complete control of that crowd and could tell them to simply stop them, leave. >> that's really damning, to have that understanding and then not come forward in the
aftermath of january 6 in a united front to ensure that we -- that this never happens again. this was an attempt to thwart the democratic voice of the people, something i regard as sacred. i have taken on oath to the constitution of the united states many times over my lifetime. the first time when i was 18 years old and entered into the naval academy most recently. i did it last january as i started a new session of congress. and what's really incredibly heartbreaking to me is every single member of congress we're talking about when we're talking about people like mark meadows, when we're talking about the president of the united states, every single one of them took that same oath. >> congresswoman mikie sherrill, thank you very much for joining us tonight. i really appreciate it. >> well, thanks for having me. >> thank you. coming up, i'll ask transportation secretary pete buttigieg about president
biden's announcement tonight about the build back better bill. secretary pete buttigieg joins us next. tigieg joins us next. always put clients first. (other money manager) so you do it because you have to? (naj) no, we do it because it's the right thing to do. we help clients enjoy a comfortable retirement. (other money manager) sounds like a big responsibility. (naj) one that we don't take lightly. it's why our fees are structured so we do better when our clients do better. fisher investments is clearly different. when our daughter and her kids moved in with us... our bargain detergent couldn't keep up. turns out it's mostly water. so, we switched back to tide. one wash, stains are gone. [daughter] slurping don't pay for water. pay for clean. it's got to be tide. woman: i have moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. now, there's skyrizi. with skyrizi, 3 out of 4 people achieved 90% clearer skin at 4 months after just two doses.
skyrizi may increase your risk of infections and lower your ability to fight them. before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tuberculosis. tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms, such as fevers, sweats, chills, muscle aches, or coughs or if you plan to or recently received a vaccine. ♪ nothing is everything. ♪ woman: talk to your dermatologist about skyrizi. learn how abbvie could help you save. dry eye symptoms driving you crazy? inflammation might be to blame. inflammation: time for ache and burn! over the counter eye drops typically work by lubricating your eyes and may provide temporary relief. inflammation: those'll probably pass by me! xiidra works differently, targeting inflammation that can cause dry eye disease. inflammation: xiidra? no! it can provide lasting relief. xiidra is the only fda-approved non-steroid treatment specifically for the signs and symptoms of dry eye disease.
one drop in each eye, twice a day. don't use if you're allergic to xiidra. common side effects, include eye irritation, discomfort or blurred vision when applied to the eye, and unusual taste sensation. don't touch container tip to your eye or any surface. after using xiidra, wait fifteen minutes before reinserting contacts. talk to an eye doctor about xiidra. inflammation: i prefer you didn't. xiidra. not today, dry eye. [ coughing and sneezing ] inflammation: i prefer you didn't. cold season is back. bounce back fast with alka seltzer plus. with 25% more concentrated power. alka-seltzer plus. ♪ oh, what a relief it is ♪ so fast! also try for cough, mucus & congestion. firefighter maggie gronewald knows how to handle dry weather... ...and dry, cracked skin. new gold bond advanced healing ointment. restore healthy skin,
secretary pete buttigieg will join us next, and i'm always eager to talk to the secretary of transportation, especially after reading a deeply reported article in "time" magazine why elana samuels, "the truck driver shortage doesn't exist. saying there is one makes conditions worse for drivers." elana samuels report there's is no trucker shortage. there is a trucker retention problem created by the poor conditions that sprung up in the industry in the wake of the 1980s deregulation. there were 1.5 million people employed in trucking last month, according to the bureau of labor statistics. just 1% fewer than in october 2019, and 15% more than a decade
ago. that's a faster growth rate than overall nonfarm employment, which is still down 2% from october 2019 and up only 12% from a decade ago. in fact, there are so many truck drivers right now that brokers are able to pit them against each other and worsen conditions." our next guest, secretary of transportation pete buttigieg participated in a white house meeting with members of the biden administration and members of the trucking industry today, including labor leaders. secretary buttigieg helped present what the administration calls a trucking action plan to strengthen america's trucking workforce. and joining us now is transportation secretary pete buttigieg. thank you very much for joining us tonight, mr. secretary. >> thank you for having me on. god to be with you. >> i'd like to begin with what is the breaking news of this hour, which is the statement from president biden tonight about the build back better act.
he said describing his discussions with senator manchin, senator manchin has reiterated his support for build back better funding at the level of the framework plan i announced in september. he said we will advance this work together over the days and weeks ahead. leader schumer and i are determined to see the bill as early on the floor as possible. the timing there when i hear "weeks," it sounds like it won't be before christmas as was hoped. it sounds like it's moving over into january. and the september level that he's talking about with senator manchin, is that the $1.75 trillion? >> that's right. that's my understanding. and the president expressed confidence that this is going to get done, i think largely because the urgency continues. and the support among the american people continues. right now we don't have one republican vote for this, but we're continuing to have the conversation with senators to look at how exactly to get this done. look, this is only becoming more
urgent as we see a lot of news about inflation, because this bill is about cutting costs. we're going cut the cost of insulin, cut the cost of child care, cut the cost of elder care, cut the cost of pre-k to free, and something i care a lot about, cut the cost of electric vehicles so the more families can afford the gas savings that come with an electric vehicle if you can afford one. i do believe we're going to get it done, even though i can't speak to the exact date it's going to happen. >> i know the -- and we're going get to this -- trucking workforce is specifically addressed in the infrastructure bill that's already been passed, but as i was thinking about it this evening, there are so many provisions of the build back better bill that apply to truckers as well as others all over the country. when you read about just how difficult the economic life of truckers is in this country, they have -- there is ways of
benefitting the trucking workforce outside of the infrastructure bill and in build back better. >> absolutely. i'll just give you one example. we had a round table as you mentioned today where secretary walsh and i were meeting with leaders from labor and business in the trucking sector. one of the most interesting presentations was by an organization called women in trucking. and the number of women in trucking has grown to about 10%. but obviously, that's a long way short of 50%. and if we're leaving 50% of the country on the table when it comes to recruiting people into a profession where we clearly need more people, not that you have to be a woman to benefit from the child care provisions in build back better. but there is no question it's going to lead to more women returning to the workforce, which is one of many, many reasons why it's not just good for families, it's good for the economy. >> i want to go to one point in your plan released today that addresses what i was talking about and what that "time" magazine article is talking about, about the working conditions of truckers that makes the job so unattractive, which is one of the major
problems in the industry. and your plan indicates that the department of transportation, the department of labor will launch a task force to investigate predatory truck leasing arrangements that dissuade drivers from entering or staying in the industry established in the bipartisan infrastructure law. so that's already established in the law. how do you hope that will help strengthen the trucker workforce? >> well, we need to make sure that this is the most attractive job possible. on one hand, we're driving more recruitment efforts, because we do know there are a lot of people seeking to get into this profession. that's where some of the work we're doing, for example, to cut some red tape out of the process of getting a commercial driver's license is so important. recruiting more veteran, and other efforts. but we've also got to face it. there are a lot of conditions that are unfair or unreasonable that truckers face. as longs that persist, it's going to be difficult to attract
people and keep people in that profession. some of the arrangements in terms of how people are trained and wind up on the hook for the costs of their raining can be problematic if they're not paired with a good income on the back end of that. similarly with these leasing arrangements. look, we've got make sure that it's true what people are told when they're invited into this profession. now you talk to some truckers, they have had fantastic careers, good wages, benefits. that's especially true of the truckers who enjoy the protection of being the member of a union. we also got a lot who feel this is not the profession they signeded up for. we have to fix that or else our best recruitment efforts are just going to be filling a leaky bucket. >> the reporting in time magazine if you're a union trucker or independent trucker on your own. the unionized truckers have sensible work hours. and the independent truckers are just at the mercy of so many different crosscurrents. >> well, they're typically paid, the independent ones are paid by the load or by the mile, not by
the hour. and that means, for example, if they're at a port and it's operating in an inefficient way or a warehouse and they're being made to wait hours and hours just to pick up drop off a load, they're not being compensated for that time. so a time when we're talking about a shortage, and i don't want to get hung up on the language, clearly we not waste the time of the truck swrers. time is money for them. it's one example of things that need to develop in this industry if we want it to be the kind of sustaining career that makes sense for workers and makes sense economically, at a time when our supply chains are getting so much attention. look, supply chains at the end of the day are made of people, literally driven by people. and if you think inter, especially a the last two years, we've depended more than truckers. they can't come to work by zoom. we need them on the road. we have counted on them. when you order something online, it doesn't just descend from the crowd. it is brought to you home and left at your home by a trucker.
same thing with everything you see on a shelf in a store. and we've got to make sure that this profession is respected and compensated in a way that reflects its value. >> secretary buttigieg, as you look at the supply chain from -- in its totality, internationally, domestically, what do you see as the areas that need the most improvement at this point? >> well, for the reasons we just discussed, we're certainly paying allot of attention the issue around trucking capacity. we're also seeing a lot of challenges in our port, although i'm really pleased with some of the progress that's been made. at least one of our keyports in california has cut in half the amount of containers that are dwelling there for a long time, gumming up capacity and taking up space when we really need to be moving those through. cut it in half since early november. we have sweeper ships picking up empty containers. tomorrow we'll be in savannah where we see pop-up container
yards that we helped support to try to move containers inland so they can be process in order quickly and efficiently there is a lot of good work being done, but there is a lot remaining to be done. for long run, it's updating our infrastructure, including the port infrastructure. in the immediate term, it's like the steps i just described. as long as the pandemic persists, it is going to create disruptions in our supply chains, as it has from the very first time it was hard to get total paper in this country in march of 2020. that's one more reason why we have such urgency about getting everyone vaccinated and putting this pandemic this the past. >> secretary of transportation, pete buttigieg, always great to have you here. no one breaks it down as clearly as you do. thank you very much for joining us again tonight. >> thank you. >> thank you. coming up, this was the line for a drive-through covid testing in miami today. lori garrett will join us next with the latest on the omicron variant and what you need to
know about holiday travel and new year's eve parties. that's next. at's next. at vanguard, you're more than just an investor, you're an owner with access to financial advice, tools and a personalized plan that helps you build a future for those you love. vanguard. become an owner. most bladder leak pads were similar. until always discreet invented a pad that protects differently. with two rapiddry layers. for strong protection, that's always discreet. question your protection. try always discreet. ok everyone, our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy. whoo hoo! ensure, with 27 vitamins and minerals, now introducing ensure complete!
with 30 grams of protein. ♪ limu emu... & doug ♪ ♪ superpowers from a spider bite? i could use some help showing the world how liberty mutual customizes their car insurance so they only pay for what they need. (gasps) ♪ did it work? only pay for what you need ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ spider-man no way home in theaters december 17th ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ hey google. ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪
what can i du with less asthma? with dupixent i can du more... yardwork... teamwork... long walks.... that's how you du more, with dupixent, which helps prevent asthma attacks. dupixent is not for sudden breathing problems. it's an add-on-treatment for specific types of moderate-to-severe asthma that can improve lung function for better breathing in as little as two weeks. and can reduce, or even eliminate, oral steroids. and here's something important. dupixent can cause serious allergic reactions, including anaphylaxis. get help right away if you have rash, shortness of breath, chest pain, tingling or numbness in your limbs. tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection, and don't change or stop your asthma treatments, including steroids, without talking to your doctor. are you ready to du more with less asthma?
just ask your asthma specialist about dupixent. do you struggle with occasional nerve aches in your hands or feet? try nervivenerve relief from the world's #1 selling nerve care company. nervive contains alpha lipoic acid to relieve occasional nerve aches, weakness and discomfort. try nervivenerve relief. at vanguard, you're more than just an investor, you're an owner with access to financial advice, tools and a personalized plan that helps you build a future for those you love.
vanguard. become an owner. due to the steps we've taken, omicron has not yet spread as fast as it would have otherwise done and is happening in europe. but it's here now and it's spreading, and it's going to increase. for unvaccinated, we are looking at a winter of severe illness and death if you're unvaccinated. but there is good news. if you're vaccinated and you have your booster shot, you're protected from severe illness and death. >> joining us now, laurie garrett, pulitzer prize winning science reporter reporting on global pandemic. she is an msnbc science contributor. laurie, you tweeted about being on the show tonight, and you said that you'd try to answer these questions, should you change your holiday travel plans and what about new year's eve?
neither of those questions had occurred to me until i read your tweet. new year's eve clearly the most important of them. so let me put it to you this way. if i were in, say, california, should i fly to new york if i am invited to the coolest new year's eve party in new york and i just checked my new year's eve invitations, and so far it's zero. so this is a theoretical question. >> lawrence, we're facing a truly overwhelming epidemic phase here. it's going to be gigantic. you can look around the world, places like toronto reporting today or denmark for the whole country, new york city data. and everywhere what you see is not a curve that does this nice, you know, line at some 45-degree angle or even a loop di loop as
we've been seeing with delta. it is this. it is straight up. all over the world we're seeing these absolute explosions because this virus is so contagious. we know that it is significantly more contagious than delta, which was the most contagious we had seen since january 2020. and on top of everything else, it looks like it colonizes, and we have now electron microscope pictures that show this. it colonizes in the upper airways. that means that just casual breathing is expelling virus into the airspace of all of those around you. and so unless everybody is wearing really tight-fitting n95 or k95 masks and covering their nose, which is really the main route of infection, not the mouth, the nose, unless you're
doing that, then you're at risk. so, wow, that's a lot to talk and to think about if you want to get into a taxi cab or public transportation, go to the airport, go through all the crowds, tsa, everything at the airport, then flyairport, then on a plane and do everything in reverse at the other end, and then be among a mix of people, some of whom may be strangers and try to trust that everybody has tested themselves, we're seeing that this virus hits people so quickly that they can test in the morning negative and at 5:00 in the afternoon they come up positive. this is really something different from what we've dealt with up until now. so, lawrence, the question becomes, well, do you rationalize that the risk is worth it even against this very, very contagious omicron because you heard that it's somehow a milder virus, somehow it's less
likely to cause you great harm compared to delta and prior strains. and that did appear to be the case. that was what people were saying two weeks ago when everything was getting started in south africa, but keep in mind, it started on a college campus, so you're talking about two young, healthy 20-somethings, and south africa is a very youthful society. it's one of the youngest societies on earth. now we're beginning to see the virus erupting in places where the demographic skews older, in denmark, in the u.k., and eventually here in the united states, and there we have a different risk ratio. we also have to keep in mind that we have all kinds of different variabilities on who is vaccinated, who isn't vaccinated, if you had one shot, two shots, a booster, which vaccines, and all of these variables make a difference in whether or not you're going to
get sick if you get infected and how sick will you be? but you can't say it's a zero risk. that's absolutely for sure, even if you're triple vaccinated plus you previously had it, because none of it combined offers 100% protection. >> lori garrett, a lot to think about. thank you for joining us once again. we always appreciate it. >> thank you, lawrence. >> thank you. coming up, you are next in tonight's last word. seriously, you. it's all about you, next. aboutt k when heartburn hits, fight back fast with tums chewy bites. fast heartburn relief in every bite. crunchy outside, chewy inside. ♪ tums, tums, tums, tums ♪ tums chewy bites ♪ baby got back by sir mix-a-lot ♪ unlimited cashback match... only from discover.
cough cough sneeze sneeze... [ sneezing ] needs, plop plop fizz fizz. alka seltzer plus cold relief. dissolves quickly. instantly ready to start working. so you can bounce back fast with alka-seltzer plus. now available for fast sinus relief. at vanguard, you're more than just an investor, you're an owner with access to financial advice, tools and a personalized plan that helps you build a future for those you love.
vanguard. become an owner. hello? gordon ramsay? this is a cold call! nfl teams are turning to cold with tide, will you? that will never work! if it works on nfl jerseys it'll work for you. seriously! just perfect! and it'll save up to $150 a year. and it's cold! so you will turn to cold? fine! i'll turn to cold! that guy needs to chill out! this was a cold call!
small businesses like yours make gift-giving possible. now, comcast business has an exclusive gift for you. introducing the gift of savings sale. for a limited time, ask how to get a great deal for your business. and get up to a $500 prepaid card with select bundles when you switch to the network that can deliver gig speeds to the most businesses. or get started with internet and voice for $64.99 per month with a 2-year price guarantee. give your business the gift of savings today. comcast business. powering possibilities.
last night we updated you about the remarkable journey of joyce chazali who first appeared on this program five years ago when she first received a scholarship to attend high school in mawali thanks to the generous donations. you had the pleasure to watch her grow up the last few years from the first time she recited a poem in mawali. in 2019, she joined us as a guest in the studio and spoke to school kids her age about the challenge of getting an education in malawi where public education is not free and the girls' graduation rate is less than half the boys' graduation rate. last night joyce joined us from her new campus at the university of malawi college of medicine. leslie crojan tweeted, watching
joyce tonight brought tears to my eyes. i remember when she was first introduced and read her people little by little. kim tweeted, she's my favorite. i always love hearing about joyce. "little by little" she's on her way. pam said, thank you for the update on joyce. i love seeing her. so far this holiday season you have contributed an additional $786,766 to the kind fund, kids in need of desk, for unicef to provide desks to schools in malawi and scholarships for girls to attend high school. stacey roberts said, as the year ends, i've contributed once again to kind providing desks and scholarships to young girls in malawi. no amount is too small. you can contribute one time to
lastworddesks.msnbc.com. they will send an acknowledgment of your gift. bug tweeted, i just donated to kind fund to help a girl handy high school in malawi. even a little bit can change a girl's life. thank you all very much for your continued support and kindness. i thank you, and joyce chazali thanks you. >> to the people who are donating to girls scholarships, you are helping a lot of girls, including me, and on behalf of all the girls, i would like to say thank you for your support. may you continue having that good place. >> joyce chazali gets tonight's "last word." "the 11th hour" starts now. good evening.
i'm stephanie ruhle. day 331 of the biden administration and with just nine days until christmas, we are back waiting in long lines for covid tests. the nation now facing an alarming new surge in cases just as we head into year three. i'm going to say that again, year three of this pandemic. meanwhile, our already exhausted health care system is now caught between the delta variant and this new highly transmissible omicron strain. >> omicron is here. it's going to start to spread much more rapidly at the beginning of the year, and the only real protection is to get your shot. for the unvaccinated, we are looking at a winter of severe illness and death. we are going to protect our economic recovery if we do this, we're going to keep schools and businesses open. >> it is already spreading. the cdc predicts there could be over a million new cases by