Skip to main content

tv   The Last Word With Lawrence O Donnell  MSNBC  August 24, 2022 10:00pm-11:00pm PDT

10:00 pm
>> we shall see, who knows. >> we shall. >> 24 hours -- >> have a good show, have a good show. >> thank you. one reason that the national archives knew that donald trump did not hand over all presidential records when he left the white house was that some of the most famous documents of the trump presidency were not delivered to the archives after joe biden 's inauguration day. first among them was the very first document donald trump received as document, a handwritten letter from president barack obama to his successor. that, by tradition, as everyone knows, is tucked into a drawer in the desk in the oval office for the incoming president. it was public information on inauguration day in 2017. that president obama left that letter for donald trump, who
10:01 pm
said, it was, quote, a beautiful letter. he actually said that about the president obama letter to him. and then, there were the letters that became, possibly, the most famous presidential letters in history. the trump love letters. >> i got a very beautiful letter from kim jong-un, he really wrote beautiful -- three page, i mean right from top to bottom, a really beautiful letter. >> donald trump never said very much about the text of those letters from the north korean dictator. but he was never shy about the feelings expressed in those letters. >> we fell in love.
10:02 pm
okay? no, really. he wrote me beautiful letters. and they are great letters. we fell in love. >> for most of us, and that was just more trumpian the thundery. that was just donald trump opening up like that about love letters from a murderous dictator, was, for the most of us, just another one of those moments when we knew he was crazy but we did not know he was that crazy. but imagine -- imagine you are a senior archivist at the national archives. and you are watching the news that night on september 29th, 2018. and you see and hear donald trump say about kim jong-un, he wrote me beautiful letters and had great letters. we fell in love. you are an archivist. you know those letters are
10:03 pm
coming your way at some point. do you jump off of the sofa at home when you hear that? do you spill whatever you were drinking when you hear donald trump say that? that he has beautiful letters from kim jong-un? he has love letters from the murderous north korean dictator, who starves his people? from that moment forward, every archivist working at the national archives -- who knew that they were going to see, eventually, the trump presidential papers had to be planning. on day one of delivery of the trump presidential papers. an immediate high-speed search for the trump love letters with kim jong-un. by the trump presidential papers showed up at the end of the trump presidency. and the love letters weren't there. president obama's letter, to
10:04 pm
donald trump wasn't there. and that is why the archives lawyers started asking the trump lawyers for the rest of donald trump's presidential papers, not knowing how much more a donald trump had been illegally holding back at that point and keeping in his possession. but they knew that he had the love letters and he had the president obama letter. the washington post is reporting tonight on an email they have exclusively obtained from the chief counsel of the national archives, gary's turn, to trump lawyers for months after donald trump left office, with the subject line, need for assistance regarding presidential letters. . stern had apparently been in communication -- apparently agreed that there were presidential records that still needed to be delivered to the national archives. gary stern's email to the
10:05 pm
national archives, four months after the presidency, he says, it is also our understanding that roughly two dozen boxes of original presidential records were kept in the residence of the white house over the course of president trump's last year in office and have not been transferred to the national archives, despite a determination by cipollone in the final days of the administration that they needed to be. the washington post reports that in his email, stern sites at least two high-profile documents that the archives knew at the time were missing -- letters from north korean leader kim jong-un -- and a letter from former president barack obama at the beginning of trump's presidency. that is how the investigation of donald trump's illegal possession of presidential
10:06 pm
records and other governmental records, including classified records, began. it was about the love letters. the archives wanted to know where is that traditional letter on from the outgoing president, to the incoming president. and where are the love letters with kim jong-un? in that first email, archives attorney gary stern seems to know something about the love letters already. he seemed to know that donald trump had specifically decided to take personal possession of the love letters in his very final days in office. the washington post reports that attorney gary stern, quote, did cite the correspondence between trump and kim as an example of an item the former president requested just prior to the end of the administration. stern wrote, 80s our
10:07 pm
understanding that in january 2021, just prior to the end of the administration, the originals were put in a binder for the president, but we return to the office of records management for the national archives. so, already, just a few months after donald trump left office, people who work from the trump white house, were obviously already informing the national archives about exactly when donald trump took personal possession of the kim jong-un love letters. the national archives spent the rest of that full year trying to get those documents back and whatever else donald trump had. and we now know that, at the end of that first year out of office, donald trump personally looked through the boxes of government records at his florida home. the new york times reported, stir mr. trump went through the boxes himself in late 2021, according to multiple people briefed on his efforts, before turning them over. and then, one year after donald trump left office, and after donald trump personally went
10:08 pm
through all those boxes at the end of 2021, 15 boxes of documents were returned to the national archives from donald trump's florida home, and still, still donald trump was illegally keeping more classified government records and other government records in his home. and so, the national archives got the justice department involved and federal prosecutors working with fbi agents issued a subpoena for all the rest of the records that could be remaining at donald trump's home and in early june, federal prosecutors and fbi agents, visited donald trump's home in a scheduled visit with donald trump's lawyers, where donald trump's lawyers handed over even more documents to return to the archives. and then, one of the trump lawyers, christina bobb
10:09 pm
actually signed a written statement saying, that's a, that's all the right material we have here. signed her name to that. no more government records, no more classified material left in the home after that day in june. federal investigators became convinced very quickly that that that was not true, and then they convinced a florida federal judge to issue a search warrant of donald trump's florida home for evidence of illegal possession of government records and illegal possession of classified records, and evidence of obstruction of justice. and that search was carried out on august 8th. tomorrow, that same federal judge in florida will decide how much of what the fbi told him, about the possible crimes
10:10 pm
in this case, can be revealed to the public. judge bruce reinhart will consider releasing the fbi affidavit, or portions of it, that convinced him to issue the search warrant tomorrow after a 12 noon deadline tomorrow that he imposed on the justice department, asking the justice department to submit to him suggested redactions to the affidavit to protect individual sources and other possible sensitive issues raised in that fbi affidavit. judge reinhart has said that it is possible that the redactions would have to be so extensive that there would be no real point in releasing an almost fully redacted affidavit. the judge could decide as early as tomorrow afternoon about whether the affidavit can be released and in what form. but what will not be released tomorrow afternoon, or probably ever, or the trump love letters, which are classified material. >> joining us now is democratic
10:11 pm
congressman adam schiff, chair of the house intelligence committee, and member of the january 6th select committee and served as the lead impeachment manager for the first impeachment trial of donald trump. the paperback addition of his book, midnight in washington, how we almost lost our democracy and still could, he's now available with a new afterward -- thank you for joining us tonight, congressman schiff, -- we've just gotten a new piece of it -- and that we have this reporting of tonight from the washington
10:12 pm
post, about this early email from the archives, saying, any fact, we know that you have got some stuff and we know that we don't have the love letters and we don't have the barack obama letter. so, we know that is there. what else is there, give it all to us. and you can see, for a year, the archives is playing very gently with the trump team. and just hoping that the next communication will deliver all the documents. >> well, lawrence, you laid it out very well. and that's exactly the chronology they learned because the president was talking about these love letters that they don't have all the documents they should. and they asked for them, they played for them, the trump team dragged their feet and drag their feet. they get the documents, or least some of them. they want to share them with the fbi because they are concerned now that there are classified materials and the justice department and intelligence agency need to assess what damage might have been done. the trump people fight that and,
10:13 pm
as you said, a trump lawyer ultimately certifies that they have given up all the classified information and they haven't. i think what is particularly interesting about what you are mentioning is trump's own view of the materials. because that puts him right in the middle of this. if he is looking over the boxes montero that should have been provided at the end of the presidency, and he knows what is being turned over any knows, importantly, what is not being turned over. [inaudible] on someone else, as would be the presidents practice of somehow conveying responsibility to others and [inaudible] himself. >> and there is that quote, the new york times reported from staff, who were trying to convince him that this stuff had to be sent back to the archives, where donald trump
10:14 pm
said, it is not there, is it is mine. and he, it seems, believed that, even though he was told multiple times the law was. you get the feeling -- do you get the feeling that he had his reason to believe that the law would not be enforced against him? was that william barr made sure that obstruction of justice laws were not in any way enforced against donald trump. >> well, yes. he certainly had that expectation during his presidency because that is exactly how the department of justice was run. now in recent days, bill barr and, indeed, stephen engel -- memorandum, this wreaths reads like a defense lawyers briefed. and [inaudible] that shouldn't be indicted. -- could not crossed the line about the election. but yes, trump felt immune. and to some degree, may still feel immune, as long as he is a political [inaudible] as long as he is in the mix, i think it's one of the motivations he has to once again run for the presidency,
10:15 pm
which is, to stay one step ahead of the jailer. but i do think that the search of mar-a-lago, after all of the abortive efforts to get these materials shows that there is a will in the justice department to follow the law, even when that law leads to the former president. >> i know is a member of the january 6th committee, in that role, you had developed a certain amount of public and, shall we say, with the justice department in, as far as you can tell, not pursuing the same areas that you have been pursuing in the committee. how do you feel about the way that the justice department is proceeding now? >> i am encouraged by the steps that we are willing to take, with respect to the documents at mar-a-lago, which, among having some of those highly classified markings on them, pose a real danger for national security, should they fall into the wrong hands -- i would feel better, though,
10:16 pm
lawrence, if i saw that same level of determination and urgency as it pertains to the much more serious events, in my view, revolving around an attack on our democracy in an attack on our capitol. there is no reason why the fulton county district attorney 's office should be so far out ahead of the justice department in its investigation of their former presidents efforts to overturn the election in georgia. or we are so far behind our investigation when they ask for all of our files, my first reaction was, why don't you have your own files? but it is encouraging, i think, that after showing great patience, some of these documents with mar-a-lago -- maybe too much patience -- they ultimately concluded they were being stonewalled and possibly obstructed -- violation of the law. -- >> congressman adam schiff, thank you very much for joining us tonight. we really appreciate it. >> thank you. >> and coming up, wasn't a difference in the -- attorney general makes.
10:17 pm
donald trump's attorney general, william barr, covered of evidence of obstruction of justice by downtown been tonight attorney general merrick garland is actually pursuing a criminal obstruction of justice investigation of donald trump. andrew weissmann joins us next.
10:18 pm
10:19 pm
i wish that shaq was my real life big brother. what's up, little bro? turns out, some wishes do come true. and it turns out the general is a quality insurance company that's been saving people money for nearly 60 years. for a great low rate, and nearly 60 years of quality coverage- go with the general. when hurting feet make you want to stop, it's dr. scholl's time. our custom fit orthotics use foot mapping technology to give you personalized support, for all-day pain relief. find your relief in store or online. pool floaties are like whooping cough. amusement parks are like whooping cough. even ice cream is like whooping cough, it's not just for kids. whooping cough is highly contagious for people of any age. and it can cause violent uncontrollable coughing fits.
10:20 pm
sometimes followed by vomiting and exhaustion. ask your doctor or pharmacist about whooping cough vaccination because whooping cough isn't just for kids. with xfinity internet, you get advanced security ask your doctor or pharmacist about whooping cough vaccination that helps protect you at home and on the go. you feel so safe, it's as if... i don't know... evander holyfield has your back. i wouldn't click on that. hey, thanks! we got a muffin for ed! all right! you don't need those calories. can we at least split it? nope. advanced security that helps protect your devices in and out of the home. i mean, can i have a bite? only from xfinity. nah. unbeatable internet. >> this time tomorrow night, we made to do anything so you can do anything.
10:21 pm
might be reporting on new information learned from the possible release of a redacted version of an fbi affidavit that a federal judge in florida relied on and has says he believed when he authorized the
10:22 pm
search warrant of donald trump 's home in florida because that affidavit convinced the judge that the fbi would probably find evidence of obstruction of justice as well as evidence of other possible crimes involving the possession of government documents, including classified documents. it is not the first time that the justice department had evidence of obstruction of justice by donald trump. today, the justice department decided not to continue a court fight over a freedom of information act request to release a 2019 memo to donald trump's attorney general, william barr, saying that the special counsel's investigation led by robert mueller did not find proof of obstruction of justice by donald trump. to trump appointed justice department appointed lawyer said in writing, in the memo, that's donald trump's
10:23 pm
discussion with fbi director james comey about the fbi's investigation of michael flynn was not obstruction of justice because, quote, the presidents expression of hope that comey would let this go did not clearly direct a particular action in the flynn investigation. the memo also said that donald trump ordered the firing of special counsel robert mueller was not attempted obstruction of justice or obstruction of justice because, quote, there is considerable evidence to suggest that the president took these official actions, not for an illegal purpose, but rather because he believed the investigation was politically motivated and undermined his administration's efforts to govern. the memo also said, we likewise
10:24 pm
do not believe that the president's public statements exhorting witnesses, like flynn, manafort, stone or cohen, not to flip should be viewed as obstruction of justice. that means that the two authors of this bill are the only federal prosecutors in history who do not know what flip means. it is, of course, the term traditionally used by gangsters and donald trump to mean a witness engaged in criminal conduct who flips and decides to tell the truth in court about that criminal conduct. joining us now is andrew weissmann, former fbi general counsel and former chief of the criminal division in the eastern district of new york. he is professor of practice and i-20 at nyu law school and an msnbc legal analyst. andrew, i want to first get your view of what you expect tomorrow at noon when the judge gets the justice department's proposed redactions of that affidavit. >> so, lawrence, i love that
10:25 pm
you are really optimistic about what we might expect tomorrow. [laughs] but i think that what we should expect tomorrow is nothing. that submission is going to be given to the court under seal, so we won't see that, at least initially. and i think the judge is going to need to study it and look at it, and decide what party agrees with, what parts he may disagree with. so, i think it may take -- i think tomorrow might be -- i wouldn't hold your breath. but we will see. maybe you will be right and that's something by the end of the day. but i would think a couple days at least. you could ask the other side to submit something on a legal point. >> so, he may just take the proposed redactions, study them, take his time, figure it out. and then tomorrow, most likely, no action by the judge. i want to get your reaction to
10:26 pm
this release, now, of this memo that we are seeing today for the very first time. from two lawyers in the justice department, who up here,, as you read, it appeared to be working with donald trump's defense lawyers trying to come up with the most absurdest possible defenses, like we think warning -- publicly warning -- witnesses not to flip, is okay. >> so, it is hard to relive this. this was a very difficult moment in our lives in the special counsel, given what bill barr did here. it is remarkable that none of these people addressed in this memo the obvious point, which is, if they wanted director mueller, who is serving a special counsel, to actually make a decision on the obstruction evidence, they could have just told him to do
10:27 pm
that. and it was good reason for them to do that, because, after, all this was given to a special counsel for sicily because a determination was made that decision should not be -- the investigation should not be done by political appointees of donald trump. there is a good reason that we now know from this memo, that that didn't happen. because in the memo, they say, when this report comes out, the public is going to think that the president obstructed justice, which, it's pretty clear, that's exactly what people would think. many, many prosecutors said so. so, they came up with really absurdest arguments that -- it reminds me of their position with michael flynn. they just said things that just don't apply to anyone else. you made reference to some of it.
10:28 pm
there are other things in the memo where they say, you know, if you haven't committed an underlying crime, then you cannot be guilty of obstructing an investigation. but that is insane. and the prosecutor knows that that is not true. you might lie to prosecutors because you just don't want an affair to become public. you have all sorts of reasons that you might obstruct an investigation and it doesn't mean that you committed some underlying crime. they get the law will wrong, on that point. so, it's really whitewashed. and there is a reason that the district judge in the court of appeals ruled against the department. and a district judge was quite vehement, saying that the department, which is under bill barr, was disingenuous, a fancy word for, they lied to her about what was in this memo. >> is it your impression that the authors of this memo hoped and believed that it could never become public? >> i think that, yes, i think that's right. this was written by the head of the office of legal counsel and he probably thought that this would be governed by deliberative process.
10:29 pm
and frankly, the court of appeals here said that, essentially, if they had lied to the district judge about what you were doing, this might have been deliberative process. but they basically said, if you lie to a judge, you are going to be sanctioned. and the sanction he was making it public. >> andrew weissmann thank you very much for joining us tonight. >> you are welcome. >> coming up, we have breaking news at this hour, the uvalde school board has just terminated school district police chief pete arredondo over his failures at the mass shooting at the elementary school in uvalde, were 19 students were murdered and two teachers were murdered three months ago. state senator roland gutierrez will join us next.
10:30 pm
when we started, we grew a quarter of an acre. now i'm taking on new projects on the regular. we always dreamed of having this property, so - i want to make my yard look as beautiful as butters, here. butters. how are you doing over there? we do both vegetables and large mouth bass. yep. we've got tons of them, don't we, buddy? there are millions of ways to make the most of your land. learn how to make the most of yours at power e*trade's easy-to-use tools like dynamic charting and risk-reward analysis help make trading feel effortless and its customizable scans with social sentiment help you find and unlock opportunities in the market with powerful, easy-to-use tools power e*trade makes complex trading easier react to fast-moving markets with dynamic charting and a futures ladder that lets you place, flatten, or reverse orders so you won't miss an opportunity nope
10:31 pm
nope that lets you place, flatten, or reverse orders c'mon him? oo, i like him! nooooo... noooo... noooo... quick, the quicker picker upper! bounty picks up messes quicker and each sheet is 2x more absorbent , so you can use less. he's an eight he's a nine bounty, the quicker picker upper. (driver 1) it's all you. (driver 2) no, i insist. (driver 1) it's your turn. (burke) get farmers and you could save money with the safe driver discount just by having a clean driving record for three years. get a whole lot of something with farmers policy perks. (driver 3) come on! ♪ we are farmers. bum-pa-dum, bum-bum-bum-bum ♪ it's time for the biggest sale of the year, on the sleep number 360 smart bed.
10:32 pm
it senses your movements and automatically adjusts to keep you both comfortable. our smart sleepers get 28 minutes more restful sleep per night. all smart beds are on sale. save 50% on the sleep number 360 limited edition smart bed. ends monday. i brought in ensure max protein with 30 grams of protein. those who tried me felt more energy in just two weeks. uhh... here, i'll take that! yay!!! ensure max protein, with 30 grams of protein, 1 gram of sugar enter powered by protein challenge for a chance to win big!
10:33 pm
joe biden and democrats in congress just passed a law to lower the cost of medicine. for a chance the inflation reduction act lets medicare negotiate lower prices with drug companies for the first time. that's more savings for us. for decades, i've worked at the intersection of domestic violence and homelessness. so when prop 27 promised solutions to homelessness, i took a good, hard look. it's not a solution. 90% of the money goes to the out-of-state corporations who wrote it. very little is left for the homeless. don't let corporations exploit homelessness to pad their profits. vote no on 27. >> you don't care a squat about
10:34 pm
this family. if it was one of your children, heads would be rolling right now. but because it is not, you don't care! >> if it was one of your children, heads would be rolling right now. that was daniel myers speaking to a meeting of the uvalde school board tonight, with a question before the school board was weather to continue the employment contract of the
10:35 pm
school district police chief, pete arredondo, who allowed over an hour to pass in robb elementary school in uvalde, before police opened the door of a classroom and killed a mass murderer who had killed 19 children and two teachers. >> i have messages for pete arredondo and other law enforcement there that day. turning your badge and step down you don't deserve to wear one! [applause] >> chief arredondo and his lawyers did not show up at the meeting tonight to present a public defense of the chief. but arredondo's it's a written statement to the school board in which they complained of inadequate due process as required, they say, by texas law. and they said, quote, chief did arredondo the right thing, the chief did everything he knew how to save the children and school employees on may 24th.
10:36 pm
the tactic a legal argument arredondo's made in the written statement was clearly presented. but the rest of the statement was very badly written. and at times, directly insulted people who lost family members in the mass murder. the statement actually says, so, naturally, those affected, lash out and seek more retribution by identifying a new target to focus their grief on, with the belief that it will help them stop them hurting. unfortunately, it won't. and so there are pete arradondo and his lawyers going inside the minds of the grieving families and claiming that those families are angry at pete arredondo and are expressing their anger at pete arredondo just to ease their own pain, not because of anything pete arradondo did or didn't do. brett krause, who lost his nephew in the mass murder, asked the school board, to not
10:37 pm
do their business this time in a closed session. >> do not take this as a closed session. we deserve to hear -- our babies are dead, our teachers are dead, our parents are dead. the least y'all can do is show us the respect to do this in the public. >> after that, the school board went into closed session. when they came out of that closed session, this happened. >> mr. board president, i move that good cause exist to terminate the contract of pete arredondo further immediately. i further move -- that good cause exists to ratify the unpaid leave status of mr. arredondo starting july 19th, 2022. finally, i moved to authorize a
10:38 pm
superintendent, to issue notice to mr. arredondo, at this board action, including filing any needed reports we by the termination. >> [inaudible] any further discussion? all in favor? motion passes unanimously. item number five [inaudible] -- >> mr. board president, i make a move that we adjourn -- >> [inaudible] >> we [inaudible] stand adjourned. thank you. have a good night. >> and joining us now from uvalde is nbc news correspondent priscilla thompson, who is at that meeting tonight. priscilla, what was it like when the suspense was finally broken and they took that vote to fire pete arredondo? yeah, lawrence, you saw there with the crowd erupting in applause and cheers. this is something that many people in this community have
10:39 pm
been waiting on for three months and finally, it's coming tonight with the board finding that there is in fact good cause determinate chief arredondo, or former chief arredondo's, which contract, effective immediately. and this was a very tense meeting. it began with around a handful of community members stepping to that microphone and sharing some of those very impassioned speeches that you heard, calling for transparency and accountability. they did not want this to happen behind closed doors. but the board said that, because this was a personnel matter, they were required to do it behind closed doors and they also wanted to consult with the school boards attorneys on this issue. and so, they were in that closed-door meeting for more than an hour, during which you could feel the tension in the room steadily rising as people continue to get up and go to the microphone and share their frustrations. >> at one point, a community member even saying, just tell
10:40 pm
come out and tell us what the decision is already, stop wasting our time. and so, this was by no means a done dell. many of the families here felt like they have been hiccups and misinformation every step of the way. nothing about this process has been easy and they expected that they were in for a fight tonight. as for chief arredondo, he did not attend in person, his attorney, of course, releasing that 17-page statement, calling for his reinstatement and also calling for back pay, and benefits, that obviously did not happen. tonight, many of the families are calling this a victory for the victims, the families, and also this community. lawrence? >> nbc's priscilla thompson. thank you very much for that reporting from uvalde tonight. and joining us now is texas state senator roland gutierrez, represents texas's 19th district, which includes uvalde. and he attended tonight's school board meeting.
10:41 pm
senator, thank you for joining us once again tonight. what can you tell us about what it was like to be there tonight? >> well, thank you lawrence, for having me. certainly, this communities broke, and lawrence. these families have been asking for this to happen for sometime now. it was 90 days to long. but obviously,, there is a process, they understand that. these folks at the school board probably took a lot longer than they needed to. but the families are absolutely certain that this is just the beginning of accountability. we still have to look at the role of the police, the sheriff, and they are talking about those things and the department of public safety. it is unfortunate but we still have so much information that we have yet to even find out, because the p. s. and the district attorney don't want us to have the information that these community leaders are asking for this time. >> one of the things and what i thought was the very badly written section of pete arredondo's lawyer's statement tonight, was a point that they inartfully, rather terribly and crudely, made, that pete
10:42 pm
arredondo was the person who many -- who were involved in this are hoping everyone will just blame him and that will take care of it. he can be the scapegoat. especially state police officials. those lawyers say, they are hoping at the state police level that everyone just looks at what happens tonight and says, okay, that is, it the person responsible for what happened there is now gone. >> well, i can tell, you from my part, lawrence, i am not stopping here. it was clear to me in everything that we have seen so far that the state police are equally as responsible. they arrived at 2:28, 91 of them on the scene. i do find it ironic that arredondo's lawyer's letter suggests this, and said that he was not receiving justice. talk to these families. these families haven't received an ounce of justice this state,
10:43 pm
this government, has failed them and failed him prior to may 24th, did it on may 24th, the worst law enforcement response in this type of case, in texas history. and it has continued to fail over. this department of public safety is it has continued to be honest with people. it's refuse to get is the information that we need. and to be clear, this is greg abbott's own personal operation lone star task force that was on the scene. greg abbott has failed these people and his own director, who directs reports to greg abbott, has given no accountability and greg abbott has asked for no accountability. >> texas state senator roland gutierrez, thank you very much for joining us once again on this very important story. >> thank you, lawrence. >> thank you. and coming, up today, on ukraine's 31st independence day, president biden authorized the single largest delivery of military aid yet to ukraine.
10:44 pm
and terrorist leader vladimir putin committed yet another war crime with another missile strike on civilian targets. that is next. [eerie shrinking sounds] (brad) congratulations! you're having an out-of-apartment experience- 'cause these cramped confines aren't going to fit your rapidly expanding family. but with more rental listings than anybody else, apartments-dot-com can help you trade this love nest for... (woman) actual nest. (brad) baby names! for a boy, brad. for a girl, brad. apartments-dot-com. the place to find a place. power e*trade's award-winning trading app makes trading easier. with its customizable options chain,
10:45 pm
easy-to-use tools, and paper trading to help sharpen your skills, you can stay on top of the market from wherever you are. power e*trade's easy-to-use tools make complex trading less complicated. custom scans help you find new trading opportunities. while an earnings tool helps you plan your trades and stay on top of the market. it's 5:00 a.m., and i feel like i can do anything. we've been coming here, since 1868. there's a lot of cushy desk jobs out there, but this is my happy place. there are millions of ways to make the most of your land. learn more at
10:46 pm
♪♪ does it get better than never getting lost? ♪♪ does it get better than not parallel parking yourself? ♪♪ alexa ask smartfeed to feed the dog. does it get better than feeding your dog from 50 miles away? yes... it does. at buick we see a future that's even better. because the life enhancing innovations you've never even dreamed of? buick is dreaming of them every day.
10:47 pm
10:48 pm
vo: hi. we're zerowater. and we believe everyone deserves the purest tasting water. that's why we strive for zero. you see, to some it means nothing. but to us, it means everything. here, take a look. this meter showing triple zeros means our five-stage filter did its job. and that virtually all dissolved solids, or tds, have been removed. and all that's left is the purest tasting water. let's compare. a two-stage brita filter stops here. but our five-stage filter doesn't quit. zero water. we strive for zero. >> it is independence day today in ukraine, where they celebrated 31 years of independence from the cruel dictatorship of the former soviet union. ukrainians also marked the six month point in their survival of the terrorist attack on their country, launched by the most murderous terrorist of the
10:49 pm
21st century. vladimir putin. vladimir putin celebrated ukraine's independence day, the only way a terrorist knows how, with another russian war crime, missile strike on a civilian target. this time, vladimir putin and the terrorists in his military murdered 22 people and left 15 severely injured. in a speech, before the russian terrorist attack today, ukraine's president zelenskyy said that ukraine was reborn after the russian terrorist invaded the country. he said, we finally became truly one. a new day shun that emerged on february 24th at 4 am, not born but reborn. a nation that did not cry, did not scream, did not get scared.
10:50 pm
did not run away and did not give up, didn't forget. we are holding on for six months. it is difficult for us but we punched our fists, fighting for our faith. what is the end of the war for us? we used to say piece. now we say, victory. we will not seek an understanding with the terrorists. today, president biden wanted ukraine independence day by announcing three billion dollars in military aid for ukraine, the largest single military aid package yet for ukraine, in a written statement, president biden said on behalf of all americans, i congratulate the people of ukraine on their independence day. over the past six months, ukrainians have inspired the world with their extraordinary courage and dedication to freedom. they have stood resolute and strong in the face of russia's full scale invasion of ukraine. and today is not only a celebration of the past, but a resounding affirmation that ukraine proudly remains and will remain a sovereign and
10:51 pm
independent nation. joining our discussion now, phillips p. o'brien, professor of strategic studies at the university of st andrews in scotland. he is the author of how the war was one, here, see, power and allied victory in world war ii. and is david rothkopf joining us, foreign affairs analyst and columnist for usa today and the daily beast. david, let me begin with you and where you think things stand in ukraine at this six month point in this war of survival that ukraine is fighting against russia. >> a few things. first, we were not supposed to get here. this was supposed to be over in three days. that did not happen. in fact, putin has demonstrated that he he's a bad military leader, a bad national leader, and russia has blundered at every turn.
10:52 pm
the u.s. estimate is a loss of 70 to 80,000 troops to be killed or injured, 4000 armored vehicles, while russia holds about 20% of ukraine, the reality is that there are a number of signs that suggest that ukrainians are gaining strength, thanks to western, particularly u.s. support, and i think now in the next two months we are going to have a look and see if they can launch a successfully uninitiated of to retake kherson, if they can continue their strikes against crimea, if they are able to successfully do those things, i think russia is going to be further out of that foot, further as we get towards winter, the other thing we are going to look at is to see whether europe is indeed able to withstand the pressure that might come from-limited russian energy supplies -- it looks like they are getting ready for that. and so it looks bad for russia. further as we get towards winter, the other thing we are going to look at is to see whether europe is indeed able to withstand the pressure that
10:53 pm
might come from-limited russian energy supplies -- it looks like they are getting ready for that. and so it looks bad for russia. >> phillips p. o'brien, six months ago, the fear level of russia in the neighboring countries was, of course, extremely high. do they have reasons, six months later, poland, for example, to be somewhat less fearful of russia, when they are seeing what amounts to a russian military failure so far in ukraine? >> it is a great question, lawrence. i think in one case, of course, when we has of his a horrible military crime committed in russia but we also have a tremendous military disaster that we are seeing unfold amongst ourselves. putin has put hamas's entire armed forces in the ukraine. by some estimates, more than 80% of russian frontline military force has been deployed in ukraine and it has been destroyed. it has been stopped, it hasn't been able to advance. so the idea, for instance, that
10:54 pm
russia would represent a threat to nato now is farcical. nato would crush the russian armed forces in a matter of days. so, never before has nato really been so secure. the reality is, the russian army was terribly overrated. ukraine was sadly starved of arms. the big tragedy in this is, how do we not overrated the russian military as this great force going into the war, and had ukraine been armed properly, the war might be over now, because the russian army similar simply isn't as powerful as thought. but we are where we are and nato we secure and we knew this after worrying about a russian attack now. and it is a question of helping ukraine store with they but we are where we are and nato we secure and we knew this after worrying about a russian attack now. and it is a question of helping ukraine store with they have lost. >> phillips p. o'brien and david rothkopf, thank you very much both for joining us on ukraine independence day. really appreciate it. >> thank you. >> thank you. >> thank you. >> we will be right back.
10:55 pm
here's a pool party. ♪ good times. insurance! ♪ only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪
10:56 pm
10:57 pm
new astepro allergy. now available without a prescription. astepro is the first and only 24-hour steroid free spray. while other allergy sprays take hours astepro starts working in 30 minutes. so you can... astepro and go. an amusement park is like whooping cough, it's not just for kids. whooping cough is highly contagious for people of any age. and it can cause violent uncontrollable coughing fits. ask your doctor or pharmacist about whooping cough vaccination because it's not just for kids. your shipping manager left to “find themself.” leaving you lost. you need to hire. i need indeed. indeed you do. indeed instant match instantly delivers quality candidates matching your job description. visit with xfinity internet, you get advanced security
10:58 pm
that helps protect you matcat home and on the go.ion. you feel so safe, it's as if... i don't know... evander holyfield has your back. i wouldn't click on that. hey, thanks! we got a muffin for ed! all right! you don't need those calories. can we at least split it? nope. advanced security that helps protect your devices in and out of the home. i mean, can i have a bite? only from xfinity. nah. unbeatable internet. >> and that is tonight's last made to do anything so you can do anything.
10:59 pm
word, the 11th hour with stephanie ruhle starts right now. ♪ ♪ ♪ >> tonight, a secret memo to former attorney general bill barr is unsealed today. the memo supports bill barr's questionable decision not to charge donald trump with obstructing the russian investigation. and the former president says he was surprised the fbi came to get top secret documents at his club. but it turns out the government had been trying since before he left office. then, president biden's game-changer announcement on student loan forgiveness -- a [inaudible] for millions of americans. plus, the big lie turned a big
11:00 pm
rift. how some are profiting off of disproven election fraud claims. goes beyond the former president. as the 11th hour gets underway on this wednesday night. ♪ ♪ ♪ good evening once again, i'm alicia menendez, in four stephanie ruhle. as if the current day controversies of the former president were not enough, we begin with new insight tonight into how donald trump may have avoided accountability in the investigation that consumed must of his presidency. late today, after a lengthy court fight, the justice department released a document related to the russia investigation. the memo was top secret and now we know why. former presidents attorney bill barr wanted to keep it a secret. in march 2019, bill barr told us before the mueller report was released, that the report had all but exonerated the former president. and therefore, there was no reason to charge him.