Skip to main content

tv   The Ed Show  MSNBC  September 23, 2009 6:00pm-7:00pm EDT

6:00 pm
a woman in her early 40s who did have a wonderful, high-paying job, owns her own home and was real contributing member of society. she lost her job just a couple of weeks ago she found out that she have tumors in her belly and that she needs an operation. her doctors told her that they are growing and she needs to get this operation quickly. she has no insurance. >> i guess i would ask what the situation is in terms of income eligibility and the existing programs that are out there because if we look at the uninsured right now, there is probably 23%, 24% of the uninsured that is already eligible for an existing government program beyond that. i know that there are programs, there are charitable organizations, there are hospitals here who do provide
6:01 pm
charity care. >> that is a classic, my friends. did you get all of that? a woman's got stomach issues. she's got cancer. she needs surgery now. this is a classic because when you present the republicans in the obstructionists with a real-life scenario, they don't have an answer. they're still talking percentages. how would you like to be in the percentage where you're left out? you're just sol? that's their reform. that's their answer. you know, they're great at holding up the socialism, the communism, the marxism, all kinds of isms, bullt they don't have an answer for that woman. she's just at the wrong spot at the wrong time, and we've got to talk about the redistribution of wealth. you know, i was watching the u.n. coverage today here on
6:02 pm
msnbc, and all the speeches that were given, and they took a wide shot of all the different diplomats and leaders of the countries that were there, and i wish i had gone over there with a camera and done an international man on the street or leader on the street and asked them if they do health care in their country the way we do it here. i know the answer. it's no. we like to butcher people who have got cancer that don't fall in the correct percentage point. so here's my point. americans, you can't trust eric cantor. cantor's response speaks volumes about how inept the republicans are and how they are simply not solution-based. charity? is that what he said? this woman can't get a government program. she's in her early 40s. she's too young for medicare. she doesn't qualify for medicaid, but there's always charity, or what the heck?
6:03 pm
you can go to the hospital and plead your case and say, you know, i'm broke. cantor should know that there's no such thing as a free lunch in health care. the hospital passes the costs on to the other patients or they pass it on to the insurance companies and then they pass it on to you and me in some form of a higher premium. that's how the hell we got started in this debate in this country in the first place about health care reform. hold it right there. the republicans lie. they want to see you dead. they'd rather make money off your dead corpse. they kind of like it when that woman has cancer and they don't have anything for her. that's how the insurance companies make money. by denying the coverage. democrats, what's wrong with you? you can't deal with these people. at all, but it's socialism. but it's about taxes. let's get to the larger issue here. cantor thinks that there are more important issues than a
6:04 pm
life or death thing for that woman. there's the pressing issue of amendments over on the senate side that he hasn't said anything about like, hey, man, let's go after a.c.o.r.n. make sure we don't have czars in health care reform. the folks on the senate finance committee, they don't get it either. here's senator olympia snowe asking for what? the september stall, stall, stall again. >> if it takes two more weeks it takes two more weeks. i mean, we're talking about trillions of dollars in the final analysis. i do not understand it. what is the rush? what is happening in two weeks? is there something happening in two weeks that we cannot wait? is it the columbus day recess? what is it? because i'm not quite clear. i want to do my job, and our job is to sit here and do it as long as it takes.
6:05 pm
>> do it and watch people die. that's the republican way. why can't we delay? senator snowe, what part of this didn't you get? >> she has tumors in her belly 3 she needs and operation. her doblgters told her they are growing and she needs to get this operation quickly. she has no insurance. >> two weeks. matters a lot. now, olympia snowe, i'm not wishing bad on you at all, but if you get cancer in your stomach, senator snowe, what i would like you to do is wait two weeks to see a doctor. huh? you're telling them to suck it up. this is a moral issue. we've got to act on this now. there has got to be a cure for this woman in the greatest country on the face of the earth. are we the greatest country on the face of the earth when it comes to health care? i don't buy that. i think we can do better. here's what the republicans and the righty talkers and all the
6:06 pm
psychos on tv do. what they do is play to your fears. as if somebody is going to come take something from you. the president of the united states is trying to make it right. the republicans are fighting him tooth and nail on this. get for cell phones out. should the senate finance committee delay a vote on health care reform? text "a" for yes b" for no to 622639. we'll bring you the results later on in the show. note on the senate finance committee. they're going to take a break for dinner and come back and vote on an amendment. an amendment today was to delay the vote. thank god we won that one 12-11. there will probably be a vote on friday to stay on schedule there. my passion on this just continues to grow and boil when i hear stories like that. what would you say to that woman if she was your next door neighbor?
6:07 pm
hey, when's the funeral? what cemetery do you want? would you like to go next door to her and say, you've got some hope? a chance at life? because there is something for you, even though you lost your job and even though you got cancer, this great country that those guys on omaha beach died for and those guys in the big one in ww ii died for. they never thought america would be like this. you know what? the righties tell us, well, they support the troops. it is so convoluted. it is so wrong. this is not the country that i grew up in. i'm willing to pay more. i'm in the top 2%. let me remind you wonderful viewers this. all of the people on this network, all of the people on all the other networks, all of the people that work in new york on tv, they have health care. they have health care. and if they get cancer, they got
6:08 pm
nothing to worry about because they're going to get treated. when you bring a real-life scenario to the republican leadership in the form of a cantor or boehner, you know what they do? they talk percentages with that woman, with that problem in her gut. how do you think her family feels? do they feel very patriotic when they hear that? do they feel better about america when they hear that that's the way it is? do you think they would like to be in that long line in canada if there really is a long line in canada? when are we, as a nation, and when are the democrats as an organization going to stand up and say, you know, we've done a lot of things right as a country but this is the one thing we have screwed up. this for profit stuff is a bad deal. we have people dying. we play percentages with them. there's a party out there that wants to give you a number and if you're in line you're in
6:09 pm
line. i know we're better than this. i'm not afraid of hitler. i'm not afraid of socialism and i'm not afraid to make a change. i would rather be called all the names in the world and communicate with that lady in her family knowing that she got help and stand up and say, i think the guys that were on omaha beach that sacrificed their life for this country, i think that's the kind of america they would want. joining me now, senator bob casey of pennsylvania. he's a member of the senate health committee. senator, good to have you with us tonight. >> thanks ed, good to be with you. thank you. >> i'm looking for language in all of the republican proposals on what will stop the gouging because the big issue now is you, the dls want to get a bipartisan agreement. i'll accept that. you want to work with them. i get that. i'm looking for language in all
6:10 pm
of the republican bills and i don't see anything that deals with the constant gouging and the denial of care for the american people to address the scenario that we just played out here on this show. if there's something i'm missing, senator, i'll give you the rest of the show to explain it. >> ed, you raise a great point. first of all, there's no sense of urgency with republican politicians on this issue. there just isn't. especially when you hear what -- what congressman cantor just said. there's no sense of urgency and there's also no credible counterproposal to what we've been talking about for months. 44,230 people every single week lose their coverage and you hear this, well, let's think about it some more. there's no sense of urgency, no sense of common purpose to get this done. when i hear people on the republican side of the aisle in washington talking about we've got to focus on the economy, i don't know where they've been. we passed a recovery bill that's working already and not a single house republican voted for it.
6:11 pm
now they want to talk about who's working on the economy. health care, unfortunately, right now is the driver of our long-term national debt. we have to make sure we address this now, not only for people that you just highlighted. i hear it every day of the week. i sat in my office yesterday with a woman from pennsylvania who had a similar story. has a very urgent medical need and she can't get the kind of coverage even with -- even under the umbrella of some kind of an insurance policy. this is -- the sense or the lack of a sense of urgency on their side is appalling. >> they have to be able to tell the american people, what are you going to do to make sure insurance companies are not denying people coverage because of a pre-existing condition or gouging them of out of pocket costs or preventing people from getting mammograms or paying exorbitant prices on that or putting lifetime caps on your coverage. they don't seem to have answers. they want to talk about the
6:12 pm
politics of washington instead of talking about what real families are facing today. not years from now. >> senator casey of pennsylvania, i have one nine question i want to ask you tonight. what about the timing of this? the republicans over on the senate finance committee, today, they wanted to draw it out another couple of weeks. what's your counter to that? i mean, can we have a timetable here? >> we've been, ed, you know better than i. we've been debating this issue for decades. we've been debating it intensively at least since the early 1990s. we have to get a bill done now in the next couple weeks. the finance committee has worked and i appreciate the fact they've tried to be bipartisan. we have to move and get this done. we can do it because we proved it in the house education labor pension committees. we got a bill out of our committee in the middle of july. they can get it done on this window. we can do this. we know what works. i don't think we should delay it longer. >> senator casey, great to have you on.
6:13 pm
keep up the fight. for more, let me turn back to the house side for a moment. congressman brian bilbray from california, republican. good to have you withes tonight. >> great to be with you tonight. >> i want solutions, and i want a fair conversation. mr. cantor who's in a leadership role for the republicans in your party stood up and basically told this woman to go get charity and to go find a government program. she doesn't have either one. so do the republicans have a solution for this? >> ed, look, i'm somebody who worked on the safety net for the county of san diego, 3 million people. there is solutions. one of the biggest challenges we have is as we talk back and forth, what have we done in washington to reduce the cost, the waste, the fraud? we talk about we're going to do it. we really haven't been willing to do the heavy lifting of actually proving that we can manage these things and -- >> i don't disagree with you on
6:14 pm
that, congressman. that woman stood up and asked the republican leadership a question and she was told to go get a charity. now, is that what the republicans are telling steny hoyer when steny says, hey, come on in and let's work together on this? is that what's being said? >> absolutely not. in fact, we know there are a whole lot of services out there that aren't being tapped into. the real big problem is the fact both sides aren't willing to tell their buddies that, look, insurance companies, trial lawyers, you guys have got to give up profits so we can afford to have the type of health care that the american people would like to have. >> congressman, good to have you on tonight. i appreciate your time. thanks so much. >> thank you very much. coming up, two of my favorite warmongers, john mccain and condi rice. once again they're trying to scare us into staying in afghanistan. award winning filmmaker robert green would joins me at the bottom of the hour. beckster is become in
6:15 pm
"psycho talk." he's saying our country might not survive obama's presidency. that's going to own him a trip into the zone tonight. encore performance. president obama stared down the leaders of the world, ahmadinejad. jamie ruben will tell us how did the president do today? was he tuf enough? that's coming up in our "playbook." even experts agree. it's damage protection results leading salon brands can't beat. the blow dryer, the curling iron, and my hair's still shiny. pantene. now your card comes with a way to plan for what matters to you. introducing blueprint. blueprint is free and only for chase customers. it lets you choose what purchases you want to pay in full to avoid interest...with full pay. and those you split... you decide how to pay over time. if having a plan matters.
6:16 pm
chase what matters. create your own blueprint at president obama may be walking into a hornets nest in the g-20 in pittsburgh. union president of the steelworkers union up next on "the ed show." [ engine powers down ] gentlemen, you booked your hotels on orbitz. well, the price went down, so you're all getting a check thanks. for the difference. except for you -- you didn't book with orbitz, so you're not getting a check. well, i think we've all learned a valuable lesson today. good day, gentlemen. thanks a lot. thank you. introducing hotel price assurance,
6:17 pm
where if another orbitz customer books the same hotel for less, we send you a check for the difference, automatically. getting an early flu shot is the best thing you can do... to protect you and your loved ones from the flu. it's also one of the easiest things you can do... because walgreens is now offering seasonal flu shots... every day of the week with convenient hours guaranteed. so you can just stop in. our 16,000 dedicated pharmacists... and take care clinic nurse practitioners... are waiting to help you beat the flu... in neighborhoods nationwide.
6:18 pm
6:19 pm
welcome back to "the ed show." the g-20 summit kicks off this week in pittsburgh. president obama going face to face with the chinese president. just weeks after the president ordered a 35% tariff on tire imports from china. the tariff a victory for labor unions like the united steelworkers who seem to have a friend in the white house and obama. the backlash was quick from free traders worried about protectionism. for instance, "the chicago tribune," quote, these tariffs will not bring our jobs home. if anything, they might prompt manufacturers to move lower-end tire production to countries that don't face u.s. tariffs. "the new york times" wrote president of the united steelworkers union gerard is, quote, often viewed as the number one scrooge of free traders. i support that scrooge and the millions of americans effected
6:20 pm
by that. scrooge, how are you doing, buddy? >> voice of christmas past. >> okay. now, what do you expect out of president obama, mr. gerard, at the g-20 when he goes face to face with the chinese leaders? >> well, i think this will be a very minor issue. it's a small issue in the faces of the global economic collapse that we're still in. what i hope president obama does is talk about jobs, jobs, jobs. we actually have a real unemployment rate in america of close to 17% with people that are unemployed looking for work, people that have given up work and people that are underemployed. i want them to talk about jobs. i want them to talk about green jobs. i started talking about brown jobs. rela retrofitting our buildings, our industry. putting people back to work. we need to have green jobs, brown job, put people back to work. we can't let the bankers push us back. there is no economic recovery for workers.
6:21 pm
i fin iished a meeting this morning with trade union leaders from those 20 countries. not one of them said there was job growth happening in their country. >> so we've got this world issue. so here comes president obama fighting for the american workers. this move on the chinese tires looks to be a level of protectionism, but it's not because he filed a lawsuit. the wto, through the rules that were there that china agreed to and cheated on it and got caught. there was a ruling on that. the president stood behind you. there's going to be more of these. they cheat in a lot of areas. how do you want the president to handle this? >> i think we need to think about it very smartly. we're the protecters of global trade. i don't like to admit that, but i don't like the global trading system. here is the analogy. we have certain places along the highway where the speed limit is 55 or 60 miles per hour. i have a brand new buick. i think my buick can do 70 and be safe. if the police catch me speeding
6:22 pm
i pay a ticket. we have a global trading arrangement that's supposed to be a rules-based trading system. if we catch someone cheating, whether a country or another company, they get ticketed like i would for speeding. in this case what the 421 case on chinese tires, we caught them breaking the rules. we've had case after case where we've been able to show china has agreed to enter sbee a rules-based trading system but breaks rules day in and day out. they should be called violators of the rule. >> mr. gerard, great to have you with us on "the ed show." >> my pleasure. coming up, the beckster must have fallen off his garbage truck and bumped his hid. he's trash talking now. his stark vision of the comie i apocalypse is up next in "psycho talk." protect your mouth right with crest pro-health rinse at night.
6:23 pm
it kills 99% of germs that cause gingivitis, plaque, and bad breath, without the burn of alcohol. for a healthier mouth that's cleaner in the morning. when it comes to italian sauce, some people prefer this jar. but more people prefer this sauce. winner of the blind taste test. the sweet and savory taste of prego. it's in there. what? where? don't freak. it's gone. how? who did it? i did. with one of these.
6:24 pm
this is a mouse trap? yeah. it's a new kind of mouse trap from ortho. home defense max. it's guaranteed to kill the mouse. you just push down this little lever right here... ...and it does the rest. nothing to see. nothing to touch. you just throw it away. no mess. no drama. we could do without drama. excuse me? (man) ortho home defense max. (woman) defend what's yours.
6:25 pm
you can learn to switch off hungry and lose weight. right now weight watchers is offering a whole month free. join and get a month of unlimited meetings and online tools. so all you'll need is 45 minutes a week to take control, turn hungry off... ...and turn weight loss on. the free month offer's only available for a limited time so join today. hurry registration's free too. weight watchers. stop dieting. start living.
6:26 pm
oh, we've got, i guess you could say the most publicized psycho talker in america in tonight's edition. he was here last night. it's the beckster. today on his radio show he warned us what would happen if president obama fulfills his campaign promises. >> the country may not survive barack obama. now, if he does fundamentally transform america, we're done.
6:27 pm
we're done. you don't have to worry about a 2012. >> if obama gets what he wants we're done by 2012? if everyone in america gets quality health care we're finished? if labor unions are protected and working americans get to keep their jobs, we're through. in fact, if we make the world a cleaner place to live for our kids in the next generation somehow that really is going to ruin us. come on, glen. now, remember, the beckster got himself into "psycho talk" yesterday by saying this. >> how about this? i think john mccain would have been worse for the country than barack obama. how's that? >> so if mccain would be worse than obama and if under obama we're going to cease to exist by 2012, does that mean if mccain were president we'd all be toast by 2010? what a load of "psycho talk."
6:28 pm
coming up, eric can't get anything done cantor is unbelievable. after the republicans drag out the health care debate, he's got the nerve to start complaining, it's taking too long. plus, the righties can't stop fear mongering. mccain says if we pull out of afghanistan quickly it puts our troops in danger. condi rice says it will lead to another attack on u.s. soil. robert greenwald, exclusive video from afghanistan is going to set them both straight. activ! delicious, fat free, and above all... activ! the only one that has bifidus regularis and is clinically proven to help regulate your digestive system. activia light. ♪ activiaaa!
6:29 pm
boy: is that your new car? uh...yeah. boy: cool. thanks. i knew i wanted the new subaru legacy. i went back and forth on the hood scoop. but i'm glad i went for it. the all-new subaru legacy. feel the love. chef's meal with pommes frites perhaps a night at the theater with extra special seats additional hotel night, our treat your world in perfect harmony: priceless
6:30 pm
look for world on your mastercard to get rewards and offers that matter to you. i just gave you some at the restaurant. yea, i know. i threw them out-- they were old so... old-- they are rollover minutes. they are as good as new. ya know not everyone gets to keep their unused minutes. and these days we can't afford to be wasteful. saving minutes-- saves money. yea. (announcer) only at&t's family talk with rollover saves your family's unused minutes. and saving minutes saves money. now get 50% off all samsung touchscreen phones
6:31 pm
welcome back to "the ed show." the crowd that brought us the war in iraq, they're back for more. now they want a surge in afghanistan. it's the usual suspects. mccain, condi, and our old friend joe lieberman. the same old line, the war is the only way to keep us safe. they didn't even change the script. take a listen.
6:32 pm
>> we need additional troops and the longer we wait and delay, the more americans will be put at risk unnecessarily. >> our national security interests are very much tied up in not letting afghanistan fail again and become a safe haven for terrorists. it's that simple. if you want another terrorist attack in the united states, abandon afghanistan. >> when we sent more troops in we turned it around. iraq is rising up on its own. now people support the war in iraq and it's a lesser concern. we're capable of doing that in afghanistan. if we don't the taliban and al qaeda will be back there from which they struck us on 9/11. >> joining me now, robert greenwald, director of "rethink afghanistan." good to have you back with us tonight. >> thank you. >> before we start our discussion, i want to play this exclusive excerpt you made available to us in exchange
6:33 pm
here. here it is. >> focusing on what our original goal was which was to get al qaeda. >> al qaeda is no longer in afghanistan. they're not in kandahar. they are not out in the desert. they are not in any part of afghanistan. they've moved, but we are still fighting a war. the enemy is not even there. it's crazy. >> to al qaeda at all in afghanistan. is that an exaggeration, general petraeus, or is that true? >> i would agree with that assessment. >> our strategy in afghanistan is serving that goal, then we're on the right track. if it starts drifting away from that control, then we may have a problem. >> and the last development, latest development on afghanistan, today, general petraeus has endorsed general mcchrystal's request for more troops. mr. greenwald, what do you make of all of this? >> well, it was pretty clear that was going to happen. i mean, when you go to the military, the military is going
6:34 pm
to ask for more troops. go for a surgeon, surgeon's going to say operate. the sad thing, ed, and the tragic thing is having been in afghanistan and you go to the third poorest country in the world, they desperately need things, but they don't need to be occupied. they need jobs. they need schools. they need doctors. they need teachers. we could supply all those things, but we're not going to supply them and we're not going to make ourselves safer by going to a military solution. we have, as you heard in the clip, cia experts who talk about the fact that this is not a way to make us safer. in fact, you can argue, it's going to make us less safe by encouraging terrorism and alienating the population. >> the three politicians and former secretary of state we heard setting up this clip, they're wrong. what do they base their information on? if we're not there with a troop surge, not there with a heavy presence that we're going to get hit again? >> i think it's religious belief
6:35 pm
in some supernatural idea that every problem is a military problem and, therefore, everything you solve it with a hammer. i think that, you know, i don't now how you could get up in the morning, ed, with those people who you heard clips from knowing the part they played in the iraq war and the number of lives lost and the bols of dollars and advocated for it and they're doing the same thing again. i think it's an important moment because the president is being pushed on the right by those and it's important who those of us who don't accept that speak up loud, clear and very strongly. >> rethink afghanistan. you've got experts in there who say al qaeda in not in afghanistan. well, where are they for sure, and why aren't we going after them there? >> well, one of those experts is general petraeus who used the quote from. the reality is that
6:36 pm
afghanistan -- that caal qaeda around the world in different place. they have to bo. progressives need to take a strong position about this. finding them, hunting them, capturing them. the way you do that is with international cooperation across countries. they don't stop at a border. the way you do that is working with police forces around the world. that's where there's been the most success. the notion you go in and you occupy a country and then people are going to cooperate with you? it makes no fundamental sense which is why we're so pleased to see that the president is rethinking the policy. he's going to take a lot of heat for it. it's an important time to do it. >> mr. greenwald, your website, so folks can see "rethink afghanistan." >> go to see the clips which are free. they can get the dvd. we're having hundreds and hopefully thousands of screenings around the country and we're asking people to invite a member of the house or
6:37 pm
their senator to see the film and ask the questions. how many troops, how much money, how long, what's an exit strategy? >> okay. robert greenwald, great to have you with us tonight. thanks so much. for more on this, bring in our panel. bill press, radio talk show host. jack rice, former cia officer and radio talk show host. also radio talk show host michael medev, author of "the ten big lies about america." i want your take on the latest news this afternoon that general petraeus is endorsing the request for more troops by general mcchrystal. michael, what do you think of that? >> i think president obama should take that more seriously than advice from joe biden. the reports being he's listening to the vice president rather than do military commanders in the field. i think conservatives deserve credit for supporting the president on this. one of the first things he did when he came into the white house was to send 20,000 more troops. he also campaigned very clearly
6:38 pm
on more focus on afghanistan. >> if al qaeda is not in afghanistan, why stay there? why send more troops? it might be the wrong mission. >> it's precisely the same reason president obama gave during the campaign. because we went into afghanistan, set up a new government, because al qaeda was there originally with the training camps and now to abandon that government under pressure would be disaster for the united states. >> jack rice, how credible would mr. bare's information be at this point as a former cia expert? >> i think it's quite credible. the first thing we have to consider here is iraq is not afghanistan. afghanistan is a completely different animal. if we assume we roll more troops in that's going to make a difference? contemplate how much landscape we have to deal with. we have to contemplate just the fact the karzai government may be questionable at best, illegitimate at worst. we're trying to separate the question of afghanistan. i'm thinking about this as a former cia officer. we have to separate this
6:39 pm
question of afghanistan from pakistan and we can't do that. they must be looked at as a whole. >> all right. the latest nbc/"wall street journal" numbers are this. 51% of the american people oppose a troop surge in afghanistan and also 66% of democrats oppose afghanistan troop surge. take us down that road, bill press. what do you think? >> i think for barack obama this is the toughest decision he's going to face if he's there eight years, ed. look, i think this is his lbj moment. i wouldn't pay attention to the polls but what the strategy is and what the strategy is working. president obama. he's going to be remembered for delivering universal that's going to protect all americans are remembered for delivering this country, taking this country into another unwinnable war. >> bill, let me ask you this. we know or at least it's been talked about by former senator bob dole that general petraeus may have political ambitions.
6:40 pm
here he is calling for more troops. doesn't this box president obama in if that's the case? >> you know, the worst thing that could box him in, ed, would be to take what the generals say and run with it. that's what george bush said. didn't think it out, didn't see whether the strategy was working. he kept sending young men and women to their deaths. barack obama is stepping back and saying, wait a minute, before we go anywhere, is this strategy working? it's not working. he's got to see that and shut it down. >> what do -- you're not agreeing with that, jack rice? >> i absolutely agree. the bottom line is you add 1 10,000, 50,000 more troops this is going to be a failed policy. >> the president should have spoken about that in the campaign. you become president and take sponlts responsibility. part of taking responsibility, we heard a few weeks ago all the confidence in had in general mcchrystal. i think it will be a disaster for this president -- >> we had a president -- we had a president that would not
6:41 pm
change strategy based on conditions and now we've got one that will. we'll see how it works out. gentlemen, stay with us. we've got you coming back. the president changed a diplomatic playbook for delivering a blunt message to the world today. don't expect us to solve all your problems. former assistant secretary of state jamie ruben weighs in next. (announcer) sleep can help lighten your mood... ...and improve your concentratio tylenol pm quiets the pain and helps you sleep. because the better you sleep, the better you feel. an ordinary manual brush until you turn it on. its deep cleaning vibrating bristles break up plaque between teeth for an enhanced deep clean. manual control plus deep cleaning power. the oral-b pulsar. hey thanks for the window seat. oh please. you got the presentation? oh yeah right here. let me stow that for you, sir. thank you.
6:42 pm
you know, just to be safe i used fedex office print online. oh you did? yeah -- they printed and bound 20 copies of the presentation, shipped it to portland, they're gonna be there waiting for us. that's a good idea. yeah. you have a nice flight. thank you. (announcer) print upload your document -- we'll take care of the rest.
6:43 pm
if you're using other moisturizing body washes, you might as well be. you see, their moisturizer sits on top of skin, almost as if you're wearing it. only new dove deep moisture has nutriummoisture, a breakthrough formula with natural moisturizers...
6:44 pm
that can nourish deep down. it's the most effective natural nourishment ever. new dove deep moisture with nutriummoisture. superior natural nourishment for your skin. we will not be quiet. ♪ when we're in a sandwich, you'll know it. we are our own mixed up blend of one of a kind spices. we are miracle whip. and we will not tone it down. you should know, bayer aspirin is one of most studied, most trusted, anti-fever, anti-inflammatory, and anti-pain medications in the world. from pain killer to life saver, bayer aspirin is the wonder drug that works wonders. in my "playbook" tonight, president obama ran his first big play at the united nations today with a speech to the general assembly. called for unity and cooperation among nations and also made it
6:45 pm
clear that there was a new guy in the white house. >> i have been in office for nine months. the time has come for the world to move in a new direction. in iraq we are responsibly ending a war. we've also reengaged the united nations. we have paid our bills. the old habits, the old arguments are irrelevant to the challenges faced by our people. the united states stands ready to begin a new chapter of international cooperation. >> let me bring in mr. james ruben, adjunct professor, columbia university and former assistant secretary of state to the clinton administration. >> good to be with you, ed. >> olive branchs are all over the place today. is that a good interpretation? >> absolutely. this speech was president obama's opportunity to show the ways in which things have changed. we now have a president who's supporting international law, who believes in treaties to
6:46 pm
pursue arms control and nonproliferation. someone who wants to be a leader rather than stay out of the climate change problem. someone who has changed our policy on prison aerns torture. he's taken all of these ching things over the last nine months that were things the rest of the world criticized america for under president bush. the changes have come, we've moved in the direction many of you wanted. now, this is where he's trying, i think, to get more support from the rest of the world. okay, we've made these change, but now all of you can't expect us to solve the world's problems. you have you contribute. do your part whether it's climate change, china and some of the other countries make their contribution, whether it's nonproliferation, getting russia and china to agree to punish those who won't abide by the nonproliferation treaty. he was cataloging all the ways in which this presidency is in
6:47 pm
sync with the rest of the world but saying we need all of you to do your part. >> and the president addressed north korea and iran. here it is. >> the governments of iran and north korea choose to ignore international standards. if they put the pursuit of nuclear weapons ahead of regional stability own security and opportunity of their own people, if they are oblivious to the dangers of escalating nuclear arms races in north asia and the middle east, they must be held accountable. the world must stand together to demonstrate international law is not an empty president. >> mr. rubin, what's that mean? must be held accountable? >> in this case what he's talking about are the consultations that have begun and will come to a head soon on iran. that is whether china, russia, some friends in europe, other countries that are going to realize that if iran won't stop its enrichment or come to an
6:48 pm
agreement about nuclear enrichment activities then there must be a price to be paid. i think hold accountable -- >> sanctions? >> sanctions, and his -- hillary clinton, the secretary of state said crippling sanctions. china and rush is a so far have been reluctant to do that. today we have a hint from the russian president they wouldn't rule out sanctions, but i think it's going to be a long, long hard road to get those countries to support. >> mr. gadhafi, 96-minute speech, rambled a lot. did refer to the president of the united states as our son. was that a strategic move to make opposition in this country nervous about the president? >> that speech, for people who followed the u.n. told me they've never seen anything like it in 30, 40 years. he had the kennedy assassination in there, he had conspiracy theories about 9/11. the whole package of i guess you would have to say unusual diplomatic views. >> looked to me like he had a
6:49 pm
lot of bar notes on him. kept pulling out bar notes and stuff. this tent think. >> you know, it's a strange thing. i live in new york. new yorkers can't decide sometimes whether they want to be the capital of the world and like the u.n. here or they want to be able to, you know, complain about the u.s. diplomats. the fact is this guy lives in a tent, and now some people in new york are trying to prevent him from putting it up. whenever you're dealing with muammar gadhafi, you're going to have loony aspects. >> good to have you with us. coming up, we've got the gang warfare over held care. let's see, there's the gang over health care. gang of six, gang of seven, gage of 40 has done a lot of damage. none of them can be trusted. what we need is a gang of 60. we'll stand that up to our panel next on "the ed show."
6:50 pm
great looking skin... it's in the dna. [ female announcer ] new regenerist dna cream with spf 25 doesn't just correct. it helps protect your dna without a $200 department store price tag. olay regenerist.
6:51 pm
get wrapped up in the luscious taste of butternut squash, blended with delicate herbs. v8 golden butternut squash. from campbell's. a soup so velvety and delicious you won't be able to contain yourself. campbell's v8 soups. diarrhea, constipation, gas, bloating. that's me! can i tell you what a difference phillips' colon health has made? it's the probiotics. the good bacteria. that gets your colon back in balance.
6:52 pm
6:53 pm
who makes more money than anyone else in the health care field? insurance companies. right? the people have been losing their jobs and losing their homes, losing their health care. insurance company profits continue to skyrocket. >> senate majority leader harry reid at a rally with nurses on capitol hill. the insurance companies, obviously, gouging consumers. he's got to right. public option is the only way to
6:54 pm
guarantee competition. i just hope reid is serious when he says he's willing to use reconciliation. our panel on that tonight. bill press, what's the downside of 51 people? >> hey, listen, ed, i think harry reid gave the best argument for single payer i've heard in a long time. what do you think. >> i'm all about it. >> let's start over again. look, ed, one more minute wasted in the finance committee, any minute wasted in finance committee is a minute wasted. republicans don't care. they don't want health care reform. democrats have to realize that. go to reconciliation. get the strongest bill they can get and put it on president obama's desk. >> might as well not waste where are time anymore. may be clear in the senate finance committee now. the republicans have no interest. they pulled the public option off the table and did not get
6:55 pm
one republican that lined up with them. drive forward, get the democrats, line them up and put the bill on president obama's desk. >> in the town hall clip we showed earlier tonight, mr. cantor, one of the leaders of the republicans over in the house was con fronted with a real-life scenario, woman has cancer, lost her job, doesn't have insurance, doesn't qualify for medicare, medicaid, there's no program out there. he told her to go get a program and check out charity. now, do you go along with hat that? do the republicans have to do a better job of that? >> absolutely. there are 14 million people out there who don't have insurance right now who are already eligible for medicaid. one f the things republicans support is an expansion of medicaid eligibility. there are half the republicans in the senate are supporting that. so this is -- this is clearly the point. i mean, there's no question at all president obama could go ahead and get his 51 votes in the senate and get his votes in the house. the problem here is the economic recovery. we are not in recovery yet. there is still a recession out there.
6:56 pm
any hint of a recovery would be strangle in its cradle if we move forward the radical expansion of government debts. >> michael, with all due respect, you have it backwards. health care is the number one driver of our deficit today. you cannot fix the economy without fixing health care. it is bankrupting so -- >> health care by spending more on it. >> bankrupting businesses large and small. >> no doubt, got to fix it. gentlemen, i want to pose this to you, jack rice. the point here is that when mr. cantor was delivered to him right there a real-life scenario, he didn't have an answer. go get a charity? i mean, she's going to die of cancer. she needs surgery. this one of the problems, i think, that the republican party has. when you ask them, what do you do for people like that, they come out with, hey, you're in a percentage. go get a charity. why should the democrats mess around with people like this? >> there's no point. the republicans are the party of
6:57 pm
status quo. they want nothing to happen. they -- i mean, they've become the party of no. the american people are looking for answers. they're looking for results right now. the republicans have come up with nothing legitimate. when you put them in a corner they say, we'll get back to you and throw out a couple numbers. >> quickly, michael medved, do we need more time? the senate finance committee voted on an amendment to draw is out another couple weeks. do you really need more time? >> when you're talking about changing 1/6 of the american economy, yes, talking about more time to get more consensus is a good idea for the country. >> gentlemen, good to have you with us. i asked our viewers what you thought. should the senate finance committee delay a vote on health care reform? 8% of you said yes. 92% of you said no, absolutely drive it on and let's go. that's "the ed show." i'm ed schultz. for more information on "the ed show," go to or check out our radio website at
6:58 pm "hardball" with chris matthews starts right now on the place for politics. msnbc. james traffic cant. let's play "hardball." good evening. i'm chris matthews in boston. leading off tonight. he is back. james traficant, the former congressman found guilty of bribery and racketeering is fresh off his seven-year prison snrngs the expelled politician known for being one of the more colorful characters on capitol hill is coming here to "hardball." plus president obama's considering scaling back american forces in afghanistan which could satisfy some democrats but infuriate some republicans who have been in support of his hawkish policy in the region. the political perils of afghanistan. republicans are still
6:59 pm
hawkish on afghanistan but the party is going to war with some of its own members who don't stick strictly to the conservative message. south carolina republicans are on the hunt for what they call rinos, republicans in name only, their current target bob ingles. is the risk becoming the pure republicans carrying the risk of becoming the small party? also the democrats are getting 60 senators. massachusetts has acted to bet the governor pick an interim senator, pick someone to fill ted kennedy's seat. looks like it's going to be longtime kennedy ally paul kirk. that is coming up in "the politics fix." finally, mu mar gadhafi today called president obama a kenyan who he would like to see president for life. gadhafi's words on obama in "the sideshow." let's start with the former u.s. congressman who made these words his trademark. >> beam me up. >> jim traficant, thank you very