Skip to main content

tv   The Ed Show  MSNBC  February 4, 2010 6:00pm-7:00pm EST

6:00 pm
taxes and increased lending if they can get to work and cash for clunkers, tax incentives for making homes and businesses more energy efficient which, of course, will create construction jobs. every item i just mentioned involves one thing, that's cutting taxes. i mean, this ought to be a no-brainer for the republicans. they just want to vote by monday and show that washington can actually work together. >> bottom line is this, this is a good faith offering on the democratic side. we are inviting our friends on the republican side to join us. bring your best ideas forward. let's put these on the floor and move on them with a sense of urgency. >> a number of things they have talked about here today were talked about in the republican caucus yesterday. i would hope we can continue to move forward on a change on a bipartisan basis. we are going to do that if we
6:01 pm
can. we say about jobs as we have said about health care, we have said about energy, we have said about everything we have worked on the past year, we want to work with republicans and it appears to me on the jobs program, they want to work with us. >> have you ever seen a party with 59 votes or 57 or 55 votes just do everything they possibly can to work with the minority party? now, the republicans don't have to like the package or even vote for it, because as of an hour ago, they now have 41 votes. senator scott brown has a chance to show his independence and willingness to work cooperatively across the aisle or he can help the republicans filibuster and stop everyone in congress from taking any action to create jobs. well, tell me what you think on this one tonight, folks, our telephone survey. the number to dial is 1-877-ed-msnbc. my question tonight is do you trust, it is about trust, do you trust that the republicans will
6:02 pm
work with the democrats to create jobs? press 1 for yes, press 2 for no. i will bring you the results later on in the program tonight. joining me now, where unemployment is high the state of michigan, senator debbie saab now joins us tonight. good to have you with us. >> thanks, good to be with you. >> i was at this health care clinic yesterday in hartford, they basically feel that the congress has struck out on health care reform. if the congress strikes out on job creation, who is going to pay the political price here? what do you think? >> well, ed, first of all, i don't believe that we are going to strike out on health care we can't afford to do that, because it is about jobs, we are losing jobs because of the cost of health care, losing jobs overseas because of it as you saw yesterday at the clinic, the problems that people are having aren't going away. so, i'm still also very focused
6:03 pm
on doing everything we can, whatever mechanism it is, to get something done on health care. and we have got to address jobs in this same way. i mean, jobs are connected to everything we do and we did, by the way, do the recovery act last february, which did begin to slow down, dramatically slowed down the job loss. now that is not good enough, but i can tell you in michigan that that advanced battery manufacturing, the efforts we have put into retooling loans, causing ford to bring jobs back from mexico to michigan and we are seeing some job growth that is very important. but today, what we are talking about is moving forward to help small business. it is absolutely critical. >> seine to you really think the republicans are going to work with the democrats on this or -- >> i don't know. >> isn't it wishful thinking at this point? do you really think that they want to see barack obama going out on the campaign trail saying that we have turned the job
6:04 pm
numbers around and we presented a plan forward in the president would get credit for that. isn't their whole mission to stop barack obama and not help him? >> well, there is no question. that has been their mission. with the new senator who says he comes in representing the people in massachusetts who are hurting and says he is independent, we will see. but from my perspective, ed, i'm willing to support whatever mechanism, whatever tools we have to get things done. that's our job. and we are going to do everything we can to get things done. we passed the recovery act last year when we had 58 votes. we passed children's health insurance, a whole range of things, mortgage help, credit card help, so on. so we are going to proceed. they can choose to be with us and govern or they can choose to continue. we are at 107 objections now, higher than any other time in our history. so they can choose to do that. >> we have talked about filibusters. you have talked about it in the past. >> right. right. >> you see this sea change all of a sudden, the republicans
6:05 pm
changing their attitude. i just don't see it happening because of the create jobs obama's going to get -- the president's going to get an awful lot of credit for it. >> right. >> but when you take a look at the obstruction numbers, what is different about a job package that would turn republicans around in their thinking? >> well, you know, ed, we don't know what's going to turn them around. maybe nothing will. maybe it is a matter of exposing them, which we intend to do. if they choose to vote against efforts to give community banks more capital for small business or to strengthen other efforts to help small business, then they have to be accountable for that. if they choose to vote against a jobs credit or manufacturing efforts or efforts to put people to work rebuilding america, then they will have to be accountable for that. from my perspective, we have got 59 votes and need to use everything possible that we can to get things done. people are hurting. >> yeah. >> it is not change, because of
6:06 pm
massachusetts, as you know. and so we are going to do everything we can with. we are going to put forward ideas and they are going to have to decide whose side they are on. >> yeah. >> are they going to be on the side of the people who are hurting or are they going to be continuing to fight for the past, where we lost over 6 million manufacturing jobs under president bush? >> senator stabenow of michigan, thanks for joining us on "the ed show." >> good to be with you. >> i personally don't see the republicans all of a sudden shifting sales and saying, hey, let's go sail with obama and see if we can help him create some jobs. they are going to vilify this agenda all the way to next november. they are going to do everything they possibly can to keep these numbers down. and the democrats are just a gluten for punishment. here comes harry reid, throwing out olive branches, saying we really want to work, really want to work. the republicans aren't going to be coming around on anything, mark my words. ohio senator sherrod brown with us tonight here "the ed
6:07 pm
show." senator, why is this jobs package the hot ticket? what do you think? >> well, it is something we have to do and i mean i want the republicans on board, as you do, but i think we put good legislation on the floor and we keep doing it and keep doing it and keep doing it eventually public -- if they keep fill bustering and keep -- we can't get 60 votes, then eventually public pressure pushes them to do it. for instance, we ought to do this bank tax, levied at the big banks that, frankly you got all kinds of benefits from something we had to do, the bank bailout, and use that -- those tax revenues into the big banks for a jobs program. we keep putting that on the floor. they keep saying we have to have 60 votes. we keep trying to. we keep trying. eventually, they are embarrassed into passing, in my view. and we got to show whose side are you on and the public, this massachusetts -- polling out of the massachusetts ray the voters thought government is more on the side of wall street than main street. >> yeah.
6:08 pm
>> and that can't be with the democrats in power. we have to show whose side we are on. >> senator, the folks that i ran into yesterday at hartford, connecticut, they think washington is broken. they like obama, they want him to succeed, but they don't believe that this congress is ever going to get together or work together on anything and they feel like they are being left behind and there is a real, no offense, throw the bums out attitude out there. >> i get that i get that. >> and i know you get it. so considering that, if it's about getting something done, have the democrats in caucus talked about reconciliation on everything? reconciliation on everything? they haven't come your way in over a year. what's going to change this? you have to create jobs. if they don't want to do it, the hell with them. you got go reconciliation on this as well, don't you? >> as much as we can pass with the majority vote, we do. there is -- one of the problems with this system, as you know as well as anybody, ed is that the special interest money here and
6:09 pm
the power of the insurance companies and drug companies and the oil industry that's why that supreme court decision was so awful that basically said to america's largest corporation, domestic and foreign, you can pour unlimited money into the campaigns, drug companies come on in, insurance companies come on n the only way to beat that sbakt kind of grass roots efforts that your viewers know how to do i have a petition on my website, sher red, i encourage people to sign that petition, work with a lot of my colleagues to basically say to the court, you know, your corporate, your corporate leanings time and time again aren't going to stand. we are going to fix a lot of this and we can do t so i encourage people. >> senator, i agree with you on that and i agree that the grass roots can do an awful lot between now and november, but the american people are expecting the democrats in power to do something, reconciliation has to be a real line in the sand. i think for everything at this
6:10 pm
point. >> i agree. >> when does the negotiation stop and when do we start moving forward? >> well, sooner rather than later a lot of us are surging our leadership to do that you know, it's -- i don't think we can do it on everything, because there are a lot of senate rules but we can do it more often than we are. and the public wants us to get something done and want to know who is on their side. frankly, the democrats aren't making that clear. we have got to pass health care that way and we have got to move forward on jobs and health care. those are the two things that matter and people'swe are in charge and have to make sure we do. >> quickly, the citizen's right to know act this is something that you have introduced. this deals with the supreme court, the ruling where corporations are going to start giving money, they also have to serve up some information well do they not? >> yeah, saying on our bill that people have to -- they have to disclose, the ceo of the company has to get on and look in the camera and say their company paid for the ad it is a ban on
6:11 pm
foreign corporations giving money and got to be a shot, a stockholder vote. if you support that bill and want to help our efforts, as i said go on my website, sherrod and sign our petition. the more grass roots efforts we have, the more we can push this through and to help preserve our democracy. there is already way too much corporate influence in this town and we don't want more. >> senator, good to have you on tonight. thanks so much. >> thanks, ed. good to be on. >> a good bill no doubt. coming up, toyota is having a tough time and there may be trouble with the prius. we will talk to a michigan congressman who will tell you why it's time to buy american-made. and white house chief of staff rahm emanuel, a tough guy who knows how to drop the f-bomb says -- says that the r-word and got him into some -- a heap of trouble. i will tell you why i'm bothered about the apology in the playbook. all that, plus happenity returns to the zone. you are watching "the ed show" on msnbc.
6:12 pm
that's right. enjoy the world's perfect pepper. pace. made right since 1947. ♪ ♪ when it comes to protecting the things you care about... ...leave nothing to chance. travelers. insurance for auto, home, and business.
6:13 pm
coming up, if you were watching with last night, you saw me get more than a little worked up about joe lieberman and how he has been abandoned the people he pretends to rem represent. we got a lot more where that came from. stay with us. i'm dishing it out at the bottom of the hour. ncer ] when something's so good... now that's what i'm talking about!! [ female announcer ] only need so much. the same is true with bath tissue too. that's why there's charmin ultra soft. its ultra soft design is soft and absorbent. it has so much absorbency you can use 7 sheets versus 28 of the leading value brand. so your family can get more out of less. smooooooth. [ female announcer ] charmin ultra soft. enjoy the go. hey, buddy. how's it going? what's up? what's shakin'? poppin'. crackin'. yeah, buddy. brother! dude! dude! what's up? what's up? hey. bro. hey. hey! daddy! darlin'. sweetie! buddy. beautiful. aww. buddy! [ male announcer ] now you can call who you want, when you want, for a whole lot less. at&t introduces unlimited calling nationwide
6:14 pm
for only $69.99. at&t. this valentine's day, buy any smartphone after mail-in rebate and get any messaging phone free after mail-in rebate.
6:15 pm
welcome back to "the ed show." more problems for toyota today. the united states department of transportation has launched an investigation into reports of faulty brakes on the 2010 prius cars. just two weeks ago, toyota recalled millions of cars and trucks because of accelerator problems causing the company's stock to plunge. and transportation secretary ray
6:16 pm
lahood made matters worse at a budget hearing yesterday. >> my advice is, if anybody owns one of these vehicles, stop driving it, take to toyota dealer because they believe they have the fix for it. >> well that comment had major repercussions. toyota stock dropped almost 6% yesterday and lahood was forced to backtrack. >> what i meant to say, what i thought i said was if you own one of these cars or if you are in doubt, take it to the dealer and they are gonna fix it. >> as bad as the situation may be for toyota, i think there's a real opportunity here for american car manufacturers. let me bring in democratic congressman gary parties of michigan. it would seem to me that if i were a car dealer anywhere in america, i might take out a pretty aggressive commercial, congressman, saying, you know, you should have been buying american all along. or is that over the top for
6:17 pm
these politically correct times. what do you think? >> i think it is very important for american car buyers to know that our domestic auto industry are making some great cars. you know, jd power consistently ranks both chrysler and general motors and ford at the very top when it comes to customer satisfaction. the insurance institute of highway safety has ranked all of the big three cars at the top of the list when it comes to highway safety. and you've got the motor trend car of the year, both the dodge ram truck as well as the ford taurus as car of the year. so there's great products. we are certainly hopeful as people are thinking about buying a car that they are going to those domestic showrooms. in the past, some people drove right by them. now is the time to go in there, kick the tires and you will find it is a first-class quality product. >> you know, in business, congressman, sometimes you've just got to go for the jugular, don't you? i mean, isn't this the moment -- i mean, you look at ford sales in january, up 25%, gm sales in january was up 14%.
6:18 pm
now is the time. and it would seem to me that for the american worker, for the american economy, this -- it would seem to me that everybody would be standing on top of the highest hill they can find and say, see that? buy american, american workers, and just capitalize on this. i guess -- >> you are right, ed. you are right, ed. there is no question. we have talked about this on this program and you have said it you have said it many, many times that the best way to get the american economy going is to have folks buy american-made cars, american workers, american steel and glass. and if there was any perception in the past that american cars may not have had the same quality as some of our foreign competition, i think that's been laid to rest. we have great cars, american-made cars. people need to be going into those showrooms. they are going to get a first-class, quality car and they are going to be helping the american economy, american workers and american businesses all at the same time. >> i want to talk about the t.a.r.p. money that's going to be used for small businesses.
6:19 pm
you're in favor of that, i take it? >> i am. in fact, it's probably the number one impediment right now for job creation is the lack of lending to our small businesses. as you know, those big money center banks, those big wall street banks that received a lot of t.a.r.p. money, they are not lending to small businesses. >> no. >> they are not out there doing that and so we need to be helping the folks who i know will be helping them, which is our smaller, community banks. that's the case in michigan. we have got these large wall street banks that take our deposit bus they lend the money somewhere else. we have got to help those community banks that know the local business and always, disproportionately, lend to small businesses that's where the help has to go. >> congressman parties, quickly, on a scale from one to ten what are your chances of getting the republicans to help you on job creation? >> well, so far, they have been not willing to be helpful on anything. we have got to continue to press the case that this is just absolutely critical. we need bipartisan solutions. we need to be coming together. the american people are asking for it. they deserve it. we need to have that and get
6:20 pm
that done. >> congressman, good to have you on. thanks so much. >> thank you, ed. coming up, mr. intellectual honesty shanked one off the tee box while licking bush's boots last night. that lands him in the psychozone, next. i tched what. i worked out. personally, i thought i was invincible. once it happened, i realized it's a different story. i'm on an aspirin regimen now because i never want to feel that helplessness again. [ male announcer ] aspirin is not appropriate for everyone. so be sure to talk to your doctor before you begin an aspirin regimen. i was the guy who was doing everything right. i was wrong. talk to your doctor, and take care of what you have to take care of. [ male announcer ] learn more about protecting your heart at
6:21 pm
but now that i'm breathing better with advair... i can enjoy the zoo with my grandkids. (announcer) for people with copd including chronic bronchitis, emphysema, or both, great news. advair helps significantly improve lung function. while nothing can reverse copd, advair is different from most other medications because it contains both an anti-inflammatory and a long-acting bronchodilator working together to help you breathe better. advair won't replace fast-acting inhalers for sudden symptoms and should not be use more than twice a day. people with copd taking advair may have a higher chance of pneumonia. advair may increase your risk of osteoporosis and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking advair. we had a great day, grandpa!
6:22 pm
we sure did. ask your doctor how advair helps improve lung function for better breathing. (announcer) find out how to get your first full prescription free at
6:23 pm
and in "psychotalk" tonight, mr. accurate, sean hannity. last night on his show, hannity was arguing that george w. bush was more in touch with the
6:24 pm
american people than barack obama. listen to his reasoning on this one. >> george bush, who you work for, did not play golf while his country was at war. he made it -- he didn't want the families of loved oneselfing or that may have lost a loved one seeing him on a golf course. >> so intense there. hannity, i know that you're big on intellectual honesty, but you are way off base on this one, big guy. let me help you here. we went to war in afghanistan on october 7, 2001. here is the president ten months later. >> we must stop the terror. i call upon all nations to do everything they can to stop these terrorist killers. thank you. now watch this drive. ♪ i'm all right, don't nobody worry about me ♪ ♪ you've got to give me a fight ♪ ♪ why don't you just let me be ♪ >> george bush, how work for,
6:25 pm
did not play golf while his country was at war. >> stop these terrorist killers. thank you. now watch this drive. >> you know, that's almost as bad as showing some video of the alleged crowd at the tea party rally, isn't it? hannity, i think it's time for you to turn in your membership card to the intellectual honesty society, 'cause you're full of "psychotalk," big guy. coming up, the speaker of the house in connecticut will tell us why joe lieberman is just so out of touch with his constituents. we saw it firsthand last night and he ought to be ashamed. and there are reports that tiger is coming out of sex rehab and returning to the fair way in the near future. we will talk about that in the playbook. and and rahm emanuel's dirty mouth gets him in trouble, gets washed out by sarah palin soap. you are watching "the ed show"
6:26 pm
on msnbc. stay with us. that's right. enjoy the world's perfect pepper. pace. made right since 1947. it can take so much out of you. i feel like i have to wind myself up just to get out of bed. then... well... i have to keep winding myself up to deal with the sadness, the loss of interest, the trouble concentrating, the lack of energy.
6:27 pm
if depression is taking so much out of you, ask your doctor about pristiq. (announcer) pristiq is a prescription medicine proven to treat depression. pristiq is thought to work by affecting the levels of two chemicals in the brain, serotonin and norepinephrine. tell your doctor right away if your depression worsens or you have unusual changes in mood, behavior, or thoughts of suicide. antidepressants can increase suicidal thoughts and behaviors in children, teens and young adults. pristiq is not approved for children under 18. do not take pristiq with maois. taking pristiq with nsaid pain relievers, aspirin or blood thinners may increase bleeding risk. tell your doctor about all your medications, including those for migraine, to avoid a potentially life-threatening condition. pristiq may cause or worsen high blood pressure, high cholesterol, or glaucoma. telling your doctor if you have heart disease... or before you reduce or stop taking pristiq. side effects may include nausea, dizziness and sweating. (woman) for me, pristiq is a key in helping to treat my depression. (announcer) ask your doctor about pristiq.
6:28 pm
6:29 pm
welcome back to "the ed show." thanks for watching tonight. i spent a full day at the free health care clinic hartford, connecticut, yesterday. and it was a really profound experience, i saw the divisions, not just between the rich and the poor and the have and have nots but the division between washington and a lot of americans out there. washington wants to slow down and take its time on health care reform. there were people at that clinic who don't have time. they are without care. they may not be here a year from now. it is that serious for a number of them. washington treats health care like it's a fiscal problem. let me tell you, it's a moral problem, a moral failing on the part of this country to get it right. and as i said on this broadcast last night, you know, we do a lot of things in this country the correct way, but when it comes to this issue, we have got
6:30 pm
it wrong. what is killing this country, right snourks not the threat of terrorism and fear, it is selfishness. that is going to be our downfall as a great nation, the selfishness and the absolute corporate greed that just continues on. that's what's tearing us apart in this country that is what is creating the divide between the people in washington. some of this that is sweeping the country can be just really summed up in one word and that's discontent. that's where the people are right now. we just feel like washington is not working and all the incumbents, left, right, ought to be thrown out, until we get some people in there and get it done. it's because they see the politicians like joe lieberman. joe, you know, in his state, they have passed in the house and the senate, universal health care, a representative body, both bodies passed universal health care and then this guy
6:31 pm
goes to washington and is the obstructionist, helping out the opposition. he -- he is doing in washington -- he is doing in washington whatle people of connecticut don't want him to do. so that's the disconnect. people feel it. and i really think, no offense to dog catch yoerks think dog catcher in boston, he couldn't get much publicity, could have run in that senate seat in massachusetts and won there is this feeling here across the cup, get out of here, you have been around -- we want something new and different. believe me a guy doing pin up, that is new that is different for sure. for more, let's bring in john nichols, washington correspondent of the nation, the author of a new book, "the death and life of american journalism." also with us is ab to the dashed acre associate editor and columnist to the hill. john nichols, let's talk about some of the vernacular that is being used, the discourse, the disconnect, all plays in to what's happening in this country
6:32 pm
right now where are we missing it? where are the american people missing it? is it our fault? what do you think? >> the american people aren't missing anything, ed, in fact, they are trying very hard to send powerful messages, not merely to washington but frankly to a lot of american media itself. what they are saying is, look, we have got sick people out here. we have real fundamental needs. and all that you have given us is a very narrow dysfunctional debate that suggests that the answer to health care is something more complicated, more messed up than what we already h the democrats and the republicans have blown this debate. the republicans actually come out looking better because at least they just said no to something that no one understood, but the bottom line is this. the media itself has caused a lot of the problem by frankly reporting on this debate, not with a humane or human perspective but with a purely political perspective that frankly doesn't make much sense to most americans. >> ab, how do we turn this
6:33 pm
attitude around? how does the republican or the democrats catch the fancy of the american voter and motivate them again with this climate that has taken place in this country of tremendous and terrible discourse? >> well, i mean, ed, i do think that the republicans -- saying no all year has paid them great political dividends in this angry, volatile electorate in this bad economy, in these troubled times and i think that they will be rewarded with many seats in the congressional midterm elections in the fall, the democrats are going to take a beating. short of an unforeseen, absolutely miraculous recovery in the economy that would produce jobs again, the narrative really -- it is cut in stone at this point. i think you have to think long-term about the growth of the independent vote. people moving become to the middle, maybe hope for some kind of future, different
6:34 pm
bipartisanship, but for now, the two parties are dug in and everybody is angry, i think the people -- the party in power is going to pay. >> so a.b. i will stay with you on this what should president obama do? he has met with the republicans. he has met with the democrats. he has given a very impressive state of the union speech. people like this president. he is over 50% in approval rating. how does he navigate through this and basically save his party, because right now the democrats are not there. they are viewed -- they have lost their personality. let me -- i will take some time here. when ted it kennedy passed awake the democratic party lost a lot of fight, a lot of vigor, vie tate, desire passion. it is like their personality has changed, that if someone says something the democrats, i say, okay, i will apologize. if someone says, hey, you got to
6:35 pm
get tough, oh, no, we can't put any lines in the sand it is like the democrats are afraid, a.b. to take the bull by the horns and just run with it. your thoughts on that? >> i do think the word "fight" is critical here. president obama to save his presidency, i don't know how much he can to the democrats before this fall election to save his president circumstance he needs to get out on the road and start talking to americans every day about small business tax relief, national security policies that are going to keep us safe, improving the economy, bringing back jobs what ever he can, but he needs to connect face-to-face with people and make them believe that he understands them. but the other thing is that the democrats ed,z as you know, throughout the ugly process of health care have become associated with back room deals, okay, not talking about changing wait washington works, the way president obama did in his campaign. no, they are not. no. >> didn't have a transparent
6:36 pm
process, people are furious about what they think is a pro-industry, pro-bailout, pro-bribe majority party legislating in the dark and back rooms some that -- i think that narrative, as i said is set. i don't think congressional democrats can turn that around any time. >> but john nichols, the democrats have got to move on something. they are going to have to reconcile and legislatively move on something. i'm not convinced the republicans are going to help them do anything for this president. what is the best play? >> the best play is to understand that the fundamental issue in america right now is jobs. we have 10% unemployment officially, 17% unofficially when you wouldn't count in all those people who have given up or severely underemployed. this democratic party has to just say we really don't care about all the games, most americans don't even understand what low sure s we are going to put our pedal to the metal and pass a jobs bill that is really about putting people to work now f they do that, i disagree with a.b. i think they can turn this
6:37 pm
thing around but nothing short of that will do it and it must be a massive jobs bill, not $100 become as the president said. >> john nichols, ab to the dashed, great to have you with us tonight. if they do get a jobs bill and it is $30 billion that will definitely stimulate the economy no question. can they get it done between mind november? i want to go become to health care for a moment chris donovan is with us, the speaker of the connecticut house of representatives. they, of course, passed universal health care, both in the house and in the senate. the governor in that state vooet vetoed it. now this universal health care package, mr. donovan this was health care for every be in your state, the word universal. do i have that correct? >> we had two packages. someone the package based on what was happening in the federal government but we also had a package that opened up the state health care plan for the state employeeses, the governor, legislatures, cities, towns, small businesses, nonprofits and eventually, yes, every not be
6:38 pm
state. >> so really it is opposite joe lieberman's position when he goes to washington when it comes to representing his constituentsome that a fair statement? >> i would say it is fair. i think joe maybe doesn't know what is going on in his own state. >> what pressure can be brought to bear on someone that goes to washington without the folk at home on a state level paying a political price? there is this disconnect between the people that are out there, want health care, i saw them, came face-to-face with them yesterday and the long-time senator from connecticut who is doing exactly the opposite of what the people want? how do you cure that? >> i mean, ed york kn, i don't . you saw it i see it every day in my town. people losing health care, people who can't get coverage. people laid off and because their pre-existing condition, they cannot get health care coverage. this is a reality. i'm as frustrated, as many are in terms of we can't wait for a
6:39 pm
health care plan. people need it now we are doing what we can here in washington, i mean in connecticut. we really hope they do well in washington. it would have been nice if senator lieb lieberman had come down and seen the people in the district. the democrats in connecticut passed a universal health care plan, a public option plan here in connecticut. government nor who is a republican vetoed, came pretty darn close to overturning it, but we are continually fighting for the people in our state to make sure the small businesses, the every day person has health care. it is so important in our statement. >> i talked to so many people yesterday in your state that feel disconnected, left behind, the system doesn't work t could would seem to me you have got to go out and instill that confidence that you are there for? >> absolutely. an ongoing fight. heck, i have been fighting for health care for people for 10, 20, 30 years. i am not giving up now. a lot of other people aren't
6:40 pm
giving up now. sure there is going to be down turns every now and then but you got to keep remembering why you were elected. that is to represent the people. right now the people are in need of health care. they are in need of jobs. that is why we are elected. >> mr. donovan, how do you get your bunnell net state of connecticut under control and deliver health care to everybody? your state is no different from most others. i think there's only four states in the union that have got a surplus. but your state, like many others is looking the a lot of red ink. how do you accomplish that? >> one of the ways is to actually open up the state health care plan. we pay less for health care and it is good health care. you know why? because we have 200,000 lives in our health care plan and we can put it out to bid and people who -- or want to administrate that, they come in at a low bid because they know they will get more because we are doing it in volume. if you are a small business and i have four or five people, i'm going to pay through the nose. so let's open up the state health care plan. let's make it a public option.
6:41 pm
let's have the small businesses come in there. let's have the nonprofits come n let's have the citizens come in a way so they can have good health care at an affordable. that will lower the rates for everybody in the state. if washington helps out with some health care plans in terms of medicare reimbursement that would help us out as well. >> quickly if there was an election right now in connecticut, would we see the sea change that we saw in massachusetts? >> hey, that's massachusetts. we are connecticut. >> okay. all right. i just think there is an attitude out there amongst the count countryside that people want to throw out incumbent and they feel it is dysfunctional. i hope you can get it through, unfortunate that joe lieberman has represent ared your state on this issue in such a terrible fashion. >> we have other good congressional people who are fighting for us and we are happy with them and we are going to continue the fight and get our mess am to the people. >> mr. donovan, good to have on
6:42 pm
the ed show. thanks so much. my pleasure. coming up who would have thought that in a battle between sarah palin and rahm emanuel, that rahm would be the one with to back down? i will give you the details on his apology, next in the playbook. stay with us. totruck or gas st. anncr vo: emergency services... anncr vo: ...collect accident information. anncr vo: or just watch some fun videos. anncr vo: it's so easy, a caveman can do it. caveman: unbelievable... caveman: where's my coat? it was suede with the fringe. vo: download the glovebox app free at
6:43 pm
not to late to lettest now what you think. the number to dial tonight is 1-877-ed-msnbc. tonight's telephone survey question is do you trust that the republicans will work with the democrats to create jobs? press 1 for yes, 2 for no again, the number is 1-877-ed-msnbc. we are right back. any car in the aisle. choose any car? you cannot be serious! okay. seriously, you choose. go national. go like a pro.
6:44 pm
somewhere in america... there's a home by the sea powered by the wind on the plains. there's a hospital where technology has a healing touch. there's a factory giving old industries new life. and there's a train that got a whole city moving again. somewhere in america, the toughest questions are answered every day. because somewhere in america, more than sixty thousand people spend every day answering them. siemens. answers. ( kids giggling ) ♪ you have multiple cars...
6:45 pm
and multiple toys... with multiple places to go. so be smart. simplify. combine and save. get all your insurance from one allstate agent, and you can get multiple discounts... on your multiple policies. simpler is smarter. that's allstate's stand. are you in good hands? it would frustrate me. my bayer meter is very important. (announcer) only bayer's contour meter has programmable personal high low settings. it allows me to make sure that my diabetes is controlled as tightly as possible. (announcer) the contour meter, only from bayer. and in my playbook tonight, who wants rahm emanuel gone more? let's see, liberal activist groups or sarah palin? both sides are pushing the story about the obama's chief of staff calling some liberal activist "retard
6:46 pm
"retarded." and actually, there was an f-word before that emmanuel made the comment in a closed-door meeting with liberal groups back in august when they were talking health care. but it only made its way to the public arena last week when it was reported by "the wall street journal." since then, sarah palin has jumped on the comment. she called for the president of the united states to fire rahm emanuel on her face back page. she posted, just as we would be appalled any public figure of rahm's stature ever use the n-word or other such inappropriate language, rahm's slur on all god's children is unacceptable and it is heartbreak. i would ask the president to show decency in this process by eliminating mr. emmanuel. for more, let's bring in our panel tonight. laura granters is the author of "blue grit" and the host of and john feehery, republican strategist. now, we are all worked up about the word retarded. and i understand that. it is wrong to use that. it was a closed-door meeting but
6:47 pm
that still doesn't excuse it. here's the story that no one is talking about, in my opinion. i will have both of you respond. if the chief of staff of the president, rham emanuel, is going behind closed doors in august using that type of terminology about a health care plan that liberal groups want, such as maybe single payer or public option and the white house response is those two words, which includes an f-word and retarded, i want to know, as a good liberal, just how hard did the white house fight for health care reform? that's the story. is that the attitude of the president behind closed doors when the liberals come to the table and want health care reform? laura flanders, your thought on that. >> well, i'm with you, ed. i don't know what's more cognitively challenged here. it seems to me that only thing rahm emanuel should have been saying to the democratic base,
6:48 pm
particularly those activists thought on health care was thank you, thank you for getting me elected, thank you for getting us here. we are going to be working together. we are going to get you real reform, the kind of reform americans really want. what's cogny knittive ae's cogns having any kind of quarrel with the base and rejecting what most americans want and going for some kind of plan most americans don't want. we don't want to be forced to pay more for private for-profit companies without any nonprofit, single payer or public option. this was the cognitively challenged health care campaign of all times that's what you should be talking about. you're right. >> john feehery, if the democrats didn't think that sarah palin was politically influential before, they can check that attitude at the door. she made the white house respond. your thoughts? >> well, i think they are out for rahm emanuel. i don't think he is going anywhere any time soon. he is -- you know, he has always been more of a moderate in the
6:49 pm
white house, pushing for more centrist positions. and liberal activists don't like him. and actually, a a lot of people on capitol hill don't like him, starting with the more liberal members of the congress. you know, sarah palin does have some juice there is no doubt about it, with her facebook comments. i would say though that, you know, once this got out in the "wall street journal," he had to respond. i'm not sure fess responding to sarah palin or no i do think that rahm emanuel's thinking about running for mayor of chicago, i don't think this comment helps him at all. >> i'm surprised he apologized and didn't fire back on sarah palin because levi johnston in the article in vanity fair said this, i couldn't believe it when she could would come over to us and sometimes say, playing around, no, i don't want the retarded baby. i want the other one and picked up tripp. that was just her. now, will the real sarah palin
6:50 pm
please stand up? laura flanders. >> absolutely. the real rahm emanuel is no mystery. i mean, the chief of staff is often referreds as to the chief of gaffe. he has a foul mouth is old news. the story is old news. i mean it is kind of amazing that sarah palin -- i don't think she has ever said there is anything "the wall street journal" hasn't picked up on. haven't they got better things to do? >> you think this is over with, john? >> well, i don't think it is over with in one sense. i think that the long knives will be out for rahm emanuel from the left for quite some time. >> yeah. >> they strategically disagreed with where they want to put the country. i think for rahm iman use i think he is very close to the president. i don't think he is going anywhere any time soon, but this is going to be an internal brawl that is going to continue to happen for quite some time. >> external because if that is how he feels about health care reform from the liberal perspective, he just did not endear himself to the liberal base of the blog go sphere. great to have you on tonight. one final page in the playbook tonight, there is speculation that tiger woods may be getting out of sex rehab to
6:51 pm
play golf. radar online reports that tiger's wife, elin is waiting to take him home from the clinic in mississippi. the timing fueling rumors, the accenture match play event starts february 17th in arizona but there has been no official word from the pga event coordinators or tiger's people. coming up, troops, u.s. troops, fresh off the battlefield, are planning to storm capitol hill and really make somewhat i consider to be very fair demands. we will talk about fearless next here "the ed show." stay with us.
6:52 pm
vegetables are naturally low in calories. v8 juice gives you 3 of your 5 daily servings. it's a tasty, nutritious way to make this number go up... and help this one go down. v8. what's your number? only alka-seltzer relieves your upset stomach, heartburn, indigestion and headache... so you're good to go in the morning. you're late. alka-seltzer brings you back.
6:53 pm
6:54 pm
6:55 pm
and finally tonight, president obama has promised tone the wars in iraq and afghanistan and bring the troops home over time. but the organization, iraq and afghanistan veterans of america, says the administration also needs to focus on helping them when they come back here to the united states. and veterans from around the country are heading to washington this weekend to fight for reform. joining me now is the executive director of the iava, paul wry cough, paul, great to have you with us tonight. when i hear the word reform, i thought we passed a gism bill in this country. what's happening with that? >> we did ed, but there is still major problems. veterans are experiencing a lot of confusion trying to utilize that gi bill. the va was caught flat footed here, caught up now and worked on fixing it but 90% of the phone calls that went to the va's gi bill hotline between
6:56 pm
october and december didn't get through. so the va has to do better there and they have to reform the way they do bureaucracy across-the-board. we will be fighting for disability reform all next week, cutting through that red tape and making sure our veterans get the benefits they deserve. >> do you think it is a lack of manpower in the va, infrastructure in the military to deal with the influx of veterans coming home? is that it? >> manpower is one part of it ed, but also about innovation. they have really got an antiquated, outdated system at the va right now not a lot different from when guys came home from vietnam. so if you are putting in a disability claim right now, you are probably going to wait about 161 days. if you appeal that claim it is going to be two years. so, we are bringing veterans from all over the cup, as you mentioned, here to washington to fight to change that push for disability reform. folks are watching, they can help us by going to storm the they can support these young veterans going to be meeting with over 100 folks on the hill next week, the white house, va, dod gherkt done this year and fix it. >> and paul, what about the education benefits that you are
6:57 pm
in the gi bill, how is that working out for the gis? >> they are robust and they are really solid. you know, the president deserves a lot of credit for pushing for that guy. bill and secretary shin sec ski trying to make it smoother at the va. i was testifying today on the house side about the new budget increase which is the largest one in a long time it is about a 15% increase so money's there and it is a strong sign. we have to make sure they are doing a better job:doing customer service for the veterans calling and going to the websites. >> the number of veterans coming back and coming into the va, isn't it proportionately much higher than it was in the past? >> it is a very high percentage. you have got folks now doing four, five, six tours. one of the guys on our staff here in d.c. just got back after his fourth tour. so, there's folks coming home with complex injury, dramatic brain injury, mental health issue, huge challenges there we know the folks at the va are working are really hard, they have got to be more efficient and innovative. >> you are doing great work for the veterans, god bless you, keep going, my man. >> thank you, ed. we appreciate the support, my man. >> you bet.
6:58 pm
tonight in our telephone survey, i asked you do you trust that the republicans will work with the democrats to create jobs? 5% said yes, ma'am 95% said no i'm not majority that's "the ed show." i'm ed schultz, for more information "the ed show" go to or check out my radio website at we got "hardball" with chris matthews start rights now on the police for politics, msnbc. we will see you tomorrow night.
6:59 pm
good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. leading off tonight, double jeopardy, as goes the house, so goes the senate. could the democrats lose ten senate seats this fall as well as the u.s. house of representatives? in seven years, no party has lost control of the house without also losing control of the senate in the same election. does this say the democrats better make a comeback this spring and summer or they'll be in worse trouble than even they imagined? plus, ending "don't ask, don't tell." here's a quote from a gi serving in iraq. "yeah, i think my former commander was gay. kicked ass. would have followed him back to fallujah. shame he was shot." let's get past the loose talk and find out what life in the military is really like from men in uniform. would ronald reagan have been reagan enough for republicans these days? the gop don't like to talk about it, but reagan raised taxes. he signed a bill that granted amnesty to immigrants and named pro-choice sandra day o'connor to the supreme court. what happens when the rhetoric smacks into reality? the tea partiers begin their co