Skip to main content

tv   [untitled]    December 18, 2011 10:31pm-11:01pm EST

10:31 pm
very confines the brush as far as cards leaving four people dead and unfortunately missing most shapes and that plane have joined the research of racial lines to be aware the conditions are comprehend the imagined c f it. on those are the main headlines up next crosstalk.
10:32 pm
and you can see. below in welcome to cross talk on people about like a blazing phoenix rising from the ashes newt gingrich again shows himself to be a major figure in american politics does he represent the republican party base is he really a conservative and most importantly if nominated can he beat barack obama at the ballot box to become president. and. the so. to cross talk the return of newt gingrich i'm joined by bill schneider in washington he is a distinguished senior fellow and resident scholar at the third way in new york we have steve lesser he is a columnist for democrats for progress and in nashville we crossed a judge in philips he is the founder of the tea party nation all right gentlemen this is cross talk and you can jump in anytime you want and i very much encourage
10:33 pm
it but first let's have a look at the man himself. as a candidate newt gingrich seems to have become a flavor of the month nominee among republican frontrunners with less than three weeks before the first nominating contest in iowa gingrich enjoys the strongest lead of any candidate this year. commanding some forty percent support among likely g.o.p. voters an impressive advantage compared with twenty three percent for republican mitt romney gingrich a quirky politician who's perplexed a number of people during his campaign is not new to washington which is a fact he enjoys stressing i think at a time when we're hurting financially we're hurting in jobs we're hurting in the deficit we're hurting in foreign policy having somebody who is a serious developer of better solutions and somebody who has a track record of actually doing it in washington also in kind of job but it's his track record of making provocative and controversial statements that analysts say could alienate swing voters among gingrich's most notorious policy trajectories and
10:34 pm
statements is his support for death penalty for marijuana smugglers claims that child labor laws are stupid and disparaging remarks on health care policy people have to run their judgement in my case i said up front openly i've made mistakes and times i've had to go to god for forgiveness and render judgment they have his most recent comments in which gingrich called palestinians an invented people cause dismay among palestinian officials i'm certain with what mr gingrich said this is unfortunate. but. he's looking for some. election campaign and i'm sure as hell. is he he is the history of the middle east and the palestinian people so is gingrich continues to ride his wave of success presumably with intent to sustain it he's faced with the task of broadening his appeal and to do that experts say he would have to swing into a full blown presidential operation mode and be able to defend himself and his long
10:35 pm
and controversial record. for cross talk r.t. . ok i want to go to justin in nashville first i'd like to read something that maureen dowd wrote a couple days ago which i think is interesting and a bit funny next to romney gingrich seems authentic next to him and cain gingrich seems faithful next to jon huntsman which seems conservative next to michele bachmann and rick perry gingrich appears to actually look like an intellectual is that why people like him for those reasons. no i think there's some other reasons beyond that you know one of the things that newt gingrich offers he offers experience which was clearly something we didn't get in two thousand and eight and the thing that he offers that all the other republican candidates don't really offer he offers a vision for a conservative revolution in washington and i was in a meeting with him a week ago and that was the first thing he talked about his vision starts in january two thousand and twenty one with him successfully completing two terms
10:36 pm
successfully leading a conservative revolution successfully getting conservative permanent conservative majorities in the house in the senate so he offers a compelling vision that nobody else really offers out there and i think a lot of republicans and a lot of conservatives really like that message that he's offering ok steve if i can go to you and i want to be generous here but most people think that newt's time is the speaker of the house was disastrous i mean why should he become president. yeah. exactly right peter you know when you when you talk about most candidates for political office you talk about do they have any skeletons in their closet the joke about newt gingrich is he doesn't have skeletons is cause his closet his grave yards and his client in his closet you know his his time the speakership ended with him being the first the first speaker of the house who was basically found guilty of ethics violations had to pay a three hundred thousand dollars fine and by the way the house ethics committee was chaired by a republican led by republicans since republicans controlled the house at that time you know he's got two two marriages where he was unfaithful you know speaking of
10:37 pm
that infidelity and thinking you know john edwards is standing out there somewhere saying hey if i do this again can i run for president in two thousand and sixteen you know this is the family values party yeah it's the family values party he's got to affairs out there he says he's sorry he promises he won't do it a third time you know this is one of the guys as a democratic strategist that i looked and said god wouldn't be great if we could get this guy to run against barack obama because you know the opposition research on this guy is volumes you know we went we went on a router spin when he didn't know our story very you know they're enough but fair enough you know i mean he is leading in the polls for republicans bill i want to go to you in washington you're an old timer watching american politics what is in your opinion what is the appeal of newt because he's not something new we all know who we use we know a lot about him. he brought gridlock to washington that's been the rule since the two thousand and ten midterm nothing has really been accomplished in washington except under extreme deadline pressure last summer when
10:38 pm
a default was hanging over the country newt gingrich came to congress in one thousand nine hundred eighty eight he told the republican minority don't go along don't get along make trouble hold things up create gridlock and he brought it all the way to the time in one thousand nine hundred five when they shut down the federal government he is a revolutionary as your first guest said but americans are very cautious when they vote for president i'm not they definitely want change i'm not sure they want to revolution because gingrich comes across as very very reckless ok jetson i mean that in looking at the commentary and you know and i want to be fair here because you know i know you like him as a candidate but what is it what is it is new about newt that you like because he has an amazing track record and a lot of people say he's a very reckless person that he's someone not to be trusted and for many reasons what bill just said right there just don't do anything just obstruct. well you know let's do a little bit of history that bill is not mentioning here in one nine hundred seventy eight when newt gingrich came into the congress the republicans were in
10:39 pm
such a minority they had they only had one third of the house and they had one third of the senate and they were happy with that arrangement it was absolutely insane newt gingrich came to congress and said you know what we republicans can control congress and he worked a lot of people even as for the latest one nine hundred ninety four didn't believe that the republicans could take congress away from the democrats they'd held for thirty eight years guess what newt gingrich came in and did it and you know steve talked about all these ethics violations well guess what eighty three of eighty four dismissed the only one he paid a fine on was basically the equivalent of a plea bargain where he just said screw it i'm tired of this i'll pay some money over a college course he was teaching and he was done with it the i.r.s. went through newt gingrich with a fine tooth comb they didn't find anything let's remember newt gingrich balanced the budget under bill clinton who wanted to spend about as badly as barack obama wanted to spend they reformed welfare. he's got a whole bunch of good credits and the myth that newt gingrich shut the government
10:40 pm
down no sorry about that it was bill clinton that shut the government down we're going back to the same battleaxe remember when it happened steve do you want to get in there because there's also the freddie mac. money that gingrich got one point six million dollars i mean again all the way up to the he didn't he only made it to it when he was confronted with it i mean again he's the consummate insider how can this be something new how can he spin himself as something new. well you know the judge has got a difficult job there and i don't envy it all i mean there's gingrich always has an excuse for something he did you know he didn't do anything wrong you know they dismissed eighty four out of eighty five charges well you know judgment judson's an attorney he knows better than that you know in plea bargain agreements they often will dismiss tons of the charges if you'll admit guilt to one of them and apologize and make restitution that's what happened to the family in my case and not only you're right he did say you know what i raised my russia you know he did have and i are so i think he's a he hasn't yes in the interest i know you take care of your so you shall know them
10:41 pm
better than that you should know judge you should know better than that no you're just making is no less here. that's why i mean trailing about also and on making so you're just kind of sitting over there are naked stuff is the record and this is what it's going to be the entire time the rest of his candidacy this is what it's going to be we're going to be making excuses we're going to be saying oh that's not the record where everybody can look it up it is the record that is the record he had to pay three hundred thousand dollars fine it was a republican chairman of the house at that you know and there is over his huge like it's a legitimate that's fault it's not bill clinton's fault. ok let me jump in here carol is an excuse it isn't just there's a democrat you know it's george bush's fault ok i'll change it hardly can i still rehashing the past here ok i got to go to fill the time when everybody began which that i may quote i helped ronald reagan and jack kemp develop supply side economics i helped lead the effort to defeat communism in congress i helped as speaker of the house balanced the budget for four years straight i mean none of those statements
10:42 pm
are true they're not and they're patently obviously false. well they're not completely falls he had a large role in balancing the budget he certainly supported ronald reagan but he claims essential that he did all these things more or less on his own he did not. he was part of the coalition between clinton in the republican congress that got a lot done welfare reform free trade balancing the budget yes he did work with bill clinton and then he led the move to impeach bill clinton the problem with newt gingrich is from the very beginning when he spoke burst on the national scene in the early one nine hundred ninety s. the public hasn't liked him they don't like him i looked at thirty five polls of how people think feel about newt gingrich and in thirty two of those thirty five fold polls taken in the last fifteen years people have a negative impression he is going to be a very very difficult candidate to elect a retiring democratic congressman barney frank said it would be it is a press conference where he departed from congress he said i never thought i lived
10:43 pm
a good enough life to see the republicans nominate newt gingrich for president he has more baggage than united airlines ok. if i go to. you know i want to expand i jump in real quick i want to take it. the i want to spend on what bill just said i mean you can see it in the debate you can see why people don't like him there's sort of this milling arrogance to newt gingrich you know even the snark that he did with mitt romney saying you know the only reason that you were in private life was because you lost to ted kennedy that's not a policy discussion that's just a nasty remark to make that soon newt gingrich is that's why people don't like him there's this arrogant entitled ness to him that no matter how hard he tries he can't he can't hide it ok gentlemen we're going to go to a short break and after that short break we'll continue our discussion i do get rich state r.t. .
10:44 pm
if you want to. hear in bygone days sleds were fighting to get around. but today they're more leisure than life line. what drives people to quit their modern lives and settle in remote woods. one finds them up to survive in the freezing cold. beginning in russia's new discover the arctic circle on r.t.e. . will do the. science technology innovation all the developments from
10:45 pm
around russia we've got the future covered. well. welcome back to crossfire computable remind you we're talking about the return of news. ok gentlemen i go back to you in nashville i ask you just kind of just point blank if you like the man do you think he can beat barack obama oh absolutely there's no question about it. in fact it's almost a situation of who can beat barack obama now because. if they're if the republicans are smart what they're going to run next year on is when the republicans last controlled the government unemployment was at four point six percent the economy
10:46 pm
growing for fifty two consecutive months and gas was about two dollars and twenty two cents a gallon by the time obama's going to be up for election when the election is actually held next year employment is probably still unemployment rather still going to be north of nine percent the economy's not going to growing and if the experts are right gas is also going to be north of four dollars a gallon and that's just going to be an unwinnable combination and then when when obama and gingrich debate holy cow that ought to be on pay per view that is going to you know that's going to be like like a high school team going up against albert pool halls because gingrich is going to wipe the floor with obama ok interesting bill i mean i tend to think that obama's pretty good at debating his last time it was not that bad what do you think though i mean do you think he has. a chance next to obama. well look under the right circumstances in the united states anyone can get elected if things are bad enough i don't think they're that bad they're bad there's no question about it but they'd have to be really bad mean another recession for americans to take
10:47 pm
a chance in voting for newt gingrich they almost didn't vote for ronald reagan back in one canadian point it wasn't until the last week of the campaign it was the last week of that campaign when people decided that reagan was a safe choice even though they were very unhappy with jimmy carter my guess is that if gingrich does well in january where there are four crucial contests if he were to do the unexpected and beat romney in new hampshire in that primary then february where there's very little going on you're going to see the republican party establishment in full panic they're already moving in that direction you're going to see karl rove and maybe jim baker and possibly both former presidents bush warned the party that they could be jumping off a cliff there's not much they can do about it they have to influence primary voters but they're going to be a lot of concern there already is that he simply can't beat obama in a year when republicans ought to be able to easily beat obama for the reasons that judge judge just gave you know steve it seems to me and you know and i'm going to stand out above the fray here because i probably won't vote but. you know newt has
10:48 pm
the advantage has the advantage because the field is so weak around him i mean looking at these other candidates it's really just it's more comical than anything else at least looking at it from the outside why do you think obama would feel confident if you think he's confident that he could beat newt gingrich if he's the nominee. well you know the entire angle of going after an incumbent is you look at incumbents record you know you hope to poke holes in it you hope to say things aren't doing so well the problem is newt gingrich has a record of his own that's at least as problematic as barack obama's and you know all that all that you know bamma campaign really has to do is play back newt's own statements play back his contradictions play back the fact that if newt's going to attack him on health care reform he supported an individual mandate he supported marijuana legalization you know he supported all of these things i mean if you put together all of newt gingrich's liberal statements all together in one person you end up with al gore so you know i mean it's going to be very tough for newt
10:49 pm
gingrich to come up with a consistent statement that says he's different from barack obama he's the solid conservative and he's the one who should be elected his his own record is at least as bad and perhaps worse than what some of the things that you know in my opinion not obama's fault but has had that have happened during the campaign and there's a big contrast you know you can say you don't like some of barack obama's policies but he said what he was going to do when he was running for president he did those things you got a great record if you look at the websites that track you know promises kept i don't think you can say that about newt gingrich i don't think he's got that consistency that barack obama has and then when you when when when the optics of barack obama with a happy family life. and you know a happy marriage that's put up next to you know newt gingrich is history i mean he can say he's a can for you know a changed and converted man and whatever he wants to say those optics are not good for newt gingrich ok jenson if i go back to you is newt gingrich really
10:50 pm
a conservative because i mean in reflecting upon which steve just said there i mean you could parse together a liberal newt gingrich if you wanted to if you made the attempt but i mean you know you're involved the tea party movement is he conservative enough for you and you think for the for the rank and file of the movement you're part of. yeah i think he is you know if you look at newt gingrich's history of first of all if you get somebody whose history is long enough if they do anything other than vote present like barack obama did all the time you can create almost any kind of narrative you want for that particular person but newt has a ninety percent career rate ranking from the american conservative union he didn't get that by sitting there following barney frank off the cliff so you know he is conservative enough for the tea party but he's going to be supported by the tea party movement and you know. what it comes what is going to come down to next year any time you have an incumbent running for reelection and steve and bill i'm sure are going to agree with me on this point one of the few points they probably will but they'll agree with me on this the election is always
10:51 pm
a referendum on the incumbent right now the economy sucks and there's no two ways about it i'm calling it the great obama depression because we have what fourteen fifteen million people out of work all do really has to do i don't care what obama throws up there all the has to do is recycle ronald reagan are you better off or you're are you better off now than you were four years ago the great majority of americans are going around to go not only nobody held know and they're going to vote for they're going to at the end of the day decide we don't want to obama we don't like his policies he's wrecked the country and we may or may not trust newt gingrich but he's better than the alternative you know bill a few days ago newt gingrich talked about the palestinians and looking at the foreign policy debate it looks like newt really wants to have a new cold war the enemy this time will be iran but his comments about the palestinians is really quite extraordinary i mean it's not just a lunge to get the the pro israeli vote to the jewish vote in the united states because even most jews in the united states recognize that there is a palestinian people. well look the problem with that statement was that it was
10:52 pm
extremely undiplomatic in the present the united states has to be a diplomat he has to pursue a peace process there was some argument for what gingrich said about the palestinian people being invented people you know we americans are also an inventor very good have only a long time ago very good point yes we are an invented people so it was simply a very reckless statement to make contributed nothing to the peace process even the israeli government had to back away from it and the damage that it did wasn't so much that americans disagreed with them or even jewish voters disagreed with them it's that they wondered do we need a president who makes those kinds of reckless statements and creates diplomatic incidents whenever he opens his mouth that's a good point you know stevie you know i mean i know that in america being american being american myself i know foreign policy doesn't always play a big role but at the same time personality does is this the kind of thing that you know even you think republicans are going to buy into as we go to the primaries
10:53 pm
because that's just walking into a room and pulling a pin on a hand grenade and throwing it you know randomly. well you know what came out today peter is that back in one thousand nine hundred three after the oslo accords you had newt gingrich embracing yasser arafat and his aides at the time are saying that gingrich said to arafat i've got some great ideas on how you can quickly bring a palestinian state into being and now you have this radical flip flop where he's saying he's entered the palestinians and i think i think what this speaks to you talked about personality peter i think what this speaks to is gingrich really supports whatever seems to be the best for newt gingrich at that moment in terms of what he's looking what he's looking to get for himself i don't think he really has any sort of solid beliefs or ideology at all in anything you know i mean it's whatever is good for him at the time whatever woman is good for him at the time whatever position on the issue is good for the time at the time support medical marijuana support the death penalty for use of marijuana you know support mandates
10:54 pm
no i was never for mandates or i was wrong about mandates and this is going to be a consistent theme in the campaign if he's the republican nominee it's a conversation i can't wait to have that's for sure jetson what do you think about that because i mean a politician's do change that through time and i think everybody would agree with that but i mean what it is giving given what steve just said there new gingrich will say anything to get elected ok i guess we say that about a lot of politicians should we say that about him and i know actually that probably belongs to both barack obama and mitt romney but know things change people change that newt gingrich may or may not have said that he asked her arafat almost twenty years ago but guess what something major happened between then and now was called nine eleven and you know i love to get rich's comment i'm glad he hacked off the palestinians because you know what i don't care because i remember september eleventh two thousand and eleven and i remember the. thank you what i said is just that it's not only one point that i remember the palin but now you know that hey hey let me finish a sentence let me finish
10:55 pm
a sentence let me finish the senate state the reason i remember that is because on september eleventh two thousand and one the palestinians were dancing in the streets celebrating that we have been attacked so you know what they don't like us i don't like them and i'm glad gingrich made some hella stand ins were doing it and the leadership of the palestinians that's wrong to do they stepped in and they stopped their own people for doing that but how does that make them a people then but not now i still i don't understand it that doesn't validate gingrich's statement at all ok bill i want to go to i want to go to trial is going around and i have it jammed so you get our people now but not they were way back then cable and every single people in the middle east were invented gentlemen this is kind of a useless conversation bill if i can go to you what is his candidacy tell you about american politics today because i said early in the program we really know him very well and he's got he's surging in the polls what does this tell you you about american politics today. well he says we're in a cycle of revenge when the democrats took office with barack obama and
10:56 pm
a solid majority in congress essentially did something that we're not used to in the united states we've got party government the democrats passed the economic stimulus they passed health care reform they passed financial regulation with very little republican support and now republicans see the possibility that they can take the white house they can keep their hold on the house of representatives and they have a good chance to gain the senate next year and they are thirsting for revenge they want their own party government they want a republican party government next year what we've got last this past year and probably next year is just gridlock so republicans are not going to compromise because they say soon they believe they'll be able to call all the shots into that anger and that cycle of revenge that's going on ok judge said i'm going to be the last word on this program what kind of america would. govern. it's an america that's looking for some competent leadership which we haven't had since january of two thousand and seven when the democrats took over congress and
10:57 pm
then two years later when obama took over the country i think america as soon as newt gingrich gets elected president we're going to see an economic recovery coming with a republican congress we're going to see a lot of bad democratic ideas put to bed some good ideas advanced and we will see the good times again all right gentlemen we'll see if that happens there are many thanks to my guests today in washington new york and in nashville and thanks to our viewers for watching us here already so you next time remember.
10:58 pm
10:59 pm
download the official anti application. called touch from the shops to. watch on t.v. life on the go. video on demand tease my old girls and feed in the palm of your.
11:00 pm
question on the dot com. breaking news this hour north korea's with all standing leader kim jong il dies a part failure at the age of sixty nine his death sending shock waves across the reclusive country he's youngest son has reportedly been named as successor. forty nine people are still missing in the freezing waters off russia's far east coast more than twenty four hours after the oil rig capsized and went down. an explosive mood in kazakhstan as fifteen people are confirmed dead and dozens more injured in a series of violent rallies sparked by striking oil workers.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on