enter the queue. mr. atkins, can you put the next caller through? >> my name is [indiscernible] and my pronouns are she and her. thank you for honoring brian edwards. he always appreciated when i stirred up a fucking storm before this board. now for some other shit. you know that there are people facing prison time, who are facing fucking felony charges for doing open rescue, rescuing animals, and this is not just about animal rights, this is about pandemic prevention, this is about saving lives. you can have as many

[indiscernible] as you want, but animal agriculture, that's what's destroying this planet. we need to come together, and we need to end these factually farms. we need to also given the tools to more plant based sustainable agriculture, so yeah. and also, i called in about three weeks ago about these hunger strike from mary rogan, and i think we need to call a hearing on the housing support issues in this city. even we got our rent lowered to 30%, there's still too much shit to do and we've still got to get the city involved. thank you. i yield my time. >> clerk: thank you for your comments. may we have the next caller, please. >> hello.

my name is [indiscernible] and i would also like to comment on the item sponsored by supervisor haney, and i strongly urge everyone else on the board of supervisors to sign onto the resolution. i've been to factory farms in california, and they're horrific. animals are sentient individuals that have thoughts and feelings. animals are born in captivity. they often don't have enough space to turnaround. they suffer tremendously throughout their lives, and they're brutally slaughtered in the most heinous ways possible.

history won't look kind on our farming practices, and on top of the mass animal cruelty that takes place on factory farms, they emit more greenhouse gases more so than the entire transportation sector. the manure load pollutes nearby water and land. i hope san francisco passes this resolution and can lead the world in creating a more just food system. thank you. >> clerk: thank you for your comments. may we have the next caller? >> operator: madam clerk, there are no further callers in the queue. >> clerk: thank you. mr. president? >> president walton: thank you so much, callers, for calling

in. public comment is now closed. madam clerk, let's go to our for adopt without committee reference, items 22 through 27. >> clerk: these measures were introduced for adoption without committee reference. a unanimous vote is required for adoption of these resolutions today. any supervisor may require any resolution to go to committee. >> president walton: do any of my colleagues have any items that they wish to sever? seeing no names, madam clerk, would you call the roll. >> clerk: on items 22 through 27 -- [roll call]

>> clerk: there are nine ayes. >> president walton: thank you, madam clerk. these items are passed unanimously. madam clerk, do we have any imperative agenda items? >> clerk: we do not have any imperative agenda items. waumt wallet thank you. would you please present the in memory -- >> president walton: thank you. would you please present the in memoriams. >> clerk: yes. [names read] >> president walton: thank you so much, madam clerk. do we have any further business before us? >> clerk: that concludes our business for today. >> president walton: thank you. be kind when possible, and remember, it's always possible.

the 14 dalai lama. this meeting is adjourned.

>> my name is miguel bustos and this is a regular meeting for november 16, 2021. i'd like to welcome members of the public who are streaming live aswell as staff and those participating in today's meeting . following the guidelines for by local officials at this time the members of the commission our meeting remotely to ensure the safety of everyone including members of the public sothank you all for joining . madam secretary, pleasecall the first item . >> the first order of business is item one, commissionmembers respond when i call your name . commissioner brackett is absen . [rollcall]

>> commissioner brackett is absent. the next order of business is item 2, announcements. the next regularly scheduled meeting held remotely on tuesday, december 7 2021 at 1 pm. public comment procedures, each member of the public has up to three minutes to make pertinent public comment unless commissioners adopt a shorter period. during public comment period viewers will be instructed to dial415-655-0001 and andrew the access code . press the #and #again to enter the call. press star three to submit your request to speak. you will hear the following

message. when you have raised your hand please wait to speak until the host calls on you. when you hear your line has been unmuted this is your opportunity to provide public comment. speak clearly and slowlyand you will be placed back on mute . you can stay on the line and listen to the meeting or choose to opt out. it is recommended you call the public comments line ahead of time and to present you from experiencing potential delay caused by light streaming . today's hearing is available at as foia.org under commission and public meetingshave . the next order of business is item 3 actions taken of the previous closed session meeting. there are no reportable action . next order of business is item 4,matters of unfinished business . there are no matters of unfinished business .

next item is item 5, items of new business on the regular agenda. part ofthe consent agenda item 5 a approval of the minutes . regular meeting andnovember 2, 2021 . mister chair. >> president: do we have anybody whowishes to speak on this item from the public ? >> clerk: at this time members who wish to provide public comment should call 415-655-0001 and enter the access code. press the #and #again then press star three to submit your requestto speak . if you're listening by phone and would like to provide public comment three please press star 3. we will allow a few moments. mister chair there does not

appear to be any members of the public wishing to comment on the mission minutes. >> hearing norequests to speak i will close public comment. may i get a motion on the consent items ? >> i move the minutes for october 19 and november 2 be approved with any necessary corrections. >> chair: thank youcommissioner scott, may i have a second ? >> i will second, this is mart . >> chair: madam secretary please take role. >> clerk: pleasedenote your vote for the consentitems when i call your name . [roll call vote] . mister chair, the vote is 4 aye's and one absent.

>> chair: motion carries. madam secretary please call the next item.>> clerk: next is regular agenda, 5b is approving a budget for a community facility district administered by accessories to the redevelopment agency and count of san francisco. discussion and action resolution member 40 2021 . adam director . >> good afternoon commissioners. this item is the approval of the cnc 2022 annual budget we presented to you at the last meeting so with that i will hand over to melissa white house from our finance team . >> hello commissioners, thank you for having me back. i am melissa whitehouse, community district project manager and i appreciate your time last week two weeks ago when i came to do an extensive overview of our committee facility district project , today my presentation willbe much more quick .

next slide please. i'm going to give you a quick reminder onhigh-level assessments lastweek and move forward with approval of our cfp budget . next slide . as you all recall we had a workshop on 11 to along with a detailed budget narrative that was sent in advance of the meeting outlining our individual cfp budgets as well as the work plans coming for the next few months on ourcfp's . and now i am your recommending that you approve the fiscal year 2122 special tax levy as well as the calendar year 2022 expenditures for the seven community facility district that oci iadministered next slide please .as a reminder and a high level are special tax levy for the upcoming year is 18.7 million and our budget also includes 124,000 funded through mission gains towards property tax for

a total of $18.8 million budge . we also had $37 million in unappropriated fund balance which was chaired by cfb and we will be coming back to you in the spring along with the regular oci budget with the same level of detail for our cfp and we will be providing this level of detail moving forward to get more transparency aroundour csb . next slide please. so the majority of our budget as a reminder for our infrastructure cfp's are spent on service and then the majority for ourmaintenance fees is on maintenance ofthe actual infrastructure now that it's been built . next slide please . that's really it. nothing has changed since last week.

we did get questions from the commission which we appreciated at the last meeting. wedid not get any recommendations for changes so we see no changes to the budget from what you saw two weeks ago and today i recommend your approval of the budget and i thank you for your time and i'm happy to take any questions . >> chair: thank you miss white house. anybody from the public who wishes to provideany comment on this item ? >> members of the public who wish to provide public comment on this item all 415-655-0001 . and your access code 2486 866 6121 followed by a pound and pound again. press star three to be added to the queue. if you would like to comment on a specific item please press star three to be placed in the queue. we will allow a few moments.

mister chair it does not appear that any members ofthe public wishing to comment on this item . >> chair: seeing there are no requests to speak i will close public comment and turn to my fellow commissioners for questions they may have and i'd like to start with commissioner beisner. >> no comments or questions rather than to say that i missed our lastmeeting and was able to see materials and they were very comprehensive . >> chair: commissioner scott. >> no comments or questions misterchair . >> vice chair rosales. >> no comments or questions and i move the item. >> chair: we have a motion to move the item from vice chair rosales , may i have a second? thank you commissioner scott.

madam secretary please take role. >> please announce your vote. commissioner brackett is absent.[roll call vote] mister chair, the vote is 4 aye's and one absent. >> chair: the motion carries. please call the next item. >> next is item 5b workshop on annual housing production report fiscal year 2020 through 2021. madam interim director. >> thank you madam secretary. it's that time of year again when i'm happy to give an annual report on the previous fiscal year and as you know reduction housing and affordable housing is at the heart of our mission and all that work is really dedicated teamwork and coordination.

so we're extremely proud of the board. i want to note that typically there's a certificate of preference annual report but i wanted to assure the mission that a full schedule will be at the next commission meeting so this item we are focused on the exception so with that i will turn it over to white, our program manager to walk you through the report. >> thank you madam director and good afternooncommissioners . i'm happy to be here today to present our productionreport for fiscal year 2021 . please keep in mind the 12 you're seeing are the series ending in june ofthis year . the report right now is the draft form and if you'd like any suggestions or input you may have and after incorporating these we will distribute to the report for

interested parties and post on our website . next slide. as we go through the presentation i'm going to roughly follow the report itself which was overview of our house program inthe project areas .the fiscal year result for marketing outcomes with more specifics on how completionswould start . cop highlights and spe and workforcehighlights . next slide please. here is a map i'm sure you've seen multiple times but wanted to remind you of the major development project starting in the north that is transparent and we got fisher bay north and south and the shipyard through six points.next slide please. so this charts got a lot of

numbers and i like to show the obligation to the project area. there's also status of housing production. these numbers include both market rate and affordable housing purview and as you can see over all there's the 21,000 housing units of which 32 percent will be affordable. and then you can also see almost half of the units will be at six points. next slide please. just a reminder on affordable housing. it's for very low income san franciscans and to the ami percentages for a four-person household it's $10,600 to 133

thousand $200 for 100 percent ami households. next slide. and before jumping into the mist fiscal year results just updating you onchanges to funding sources for our affordable projects . the goal funding structures including 35 percent of financing needed for the project and the tax credit equity and both cii covers much of the remaining gap. housing staff has highlighted over the past mostly two years the funding environment has significantly changed and added uncertainty of affordable housing pipelines. and we're working closely with mohcd to ensure san francisco

does not disadvantage bond applications resulting in fewer project vetting applications and in this current round as an example the projects are being recommended at the state including our shipyard blocks . next slide please. so this is mostly similar to the chart you just looked at but i wanted to show again and gothrough each of the project areas . and shipyard phase i, 35 percent of the housing has built up 29 percent affordable. and with it in phase i we have hilltop, horizontal construction underway on hillside and vertical constructionscheduled to commence in 2022 . then in phase 3, three percent

of the households were complete today filled up 31 percent of the units that are complete are all affordable. and then mission bay north and south overall 93 percent of our housing is complete and 29 percent will be affordable at buildout . mission bay north and south, 87 percent of the housing is complete today and it's filled out34 percent . entrance bay is on one is 68 percent of the housing is complete and at buildout in that part oftrans they 34 percent is affordable . next slide. so this chart just reflects the housing completions from start

in the fiscal year and you can see mission bay south entrance bay and the start were in shipyard phase i. next slide please. in the fiscal year our funding access was approved. we approved three development loans totaling $6.1 million and shipyard phase i and trans they. next slide please. so this hour fiscal year highlights a strongyear, 458 units . 231 of those units were affordable and those units we house approximately 575 low income families with san francisco. next slide please.

these are our completion projects, one is in mission bay and one is trans day. next slide please. this slide gives you a sense of what we built to date. 72 percent of our units are family rentals. 14 percent are ownerships and five percent senior rentals and nine percent are affordable housing units. we do have more senior rental and supportive and homeownership in the pipelines but that's going to instantly shift each person. next slide please. here's a bit more detail on the completions in the fiscal year. so there's mission bay south, it's 152 units and 100 percent affordable. 38 percent of those units are occupied by hope s at sunnydale households who chose to

voluntarilyrelocate . and you can see the image. it's trans day block one, here are the project components. and the fiscal year that's got 316. that's got 316 units and 80 of them are emi ownership. next slide please. then here are our construction starts during the fiscal year. we got one in shipyard and one in mission bay. and going in a little bit more detail, one is in shipyard is 77 units with nine completion very units, this is a homeownership project and then the mission bay south lot 9 project 141 units of prominently supportive housing for formerly homeless adults.

this is the project that is being constructed with onshore construction. next slide please. this is just an overview. as you know we have a memorandum of understanding and part of that and you gives the responsibility to oversee marketing of oci's affordable housing units. mohcd also regains marketing outcomes support when the project is occupied and we closely coordinate with mohcd, all of us courtney but also our officials in stem. mohcd applies the occupancy preference service glitch including cop august 1 and the housing preference.

and then san francisco resident workers. next slide. this summarizes our marketing outcomes for the fiscal year. we had one project reached 100 percent occupancy during the new year and it made 100 affordable completion or units at a stable of nine. and in these units 250 san franciscans were allowed and somewhat remarkably we had over 6800 applicants with 108 units. and we presented the marketing outcomes report and i think it was march of this year. we did have 12gop holders will apply but none of them were housed . and as sally mentioned earlier the annual marketing report we are doing that in about three

weeks. next slide. this is marketing outcomes complicating what i just said but you can see that eight of the units went to dc hp households and 43 percent into the neighborhoodresidents housing projects which were acted at 40 percent. next slide please . and then this gives a eight-year look back at our cob results and unfortunately we don't have many this year. but we do have a small number of units available but you can see the trajectory of the gop was been housed here. next slideplease . this summer are highlights of

our workforce program. developers are working cooperatively to meet the 50 percent goals and great result this year. it exceeded the 58 percent, had 59 percent of contracts were awarded to spe. 78 percent for participation and professional services and 75 percentparticipation in construction . 18.3 percent was the local construction workforce participation and 461 san francisco residents performed over 100,000 hours . next slide. so yes. our accomplishments are really a joint effort of all our staff and we are grateful to the commission's ongoing support and collaboration. in addition to having staff a

special thanks to our legal team, contract providersand legal folks . the housing team is a senior development specialist hampton and also senior development specialist can absolve , jane preston and assistant development specialist and then during the year other specialistworked on the team and she is no longer with the cii . so with that i'm happy to take any questions you might have. >> thank you mister white. madam secretary do we have anybody fromthe public who wishes to provide comment . >> at this time memberswho wish to providepublic comment should call 415 , 415-655-0001 . and her access code 2486 866 6121. press pound and pound again.

press star then three to be placed in the queue. if you are listening by phone and would like toprovide public comment release press star three on your phone . if you're on the weather. >> link and it looks like we do have someone here. there we go. >> caller: this is peter cohen from the community housing organization and i wanted to make sure my audio is sufficient. thanksfor having me here . our coalition i think many of you are familiar comprises most of the affordable housing element sector in san francisco and it's been a long time since we've been able to come to commission hearing rooms but wanted to show up either way. my colleagues have had a really

good working relationship with your staff in the first and foremost want to thank jeff and sally and other members of the staff for coming every month to dutifully and energetically to our choo-choo council meeting to share updates and just to kind of share our collective interest in seeing affordable housing really succeed in san francisco. and i also want to say that i think we're lucky every time i listen to these presentations and in san francisco we have such a robust affordable housing sector and political leadership and kind of collective commitment and it really honestly doesn't show up like this in most of the rest of the state or the country. so that's not a testament to me or anyone else. it'sjust part of now the dna of san francisco and i think it's

fantastic . the report you heard everything on is something we've been really supportive of for several years now .it's this perfect snapshot. it's very user-friendly and allows folks to understand how the agency as we used to call it, the oci i is doing its work and most importantly how it's doing its workaccording to the visions of folks laid out many years ago . and it's interesting, redevelopment now seems like a distant memory but one of the things i think we say clearly lost is this idea of comprehensive holistic plannin as a way to set the framework and set the conditions for good implementation . we're seeing that with these court for redevelopment areas. development of a comprehensive thinking up the front and which means many years later all of your granular results can be re-looked at against that

masturbation. for the most part succeeding and i think that's a testament to theplanning but also the transparency and tracking this kind of annual report does . so great work and also hoping that other agencies, planning, mohcd are looking at these kind of tools and your approaches and trying to incorporate that into other parts of the city's efforts because i think you folks we see all the high bar and a good standard. if there's anything one thingi would suggest as a tweak , jeff and team and you know, we're not always the most expert on reading these things but the key thing is how is the present affordable in these project areas meeting up to the goal that was set out at the front end and i know that's all in there but the more that can be really clear i think the better because the basic theory that we've all been operating on his

san francisco is under this pressure cooker of gentrification displacement and not the only way but one significant way that we care counterbalance that is when we are actively incentivizing development. incentivizing market rates and affordableimbalance so if you have let's say a 35 percent affordable housing balance , ideally at any snapshot in time the production should roughly bearound that balance . i think will be seen in other parts of the city is when it's like 90 percent market rates and 10 percent affordable that's when you start to see the disruptions and the destabilization so bowls relative to performance is a good and smart of how proceeding and it looks good so thank you again. >> thank you mister cohen, appreciate those great words and we appreciate agree that thestaff is doing a wonderful job. anyone else just available who wants to speak on this item from the public ?

>> clerk: it does not appear there any other members wishing to comment on this item. >> chair: not hearing anyone wishing to speak wewill close the comment and i'll turn to my fellow commissioners for any questions or comments they may have . commissioner bycer, any comments or questions? >> no question. i see the information brought in front of us and i'm excited tosee what the next fiscal year plan looks like . i'd like to see many units built and as many of you know i wake up every morning with construction noise. beautiful music, construction noise that is block nine.i'm excited to see this project pu together. they put on the last modular units a couple of weeks ago . i guess three weeksago so it's great to see that project come together and in real-time .

we see numbers on a page that they're going to be homesfor people. andseeing those buildings , ,. four or five stories is nice. >> chair: commissioner scott. >> thank you mister chair. thank you so much jeff and team and it was said just seeing this and knowing what it does and living in the community and being able to thiswhat's happening is wonderful . peter cohen, mister colin just went right into my notes. as much as we are doing, how do we and can you tell me regarding gentrification replacement and we're setting up all these wonderful opportunities but is there a breakdown of what people are benefiting from the what is it,

108 108 affordable rentals that are occupied. is there a way of knowing who is benefiting from this wonderful opportunity as a people's group. can you speak a little bit into that and we know that san francisco is really leading nationally withwhat we do and how we do it . and then we also know we are the highestin rent . and home purchase. can you help us and help me understand which ones we are actually reaching when wefill our place ? >> that's a good question. i would say it might be we can have a look at the marketing outcomes report that was presented in march and that goes into more detail about the folks that are being served and

in the hundred eight units, there were eight households that have been displaced so they came off of ... they had that displaced housing frontline and then another 43 i think of the units are low income folks from the neighborhood . so that's one way of making sure housing is being served in that neighborhood is getting to a good portion of the people. >> vice chairman rosales, any questions .

>> i agree with the comments and everyone's comments in particular. it's an easy read. i read the draft report and it was just seamless. it was easy, lots of information. but the kind of information that is basic and complex at the same time so you can capture it.it's very pleased in almost every area. the small business obviouslyhad workforce goals in terms of performance . historically over the last eight years there's been a preference program even though this year as noted no households and will talk more about that in the december meeting but improving improvements and improving the marketing process is also appeared to be well understood and incorporated and this are the kind of results we thought about when we push for those outcomes. so it was just overall. i was very pleased.to have been part of this experience so i commend everyone,

commissioners in particular as well and the draft force in getting this done so the only question i have is before i get that i wanted to highlight just looking at my notes that i think we need to commend not just ourselves but we need to communicate this note that's on page 3 that jumps out which is at the 460 housing units that are affordable produce housing for over 1150. to me those are the kinds of metrics if you will when you hear that that's in human terms and in real terms those are the kind of impacts that we're doing. so i wanted to highlight that. the question i have was really about the determination about

this report. i mentioned before i like the idea of course of our website. and so the question i have is that this report go to the mayor and let's say in mohcd for the planning department that was mentioned by mister colin that could benefit from understandingour work, the board of supervisors . >> we do get the report to the folks in the mayor's office the mohcd, planning department and the board of supervisors so yes, we did that too. >> go ahead. >> in addition to that are thereother folks you're thinking of ? >> i think not everyone is as

attentive with what our work is but i find myself as a community talking to folks about affordable housing and people sometimes have misunderstandings perhaps of what the city is doing. they think the city is not doing enough and then they quote chapter and verse, the agency i work with is doing xy and z and it feels like we're talking about folks that are listening and paying attention. not necessarily always knowing so i feel like i'm constantly educating people. and we hear so much about the homelessness issue in san francisco the cost of living, gentrification ,displacement but we don't hear enough i think about the efforts , the real efforts that are being made and the inroads being made to reverse some of those circumstances so i'm thinking i don't know thatwe do press releases for instance . is there any kind of dissemination to community

organization. community-based organizations forto say no more about our work. those are generally my thinking on that . but i'm open to other ideas of course. >> we will make sure we get it out to a more robust list of folks including others. that's a great idea. >> i've had folks in the mission say they don't know it's in the mission so that they would benefit the neighborhood preference. it's something that is understood a little bit more but because of course mayor reed campaigned on the efforts that she personally was involved with and championed so people know about that is bein implemented for instance in th mission project i also found the board of mission corporation so people know about that .

it seems , not so much some of these other substances but i have to say the fact that we have something like over 6000 people interested on one hand it's sends me that so many people are wanting and needing affordable housing and the numbers are astronomical as compared to what's available but on the other hand it also means that the success of the dahlia program. understanding that through dahlia they're able to get more access potentially. to affordable housing. so those were my comments. >> thank you vice chairman i want to echo everyone's phrase of the staff for putting together a robust presentation and remaining now what we do . i would like to see how we can share this information morewith our wider audience . it'sinteresting . sometimes i don't think people even know of cia exists.

especially when we go to events they will acknowledge agencies and sometimes they will skip oci and we're doing such great work that we need to figure out how to share that information with folks and just force in history, the neighborhood preference program actually was an idea that i had because of my workon redevelopment . our redevelopment circuit of preference and when our mayor became a member of the board of supervisors for district 5 after one of our meetings i went over to her office to talk to her about what weshould be doing in areas where there's a lot of gentrification . i said let's do something like a neighborhood preference similar to a certificate of preference that allows people in the communities to stay in the community and we even said we can have them reduce pg&e

bills. leases to show they have history in the community so neighborhood preference actually came from experience at oci iso we should definitely take credit for that. i'm disappointed by the cop preference work or lack thereof and i'm sure that there's going to be a more robust conversation with the mayor's officeof housing at the december meeting so if you're listening , mayor's office of housing we definitely need to know what's going on and what's not going on , the fact that we had zero number of individuals getting housed from copd so will have that conversation in december. thank you so much everyone. and if there's let's see, this is a workshop so yes. >> one more point for jeff and his team.

i'm glad to hear that neighborhood cop asked mister chair said. their preference is working. and then what i was really asking about two is the race. where gentrification is happening to the african-american culture superseding any other culture. and so what we are hoping for and watching and listening for is all of the efforts that we can produce and put to action to bring people back or to allow people to know like morris said many people don't know about this opportunity. so if we could find out when we house beyond just the

neighborhood preference, what is happening for the african-american culture with the preferences for affordable housing? >> you. thank you for that suggestion. and i we do have some of that data in the office of support but we can also have work maybe for each preference giving like a ethical racial breakdown. to have a sense of what's happening, what you're saying with african-americans so in those different preferences. >> thank you so much. >> madam secretary please call the next item.

>> the next order of business is item6, public comment on non-agenda items . mister chair. >> is there anybodywho wishes to provide a public comment ? >> clerk: at this time any members who wish to provide public comment on this item must call 415-655-0001. enter access code 2486 866 6121. >> if you are already wrestles listening and would like to provide a public comment please press star three or look for the icon to raise your hand. i'll allow for a few moments for the public to call in.

mister chair, itdoes not appear that are members of the public comment wishing to comment . >> chair: out" comment. please call the next item.>> clerk: next item of business is item 7. >> chair: please call the next item.>> next item is reports of executive director.interim director. >> i have no report today. >> next item of business is item 9, commissionersquestions and matters . >> chair: are thereany questions or matters you want to bring up at this time ? >> is it appropriate that i as , i attended an event yesterday at the heritage community center and it was on the news. you may haveseen it. is there any status , and information. i got a lot of questions. they want to know where things

are. what'shappening . what's something we can addres ? >> chair: i'd like to ask our interim director if she can provide a comment. i know we're not supposed to have a discussion on it if you could give us guidance . >> i can provide the information of how we are aware there was an event gathering today at heritage and just to clarify what i can do is i can find ocii's role. our long-range planrequires the property be transferred to the city . the garage for governmental use is the parking garage and the commercial space for redevelopment purposes which includes serving as catalyst for essentialrevitalization of the neighborhood .

but ocii is not managing the property and not responsible for any costs. the city isresponsible for that. at this time my understanding is the city does not have any pending sale . they are currently evaluating all the potential outcomesfor those properties so i can at least provide you with the current status . >> any other questions or comments from other commissioners. see none, madam secretary please call thenext item. >> next item of business is item 10, closed session. no close session items. next item of business is item 11, adjournment . >> i would need emotion and the second to be able to adjourn today's meeting. >> i know that the meeting be adjourned . >> is there a second.

okay, we had a second by vice chairman rosales and also the chair.i mean, commissioner bice or so we have a first and a second.so we areadjourning this meeting at 1:40 8 pm. thank you all for your hard work . goodbye.

>> chair haney: this meeting will come to order. this is the november 17, 2021 budget and finance committee meeting. i'm matt haney, chair of the budget and finance committee. i'm joined by supervisors safai and dean preston who is h