John Wolfe, New York (1873–82; bought from the artist during the Salon of 1873; Wolfe sale, Chickering Hall, New York, April 5–6, 1882, no. 50, for $9,700, to Lyall), David C. Lyall, Brooklyn (1882–died 1903; estate sale, American Art Association, New York, February 19, 1903, no. 105, to F. J. Goodwin as agent for Goodnow and Bigelow), Mrs. E. L. Goodnow and Mrs. I. L. Bigelow, Brooklyn, N.Y. (from 1903; on loan to the Brooklyn Museum, 1903–39, when returned to Goodnow family), Goodnow (by 1939), unidentified hotel, Wilkes-Barre, Pa. (until 1980; sold to Michelman), [Joan Michelman, New York, 1980, sold to Ross], Mr. and Mrs. Frederick C. Ross, New Jersey (1980–99; on loan to MMA, 1996–99; sale, Sotheby's, New York, May 5, 1999, no. 99, bought in), Steven and Alexandra Cohen, Greenwich, Ct. (until 2012; on loan to MMA, 2006–12)
