please welcome, anne joyce. [applause] >> thank you very much and thank you to john duke anthony and the national council for having this program. as broad and complex and gets us all an opportunity to examine issues that are in the public debate over time, at least from this is.ime i think we have to be a little. humble when we talk about education. we americans tend to preach to others about it as if it werehes the philosophers stone or youby can transform base metals intonm gold.s not quite. education is necessary, but not sufficient. we also have to talk about what kind of education were talkingut about. what is appropriate for any particular society. particular are we talking about liberal lia arts as an education? critical thinking, technical tr? training? bear many aspects to it.o and when you see ouranwhen unemployment rate at the momente and the amount of discontent inf our society about jobs and forth, we have a lot of questions to askhow d ourselves. we fit our people ino lives that are satisfying for