. >> matsuda. >> here. >> and pearlman? >> here. >> first on the calendar is general public comment, at this time the members of the public may address the commission on items of interest to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission except for the agenda item, your opportunity to address the commission the opportunity will be afforded when it is reached and each may address the commission for a three minutes. >> two speaker cards. >> yes, president, hasz, and members of the commission, first, thank you for having the note on your agenda that you will adjourn the meeting in memory of alice carry. and i think that you all know that alice was the preservation architect for this building and some of the other notes that have circulated around either by e-mail or in john king's obituary of her work. and but, i think that there are a couple of other things, that could possibly add to alice's story which are not known to most people. one is that it was mentioned by king that she had a constructio

. >> matsuda. >> here. >> and pearlman? >> here. >> first on the calendar is general public comment, at this time the members of the public may address the commission on items of interest to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission except for the agenda item, your opportunity to address the commission the opportunity will be afforded when it is reached and each may address the commission for a th. >> two speaker cards. >> yes, president, hasz, and members of the cothe noagenda that you will adjourn the alice carry. and i think that u all alice was the preservation architect for this building and arou either that by e-mail or in john king's obituary think that there are a couple of other d possibly add to alice's story which are not known to one is that it was mentioned by befoheat she had a became an archect. and i think that the med at number tabatha n, edth ienting t circular saw d when i don't shertegan an orgatiho io tenants or rin tin for i these maritime museum anand wrote won adjou

>> yes. >> johns. >> yes. >> johnck. >> yes. >> matsuda. >> no. >> pearlman? >> this is a hard one, i am going to say no. >> wolfram? >> yes. >> president hasz. >> so moved, commissioners that motion passes five to two, with commissioners matsuda and pearlman voting against. >> that will place us on item eight. 2013.0317a (lily yegazu: 415-575-9076) 901 battery street northwest corner of battery street and vallejo street. assessor's block 0135, lot 003 request for a certificate of appropriateness >> i make a motion to recuse mr. hylan? >> second. >> on the motion to recuse commissioner hylan? >> hylan. >> yes. >> commissioner johns >> yes. >> johnck. >> yes. >> matsuda. >> yes. >> pearlman? >> yes. >> wolfram. >> yes. >> and hasz. >> yes. >> you are recused. >> good afternoon again, planning department staff. the project before you currently is a request for a certificate of appropriateness for a property located at 901 battery street. and commonly known as the petri cigar building, it is a four story reinforced building that was constructed in 1923, the subje

. >> matsuda. >> no. >> pearlman? >> this is a hard one, i am going to say no. >> wolfram? >> yes. >> president hasz. >> so moved, commissioners that motion passes five to two, with commissioners matsuda and pearlman voting against. >> that will place us on item eight. 2013.0317a (lily yegazu: 415-575-9076) 901 battery street northwest corner of battery street and vallejo street. assessor's block 0135, lot 003 request for a certificate of appropriateness >> i make a motion to recuse mr. hylan? >> second. >> on the motion to recuse commissioner hylan? >> hylan. >> yes. >> commissioner johns >> yes. >> johnck. >> yes. >> matsuda. >> yes. >> pearlman? >> yes. >> wolfram. >> yes. >> and hasz. >> yes. >> you are recused. >> good afternoon again, planning department staff. the project before you currently is a request for a certificate of appropriateness for a property located at 901 battery street. and commonly known as the petri cigar building, it is a four story reinforced building that was constructed in 1923, the subject property is identified as a con tributing structure wi

and commissioner matsuda you are making the motion? and commissioner wolfram is seconding. >> on the motion to recuse >> hylan. >> yes. >> johns. >> yes. johnck. >> yes. >> pearlman >> yes. >> wolfram. >> yes. >> hasz. >> yes. so moved that passes unanimously. >> thank you, good afternoon, crai, the department staff and the item before you is a informational presentation on the park and i would like to introduce you to mark and david from the port of san francisco. >> good afternoon, commissioners mark piat, court preservation staff and i wanted to pass forward a letter march 5, 2013, from the architect you aral heritage and mark had to leave and was not here to present this himself. and it is a letter of support for the train, code master plan. >> and so, i am going to just give you a quick background and then david pray will get into the substance of the planning effort and the proposals within the plan. >> so just in the way of introduction, the site location pier 70, is the port property between mariposa and 22nd street, east of il

. >> i am matsuda, from the 25 holaling hoa, and following up on angela's comments there were only two residential buildings, and we are obviously attracted to the historic square and we support the developer coming on board and taking this project on and seeing the completion of this building. i guess that renovation is a strong woerd, but evolution and seeing the bliet lifted. what we are concerned with is we are blue sky starved already and we are at the base of the financial district and also the cer csf that went up right in the sun arc and blocked a lot of our sunlight during more than half of the year. and we are very supportive of the developer, and working through this project. what we do want to ask is that light blue sky, privacy issues are taken into consideration, for the other home owners, and we are building of eight condos, and two parcels, south of this project. and the penthouses that are already two penthouses on the roof. so i am not sure that if this is a third pept house being discussed but i would like to see some consideration of minimizing additional structures

. >> matsuda. >> yes. >> pearlman >> yes. >> wolfram. >> yes. >> hasz *. >> yes. >> that passes 7 to 0. and in places you on item

. >> matsuda >> yes. >> wolfram. >> yes. >> pearlman >> yes. >> hasz. >> yes. >> and that passes 6 for 0. if we may take a 2008.0405a (shelley caltagirone: 415-558-6625) 628-632 steiner street, east side between hayes and fell streets. assessor's block 0822, lot 024 - request for a certificate of appropriateness >> good afternoon, i am here to report on 632 steiner street which is a residence that contributes to the landmark district and the building was designed by the architect matthew obrain in 1902. and john fillmore, and the proposal includes a three car garage at the existing level of the building and creating a garage opening that will require removal of the curved concrete bay and currently interrupted by a pedestrian an door on the south side. and the door would be 8 feet wide by 6 feet and 8 inches tall and it will be placed flush with the facade. the concrete base would be repaired and replicated to infill the area currently occupied by the pedestrian an door. the staff is determined that the proposed work is compatible with the character defining features of the subject bui