the e-mails are connected to the investigation into benghazi. earlier i spoke with congressman trey gowdy, the chairman of the house select committee on benghazi. >> chairman gowdy, i want to get your reaction to the decision by the former secretary of state hillary clinton to turn over her private e-mail server to the justice department. what do you think about this? >> about damn time was my initial reaction. we asked her in march to turn that server over to a neutral detached independent arbitor like the inspector general. i can't help but smile at the notion somebody is voluntarily turning something over to the fbi. they generally don't ask. they generally tell you to do so and i doubt very seriously that they asked her to turn her server over. if they have jurisdiction, they don't need to ask, they go get it. >> hillary clinton this week certified under penalty of perjury that she has turned over all of the e-mails related to her time at the state department do you take her at that word? >> well, i read that statement and it's easier to rea

what does this have to do with investigating what happened around benghazi? >> well, probably not much of anything. it was just us that determined this unique e-mail arrangement she had with herself. we have interviewed three dozen witnesses, not a single one is named clinton, in fact, while i'm happy to be on the show, had she not had this arrangement herself, you would not be talking with me this morning. before i can write the final accounting of that, i have to make sure that the public record is complete. sop all of this started with my desire to get her e-mails. and e-mails of her top aids. that's when we learned she had this unprecedented e-mail arrangement with herself, and thanks to frankly some folks in your line of work who did some good journalistic investigation and thanks in part, i guess to my colleagues on the committee, we have determined that there's a lot more to her e-mail story than just the completeness of the record. in terms of what i'm interested in, it is doing a good job for those four murdered americans and their families. the clas

and again, this was supposed to be about benghazi. there's nothing there that indicates somehow that she is to blame for benghazi or somebody was negligent in protecting our assets or ambassador. >> she was negligent. she denied him protection. >> how many hearings have we had? >> she denied him protection. >> she didn't comply with or provide the information. that's the thing. you say there's nothing there. really? >> really. >> they had security issues. she knew about it. they died. she denied it. >> she testified and case closed. nothing was found. >> juan, you're carrying more water than an alhambra truck. >> i don't even know what that means. >> bottled water. >> maybe that's west coast. >> do we have time for this or what? i'm going to go for it. so you heard that joe biden might be deciding to run. she actually responded to this with this incredible response. take a look. >> i have a great deal of admiration and affection for him. and i think he has to make what is a very difficult decision for himself and his family. and he sh

she was talking about benghazi. this is an issue where republicans have really hit her hard, and she said, look, i'm tired of peopling politicizing these attacks. she wants to move beyond it. let's take a look at what she had to say about that. >> now, they'll try to tell you this is about benghazi, but it's not. benghazi was a tragedy, four dedicated public servants lost their lives and we have to be focused on how to prevent future tragedies. and do you know what, it's not about e-mails or servers either, it's about politics. i've just provided my server to the justice department. but here's what i won't do. i won't get down in the mud with them. i won't play politics with national security or dishonor the memory of those who we lost. >> reporter: now, even as hillary clinton is trying to move beyond these issues, whether it be benghazi or whether it be the e-mails, republicans are not keen to let that happen and donald trump is becoming her latest critic. he thinks these controversies could end up being the death

what does this have to do with investigating what happened around benghazi? >> well, probably not much of anything. it was just us that determined this unique e-mail arrangement she had with herself. we have interviewed three dozen witnesses, not a single one is named clinton, in fact, while i'm happy to be on the show, had she not had this arrangement herself, you would not be talking with me this morning. my focus is on the four murdered americans in benghazi, but before i can write the final accounting of that, i have to make sure that the public record is complete. so all of this started with my desire to get her e-mails. and e-mails of her top aids. that's when we learned she had this unprecedented e-mail arrangement with herself, and thanks to frankly some folks in your line of work who did some good journalistic investigation and thanks in part, i guess to my colleagues on the committee, we have determined that there's a lot more to her e-mail story than just the completeness of the record. in terms of what i'm interested in, it is doing a good job for

bill: hillary clinton will testify for a few months on benghazi. the head of the country says clinton better be ready for a very long day. >> i get that she's frustrated. they look at the mirror and engage in self reflection and lash out of and blame non-existent right-wing conspiracies and apparent lay she has chosen to do the latter. my name is chris hughes and i am a certified arborist for pg&e. i oversee the patrolling of trees near power lines and roots near pipes and underground infrastructure. at pg&e wherever we work, we work hard to protect the environment. getting the job done safely so we can keep the lights on for everybody. because i live here i have a deeper connection to the community. and i want to see the community grow and thrive. every year we work with cities and schools to plant trees in our communities. the environment is there for my kids and future generations. together, we're building a better california. my psoriatic arthritis i'm caused joint pain.o golfer. just like my moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis. and i was w

what does this have to do with investigating what happened around benghazi? >> probably not much of anything. it was just us that determined this unique e-mail arrangement she had with herself. we interviewed three dozen witnesses. not a single one is named clinton. in fact, while i'm happy to be on your show, had she not had this e-mail arrangement with herself, you wouldn't be talking to me this morning. my focus is on the four murdered americans in benghazi but before i can write the final definitive accounting of that, i have to make sure that the public record is complete. all of this started with my desire to get her e-mails and the e-mails of her top aides. that's when we learned she had this unprecedented e-mail arrangement with herself and thanks to some folks in your line of work who did some good journalistic investigation and thanks in part i guess to my colleagues on the committee, we have determined that there's a lot more to her e-mail story than just the completeness of the record. in terms of what i'm interested in, it's doing a good job for

four americans died in benghazi in november 2012. she will testify on benghazi sometime this fall. rich, how is she depending herself today. joishgs boy labels she never sent or received class foyed material. that is how classified information made its way on to it. and clinton claims that the controversy surrounding her private server is motivated boy partisan opponents and the federal government is navigating bureaucratic procedure. >> that's something they will have to determine. and i think there are disputes among the agencies of what should of or would of been done. and that's something for them to work out. i am repeating the facts. and the facts are, i did not send or receive material marked classified. >> the inspector general said four of the e-mails contained classified information. and a private data center turned over the clinton server to the fbi. >> is this damaging the run for president. >> support is weakening. two months ago voters had a favorable view. and now more find her unfavorable. bernie sanders is leading here in a new hampshire poll. and running the gamme

she's lied about benghazi, she's lied about her server and she's lied about her e-mails. some this the media found that language harsh. the more this story goes on the more it becomes clear that she has lied and it's clear that this server was parked in some i.t. firm in new jersey getting cleaned, boy, that raise all kinds of issues and it's almost hard to believe, it's strange credit nullity. now, we're finding out she did as usual. cover-up is worse than the crime. >> you also made comments last month on fox that hillary has blood on her hands when it comes to benghazi, are you saying she was responsible -- somehow responsible for the death of those americans? >> what i'm saying is, the night that benghazi attack happened, secretary of state clinton, president obama and others knew that this was a purposeful, preplanned terrorist attack, nevertheless, the next morning, she addressed the american people from the state department and talked about a video and how it didn't represent the values of the american people and several days later, she stood over the bodies of the

i'd just like to say the emails and all this is a misdirection on benghazi. i think that ambassador stevens was the most knowledgeable about what was going on, on the ground. he knew that that compound was due to be closed and that they were going to collate with the c.i.a. at the beginning of the next year, in three months. he knew there wasn't going to be a lot of security -- money put into that compound. he knew there wasn't a safe room and elected to stay there on the anniversary of 911. he made a lot of on the ground decisions that i think came back to bite that group in the butt. host: that's cindy from washington. any thoughts, francesca chambers? guest: just going back to everything i said before. i really think we've covered a lot of that. host: our last caller will be from east new york calling on the democratic line. ellie, go ahead. caller: yes, good morning. thank you for taking my call. i am so disgusted with this whole political arena that we have been living through. one, hillary clinton emails? yes. it always should be investigated. we must k

>>> next, benghazi committee >>> next, benghazi committee chair trey gowdy, and clinton supporter claire mccaskill are here live to take on that e-mail controversy. a better retirement... it's called a reverse mortgage. call right now to receive your free dvd and booklet with no obligation. it answers questions like... how a reverse mortgage works, how much you qualify for, the ways to receive your money... and more. plus, when you call now, you'll get this magnifier with led light absolutely free! when you call the experts at one reverse mortgage today, you'll learn the benefits of a government-insured reverse mortgage. it will eliminate your monthly mortgage payments and give you tax-free cash from the equity in your home and here's the best part... you still own your home. take control of your retirement today! ♪ (dorothy) toto, i've a feeling we're not in kansas anymore... (morpheus) after this, there is no turning back. (spock) history is replete with turning points. (kevin) wow, this is great. (commentator) where fantasy becomes reality! (penguin 1) where are we going? (penguin 2

she's lied about benghazi, she's lied about her server and she's lied about her e-mails. and there were some in the media that found that language harsh. the more this story goes on, the more it becomes clear that she has lied and it's clear that this server was parked in some i.t. firm in new jersey getting cleaned -- boy, that raise all kinds of issues and it's almost hard to believe, it's strange credulity to accept that a secretary of state, who handled all of her communications on a home server, never passed classified information on her device and over that server. of course, she did. now, we're finding out she did as usual. the cover-up is worse than the crime. >> you also made comments last month on fox that hillary has blood on her hands when it comes to benghazi, are you saying she was responsible -- somehow responsible for the death of those americans? >> what i'm saying is, the night that benghazi attack happened, secretary of state clinton, president obama and others knew that this was a purposeful, preplanned terrorist attack. nevertheless, the next morning,

she's lied about benghazi, she's lied about her server and she's lied about her e-mails. and there were some in the media that found that language harsh. the more this story goes on, the more it becomes clear that she has lied and it's clear that this server was parked in some i.t. firm in new jersey getting cleaned -- boy, that raise all kinds of issues and it's almost hard to believe, it's strange credulity to accept that a secretary of state, who handled all of her communications on a home server, information on her device and over that server. of course, she did. now, we're finding out she did as usual. the cover-up is worse than the crime. >> you also made comments last month on fox that hillary has blood on her hands when it comes to benghazi, are you saying she was responsible -- somehow responsible for the death of those americans? >> what i'm saying is, the night that benghazi attack happened, secretary of state clinton, president obama and others knew that this was a purposeful, preplanned terrorist attack. nevertheless, the next morning, she addressed the ameri

benghazi, it's about e-mails. maria: right. >> who knows what the third leg is going to be, but i think what we're going through is politics and i think people are spinning a lot of facts. they're not just on her, clearly on others, so i'm confident-- look, the way i made a decision who do i support is by looking at their record. i thought she was one of the best senators we've ever had since of' been in new york and i've been here for 50 years. maria: wow. >> she's very responsive. look at 9/11 how she went to bat for downtown and got $25 billion along with other senators and elected officials from the state to help the city come back. i think of secretary of state, people criticize her for travelling too much and on the plane too much. her job was to execute the policies set out by the president. i think she did that. maria: did she put this country in a vulnerable position in terms of hacking into important files of the usa because of her home server? >> well, you may have more information than me. i don't know

she certainly took a little bit of benghazi. bush bringing up iraq thing he has to do it, go after her on foreign policy, obviously. but it raises the question of his brother and iraq and the fact that isis wasn't there before we invaded iraq. so he has to be ready -- >> they were there when we left. hillary clinton says in her book she was against the dramatic pull out. she was actually for going after bashir al assad. i think this is a good strategy to take hen on on those vulnerabilities. >> dana, how do you think republicans should respond when she says that basically? she's going to come out and say, well, i wasn't president. barack obama was president. if i was president i would have done things differently. >> you had a seat at the table on the cabinet as the secretary of state. it's not like you were the governor of florida. >> she's part of the relay team be honest. i don't want to give her any credit about her experience in foreign policy. i want you to impress me that you're really good at your job, not being incompet

>> hillary clinton lies about benghazi. she lies about e-mails. she is still depending planned parenthood and she is still her party's frontrunner. >> reporter: you can see there are lots of candidates who managed to get zingers in with donald trump on stage. as for trump, his campaign put out a press release declaring himself the winner of the debate. he spent most of the night tweeting about the questions from fox and megyn kelly. >> he is tweeting right now, sara. very nice job setting the tables. let's bring in a few other analysts with sara. we have peter handby and ron brownstein. gentlemen, thank you. sara you are with us. let's start with you, ron. we know what the expectations were. what did and did not meet your expectations last night? >> you know. it was a very entertaining

>> i said in my closing comments at that fox news debate that hillary clinton has lied about benghazi, about her e-mails, about her server. and there were some in the liberal media who said, wow, that's really strong language. but of course, it is the right language. she has lied. and i think the more we learn, the more we know that's true. >> do you think some of your fellow candidates might be afraid to say, i agree with you. she lied. as plain as day to me. i think she really has a very difficult legal problem on her

. >> now, they'll try to tell you this is about benghazi, but it's not. benghazi was a tragedy. four dedicated public servants lost their lives and we have to be focused on how to prevent future tragedies. and you know what? it's not about e-mails or servers, either. it's about politics i've just provided my server to the justice department but here's what i won't do. i won't get down in the mud with them. i won't play politics with the national security or dishonor the memory of those who we lost. >> she was very well received at that speech friday night. >> she was. >> but her strategy is basically to say this has nothing do with an fbi investigation, it's all about republicans trying to smear her. >> it's not strategy, that's reality, right? i'm old enough to have lived through this for many years. this is what republicans do. what i don't understand is why they keep doing it, because it fails. years ago hillary said this to me when we needed to change strategy for her husband and i didn't want to. she said "insanity is defined by doing the same thing over and over again expe

it's what you do. >>> a brand new benghazi bombshell involving hillary clinton's e-mail. we are learning who sent potentially classified information on benghazi using the private server. i am martha maccallum. >> and i will bill hemmer. good morning. that classified intelligence contained in two e-mails coming from military sources and sensitive fbi files on the benghazi attack. the senders are jake sullivan and another close advisor to her, oboth leading the campaign. catherage is here. >> reporter: these e-mails were released in may and were the catalyst for the investigation because they contained classified information. one e-mail was sent to ms. clinton's private account by jake sullivan, and the e-mail was posted to the state department and it is retracted and includes the notation showing it is classified and the other refers to the suspects in the attack came from fbi forces. the second information was forded by her aid who works for the clinton campaign as well. fox news is told the e-mail had classified information from military intelligence sources and was mist

the first benghazi e-mails were released in may. it's been a mystery which one sparked the fbi investigation. now fox news is the first media organization to confirm who sent them and the content. one e-mail from november 18th, 2012, two months after the benghazi terrorist attack was sent by jake sullivan who at the time was her chief of staff and now serves on her 2016 campaign. the version released to the public is heavily redacted and carries the b 1 code for classified information. the other redaction refers to suspects in the benghazi assault. chris farrell has also served as an intelligence security officer. >> the information withheld from this document that's redacted points to intelligence and law enforcement information that is essentially classified information. >> reporter: mrs. clinton's aide, huma amedin who works for the clinton campaign forwarded the second e-mail during the 2014 libyan revolution. this e-mail contains classified information from military intelligence sources, and the inspector general says it was wr

by the way, i'm looking toward to the benghazi hearing in october. we should see how many questions they're going to ask on benghazi. what they need to do is just calm down and, you know, enjoy the race. there's going to be some interesting politicking coming up and it will be fine. >> all right. what was your honest interpretation of her performance yesterday in nevada? because she came across to a lot of people as sort of crass, dismiss dismissive, flippant, not wanting to give this issue the time, despite the impact that it's had on her numbers. >> well, look, if you go out to the press and you do things, i thought she was fine. i thought she was superb in the black lives matter thing. i thought that the education stuff was superb. i think her campaign has some really good things going out there. they're just going to have to deal with this. people are going to interpret every word, every expression that she makes. everything -- you know, the rule of the media is this. the clintons don't deserve a defense. they get irritated if somebody comes on a

every time they get her in a press conference them just yell benghazi, benghazi, benghazi. and e-mail, e-mail, e-mail. they don't even know what the gun is. what are they for? how do you deal with that in terms of press relations? like she had this trouble the other day. >> well, i think first of all, she has to fight through it. she has to fight back. she has to be strong and assertive. and at the end of the day. what they're really asking americans to believe is that hillary clinton as secretary of state somehow wanted to harm americans serving abroad as part of her organization? or that she wanted the chinese to be able to hack into our systems? i mean, i think at the end of the day, a lot of this becomes noise. and look at her numbers, still. people talk about her unfavorables. they're much lower than donald trump's. everybody is talking about donald trump. he's great, doing so great. his unfavorables are much higher than hillary clinton's. >> i know. >> he's got 20% of the vote in that means 80% of the vote against him. perspective and context matters. >> the night tha

at least two classified emails on benghazi were sent to catholic's private email account. kicking off, as you know now, the fbi investigation. and they're now part of the hundreds of emails, mostly classified after the fact, found on her personal server. as we heard earlier, the clinton campaign continues to laugh off this scandal. catherine herridge live for us in washington today. catherine, what is the significance of these two emails? >> gretchen. these emails from clinton aides got the ball rolling as you mentioned on the fbi investigation. this is the first time any media organization has identified who sent them and the content. the november 18, 2012, email two months after the benghazi terrorist attack was sent by sulliv sullivan, her chief of staff who now serves on her campaign. the version released to the public is redacted and carries the classified information code. the other redaction shows it came from fbi sources and refers to possible suspects in the 2012 terrorist attacks. the second email that contained classified information was forwarded to mrs. clinto

he signed off on the use of the consulate in benghazi. he had to sign off on paper or at least tacitly agree to the use of the state department's server, and we're now investigating whether there were internal complaints at the state department to their inspector general to their watchdog, about the use of this server, and patrick kennedy may have attempted to block or thwart those maintains about the clinton operation. >> so many different angles of the story and more developing. >> like a house of cards. >> no doubt. thank you so much. >> you're welcome. >> former nfl football qb injured in an apparent suicide attempt. trace gallagher is live with more on the chicago bear qb. >> reporter: we should start by saying eric kramer worked at fox sports, friend of the network, good guy. reportedly shot himself in a hotel room in calabasas north of los angeles. authority says the wound was not life-threatening but kramer's sister says the injury could be life-threatening. his ex-wife says he is in a medically induced coma. we have not been told

>> no, i think benghazi is a long, long time ago. the e-mail thing or some story that hasn't come out yet might. people have been pounding on the benghazi drum for a long time. it's become one of those things that i think voters can too easily tune out. there's a small fraction of voters who believe something bad happened, and facts on either side aren't going to change their view. the vast majority of people have moved on. they're going to care about the issues that have to do with their wallet, jobs, and their future. and security issues next. but things like benghazi are long over. >> more recently, broad out whether or not congress upholds the iran nuclear deal next month. who do you think in the 2016 poll has the background to navigate this? >> i think every single person involved in the campaign from the democratic side to the republican side will seek to have better relations with israel than barack obama has with israel. barack obama has sort of gone at this with a chip on his shoulder. the relationship right now is completel

benghazi is not very popular. people don't care -- >> "american sniper" made $350 million. >> it also depends what the movie is about. if it is based on a small group of operatives who desperately tried to -- it de peppedz -- it depends. >> even though it was a tragedy and it reflects very badly, almost criminally on the administration in my opinion, i think these guys are heros and that will make the administration look worse. it is about what happened because they were neglected. >> the problem is he is a dreadful film maker and he will make a dreadful movie out of it. he made lone survivor and clint eastwood made "american sniper." i write about movies for the weekly standard. weekly standard.com. >> commentary magazine.com. >> have to read it. >> is it wrong for an indian restaurant to hire an indian waiter? don't forget to set your dvr to record "red eye" with tom shillue. that way we will be waiting when you wake up. >>> what would we do without the new york city human rights commission? always on the lookou

the first benghazi e-mails were released in may. it's been a mystery which one sparked the fbi investigation. now fox news is the first media organization to confirm who sent them and the content. one e-mail from november 18th, 2012, two months after the benghazi terrorist attack was sent by jake sullivan who at the time was her chief of staff and now serves on her 2016 campaign. the version released to the public is heavily redacted and carries the b 1 code for classified information. the other redaction refers to suspects in the benghazi assault. chris farrell has also served as an intelligence security officer. >> the information withheld from this document that's redacted points to intelligence and law enforcement information that is essentially classified information. >> reporter: mrs. clinton's aide, huma amedin who works for the clinton campaign forwarded the second e-mail during the 2014 libyan revolution. this e-mail contains classified information from military intelligence sources, and the inspector general says it was wr

what happened in those 13 hours in benghazi, and what played out before that? the dereliction of duty issue is very important here. what happened in the decisions that were made with assets that were not put out there? >> right. it's one thing to say vast right-wing conspiracy which the clintons, harris, have historically said. you can't say it on this server issue because it's the obama fbi and cia that have sort of been fueling this server issue, but i want to talk messaging because i don't think it's smart for the clinton campaign to go in this direction. and i also think republicans need to hit on what david said. at best, harris, both of these issues are an issue of incompetence, profound incompetence, which is not something good for a potential -- >> all right, so how do we know that she may cede what you just said? she had two weeks planned in the hamptons, and she canceled it to get on the campaign trail. where is she going? ohio, a very important primary state. they all are, but ohio's very important particularly for democrats. you win that, you typica

>> well, i have about six pages of questions that are exclusively related to benghazi. there's not a single e-mail question on my first six pages of questions for secretary clinton, so i don't know how she or any of her acolytes could possibly say that. she wasn't interviewed by the arb. she appeared before one house committee and one senate committee and you and i have followed congress enough tow. >> the arb being the state department review board. i'm just making that clear. >> that's right. and they didn't even bother to interview her. then you had the house and the senate where she made a single appearance. but you have five minutes and, frankly, they're not the best questioners in the world. so i don't think it's asking too much that she do what she says she's going to do, which is come before congress and answer all the questions that we have with respect to the security profile, the pendency of the attacks and the administration response in the aftermath. ultimately it will be you and our fellow citizens to judge whether our questions are fair and appropriate or

they'll try to tell you this is about benghazi, but it's not. and you know what. it's not about e-mails or servers either. it's about politics. i won't get down in the mud with them. i won't play politics with national security or dishonor the memory of those who we lost. >> i get that she's frustrated. sometimes when people are frustrated, they look in the mirror and they engage in a little bit of self-reflection and sometimes they lash out and blame nonexistent right-wing experiences and apparently, she's chosen to do the latter. >> two different perspectives on the hillary clinton e-mails. it's not her political opponents who are stirring up this hornet's nest. it is two inspectors general and also now the department of justice and the fbi. and there's some new information today that the state department has now recommended that 305 of clinton's e-mails be flagged for review for potential violations of sending classifiied information. let's bring in our panel now. what do you think of the new developments, charles? >> it shows you once again how bad a candidate

e-mail forwarded by aide jacob sullivan outlined reports of possible arrests in connection with the benghazi attack. the e-mails are among some 30,000 clinton turned over to the state department from her private server. on monday the state department said it had flag third degree 05 e-mails out of the 20% it has reviewed as potentially contained classified information. clinton has insisted there was no classified information on her server. >> whether it was a personal account or a government account, did not send classified material and did not receive any material that was marked or december ig nated classified which is way that you know something is. >> reporter: but it's not just clinton's private sevener that may have contained priefbtd information. the state department filed court parps wednesday afternoon saying it does not know. dan ackerman is an editor at cnet. >> any time you're bringing your own equipment and using it for work purposes, it's not something that's secure because they take those laptops for example and they preconfigure them, put new soft wairks try new software. >>

e-mail forwarded by aide jacob sullivan outlined reports of possible arrests in connection with the benghazi attack. the e-mails are among some 30,000 clinton turned over to the state department from her private server. on monday the state department said it had flag third degree 05 e-mails out of the 20% it has reviewed as potentially contained classified information. clinton has insisted there was no classified information on her server. >> whether it was a personal account or a government account, did not send classified material and did not receive any material that was marked or december ig nated classified which is way that you know something is. >> reporter: but it's not just clinton's private sevener that may have contained priefbtd information. the state department filed court parps wednesday afternoon saying it does not know. dan ackerman is an editor at cnet. >> any time you're bringingour own equipment and using it for work purposes, it's not something that's secure because they take those laptops for example and they preconfigure them, put new soft wairks try new software. >> th

like benghazi, first it was obama didn't call it terrorism. well, he did. well, four americans died in ben gauzy. well, yeah, they did, but more americans died in the anthrax attacks in 2001 and that was never even called a terrorist attack. in fact in 2006 george bush proudly proclaimed there had been no more terrorist attacks on american soil after 9/11, despite five americans dying in the anthrax attack. and i think that republicans play victim to the media, trying to force the media into covering stories that just don't even exist. >> okay, john. mr. boehlert. >> yeah, he makes a lot of good points. again, i think the clintons have an unusual relationship with the press. as he says, they have been the topic of endless skrocrutiny, m so than any other political couple. and yet instead of coming to the conclusion that they have been vetted or this is their career or they have been extremely successful or this is their agenda, they just seem to become continually distracted and convinced they're going to -- you know, there's something there that's going to

every time they get her in a press conference them just yell bae benghazi, benghazi, benghazi. and e-mail, e-mail, e-mail. they don't even know what the gun is. what are they for? how do you deal with that in terms of press relations? like she had this trouble the other day. >> well, i think first of all, she has to fight through it. she has to fight back. she has to be strong and assertive. and at the end of the day. what they're really asking americans to believe is that hillary clinton as secretary of state somehow wanted to harm americans serving abroad as part of her organization? or that she wanted the chinese to be able to hack into our systems? i mean, i think at the end of the day, a lot of this becomes noise. and look at her numbers, still. people talk about her unfavorables. they're much lower than donald trump's. everybody is talking about donald trump. he's great, doing so great. his unfavorables are much higher than hillary clinton's. >> i know. >> he's got 20% of the vote in that means 80% of the vote against him. perspective and context matters. >> the night tha

. >> she has lied about key things, benghazi, her e-mails, her server. >> we're going to build a wall -- >> reporter: but donald trump's tough talk has the republican field stuck an defense, responding to his talking points. >> i don't agree that we should be trying to amend the constitution. >> i think birth right citizenship as a policy matter doesn't make sense. >> if folks want to come to our country, they should come legally. >> reporter: trump is defending an immigration plan that could cost between 100 and 6$600 billion and not saying exactly how he would pull it off. >> it's called management. the first thing we have to do is secure the border. >> reporter: managing the conversation, donald trump is still leading in the polls. brian moore, nbc news, washington. >>> the fallout continues after the hacking of adultery site ashley madison. jeffrey ashton, a florida state attorney who gained national attention in this unsuccessful case against casey anthony has admitted to signing up for the site two years ago. on sunday he says he committed no crime and never followed through wit

she will talk about benghazi and e-mails. i think the rubio's statement was really strong it is an issue on which republicans had been on offense because of planned parenthood and hillary clinton she cannotfter against exceptions on an portion rubio right now shows fight for the middle not for the base. >> and think he should still fight for the base but he was strong. >> no fight for the middle. >> hillary clinton was on her own offensive rampage this week. she targeted marco rubio on abortion and on a conference call with reporters today jake sullivan preempted that jeb foreign policy speech by tying him to his brother's legacy in iraq and in new hampshire, clinton used in education speech to, another republican 2016 contender. >> you take someone like governor walker of wisconsin who thes to delight in slashing investment in higher education in his state and making it more difficult for students to get scholarships or to pay off their debt. >> it sometimes feel likes we are in the general election. walker defended himself

before it was released or this one sent by her close aide houma abedin on deteriorating conditions in benghazi. mrs. clinton says she didn't think any of those e-mails were classified. >> i did not send classified material, and i did not receive any material that was marked or designated classified, which is the way you know whether something is. >> reporter: but could she be charged with a crime? could it be like the case against former general david petraeus? he pleaded guilty to mishandling classified information. clinton supporters say that was different. >> you had someone who knew he was holding on to classified information, admitted on tape that he knew the information was classified, and then took it and turned it over to someone who was not authorized to view that information. >> reporter: but a former republican attorney general says mrs. clinton could be charged just as petraeus was for keeping classified material where it shouldn't be. >> the place in his case was his home. in her case it's her private e-mail server. so the question then becomes whether she was the one who caused i

go through your list of where she lied. >> benghazi, e-mails and server. i will debate her on the issues facing this nation. i will debate her on her positions. i will ask her for example how she can possibly continue to defend planned parenthood. i will ask her why she continues to say show's a champion of the middle class while every single proposal she has put forward makes cronie capitalism worse and worse and worse. >> at the end, you don't see the end there, he's completely crying. she made matthews into mincemeat, kennedy. >> she held her own, and that's why she did well in the debate, because she's got a substantive response for just about anything. and she can make lists. >> let's get john because we know he doesn't care. >> i got a thrill going up my leg. liberals can't debate. they're great with two other liberals around the panel. >> shut up! >> see? look at you, john, you're falling apart. >> look what she did to chris. he's a lion. >> he's like -- >> look at cecil. >> that's too much for cecil. >> she shut him down. that's what you have to do

four americans died in benghazi. rthey -- they did. more americans died in the anthrax attacks in 2001. george bush claimed there had been no more attacks, -- in 2011. george bush proudly claimed there had been no more attacks, despite those five deaths of the anthrax attacks. host: ok, jon. mr. boehlert. guest: i think he makes a lot of good points. the clintons have an unusual relationship with the press, as he says. they have been the topic of endless scrutiny, more so than any other political couple. and yet, instead of coming to the conclusion that they have been vetted or this is their career or they have been extreme and successful or this is their agenda -- they have been extremely successful or this is their agenda, they are convinced there is something that is going to take them down. i wish they would cover the clintons, specifically hillary clinton, fairly. no one is asking for any breaks. just cover her as the democratic front-runner. both have" fox -- written articles about how the press' goal is to take down hillary clin

e-mail forwarded by aide jacob sullivan outlined reports of possible arrest in connection with the benghazi attacks. the e-mails are among the 30,000 clinton turned over to the state department from her private server. clinton has insisted there was no classified information on her server. >> whether it was a personal account or a government account, i did not send classified material and i did not receive any material that was marketed or designated classified which is the way you know whether something is. >> reporter: the state department filed court papers this afternoon saying it does not believe that any personal computing device was issued by the department to clinton. and as for that server, her attorney confirmed it was wiped clean of all its data before she turned it over to the fbi. jan crawford, cbs news, washington. >>> the secret is out. the customer data list from the ashley madison hack is now searchable online. they cater to married people looking to have affairs. a recent hack exposed about 32 million customer names. e-mails, and physical addresses. around 15,000 of those

attorneys subpoena hillary clinton's benghazi documents. she denies she was subpoenaed. >> you say you never received a subpoena. you did get one in march. couldn't be more plain. the honorable9)áv r clinton. >> hillary denies there are any benghazi e-mails despite photos of using her blackberry on the way to libya. and this puts truth to the lie she had none. hillary, now in panic mode. she would then go through 61,000 e-mails, deleting 31,000 she says are personal. another 30,000 she hands over, she says there is no classified information in them. >> i did not e-mail any classified materials to anyone on this e-mail. there is no classified material. i'm certainly well aware of the classification requirements. >> but the inspector general says in a sampling of just 40 e-mails, four contain classified information. her defense? they weren't marked classified. nothing to see here, folks. move along. truth? it couldn't be marked classified because by not using government servers she actually prevented the government from reviewing her e-mails

benghazi is not very popular. people don't care -- >> "american sniper" made $350 million. >> it also depends what the movie is about. if it is based on a small group of operatives who desperately tried to -- it de peppedz -- it depends. >> even though it was a tragedy and it reflects very badly, almost criminally on the administration in my opinion, i think these guys are heros and that will make the administration look worse. it is about what happened because they were neglected. >> the problem is he is a dreadful film maker and he will make a dreadful movie out of it. he made lone survivor and clint eastwood made "american sniper." i write about movies for the weekly standard. weekly standard.com. >> commentary magazine.com. >> have to read it. >> is it wrong for an indian restaurant to hire an indian waiter? don't forget to set your dvr to record "red eye" with tom shillue. that way we will be waiting when you wake up. ever since darryl's wife started using gain flings, their laundry smells more amazing than e

leticia writes things to help the middle class that's not abortion, benghazi, terrorist. paul writes i want to hear about legalizing the growing of hemp strengthening native american relations and getting tougher on illegal immigration. we read more comments i had of the forum. while we wait for the remarks of the young african leaders summit we will take a look at washington journal. host: medicare markets 50th anniversary. here to discuss that the former administrator from the centers for medicare and medicaid services from 1990 to 1992. dr. robert berenson the acting administered are from 2000 to 2001, thank you for being here. i want to show viewers and you what president lyndon b. johnson had to say 50 years ago when he signed this legislation into law. pres. johnson: there are over 50 million americans over the age of 55, most have limited income and are threatened by illness and expenses. through this new law, every citizen will be able to in his years to ensure himself against the ravages of illnesses and old age. this insurance will help pay for hospitals, nursin

says contained classified information were uncovered during an investigation of the 2012 attack in benghazi, libya that killed ambassador chris stevens and three other americans. the first email from april 2011 was forwarded to clinton by aide huma aberdeen citing reports from the u.s. african command on libyan troop strengths and movements. the second forwarded by aide jacob sullivan outlined reports of possible arrests in connection with the benghazi attack. the emails are among the some 30,000 clinton turned over to the state department from her private server. clinton has insisted there was no classified information on her server. >> whether it was a personal account or a government account, i did not send classified material and i did not receive any material that was marked or designated classified which is the way you know whether something is. >> reporter: the state department filed court papers saying it does not believe that any personal computing device was issued by the department to clinton. and as for that server, her attorney confirmed it was wiped clean of all its data befor