if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's fice and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's.

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

peskin. >> present. >> supervisor tang. >> tang not present. >> supervisor wiener. >> here. >> supervisor yee. >> here. >> mme. pres., you have a quorum. >> thank you. ladies and gentlemen, can you please join us for the pledge of allegiance? >> [pledge of allegiance] >> members, are there any changes to the meeting minutes of june 28, 2016. seeing none is there a motion to approve? we have a motion to approve by supervisor mar and seconded by supervisor tang. seeing none is there a motion to approve? colleagues can we take this without objection, without objection those meeting minutes will pass after public comment. >> [gavel] >>> mme. clerk, can you please read our first item. read our first item. >> mme. sec. can you please call the roll >>[roll call vote] >> there are 11 ayes. >> this vote item is approved unanimously. >>[gavel] >>next item please.>> item 2 >>[reading item] >>can we take this same house same call? >>without objection this is passed unanimously. >>mme. clerk can you pleas

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

peskin. supervisor kim. >>thank you mme. supervisor i would just like to say that i would like to finalize this before the board today. last week proposition highlighted the growing concern of the alarming loss of manufacturing repair as well as the strength and enforcement of the current controls put in place to protect and encourage these types of use and consequently the jobs that come with it. over a year and a half ago our office reached out to over 100 different artists that were at fear of being evicted this was termed over 40 different artists that were evicted and through this process we brainstormed and brought together different ideas of how we can protect and encourage art uses three range of controls. i do want to remind the artists [inaudible] although are initially are were legislation had started out as an ordinance to protect and encourage artists to stay here in san francisco i mentioned that one of our outcomes of our meetingswas that the arts commission whose staff partici

>>supervisor peskin. >>my urge is that the board will work with the cpuc and adopt a resolution to adopt conviction history regulations in furtherance of a level regulatory playing field and in compliance with san francisco's 2014 fair chance ordinance. >>thank you supervisor peskin has this been approved by their legislature. >>it is my understanding that they have no objections. >>so, i just need some clarity >>this would be consistent with the ordinance in 2015 for prior conviction histories to those directly relating to the job in question of those having specificregulatory bearing on the job in question and further, it must be a conviction that is less than seven years old. >>okay, i know everybody is tired and i will just make a few comments. i do appreciate supervisor peskin's role in this to work with a number of organizations to try and come up with the right balance in order to address this issue unfortunately, i don't think that i'm going to be supporting this resolution today. we have worked r

>>supervisor peskin. >>my urge is that the board will work with the cpuc and adopt a resolution to adopt conviction history regulations in furtherance of a level regulatory playing field and in compliance with san francisco's 2014 fair chance ordinance. >>thank you supervisor peskin has this been approved by their legislature. >>it is my understanding that they have no objections. >>so, i just need some clarity >>this would be consistent with the ordinance in 2015 for prior conviction histories to those directly relating to the job in question of those having specificregulatory bearing on the job in question and further, it must be a conviction that is less than seven years old. >>okay, i know everybody is tired and i will just make a few comments. i do appreciate supervisor peskin's role in this to work with a number of organizations to try and come up with the right balance in order to address this issue unfortunately, i don't think that i'm going to be supporting this resolution today. we have worked r

peskin, present. tang, present. wiener, present. yee, absent. madam president you have a quorum >> motion to excuse supervisor farrell? motion by supervirez mar and seconded by supervisor avalos. take this without objection? without objection supervisor farrell is excused. any communications madam clerk? >> no madam president. >> please call iletms 1 and 2. >> pursuant to motion at july 26, 2016 board meeting the board will convene committee for items 1 and 2. item 1 is public hearing toconsider item 22, charter amendment to amend the charter to remain the office of citizen complaints gives dpa authority over the budge squt requires performance audit every 2 years of how the police department handled claims of officer misconduct and election held negative 8, 2016 >> any members who like to comment on this item seeing none, public comment is closed. this hearing is held and now filed. madment clerk, item 2, please call-supervisor cohen? >> good morning i like to thank everyone coming to the compromise and moving this legislation forward. on tuesd

peskin. >>mme. city president i believe the city attorney has changed his original advice i do not want to put words in his mouth but i believe that this body may take a position on school board matters if it chooses to do so. >>mr. gartner, can you explain? >> yes john gibner, district f the college board chooses to submit the argument and that will be on that and that will be on the ballot pamphlet and if there is a yes argument and the community calendar school board does not choose to submit an argument then that will appear. >> i don't know if i understand that but let's get started. loading items 16 and 17-- i heard voices. supervisor peskin. >> mme. pres. i have asked to be no argument to the community college measure. >>i have you there but i was under a different impression so i will go down the list and colleagues, please correct me if i'm saying something inaccurate so we can make the appropriate changes. these are the proposed amendments to the resolution.416-17 voting pro avalos,

supervisor peskin. >> present. >> supervisor tang. >> tang not present. >> supervisor wiener. >> here. >> supervisor yee. >> here. >> mme. pres., you have a quorum. >> thank you. ladies and gentlemen, can you please join us for the pledge of allegiance? >> [pledge of allegiance] >> members, are there any changes to the meeting minutes of june 28, 2016. seeing none is there a motion to approve? we have a motion to approve by supervisor mar and seconded by supervisor tang. seeing none is there a motion to approve? colleagues can we take this without objection, without objection those meeting minutes will pass after public comment. >> [gavel] >>> mme. clerk, can you please read our first item. read our first item. >> mme. sec. can you please call the roll >>[roll call vote] >> there are 11 ayes. >> this vote item is approved unanimously. >>[gavel] >>next item please.>> item 2 >>[reading item] >>can we take this same house same call? >>without objection this is passed unanimously. >>mme. clerk can you pleas

. >> commissioner kim h supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor peskin supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos commissioner london breed no supervisor campos supervisor cowen no commissioner farrell no there are 6ize with supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor cowen and supervisor farrell in december sent this charter amendment been submitted madam clerk please read public comment. >> at this time, members of the public may address the commission on items within the jurisdiction of the board. >> first speaker. >> thank you good morning, supervisors chinatown missionary officer as a national leader one must seek the prosperity in general benefits for all the people as custom and tradition come to a degrading downfall tragic disasters are trend flow across every continental the loss of peace of nature and the corruption of human heart the misconduct and corruption of human heart is caused by the loss of wholly religion this is volumes of money and family this is attracting people's attendance from the values of humanity of holiness to put an end t

supervisor peskin >> 17. >> we just - oh, 16 i apologize call item number 17. >> item 17 and 18 were referred without recommendation from the transportation committee and item 17 an ordinance for the administrative code to establishment the downtown preservation funds to vacate a portion of jessie street and a portion of alley and first street with the ocean wide project on 55 street. >> roll call vote. >> supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor peskin no supervisor tang supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed supervisor campos supervisor malia cowen commissioner farrell last year 10 i's with supervisor peskin in the dissents. >> this ordinance is finally passed item 18. >> to amend the planning code for the construction of accessary dwellings as long as in-law unit on all lots in areas that allow the retail use. >> supervisor farrell. >> thank you i'd like to ask we hear this labor market in the calendar to work out the technical glitches and passes unanimously last week and anticipated doing so we want to make sure all the language is in

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

supervisor cowen not present per supervisor farrell supervisor kim supervisor mar not present supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee madam chair we have quorum thank you and supervisor cowen is walked in ladies and gentlemen, can you please join us no pledge of allegiance and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> thank you and madam clerk are there any consumptions. >> yes. madam chair we are in receipt of a communication if the mayor communicating his veto of file one six 0660 urging the delegation to amend or oppose the buy right approval the budget tailor bill i've submitted a consumption to the board indicate if their tdr in switzerland a meeting send me a communication. >> colleagues in the what happened last week where the clerk and myself had to remind board members of the appropriate conduct of board i want to set the tone by reminding colleagues of rule 5.12 regarding the conduct of supervisor may not directly or indirectly we any form of the word to another supervisor or other supervisor

>>supervisor peskin is correct, there is no conflict that means supervisor peskin would have to cast a vote in less the board decides to recuse her from the vote. are suggesting the supervisor cohen was that the board recuse her though it that there was no suggestion or clout to the board proceeding or any suggestion to the proposed gift of the project sponsor was proposing the outcome. >>okay, with that colleagues, understanding your concern supervisor peskin this is not because of your concern. it was actually recommended by the city attorney based on the comments or made by supervisor cohen.with that,do we have a motion for this? supervisor kim. >> i actually have a question for the deputy city attorney. it was your suggestionthat she recuse herself.if >> the offering of the gift during this proceeding would influence the outcome of the proceeding that is a concern that we want to avoid. the board should be making this determination based on its review of the eir and its adequacy based on the eir and not any adequacy's within the project sponsor. >>i trust that my colleagues will

>>supervisor peskin is correct, there is no conflict that means supervisor peskin would have to cast a vote in less the board decides to recuse her from the vote. are suggesting the supervisor cohen was that the board recuse her though it that there was no suggestion or clout to the board proceeding or any suggestion to the proposed gift of the project sponsor was proposing the outcome. >>okay, with that colleagues, understanding your concern supervisor peskin this is not because of your concern. it was actually recommended by the city attorney based on the comments or made by supervisor cohen.with that,do we have a motion for this? supervisor kim. >> i actually have a question for the deputy city attorney. it was your suggestionthat she recuse herself.if >> the offering of the gift during this proceeding would influence the outcome of the proceeding that is a concern that we want to avoid. the board should be making this determination based on its review of the eir and its adequacy based on the eir and not any adequacy's within the project sponsor. >>i trust that my colleagues will

supervisor peskin. >>i would like to adjourn today's meeting with memory of pat--and she was [inaudible] and i will truncate this a bit and i will truncate this a bit because i know that it is late everyone would like to go home but her daughter is here and she bears a resemblance to her mother and i just would like to honors her in the late 70s she hosted a show in the 70s on politics she was a journalist for a local newspaper for five years and she traveled the world they do on in her years her final unfinished project was on aging pat worked in the san francisco chamber of commerce and she ran her own public relations firm and worked tirelessly and professionally to protect small businesses and neighborhoods in san francisco. throughout her career she received many awards and accolades from state senators, governors, the business community and city civic leaders including mayor leo around and the pat christiansen achievement award in san francisco and i would also like to give supervisor yee an oppor

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

supervisor peskin. >>i would like to adjourn today's meeting with memory of pat--and she was [inaudible] and i will truncate this a bit and i will truncate this a bit because i know that it is late everyone would like to go home but her daughter is here and she bears a resemblance to her mother and i just would like to honors her in the late 70s she hosted a show in the 70s on politics she was a journalist for a local newspaper for five years and she traveled the world they do on in her years her final unfinished project was on aging pat worked in the san francisco chamber of commerce and she ran her own public relations firm and worked tirelessly and professionally to protect small businesses and neighborhoods in san francisco. throughout her career she received many awards and accolades from state senators, governors, the business community and city civic leaders including mayor leo around and the pat christiansen achievement award in san francisco and i would also like to give supervisor yee an oppor

with that i want to hand it over to supervisor peskin for his comments. >> supervisor peskin >> thank you chairman farrell. the chairman's strong words notwithstanding, i don't think this is about demonizing any person or any organization it i think this is really a conversation that is overdue about san francisco business tax policy. i was around in the days when san francisco actually had an alternative tax structure where we had a gross receipts tax and a payroll tax. i was one of the members of the board who had to settle the lawsuit that was brought against the city and county that gave us hundreds of millions of dollars of liability, and as a result of that settlement, we abandoned our gross receipts alternative and ended up with a payroll tax that none of us, whether jim lazarus from the chamber of commerce or progressive supervisor from the board of supervisors like i agree with chair farrell that we the payroll tax was a disincentive to drop growth in san francisco. in working with the comptroller's office in the city attorney's office, we tried to figure out a gross receipt

with that i want to hand it over to supervisor peskin for his comments. >> supervisor peskin >> thank you chairman farrell. the chairman's strong words notwithstanding, i don't think this is about demonizing any person or any organization it i think this is really a conversation that is overdue about san francisco business tax policy. i was around in the days when san francisco actually had an alternative tax structure where we had a gross receipts tax and a payroll tax. i was one of the members of the board who had to settle the lawsuit that was brought against the city and county that gave us hundreds of millions of dollars of liability, and as a result of that settlement, we abandoned our gross receipts alternative and ended up with a payroll tax that none of us, whether jim lazarus from the chamber of commerce or progressive supervisor from the board of supervisors like i agree with chair farrell that we the payroll tax was a disincentive to drop growth in san francisco. in working with the comptroller's office in the city attorney's office, we tried to figure out a gross receipt

the ordinance as supervisor peskin says would apply to booking services. which is basically those that collect a fee in connection with reservation or payment service. i think ms. goosen is correct that craigslist does not collect a fee with a booking service. i can't say vrbo's business model. >> thank you for the clarification, supervisor wiener. >> i asked the question, because i think it's important when regulating short-term rentals that we're regulating as broadly as possible and not regulating some companies and not other companies because different companis have different structures. but they are all facilitiating short-term rentals and for all the good reasons that we want to regulate them it should apply to all short-term rentals. this measure that this amended, that i voted for, to try to increase enforcement because we want people to comply with the law, to the extent that the amendments were to contract that and basically exempting out certain companies and focusing on other companies; that would be an issue for me. i would be interested in pe

if you have something else. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you. i wanted to apologize for not acknowledging the controller's office and add the role of a number of deputy advertising played and acknowledge bryan from congresswoman jackie spier's office i think that he has endeavored to bring this thing together and congresswoman spear and president obama administration god speed. >> for clarity who will be permitting the request to amend the legislation. >> the amendments madam president before you i have circulated them and also want to announce we shared all of these changes with supervisor cowen's staff that be aware of them and supportive of them but like to make a motion to put the amendments that are before you before us and make that motion. >> supervisor peskin has made a motion to amend seconded by supervisor tang colleagues without objection without objection the amendments passes unanimously and call roll. >> supervisor peskin supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor breed supervisor kim supervisor mar there are 7 i's

. >> commissioner kim h supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor peskin supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos commissioner london breed no supervisor campos supervisor cowen no commissioner farrell no there are 6ize with supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor cowen and supervisor farrell in december sent this charter amendment been submitted madam clerk please read public comment. >> at this time, members of the public may address the commission on items within the jurisdiction of the board. >> first speaker. >> thank you good morning, supervisors chinatown missionary officer as a national leader one must seek the prosperity in general benefits for all the people as custom and tradition come to a degrading downfall tragic disasters are trend flow across every continental the loss of peace of nature and the corruption of human heart the misconduct and corruption of human heart is caused by the loss of wholly religion this is volumes of money and family this is attracting people's attendance from the values of humanity of holiness to put an end t

with that i want to hand it over to supervisor peskin for his comments. >> supervisor peskin >> thank you chairman farrell. the chairman's strong words notwithstanding, i don't think this is about demonizing any person or any organization it i think this is really a conversation that is overdue about san francisco business tax policy. i was around in the days when san francisco actually had an alternative tax structure where we had a gross receipts tax and a payroll tax. i was one of the members of the board who had to settle the lawsuit that was brought against the city and county that gave us hundreds of millions of dollars of liability, and as a result of that settlement, we abandoned our gross receipts alternative and ended up with a payroll tax that none of us, whether jim lazarus from the chamber of commerce or progressive supervisor from the board of supervisors like i agree with chair farrell that we the payroll tax was a disincentive to drop growth in san francisco. in working with the comptroller's office in the city attorney's office, we tried to figure out a gross receipt

i'm malia cohen the chair to my right is vice chair supervisor wiener and to my left is supervisor peskin and our clerk is erica i'd like to thank phil jackson and jesse larson for broefrt i'd like to remind the members of the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind. please silence any devices that may sound off during the proceedings. items acted upon today will appear on the pr call item one >> an on those amending the ordinances now 10 61 irregularity the width of the sidewalks so dpw is the sponsor of the legislation and bruce is here welcome the floor is yours. >> pardon me if i swu up i don't do this very often. >> on screen this the board one 8429320 or the sidewalk changes around the assessor oversees block lot one a new residential and a semi commercial development june 4th city planning gave us a general plan con formation dpw got no objections from the city agencies or private lawsuit companies proposed ordinance and changes of sidewalk with various locations q 20 dash 820 map memorializing and a copy i said was approved on june 4th and that's it

i'm malia cohen the chair to my right is vice chair supervisor wiener and to my left is supervisor peskin and our clerk is erica i'd like to thank phil jackson and jesse larson for broefrt i'd like to remind the members of the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind. please silence any devices that may sound off during the proceedings. items acted upon today will appear on the pr call item one >> an on those amending the ordinances now 10 61 irregularity the width of the sidewalks so dpw is the sponsor of the legislation and bruce is here welcome the floor is yours. >> pardon me if i swu up i don't do this very often. >> on screen this the board one 8429320 or the sidewalk changes around the assessor oversees block lot one a new residential and a semi commercial development june 4th city planning gave us a general plan con formation dpw got no objections from the city agencies or private lawsuit companies proposed ordinance and changes of sidewalk with various locations q 20 dash 820 map memorializing and a copy i said was approved on june 4th and that's it

>> well, i don't think we've been asked to take action by supervisor peskin's office. we've been asked by his staff member and also by several of the people who are in favor of the measure to indicate by comments and other things as to whether or not we believe that the measure is on the right track, whether we would endorse it. it's not something that's going to be part of the ethics commission's bylaws or any part of us doing anything. so, i can say that just personally as one commissioner, i think supervisor peskin's on the right track in regard to where he's heading. there are some concerns that are pointed out both by our staff and other people by the interesting parties, that compromise could be reached out in order to reach the transparency so that someone doesn't lefrj their position as commissioner or as a san francisco official in any kind of improper way. there's a necessity for that and in my opinion, supervisor peskin is on the right track and is going in the right direction. >> i would only add to that, that i agree this is on the right track. i would lik

>> supervisor peskin. >> supervisor peskin did we file item 53 i. >> just to be clear 53 the hearing has been held and now closed thank you supervisor peskin madam clerk call our final 3:00 a.m. >> compromises the person's interested in the planning commission certification of a sitter on 16th street and 12 hundred stewart issued may 12th consistent of three hundred and 95 unions and retail use in two new buildings and is vehicular and bike parking with the open space and streetscape and improvements item 50 is the motion affirming the planning commission certification of environmental impact report for the proposed project item 51 the motion reversing the certification and item 52 to have the preparation for the reversal of the boards certification. >> thank you, madam clerk colleagues before us an appeal of the final environmental impact report for the project at 90116th street and 12 hundreds 17th street located in district 10 our consideration of the appeal involves the analysis of adequacy and crackcy and completeness the environmental impact report without objection we will pre