carrie goldberg, owner of ca goldberg. mr. matthew wood, vice president of policy and general counsel free press action. mr. daniel lyons, professor and associate dean of academic affairs, boston college law school. a nonresident senior fellow of the american enterprise institute. mr. eugene volokh, gary t. schwartz distinguished professor of law, ucla school of law. the honorable karen kornbluh, director of digital innovation and democracy initiative. and senior fellow of the german marshall fund of the united states. and dr. mary anne franks, professor of law and michael r. klein distinguished scholar, chair at the university of miami school of law, president and legislative tech policy director, cyber civil rights initiative. welcome to all of you and thank you for being here. we look forward to your testimony. we will recognize each of you for five minutes to provide your opening statement. there is a lighting system in front of you. you will see lights. it will start initially green, turn yellow when you have a minute lef

goldberg's answer is amazing and it shows the balances we have to strike. a small business exemption could prevent an increase in litigation and even strategic lawsuits against litigation, so there is danger there. we also think that big platforms can generate beneficial engagement, and small ones can cause harm, so that is why we would be careful about only attaching liability to the largest platforms and making sure that smaller ones cannot be held accountable. chairman doyle: ok, thank you. my time is up. i want to recognize the ranking member for five minutes. >> thank you very much for the panel. mr. volokh, twitter has a new ceo and his earliest statements indicate he is not a fan of the first amendment. twitter has expanded the scope of their private information policy to prohibit the sharing of private media, such as images or videos, without their consent. this is abuse of power by these companies to show that they are being arbiters of truth, however twitter goes on to say that they will take into consideration whether the images are publicly avai

goldberg was speaking to earlier. >> let me ask you this. you look at the car abouts that would -- look at the car veouts we have. [indiscernible] you are subject to liability. i don't hear those topics being suggested that my or your free speech is being limited in any way, so how is it limited when we apply it elsewhere? >> again, i would say i am not talking about limiting free-speech. when you have the lowering of the shield upon receipt of any request for injunctive relief -- >> let me ask you this question. let me just ask you this question. if you and i can be subject to these things, why can't big tech? >> they can be. the question is is that a better state of the world? the question is -- >> why is it not? >> because these platforms do provide -- these platforms do provide special benefits for people to communicate, and yet i think they should be held liable when they go beyond that.we recommend not taking away the shield upon simple receipt of a request for injunctive relief. some could be meritorious, some could not be. we do not

start with you, attorney goldberg. we have hr-3184 which attempts to remedy civil rights violations. i want to get your opinion on the importance of injunctions in these civil rights violations whether they are ongoing for a victim. your thoughts on damages. >> i think injunctive relief is important. the current standard is you can't enforce an injunction against a tech company because of section 230, but you can't include them as a defendant because of section 230. take my client, for example. she was the victim of extreme cyber stalking. her ex-boyfriend impersonated her and made bomb threats all around the country to jewish community centers. he was charged with 60 months in federal prison. a lot of the threats he was making were on twitter. he smuggled a phone into prison, got in trouble for it, got re-sentenced. twitter won't take that content down, even though it's -- it was the basis of his sentence and really very much related to why he was in trouble in the first place. i can't get an injunction against them.

carey goldberg, owner of ca goldberg, mr. matthew wood, vice-president of policy and general counsel free press action, mr. daniel liens, dean of academic affairs boston college law school, nonresident senior fellow american enterprise institute, mr. eugene balloch, distinguished professor of law, ucla school of law, the honorable karen, senior fellow of marshal fund of the united states and dr. maria ann franks professor of law and michael r. klein distinguished scholar, chair university miami school of law, policy director, cyber civil rights initiative, welcome all of you and thank you so much for being here. we want to look forward to your testimony, we will recognize each of you for five minutes to provide your opening statement. there's a lighting system there in front of you, you'll see lights that will start initially green and turn yellow when you have a minute left and when it turns red, it's time to wrap up your testimony. so we'll get started right away. ms. goldberg, you are recognized for five minutes. >> good a

we'll start with you attorney goldberg. we have hr-3184 which attempts to remedy civil rights violations and i want to get your opinion on the importance of injunctions in these civil rights violations when they're ongoing for a victim. and your thoughts on damages. >> so the -- i think injunctive relief is really important. the current standard is that you can't -- you can't enforce an injunction against a tech company because of section 230, but you can't include them as a defendant because of section 230. so take my client, for example, she was the victim of extreme cyberstalking. her ex-boyfriend impersonated her and made bomb threats all around the country to jewish community centers and he was charged with 60 months in federal prison. a lot of the threats he was making were on twitter. he smuggled a phone into prison, got in trouble for it, got resentenced and twitter won't take that content down. even though it's -- it was the basis of his sentence and really, you know, very much related to why he was in trouble in t

clara painted manfred goldberg. have you been well? the painted manfred goldberg. have you been well? , , , painted manfred goldberg. have you been well? , ,, .,, been well? the process was challenging- _ been well? the process was challenging. covid - been well? the process was challenging. covid meant i been well? the process wasl challenging. covid meant the sittings began virtually before they could finally meet. she sittings began virtually before they could finally meet.— could finally meet. she wanted not onl to could finally meet. she wanted not only to paint— could finally meet. she wanted not only to paint my — could finally meet. she wanted not only to paint my likeness - could finally meet. she wanted not only to paint my likeness but - could finally meet. she wanted not only to paint my likeness but she l only to paint my likeness but she tried _ only to paint my likeness but she tried to _ only to paint my likeness but she tried to get sort of into my soul, she tried — tried to get sort of into my soul, she tried to— tried to get sort of int

i have "the new york times" michelle goldberg, eric buller who follows fox news very closely and the editor of pressrun.media and cornell belcher. michelle, i understand the kind of jump in the media and on the internet to always say, well, didn't we know some of this? okay, so what? i'm curious, though, with an eye on the evidence what you think about the fact that the congress

carrie goldberg, owner of ca goldberg. mr. matthew wood, vice president of policy and general counsel free press action. mr. daniel lyons, professor and associate dean of academic affairs, boston college law school. a nonresident senior fellow of the american enterprise institute. mr. eugene volokh, gary t. schwartz distinguished professor of law, ucla school of law. the honorable karen kornbluh, director of digital innovation and democracy initiative. and senior fellow of the german marshall fund of the united states. and dr. mary anne franks, professor of law and michael r. klein distinguished scholar, chair at the university of miami school of law, president and legislative tech policy director, cyber civil rights initiative. welcome to all of you and thank you for being here. we look forward to your testimony. we will recognize each of you for five minutes to provide your opening statement. there is a lighting system in front of you. you will see lights. it will start initially green, turn yellow when you have a minute lef

we solved it, david plouffe, and michelle goldberg. thank you both, that is all on, this thursday, night the rachel maddow show right starts right now. >> good evening chris, thanks my friend, much appreciated. thanks for joining us this hour, when the day this is been. be true. turns out it was rudy. here's the front page at cnn.com right now. giuliani led fake electors' plot. here's "the washington post's" version of the that same front page story today. giuliani coordinated plan for trump electoral votes in states biden won. it was mr. giuliani, apparently. you know, you find a little thread of a story, you tug and you tug and you tug some more an one day you're like one more tug on the same thread and the whole sweater comes apart. today the whole sweater came apart and now we're sitting in a

a clerk to supreme court justice goldberg, a prosecutor in the department of justice, a member of the watergate prosecution team. i first met stephen breyer as a senator on the judiciary committee. he started off taking care of one of the subcommittees for teddy. then he became chief counsel during his tenure as ted's chairmanship of the judiciary committee. beyond his intellect and hard work and legal insight he was famous for biking across washington virtually every day for face-to-face meetings with the republican chief counsel, the ranking republican counsel. over breakfast they discussed what they would do for the country together. in those days we tried to do things together. that spirit stuck with me when it took over the judiciary committee as chair after senator kennedy's tenure. it was my honor to vote to confirm justice breyer to serve in the u.s. supreme court -- court of appeals first in 1980. 14 years later, 1994, i got to preside as chairman of the judiciary committee over the supreme court confirmation hearings. we were joking with another, did he ever think he would s

goldberg, a prosecutor in the department of justice, a member of the watergate prosecution team. i first met stephen breyer as a senator on the judiciary committee. he started off taking care of one of the subcommittees for teddy. then he became chief counsel during his tenure as ted's chairmanship of the judiciary committee. beyond his intellect and hard work and legal insight he was famous for biking across washington virtually every day for face-to-face meetings with the republican chief counsel, the ranking republican counsel. over breakfast they discussed what they would do for the country together. in those days we tried to do things together. that spirit stuck with me when it took over the judiciary committee as chair after senator kennedy's tenure. it was my honor to vote to confirm justice breyer to serve in the u.s. supreme court -- court of appeals first in 1980. 14 years later, 1994, i got to preside as chairman of the judiciary committee over the supreme court confirmation hearings. we were joking with another, did he ever think he would serve decades on the court an

soon afterwards, just go give our doll lobbed a helpless cohen castillo to make it to goldberg who finished 4th last season. i now in 14th with pressure mounting on coach florian co, felts now the a 10000 sports fans attending an indoor hockey game in the u. s. last night. new the forecast, a down pole. and on the 1st go scored by the home team. the hershey bez the rain then began teddy bears by the thousands, tens of thousands of them. the teddy bears toss is a kid's charity event held every year by the 2nd tier club in the state of pennsylvania. and the plays seem to like it to the final numbers aren't in yet, but organizes were confident they would surpass the last teddy total of nearly $45000.00 bez, for children in neat, $4500.00 or his reminder of our top story. ukraine faces the threat of a possible new invasion by russia as troops mass along its order. but you are a secretary of state. antony blanket has rejected. immediate sanctions saying, diplomacy needs to be given. another chance you're watching. the de leon is leih from berlin. up next is well, stories are mother. you can also

whoopi goldberg and cnn's jim acosta saying how dare you, grow up. come on, man. there entering our third year of the pandemic. bill maher and barry white are right here, can we please stop, start living our life? i hope so and i don't think the establishment is waking up, the regime that's greatly benefited them and they have high hopes will push through, a lot of policies with nothing to do with covid. they are not getting enough, they followed a on the and they might not going to product spaces so you still have people deranged about this but i do think it represents the middle of america waking up turning to pushback a breath of fresh air and a comedian can actually be funny and not just drunk, drunk narrative i appreciate him giving best but i think he speaks for a lot of people who are maybe not super political that up pushed on them and ready to rise up against it. >> blame the people fascinated and don't follow the rules, yes, it would happen overhead everybody got the vaccine. it would have been over. kennedy: you are over your skis. >> we are not asking

a locker to supreme court justice goldberg, a prosecutor in the department of justice, a member of the watergate prosecution team. i first met stephen breyer as a senator on the judiciary committee. he started off taking care of one of the subcommittees for teddy. then he became chief counsel during his tenure as ted's chairmanship of the judiciary committee. beyond his intellect and hard work and legal insight he was famous for biking across washington virtually every day for face-to-face meetings with the republican chief counsel, the ranking republican counsel. over breakfast they discussed what they would do for the country together. in those days we tried to do things together. that spirit stuck with me when it took over the judiciary committee as chair after senator kennedy's tenure. it was my honor to vote to confirm justice breyer to serve in the u.s. supreme court -- court of appeals first in 1980. 14 years later, 1994, i got to preside as chairman of the judiciary committee over the supreme court confirmation hearings. we were joking with another, did he ever think he would s

,a law clerk to supreme court justice goldberg, a prosecutor in the department of justice, a member of the watergate prosecution team. i first met stephen breyer as a senator on the judiciary committee. he started off taking care of one of the subcommittees for teddy. then he became chief counsel during his tenure, as ted's chairmanship of the judiciary committee. beyond his intellect and hard work and legal insight, he was famous for biking across washington virtually every day, for face-to-face meetings with the republican chief counsel, the ranking republican counsel. over breakfast, they discussed what they would do for the country together. in those days, we tried to do things together. that spirit stuck with me, when i took over the judiciary committee, as chair, after senator kennedy's tenure. it was my honor to vote to confirm justice breyer to serve in the u.s. supreme court -- the court of appeals first in 1980. and then 14 years later, 1994, i got to preside as chairman of the senate judiciary committee over the supreme court confirmation hearings. we were joking with one an

michelle goldberg right here, the school's ceo saying i don'tn think that offramp will exist. i think this is how our life will be for a while. that means forever, by the way, so our question tonight where the heck is republican governor of maryland larry hogan? joining me now is bethany mandel, montgomery county resident and editor at ricochet . bethany, liberals are beginning to kind of put up the white flag here. they're saying the political fallout and some are saying fall out with their own children. but why is larry hogan, who supposedly a middle of the road republican allowing far left county executives to destroy kids education two years into this i've been wondering for a long time i have been screaming for larry hogan to step in on any numbert ofhe issues in this county,um this county has gone so far to the left while the state has veered back on the on the ramp of normalcy. and you know, larry hogan wants to be president and i think what a lot of people loved i right what i think a lot of people loved about trump and love about the santas and now young ken is they f

a clerk to supreme court justice goldberg, a prosecutor in the department of justice, a member of the watergate prosecution team. i first met stephen breyer as a senator on the judiciary committee. he started off taking care of one of the subcommittees for teddy. then he became chief counsel during his tenure, as ted's chairmanship of the judiciary committee. beyond his intellect and hard work and legal insight, he was famous for biking across washington virtually every day, for face-to-face meetings with the republican chief counsel, the ranking republican counsel. over breakfast, they discussed what they would do for the country together. in those days, we tried to do things together. that spirit stuck with me, when i took over the judiciary committee, as chair, after senator kennedy's tenure. it was my honor to vote to confirm justice breyer to serve in the u.s. supreme court -- the court of appeals first in 1980. and then 14 years later, 1994, i got to preside as chairman of the senate judiciary committee over the supreme court confirmation hearings. we were joking with another, d

a clerk to supreme court justice goldberg, a prosecutor in the department of justice, a member of the watergate prosecution team. >> he served in all three branches of the government before he turned 40. and as he was a law clerk, a prosecutor in the department of justice, a member of the watergate prosecution team. i first met stephen breyer when i was a senator on the judiciary committee. and he started off as taking care of one of the subcommittees and then became chief counsel during his tenure as chairman of the judiciary committee. beyond his intellect and hard work and legal insight, he was famous for biking across washington virtually every day for a face-to-face meeting with republican chief counsel, the ranking republican counsel. over breakfast they discussed what they would do for the country together. in those days, we tried to do things together. that spirit stuck with me when i took over the judiciary committee as chair after senator kennedy's tenure. and it was my honor to vote to confirm justice breyer to serve in the united states supreme court under the court of app

in response to the filing on, nicholas goldberg wrote i don't understand how crowing over the deaths of others furthers useful debate or increases vaccination rates? but a few days later, goldberg's colleague published a column expressing the exact opposite, mocking anti-vaxxer's death is grueling but might be necessary. michael is with me now. he's also a pulitzer prize winner. michael, let's talk at the outset, you're not talking about the everyday people who sadly contract covid and die. you're talking about people with a platform, right? >> that's correct, michael. in my column, i made a distinction, i pointed out that the unvaccinated really fall in three categories. there are those who can't get vaccinated for legitimate reasons. small children, people with genuine medical contradictions of vaccination. then there's a certainly large group of people who have been duped into resisting the vaccine, duped by misinformation ands did information about the vaccine. and sort of nonsense about preserving our premiums in the face of this peal. real targets who are important here are tho

and michelle goldberg of the "new york times." "the new york times" columnist. sarah, late this afternoon we learned the biden administration is considering more than a dozen candidates to replace justice stephen breyer on the supreme court. the republican senator of mississippi made, raised some eye introduces. he made statements that raise someday eyebrows friday with his comments about president biden's vow to choose a black woman for the supreme court. take a listen. >> the irony is that the supreme court is at the very same time hearing cases about this sort of affirmative racial discrimination. >> yes. >> and while adding someone who is the beneficiary of this sort of quota, the majority of the court may be saying at large, it is unconstitutional. we'll see how the irony works out. >> now, we should note that republican senator lindsey graham who actually sits on the judiciary committee has said that he does not object to president biden's promise to nominate a black woman. given all that, are you concerned about the potential racialization of this nominat

just the right man is a member of the new york times editorial board and michelle goldberg is a -- at the new york times. they both join me now. jesse, i was really struck by the -- warning a very stark terms about the oppressiveness and particularly calling -- linking the republican party to authoritarian movements around the world. i imagine that was a debated turn of phrase. >> sure. i mean this is something that we talked about for years. it has taken a lot of us not only journalism, but among the american people a while to come to terms with what we are looking at here. i think it is really after the last 5 to 6 years, it is really indisputable that you have one party in a two party system that has turned openly and eagerly almost against democracy, and i met dense the basic functions of that democracy. so, i think the piece is written as much and sadness as it is in sort of you know, thumping anger. this is a sad moment for the country and one where i think we are at a point of -- reckoning -- needing to determine how we move forward, how do we, how do we build the democracy and

goldberg's case has been mild so far. >>> all right. she was compared with steve jobs. she claimed her blood testing st start-up was revolutionary. she is looking at years for defrauding investors.. full prescription-strength? reduces inflammation? thank the gods. don't thank them too soon. kick pain in the aspercreme. kim is now demonstrating her congestion. save it slslimeball. i've upgraded to mucinex. we still havave 12 hours to australia. mucinex lasts 12 hours, so i'm good. now move! kim, no! mucinex lasts 3x longer for 12 hours. hello, for the last few years, i've been a little obsessed with chasing the big idaho potato truck. but it's not like that's my only interest. i also love cooking with heart-healthy, idaho potatoes. always look for the grown in idaho seal. nicorette knows, quitting smoking is freaking hard. you get advice like: try hypnosis... or... quit cold turkey. kidding me?! instead, start small. with nicorette. which can lead to something big. start stopping with nicorette it's the most wonderful time of the year. it is all about t-mobile with their

people have no faith in democracy anymore. >> very quickly, jonah goldberg, can the january 6th come up with anything that would change republican minds? >> it remains to be seen. a lot of people did some very, very bad things trying to steal the election, and it just depends whether they can find the actual evidence, the smoking gun. if there are, in fact, videos of donald trump practicing his appeal to the mob to go home that have all sorts of damning stuff on it, that could be a big deal, but it just remains to be seen because a lot of this is baked in. i do want to say i think there are a lot of what i call closet normals in the republican party whose chief crime is just cowardice and not being willing to tell the truth rather than actually believing the full scope of the big lie nonsense. >> and that's what we're all hoping, looking for people to just speak the truth. >>> that's all we have for today, guys. thank you for watching. have a safe and healthy new year. we'll be back next week because if it's sunday, it's "meet the press." [ no audio ] on where donald trump was, what

no shortage of kind words from john stewart, whoopi goldberg. gilbert god free -- godfrey. bob saget was 65 years old >>> returning to the bronx where a fire killed 19 people. the investigation is under way right now they say it was space heater that started the whole thing. >> officials say it all likely stemmed from a malfunctioning space heater >> the five-alarm fire ripped through this bronx high-rise flames shooting out on the second and third floor >> karen making breakfast when it started >> i heard people screaming, help, help, help >> in this 19-story building >> damage was found throughout the building in every floor and stair well taking them out in cardiac and respiratory arrest >> the response was massive. roughly 200 firefighters, some pulling residents down ladders others tending to the injuried >> new york city's mayor calling it one of the worst fires in new york history >> the impact of this fire is going to really bring a level of pain and despair in our city the numbers are horrific >> dozens injured and transferred to five hospitals. the second fire wit

michelle goldberg, as always, thank you so much for being with us. we really appreciate it. >> thank you. >> great column. great discussion. >>> mika, i want to follow up on something mike said. he just talked about us being spoiled as a country and taking things for granted. i want to take everybody back to when covid started. we were told it would take two years, three years, five years, maybe even ten years for us to get the vaccine. we may never get a vaccine. we had that conversation on this program over and over again. it was done in a year's time. it was a modern scientific miracle. yes, we had a republican president that picked moderna, that picked pfizer, that picked the right companies. we had a democratic president that got that vaccine out. this is something, in normal times, in normal times, we would be celebrating this, instead of everybody going on, you know, their podcasts or their cable news shows or wherever and trying to divide the country. because this, again, modern miracle, we should just stop for a second, once in a while as a

and we're joined by michelle goldberg, an op-ed journalist for "the new york times." i think, as we take stock a year in, that's one lessen. and voters are not going to penalize republican party for this sort of antidemocratic thrust. the question is can that be changed and is it even worth changing? or should people think about the more meat and potatoes messaging that steers clear of that kind of thing? >> well, this is an existential crisis. so, i don't think you can hide from it. there's no question people are going to be drawing contrast with the republican opponents on health care, who gets tax cuts, gets taxes raised. but a lot of people who get nominatered going to be true believes in trump. and in those races, you can hang this on and say if you hand over control to republicans, all they're going to do is basically engage in retribution on kon donald trump's behalf. i think that picture is really important. because whether people say i want to save democracy or not, it will help a democratic turnout, we hope that will help. but with swing voters, we want them

people have no faith in democracy anymore. >> very quickly, jonah goldberg, can the january 6 committee come up with anything that would change republican minds? >> remains to be seen. a lot of people did some very, very bad things trying to steal the election, and it just depends on whether they can find the actual evidence, the smoking gun. if there are in fact videos of donald trump practicing his appeal to the mob to go home that have all sorts of damning stuff on it, that could be a big deal. but it just remains to be seen, because a lot of this is baked in. i do want to say i think there are a lot more what i call closet normals in the republican party whose chief crime is just cowardice and not being able to be willing to tell the truth rather than actually believing the full scope of the big lie nonsense. >> and that's what we're all hoping. looking for people to just speak the truth. that's all we have for today, guys. thank you for watching. have a safe and healthy new year. we'll be back next week, because if it's sunday, it's "meet the press." ♪♪ (soft music) hey dad, i'

i have "the new york times" michelle goldberg, eric buller who follows fox news very closely and the editor of pressrun.media and cornell belcher. michelle, i understand the kind of jump in the media and on the internet to always say, well, didn't we know some of this? okay, so what? i'm curious, though, with an eye on the evidence what you think about the fact that the congress has found more receipts that suggest more people around trump who were loyal to him, who agreed with his politics thought he was headed towards doing very bad things on the 6th? >> something i think that i would really like to know specifically is in one of those texts sean hannity says something along the lines of we can't lose the entire white house counsel's office. he's hinting, i think there, that trump is going to ask the white house counsel's office to do something that is going to cause them all to resign. so just knowing what those plans are specifically is really important -- >> michelle, let me just read that for your analysis. we have it up on the screen so people can see the evidence again, brand

people have no faith in democracy anymore. >> very quickly, jonah goldberg, can the january 6 committee come up with anything that would change republican minds? >> remains to be seen. a lot of people did some very, very bad things trying to steal the election, and it just depends on whether they can find the actual evidence, the smoking gun. if there are in fact videos of donald trump practicing his appeal to the mob to go home that have all sorts of damning stuff on it, that could be a big deal. but it just remains to be seen, because a lot of this is baked in. i do want to say i think there are a lot more what i call closet normals in the republican party whose chief crime is just cowardice and not being able to be willing to tell the truth rather than actually believing the full scope of the big lie nonsense. >> and that's what we're all hoping. looking for people to just speak the truth. that's all we have for today, guys. thank you for watching. have a safe and healthy new year. we'll be back next week, because if it's sunday, it's "meet the press." ♪♪ >>> good morning it's mo

man, i was on "the view" talking to whoopi goldberg. but by lunchtime the news alerts on my phone began to buzz. something was happening in the capitol, and we all know the rest of that sad and tragic story. a violent assault on our nation's capitol, driven by the big lie. ugly words, signs and symbols of racism and anti-semitism, an effort to stop the legal certification of an election and, in spite of those who want to hide, sadly january 6 really did happen. and we must face up to it. we cannot hide from history. january 6 happened, but here's the thing, january 5 also happened. georgia, a state in the old confederacy, sent a black man and a jewish man to the senate in one fell swoop. our nation has always had a complicated history, and i submit to you that here's where we are -- we're swinging from a moral dilemma. we are caught somewhere between january 5 and january 6. between our hopes and our fears. between bigotry and beloved community. and in each moment we the people have to decide which way are we going to go, and what are w

elected republicans, to your point, and their lack of leadership on this issue. >> you know, jonah goldberg, the conclusion i have come to and i feel like because you've started the news organization you've started it's a conclusion you've come to, a year later it's clear to me the information ecosystem in this country is broken and that's why we have 40% of the country that has just been spoon fed these lies. >> i think that's right. i think that the lesson of january 6 for me in some ways is how the power and the attraction of maintaining the right narrative has become more important than maintaining the right facts or speaking honestly about things. we saw this almost instantaneously on january 6 where we now know that, you know, my former fox colleagues, laura ingraham and sean hannity and others saw and recognized at face value that that mob was instigated by the president and by the -- and motivated by the lies that he had spread, and they were saying, this is terrible, don't do it, and call it off, but then almost immediately once they went on tv they started coming up with alternati

we're joined by "the new york times" michelle goldberg. michelle, your thoughts on the ruling and where we go from here? >> i think that headline you just showed, at least by adam serwer, really nailed it. what was alarming about this ruling beside its deviation from the plain language of the law, there's specific federal statute that authorizes osha to make emergency regulations when i believe the word is, when there's a new hazard. i don't see how anybody could define covid as anything else. they made up all these reasons why the covid vaccine doesn't apply. but again, what i think adam serwer gets at is both their questioning during the hearings on this and some of the language in the opinion itself suggests a kind of marination -- although they go out of their way saying we're not questioning the efficacy of the vaccine, there is a sense that this vaccine is a dangerous imposition on people that they all buy into. >> right. i stress this because so much of the language occludes the facts. the rule was just to get tested. and that's no

as he began his career in architecture, goldberg became gehry. in 1975 gehry married berta aguilera, his second wife. they had two boys. boys.he had two daughters from a previous marriage. it was in the 1970s when he renovated his home using industrial materials that he first gained attention on his front yard. >> what did you think when the tour buses came along? >> go away and leave me alone. >> reporter: he would prefer that his buildings draw the attention, like the guggenheim museum. his free-flowing forms have left an impression hasocipline.n the >> oh, frank gehry, you're a genius. >> reporter: the impression, thanks to the simpsons, is that a lot of your designs are extemporaneous, or even unplanned, and that is not true. >> no. so later in this interview, i'm going to show you the number of models and the iterations on a project and how long it took to get to the conclusion. ♪♪ >> reporter: playful, light, surprising, graceful, his creations invite the eye, draw you in, embrace you. that personal touch has won him acclaim all over th

as you can see, what back in boxes and doing the show remotely even whoopi goldberg called out from the view today after testing positive for covid. we've heard about all the call out of the big companies, but often times it hurts the most at smaller businesses like supermarket in miami, where today the owner was running a cash register. if someone calls out, do you then have to fill in. i'm have another person to fit in. i have to do it. >> how often does that happen this week the last 3 weeks, every every day. yes, >> this is where all the shipping jamie mcdonnell is having the same problem. he owns an environmental testing company and landscaping service with about a 1000 employees. have there been a lot of people calling out sick. a lot of people mcdonnell encourages its employees who are really sick to stay home but says some have taken advantage. one person. >> try to tell h r that they had covid and they sent him a copy of a report and when hr zoomed into the report through the text message. it actually was even that same person with someone else's result. i try to make intellige

remembering him as a lovely human and there was no shortage of kind words from jon stewart, whoopi goldberg, and gilbert godfried in a statement, his family said he loved his fans, performing live, and bringing people from all walks of life together with laughter bob saget was 65 years old >>> breaking overnight, novak djokovich is staying in australia for now after a successful appeal of his visa being cancelled. a federal judge ordered djokovich passport be returned and the tennis star be allowed to leave the hotel where he was being obtained the judge declared he was present with his lawyers at the time of the ruling djokovich was unvaccinated, and his lawyers argued positive test result last month led to the australian open's organizing group, tennis australia, giving him a medical exemption. >>> u.s. diplomats are holding high stakes talks with russia today with the threat of a russian invasion ukraine has been sidelined from conversations this week. monica alba is at the white house with the latest. >> reporter: ukraine on edge ahead of major talks between the u.s. and russia. >> we'r

only so much, absent the consent of these few players, that we can do. >> jesse wegman and michelle goldberg, thank you both. >> thank you. >> thank you. >>> coming up, there are big questions about what's actually going to happen now the kids are back in school during the age of omicron. we'll talk about what answers are beginning to get with one of the best education reporters in the country. ith one of the best education rorepters in the country. i see trees of gren ♪ ♪ red roses too ♪ ♪ i see them bloom for me and you ♪ (music) ♪ so i think to myself ♪ ♪ oh what a wonderful world ♪ do you struggle with occasional nerve aches in your hands or feet? try nervivenerve relief from the world's #1 selling nerve care company. nervive contains alpha lipoic acid to relieve occasional nerve aches, weakness and discomfort. try nervivenerve relief. for people living with h-i-v, keep being you. and ask your doctor about biktarvy. biktarvy is a complete, one-pill, once-a-day treatment used for h-i-v in certain adults. it's not a cure, but with one small pill, biktarvy fights h-i-v to

two remembering him as a lovely human there was no shortage of kind words from jon stewart, whoopi goldberg, and steve martin gilbert godfried shared a photo of the two of them as well he loved his fans, performing live, and bringing people from all walks of life together with laughter he was 65 years old. >>> a tragic scene in the bronx after an apartment fire killed at least 19 people, nine of them children 30 more were hospitalized. a malfunctioning electric space heater started the blaze around 200 firefighters responded. >> and to say thank you to the men and women who went in this building some of these firefighters, their -- their oxygen -- their oxygen tanks were empty and they still pushed through the smoke >> nbc's kathy park has details from the scene >> reporter: officials say that this is one of the deadliest fires in new york city history it happened just before 11:00 in this 19 story apartment building behind me. at one point 200 firefighters were on the scene. at this time we can tell you 19 people are confirmed dead, nine children, ten adults dozens also suffering from smok

wabc meteorologist lee goldberg says the storm is starting to come into focus. >> here's what i think with snow totals. the bless chance of seeing a foot or more is on the east end of long island. i do think the heart of the storm is over southeastern new england then this difficult area and what i have deticked here is the city straddling three to six-inch total and 6 to 12-inch total as we go into the storm. >> expected to have less of an impact in washington, d.c. or philadelphia. we'll get the full picture from accuweather in less than ten minutes. >>> the other big story, the retirement of supreme court justice stephen breyer. >> after nearly three decades on the bench, the official announcement expected to come today setting up a confirmation battle over his replacement there's already a front-runner, em nguyen has the latest. good morning. >> reporter: good morning. president biden and justin breyer are expected to make that official announcement in a joint appearance at the white house today. longtime supreme court justice stephen breyer is expected to announce today his retir

when somebody like elizabeth warren and woochy goldberg has three vaccinations and masks and they still get this variant, they have to change because they don't have credibility. jesse: do you have think we'll ever hear from the left? you were right. you were right about keeping schools open. you were right about the crime wave. you were right about the fact that you can be vaxxed and still catch it and transmit it? it sounds like i need to hear that. does that make me a petty person? >> yes, it does. jesse, when reality is too hard to bear for the left, they revert to fantasy. the reality is too much to admit so the fantasy is january 6, january 6, armed insurrection, worst thing since the civil war. they can't handle the reality they created. so they escape on the fantasy they voiced on the rest of us. jesse: if they do admit it, i want an apology face to face. victor davis hanson, there is no apologies coming but i'll wait as long as it takes. >> you have got a long wait. jesse: can kamala harris be removed as vice president after what she said this week? that's next. this is elodia.

artist, portrait and subject, clara drummond painted manfred goldberg. have you been well? the process was challenging. covid meant the sittings began virtually before they could finally meet. hello, manfred! she wanted not only to paint my likeness, but she tried to get sort of into my soul, she tried to paint me heart and soul, and looking at my portrait, people tell me that they can see it in the way she has painted my eyes. those eyes saw the brutality of nazi labour camps, where manfred was sent with his family. one day his younger brother herman was taken by ss guards, manfred never saw him again. he did describe it as hell on earth, and it was very hard for me to imagine what it must have been like. it was very harrowing, but i feel that was really important to go there and to realise how dark it had been in order to realise what a bright light manfred is. so much is in the detail of each portrait. aric hirsch rests his hand on his left arm, the arm that bears his auschwitz number. and lily abert is painted with a gold pendant which she hid in the heel of a shoe whil

artist, portrait and subject, clara drummond painted manfred goldberg. have you been well? the process was challenging. covid meant the sittings began virtually before they could finally meet. hello, manfred! she wanted not only to paint my likeness, but she tried to get sort of into my soul, she tried to paint me heart and soul, and looking at my portrait, people tell me that they can see it in the way she has painted my eyes. those eyes saw the brutality of nazi labour camps, where manfred was sent with his family. one day his younger brother herman was taken by ss guards, and manfred never saw him again. he did describe it as hell on earth, and it was very hard for me to imagine what it must have been like. it was very harrowing, but i feel that was really important to go there and to realise how dark it had been in order to realise what a bright light manfred is. so much is in the detail of each portrait. aric hirsch rests his hand on his left arm, the arm that bears his auschwitz number. and lily abert is painted with a gold pendant which she hid in the heel of a shoe

artist, portrait and subject, clara drummond painted manfred goldberg. have you been well? the process was challenging. covid meant the sittings began virtually before they could finally meet. hello, manfred! she wanted not only to paint my likeness, but she tried to get sort of into my soul, she tried to paint me heart and soul, and looking at my portrait, people tell me that they can see it in the way she has painted my eyes. those eyes saw the brutality of nazi labour camps, where manfred was sent with his family. one day his younger brother herman was taken by ss guards, and manfred never saw him again. he did describe it as hell on earth, and it was very hard for me to imagine what it must have been like. it was very harrowing, but i feel that was really important to go there and to realise how dark it had been in order to realise what a bright light manfred is. so much is in the detail of each portrait. aric hirsch rests his hand on his left arm, the arm that bears his auschwitz number. and lily abert is painted with a gold pendant which she hid in the heel of a shoe