bush, donald trump got that. -- donald trump never got that. you need to put together a coalition, which donald trump is incapable of crating. there needs to be liz cheney. i do think she is going to succeed in her primary. i feel good about that. [applause] what she understands is she has political capital and she is using it. a lot of people have political capital who have not used it and we have got to get them to -- if we say, yes, good, use it. send them a note. do something on social media saying, thank you for speaking out and doing this. i have had people, numbers who are out there, not saying much about trump, but going thank you for saying that, or thank you for agreeing with this. they need support. >> from the center right to the far left over there. >> michael, we have the microphones to give people to ask the questions. thank you for pointing that out. >> thank you. >> sorry. who is talking? >> for the panel, my question is simple. you are faced with the republican party and i cannot even tell you what it stands for. did you want

god bless president trump. [applause] ♪

he became a longtime trump employee and remains a true trump loyalist. the trump administration and scavino served as director social media and for its final two years, as deputy chief of staff or communications. as the select committee reports notes, then scavino was with then president trump on january 5th and sixth. he spoke with president trump several times on january 6th. i was with the president when many urged him to help stop the violence of the capitol. he was always in all relevant times a trump and white house insider. social media as a means of monitoring that is shaping trends, was dan can -- scavino's core business. reports tell us that dan scavino and his team honored extremists social media sites, modern -- to shape the public perceptions. there is in short a great deal of highly important information that than scavino has that the select committee needs to know. i want to focus on one aspect of, that the dance can be no could tell us about what then president trump thought was likely to happen on january 6th. the president noted the ral

bush, donald trump got that. -- donald trump never got that. you need to put together a coalition, which donald trump is incapable of crating. there needs to be liz cheney. i do think she is going to succeed in her primary. i feel good about that. [applause] what she understands is she has political capital and she is using it. a lot of people have political capital who have not used it and we have got to get them to -- if we say, yes, good, use it. send them a note. do something on social media saying, thank you for speaking out and doing this. i have had people, numbers who are out there, not saying much about trump, but going thank you for saying that, or thank you for agreeing with this. they need support. >> from the center right to the far left over there. >> michael, we have the microphones to give people to ask the questions. thank you for pointing that out. >> thank you. >> sorry. who is talking? >> for the panel, my question is simple. you are faced with the republican party and i cannot even tell you what it stands for. did you want

trump is not the cancer in the party. trump -- it has metastasized way beyond him. i know i am a dark guy, you're going to throw something at me. maybe my vantage point is skewed. i hear from these people every day. it is not changing. the fever is not breaking anytime soon. to everything miles and barbara has said we need to do to support the good guys, liz cheney wonderful. i hope she wins. i don't think there is any way she could win a republican primary in that state. adam couldn't have survived a republican party primary. everyone in this room would help him, as what i, but we have also got to be -- wake up and be realistic. i am not done, but i am done for now. [laughter] >> let me just say something real quick and i have got a quick question for joe and miles. i think donald trump can never be commander in chief again. it is not just what happened on january 6 but everything that happened on election day that disqualifies him from not having any sort of power. with that being said, the two are more friendly to the third party option. there is a danger with th

on, december 19, 2020, trump urged viewers to fight for trump. january 6 was 2.5 cents -- 2.5 weeks off. president trump retweeted a video titled "how to steal an election," among other things, it argued covid-19 was created to ensure that trump would lose the election. here's that one. qanon had retweeted that one by the time that trumped it. we would like to hear what president trump's director of social media has to say about that. trump's extremist followers on the donald, what do they make of that? to join in a wild protest on january 6? some of his followers took it as marching orders. mr. scavino's camino had every reason to know that they would be violent. mr. scavino was well aware of what his boss wanted. to the extent that the users fight like donald trump. he sent out a video himself that a user of the same site understood to be "literal war drums." president trump had been president for a full four years with dan scavino and his side. they knew exactly what they were doing. the select committee needs to hear directly from dan scavino

attorneys for donald trump allege in a lawsuit against "the new york times" and trump's niece mary trump orr the 2018 reporting on his tax records that "the new york times" communicated with mary trump via a burner phone so that was an information that he monitored very closely. i wonder if we get passed the meaning of does not know what a burner phone is this bigger question of on instructing the communications that the president had for nearly eight hours. what are the questions around that? >> the most significant event this week is the opinion of the federal judge, judge carter, that almost certainly donald trump and maybe john eastman violated federal law, committed a felony with respected to the january 6 insurrection. i think that's a profound opinion by a federal judge that dereceivers attention both by the january 6 committee here in congress maybe more importantly by the attorney general of the united states. >> the judge as you just said they likely committed felonies. he also goes on to say that not holding him accountable would bring about another january 6. we know what don

if trump runs he will not be challenged. to barbara's other point trump is a cancer. trump is not the cancer in the party. trump is the cancer but it has metastasize way beyond him. and again i know i am a dork irishman you're all going to throw something at me before we are out of here. be my vantage point is skewed because i hear from these people every day. it is not -- it is not changing -- the fever is not breaking any time soon. do everything at miles and barbara say we need to do to goodrt the good guys, the gals liz cheney wonderful i hope she wins. i don't that there's any way she can win a republican primary and that states. i hope she does. my good friend adam can singers not running again. adam could not have survived the republican party primary. if you are running everyone in this room would help him as would i. but we have also got to be -- wake up and be realistic i am donewa. i'm not done but i'm done for now. [laughter] post on that what we say something really quick and then i have a question for joe and miles. donald trump can never ever be command

trump endorsed him for reelection. actually, in the senate election happening in that state, for the open sentences. he started trailing in the polls to another republican in the contest, trump withdrew that endorsement, just took it back, because it was not panning out in georgia, trump endorsed former republican senator david perdue against incumbent them republican governor brian kemp. and just for one reason, right? because trump believes kemp and raffensperger, too conservative republicans, did not do enough to help him steal the 2020 election. ahead of trump's disappointing rally in georgia last weekend, purdue was narrowly defeated for reelection in 2020. he said quote, in my election, in the presidents election, they were stolen. he is reported saying if he were elected he would decertify the 2020 georgia election results. i don't even think that is a thing. but again, it is not clear that this rhetoric is enough. a fox news poll earlier this month found purdue trailing kemp by 11 points, despite his embrace of

trump is not the cancer in the party. trump -- it has metastasized way beyond him. i know i am a dark guy, you're going to throw something at me. maybe my vantage point is skewed. i hear from these people every day. it is not changing. the fever is not breaking anytime soon. to everything miles and barbara has said we need to do to support the good guys, liz cheney wonderful. i hope she wins. i don't think there is any way she could win a republican primary in that state. adam couldn't have survived a republican party primary. everyone in this room would help him, as what i, but we have also got to be -- wake up and be realistic. i am not done, but i am done for now. [laughter] >> let me just say something real quick and i have got a quick question for joe and miles. i think donald trump can never be commander in chief again. it is not just what happened on january 6 but everything that happened on election day that disqualifies him from not having any sort of power. with that being said, the two are more friendly to the third party option. there is a danger with th

adviser to former president trump spoke at the cpac in florida. this is 20 minutes. >> ladies and gentlemen, please welcome formerredded a viez viedor to president -- adviser to former president trump, kimberly guilfoyle ♪♪ >> hello hello. nothing former about it care and national finance chair to the greatest president this country has ever seen, president donald j. trump the puppets all great to be with you here today those of you that are watching for cpac and live it every single year. it's an incredibly important in time of political history. we are all witnessing it. we need to be a part of it and not passive observers. but is because of patriots each and every one of you in this room. together we will make america great again. [applause] to mrs. president trump? [applause] >> like every minute of every day. wake up and you go to bed. i miss him. i just want to say pop quiz, the answer is trump was right about everything. he was trump and was right when he talked about spying on his campaign. he was right when he said the deep state was

he documents the committee sought from the trump white house, trump sued to try to block them, and i don't think we know what is inhose documents yet. i am sure the january 6 committee will get around to telling us very soon, but the question here is really, what did clarence thomas know and we did he know it? when did clarence thomas know that hisife potentially implicated in the january 6 attack? and ihe knew that, did he obviously cannot sit on a case involving an investigation into the january 6 attack. juan: could you talk in general about justice thomas's record, this dissent in the case not necessarily out of the ordinary for how he has dealt with cases in the past. >> that's right. if i did not know about ginni thomas's involvement, still would not be surprised by the vote that clarence thomas cast in that one case because he consistently has been a strong opponent of voting rights laws. he has wanteto go much further. he is the support of a doctrine that would essentially allow state legislatures to ignore their state constitutions when passing election laws. he is a huge pr

trump's lawyer. if you get a chance, would you please give me a call? have a few things i'd like to talk over with you. maybe we can get this thing fixed up. you know, i really think it's a shame that republicans sort of were put in this kind of situation, and i think there might be a nice way to resolve this for everybody. so give me a call, bill. i'm on this number, any time, doesn't matter. okay? take care, bye. >> thompson: when he said, "we're republicans in this together," what do you take that to mean? >> well, i think they believe that they can pick off elections officials, republicans, who are concerned about their future political prospects and, you know, work with these folks to overturn an election, which is despicable. i think every elected official in the republican party who remains silent is aiding and abetting this. they all know this is wrong. they tell me that, but then they're silent. >> thompson: and what happens to this country if, moving forward, nobody has faith in our electio

trump. he said i don't care one way or another what happens in ukraine. >> would you support the no-fly zone? 15 seconds, yes or no. >> we should not have american pilots flying in ukraine. what we should be doing is providing the mix from poland --migs from poland that present zelenskyy required. that is peace through strength. we need to make sure they have the weapons they need to defend ukraine. colleen: we are sticking with ukraine. i have a 32nd follow-up for you, mr. mandel. you are endorsed by congressman hawthorne who called ukrainian , president zelenskyy a thug. do you agree? >> i fundamentally disagree. i think the thug is vladimir putin. people forget he was the kgb station chief in east germany when the wall fell. the kgb station was surrounded and he was embarrassed for his life and mother russia, and he hated president reagan and hated us. everyone watching at home, and us putin hates us and america , and he is the enemy. >> mr. gibbons, jd vance has said your response to ukr

and then a president trump policy. is that how it looked to you? it's probably as good a description as any and it's kind of confusing because the trump administration policy the president's official policy was actually pretty strong. it was a continuation of the obama policy. i thought that was a very good policy in terms of supporting ukraine and helping ukraine move forward to become the kind of partner. that would be best for the united states. that's what they wanted, you know to fight corruption develop their economy improve their democracy and and their security, of course, so we had a strong and a robust relationship with ukraine particularly after 2014 and the revolution of dignity and the russian actions in return when they grabbed crimea illegally and attack the dome boss area in in the east so trump the trump administration continued that strong policy and in one way, he actually even strengthened it which is that there had been some discussion under the obama administration that share, you know transferrin

trump's whole bit is trolling. he trolls the media and liberals, and his disciples have picked up the mantle, like florida congressman matt gaetz, the only person on earth, this is interesting, whose funko pop would have a smaller head. [ laughter ] gaetz appeared at the rally and once again floated an idea he's pitched before, to make trump speaker of the house if republicans win the midterms in november but trump did not have much of a reaction >> give us the ability to fire nancy pelosi, take back the majority, impeach joe biden. and i'm going to nominate donald trump for speaker of the united states house of representatives! [ cheers and applause >> thank you very much thank you, everybody well, that was interesting [ laughter ] >> seth: he sounds like a dad whose teenager just made him watch "euphoria" for the first time [ laughter ] "well, that was very interesting. hey, i'm going to come to school with you tomorrow. nope, for the whole day. so, regardless of what happens with trump himself, trumpism is very

, saying trump's guilty of crimes. so will ownership won't there be an indictment? my legal breakdown you have for you tonight, that's coming up later. have for you tonight, that's coming up later. to be a thriver with metastatic breast cancer means asking for what we want. and need. and we need more time. so, we want kisqali. women are living longer than ever before with kisqali when taken with an aromatase inhibitor or fulvestrant in postmenopausal women with hr+, her2- metastatic breast cancer. kisqali is a pill that's significantly more effective at delaying disease progression versus an aromatase inhibitor or fulvestrant alone. kisqali can cause lung problems, or an abnormal heartbeat, which can lead to death. it can cause serious skin reactions, liver problems, and low white blood cell counts that may result in severe infections. tell your doctor right away if you have new or worsening symptoms, including breathing problems, cough, chest pain, a change in your heartbeat, dizziness, yellowing of the skin or eyes,

but, his wife ivanka trump, trump's daughter, was there all day. she was one of the people kind of running in and out of the oval office, getting stuff, he would potentially have some visibility over that, then more broadly, the committee is looking not only into the day, but to the run up of january 6th. jarred was one of those advisers, who was involved in discussions from election day on as to what steps to take or not take when it came to try to overturn the results of a free and fair election. yes, reminder, the president's daughter ivanka trump was with him at the white house, and though she has not sat down for a single television or print interview since they left office, she has made sure it has been leaked out to the media, that she was trying hard to get her father to do the right thing. she is welcome to come join us on the 11th hour, any night to discuss it. actually, luke, joyce, thank you so much for joining us. and starting us off on this busy night. coming up, russia claims its reducing forces near kyiv, the pentagon warns that the

early, and again harp our partner trump to become president. help our partner trump. that is tonight's last word, tomorrow night at this hour we will be joined by the washington post bob woodward with his new reporting on clarence thomas's wife's communication with the white house, and the seven and a half hour gap in the presidential phone logs of january six. bob woodward joins us tomorrow night, the 11th hour with stephanie ruhle, starts now. e, starts now. tonight, seven hours and 37 minutes missing. logs, given to the january six committee show that gap in the former president's phone records. was there a burner phone? then, cautious optimism over ukraine. russia talks dialing back from kyiv, as the shelling continues, the west is skeptical. saying, the jet west -- and that so-called don't say gay bill, now law in florida. what is actually a legal now, as the 11th hour gets underway on this tuesday night. good evening once again, i'm stephanie ruhle. we are tracking significant developments on the war in ukraine, tonight. our first story, the house investigation

on trump is - [ laughter ] i can't do it. >> announcer: this has been "trump is right. [ laughter and applause >> seth: the -- the house select committee investigating the january attack on the capitol issued a subpoena last week for donald trump jr. and his fiance, kimberly guilfoyle the good news is she can do it from home. they can still hear her. [ laughter ] new york mayor eric adams announced last week that he is lifting the city's vaccine requirement for indoor entertainment venues and said, "this is truly an arnold schwarzenegger moment we'll be back. okay, but just to refresh your memory when he came back, he killed, like, a ton of people. [ audience groans ] [ laughter ] guess we refreshed everyone's memory [ laughter ] according to a new study, the top so-called unusual phobia for new jersey residents is the fear of long words, which is just any word longer than "oh!" [ laughter ] organizers of the oscars have announced lady gaga and kevin costner will be presenters at this month's ceremony, so if you liked "yellowstone" and you liked "house of gucci," i'd love to meet you

he became a long-time trump employee and remains a true trump loyalist. the trump administration dan scavino served as director of social media and final two years as deputy chief of staff for communications. as the select committee report notes dan scavino was with then president trump on january 5 and 6. he spoke with president trump by phone several times on january 6 and was with the president when many urged him to help stop the violence at the capitol. he was always at all relevant times a trump and white house insider. social media is a means of monitoring the shaping trends was dan scavino's core business. reports tell us that dan scavino and his team monitored extremist social media sites, monitored trends on social media, and used extremist social media sites to shape public perceptions. there is, in short, a great deal of highly important information that dan scavino has that the select committee needs to know. i want to focus on one aspect of that. what dan scavino could tell us about what then president trump thought was likely to happen on j

trump. deterrents. he talked nato into increasing his spending, even he was attacked as a russian operative who are undermining nato, no he was fed up with nato. and iran didn't in a pot, they feared, trump, because trump was destroying iran, he spoked iran -- choked iran, little rocket man in north korea he was behaving himself too, we could go on and on, for all attacks on donald trump, he was a foreign policy genius, sorry, john bolton, you blew it. i have a book, here, he became an activist, a worldwide figure that soviet union attempted to silence, he was asked, what do you think about this, i want to do something on this program we can't do on many others, we have a long forming program, putin said biggest attract of 20 century was the destruction of soviet union. he doesn't want to bring back communist ideology, he sees himself as filling the shoes of peter the great, and catherine the great and stalin. whether it is poland, he sees these like a czar, all russian lands, he sees bringi

of course, that the finds trump actions on this. the ginni thomas texts that you have revealed are exclusively going back and forth between mark meadows and virginia thomas. we see jared kushner's name brigitte mentioned in their. jared kushner clearly going to be asked by the committee, what about your communications with the virginia thomas? so there's conceivably several other people, within the trump white house, who will have these kind of communications with virginia thomas that may or may not be revealed. >> that indeed -- bob costa and i checked on jarred and talk to a spokesman for him, and he indicated that he didn't recall getting anything on this. we'll see. as you know so well, this is about the perception of the honest functioning of government, all branches. this is, as my colleague bob costa calls it, a dangerous, looming entanglement between justice clarence thomas and his wife, and it needs to be explained. we have a system, thank god, -- used to always say, the truth emerges. sometimes it takes a long time. i thin

it's a trump state of the union. you get the shot of the president, the vice president, and the speaker. >> the state of our union is stronger than ever before. >> (cheering and applauding) >> we know that political media analyzes every eye roll, every decision to stand or not stand, to clap or not clap. so she knows every eye is on even her most subtle gesture. >> we will never let socialism destroy american healthcare. >> (cheering and applauding) >> you could just sense pelosi feeling tighter and angrier and just watching him perform. all of that is kind of coming out, you know, in the house chamber. and it's nancy pelosi's chamber. she's the speaker of the house. >> here tonight is a special man, beloved by millions of americans. rush limbaugh, thank you for your decades of tireless devotion to our country. >> (cheering and applauding) >> rush limbaugh. this conservative radio host, who, of course, had been attacking nancy pelosi for a long time. >> so, you know, with pelosi, there's stupid and then there's botox

trump around 1992. he worked for him for many years , first at the trump international golf club and then ask director of social media for his 2016 presidential campaign. then ex-white house deputy chief of staff for communications and on his 2020 campaign. and later on efforts to reverse the election results, which former vice president mike pence has denounced as un-american. according to many published reports, mr. scavino worked closely with mr. trump to use social media to spread lies regarding nonexistent election fraud and to inflame a violent, angry mob. for example, one twitter account priced a false report alleging election of fraud, treating -- tweeting, "a great report. big purchase on washington dc on january 6. be there. it will be while." this committee has reason to believe that doing so provided mr. savino with explicit advance warning of the violence that was to occur on january 6. mr. scavino may have shared these warnings of violence before january 6. he attended several meetings wit

trump/putin axis. take a listen. >> listen, i never give the former president advice. so he can talk about what he wants to talk about. i am interested to hear what happens with hunter biden, though, and the federal investigation into him and i imagine that we'll be learning more about that. so we'll see. sounds pretty serious. >> i don't know if he has dirt on biden. if he does, he should reveal it. >> jay. >> i think what you're hearing is those gop senators understand that what trump has done in trying to move the message to hunter biden away from vladimir putin. they still believe that that is a winning play and strategy for them that what really works for the electorate is a war against other americans. that's something pat buchanan had insight into in the 90s where he said communism isn't over. i think they recognize that what donald trump was doing was very beneficial for them. that's kind of what ron desantis has been doing. it's no coincidence that he signed this don't say gay bill during this

the nature of a donald trump republican party. that lawsuit against clinton, one analyst called a press release, i will call it a platform, right? the republican party does not have a platform. they did not adopt one. but i think what is in that lawsuit is essentially how donald trump will run for president again. it shows the emptiness of today's republican party, compared to the responsible sober leadership of a joe biden lead democratic party. >> joe, thank you as always for spending your time soon your weekend with us. david, you're staying with me. >> next, the gop attacks on judge jackson, and why is it more about the state republican party than the two about the supreme court nominee herself? we're gonna take you back to lviv, the western ukrainian city under siege from russian rockets today. an update, just ahead. an we gotta tell people that liberty mutual customizes car insurance so you only pay for what you need, and we gotta do it fast. [limu emu squawks] woo! new personal record, limu! only pay for what you need. ♪

exchange between trump and ukraine during the summer of 2019 where trump held up $250 million in security assistance so that ukraine could find the hillary clinton server that was apparently hidden in ukraine or find out what hunter biden's income derived in ukraine was very damaging to the new zelensky government. because of our extensive campaign through 2020, zelinski and ukrainian government could not really develop a good bilateral relationship with the united states. i think putin is essentially waiting for the campaign to be over and i think you would have tested trump at that time. as i've said before, i think russian forces would've invaded in kn kristen: you said trump barely knew anything about ukraine. like, how so, examples? ambassador bolton: one example with regard to finland, he once asked john kelly, his chief of staff at the time if finland was part of russia. he didn't understand the history of ukraine, he didn't understand the independence over the last 30 years, he didn't understand the strategic issues at stake, and he didn't care about any of it. he cared about the

trump's daily diary. at 1:21 p.m. the president met with his valet, which signals a return to the oval office. the mob breached the capitol just after 2:00 p.m. in the next entry isn't until 4:03, when mr. trump went to the rose garden to record a video for supporters. >> we have to have peace. so go home. we love you. you're very special. >> reporter: the phone logs pick up again that night, when mr. trump had at least 11 calls between 6:54 and 11:41 p.m. >> and robert joins us now. all right. burner phones. i mean, what is president trump saying about all this? >> his spokesperson told us he had nothing to do with the records. trump himself told us he doesn't even know about the phrase "burner phones," has never used burner phones. but that statement's been called into dispute today by john bolton, his former national security adviser, who told us trump behind the scenes used that phrase many times in conversation. >> it's just extraordinary. and so is the committee looking at this use of burner phones and what they

within to the trump school of grammar. you are the leading with him who is standing for america's constitutional governance at the press piece. the majority knows biden and the left is attempting the greatest heist of our history. that's from someone that doesn't have access to the best information available but something entirely dimptd coming from someone with access to the truth. this one on november 19th. quote, sounds like sidney and her team are getting inundated with everyday of fraud. make a plan. release the kraken and save us from the left taking america down. now crazier than fox. january 10th after the deadly insurrection text this, quote, we are living through what feels like the end of america. most of us are disgusted with the vp. and are in listening mode to see where to fight with the teams. those that attack the capital are not representative of our great team of patriots for djt. why does ginni thomas matter? >> right. the text have presented an issue for debate for the committee. they have had these for

because putin feared donald trump. putin knew in trump said it, he would do. weakness invites chaos and carnage. donald trump didn't need, after 4 years of his presidency, he made america energy independent and an exporter of energy. that's a big factor in all of this. without a doubt biden's disastrous withdraw from afghanistan emboldened every dictator around the world. i said it would. i wish i was wrong. day 198. wednesday 2 monday days. joe biden turned the page. never mentioned them. the media mob never mentions americans left behind want green card holders left behind. our afghan allies abandoned and stabbed in the back. abandoned all by joe biden. if joe biden were a descent leader he would address this in tomorrow's state of the union. he would announce a new wave of sanctions against putin's oil and expand energy production to meet the energy needs of our country and our allies in europe. joe's economic energy policies have hurt every american family. we pay more for every item we buy. everything costs hear to get it to the store and for a gallon of

the links of trump and trump-ism is clear. in order to lead biden has to pretend we are a better democracy than we currently are. >> eddie, in addition to georgia, black voters are having their vote suppressed, they fear how difficult to have their vote suppressed. there is also texas where voters are being disenfranchised. some 23,000 mail-in ballots were tossed out, almost all of them from failing to meet the voter i.d. requirements. i feel it is being ignored and only partly because of ukraine. >> well, it has a lot to do with the difficulty around passing the john lewis voting bill and the other voting bill with sinema and manchin and not having a way forward. and then voters may not be satisfied with judge brown-jackson. maybe the constituency will be satisfied. it seems to me that he had the perfect opportunity to join -- in some ways to have another campaign. remember the naacp campaign's campaign. he had an opportunity to talk about defending democracy abroad and at home. but instead he slipped into that worry, that ji

contempt votes tonight for two trump aides. investigators want to question clarence thomas's wife about her role in all this and what lines may have been lost. and jared kushner will also face a grilling. we will break it down, including how peter navarro talked his way into subpoenas and this contempt vote tonight. stay with us. vote tonight stay with us ♪ we believe there's an innovator in all of us. ♪ that's why we build technology that makes it possible for every business... and every person... to come to the table and do more incredible things. there's a different way to treat hiv. it's every-other-month, injectable cabenuva. for adults who are undetectable, cabenuva is the only complete hiv treatment you can get every other month. cabenuva helps keep me undetectable. it's two injections, given by a healthcare provider every other month. it's one less thing to think about while traveling. hiv pills aren't on my mind. a quick change in my plans is no big deal. don't receive cabenuva if you're allergic to its ingredients

trump. he said i don't care one way or another what happens in ukraine. >> would you support the no-fly zone? 15 seconds, yes or no. >> we should not have american pilots flying in ukraine. what we should be doing is providing the mix from poland --migs from poland that present zelenskyy required. that is peace through strength. we need to make sure they have the weapons they need to defend ukraine. colleen: we are sticking with ukraine. i have a 32nd follow-up for you, mr. mandel. you are endorsed by congressman hawthorne who called ukrainian , president zelenskyy a thug. do you agree? >> i fundamentally disagree. i think the thug is vladimir putin. people forget he was the kgb station chief in east germany when the wall fell. the kgb station was surrounded and he was embarrassed for his life and mother russia, and he hated president reagan and hated us. everyone watching at home, and us putin hates us and america , and he is the enemy. >> mr. gibbons, jd vance has said your response to ukr

of boasting about the successful operation to get trump in office brazenly asserting trump is ours mocking the american intelligence committee while they elected a u.s. president and travel to russia to make deals with our hackers so they could rig the midterms in favor of trump's team. putting aside whether or not we find those factual because the russian government doesn't tell the truth and russian state tv doesn't, what do you make of them calling trump a partner and they'd like him back in office and would like to help? >> there is a sincerity in that comment. if they prefer joe biden to donald trump in office, you could kiss nato good-bye. you could kiss any kind of any harsh response to russian aggression good-bye and he's easily manipulated but as you pointed out, some of those messages are a bit over stated. they know which ones are going to trigger kind of backlash within the u.s. committee, which ones are going to sew discord. the most important part is the fact that donald trump keeps asking for help. he keeps asking, you know, offering friendship to vladimir putin and saying h

it's the party of trump. we'll be right back. lem. it's the party of trump. we'll be right back. we got the house! you did! pods handles the driving. pack at your pace. store your things until you're ready. then we deliver to your new home - across town or across the country. pods, your personal moving and storage team. we need to reduce plastic waste in the environment. that's why at america's beverage companies, our bottles are made to be remade. not all plastic is the same. we're carefully designing our bottles to be 100% recyclable, including the caps. they're collected and separated from other plastics, so they can be turned back into material that we use to make new bottles. that completes the circle and reduces plastic waste. please help us get every bottle back. >> woman: what's my safelite story? i see inspiration right through my glass. so when my windshield cracked, i chose safelite. they replaced the glass and recalibrated my safety system. that's service i can trust. >> singers: ♪ safelite repair, safelite replace. ♪ one of my favorite supplements is qunol turmer

than trump. so in some ways that, you know the success of the trump movement could be even could be more extreme but also more competent than the than the original and and you dig into one of the anecdotes in your book that that teal is is well known for which is this whole kogan lawsuit that drove gawker out of business and that he was secretly bankrolling and until it emerged that he was can you talk a little bit about you know, what that means for for press freedom, really and and what what god him behind hulk hogan in the first but yeah, i mean, i always feel weird a little weird talking about this because of course there there are journalists under just you know, a lot more stress and and who are really putting their lives on the line. i mean even right now and ukraine, but but what teal did is he bankrolled this lawsuit that whole kogue in the wrestler? who's real name is terry bella and it was a it's very toddry it he was a sex tape that gawker published and hogan sued gawker for invasion

if you want to get something done right, send trump." why would nato want to see trump? he repeatedly slammed nato he's like their wwe wrestling villain. would they know he was there when they heard his entrance music? "so, we need to be careful about what steps we take next as to not inflame tensions and obviously -- [ "ymca" playing ] ♪ "my god. that's donald trump music! ♪ [ laughter ] and then don jr.'s copy of a copy of a fax brother eric trump - [ light laughter ] -- went on tv and made a similar claim, but with even dumber reasons. >> listen, my father would, you know, call up and he would have said, "vladimir, don't even think about it don't even try us. i'm telling you, it's not going to work out very well for you. >> seth: you really think that's how the conversation would go? you sound like you're talking to a dog who's about to pee on the rug. [ laughter ] of course, if trump talked to a dog the way he talked to putin, he would immediately give in every time the dog complained. "sparky, don't do it don't even think about it. don't you dare don't you dare

so, in my minds, president trump is a dereliction of duty. and if he was a military officer, he would be facing a court martial for that dereliction of duty, under these circumstances. so there are so many questions that the committee is trying to answer, that's why we need to hear from people like dance could be no, who we referred contemptuous on, because he decided that he's above the law, and he does want to talk to congress under subpoena. >> some context first could be another seems important, he was obviously at one point the presidents caddie, he then became his social media manager, obviously been a social media manager involves having access to the account of the president. and some close proximity of the phone you are using, or his phone. there is also a subpoena for his phone records, that he has been fighting very hard. illegal mystery of this anonymous objection to it, again on january 5th this year, when they personally identified a plaintive -- issue to verizon, by the special congressional committee, u.s. district chief judge

president trump, working with mr. scavino successfully spread distrust for our courts, which had repeatedly found no basis to overturn the election. and trump's stolen election campaign succeeded in provoking the violence on january 6th. on this point, there is no doubt. the committee has videos, interviews and sworn statements from violent rioters from demonstrating these facts. mr. navarro is also a key witness. he's written a book boasting about his role in planning and coordinating the activity of january 6th. yet, he does not have the courage to testify here. we have many questions for mr. navarro, including about his communications with roger stone and steve mann, regarding the planning for january 6th. as judge quarter concluded today quote, based on the evidence the court finds it more likely than not that president trump corruptly attempted to obstruct the joint session of congress on january 6th 2021. our committee will continue to litigate to abstain a testimony we need. we have already defeated president t

donald trump didn't take it. of course, one of the reasons we even note about that phone call is because of national security official named alexander vindman, he was listening to it live, he knew it was wrong. he knew -- and reported it up his chain of command and testified to the united states congress hearing on the impeachment of donald trump. joining us now is alexander vindman, he was a ukraine expert on the national security council and a witness to president trump's impeachment hearings. it's an honor to have you back with us. in your book, titled here right matters, you detail this specific matter, the fact that you had provided -- you and your cohorts at the white house and the national security council, have provided guidance and advice that president trump was supposed to have red and taken to say, you need to do very little for ukraine right now, the congressional aide had already been approved and was on his way to ukraine. all you need to do is show this man support so that he can stand up against