Skip to main content

We will keep fighting for all libraries - stand with us!

Full text of "A multi-wavelength study of the Seyfert 1 galaxy MCG-6-30-15"

See other formats

Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000-000 (0000) Printed 1 February 2008 (MN M?eX style file vl.4) 

A multi-wavelength study of the Seyfert 1 galaxy 

C. S. Reynoldsi'2, M. J. Ward^ A. C. Fabian^ and A. Celotti^ 

1 JILA, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado, CO 80309-0440, USA 
■^Institute of Astronomy, Madingley Road, Cambridge, CBS OHA 

^X-ray Astronomy Group, Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Leicester, Leicester, LEI 7RH 
"S.LS.S.A., via Beirut 2-4, 34014 Trieste, Italy 

1 February 2008 







We present a multiwaveband spectroscopic study of the nearby Seyfert 1 galaxy 
MCG— 6-30-15. New optical spectra from the Anglo-Australian Telescope are pre- 
sented which clearly show the effects of dust extinction/reddening on both the emis- 
sion line spectrum and the non-stellar AGN continuum. The reddening is constrained 
to be in the range E{B — V) = 0.61 — 1.09. Spectroscopy in the X-ray band, with both 
i^OS'^T' and ASCA, reveal absorption by the warm absorber but little or no neutral 
absorption expected to accompany the dust responsible for the optical reddening. The 
dusty warm absorber solution to this discrepancy is discussed and photoionization 
models of such warm absorbers are constructed. The optical spectrum also displays 
the relatively strong 'coronal' lines of [FeX]A6375, [FeXI]A7892 and [FeXIV]A5303. We 
show that these lines may plausibly originate from the outer regions of the warm ab- 
sorber, although better calculations of the collision strengths for these transitions are 
required in order to conclusively address this issue. We also present new ultraviolet 
data from the International Ultraviolet Explorer and suggest that much of the observed 
UV flux is scattered into our line of sight (with a scattering fraction of 1-5 per cent). 
We conclude with a discussion of the global energetics of this system. 

Key words: galaxies: active - galaxies:individual:MCG— 6-30-15 - X-rays:galaxies 


Accretion of material onto a supermassive black hole has 
long been believed to be the fundamental power source of 
active galactic nuclei (AGN; e.g. see Rees 1984 for a re- 
view). However, the physical processes by which the gravi- 
tational potential energy of the accretion flow energizes the 
observed spectrum are still far from certain. Recent spec- 
troscopic studies in the X-ray waveband have shown that, 
in the innermost regions (i.e. r < lORsch; where Rsch is 
the Schwarzschild radius of the central black hole) of at 
least some AGN, there is a geometrically-thin, radiatively- 
efiicient accretion disk (Tanaka et al. 1995; Fabian et al. 
1995). A significant fraction of the accretion energy appears 
to be liberated in a hot, optically-thin, disk-corona which 
is a prolific radiator of X-rays and 7-rays (probably via the 
Gomptonization of optical/UV photons from the cold accre- 
tion disk: Haardt & Maraschi 1991; Field & Rogers 1993; 
Zdziarski et al. 1994). Although most of the primary radia- 
tion is produced in the inner regions of the accretion fiow, a 
significant fraction of this radiation is reprocessed at greater 

distances from the black hole into UV, optical and IR wave- 
lengths. Studying these reprocessing mechanisms allows the 
structures surrounding the accreting black hole to be probed 
and are necessary if we are to disentangle the primary emis- 
sion from the reprocessed emission. 

In recent years, much has been learnt about the various 
reprocessing mechanisms. It has been realized that approx- 
imately half of the X-ray photons emitted from the corona 
will strike the cold accretion disk, thereby producing 'reflec- 
tion' features in the X-ray spectrum (Guilbert & Rees 1988; 
Lightman & White 1988; Pounds et al. 1990). The emission 
that emerges from these central regions can also be inter- 
cepted by more distant structures: these include the broad- 
line region (BLR), the putative molecular torus of the unifled 
Seyfert schemes and the warm absorber. The scattering of 
primary radiation into our line-of-sight is also known to be 
important in at least some AGN. Multi- waveband studies of 
nearby, bright AGN are invaluable in studying such complex 

Many such multi- wavelength studies of AGN have been 
performed. For example, AUoin et al. (1995) utilized many 

© 0000 RAS 

2 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

ground-based and space observatories to obtain a snapshot 
(i.e. all data taken almost simultaneously) of the Seyfert 1 
galaxy NGC 3783. After careful consideration of possible 
contaminating sources, these authors fit thermal accretion 
disk models to the classical big blue bump displayed by this 
object and hence constrain the black hole mass and accretion 
rate. They also find an infrared bump which they interpret 
as thermal emission from hot and warm dust. Many other 
studies focus on multi-wavelength monitoring in an attempt 
to map the central engine. For example, extensive monitor- 
ing campaigns have been performed on NGC 4151 (Edelson 
et al. 1996) and NGC 5548 (Korista et al. 1995). 

In this paper we perform a multiwaveband study of the 
nearby Seyfert 1 galaxy MCG-6-30-15 {z = 0.008; Pineda et 
al. 1978; Pineda et al. 1980). Snapshot optical imaging with 
the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) clearly shows this object 
to be a SO- type galaxy with a bright, nuclear point source. 
This X-ray bright AGN has recently been the subject of in- 
tense spectroscopic study in the X-ray band and so is a good 
candidate for a multiwavelength study. We present new op- 
tical data from the Anglo- Australian Telescope (AAT) and 
new ultraviolet data from the International Ultraviolet Ex- 
plorer satellite (lUE). Together with archival infrared and 
X-ray data, this represents the most detailed multiwaveband 
study of this nearby AGN to date. In particular, we review 
and reinforce evidence that there is a significant column of 
dusty ionized material along our line of sight to the central 
continuum source and BLR, the so-called dusty warm ab- 
sorber. This material is shown to have a major effect on the 
observed spectrum of this source. 

In Section 2, the data are presented and the basic char- 
acteristics at each waveband are discussed. Section 3 exam- 
ines various estimates for the amount of extinction and ab- 
sorption towards the central source. A discrepancy between 
the optical/UV extinction and the X-ray absorption leads 
us to discuss the possibility of dusty warm absorbers in Sec- 
tion 4. Section 5 probes the connection between the warm 
absorber and coronal line emission. We discuss our results 
and their implications for the energetics of the system in 
Section 6. Section 7 presents our conclusions. 


2.1 Optical 

Optical spectra of MCG— 6-30-15 were obtained with the 
AAT on the night of 1995 April 10. The RGO spectrograph 
with the 300B grating (grating angle 23.27°) was used to ob- 
tain blue (3500-5500A ) spectra and the Faint Object Red 
Spectrograph (FORS) provided red (5700-lOOOOA ) spectra. 
Red and blue spectra could be taken simultaneously^ via 
the use of a dichroic beam splitter. The spectral (FWHM) 
resolutions are ~ 9A in the blue and ~ 30A in the red. 
Standard data reduction was performed using the FIGARO 
software package provided by STARLINK. Wavelength cali- 
bration was performed using a Cu-Ar arc. We estimate that 

* Due to the shutter configuration and the read-out constraints, 
the red spectral integrations had to be terminated and read-out 
60 s before the blue. 

the wavelength calibration is accurate to within lA in the 
blue spectrum and 3A in the red spectrum. Absolute flux 
calibration utilized the standard star L745-46A. Finally, the 
atmospheric water bands within the red spectrum were cor- 
rected for using the extremely metal-deficient red giant star 
HD126587 as a continuum reference source. 

In order to be sensitive to intra-night variations in 
flux or spectrum, we took 18 separate red/blue spectra of 
MCG— 6-30-15. A normal Galactic F-star is situated 6 arcsec 
to the south of the nucleus of MCG— 6-30-15 (Pineda et al. 
1980): the slit position was arranged so as to cover both the 
nucleus and the star. Assuming the star to have a constant 
flux during the night, this provides a good control against 
which we can search for flux variations in the nucleus. The 
exposure time of each spectrum was 600 s in the blue and 
540 s in the red. 

After reduction it was found that only 8 red/blue 
spectra were unaffected by the variable weather conditions 
during the night. The spectrum of the nuclear region of 
MCG— 6-30-15 was extracted from each long-slit spectrum. 
No significant difference in either overall flux or individual 
line fluxes could be found between these spectra. Further- 
more, no signiflcant variability could be detected when the 
overall nuclear flux was compared with that of the nearby 
F-star. These conclusions remain robust even if we include 
periods of data that were affected by poor weather. We can 
set upper limits of ~ 5 per cent on intra-night variation 
of the optical flux of the nucleus. Given the lack of any 
detectable variability, the 8 'good' spectra were combined 
to form a single co-added spectrum with effective exposure 
times 4800 s in the blue and 4360 s in the red. Figures la 
and lb show the blue and red coadded spectra, respectively. 

These spectra possess extremely high signal-to-noise 
and, therefore, uncertainties are dominated by calibration 
effects and atmospheric variations. Comparing the 8 sepa- 
rate good spectra (i.e. those obtained prior to co-adding), 
we estimate that there is a ~ 10 per cent uncertainty in 
the overall normalization of each spectrum. These are most 
likely due to 'grey' variations in atmospheric conditions. 
Treating these uncertainties as independent, the coadded 
spectra should each have an uncertainty of approximately 3 
per cent in overall normalization. The uncertainties in the 
red and blue spectra should be statistically independent. 

Several features are immediately apparent from these 
spectra. The emission line spectrum is dominated by broad 
Balmer lines (Ha, H/3, H7 and HiS) and narrow forbidden 
oxygen lines ([OII]A3727 and [OIII]A4959/5007). The emis- 
sion line spectrum, which is clearly related to the Seyfert 
activity, is examined in more detail below (Section 2.1.2). 
The spectrum between 9000A and lOOOOA may be severely 
affected by incorrect subtraction of atmospheric water fea- 
tures, and so the line-like features in this region of the spec- 
trum should be treated with caution. The presence of the 
Ca 11 doublet in absorption (near 4000 A ) shows there to be 
a non-negligible fraction of starlight from the host galaxy 
contributing to this spectrum. We now examine this stellar 

2.1.1 The galactic spectrum 

For the blue data we extracted the spectrum of the host 
galaxy (which appears on the long slit frames as a clearly 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

A multi-wavelength study of MCG— 6-30-15 3 

(a) Blue (TEK) spectrum 

— I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 r- 




—I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1— 






(b) Red (FORS) spectrum 

-] 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 p 

— 1 1 1 1— 




Q I I I I I I ■_ 

_l I I I I I I I I I l_ 

—I I I l_ 







Figure 1. The blue (a) and red (b) optical spectra of the nuclear region of MCG— 6-30-15. Prominent emission lines and the Call 
absorption feature have been marked. 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

4 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

(a) Stellar (i.e. off nuclear) spectrum 

— 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 r- 







(b) Stellar substracted Seyfert spectrum 







Figure 2. a) Spectrum of the ofT-nuclear, stellar component. The absence of broad Balmer hncs, together with the strong redshifted 
Ca 11 doublet feature verifies that the host galaxy has been successfully isolated from the nuclear flux, b) Pure Seyfert spectrum obtained 
by subtracting the stellar spectrum from the total nuclear spectrum until the Call feature vanishes. Note that the stellar absorption 
feature of Mg B around 5200A (rest frame) is also successfully removed. 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

A multi-wavelength study of MCG— 6-30-15 5 

defined 'fuzz' surrounding the bright nuclear emission.) The 
spectra extracted from the individual long-slit frames were 
again co-added to form a single spectrum. Figure 2a shows 
this co-added spectrum. The absence of any broad Balmer 
linos from this spectrum is verification that wc have success- 
fully isolated the stellar component. Note that there is nar- 
row [Oil] and [OIII] line emission present in this spectrum. 
Wc attribute this to the narrow line region (NLR) possess- 
ing significant spatial extent (and therefore contaminating 
the spectrum of the host galaxy.) 

The stellar spectrum reveals several absorption features. 
The weak H/3 absorption indicates the presence of a young 
stellar population. An older stellar population give rise to 
the Mg B, Fel, G-band and Can absorption features. 

2.1.2 The nuclear spectrum 

Assuming the stellar spectrum to be spatially uniform, we 
can subtract the spectrum of the host galaxy from the total 
nuclear spectrum in order to isolate the spectrum of the 
active nucleus. In practice, we progressively subtract more 
of the stellar spectrum from the total spectrum until the 
Can doublet feature at ^ 4000A vanishes. The resulting 
difference spectrum is taken to be the spectrum of the active 
nucleus. This is shown in Figure 2b. A similar procedure 
was not performed for the rod (FORS) data because the 
poorer spatial resolution of our FORS data makes isolation 
of the host galaxy spectrum more difficult. This would make 
subtraction of the stellar component rather subjective and 
consequently diminish its value. 

As is typical for Soyfort 1 nuclei, the spectrum consists 
of a strong non-stellar continuum, broad Balmer lines and 
narrow permitted and forbidden lines. Both the red and blue 
spectra were visually examined for known prominent lines. 
All such identified lines were characterized by fitting a sin- 
gle Gaussian profile whilst modeling the local continuum as 
a power-law. This procedure was performed on the galcixy- 
subtracted spectrum, with the exception of those few lines 
that were identified in the FORS data (for the reasons given 
above). Since our stellar spectrum is contaminated with for- 
bidden oxygen line emission (presumably from an extended 
NLR), we note that these oxygen lines will be suppressed 
by ~ 10 per cent in the galaxy-subtracted AGN spectrum. 
The single Gaussian parameterization is a (visually) good 
fit to all of the emission lines except H/3. Three Gaussian 
components are required to properly describe this line: 

a) A narrow line component at the systemic velocity 
of the galaxy (defined as the velocity of the [OIII] emission 
line region) with FWHM< 700 kms"^ and flux Fn(i?/?) = 
9.6 X IQ-^^ergcm^^s^^. 

b) A broad 
line component blueshifted by 200 ± 60kms~'^ relative to 
the systemic velocity with FWHM~ 2400 ± 200 km s"^ and 
flux F^,{HP) = 6.3 X 10"^''ergcm-2s~i . 

c) A very broad line component redshifted by 
500 ± 120 km s^^ relative to the systemic velocity with 
FWHM- 7100 ± 700kms-i and flux Fvb(J?/3) = 4.6 x 
10"" erg cm-^s"^. 

The resulting lino identifications, wavelengths, line 
widths and total line fluxes for all of the identified lines 
are given in Table 1. The errors quoted in this table (and 
those for the H/3 components above) include both statisti- 

2 I ' 1 ' 1 ' r 



I J I L 

1400 1600 


Figure 3. lUE (SWP) data for MCG-6-30-15. Note the weak 
continuum and the prominent C IVA1549 line. 

cal errors and an estimate of any systematic errors resulting 
from the wavelength/flux calibration. The statistical errors 
are derived from fitting of the Gaussian models to the 
data, assuming that the pixel-to-pixel variation is due to 
random Gaussian noise. 

The optical spectrum clearly shows the efiiect of dust 
extinction: the continuum flux declines towards the blue end 
of the spectrum and the Balmer decrements are large. The 
line-of-sight extinction, and a comparison of this extinction 
to the line-of-sight X-ray absorption will be addressed in 
Section 3. 

2.2 Ultraviolet 

The ultraviolet data were taken by lUE on 1994 July 23-24 
(i.e. three days prior to the ASCA observation described be- 
low.) Due to excessive scattered solar light, we present only 
the data taken with the short wavelength primary (SWP) 
camera. These short-wavelength data were taken during one 
full shift on 1994 July 24 (efi'ective exposure time 8 hours). 
Data reduction was performed using the ark software pack- 

The resulting SWP spectrum is shown in Fig. 3. The 
source is found to be weak in the UV compared with other 
wavebands (apart from radio). The hypothesis that this UV 
spectrum is flat and featureless can be rejected with a high 
level of confidence: such a hypothesis gives — 153 for 
65 degrees of freedom (dof). The most significant deviation 
from the constant model is clearly the C lvA1549 resonance 
emission line doublet. Modeling this with a Gaussian profile 
leads to a highly significant improvements in the goodness 
of fit (Ax^ ~ 35 for 3 additional dof). The inferred prop- 
erties of this line are reported in Table 1. The CivA1549 
line appears to be significantly broader than the Ha line, 
and has a FWHM comparable with the 'very-broad' com- 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

6 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

line rest observed relative velocity FWHM line flux equivalent 

identification wavelength (A) wavelength (A) of line (kms^-*^) (kms^-') (lO"'^^ erg cm~^ s^^ ) width (A) 



1545 ± 6 

-3000 ± 1200 

6200 ± 2100 

250 ± 90 

140 ± 70 



3758 ± 1 

160 ± 80 

< 790 

16 ± 2 

14 ± 1 



3899 ± 1 

-10 ±80 

< 1030 

4.3 ±1.0 

4.0 ± 1.5 



4133 ± 1 

-140 ± 70 

3000 ± 370 

18 ±4 

14 ±4 



4374 ± 1 

-130 ± 70 

2470 ± 180 

37 ±3 

30 ±3 



4400 ± 2 

210 ± 140 

< 1470 

5.9 ±1.2 

4± 1 



A ^Of^ 1 "1 

4722 ± 1 

—30 ± 60 

< 710 

5.4 ± 0.6 

2.7 ± 0.3 



see text 

see text 

see text 

119 ± 5 

66 ±3 



4997 ± 1 

-40 ± 60 

< 530 

24.0 ±0.8 

11.3 ±0.3 



5046 ± 1 


< 530 

83.0 ±0.7 

37.2 ±0.3 



5199 ± 1 

-10 ±60 

860 ± 160 

3.4 ±0.7 

1.4 ±0.3 



5343 ± 1 

-90 ± 60 

2320 ± 300 

14 ± 1 

5.2 ± 0.4 



6422 ± 3 

-130 ± 140 

1950 ± 500 

15 ±3 

3.0 ±0.4* 



6613 ± 2 

-50 ± 90 

2590 ± 90 

952 ± 23 

211 ±20* 



6775 ± 3 

480 ± 130 

< 1580 

16 ±3 

3.0 ±0.7* 



7947 ± 3 

-250 ± 110 

< 1850 

15 ±3 

3.0 ±0.7* 

Table 1. UV/Optical/NIR line spectrum for MCG— 6-30-15. Column 4 shows the velocity redshift of the line centre with respect to 
the reference frame defined by the [OIII]A5007 emission {z = 0.00779). Column 6 shows the total flux in the line, corrected for Galactic 
extinction. Those equivalent widths marked with an asterix have been measured from FORS data which have not been galaxy-subtracted. 
All errors and limits are quoted at the 1-cr level. 

ponent of the H/3 line. The C iv line is also blueshifted by 
~ 3000 km with respect to the broad Balmer lines. This 
appears to be a generic feature of high-ionization lines from 
AGN (e.g. sec Espey et al. 1989). This has been interpreted 
by some authors as evidence for a two-component BLR (e.g. 
Collin-Souffrin et al. 1988). 

There may also be an absorption trough to the blueside 
of the C IVA1549 lines. Modeling this with a Gaussian profile 
leads to a further improvement in the goodness of fit by 
Ax^ = 12 for 3 additional dof. According to the F-tcst, this 
is not a significant improvement at the 90 per cent level. 
Thus, we cannot conclusively determine the reality of this 
feature and shall not discuss it further. 

Formally, the best fit contiimum level is Fswp ~ (1.1 ± 
0.2) X 10"^^ ergcm"^ s~^ It is possible that much of 

this UV continuum could be stellar in origin. Thus, this 
value should be considered only as an upper limit to the UV 
continuum fiux from the AGN. High-resolution UV imag- 
ing with HST will allow the stellar UV fiux to be almost 
completely separated from the AGN UV flux, thereby al- 
lowing these two components to be separated. At the time 
of writing, such UV imaging has yet to be performed. 

2.3 Other wavebands 

To make this study genuinely multi- waveband in nature, we 
have supplemented the above new spectra will previously 
published data. The remainder of this section will introduce 
these data. 

2.3.1 Infrared 

Mid/far infrared (MIR/FIR) data were obtained from the 
Infrared Astronomy Satellite (IRAS) Faint Source Cata- 
logue (version 2.0) at four wavelengths (12 /xm, 25 iim, 60yum 
and 100 //m.) Giuricin, Marddirossian & Mezzetti (1995) 
find good agreement between the IRAS 12 fjja flux and the 

ground-based, small-beam 10 pim (N-band) flux. Thus, it ap- 
pears there are no strong confusing IR sources in the IRAS 
beam at the short IRAS wavelengths. Unless there is a very 
cool confusing source which only reveals itself at the longer 
IRAS wavelengths, this suggests that IRAS is providing a 
reliable measurement of the fiux of MCG— 6-30-15 at all 
IR wavelengths. Furthermore, this agreement between the 
ground-based observations and IRAS implies that there is 
little contribution to the NIR flux from the host galaxy. 
This is consistent with it being of Hubble type SO. 

J-, H-, K- and L-band (i.e. 1.2 — 3.5/im) fluxes were 
obtained from the ground-based work of Ward et al. (1987). 

2.3.2 Soft (0.2-2keV) X-rays 

Soft X-ray data from the ROSAT Position Sensitive Pro- 
portional Counter (PSPC) were retrieved from the public 
archive situated at the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. 
We chose the longest of the two available PSPC observations 
of this object. This observation started on 1992-January-29 
and collected a total of 8500 s of good data. A PSPC spec- 
trum of MCG— 6-30-15 was formed by binning all counts 
extracted from a circular region of radius 2 arcmin centered 
on the point source corresponding to MCG— 6-30-15. The 
background count rate within this region is found to be neg- 
ligible compared with the source. 

These data have been previously discussed by Nandra 
& Pounds (1992). These authors found evidence for a notch 
in the PSPC spectrum at an energy of i? ~ 0.8 kcV. They 
interpreted this feature as a blend of O vil and O vill K- 
shell absorption edges resulting from highly-ionized mate- 
rial along the line of sight to the primary (power-law) X-ray 
source. This material has become known as the warm ab- 
sorber (Halpern 1984), and shall play a major role in the 
discussion presented in this paper. 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

A multi-wavelength study of MCG— 6-30-15 7 

2.3.3 Hard (0.6-10 keV) X-rays 

The Advanced Satclhte for Cosmology and Astrophysics 
{ASCA) performed a long (4.5-day) observation of MCG— 6- 
30-15 on 1994 July 27. The 'good' exposure times were 
~ 1.5 X 10® s in each of the four detectors. As a result, high 
signal-to-noiso, medium-resolution X-ray spectra wore ob- 
tained in the 0.6-10 kcV band. The fact that the X-ray flux 
is highly variable on short timescales, together with ROSAT 
imaging, confirms that the observed X-rays are originating 
from the central engine of this Seyfert nucleus (see Fig. 1 of 
Fabian et al. 1995). 

Detailed analyses of these data are presented in Tanaka 
et al. (1995), Otani et al. (1996) and Iwasawa et al. (1996). 
As discussed by these authors, the 0.6-10 keV X-ray spec- 
trum shows clear deviations from the canonical power-law 
form. In particular, the O vil and O vill edges from the warm 
absorber are prominent features in the 0.7-2 keV range and 
a broad emission feature is seen between 5-7 keV. 

ASCA revealed the warm absorber in MCG— 6-30-15 
to be highly variable (Fabian et al. 1994; Reynolds et al. 
1995; Otani et al. 1996). Detailed modeling of this variabil- 
ity (Otani et al. 1996; Reynolds 1996) has led to a two-zone 
model for this absorber. There seems to be a highly pho- 
toionized inner region (possibly related to the BLR) and a 
less ionized outer region (possibly related to the putative 
molecular torus or NLR). It is likely that both of these ab- 
sorbers are in outflow driven by the radiation pressure of 
the central source (Reynolds & Fabian 1995). 

The emission feature at 5-7 keV is thought to bo due 
to the fluorescent Kq line emission of cold iron (i.e. Fel- 
Fexvil) that results when primary X-rays illuminate cold 
material in the vicinity of the central engine (George & 
Fabian 1991; Matt, Perola & Piro 1991). The rest-frame 
energy of this emission lino is 6.4 kcV. ASCA resolves this 
line and allows its profile to be determined. It is found that 
the profile is in good agreement with the hypothesis that it 
originates from the innermost regions of a thin, radiatively- 
efBcient, accretion disk about a black hole (Tanaka et al. 
1995; Fabian ct al. 1995; Iwasawa et al. 1996). Relativistic 
beaming, transverse Doppler shifts and gravitational red- 
shifts are of major importance in determining the profile of 
this emission line. From the point of view of the current 
work, the iron line observation is important since it con- 
strains the geometry of the energetically important inner 
accretion disk: in the innermost region, much of the energy 
appears to be liberated as X-rays in an optically-thin region 
near a radiatively-efficient thin accretion disk viewed at an 
inclination of 30°. 

2.4 The multi-waveband spectrum 

The above data are compiled together into a multi- waveband 
spectrum in Fig. 4. The spectral data plotted in this figure 
have not been stellar-subtracted or corrected for any redden- 
ing (i.e. this is the total galaxy-|-AGN spectrum as observed 
at Earth) . The dotted line sketches the approximate intrinsic 
(i.e. dereddened/unabsorbed) spectrum of this source given 
a reddening of E{B — V)= 0.61 (sec Section 3). 

There are several noteworthy features in this nmltiwave- 
band spectrum. First, the observed spectral energy distri- 
bution [i.e. vF{v)\ peaks in the mid-infrared (i^ ~ 2 — 3 x 

10^"^ Hz). As discussed below, this is probably due to ther- 
mal emission from warm/hot dust grains. Secondly, whereas 
many classical Seyfert 1 galaxies display a strong optical/UV 
continuum (the so-called Big Blue Bump), MCG— 6-30-15 
is heavily reddened in the optical band and almost extin- 
guished in the UV. There is then a strong recovery at X-ray 
frequencies. The effect of the warm absorber and iron Ka 
emission line are clearly seen in the X-ray spectrum. 


The NIR/optical/UV spectrum of MCG-6-30-15 displays 
the signatures of extinction and reddening by dust. In this 
section, these signatures are discussed and the amount of 
reddening is estimated. We then compare the amount of 
reddening with the observed X-ray absorption. 

3.1 Extinction of the optical emission line regions 

Extinction by cosmic dust is highly wavelength dependent 
and hence can change observed line flux ratios significantly 
away from the intrinsic (i.e. emitted) values. This provides 
a classic method for determining the amount of dust extinc- 
tion along the line of sight to a particular emission line re- 
gion. The relative ratios of the Balmer lines of hydrogen are 
often used as extinction indicators due to the fact that they 
are observationally convenient (being in the optical band), 
strong and their intrinsic relative flux ratios are fairly well 
determined from atomic theory. 

In the case of Balmer lines from AGN, one would ideally 
deblend the lines into kinematically distinct components, 
e.g. a broad component (from the BLR) and a narrow com- 
ponent (from the NLR). One could then obtain information 
about the extinction through to each component. However, 
high-resolution data is required to facilitate the deblending. 
To avoid introducing uncertainties due to the deblending 
procedure we choose to use the total Balmer decrements: 
thus, the extinction estimates below should be considered 
as average values over all of the emission line regions. 

Table 2 gives the observed Balmer decrements and the 
expected intrinsic value based upon the assumption of case- 
B recombination. These decrements have been converted 
into the reddening, E{B — V), using the standard interstel- 
lar extinction curve of Osterbrock (1989). This interstellar 
extinction curve leads to the expression 

S(B-T/) = alog(^) (1) 

where TZ is the observed Balmer decrement, 7?,intr is the in- 
trinsic Balmer decrement and a is a constant which is given 
in Table 2 for the three Balmer decrements quoted. Table 2 
also associates a hydrogen column density, ATh, with this 
reddening. This is given by (Heiles, Kulkani & Stark 1981) 

iVn = (2.14±0.20)xl0^°-F(3.91±0.21)xl0^^ E{B-V) cm'^ (2) 

and is the column density of cold gas that would bo present 
under the assumption that the nature of the dust and the 
cold-gas/dust ratio is the same as is found locally in our 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

8 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

V (Hz) 

Figure 4. Multiband spectrum of MCG— 6-30-15. These data have not been corrected for reddening (either Galactic or intrinsic) and 
include the stellar component. The dotted line shows the estimated intrinsic spectrum of the source, after correction for reddening and 
absorption. A reddening of E{B — V) = 0.61 (see Section 3) has been assumed in the placement of this line. 





E{B - V) 


ratio TZ 

ratio T^intr 

(1020 cm-2 ) 


8.0 (7.6-8.4) 



1.02 (0.61-1.09) 

42 (26-44) 


0.31 (0.22-0.37) 



0.95 (0.56-1.72) 

39 (24-69) 


0.16 (0.10-0.26) 



0.75 (0-1.47) 

31 (0-60) 

Table 2. Balmer decrements and inferred extinction for MCG— 6-30-15. See text for a discussion of the significance and possible causes 
of differences between E{B — V) as calculated from difference Balmer decrements. The figures in brackets are the allowed range of the 
parameter given the vajrious systematic effects discussed in the text. 

The calculation of the uncertainties in E{B — V) de- 
serves discussion. We must critically consider both the obser- 
vational uncertainties and the intrinsic nature of the source. 

First, we consider observational uncertainties. The Ha 
line and H/3 line were measured in different spectrographs, 
the data from which have undergone independent reduction 
and cahbration. This will introduce some uncertainty into 
the Ha/H/3 Balmer docromont: in Section 2.1 wo estimated 
that both the red and blue spectra have absolute normal- 
izations which are uncertain to ~ 3 per cent (with these 
two uncertainties being independent). This leads to a 4- 

5 per cent in the Ha/H/3 Balmer decrement, correspond- 
ing to an error on the reddening of E{B — V)Ha/Hf3 = 
1.02 ± 0.05. The H/3, H7 and H5 lines all appear in the 
data from the same spectrograph and so the two indepen- 
dent Balmer decrements that can be formed from these 
three lines are not sensitive to uncertainties in the overall 
normalization. However, H7 and US do suffer from poten- 
tially significant observationally-related uncertainties. The 
H7 line is blended with the [OHIJA4363 line and so an un- 
ambiguous determination of the H7 flux, F{Hj), is dif- 
ficult without higher resolution data. By examining ex- 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

A multi-wavelength study of MCG— 6-30-15 9 

treme cases, we can conservatively bracket F{Hj) to the 
range (2.8 — 4.3) x 10^^'' ergcm"^ s~^ . The corresponding 
range of inferred reddening is E{B — V)H-y/Hi3 =0.56-1.72. 
The H(5 flux, F{HS), is uncertain due to the fact that 
it is weak compared with the local continuum and so is 
sensitive to the modeling of that continuum. By examin- 
ing extreme cases, we can conservatively bracket F{H5) to 
(1.3 — 3.0) X lO"'^* ergcm"^ . The corresponding range 
of inferred extinctions is E{B — V)hs/hi3 =0-1.47. 

Secondly, we must consider the possibility that the in- 
trinsic Balmer decrements are not well represented by their 
case-B recombination limits. Deviations from case-B values 
can occur due to colhsional effects and radiative transfer ef- 
fects which are especially important in the high-density gas 
found within the BLR. Theoretically, these processes can 
increase the Ha/H/3 decrement from the case-B value to 10 
(Kwan & Krolik 1981) or more (Canfield & Puetter 1981). 
In these extreme cases, we would not have to postulate any 
dust reddening towards the emission line regions of MCG— 6- 
30-15 at all. However, observations of other Seyfert 1 nuclei 
which are thought to be unreddened suggest that intrinsic 
Ha/H/? decrements do not exceed 4 (e.g. Malkan 1983; Wu, 
Boggcss & Gull 1983). Using this value of the Ha/H/3 ratio 
instead of the case-B value decreases the inferred reddening 
from E{B - V) = 1.02 to E{B - V) = 0.67. Including the 
uncertainty in the measured Ha/H/3 ratio, the lower limit 
to the reddening is E{B — V") = 0.61. The effect of devia- 
tions from caso-B recombination on the intrinsic H7/H/3 and 
H5/H/3 have not been investigated in as much theoretical de- 
tail as for Ha/H/?. However, the corresponding uncertainties 
on the reddening are likely to be insignificant compared with 
the observational uncertainties discussed above. 

To summarize these Balmcr decrement studies, the 
large Ha/H/9 ratio suggests a reddening in the range E{B — 
V) = 0.61-1.09. This is compatible with the reddening in- 
ferred from H7/H,i'? and H(5/Hi? although these two Balmcr 
decrements have large uncertainties due to line blending and 
the modeling of the contirmum. Assuming that the cold- 
dust/gas ratio is similar to that observed locally in our 
Galaxy, the column density of gas associated with this red- 
dening is in the range Nh = (2.6 — 4.4) x 10^^ cm~^ . 

3.2 Extinction of the continuum source 

The optical continuum radiation will also be affected by ex- 
tinction and reddening. Suppose the intrinsic spectrum of 

the (optical) contirmum has a form -Fintr(;^) 1^^". Fur- 
thermore, suppose that the observed (i.e. reddened) optical 
continuum spectrum is -Fobs(i^) oc 1/^"°^" . The difference be- 
tween a and aobs is related to the reddening towards the 
source. Prom the definition of reddening, it is easily seen 

E{B-V) = -2.5 log (^^^)+ 2.5 log (^^) (3) 

= 2.5(aobs - a) log (4) 

^ 0.26(aobs - a) (5) 

where vb and t/y are the frequencies characterizing the B- 
band and y-band respectively. 

Unreddened Seyfert 1 nuclei in the luminosity range 

occupied by MCG— 6-30-15 tend to have optical contirma 
with a ~ 2 (e.g. see study of Morris & Ward 1988, and note 
that a flat flux spectrum in wavelength space implies a = 2 
when considered in frequency space). Fitting the (galaxy- 
subtracted) blue spectrum of the rmclcus of MCG— 6-30-15, 
we conclude that Qobs lies in the range 4.5-5. Assuming that 
the intrinsic optical spectrum of MCG— 6-30-15 is similar to 
that found in unreddened Seyfert 1 nuclei, the reddening 
of the optical continuum source E{B — V) is in the range 

The reddening of the optical continuum source is con- 
sistent with the lower end of the reddening derived from the 
Ha/H/3 Balmer ratio. Assuming that the optical continuum 
is associated with an accretion disk embedded inside the 
BLR, this result suggests that little dust is present between 
the accretion disk and the region where the bulk of the the 
broad line photons are emitted. 

3.3 The UV flux — evidence for scattering? 

Initially, we shall suppose that the observed C IV line emit- 
ting region is seen directly rather than via scattered pho- 
tons. Furthermore, suppose that the UV contirmum and 
C IV line emission are subject to the same extinction as 
the optical non-stellar continuum/line regions. Since we 
have determined the optical reddening to be in the range 
E{B — V) = 0.61 — 1.09, we can dcrcddcn the C iv line in 
order to estimate its intrinsic (i.e. dereddened) flux. Thus, 
given this supposition that the UV line emitting region is 
seen directly, we constrain the intrinsic C IV line flux to lie 
in the range 

Fi„tr(C7F) = (1.4 - 102) x 10"" ergcm-2 s"^ , (6) 

where we have included the 1-cr errors in the observed flux 
and used the UV extinction law of Osterbrock (1989). This 
is a rather large line flux, corresponding to an isotropic lu- 
minosity of 3 X 10'*'^ erg s^^ or greater in the C iv line alone. 

To quantitatively assess how large this line flux is, con- 
sider the lower end of this range corresponding to E{B — 
V) = 0.61. Por this reddening, the dereddened H/3 flux is 

Fintr(ii"/3) = 9.1 X 10"" ergcm"^ s"^ , (7) 

leading to a lower limit on the intrinsic C iv/H/3 flux ratio of 

15. This ratio is very sensitive to the reddening assumed and 
can greatly exceed this value if E{B — V) > 0.61. In unred- 
dened Seyfert nuclei, this ratio is often significantly smaller. 
Por example, in the AGN Watch Campaign on NGC 3783, 
the intrinsic C iv/H/3 fiux ratio is ~ 10 (Reichert et al. 1994; 
Stirpe et al. 1994). Similarly, the Clv/H/3 flux ratios found 
during the monitoring campaigns on NGC 4151 (Crenshaw 
et al. 1996; Kaspi et al. 1996) and NGC 5548 (Korista et al. 
1995) are ~ 7 and ~ 9, respectively. 

We must conclude that the C IV line flux is unusually 
high compared with the optical line fluxes, or that one of 
our assumptions has broken down. There are three possible 
ways that our above argument might be flawed. First, source 
variability during the 9 months separating the UV and op- 
tical observations may produce an apparently unusual line 
ratio, even if the intrinsic line ratio is normal. In our min- 
imum reddening case {E{B — V) = 0.61), only mild vari- 
ability (~ 30 per cent over 9 months) is required to make 
the observed Cvi/H/3 ratio of 15 consistent with the that 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

10 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

seen in other objects. As one postulates higher reddening 
values, the more extreme is the inferred intrinsic line ratio 
and the more violent the variability needed. Secondly, the 
reddening towards the high-ionization BLR (including the 
C IV line emitting region) may be different than that to- 
wards the low-ionization BLR (which includes the Balmer 
line emitting region). Whilst this is clearly a viable possi- 
bility (and one can imagine central-engine geometries that 
produce such an effect) there is no precedent for the high- 
ionization BLR to be less reddened than the low-ionization 
BLR. Thirdly, some fraction of the photons from the BLR 
might be scattered around the material responsible for the 
extinction. If the scattering fraction is wavelength indepen- 
dent (e.g. electron scattering), the scattering will tend to 
preferentially enhance the UV relative to the optical due to 
the fact that the direct flux is heavily reddened. Since we 
know scattering to be an important process in some other 
Seyfert nuclei, we now explore this last possibility in more 

Suppose that the intrinsic UV/optical line spectrum is 
similar to that of NGC 3783, with a C iv/H/3 flux ratio of 10. 
We can write the observed fluxes of both of these lines. Fobs, 
as a sum of the direct (extinguished) flux and the scattered 
flux which is assumed not to suffer any extinction beyond 
that due to Galactic material. If / is the scattering fraction, 
then we have 

= (lo-f^GaiCs-v)^ ^ io-'^(^'^)) F„t. (8) 

where 6 is a parameter dependent on the extinction law 
used. The standard interstellar extinction curve of Oster- 
brock (1989) gives h = 3.2 for ClvA1549 and b = 1.45 for 
H/3. The flrst term on the right hand side of equation (8) 
represents the scattered flux including the effects of extinc- 
tion by Galactic material. We take EoaiiB — V) = 0.06 
(Berriman 1989). The second term of equation (8) gives the 
contribution due to the direct (extinguished) flux. Divid- 
ing these equations for C ivA1549 and H/3 gives a relation 
between the required scattering fraction / and the total line- 
of-sight reddening E{B — V). This relationship is shown in 
Fig. 5 for interesting values of E{B — V). It can be seen that 
scattering fraction of between 1-5 per cent (doijcnding on 
the total reddening) are required in order to make the ob- 
served line ratios consistent with an intrinsic C Iv/H/3 line 
ratio of 10. 

3.4 X-ray absorption 

X-rays arc thought to be produced in the very central regions 
of the accretion disk. The absorption of those X-rays by line- 
of-sight material is readily observable at soft X-ray energies 
and provides important information on the surroundings of 
the active nucleus. The discussion of X-ray absorption is 
commonly divided into that of 'cold' absorption (i.e. by neu- 
tral material) and 'warm' absorption (i.e. by ionized mate- 

The warm absorption has already been discussed in 
Sections 2.3.2 and 2.3.3. As previously mentioned, variabil- 
ity studies have led to a two-zone model for this absorber. 
Table 3 summarizes the properties of these two absorbing 
regions based on modeling with the photoionization code 
CLOUDY (Ferland 1991). 


O I . \ . 1 1 

0.6 0.8 1 


Figure 5. Relationship between the required scattering fraction, 

/, and the total linc-of-sight reddening, E{B — V), assuming an 
intrinsic ClvA1549/H/3 flux ratio of 10. 

property inner absorber outer absorber 

JVw (1020 cm-2 ) 



€, (ergcms"^ ) 



density ne (10^ cm"^ ) 

> 20 


distance R ( pc) 

fB 0.005 


temperature T (10^ K) 




4 X 10^^/c 



4 X IQ-^fc 





Table 3. Properties of the 

warm absorbers 

in MCG-6-30-15. 

Once the effect of the warm absorber has been mod- 
eled, the X-ray spectrum can be examined for evidence of 
additional cold absorption in excess to that expected from 
our own Galaxy (the Galactic column density along the line 
of sight to this source is A'oai = 4.1 x 10^*^ cm"^ ). Describ- 
ing the warm absorber with a simple one-zone photoioniza- 
tion model computed by the code cloudy (see Fabian et 
al. 1994 for a detailed description of this warm absorber 
model), the ASCA spectrum suggests an excess cold column 
density of A^h = 1.7lo;3 10^" cm"^ . Quoted errors arc sta- 
tistical in nature and stated at the 90 per cent confidence 
level for one interesting parameter (Ax^ = 2.7). It has been 
suggested that the low energy calibration of the ASCA SIS 
is incorrect so as to over-estimate the cold absorption by 
l-3x 10^" cm^'^ (e.g. see discussion in Cappi et al. 1997). 
Thus, within these calibration uncertainties, our result may 
be consistent with there being negligible cold absorption ex- 
cess to the Galactic column. Fitting the same simple model 
to the ROSAT PSPC spectrum suggests an excess column 
density of Ah = (1.9 ±0.3) x lO^" cm"^ , in good agreement 
with the ASCA result. 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

A multi-wavelength study of MCG— 6-30-15 11 

3.5 The absorption/reddening mis-match 

Comparing tiie results of Sections 3.1-3.4 reveals an appar- 
ent contradiction. X-ray observations show that the column 
density of cold (neutral) gas along the line of sight to the 
primary X-ray source is iVn ^ 2 x 10^° cm~^ . However, both 
the optical continuum source and the BLR are highly red- 
dened. On the basis of local (Galactic) studies, we would 
expect a cold gas column density of A^h ^ 2.6 x 10^^ cm~^ 
to be associated with the dust responsible for the reddening. 
This is more than an order of magnitude above the X-ray 
limits. Since the X-ray emission is thought to occur deeper 
within the central engine than either the optical continuum 
or optical line emission, this result is somewhat surprising. 

This discrepancy for MCG— 6-30-15 was first hinted at 
by Pineda et al. (1980) and explicitly commented upon 
by Reynolds & Fabian (1995) on the basis of data drawn 
from the literature. A similar discrepancy has been found 
for IRAS 13349-F2438 (Brandt, Fabian & Pounds 1996), an 
infrared luminous quasar which also displays a prominent 
warm absorber. These authors discuss various resolutions of 
this discrepancy. To summarize these discussions, it is found 
that the only way to reconcile this result with a plausible 
geometry and a physically reasonable gas-to-dust ratio is to 
suggest that the dust resides in the ionized gas that con- 
stitutes the warm absorber. The soft X-ray opacity of this 
material is less than that of cold material primarily due to 
the almost complete ionization of hydrogen and helium. The 
dusty warm absorber hypothesis has also been explored by 
Reynolds (1997) in the context of a sample of Seyfert galax- 
ies. We now discuss dusty warm absorbers in more detail. 


In this section we explore the idea of a dusty waxm absorber 
in more detail than any of the above previous work. In par- 
ticular, we construct photoionization models of dusty warm 
absorbers and explicitly fit these models to the ASCA data. 

4.1 Dust survivability 

Dust grains are highly efficient radiators and hence can ther- 
mally decouple from the surrounding hot gas. Under the 
conditions envisaged here, there are two grain destruction 
mechanisms that must be considered. First, if the grains 
themselves become too hot, they will rapidly sublime. The 
grain temperature will be set by the thermal equilibrium be- 
tween the AGN radiation incident on a given grain and the 
thermal radiation emitted by that grain (e.g. see Barvainis 
1987). For MCG— 6-30-15, the sublimation radius (i.e. the 
radius from the AGN within which dust grains become so 
hot that they sublime) is ~ lO^'^ cm. Thus, any dust grains 
within the inner warm absorber would be rapidly sublimed 
by the intense radiation field. Dust in the outer warm ab- 
sorber would not be subject to significant sublimation. 

The second dust destruction mechanism that we must 
consider is thermal sputtering. If we make the standard as- 
sumption that the (outer) warm absorber is pliotoionizcd, 
then photoionization models suggest that the gas tempera- 
ture is only T ~ 5 x 10* K and thermal sputtering is negligi- 
ble. If, instead, we suppose that the outer warm absorber is 

purely coUisionally-iornzcd, gas temperatures of T ~ 10** K 
are required in order to achieve the observed ionization 
states (ShuU & van Steenberg 1982). From the expressions 
of Burke & Silk (1974), the thermal sputtering timescale for 
this temperature is 

3*' ( , "-3 ) 
\ 1 cm / 


where n is the electron rmmbcr density in the gas. Sup- 
pose that r is the distance of the outer warm absorber from 
the central engine, and L is the (ionizing) luminosity of the 
central engine. Furthermore, define ^equiv ^ 20 erg cm s~^ 
to be the ionization parameter of a photoionized plasma in 
which oxygen is ioruzod to the same degree as seen in the 
outer warm absorber of MCG— 6-30-15. Given our (tempo- 
rary) hypothesis that the plasma is coUisionally-ionized, the 
density must satisfy 

n > 



or else photoionization would dominate the ionization state. 
Evaluating the sputtering timescale for the parameters of 
MCG-6-30-15 gives 

top ^ 10 

1 pc 


For comparison, the flow timescale of the outer warm ab- 
sorber is 






where we have adopted a typical value of waow = 
1000 km s~^ for the velocity of the outer warm absorber, 
as indicated by UV absorption line studies of other AGN 
(Mathur, Elvis & Wilkes 1995). It can be seen that the flow 
timescale of the warm absorber always exceeds the sput- 
tering timescale unless r > 100 pc. If the outer warm ab- 
sorber was situated at such a large distance, then either we 
would have to be viewing the AGN along a very special line 
of sight, or else the mass, AI, and kinetic energy, Lk, as- 
sociated with the outflow would both be huge. From the 
expressions of Reynolds & Fabian (1995), and assuming a 
global covering fraction of fc = 0.1, we get M ~ 10® Mq 
and Lk ~ 3 x 10*^ ergs"'^ . The initial acceleration of this 
material would be extremely problematic to understand. We 
consider this possibility to be unphysical. Thus, in the ab- 
sence of a viable, coUisionally-ionized model, the observation 
of a dusty warm absorber may be taken as further evidence 
that photoionization dominates the state of this plasma. 

Whilst dust can survive in warm photoionized gas, it 
is extremely difficult to form dust in such an environment: 
the grains could never assemble at such temperatures. Fur- 
thermore, a comparison of the column density of the warm 
absorber with the cold column expected to be associated 
with the reddening reveals that the warm-gas/dust ratio in 
the warm absorber must be very similar to the cold-gas/dust 
ratio in our Galaxy. These two facts taken together suggest 
that the warm material originates from dusty cold material, 
possibility via radiative heating, and that a substantial frac- 
tion of the dust survives the heating process. The putative 
dusty molecular torus of Seyfert unification schemes might 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

12 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

model standard graphite 

parameter dust mixture dust only 

Afw,outcr(1020 Cm-2) 

47 1+2-^ 


^( erg cm s"-*^ ) 

or 1 +3.8 



r, 17+0.02 

^■-^ ' -0.04 

r, 1 + 0.02 





Table 4. Results of fitting dusty warm absorber models to ASCA 

be a possible progenitor of such a radiatively-driven, warm, 
dusty outflow. 

4.2 Photoionization models 

We fiave constructed photoionization models of dusty warm 
absorbers using the photoionization code CLOUDY. Grids of 
such models were constructed for various values of the col- 
umn density A^w, ionization parameter ^ and X-ray photon 
indices F. Since we are interested in the behaviour of the 
outer warm absorber, the distance of the absorber from the 
primary source was fixed at 1 pc. Otherwise, these models 
are identical to those of Fabian et al. (1994) and Reynolds et 
al. (1995) except for the inclusion of dust grains. The grain 
models used are described in hazy (the manual to cloudy) 
pp. 284. Prompted by the observations of the previous para- 
graph, we have fixed the gas/dust ratio to Galactic value. 
Two such grids were computed: one contains a standard (i.e. 
local) mixture of silicate and graphite grains whereas the 
other contains only graphite grains. 

These models were fitted to the ASCA data. Since we 
are interested in modeling fine details of the soft ASCA spec- 
trum, only data from the best calibrated solid-state imaging 
spectrometer (SISO) were used in the spectral fitting pro- 
cess. Furthermore, only data in the range 0.6-4 keV were 
fitted: below 0.6 keV the ASCA calibration becomes uncer- 
tain whereas above 4keV spectral complexities due to the 
Fe Ka line become relevant. In detail, our spectral model 
has three components. First, the primary power-law and the 
outer warm absorber are modeled using CLOUDY as described 
above. Secondly, the effect of the inner warm absorber 
was modeled as a O viii absorption edge with (rest-frame) 
threshold energy 0.87 keV and optical depth at threshold of 
T"08 ~ 0.18 (Otani et al. 1996)|^. Lastly, Galactic absorption 
by a cold column of A''h = 4.06 x 10^'^ cm"^ was included. 
The spectral fitting results are shown in Table 4. 

Table 4 shows that the assumed dust composition has 
a significant effect on the goodness of fit. The model which 
assumes graphite grains only is a much better fit than the 
model with a standard dust mixture (Ax^ = 68 for the 

^ Short term spectral variability in the soft ASCA band is known 
to occur during this observation (Otani et al. 1996), and one might 
worry about the effect of this variability when one performs spec- 
tral fitting on the time-averaged spectrum. However, it is known 
that changes in ro8 dominate this spectral variability. Thus, the 
best fitting parameters for the outer warm absorber (which con- 
tributes very little to the O vni edge) should be relatively unaf- 
fected by spectral variability 

same number of dof). The reason for this difference is il- 
lustrated in Fig. 6 which shows the best-fit unfolded model 
and the 0.6-2 keV SISO data for each of the two assumed 
dust compositions. The standard dust model predicts a large 
photoelectric K-edge due to neutral oxygen (threshold en- 
ergy 0.533 keV). Such an edge is not observed. The graphite 
grain model predicts a significantly smaller neutral oxygen 
edge which is much more consistent with observations. Note 
that the neutral oxygen edge in the latter model originates 
purely from the Galactic column and not from the dusty 
warm absorber. Thus, the graphite grain model seems to be 
preferred over the standard dust mixture model. 

The signatures of dust in a dusty warm absorber only 
become significant at X-ray energies below the ASCA band. 
Thus, we must check that the dusty warm absorber model 
is consistent with the soft X-ray spectrum as determined 
by the ROSAT PSPC. In detail, we compared the ROSAT 
PSPC data with a spectral model consisting of a power-law 
form (photon index F) absorbed by three components: 

a) a dusty warm absorber model as computed by 
CLOUDY (column density A'w and ionization parameter ^), 

b) an absorption edge at the threshold energy of O vill 
to mimic the effect of the dust-free inner warm absorber 
(optical depth at threshold ros), 

c) neutral absorption to account for Galactic and in- 
trinsic cold gas absorption (column density A''h). 

This 6 parameter scheme over-models the ROSAT 
PSPC spectrum (which has ~ 5 independent energy chan- 
nels). Thus, we do not formally fit the data since any such 
fit is very poorly constrained - we merely seek to demon- 
strate consistency with the fit parameters derived from the 
ASCA data. Both the standard dust and the graphite dust 
warm absorber models are found to be consistent with 
the PSPC data for the following parameters: F = 2.8, 
Nw = 4.5 X 10^^ cm"^, ^ = 20ergcms"\ tqs = 0.83, 
TVh = 6.9 X 10^" cm~2 . These parameters are roughly con- 
sistent with those derived from the ASCA data with the 
exception of F and ros- We will briefiy address these in turn. 

First, the photon index F is inferred to be significantly 
steeper in the i^OSylT observation than the ASCA observa- 
tion. At least some of this discrepancy (AF ~ 0.5) may be 
due to previously noted errors in the ROSAT-ASCA cross- 
calibration. However, there may be a true softening of the 
X-ray spectrum in the ROSAT band due to the onset of a 
soft excess. It must be noted that the ASCA data do not 
show any evidence of a soft excess above 0.6 keV (Reynolds 
1997). Temporal variations of F may also explain such a dis- 
crepancy (note that the ROSAT and ASCA observations are 
separated by over 2 years). 

Secondly, the O vill edge depth ro8 is inferred to be sig- 
nificantly deeper in the 7? OSAT" observation than in ASCA 
observation. This can be understood as a real (i.e., physi- 
cal) change. Otani et al. (1996) and Reynolds (1996) have 
found a relationship between the instantaneous value of ros 
(as measured by ASCA) and the luminosity of this source. 
From the analysis of Reynolds (1996), this relation takes the 

ros^O.uf (13) 
y 10^-^ ergs J 

where I/2-10 is the 2-10 keV luminosity of the source. This 
can be understood physically in terms of a highly-ionized 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

A multi-wavelength study of MCG— 6-30-15 13 

(a) standard dust mixture 

(b) graphite grains only 




Energy (keV) 

Energy (keV) 

Figure 6. Dusty Wcirm absorber models fitted to 0.6-4 keV data from the ASCA SISO (plain crosses). SISl data are also shown (filled 
squares) but have not been used in the spectral fitting reported in Table 4. Panel a) shows the model computed with a standard (i.e. 
Galactic) mixture of graphite and silicate dust grains. Panel b) shows the model computed with only graphite grains. 

warm absorber in which most of the oxygen atoms are fully 
stripped of all electrons (i.e. Oix is the dominant state). A 
drop in ionizing luminosity results in an increased number of 
O VIII ions due to recombination of the O ix ions. This pro- 
duces the observed anti-correlation between tos and 1/2- lo. 

During the EOiSAT observation, the average 2-10 keV 
luminosity is in the range L2-10 = 4 — 8 x 10*'^crgs~^. 
Tiie large uncertainty in luminosity is due to the uncer- 
tainty in the extrapolation from the ROSAT band to the 
2-10 keV band. The corresponding range of edge depth is 
Tos = 0.2 — 1.4. Thus, the value needed to agree with the 
-ROS^T spectrum, ros = 0.83, is completely consistent with 
this relationship. 

To summarize these X-ray results, we have shown that a 
warm absorber containing sufficient dust to explain the opti- 
cal reddening is also compatible with the ASCA and ROSAT 
data. In principle, a detailed examination of the neutral K- 
edges of the various dust-phase metals allows the composi- 
tion of the dust to be probed. Although it is extremely hard 
to make definitive statements yet due to the lack of high- 
quality soft X-ray spectra, there is evidence that the dust 
grain composition is non-standard in so far as it contains 
few silicate grains. We note that due to the tentative nature 
of this conclusion, we have not taken account of any non- 
standard dust composition when performing the reddening 
calculations of Section 3. Clearly, this should be the subject 
of future work. 

4.3 Dust emission and the infrared bump 

The multiwaveband spectrum of MCG— 6-30-15 clearly 
shows a large IR bump. If this infrared bump is interpreted 
as the thermal emission from dust grains, the correspond- 
ing grain temperature is T ~ 300 — 500 K. The fact that 
the 25 — 100//m fluxes describe an approximate Rayleigh- 
Jeans form shows that dust cooler than T ~ 300 K cannot 

contribute much to the observed emission. However, the rel- 
atively flat 12 — 25//m spectrum shows that there are prob- 
ably hotter dust components. Here we investigate whether 
this IR bump can be understood as thermal emission from 
a dusty warm absorber. 

Following the work of Barvainis (1987), we calculate the 
mass of dust required to produce the 12/im flux observed in 
MCG— 6-30-15. Assuming graphite grains with a radius of 
a = 0.05/xm, a density of p = 2.26 gcm~^ and temperature 
of T = 500 K, we estimate that 15 M© of dust is required to 
produce the 12/L(m flux. Furthermore, assuming a standard 
gas-to-dust mass ratio of 200, the corresponding mass of as- 
sociated gas is 3000 M©. If, instead, we consider a grain tem- 
perature of T = 1500 K, the increased dust emissivity lowers 
the dust mass requirement to 6 M© with a corresponding gas 
mass of 1200 M©. 

The mass of the outer (dusty) warm absorber can be in- 
dependently estimated from simple arguments using the X- 
ray data. Approximating as a thin, uniform, spherical shell, 
the mass of ionized plasma is 

M = 47vR^Nmpfc 

« 1000i?p,A^22/c Mq 


where -R = -Rpc pc is the radial distance of the absorbing 
region, A'^ = 10 N22 cm^ is the column density and /c is 
the covering fraction of the material as seen from the central 
source (i.e. the 'global' covering fraction). In MCG— 6-30- 
15, we must have Rpc < 1 in order to heat the dust to 
T > 500 K. The ASCA data directly constrain the column 
density to be Ar22 ~ 0.5. Thus, we have 

M< 500/c Mo 


with only fc remaining unconstrained. This is somewhat less 
than the mass derived in the previous paragraph, especially 
when it is noted that there are arguments suggesting fc ~ 
0.1 (see Reynolds 1997 and Section 5.) 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

14 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

The disagreement between these two mass estimates is 
not unexpected. Wo would only expect agreement if most 
of the warm/hot dust emission originated from grains in 
a warm absorber which approximated a uniform spheri- 
cal shell. Realistically, a rather more complicated geome- 
try would be expected. In particular, large quantities of 
warm/hot grain emission would be expected from dusty 
gas associated with the irradiated inner edge of the puta- 
tive dusty molecular torus. Indeed, it may be artificial to 
consider the outer warm absorber and the torus as distinct 
and separate entities - the outer warm absorber may well 
be an optically-thin, outflowing extension of the standard 
(optically-thick) cold torus. 


The optical spectrum of MCG— 6-30-15 clearly displays 
the very high-excitation forbidden lines of [FeX]A6375, 
[FeXI]A7892 and [FeXIV]A5303. These are the so-called iron 
coronal lines. Previous studies of the coronal lines in Seyfert 
galaxies have found them to have line widths iiitcriiicdi- 
ate between that of the lower-excitation forbidden narrow 
lines (such as [OIII]) and the permitted broad lines (Grandi 
1978). These studies have also found the coronal lines to 
be slightly blueshifted with respect to the narrow forbidden 
lines. As shown in Table 2, the coronal linos in MCG— 6- 
30-15 follow exactly these trends. Note that the true width 
and flux of the [FeXIV]A5303 line may be less than that pre- 
sented in Table 2 due to blending with [CaV]A5309. Oliva 
et al. (1994) have examined various models for the coronal 
line emission. 

Such observations have led to the discussion of the 
coronal line region (CLR) which is distinct from the BLR 
or NLR. Here we address the possibility that the CLR in 
MCG— 6-30-15 can be identified with the outer warm ab- 

The collision strengths for these transitions are poorly 
known (Osterbrock & Fulbright 1996; Oliva 1996). Any cal- 
culations of line strengths that we perform will be tainted by 
this basic uncertainty in the atomic physics. Despite these 
uncertainties, we have used cloudy to examine the coronal 
line emission from the inner and outer warm absorber. Ta- 
ble 3 reports the predicted coronal line fiuxes as a fraction 
of the observed line fiux. These predicted fiuxes assume an 
optically-thin, unobscured spherical shell with total covering 
fraction fc. 

It is clear from Table 3 that the inner warm absorber 
cannot contribute much to the observed coronal line emis- 
sion. This is primarily due to the fact that iron is too highly 
ionized, although coUisional de-excitation is also relevant in 
suppressing the coronal line emission. On the other hand, 
the outer warm absorber can produce significant coronal 
emission. If we hypothesize that all of the [FeX]A6375 and 
[FeXIV]A5303 emission originates from the outer warm ab- 
sorber, we deduce that /c « 0.04. However, half of the op- 
tical emission from this region may well be blocked by very 
optically-thick material (e.g. the molecular torus). This is 
suggested by the fact that, in some other Seyfert nuclei, even 
infrared coronal lines are observed to be blueshifted with re- 
spect to the low-ionization narrow lines implying that any 

redshifted coronal emission must be heavily extinguished. If 
this is the case, the true obscuration-corrected coronal line 
flux maybe twice that observed leading to a revised cover- 
ing fraction of fc « 0.08. This compares well with the esti- 
mate of the covering fraction of the outer warm absorber, 
/owa ~ 0.1, based on the analysis of ASCA data for a sample 
of Seyfert galaxies (Reynolds 1997). 

According to our cloudy calculations, the observed 
[FeXI]A7892 emission cannot be explained as originating 
from the same material as the other coronal lines. Within 
our hypothesis, three possibilities present themselves. First, 
the observed [FeXI]A7892 may have its origins elsewhere. 
Any separate coronal line emitting component would then 
be heavily constrained by the fact that it could not over- 
produce [FeX]A6375 and [FeXIV]A5303. Secondly, the uncer- 
tainties in the atomic physics may lead CLOUDY to grossly 
underestimate the [FeXI]A7892 flux and this line may, in 
fact, originate within the same material as the other coronal 
lines. Thirdly, the uncertainties in the atomic physics may 
have led CLOUDY to grossly overestimate the [FeX]A6375 and 
[FeXIV]A5303 emission from the outer warm absorber. In 
this case, either the warm absorber covering fraction is large 
{.fc ^ 0.1) or the coronal lines are emitted from a completely 
distinct (and as yet unidentified) region. Further progress in 
this area clearly requires better atomic parameters for these 
transitions, such as those which will be provided by the IRON 
project (Hummer et al. 1993). 

6.1 Polarization 

Several authors have noted a high degree of polarization in 

the optical/IR spectrum of MCG— 6-30-15 (e.g. Thompson 
& Martin 1988; Brindle et al. 1990). Polarization fractions 
of 4-6 per cent have been observed, with a slight tendency 
towards increasing polarization with decreasing wavelength. 
This is a significantly larger polarization than is typically 
found in Seyfert nuclei. The polarization is found to be 
aligned with the major axis of the host galaxy. 

There are two possible causes for this polarization (see 
Kartje 1995 for a recent review of polarization mechanisms 
in AGN). First, a large scale alignment of dust grains along 
the line of sight to the central source can produce polariza- 
tion via dichroic extinction (i.e. one polarization is preferen- 
tially scattered out of the line of sight by the dust grains). 
Secondly, scattering of flux into the observers line of sight 
by dust or free electrons will naturally produce polariza- 
tion. In MCG— 6-30-15 we have independent evidence for 
both scattering and the presence of line-of-sight dust. Thus, 
both of these mechanisms may be relevant - careful spec- 
tropolarimetry and detailed modeling will be needed to dis- 
entangle these effects. 

We note that IRAS 13349+2438, the other good dusty- 
warm absorber candidate, also displays a very high degree 
of polarization (about 8 per cent). Wills et al. (1992) have 
found that the spectrum of the polarized light is typical of an 
unreddened AGN, thereby suggesting that the polarization 
is primarily due to scattering of the flux along a relatively 
dust-free path into the observers line-of-sight. 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

A multi-wavelength study of MCG— 6-30-15 15 

6.2 Global energetics 

Using tlie estimated unreddened spectrum, we can address 
the issue of tiie energy distribution/flow in tliis source. Here, 
we sliall assume a reddening of E{B — V)= 0.61, leading to 
the unreddened spectrum sketched in Fig. 4. The (isotropic) 
luminosity in the 0.1-1000 keV band is then 

L(X - ray/7-ray) ~ 2 x 10^^ erg s^^ , (17) 

the NIR/optical/UV luminosity is 

L(NIR/optical/UV) ~ 2 x 10*^ erg s'^ , (18) 
and the MIR/FIR luminosity is 

L(MIR/FIR) ~ 4 X 10^^ erg s"^ . (19) 

The NIR/optical/UV luminosity given here is really a lower- 
limit since we have assumed the minimum possible value 
for the reddening. These waveband groups have been cho- 
sen on the basis of physical origin. The X-ray/7-ray (i.e. 
~ 2 X 10^® Hz and above) emission is thought to be pro- 
duced by non-thermal processes (e.g. Comptonization) in a 
hot corona associated with the inner regions of an accretion 
disk. The NIR/optical/UV (^ 10"-10^^ Hz) emissions have 
plausible origins as thermal emission from the optically-thick 
accretion disk material. The MIR/FIR (~ 10^^ - lO" Hz) 
emission is likely to be thermal emission from warm or hot 
dust associated with the dusty warm absorber and putative 
molecular torus. Here we address the implications of the rel- 
ative magnitudes of these luminosities for the energetics of 
the source. 

First, we will discuss some theoretical expectations. We 
will assume a pure black hole model for the AGN emission, 
i.e. we will assume no contribution to the observed 'AGN' 
emission from a nuclear star-cluster or starburst. As men- 
tioned in the Introduction, it is believed that the inner ac- 
cretion disk possesses a hot optically-thin corona responsible 
for the non-thermal X-ray /7-ray emission. Coronal models 
coupled with spectral constraints imply that a large fraction 
of the energy that is (locally) dissipated in the accretion disk 
is transported into the corona, possibly in a magnetic form, 
before being radiated. The dominant radiation process is 
thought to be inverse Compton scattering of soft thermal 
(optical/UV) photons from the accretion disk. The emission 
of the optical/UV seed photons is probably driven by high- 
energy irradiation from the corona, thereby completing a 
self-sustaining feedback. 

Suppose that the corona covers the entire disk surface 
and that almost all of the accretion energy is released within 
the corona leading to the X-ray/7-ray power-law emission. 
Approximately half of the primary high-energy photons will 
strike the accretion disk. Approximately half of the coronajT] 
flux that strikes the disk will be thermalized and re- radiated 
at optical/UV wavelengths, with the remaining half being 
'reflected' (i.e. the photons undergo Compton backscatter- 
ing or excite X-ray fluorescence). Thus, this scenario would 

t In this context, the term 'coronal flux' is used to mean that 
radiation which is associated with the X-ray emitting disk-corona, 
and is unrelated to the 'coronal line emission' discussed in Section 

L(NIR/optical/UV) = AL(X - ray/7-ray). (20) 

where A 1/3. Observationally, we infer there to be sig- 
nificantly more NIR/optical/UV emission than this, A > 1 
(where approximate equality corresponds to the case where 
the reddening takes its minimum allowed value, E{B — V) = 
0.61). There are several possible interpretations. First, only 
a fraction of the (locally) dissipated energy may be trans- 
ported into the corona. However, it is difficult to reconcile 
this with the X-ray spectrum given current coronal models 
(e.g., Haardt & Maraschi 1991). Secondly, there may be an- 
other optical/UV source in addition to the accretion disk 
such as a powerful nuclear starburst. This is difficult to rec- 
oncile with the fact that the optical continuum shown in 
Fig. 2a appears featureless and reddened to the same de- 
gree as the BLR. Lastly, and most likely, the corona may 
not cover the whole disk. It may be patchy or only exist in 
the innermost regions of the disk. The regions of the accre- 
tion disk without an active corona would still produce opti- 
cal/UV emission via thermal emission resulting from viscous 

For the minimal reddening case, E{B — V^) = 0.61, 
the MIR/FIR luminosity is comparable with luminosity in 
the whole of the rest of the spectrum. Within the dust- 
reprocessing paradigm, this is a troublesome result to un- 
derstand unless the covering fraction of the dusty material 
is almost unity or the primary emission is anisotropic (with 
more primary radiation being emitted towards the dusty re- 
processing material than towards us). A covering fraction 
of unity is implausible given our understanding of the ge- 
ometry of a Seyfert nucleus. However, if we suppose that 
E{B -V)> 0.61, then the IR/optical/UV luminosity can 
greatly exceed the above value thereby alleviating the prob- 
lem of the MIR/FIR production. 


We have presented a multiwaveband study of the Seyfert 
1 galaxy MCG— 6-30-15, including previously unpublished 
optical data from the AAT, and UV data from lUE. Our 
compilation of data, spanning 6 decades of frequency, has 
allowed us to examine reprocessing mechanisms and the ge- 
ometry of this system. 

The optical line and continuum emission both show 
the effects of dust extinction. The reddening inferred from 
Balmer line studies lies in the range E{B — V)— 0.61 — 1.09. 
Given this reddening, we would expect the UV emission from 
the source to be less than observed. The fact that we do 
detect a UV continuum and broad C lvA1549 line can be 
reconciled with a typical Seyfert spectrum if 1-5 per cent of 
the intrinsic (i.e. dereddened) source spectrum is scattered 
around the matter responsible for the extinction and into 
our line of sight. UV spectropolarimetry will be required to 
test this hypothesis. 

The X-ray spectrum of this Seyfert nucleus clearly re- 
veals a warm absorber but little of the cold (neutral) absorp- 
tion that would be expected to accompany the dust respon- 
sible for the optical/UV reddening. To reconcile the X-ray 
absorption with the optical reddening we postulate that the 
dust resides in the warm absorber. Detailed X-ray studies 
have shown the warm absorber to be comprised of at least 

© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000 

16 C. S. Reynolds et al. 

two-zones - an inner warm absorber at distances character- 
istic of the BLR and an outer warm absorber at distances 
characteristic of the putative molecular torus. Dust cannot 
survive in the inner warm absorber due to the intense ra- 
diation field - thus, the dust irmst reside in the outer ab- 
sorber. We have examined photoionization models of the 
dusty (outer) warm absorber. Upon comparing such mod- 
els with ASCA spectra we find evidence for non-standard 
dust mixtures, although the current data to not allow us to 
pursue this issue in detail. 

The optical spectrum of MCG— 6-30-15 displays the 
high-excitation forbidden hues of [FeX]A6375, [FeXI]A7892 
and [FcXIV]A5303, the so-called coronal lines. As is often 
found in other Scyfcrt nuclei, these lines have widths that arc 
intermediate between those of the broad Balmer lines and 
the lower-excitation forbidden lines. Photoionization model- 
ing with CLOUDY suggests that the CLR may be identified 
with the outer warm absorber. 


We thank Niel Brandt for several stimulating discussions 
over the course of this work. CSR acknowledges support 
from PPARC and the National Science Foundation Grant 
AST9529175. ACF thanks the Royal Society for support. 
This work has made use of data obtained through the 
High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Research Cen- 
ter (HEASARC) Onhne Service, provided by the NASA- 
Goddard Space Flight Center. 


AUoin D. ct al.,1995, A&A, 293, 293 
Barvainis R., 1987, ApJ, 320, 537 
Berriman G., 1989, ApJ, 345, 713 

Brandt W. N., Fabian A. C, Pounds K. A., 1996, MNRAS, 278, 

Brindlc C, Hough J. H., Bailey J. A., Axon D. J., Ward M. J., 
Sparks W. B., McLean I. S., 1990, MNRAS, 280, 823 

Burke J. R., Silk J., 1974, MNRAS, 190, 1 

Canfield R. C, Puetter R. C, 1981, ApJ, 243, 381 

Cappi M., Matsuoka M., Comastri A., Brinkmann W., Elvis M., 
Palumbo G. G. C., Vignali C., 1997, AJ, in press 

CoUin-Souflcrin S., Dyson J. E., McDowell J. C., Perry J. J., 1988, 
MNRAS, 232, 539 

Crenshaw D. M. et al., 1996, ApJ, 470, 322 

Edclson R. A. et al., 1996, ApJ, 470, 364 

Espey B. R., CarswcU R. F., Bailey J. A., Smith M. G., Ward 
M. J., 1989, ApJ, 342, 666 

Fabian A. C. ct al. 1994a, PASJ, 46, L59 

Fabian A. C. ct al. 1995, MNRAS, 277, Lll 

Ferland G.L., 1991, Ohio State University, Astronomy Depart- 
ment Internal Report 91-01 

Field G. B., Rogers R. D., 1993, ApJ, 403, 94 

George I. M., Fabian A. C., 1991, MNRAS, 249, 352 

Grandi S. A., 1978, ApJ, 221, 501 

Guiricin G., Mardirossian P., Mezzctti M., 1995, 446, 550 
Guilbert P. W., Recs M. J., 1988, MNRAS, 233, 475 
Haardt F., Maraschi L., 1991, ApJ, 380, L51 
Halpern J. P., 1984, ApJ, 281, 90 

Heiles C., Kulkarni S., Stark A. A., 1981, ApJ, 247, 73 
Hummer D. G., Berrington K. A., Eissner W., Pradhan A. K., 
Saraph H. E., TuUy J. A., 1993, A&A, 279, 298 

Iwasawa K. ct al., 1996, MNRAS, 282, 1038 
Kartje J. F., 1995, ApJ, 452, 565 
Kaspi S. et al., 1996, ApJ, 470, 322 
Korista K. T. et al., 1995, ApJS, 97, 285 
Kwan J. Y., Krolik J. H., 1981, ApJ, 250, 478 
Lightman A. P., White T. R., 1988, ApJ, 335, 57 
Malkan M. A., 1983, ApJ, 264, LI 
Mathur S., Elvis M., Wilkes B., 1995, ApJ, 452, 230 
Matt G., Perola G. C., Piro L., 1991, A&A, 245, 63 
Morris S. L., Ward M. J., 1988, MNRAS, 230, 639 
Nandra K., Pounds K.A., 1992, Nat, 359, 215 
Nandra K., Pounds K. A., Stewart G. C, 1990, MNRAS, 242, 

Ollva E., 1996, to appear in lAU Colloquium 159, Emission lines 
in Active Galaxies: New Methods and Techniques. 

Oliva E., Salvati M., Moorwood A. F. M., Marconi A., 1994, A&A, 
288, 457 

Osterbrock D. E., 1989, Astrophysics of Gaseous Nebulae and 
Active Galactic Nuclei, University Science Books, Mill Valley 
Osterbrock D. E., Fulbright J. P., 1996, PASP, 108, 183 
Otani C. et al., 1996, PASJ, 48, 211 

Pineda F. J., Delvaille J. P., Huchra J., Davis M., 1978, lAU Circ, 

Pineda F. J., Delvaille J. P., Grindlay J. E., Schnopper H. W., 
1980, 237, 414 

Pounds K. A., Nandra K., Stewart G. C, George I. M., Fabian 

A. C, 1990, Nat, 344, 132 
Recs M. J., 1984, ARAA, 22, 471 
Reidiert G. A. ct al., 1994, ApJ, 425, 582 
Reynolds C. S., 1996, PhD thesis, Univ. of Cambridge. 
Reynolds C. S., 1997, MNRAS, in press 
Reynolds C. S., Fabian A. C, 1995, MNRAS, 273, 1167 
Reynolds C. S., Fabian A. C, Nandra K., Inoue H., Kunieda H., 

Iwasawa K., 1995, MNRAS, 277, 901 
ShuU M. J., Van Steenberg M., 1982, ApJS, 48, 95 
Stirpe G. M. ct al., 1994, ApJ, 425, 609 
Tanaka Y. et al., 1995, Nat, 375, 659 
Thompson I. A., Martin P. G., 1988, ApJ, 330, 121 
Ward M. J., Elvis M., Fabbiano G., Carlcton N. P., Willncr S. P., 

Lawrence A., 1987, ApJ, 315, 74 
Wills B. J., Wills D., Evans N. J., Natta A., Thompson K. L., 

Breger M., Sitko M. L., 1992, ApJ, 400, 96 
Wu C.-C, Boggess A., Gull T. R., 1983, ApJ, 266, 28 
Zdziarski A. A., Fabian A. C, Nandra K., Celotti A., Rees M. J., 

Done C, Coppi P. S., Madejski G. M., 1994, MNRAS, 269, 


© 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000-000